Catholics Tired of Recurring Accusations of Clergy Sexual Abuse

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Catholics Tired of Recurring Accusations of Clergy Sexual Abuse VOL. 57, NO. 3 DIOCESE OF OAKLAND FEBRUARY 4, 2019 www.catholicvoiceoakland.org Serving the East Bay Catholic Community since 1963 Copyright 2019 Catholics tired of recurring accusations of clergy sexual abuse By Albert C. Pacciorini Staff writer A lively, respectful group of about 100 people met with two representatives of the Diocese of Oakland to discuss the issue of clergy sexual abuse and its coverup at St. Joan of Arc Church in San Ramon the evening of Jan. 22. Steve Wilcox, chancellor of the diocese, and Rev. Jayson Landeza outlined the historical issues of clergy sexual abuse while saying the evening would be mostly questions from the audience. Repeatedly, audience members drove home a theme: people, especially the young, are avoiding the Church in vast numbers, older people are falling away. They see the Church as unresponsive in meeting the needs of the gay and transgender community and not doing enough to end clergy sexual abuse. We’ve heard all this before, many said: People’s lives COURTESY PHOTO COURTESY have been ruined. Families are ruined. We’re tired of the About 50 people from St. Joseph Basilica, Alameda, were at the Walk for Life West Coast. Leading up to the apologies and repetition. Do something now.” walk, there were two hours a day for five days of Adoration for Life. On Jan. 26, about 30 walkers gathered Wilcox said he hopes the diocese can release its list at the basilica for a blessing prior to carpooling to BART and were joined by others at the walk. Walkers of credibly accused clergy on Feb. 18. While many will be included some from St Joseph Notre Dame High School and from the Young Families group. familiar names, there may be one or two not previously widely known. Rev. Ray Sacca, St. Joan of Arc pastor, opened the evening with prayer, and noted Catholics are expressing Peaceful, positive, personal messages outrage at the renewed abuse revelations. As chancellor of the diocese, Wilcox explained, part of his job is to aid victims of abuse and to prevent it from mark Walk for Life West Coast happening. Wilcox and Father Landeza offered a presentation By Christina Gray recounting the recent history of clergy sexual abuse, from Catholic San Francisco Be part of the the Oakland diocese’s first apology service in the 1980s, SAN FRANCISCO — A throng of upbeat pro-life sup- (Continued on Page 11.) porters, some from as far away as Colorado, Arizona counter-revolution and Tennessee, swarmed the streets of downtown San Read Archbishop Salvatore J. Cordileone’s Francisco Jan. 26 carrying a wide array of messages homily on Page 7. calling for an end to abortion. A crowd in the tens of thousands poured into Civic Center Plaza on a springlike winter day for the 15th There were a handful of spontaneous hecklers, includ- annual Walk for Life West Coast, which marked the 46th ing a man who stood near the cable car turnaround on anniversary of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Roe. v. Wade Market Street and shouted, “Go to hell” at the procession. decision legalizing abortion. But neither he nor a costumed group of about a dozen The event kicked off with prayer, pro-life speakers and more organized counterprotesters distracted the walkers, the amplified fetal heartbeats of seven babies whose many of whom smiled and waved at the provocateurs. mothers stood on the event stage holding bullhorns con- For many, the day had begun with morning Mass at St. nected to their pregnant bellies. Mary’s Cathedral celebrated by San Francisco Archbishop “Babies saving babies,” said Walk for Life chair Eva Salvatore J. Cordileone, where about 2,900 received holy Muntean. “The babies are here to save their peers.” Communion. Later in the plaza at the start of the rally, he A woman allowed to see an image of her unborn baby led marchers in a prayer from the event stage. on an ultrasound screen or to hear its heartbeat will often “Give us the courage to speak the truth with love and choose not to abort, pro-life advocates say. conviction in defense of life,” he said. Despite a heavy police presence, the two-mile march Chastity Ronan, former director of San Francisco’s from Civic Center Plaza down Market Street to Embarcadero Alpha Pregnancy Center, took the stage to accept the Plaza appeared as peaceful as organizers had hoped. At Gianna Molla Award created for local “unsung heroes” times it felt more like a celebration than a demonstration. of the pro-life movement. VOICE CATHOLIC PACCIORINI/THE C. ALBERT “This is not a day for confrontation,” Dolores Meehan, St. Gianna Beretta Molla (1922-1962) was an Italian Rev. Jayson Landeza, left, and Steve