Arxiv:2009.00128V2 [Cond-Mat.Mes-Hall] 11 Sep 2020 Ments, Owing Partly to Its Extremely Low Magnetic Dis- Sipation [24]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Spin cat states in a ferromagnetic insulator Sanchar Sharma,1 Victor A. S. V. Bittencourt,1 Alexy D. Karenowska,2 and Silvia Viola Kusminskiy1, 3 1Max Planck Institute for the Science of Light, Staudtstraße 2, 91058 Erlangen, Germany 2Clarendon Laboratory, Department of Physics, University of Oxford, Oxford OX1 3PU, United Kingdom 3Department of Physics, University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Staudtstraße 7, 91058 Erlangen, Germany Generating non-classical states in macroscopic systems is a long standing challenge. A promising platform in the context of this quest are novel hybrid systems based on magnetic dielectrics, where photons can couple strongly and coherently to magnetic excitations, although a non-classical state therein is yet to be observed. We propose a scheme to generate a magnetization cat state, i.e. a quantum superposition of two distinct magnetization directions, using a conventional setup of a macroscopic ferromagnet in a microwave cavity. Our scheme uses the ground state of an ellipsoid shaped magnet, which displays anisotropic quantum fluctuations akin to a squeezed vacuum. The magnetization collapses to a cat state by either a single-photon or a parity measurement of the microwave cavity state. We find that a cat state with two components separated by ∼ 5~ is feasible and briefly discuss potential experimental setups that can achieve it. Introduction: The concept of superposition is a cor- (a) MeasureMeasurement nerstone of quantum theory, a paradigmatic example of which is a ‘cat state’ referring to, loosely speaking, a Microwave system which exists in a quantum superposition of two H0 quasi-classical states. Besides their important histori- M B cal link to Schrödinger’s famous gedanken experiment, − · y z their insensitivity to particle loss noise [1] means that z y Magnetization cat states find useful application as carriers of informa- tion (qubits) in quantum computation [2–4] or as sensors in quantum metrological tasks [5–8]. The robustness of (b) Ground State Heralded State a cat state increases with its size, i.e. how ‘distinct’ the Isotropic Isotropic two quasi-classical components are. Experimental real- 10 10 izations of cat states include photon states at optical [9– 11] and microwave [12] frequencies with a size of up to 3 ZPF and 100 photons respectively, and a spin-state with size M 0 z 0 z / 2~ composed of 3000 atoms [13]. At a fundamen- y ∼ ∼ M y y tal level, a macroscopic cat state is a prototypical sys- 10 x 10 x tem to study collapse in quantum-to-classical transitions − − [14, 15]. However, non-classical states are notoriously dif- 10 0 10 10 0 10 ficult to generate in macroscopic systems due to the lack − M / − M / of long enough coherence lengths. Considerable advances x MZPF x MZPF on this front have been obtained in optomechanical sys- tems (in which light couples to acoustic excitations [16]) FIG. 1. (a) Setup: A ferromagnetic ellipsoid (green) with [17–20], however cat states have not yet been realized in magnetization M couples to microwaves in a cavity via dipole this platform [21, 22]. coupling to the cavity magnetic field B. An external applied field H0 saturates the magnetization along one of the short Over the last few years, a new kind of hybrid quantum axes (k z). (b) Probability density of the quasi-classical mag- system has emerged as a promising platform for quan- netization’s state as a function of its components in units of tum applications, where photons are coupled coherently the isotropic zero point fluctuations MZPF ; see Eqs. ((1), to magnetic excitations (magnons) in magnetic materi- 9). Ground state: The squeezed magnetization vacuum [see als [23]. The dielectric ferrimagnet Yttrium Iron Gar- Eq. (10)] with anisotropic fluctuations. The inset shows the net (YIG) is the material of choice in current experi- non-squeezed (isotropic) case, valid for a spherical magnet. Heralded state: The magnetization state after detecting a arXiv:2009.00128v2 [cond-mat.mes-hall] 11 Sep 2020 ments, owing partly to its extremely low magnetic dis- sipation [24]. Coherent and strong magnon-microwave microwave photon [see Eq. (22)] showing features of a cat coupling using sub-mm spheres of YIG has been real- state. Such features are absent when there is no squeezing (inset). ized [25–27] and used to mediate the coupling between magnons and superconducting qubits [28]. Magnons in YIG can also coherently couple to optical photons [25, 29–32], phonons [33, 34], and electrons [35–37], point- has been moreover demonstrated [40, 41]. These develop- ing to the possibility of magnon-based