Los Angeles Department of City Planning RECOMMENDATION REPORT
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Los Angeles Department of City Planning RECOMMENDATION REPORT CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION CASE NO.: CHC-2016-3731-HCM ENV-2016-3732-CE HEARING DATE: October 20, 2016 Location: 6111 North Monterey Road; 6112 North TIME: 10:00 AM Toltec Way; 6117 North Monterey Road PLACE : City Hall, Room 1010 Council District: 14 200 N. Spring Street Community Plan Area: Northeast Los Angeles Los Angeles, CA 90012 Area Planning Commission: East Los Angeles Neighborhood Council: Arroyo Seco Legal Description: Oak Hill Park Tract, Block 2, Lots 28-29 PROJECT: Historic-Cultural Monument Application for the LEE RESIDENCE REQUEST: Declare the property a Historic-Cultural Monument OWNER: CMB Developers, Inc. Attn: Ilanit Maghen 1080 Everett Place Los Angeles, CA 90026-4413 APPLICANT: Highland Park Heritage Trust P.O. Box 50894 Highland Park, CA 90004 PREPARERS: Charles J. Fisher and Jonathan Silberman Highland Park Heritage Trust 140 S. Avenue 57 Highland Park, CA 90042 RECOMMENDATION That the Cultural Heritage Commission: 1. Take the property under consideration as a Historic-Cultural Monument per Los Angeles Administrative Code Chapter 9, Division 22, Article 1, Section 22.171.10 because the application and accompanying photo documentation suggest the submittal warrants further investigation. 2. Adopt the report findings. VINCENT P. BERTONI, AICP Director of PlanningN1907 [SIGNED ORIGINAL IN FILE] [SIGNED ORIGINAL IN FILE] Ken Bernstein, AICP, Manager Lambert M. Giessinger, Preservation Architect Office of Historic Resources Office of Historic Resources [SIGNED ORIGINAL IN FILE] Melissa Jones, Planning Assistant Office of Historic Resources Attachments: Historic-Cultural Monument Application CHC-2016-3731-HCM 6111 North Monterey Road; 6112 North Toltec Way; 6117 North Monterey Road Page 2 of 2 SUMMARY The 1938 Lee Residence is a two-story, East Asian Eclectic single-family dwelling with a detached two car garage located at 6111 North Monterey Road between Hardison Way and South Avenue 60 in the Hermon Community. It was constructed by Foss Construction Company for Edgar K. Lee and his family. Edgar Lee (originally Coon Lin Lee) was born in China in 1896 and immigrated to the United States in 1912. Shortly after, in 1917, Lee married an American woman, Alice Stuart, with whom he raised three children. East Asian Eclectic architecture, a derivative and referential style that borrowed forms and ornament directly from ancient buildings in East Asia, emerged as part of the larger Exotic Revival trend in Los Angeles in the 1920s and proliferated on a large (if geographically isolated) scale with the construction of Los Angeles’ New Chinatown in 1938. East Asian communities continued to use the style to define neighborhoods with ethnic associations. The Lee Residence retains many of its original features including multi-lite bay and steel casement windows, decorative half-timbering, a rounded, recessed entryway, decorative terracotta grilles, carved rafter tails, a clay tile roof, and sloped roof corners. Square in plan, the dwelling is clad in textured stucco and has a hipped roof with a distinctive decorative detail at