Genomewide Homozygosity Mapping and Molecular Analysis of a Candidate Gene Located on 22Q13 (Fibulin-1) in a Previously Undescribed Vitreoretinal Dystrophy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
OPHTHALMIC MOLECULAR GENETICS Genomewide Homozygosity Mapping and Molecular Analysis of a Candidate Gene Located on 22q13 (Fibulin-1) in a Previously Undescribed Vitreoretinal Dystrophy Maike Weigell-Weber, MD; Gian-Marco Sarra, MD; Dieter Kotzot, MD; Lodewijk Sandkuijl, PhD†; Elmar Messmer, MD; Martin Hergersberg, PhD Objectives: To localize the gene that causes an autoso- meric) to D22S1170 (telomeric). Lod scores were be- mal recessively inherited vitreoretinal dystrophy that has tween 0.017 and 2.36 (theta=0). A mutation analysis of not been described, to our knowledge, and to analyze a the complete coding region of FBLN1, which encodes in- candidate gene mapped to 22q13 (fibulin-1 [FBLN1]). teracting extracellular matrix proteins, revealed 4 pre- viously undescribed single nucleotide polymorphisms. Methods: Homozygosity mapping with 500 microsat- ellite markers spread over the whole genome (mean dis- Conclusions: A genomewide homozygosity mapping tance, 7.2 centimorgans [cM]) and mutation analysis of analysis supported the hypothesis that the gene respon- the complete coding region of FBLN1. sible for a unique vitreoretinal dystrophy is located on chromosome 22q13. No obviously pathogenic muta- Results: Homozygosity for all analyzed markers was tion was found in the candidate gene, FBLN1. found in the 4 affected siblings in a region on chromo- some 22 encompassing 12 cM from D22S444 (centro- Arch Ophthalmol. 2003;121:1184-1188 EREDITARY vitreoretinal COL11A2 on 6p21.3], Wagner syndrome on dystrophies are poten- 5q13-14, Knobloch syndrome on 21q22.3, tially blinding disorders Goldmann-Favre [enhanced S-cone] syn- characterized by an abnor- drome on 15q23, and multiple vitreoreti- mal vitreous gel, associ- nopathies on 11q13) were excluded by link- Hated retinal changes, and a heterogeneous age analysis. From the Institute of Medical origin. The phenotype is extremely vari- Genetics, University of Zurich able in both syndromic and nonsyndromic See also page 1109 (Drs Weigell-Weber and types. Some of them are associated with axial Hergersberg); Department of myopia of different extents and retinal de- Here, we report on a genomewide ho- Ophthalmology, University tachment. Disease-causing mutations have mozygosity mapping approach that found Hospital Zurich, been identified in various genes that en- a 12-centimorgan (cM) homozygous re- Frauenklinikstr (Drs Sarra and code components of the extracellular ma- gion on chromosome 22q13 containing, Messmer), Zurich, Switzerland; trix (ECM).1 Syndromic types of vitreoreti- among other genes, fibulin-1 (FBLN1). the Institute of Medical Biology nal dystrophies are Knobloch syndrome This attractive candidate gene was fur- and Human Genetics, (Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man University of Innsbruck, ther analyzed for mutations. Innsbruck, Austria (Dr Kotzot); [OMIM] *120328) and the rather heterog- Department of Medical eneous Stickler syndrome (OMIM #108300, METHODS Statistics, Leiden, the OMIM #604841, and OMIM #184840). Netherlands (Dr Sandkuijl). Nonsyndromic types are the Wagner syn- SUBJECTS Dr Sarra is currently affiliated drome (OMIM *143200), Goldmann- with the Department of Favre dystrophy (OMIM #268100), and the The family originated from eastern Switzer- Ophthalmology, Inselspital, allelic enhanced S cone syndrome. In ad- land. Informed consent and medical history Berne, Switzerland; dition, similar ophthalmologic findings were obtained from 3 healthy and 4 affected Dr Messmer, with Stadtspital have been described in families with X- siblings aged 68 to 77 years at the time of in- Triemli, Zurich; and chromosomal, autosomal dominant, and au- vestigation. The eighth sibling as well as both Dr Hergersberg, with Zentrum parents were not affected and died prior to this tosomal recessive inheritance. As reported fu¨r Labormedizin, Aarau, 2 investigation. The clinical data have been re- Switzerland. The authors have by Sarra et al, the chromosomal loci of some ported in detail.2 Briefly, in the 4 affected sib- no relevant financial interest of these disorders (high myopia on 18p11, lings, the onset of visual disturbance started in in this article. 12q21-23, and 7q36, Stickler syndrome early childhood, followed by progressive night †Deceased. [COL1A1 on 12q13, COL11A1 on 1q21, blindness and visual field impairment during (REPRINTED) ARCH OPHTHALMOL / VOL 121, AUG 2003 WWW.ARCHOPHTHALMOL.COM 1184 ©2003 American Medical Association. All rights reserved. Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ on 09/28/2021 the third to fifth decade of life. Clinical evaluation revealed a peculiar vitreoretinal degeneration characterized by vitreous liq- uefaction and strand formation along with diffuse retinal pig- I-1 I-2 ment epithelium atrophy and pigment clumping of the retina, and high myopia with deep posterior staphyloma. The mean axial length of the eyes was 31.4 mm (range, 28.49-33.41 mm). II-1 II-2 II-3 II-4 II-5 II-6 II-7 II-8 D22S928 2 3 1 31212 12 12 1 3 The depth of the posterior staphylomata was 0.8 mm to 2.7 mm D22S444 2 2 1 21111 11 11 1 2 (mean, 1.75 mm). Visual acuity ranged from no light percep- D22S1153 2 1 2 12222 22 22 2 1 tion to 20/70. Kinetic perimetry revealed severe constrictions D22S532 2 1 1 11111 11 11 1 1 of the isopters, with remaining small central islands. Electro- D22S1141 1 1 1 11111 11 11 1 1 physiologic investigations showed severe retinal damage, sug- D22S1160 21 212222 22 22 21 gestive of a superimposed widespread retinal dystrophy. D22S1149 31 212222 22 22 21 A genealogic analysis of 5 generations revealed no evi- D22S1170 11 212222 22 22 21 dence for parental consanguinity (Manuel Aicher, Genealo- D22S1161 1 2 2 22121 21 21 2 2 gische Forschung, Dietikon, Switzerland). However, the ori- gin of most of the ancestors from a relatively isolated population Figure 1. Pedigree of the family, with solid symbols representing affected individuals. Haplotypes for microsatellite polymorphisms most closely linked and several consanguinities in the different parental pedigrees to fibulin-1 (FBLN1) are depicted below each symbol. The markers showing were indicated. homozygosity in the affected siblings are boxed. GENOTYPING Blood samples were obtained from all 7 living siblings after writ- the Applied Biosystems Dye terminator sequencing kit (Foster ten informed consent was obtained. DNA was extracted using stan- City, Calif), followed by sequence analysis on an ABI 3700 cap- dard salting out procedures. For homozygosity mapping, the DNA- illary sequencer (Microsynth, Balgach, Switzerland). RNA was pooling method was applied (affected vs unaffected).3 The mean isolated from EDTA anticoagulated blood using a QIAamp RNA distance between the 500 highly polymorphic markers used was Blood Mini Kit (Qiagen). Reverse transcriptase (RT)-PCR analy- 7.2 cM. Microsatellites chosen for maximum informativeness were sis was performed with the Titan RT-PCR kit (Roche Diagnos- obtained from the Genethon human genetic linkage map4 and from tics, Rotkreuz, Switzerland), using the experimental condi- the Marshfield map.5 Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers tions provided by the supplier. The primers used for RT-PCR were from Research Genetics (Huntsville, Ala) or were synthe- were A4F, TCTGCCACTGACACCTCAAG, and A4R, sized with the available sequence information. Polymerase chain GGATTTTGGAGGCAACACAT (nucleotides 2141-2160 and 2321-2344, respectively, of the complementary DNA se- reaction was performed using standard conditions. Products were 9 electrophoretically separated on 6% polyacrylamide sequencing quence of variant A of FBLN1 ). The RT reaction was per- gels and visualized by silver staining.6 Linkage was calculated us- formed at 60°C for 30 minutes, followed by 15 minutes at 95°C. ing the LINKAGE (version 5.1) program package (Laboratory of The denaturation, annealing, and extension temperatures were Statistical Genetics at Rockefeller University, New York, NY), as- 94°C for 30 seconds, 60°C for 30 seconds, and 72°C for 60 sec- suming autosomal recessive inheritance, 100% penetrance in both onds, respectively, for 40 cycles. sexes, and a gene frequency of 0.001. The same assumptions were used for the lod score calculation for the homozygous region with HAPLOTYPE ANALYSIS OF FBLN1 the MAPMAKER/HOMOZ algorithm.7 For this calculation, each marker allele that showed homozygosity in the 4 patients was as- Assays were developed for the 4 single nucleotide polymor- sumed to be the most frequent allele of the corresponding marker. phisms (SNPs) identified during mutation analysis of FBLN1. The allele frequencies of the different SNPs and the haplo- MUTATION ANALYSIS OF FBLN1 types arising from the different allele combinations were ana- lyzed in the DNA of 30 families (parents and at least 1 child) The PCR primers, annealing temperatures, and PCR product not affected by vitreoretinal dystrophy or severe myopia. These sizes for the amplification of all 20 exons of FBLN1, including families had given written informed consent that their anony- the exon-intron boundaries, were derived from the gene struc- mous DNA samples could be used for research. ture as described by Pan et al,8 and are available on request. Heteroduplex analysis of the PCR products was performed by denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography on a Wave RESULTS system (Transgenomic Inc, Omaha, Neb). The column used was a DNAsep Cartridge (Transgenomic Inc). After heteroduplex HOMOZYGOSITY MAPPING formation, DNA fragments were run, with column tempera- tures between 50°C to 68°C. The column temperature was A homozygous region on chromosome 22q13 was iden- changed in incremental steps of 2°C. An elution time of 14 min- tified, which extends from the proximal marker, D22S444, utes was used: the linear acetonitrile–triethylammonium acetate– to the distal marker, D22S1170 (Figure 1). The calcu- buffer gradient ratio went from 43%/57% to 68%/32% during lated lod score for the polymorphic markers that are ho- 10 minutes, with a buffer flow of 0.9 mL/minute, followed by mozygous in this region was between 0.017 and 2.18 (theta a 100% acetonitrile wash for 30 seconds, and in an equilibra- =0). This region contains FBLN1 (base pairs 29/341/ tion step, was reduced to 43%/57% for the last 4 minutes.