The Transparency of Relief Organizations Responding to the 2010 Haiti Earthquake

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Transparency of Relief Organizations Responding to the 2010 Haiti Earthquake Report on The Transparency of Relief Organizations Responding to the 2010 Haiti Earthquake Citizen Oversight Requires Citizen Engagement 1 About Disaster Accountability Project (DAP) The Disaster Accountability Project (DAP) is a non-profit, nonpartisan organization committed to: • improving disaster management systems through policy research and advocacy; • promoting transparency and engaging citizens to become more involved in preparedness and relief; • and helping to ensure that people know what is happening on the ground during a disaster. What We Do Founded in 2007 in reaction to the bungled response to Hurricane Katrina, DAP has demonstrated that dedicated and informed oversight can help ensure that government agencies and nonprofit organizations live up to their life-saving obligations before, during, and after crises. Our History Over the past few years, members of Congress, the news media, and emergency management practitioners have requested and utilized the research and real-time information collected by DAP. For a young organization, DAP has had an out-sized and far-reaching impact (as reported by ABC News, the Associated Press, the New Orleans Times-Picayune, and the Chronicle of Philanthropy, among others). Some of these accomplishments include: • Investigating and authoring a report on how accessible and up-to-date the emergency plans in twenty-two hurricane-vulnerable Louisiana parishes were; this report prompted many parishes to update and improve the public accessibility of their plans. • Conducting a successful campaign to compel FEMA to comply with federal law and elevate the position of FEMA Disability Coordinator, so that she has more authority and resources available to fulfill the position's mandate. • Using the Disaster Accountability Hotline as a real-time listening device during Hurricane Ike and assisting numerous callers and countless others by directing details of gaps in critical services to responsible government agencies and nonprofit organizations. • Launching ReliefOversight.org: a website designed to improve transparency in aid activities, to help ensure donations reach groups with the greatest capacity to deliver needed services and facilitate coordination between organizations on the ground. 2 Table of Contents ABOUT DISASTER ACCOUNTABILITY PROJECT (DAP) ............................................................................... 2 WHAT WE DO ............................................................................................................................................................ 2 OUR HISTORY............................................................................................................................................................. 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS............................................................................................................................................. 3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.......................................................................................................................................... 4 PURPOSE..................................................................................................................................................................... 4 SCOPE......................................................................................................................................................................... 4 PROCESS..................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Survey Template.................................................................................................................................................... 7 CORRESPONDENCE LOG ............................................................................................................................................. 8 Correspondence Emails........................................................................................................................................ 8 Correspondence Log............................................................................................................................................. 9 HIGHLIGHTS ............................................................................................................................................................. 16 Overall Observations.......................................................................................................................................... 16 Response Volume.......................................................................................................................................................... 16 Compliance with Survey Questions ....................................................................................................................... 17 Question Key ............................................................................................................................................................. 17 Correspondence Analysis ................................................................................................................................... 18 Transparency ...................................................................................................................................................... 19 General Trends Observed................................................................................................................................... 23 NOTES, PROVISIONS, AND CORRECTIONS................................................................................................................. 25 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS............................................................................................................................................. 25 AGAPE FLIGHTS ....................................................................................................................................................... 26 AMERICAN JEWISH JOINT DISTRIBUTION COMMITTEE............................................................................................. 28 AMERICAN REFUGEE COMMITTEE ........................................................................................................................... 30 AMERICA’S RELIEF AND DEVELOPMENT TEAM ....................................................................................................... 