its peak. On the rear façade, there is a one-story enclosed living space with a roof deck. The exterior of the house is mostly intact. The limited alterations include the construction of an addition along the south façade, a pool built in 1980, and recent partial removal of the roof. The Lee Residence was identified in the draft findings of the citywide historic resources survey, SurveyLA, as eligible for designation at the state and local levels as an excellent example of East Asian Eclectic architecture. CRITERIA The criterion is the Cultural Heritage Ordinance which defines a historical or cultural monument as any site (including significant trees or other plant life located thereon) building or structure of particular historic or cultural significance to the City of Los Angeles, such as historic structures or sites in which the broad cultural, economic, or social history of the nation, State or community is reflected or exemplified, or which are identified with historic personages or with important events in the main currents of national, State or local history or which embody the distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type specimen, inherently valuable for a study of a period style or method of construction, or a notable work of a master builder, designer or architect whose individual genius influenced his age. FINDINGS Based on the facts set forth in the summary and application, the Commission determines that the application is complete and that the property may be significant enough to warrant further investigation as a potential Historic-Cultural Monument. CITY OF LOS ANGELES Office of Historic Resources/Cultural Heritage Commission HISTORIC-CULTURAL MONUMENT NOMINATION FORM 1. PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION Proposed Monument Name: Street Address: Zip: Council District: Range of Addresses on Property: Community Name: Assessor Parcel Number: Tract: Block: Lot: Proposed Monument Site/ Natural Building Structure Object Property Type: Open Space Feature 2. CONSTRUCTION HISTORY & CONDITION Year Built: Factual Estimated Threatened?: Architect/Designer: Contractor: Original Use: Present Use: Is the Proposed Monument on its Original Site?: Yes No Unknown If "No," where?: 3. STYLE & MATERIALS Architectural Style: Stories:tories: Plan Shape: FEATURE PRIMARY SECONDARY Type: Type: CONSTRUCTION Cladding Material: Cladding Material: Type: Type: ROOF Material: Material: Type: Type: WINDOWS Material: Material: Style: Style: ENTRY Material: Material: 4. HISTORIC-CULTURAL MONUMENT CRITERIA The proposed monument exemplifies the following Cultural Heritage Ordinance Criteria (Section 22.171.7): Reflects the broad cultural, economic, or social history of the nation, state or community Is identified with historic personage(s) or with important events in the main currents of national, state, or local history Embodies the distinguishing characteristics of an architectural-type specimen, inherently valuable for study of a period, style or method of construction A notable work of a master builder, designer, or architect whose individual genius influenced his or her age 1 UPDATED MARCH 2014 !"#%&'%(&)%*+,-(-) &``1HV%Q`%314 Q`1H%7V4Q%`HV4L!%C %`:C%3V`1 :$V%!QII1441QJ M@=2RL@ORO!2LA!%?RK?[K2 +&?"