AL Lewis Source
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
On Some Dolmens of Peculiar Types in France and Elsewhere. Author(s): A. L. Lewis Source: The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland, Vol. 40 (Jul. - Dec., 1910), pp. 336-348 Published by: Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2843262 Accessed: 16-02-2016 04:54 UTC Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/ info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Wiley and Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 209.175.73.10 on Tue, 16 Feb 2016 04:54:28 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 336 ON SOME DOLMENS OF PECULIAR TYPES IN FRANCE AND ELSEWHERE. BY A. L. LEWIS. THE fifthPrehistoric Congress of France, at whichI had the honourof represent- ing the Royal AnthropologicalInstitute, visited, amongst other objectsof interest, four dolinens of a peculiar type in the Department of the Oise. These were all alike in plan, and differedbut little in size or other details, except as to orientation. They are all chambers,between 20 and 30 feet long, and 4 or 5 feet wide and deep, lined, and originallycovered with slabs of stone, and closed at bothends. In threeof themthe stone at one end is pierced by a round hole, not more than 18 inches in diameter, and carefully worked from both sides. In the fourth,instead of the single slab with a hole, two or morestones are so arranged as to make an opening. Outside these holed stones is an open portico or shrine,of which the holed stonie forms the back, the sides being composedof two or moreupright stones, and all being roofedin by one or more capstones,which stand at a higher level than those of the allJecouverte behind them. The lengthof the whole structureis about 30 feet. At TRIE CHATEAU,about fourkilometres from Gisors, in a wood,are a menhir and a dolmen of this type. The menhir is 4 metres high,2 metreswide, and 4 of a metre thick (13 feet by 61 by 2O), and is buried in the ground to more than half its height; but it has been dug round,and some animal bones were discoveredduring the excavations. The dolmen,which is about 250 mletres fromit, is of the type I have just described,the aliJecouverte being about 24 feet long,31 to 4 feet wide,and 3 feet deep, but possiblydeeper originally. It stands about 15? east of north and west of south. The stone at the south end and the capstones have been removed. Polished stone axes and human bones were discoveredin or underneathit. At the northend the all4e is closed by a siingle stone,8 feet long,1 footthick, and 5 feet high,pierced by a round hole,not more than 18 inches in diameter,through which children were formerlypassed to cure or preservethem from fever. On the northside of this stone are two others, each 5 feet high, at right angles to it, formingwith it a porticoor shrine,which is covered by a stone 122 feet long, 6 wide, and from 2 to 3 thick. This shrine faces to about 10 east of north, while that which I have to speak of next,LA PIERRE AUX FLEs at VILLERS ST. SEPULCHRE,faces about due north. This latter structureindeed differsfrom the otheronly in retainingtwo of the This content downloaded from 209.175.73.10 on Tue, 16 Feb 2016 04:54:28 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions ~~~~~~~~~~~~~-- - 49 ~ 4 V W-, - ---f- + taget A- 5ss=. t~~~~~~6 .- S ..... 'Foake C. 50... 4 2 i5__>e__100 + A t w, 5D/)b -W isnswgS 8 C ,~-. Ai --- - so~~~~~ .145.~~~~~.1C L-11 t- tLi w .I 19 o A~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~s /+ A ?3 co lz c- Qlz .00F - ;~~~~3.L -w -|-3 '5 q~~~~SM tz z 171 Zs cli zz Ct'.) Qlt 00 Cl* Fl- >~~~~~~~~~AV 2*/ _ - . a. *-~ .1 o~ A? ^ F a .95.- DDLMEM_DFEuPEuXnsDAUIDlES a DETI[-[VATEAU . DEL DOLME{ %5t. {><it_2@t, 4!LUt'dW dcwsin- NWAUJXFEES. ~~ k d dtf cgo. le ;r Auat 9Lt9. (Sd.~~~~~~~~~~m C4 C4 -4 This content downloaded from 209.175.73.10 on Tue, 16 Feb 2016 04:54:28 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 338 A. L. LEwIs.