32 APPROPRIATE INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT GROUP ........................................................................................ 35 CATHOLIC MEDICAL MISSION BOARD ..................................................................................................................... 37 CHILDREN’S INTERNATIONAL LIFELINE ................................................................................................................... 39 CHURCH OF THE BRETHREN DISASTER MINISTRIES ................................................................................................. 41 COMPASSION AND MERCY ASSOCIATES (CAMA SERVICES) .................................................................................. 43 COMPASSION INTERNATIONAL ................................................................................................................................. 45 ENGINEERING MINISTRIES INTERNATIONAL ............................................................................................................ 47 EPISCOPAL RELIEF & DEVELOPMENT ...................................................................................................................... 49 HELP THE CHILDREN ................................................................................................................................................ 52 INTERNATIONAL AID, INC ........................................................................................................................................ 54 INTERNATIONAL CRISIS AID..................................................................................................................................... 56 LIFEWIND INTERNATIONAL (A.K.A. MEDICAL AMBASSADORS INTERNATIONAL) ................................................... 59 OXFAM AMERICA..................................................................................................................................................... 61 PHYSICIANS FOR PEACE ........................................................................................................................................... 64 PLANT WITH PURPOSE .............................................................................................................................................. 67 RELIEF INTERNATIONAL – HAITI.............................................................................................................................. 69 WORLD CARES CENTER ........................................................................................................................................... 71 INDEX ......................................................................................................................................................................... 74 CORRESPONDENCE ................................................................................................................................................... 74 American Red Cross ..........................................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Disaster Relief: Preparedness, Response and Recovery
    DELIVERING FOR GOOD Leveraging our Global Network and Logistics Expertise FedEx does more than deliver – we deliver for good. We are one the few companies in the world that has the global network and logistics expertise capable of assisting with precious shipments or responding quickly in times disaster. It’s a responsibility that we take seriously. Our business requires that we maintain a team of skilled logistics experts, pilots and drivers that spans the globe, as well as an unparalleled fleet of trucks, airplanes and other vehicles. When disaster strikes and there’s not a moment to lose, we have the infrastructure in place to help facilitate a swift response. Our people mobilize the FedEx global fleet and use shipping expertise to provide urgently-needed supplies quickly and efficiently to relief organizations. Even when there’s no emergency, FedEx gets the call to transport precious cargo safely. Whether it’s rare artifacts, traveling museum exhibits or endangered animals, we do more than deliver — we deliver for good. In FY19, FedEx provided more than $12 million in cash and charitable in-kind support to Delivering for Good programs around the world. We are proud to collaborate with these nonprofit organizations 2 Disaster Relief: Preparedness, Response and Recovery FedEx logistics experts help reimagine an emergency field hospital Hospitals and health facilities are not immune to the devastating impacts of disaster. When a region’s healthcare system is knocked out or damaged, International Medical Corps can provide emergency relief through its transportable field hospital. While the original hospital design allowed for a single configuration only, not every disaster requires a 50-ton field hospital the size of a football field.
    [Show full text]
  • Restoring Lives and Land in Fonds-Verrettes, Haiti
    RESTORING LIVES AND LAND IN FONDS-VERRETTES, HAITI 2020 REPORT AND PROPOSAL November 24, 2020 SUBMITTED TO: St. Clement’s Episcopal Church 901 Portland Avenue St. Paul, MN 55104 CONTACT: Plant With Purpose 4747 Morena Blvd, Ste. 100 San Diego, CA 92117 Doug Satre Director of Strategic Partnerships 858.274.3718 [email protected] plantwithpurpose.org 858.274.3718 1 4747 Morena Blvd. Ste 100, San Diego, CA 92117 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In the midst of a challenging year for our world, Plant With Purpose is deeply grateful for the partnership we share in Fonds-Verrettes, Haiti with St. Clement’s Episcopal Church. Together, we are equipping more than 2,300 farming families, benefiting more than 14,200 adults and children to overcome the many challenges they face and restore their land and their lives. We are especially encouraged to report that in the last fiscal year most program goals were met or exceeded, despite the challenges of the Covid-19 pandemic and of ongoing political and financial instability in Haiti. Our team also took on the additional work of adapting program activities to protect the health of farming families, and to communicate the dangers posed by the virus. We could not be prouder of our team and the quality and integrity of their work. Thank you for your commitment to the people of Haiti, and for your consideration of a $30,000 grant in FY2021. It is in challenging times like these that we must remain faithful and continue to equip farming families to gain hope and dignity. Your resources and efforts are truly making a difference.