+*#"&+%'&7? . "#$%&"$'()*+--"& !1# %R: V%:JR%1`1 V%:%G`1V`)RV*H`1] 1QJ%Q`%1Q`@%RQJV%`Q`%I:=Q`%:C V`: 1QJ#8%2.1#%#VH 1QJ%I:7%:C#Q%GV%HQI]CV VR%QJ%:% #V]:`: V%RQH%IVJ 8%%:V%#%`V% Q%1JHC%RV%HQ]1V#%Q`%G%1CR1J$%]V`I1 #%1J% .V%JQI1J: 1QJ%]:H@V %^#VV%!VH 1QJ( 8(=:?@22A!_8" 8% 1980 Swimming pool constructed at rear of property. 8% 8% 8% 8% 8% 8% 8% 8 %'+$')2*3'+$(&'4*&%+(&4%*'5%)$'6'4"$'()*^@`%@JQ1J_ !1# VR%1J% .V%K: 1QJ:C%LV$1# V`%Q`%M1# Q`1H%NC:HV#% !1# VR%1J% .V%O:C1`Q`J1:%LV$1# V`%Q`%M1# Q`1H:C%LV#Q%`HV#% PQ`I:CC7%RV V`I1JVR%VC1$1GCV%`Q`% .V%K: 1QJ:C%:JRLQ`%O:C1`Q`J1:%LV$1# V`#% !QJ `1G% 1J$*`V: %`V* !QH: VR%1J%:%M1# Q`1H%N`V#V`0: 1QJ%R0V`C:7%QJV%^MNR_% .QJRHQJ `1G% 1J$*`V: %`V" TV V`I1JVR%VC1$1GCV%`Q`%J: 1QJ:C5%# : V5%Q`%CQH:C%C:JRI:`@% Survey LA (per ARG) ✔ Survey Name(s): # : %#%G7%:%.1# Q`1H%`V#Q%`HV#%#%`0V7^#_% R .V`%.1# Q`1H:C'Q`'H%C %`:C%`V#Q%`HV%RV#1$J: 1QJ^#_7% 8 &'$$%)*+$"$%-%)$+ #.1&"&VH 1QJ":CCQ1&"7Q%" Q"R1#H%##&: &CVJ$ ." .V"&1$J1`1H:JHV"Q`" .V"]`Q]Q&VR"IQJ%IVJ ":JR"1.7"1 "&.Q%CR"GV"JQI1J: VR" :&":"81& Q`1HR:%C %`:C";QJ%IVJ 8""#7]V"7Q%`"`V&]QJ&V&"QJ":"&V]:`: V"RQH%IVJ ":JR": :H."&.VV &" Q" .V"G:H@"Q`" .1&" `Q`I8" "8% 9`Q]Q=VR*-QJ%IVJ *5V=H`1] 1QJ*T*TV#H`1GV% .V%]`Q]Q#VR%IQJ%IVJ ;#%].7#1H:C%H.:`:H V`1# 1H#%:JR `VC: 1QJ#.1]% Q%1 #%#%``Q%JR1J$%VJ01`QJIVJ 8%%@RVJ 1`7%:JR%RV#H`1GV%:J7%H.:`:H V`RRV`1J1J$%VCVIVJ #5% # `%H %`V#5%1J V`1Q`%#]:HV#5%Q`%C:JR#H:]V%`V: %`V#8 G8% + : VIVJ *Q`*+1$J1`1H:JHV*T*ARR`V##% .V%]`Q]Q#VR%IQJ%IVJ ;#%.1# Q`1H5%H%C %`:C5%:JRLQ`%:`H.1 VH %`:C #1$J1`1H:JHV%G7%R1#H%##1J$%.Q1%1 %#: 1#`1V#% .V%MO?%H`1 V`1:%#VCVH VR%1J%=VH 1QJ%'^QJ' .V']`V01Q%1']:$V_8%% Q%%I%# %#%]]Q` %7Q%`%:`$%IVJ %11 .%#%G# :J 1:C'V01RVJHV!:JR!:J:C7'1'8 2 UPDATED MARCH 2014 !"#%&'%(&)%*+,-(-) &``1HV%Q`%314 Q`1H%7V4Q%`HV4L!%C %`:C%3V`1 :$V%!QII1441QJ ,-./01-&R&4/154+60!67!/ +&?"+*#"&+%'&7? 8 !"#$%!$&'#(")*%$'"# 8]]C1H:J !:IV7! Highland Park Heritage Trust &QI]:J77+ ! `VV %&RR`V((7% P. O. Box 50894 *1 77% Highland Park ! : V: CA 1]: 90004 0.QJV%4%IGV`7% 213-807-4127 8I:1C7% [email protected] .`Q]V` 7&31JV`& !"# .V#Q1JV`#1J#"%]]Q` #Q`# .V#JQI1J: 1QJ- V% !Q J@JQ1J 4:IV: CHB Developers, Inc, Attn: Ilanit Maghen *QI]:J77% ! `VV %&RR`V((7% 1080 Everett Place *1 77% Los Angeles ! : V7% CA 1]7% 90026-4413 0.QJV%4%IGV`7% 323-807-3888 / 626-354-3283 8I:1C7% 5QI1J: 1QJ&.`V]:`V`L8]]C1H:J ;#&:V]`V#VJ : 10V& 4:IV7! Charles J. Fisher and Jonathan Silberman *QI]:J77% Highland Park Heritage Trust ! `VV %&RR`V((7% 140 S. Avenue 57 *1 77% Highland Park ! : V7% CA 1]7% 90042 0.QJV%4%IGV`7% 323-256-3593 8I:1C7% [email protected] 8 !"#"$%" !CV:%V&`V:R&V:H.&% : VIVJ &:JR&H.VH@& .V&HQ``V%]QJR1J$&GQ6V%& Q&1JR1H: V& .: &7Q%&:$`VV&11 .& .V&% : VIVJ 8& 9.VJ5&VCVH `QJ1H:CC7&Q`&].7%1H:CC7&%1$J& .V&GQ QI&]Q` 1QJ8&;1 .V`& .V&:]]C1H:J &Q`# .V&]`V]:`V`&I:7&%1$J8" !":H@JQ1CVR$V" .: ":CC"RQH%IVJ 1"1%GI1 VR"11CC"GVHQIV"]%GC1H"`VHQ`R1"%JRV`" .V"6:C1`Q`J1:"8%GC1H"9VHQ`R1":H 5" ✔ :JR"%JRV`1 :JR" .: " .V"RQH%IVJ 1"11CC$GV"I:RV":0:1C:GCV"%]QJ"`V_%V1 " Q"IVIGV`1"Q`" .V"]%GC1H"`Q`"1J1]VH 1QJ" :JR"HQ]71J$8 !":H@JQ1CVR$V" .: ":CC"].Q Q$`:].1":JR"1I:$V1"1%GI1 VR":1"]:` "Q`" .11":]]C1H: 1QJ"11CC"GVHQIV" .V"]`Q]V` 7"Q`" ✔ .V"61 7"Q`"@Q1":J$VCV15":JR"%JRV`1 :JR" .: "]V`I1111QJ"11"$`:J VR"`Q`"%1V"Q`" .V"].Q Q$`:].1":JR"1I:$V1"G7" .V" 61 7"11 .Q% ":J7"V6]VH : 1QJ"Q`"HQI]VJ1: 1QJ8 ✔ !":H@JQ1CVR$V" .: "!".:0V" .V"`1$.