quantum trans- ments together with the recent demonstration of single- ducers [38, 39]. Using YIG thin films, a Bose-Einstein magnon detection in YIG spheres [42, 43], has opened condensate of magnons showing macroscopic coherence prospects for studying and manipulating microwave mag- 2 netic excitations in a quantum coherent manner. Creat- sity for the magnetization is ing non-classical states of the magnetization is crucial for µ0 ~ future applications in what has been denominated ‘quan- mag = MNM µ0MzH0; (2) H 2 − tum magnonics’ [23]. Theoretical proposals so far include all-optical heralding of magnon Fock states [44] and gen- where M is the total magnetization and N~ is the demag- eration of entangled states [45–47]. netization tensor, arising from the finite geometry. The Here, we propose a scheme to prepare a cat state of magnitude M = Ms is a constant of motion [54] where 18 j j a macroscopic number of spins (> 10 ) which can be Ms is the saturation magnetization. For a spheroid, N~ achieved by employing state-of-the-art microwave cavi- is diagonal with Nx = Nz = NT and Ny = 1 2NT ties with an embedded magnetic element of anisotropic [54, 55]. We assume a sufficiently large magnetic− field, shape, see Fig. 1(a). The protocol relies on the H0 > Ms=2, such that the classical ground state is anisotropy of the magnet enforcing a magnetic ground M = Msz. Since the energy cost of fluctuations in My is state analogous to the squeezed vacuum in quantum op- smaller than that in Mx, the quantum fluctuations in Mx tics, plus the concomitant entangled spin-photon ground and My are different, leading to a squeezed vacuum [50]. state when the magnet is coupled to the cavity. We show We model the quantum fluctuations using the Holstein- that in a YIG sample cats with a size 5~ are feasi- Primakoff approximation [54, 56] ble, where the size can be tuned by an external∼ magnetic M iM field. x − y s;^ (3) 2 ! Model: A well established protocol to generate cat MZPF states in quantum optics is to add a photon to a squeezed valid for Mx;y Mz with ZPF defined in Eq. (1). optical vacuum [9, 48, 49]. In order to accomplish this Using Eq.j (3)j and retainingM only quadratic terms in s^, analogously in a ferromagnet, we first require a squeezed the magnetic Hamiltonian density (2) integrates to (up magnetization state [50], i.e. a minimum uncertainty to a constant) state with anisotropic zero-point fluctuations. This can ^ be realized via the ground state of a magnet with an Hmag !s 2 2 = !0s^ys^ + s^ +s ^y ; (4) anisotropic shape, such as an ellipsoid. Notably, the de- ~ 2 gree of squeezing of the magnetic ground state can be where tuned by an external magnetic field. The second step is γµ0Ms to add an excitation, i.e. to ‘flip’ on average one spin !s = (3NT 1) ;!0 = γµ0H0 !s: (5) which is delocalized in space, see Fig. 1(b). We show − 2 − that this can be achieved by coupling the magnetization The bosonic operator s^ flips a spin from +z to z, satis- − to a microwave cavity [25–27] and performing a measure- fies the canonical commutation relation s;^ s^y = 1, and ment of the latter. For low enough temperatures either a annihilates the classical ground state corresponding to all single-photon measurement [51, 52] or a parity measure- spins pointing along z (the spins are anti-parallel to the − ment can be employed [53]. We discuss these steps in magnetization), s^ 0 = 0. Mz is found by the constraint detail below. M = M . For a sphere,j i N = 1=3 implying ! = 0 and j j s T s The proposed setup is shown in Fig. 1(a) where a hence s^ (s^y) is the annihilation (creation) operator of the ferromagnetic ellipsoid is kept inside a microwave cav- elementary excitations of the magnet, i.e. the magnons. ity. The magnet is assumed to be slender and prolate, Below, we consider the case of a slender prolate spheroid 2 2 i.e. L L = L where L is the length in i-th di- with NT 1=2 where the term s^ +s ^y implies that y x z i ≈ / rection. In the absence of external magnetic fields, the the ground state is not 0 . j i magnetization would align with the longest axis. A suf- Squeezed magnetic vacuum - The Hamiltonian (4) can ^ ficiently large field, here H0z, aligns the magnetization be diagonalized to Hmag = ~!mm^ ym^ by a Bogoliubov to z with zero-point fluctuations largely along y [50], see transformation m^ = cosh rs^ + sinh rs^y, with Fig. 1(b). For comparison, a spherical magnet would s q have isotropic zero point fluctuations ZPF (ignoring a 2 2 Ms M !m = ! ! = γµ0 H0 H0 : (6) small crystalline anisotropy of YIG) given by 0 − s − 2 γ~Ms The parameter r characterizes the degree of squeezing 2 = ; (1) MZPF 2V and is given by r 1=4 where V is the volume of the magnet and γ is the abso- ! + ! M − er = 0 s = 1 s : (7) lute value of the gyromagnetic ratio.