    [Show full text]
  • Mobile Clinics for At-Risk Communities Supply Medicine to War-Torn Villages
    from the Director the Power of Community “Each of us is trying to help Dear Friends, families that need extra help. I met a precious family who Basic human needs are still inaccessible to many around literally lost everything.” the world: Food, shelter, water, education, freedom, and Lindy Nelson-Paryag stability. Regardless of the circumstances we are born into, Kingwood Christian Church, TX every human being should have the right to these basic things. Our AGI team considers one critical question when choosing the causes in this catalog: Does this project offer a long term, sustainable When Hurricane Harvey hit Texas in August 2017, some smaller towns solution to a problem? In selecting the causes to present to you (the surrounding Houston were impacted too. Kingwood, Texas, where one donor) we want to make sure the ultimate beneficiary of your gift is of AGI’s markets is held, was one of them. We called Lindy Nelson-Paryag able to make a way out of their situation. (Kingwood Christian Church market coordinator) to check on things, and she informed us that her church was operating as a temporary shelter Each gift in this catalog makes a direct impact in the lives of those for those affected. Some families had no insurance and lost nearly every- who might otherwise be trapped in a hopeless cycle. For a family thing, forced to rebuild their lives from scratch. AGI was able to help this that has endured generations of poverty, your gift is a path toward community as they recovered from the devastation. stability.
    [Show full text]
  • Impact Report | 2018-2022 Plant with Purpose Families Cut Their Poverty by Nearly Two-Thirds
    2018-2021 EDITION IMPACT EVALUATION REPORT Growing Out of Poverty Impact Report | 2018-2022 Plant With Purpose Families Cut Their Poverty by Nearly Two-Thirds One of the most important things Plant With Purpose 2,400 randomly selected families from our programs, does is measure the effectiveness of our programs. as well as data from remote sensors and mapping. We constantly collect data, but every three years we The same data is gathered from non-partnering fam- conduct an extensive evaluation of each program and ilies in the same watershed or neighboring water- its impact. With these evaluations we can ensure we sheds to make up a control sample. are positively changing the lives of those we serve. A key indicator is our multidimensional poverty index, Evaluations also help us learn how to continually im- which helps us better understand poverty in communi- prove our work, so we can foster hope, opportunity, ties with very little cash. This index looks beyond income and the love of Christ in farmers who struggle at the to measure things like access to water, education, and intersection of extreme poverty and environmental adequate housing. Collectively, Plant With Purpose par- degradation. ticipating families cut their poverty level by two-thirds, We completed the most recent impact evaluations compared with control group families. This is one of the in early fiscal year 2018, which included surveys of most exciting results we have ever measured and gives us great confidence that our work is having the desired effect Essential Stats | 2 for tens of thousands of partnering families.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report Fiscal Year 2018
    ANNUAL REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2018 ENVIRONMENTAL SOLUTIONS TO HUMANITARIAN PROBLEMS PLANTING FOR TOMORROW THE REALITY THE RESPONSE Four of every five people living in poverty For over 30 years, Plant With Purpose has around the world live in rural areas. These fami- addressed the root causes of rural poverty. lies rely on the land for food and income, mak- Local Plant With Purpose teams are working ing them vulnerable to environmental changes hand-in-hand with farming families around the such as erratic rain patterns, loss of soil fertility, world to innovate, test, and then scale up sus- and natural disasters. The results of environ- tainable solutions. Through constant learning, mental degradation and resource scarcity can we have become more efficient and effective be devastating, but hope is stronger. year after year. THE PLANT WITH PURPOSE MISSION Plant With Purpose, a Christian nonprofit organization, reverses deforestation and poverty around the world by transforming the lives of the rural poor. IMPACT ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMIC Plant With Purpose families cut their level of RESTORATION EMPOWERMENT poverty by two-thirds. Entire