- On some Dolmens o0 capstonesof the allJe,and in some small pointsof measuremientwhich I need not give in detail. Human rernainsand stone axes are said to have been foundin it manyyears ago. The third holed dolnien,the DOLMEN DE LA BELLIE at BOURY,is of the same type and of alnmostthe samnemeasurements, but the shrine or portico faces 15' north of east, to a positioln in which the sun would rise twice yearly (probablyabout 1st May and 10th August), and each of its sides consistsof two or three stones ilnsteadof one. Each of these groups of stones supports a small capstone,and the large capstone rests upon them instead of directlyupon the uprightstones. This arrangementmay have been made only because of a difficulty in gettinga stone large enouighto cover the others completely,or theremay have been some other idea involved in it. One of the roofing,stones of the allJehas 00 00 00 BOURY7 0 I5 E. AVENY7 EV) RE. AUBERC ENVILLE, COURJEONNET SElNE Er 03E. MARr . 0 0 C,ROTTES or COIZARD, PETIT MORIN,MARNE. COLLOR CIUES, AARD. FRO NT. AC K. 0 0 _ N S5T. SERNIN.I AVEYRON., qUER N5 EY. This content downloaded from 209.175.73.10 on Tue, 16 Feb 2016 04:54:28 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions .e- -Oo---e !(--9o--9~- 9 0 35 Aal 4 ztt;tn . ' Ywe bLLfoltb . 4. a. o __4 ( . ... ... 1 1-d ClClll. lz i__120___ + +so +6Q i o.4 V&. C". z VLi~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~f IIULMENim [HAMPILNULLE ;*a0 ll 1 (7 X ~~~~~~4 8|-__f__ cr) C' . A90 Z-i 4 le19AatO (9 X Z-i 1 X s f dMi4 s t Q'Zl C14 ~~1A5:I0VD,VIJJWLD,t~~~~4.W hr1 z ,'1 9''S.'kj'l~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~t Z- , 65z; W4k T- 14 Z_',-4 i F" 1 3 rev ICAc ?tof 130'4 ' 90x. '40tit Iguy, .m D5490. a,Vttcersi/trtnZ>DM 1. K DUlMENtLA 23llEE. 6,34tE ( Wvh& gwf ic;Wex. j, " w EULMENDE flAMJPIGNULLE. C" Z C,@* w Co This content downloaded from 209.175.73.10 on Tue, 16 Feb 2016 04:54:28 UTC All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 340 A. L. LEWIS.-OA some Dolmiensof faller.partly into it, blockingit up. The remainsof ninetybodies were found in the aliee with some stone axes, spearheads, and pottery,but nothinghas been foundin the portico. The point of greatest differencebetween the Dolmen de la Belle Laye and the othersis, however,the remarkablecarving which is on the middle stone on the north side of the portico. This has been thoughtto representa prehistoric goddess of a rather unpleasant description,who is associated with a stone axe (not the double-bladedCretan weapon). The resemblancebetween this sculpture and a fenmalefigure is not very strikingat firstsight, but it becomes somewhat plainer on comparingthe variousillustrations collected by M. Salomon Reinach,l by means of whichwe see that these carvings representmerely the breasts and necklace of a by no means engagingfemale figure, more fully represented in other places. In one case we find a rudimentarynose, in another a nose and mouth withouteyes, and in othersnoses and eyes withoutmouths, while some have arms and even hands and fingers. Most of these are carved on only one face of the stone,but in one instance the back of the stone is carved as well as the front. The collar or the breasts,and frequentlyboth, appear on nearlyall these extra- ordinaryfigures, and show the connectionbetween those in which nothing else is representedand those whichare more complete. Yet I think it can hardly be maintainedthat any of themare developed fromothers by a processof improve- ment, or degraded from others by unintelligentcopying, as the Gaulish and Britishcoins appear to have been degradedfrom a Greek original. It would seem ratherthat the sculptor and those forwhom be worked found the slightestcon- ventional attributesufficient to bring their deity beforetheir minds,and that,I suppose, suggests a considerableamount of intellectualityon their part. There are sculpturedstones amongstthe megalithicmonuments of Ireland and also of Brittany,and on some of the latter stone axes seem to be figured; but,so far as I know,none of them exhibit those emblemsof the goddess whichwe have been especially considering. Mr. Borlase,however, thinks that he finds traces of her in Irish traditionand folklore(Dolmens of Ireland, p. 579). It has been said (Builder, 18th May, 1907) that "of six stones that remainof a line that ran parallel to a now destroyedtomb at Tamuli (Sardinia) three have breasts,as if to distinguishthe sex of threeof those buriedin the tomb; " but the position of these stones,as shown by La Marmora and, after him,by Perrot and Chipiez in theirrespective books, seems to indicate that theyhad no connection with the tomb in question.