Diversity, Phylogeography, and Taxonomy of Hard-Corals in the Genus Porites from the Arabian Peninsula
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Diversity, Phylogeography, and Taxonomy of Hard-Corals in the Genus Porites from the Arabian Peninsula Dissertation by Tullia Isotta Terraneo In partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy King Abdullah University of Science and Technology, Thuwal, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia © December, 2019 Tullia Isotta Terraneo All rights reserved 2 EXAMINATION COMMITTEE PAGE The dissertation of Tullia Isotta Terraneo is approved by the examination committee. Committee Chairperson: Prof. Michael L. Berumen Committee Co-Chair: Prof. Andrew H. Baird Committee Members: Prof. Christian R. Voolstra, Prof. Mark Tester External Examiner: Prof. James D. Reimer 3 ABSTRACT Diversity, Phylogeography and Evolution of Hard-Corals in the genus Porites from the Arabian Peninsula Tullia Isotta Terraneo The genus Porites is one of the most important scleractinian genera in terms of species diversity and panmictic tropical distribution. However, Porites is notorious for challenging taxonomic identification based on colony gross morphology, micromorphology, and single gene analyses, suggesting that the current classification poorly represents real evolutionary relationships. This research integrates skeletal morphology data and single locus genetic evidence with genome-wide analyses and alternative line of evidence to taxonomy (i.e. symbiotic association data), with the aim of clarifying biodiversity, biogeography, and taxonomy of Porites from the Arabian Peninsula. In this dissertation, I evaluated the diversity of Porites in the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden, providing a basic morpho-molecular background to the taxonomy of Porites in the region, and highlighting that a) the current taxonomic and phylogenetic position of 15 Porites morphological species needs to be reassessed, and that b) coral biodiversity in the Arabian region needs to be re-evaluated. To address this, I reconstructed the complete mitochondrial genomes of two endemic Red Sea species, contributing a 4 solid framework for clarifying the phylogeny and taxonomy of Porites in future molecular studies. I implemented the morpho-molecular results with high-throughput sequencing data, generating a comprehensive hypothesis of species boundaries and biogeography of Porites in the seas surrounding the Arabian Peninsula. These results suggested that 15 morphological species from this region, were clustered into eight molecular lineages, two of which previously unknown. Finally, using the nuclear Internal Transcribed Spacer II (ITS2) marker in a high-throughput sequencing framework, I presented evidence derived from symbiotic association of Porites with dinoflagellates in the family Symbiodiniaceae. Symbiont diversity showed patterns of geographic-specific association at multiple levels, including at the level of Symbiodiniaceae genera, majority ITS2 sequences, and ITS2 type profile levels. Specific associations with host genotypes were also recovered, providing a further line of evidence that the current taxonomy of Porites is in need for revision. This dissertation highlights the utility of an integrated approach to taxonomy in elucidating species boundaries and phylogenetic relationships in Scleractinia and represents a framework that could be applied to other taxa awaiting revision. 5 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my supervisors Prof. Michael Berumen and Prof. Andrew Baird for funding this research, and giving me the chance to grow on a scientific and personal level over the time of my PhD. The endless opportunities that I got during the past 3.5 years would have not been possible without your support and guidance. Thank you. Thanks to my committee members Prof. Christian Voolstra, Prof. Mark Tester, and my external examiner Prof. James Reimer for their contributions and great suggestions during the preparation of this dissertation. I am grateful to Dr. Roberto Arrigoni for the time and patience he invested in teaching me all I know about molecular biology and making me love evolution. Thanks to Prof. Francesca Benzoni for molding the scientist I am from the beginning. Grazie for bringing me in a world I barely knew existed. All I learned and achieved in science is because of the trust, guidance, and infinite help you gave me. Last but not least, thanks to my partner Luis, and my amazing family, mamma, papá, Elia, Ludy & Kaila. Thanks for believing in me and giving me the freedom to be the person I wanted to be. 6 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXAMINATION COMMITTEE PAGE ...................................................................... 2 ABSTRACT ............................................................................................................. 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ......................................................................................... 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS............................................................................................ 6 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS .................................................................................... 10 LIST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................. 15 LIST OF TABLES.................................................................................................... 19 1. CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION AND LITERATURE REVIEW ........................... 21 1.1 Scleractinian corals ................................................................................. 21 1.2 Traditional taxonomy and systematics in the Scleractinia .................. 24 1.3 The molecular revolution ........................................................................ 35 1.4 The use of alternative traits to clarify scleratinian evolution ............... 45 1.5 The genus Porites ..................................................................................... 47 1.6 Project summary and objectives ........................................................... 55 1.7 References ............................................................................................... 57 2. CHAPTER 2: MORPHOLOGY AND MOLECULES REVEAL TWO UNKNOWN SPECIES OF PORITES (SCLERACTINIA, PORITIDAE) FROM THE RED SEA AND THE GULF OF ADEN ............................................................................................ 72 2.1 Abstract .................................................................................................... 73 2.2 Introduction .............................................................................................. 74 2.3 Materials and methods ........................................................................... 78 2.3.1 Sampling ............................................................................................. 78 2.3.2 Abbreviations ..................................................................................... 80 2.3.3 DNA extractions, amplification and sequence analyses .............. 81 2.3.4 Phylogenetic relationships reconstruction ...................................... 83 2.3.5 Species delimitation analyses .......................................................... 84 2.4 Results ....................................................................................................... 85 7 2.4.1 Red Sea and Gulf of Aden Porites identification ........................... 85 2.4.2 Taxonomy ........................................................................................... 86 2.4.3 Molecular results ................................................................................ 95 2.5 Discussion................................................................................................ 100 2.5.1 Comparison of morphological structures ...................................... 100 2.5.2 Molecular considerations ............................................................... 102 2.5.3 Species complex in Porites ............................................................. 103 2.5.4 Species biogeography and distribution ........................................ 106 2.6 Conclusions ............................................................................................ 109 2.7 References ............................................................................................. 117 3. CHAPTER 3: USING ezRAD TO RECONSTRUCT THE COMPLETE MITOCHONDRIAL GENOMES OF PORITES FONTANESII AND PORITES COLUMNARIS (CNIDARIA: SCLERACTINIA) ................................................... 123 3.1 Abstract .................................................................................................. 125 3.2 Introduction ............................................................................................ 126 3.3 Materials and methods ......................................................................... 126 3.4 Results and discussion ........................................................................... 127 3.5 Conclusion.............................................................................................. 129 3.6 References ............................................................................................. 134 4. CHAPTER 4: PHYLOGENOMICS AND PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF PORITES FROM THE ARABIAN PENINSULA ..................................................................... 136 4.1 Abstract .................................................................................................. 137 4.2 Introduction ............................................................................................ 138 4.3 Materials and Methods ........................................................................