watersheds are undergoing restoration, and families are gaining hope as they recog- SPIRITUAL RENEWAL nize their God-given abilities and grow in faith. FAITH EMPOWERMENT COLLABORATION Honor Christ, always Build capacity and stength Work together in partnership INNOVATION STEWARDSHIP SUSTAINABILITY Learn and improve Maximize resources for good Foster long-term health CORE VALUES WORLDWIDE IMPACT WHERE PLANT WITH PURPOSE IS TAKING ROOT INTERNATIONAL PROGRAMS INTERNATIONAL LATIN AMERICA, AFRICA, ASIA LATIN LATIN AMERICA AFRICA ASIA Mexico Tanzania Thailand Dominican Republic Burundi Haiti Ethiopia DRC (Democratic Republic of the Congo) PLANT WITH PURPOSE ANNUAL INCOME GROWTH* INCOME GROWTH $8M FISCAL YEARS 2011-18 $6M $4M $2M FY 2011 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 FY 2018 Income *Income includes multi-year pledges where part of the pledge has not been received.
    [Show full text]
  • A Tanzanian Gem  Loving God and People Through Creation Care Bamboo: the Crazy Grass with a Constructive Side  Intern Spotlight: Melissa Larson
    ® NEWS ECHO volume 38 | issue 4 honoring God through sustainable hunger solutions in this issue: a Tanzanian gem loving God and people through Creation Care bamboo: the crazy grass with a constructive side intern spotlight: Melissa Larson ECHO News 1 February 2014 David Erickson, President/CEO I hope that you thoroughly enjoy this issue of ECHO News. As you read through these articles, these two words may come to your mind: complexity and simplicity. As you readily understand, the work that we’ve taken on is complex! There are so many variables in agriculture related to weather, soil conditions, the timing and amounts of water, plant varieties, seed availability and quality, and more and more. Farming knowledge, traditions, and practices vary widely. Cultures shape roles and responsibilities within family farming, views about what can be eaten, and how foods are prepared. And then there are the challenges of language, access, and relational credibility. Our challenge and opportunity is to work through all of this to provide knowledge and guidance that is as simple and easy to implement as possible. We cannot be “simplistic”; that doesn’t serve anyone. There are also no “one- size-fits-all” solutions. We recognize that the people we serve are beautifully creative and intelligent–they have just not had the opportunity to learn what we have been privileged to learn from researchers, practitioners, and small- scale farmers all around the world. So HOW we go about our work is really important! We begin with simple humility, and we continue as learners. We don’t “dispense” information, we come alongside to share knowledge and experience.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Connections
    GLOBAL CONNECTIONS 2013 Report on Global Citizenship INTRODUCTION 2 About This Report Our annual Global Citizenship Report (GCR) tracks enterprise-wide strategies, goals, programs and progress across four key pillars: Q Economics & Access: increase global commerce sustainably for communities and shareholders Q Environment & Efficiency: create more efficient networks for our customers while minimizing our footprint Q Community & Disaster Relief: leverage our infrastructure, our resources and our people to help communities worldwide Q People & Workplace: foster a culture dedicated to making every FedEx experience outstanding Our FY13 report covers our fiscal year 2013, which ended May 31, 2013, and includes data from each of our operating Table of Contents companies and geographies unless otherwise stated. Chairman and CEO Letter 3 We began annual reporting of our global citizenship efforts in 2008, with our FedEx Office division producing its first Q&A with Mitch Jackson 4 sustainability report under the Kinko’s brand name in 2003, Economics & Access 5 prior to being acquired by FedEx. Environment & Efficiency 16 We have begun an assessment of our material issues this Community & Disaster Relief 31 year, consulting external stakeholders on global citizenship People & Workplace 41 issues most relevant for us. We plan to complete our analysis and begin reporting the results in our 2014 GCR. Our FY13 report is aligned with the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) G3.1 Guidelines. A full index of GRI indicators and reference material can be found at csr.fedex.com. RECENT AWARDS 2014: FedEx Corporation ranked 8th in FORTUNE magazine’s 2013: FedEx Corporation recognized as one of The Civic 50’s “World’s Most Admired Companies,” making the top 10 for the Most Community-minded Companies in America by The National fourth consecutive year.