Wilcox, chancel- co-chair of the walk, advised as the march began. “Just pediatrician who refused both an abortion and a hyster- lor of the Diocese of Oakland, answer questions at a say a prayer and keep it going.” (Continued on Page 10.) forum on clergy sexual abuse on Jan. 22. On our cover Rev. Danielson was ‘a rudder in a stormy sea’ Jimmy Toner, almost 21 months old, was one of the youngest participants in the 50-strong contingent By Albert C. Pacciorini from St. Joseph Basilica Parish in Alameda to the Staff writer Remembrance Walk for Life West Coast in San Francisco Jan. 26. “We trusted him … He was refuge and he was strength, This was Jimmy’s second walk. “His first time walk- a rudder in the stormy sea,” was how Rev. Daniel E. Bishop Michael C. Barber, SJ, Page 3. Danielson was eulogized at his funeral Mass Jan. 22. ing was while I was pregnant with him two years Homily Father Danielson, a priest of the ago,” said his mother, Claire Toner. Jimmy’s father, Rev. Paul D. Minnihan, Page 14. James Toner, teaches at St. Philip Neri School. Diocese of Oakland for 55 years, died Jan. 5 after a brief illness. He was 82. ATD . .12 Father Danielson led a storied cons and sisters and many of the faithful at St. Augustine Bishop’s Column . 3 career: As a clergyman, mentor, Church, part of the Catholic Community of Pleasanton, Classified. .12 advocate for priest education and for where Father Danielson was pastor from 1985-2007. Datelines . 13 a time in the absence of a bishop, as Father Danielson was born in San Francisco on Dec. Forum . 15 administrator of the diocese. 11, 1937 and ordained to the priesthood on March 2, News in Brief . 4 In addition to Bishop Michael C. 1963 at his home parish, St. Jarlath Church in Oakland. Seniors . .11 Barber, SJ, who celebrated the Mass, In a reflection, Bishop Cummins recalled Father Rev. Danielson The Church. 2 three other bishops attended, Bishop Danielson as one with an expansive view of the priest- Travel . 5-6 Emeritus John S. Cummins, and retired Bishops Daniel F. hood, who came of age during the time of the Second Weddings, Anniversaries. 8-9 Walsh of Santa Rosa and William Justice of the Archdiocese Vatican Council. of San Francisco. They were joined by many priests, dea- (Continued on Page 11.) 2 — THE CATHOLIC VOICE THE CHURCH FEBRUARY 4, 2019 THE VATICAN BISHOP BARBER’S SCHEDULE Feb. 6: Office meetings, Chancery Feb. 15: Office meetings, Chancery Feb. 7: Office meetings, Chancery Feb. 16: 10 a.m., Adult Confirmation, Cathedral of Christ the Light, Oakland Feb. 9: 11 a.m., World Day of the Sick Mass with the celebration of Sacrament Feb. 17: 3 p.m., Mass, banquet in of the Anointing of the Sick, Cathedral of celebration of the Lunar New Year with Christ the Light, Oakland the Chinese community, Our Lady of the Rosary Parish, Union City Feb. 14: Office meetings, Chancery THE CATHEDRAL VATICAN MEDIA/CNS VATICAN 3D-printed helmets While the Swiss Guard’s halberds and uniforms have remained largely unchanged over the centuries, its ceremonial helmets are now a product of 21st-century technology. The four-pound, hand-forged metal helmet has been replaced with new lightweight headgear. Still crafted in the “morion” style of the Renaissance and topped with a fluffy red or white ostrich feather, it is now made using a 3D printer and tough, weather-resistant ASA thermo- PHOTO COURTESY plastic — the same material often used for automotive exterior parts. The New school year Swiss Guards used the new helmets during a special ceremony Jan. 22 at The St. Junipero Serra Catechetical Institute and the School for Pastoral the Vatican commemorating the 513th anniversary of their foundation. Pope ministry started a new school year Jan. 12. Around 75 new students began Julius II requested a contingent of Swiss soldiers to protect the pope and their journey toward catechetical certification, both in English and Spanish. his palace in 1505 and the first Swiss soldiers arrived at the gates of Rome The School for Pastoral ministry gathered for a day of recollection, led by Jan. 22, 1506. The Swiss Guard — made up of 110 soldiers — is the small- Father Michael Castori, SJ. The catechetical institute is a one-year formation est and oldest military corps in the world. The men guard all entrances into process for parish and Catholic school catechists, parents and all adults Vatican City State as well as keep watch over the pope and his residence, who want to know their Catholic faith better and be able to hand it on more the Domus Sanctae Marthae. effectively. Participants will receive a solid introduction to the Catholic faith in 60 hours of basic catechetical formation, and if they complete the pro- a catechetical and working gathering,” gram, will be eligible to receive the Basic California Catechist Certificate.