    [Show full text]
  • Direct Relief
    Leighton Jones Director, Emergency Response & New Initiatives Direct Relief [email protected] History | Since 1948, nonsectarian, apolitical, and privately funded Established by immigrant businessmen displaced during wartime to help people in postwar Europe living under tremendous hardship HUMANITARIAN HEALTH MISSION ...to improve the health and lives of people affected by poverty or emergencies – without regard to politics, religion, or ability to pay. | Guiding Principles GUIDING PRINCIPLES • Serve People. • Life from the Bottom, Pull from the Top. • Build Upon What Exists. • Remove Barriers. • Play to Strengths. • Ensure Value for Money. • Be a Good Partner and Advocate. • Respond Fast While Looking Ahead. • Do Not Discriminate. • Aim High. Global Programs | HEALTH FOCUS In the United States & throughout the World Community Health Disease Prevention Disease Treatment Maternal and Child Health Preparing for Disasters Responding to Disasters Supporting 2,000 healthcare facilities in 100+ countries and all 50 U.S. states 20,000+ deliveries, $1.3 billion in medical aid delivered in 2019 Largest provider of charitable medicines in the U.S. Largest facility of pre-positioned emergency response medical supplies globally APPROACH 1. Identify providers and analyze the health needs​ of the most vulnerable 2. Mobilize and deliver philanthropic resources​ 3. Derive and amplify insights PARTNERSHIPS Partnerships | HEALTHCARE DONORS Product contributions from 120+ global pharmaceutical and medical companies Over $1.3 billion (wholesale) in
    [Show full text]
  • Goals & Progress
    GOALS & PROGRESS 2011 Global Citizenship Goals & Progress Update Introduction Every year, FedEx offers data, information and examples in our annual Global Citizenship Report to show how we’re living up to our responsibilities as a corporate citizen. We break our reporting into four categories: Economics & Access Environment & Efficiency Community & Disaster Relief People & Workplace Every FedEx team member contributes to our progress in these four important areas, their actions speaking just as loudly as the numbers that mark our progress. To learn more about any of the four areas, click on its name above. 2011 GLOBAL CITIZENSHIP GOALS & PROGRESS UPDATE | 2 ECONOMICS & ACCESS 2011 Global Citizenship Goals & Progress Update Economics & Access Table of Contents Introduction 3 FedEx operating companies 3 Sustainable Access and trade 4 777F trade lanes 4 Electronic trade documents 4 Financial highlights 5 Revenue 5 Capital expenditures 5 Operating margin 5 Diluted earnings per share 5 Net income 5 Debt to total capitalization 5 Operating income 5 Awards and recognition 6 Endnotes 6 All currencies are translated in U.S. dollars. 2011 GLOBAL CITIZENSHIP GOALS & PROGRESS UPDATE | 2 Economics & Access FEDEX STRIVES TO CONNECT THE WORLD IN RESPONSIBLE AND RESOURCEFUL WAYS By increasing access to the marketplace and innovation, FedEx promotes GLOBAL OPPORTUNITY business opportunities that facilitate trade and economic growth. And in the process, we meet the needs of consumers the world over. At FedEx, we believe promoting Access makes smart business sense not only for our shareholders but also for the communities and businesses we serve. The goods we deliver across our networks move the global economy—from We see the most dramatic changes in the multitude of small businesses going corporations that span the world to startups that want to compete in a new global from day one, like the recent meteoric growth of Cambridge Satchel.
    [Show full text]
  • Regional Major Gifts Officer, Bay Area
    REGIONAL MAJOR GIFTS OFFICER, BAY AREA ORGANIZATIONAL PROFILE Plant With Purpose, a Christian development organization, reverses deforestation and poverty around the world by transforming the lives of the rural poor. For more than 30 years, Plant With Purpose has been a leader in linking international community development and environmental solutions, working with smallholder farmers in strategic areas where environmental degradation and poverty intersect. Plant With Purpose currently works in Burundi, Democratic Republic of the Congo, the Dominican Republic, Haiti, Mexico, Tanzania, and Thailand, employing an integrated methodology that combines environmental restoration, economic empowerment, and spiritual renewal. Activities include watershed restoration, reforestation, sustainable agriculture training, savings-and-loan groups, local leadership development, and supporting outreach efforts of the local Christian church. JOB SUMMARY The Regional Major Gifts Officer is the critical link in initiating and cultivating relationships with potential major donors (individuals, corporations, churches, and foundations) who have the capability of making significant financial contributions to the mission of Plant With Purpose. The Regional Major Gifts Officer will work collaboratively with the Director of Development and Marketing to build an effective development strategy in a particular region with a strong emphasis on major gifts. The Regional Major Gifts Officer will identify new prospective donors; build and maintain strong relationships with
    [Show full text]
  • Perspectives from the Field
    The Hebrew University of Jerusalem The Faculty of Social Sciences Glocal Internships 2011: Perspectives from the Field Glocal would like to thank the School of Public Policy and the Faculty of Social Science at the Hebrew University for their support of Glocal internships 2011. Established at the Hebrew University in the winter of 2011, Glocal Community- Development Studies was designed to be an interdisciplinary Master’s program aimed at the effective translation of academic research into practical understanding conducive to work with communities and development organizations across the globe. To this end, an integral part of the Glocal program is the internship - which serves to supplement each student’s academic learning with a grounded local experience. Each year, a group of Glocal students embark on their internships, forging connections with marginalized communities across the world through hand’s on work with leading development INGOs or NGOs. In the fall of 2011, after a year of research and preparations, the first cohort of Glocal students set out on their internships. Upon their return to Israel, the students engaged in a process of self-reflection and joint learning- unpacking their experiences through a final seminar. Inspired by the deep engagement of our students with local communities, and the breadth of insights and innovations that grew from their work, we searched for a way to share them with you. This booklet is composed of a series of posters. Each poster is distinct, describing the general work of a partner organization, and highlighting the unique path each student followed as they developed their projects with a local community.
    [Show full text]
  • September 16, 2020 MEDIA CONTACTS Christi Renaud, Plant
    NEWS RELEASE San Diego, CA/Lancaster, PA/Bujumbura, Burundi - September 16, 2020 MEDIA CONTACTS Christi Renaud, Plant With Purpose [email protected] Becky Svendsen Harbaugh, HOPE International [email protected] Plant With Purpose and HOPE International partner to bring regenerative agriculture and environmental restoration to savings groups Plant With Purpose and HOPE International are excited to announce a new strategic partnership that merges the strengths of both organizations to equip rural families to grow out of poverty. This joint initiative in Burundi is a promising first step in collaboration and learning, and both organizations are excited to explore additional opportunities to work together. The partnership launches this September in Burundi. Plant With Purpose will train 1,850 farmers who are members of HOPE International’s local savings groups in regenerative agriculture. The partnership will focus on collaborative program implementation, innovation, research, and evaluation for shared learning and impact. Both organizations expect that this will be just the start of a fruitful collaboration. HOPE International’s savings groups will gain access to regenerative agriculture training, which, in combination with savings groups, has proven to have a substantial impact on poverty reduction and financial resilience in rural communities. In joining forces, Plant With Purpose gains the opportunity to extend its core program model to a larger population in an innovative and efficient way. Jared White, Plant
    [Show full text]