Recommended publications
  • West Coast Walk for Life in It's 12Th Year, Bigger Than Ever
    (North Coast Ecumenisist, cont. from page 22) ing missions.” The brief holiday occasioned by the Adult Faith delayed debarkation, provided him the opportunity Formation & Certification 2015-2016 to investigate the California Catholic mission culture. Chancery Cardinal Newman HS His journals reveal his joy and wonderment at the St. John School NORTH COAST CATHOLIC 985 Airway Ct. 50 Ursuline Rd., Santa Rosa 983 Napa St., Napa ecumenical experience. Oxford University Professor Santa Rosa 10am-3pm/Lunch 12-1 • • 6:00pm-9:30pm S. A. Mousalimas observes that Innocent’s journals The newspaper of the Diocese of Santa Rosa www.srdiocese.org JANUARY 2016 SCHEDULE 10am-3pm\Lunch 12-1 (BC) Room 27 (BC Only) (BC Only) 9am-3:30pm/Lunch 12-1 during the California trip reflected his “enjoyment Faculty Room Conference Room (MC) Room 29 of another culture.” Orientation, Introduction, Oct. 2 Oct. 21 Oct. 31 At Mission San José he met Father Jose Maria de & Spirituality of Catechesis Jesus Gonzalez. “He was,” wrote Innocent, “the most Noticias en español, pgs. 18-19 The Creed & Christology Nov. 6 Nov. 18 Nov. 21 educated and kindly of any of his brethren in all of Holy Spirit, Ecclesiology, Mary & Saints Dec. 4 Dec. 16 Dec. 5 California.” While at the mission he attended “Mass Liturgy & Sacraments of Initiation Jan. 8 Jan. 20 Jan. 30 four times and saw all the [Roman Catholic] religious Sacraments of Healing & Service Feb. 5 Feb. 17 Feb. 27 Annual implements.” Innocent and Gonzalez “conversed [in Principles/Methods/History of Catechesis; March 4 March 16 March 19 Latin] about religious matters” for hours while “shar- Intro to Ecclesial Method Moral Life in Christ: Foundations April 1 April 20 April 23 ing his table” over the next four days.
    [Show full text]
  • January 13, 2019
    January 13, 2019 Pastor: Rev. Scott S Herrera Associate Pastor: Rev. Fr. Manuel Gutierrez del Toro Palomar Hospital Chaplain: Rev. Gabriel Afeti Deacons: James Kostick Mitch Rennix Andres Sanchez Amador Durán (on Sabbatical) Parish Office Address: 1170 South Broadway Escondido CA, 92025 Phone: (760) 745-1611 Fax: (442) 248-8600 www.stmaryp.org Office Hours/Horario: Monday-Friday/Lunes-Viernes 9:00 am-12:45 pm Closed for lunch/ Cerrado durante el almuerzo 2:00 pm-5:45 pm St. Mary School: (760) 743-3431 www.stmesc.org St Mary Preschool: (760) 745-1611 Ext. 301 LITURGY & SACRAMENTS LITURGIA Y SACRAMENTOS Daily Mass: Mon - Sat 8:00am Misa Diaria: Lunes a Viernes 6:00pm Morning Prayer: Mon - Sat 7:40am Rosario: Lunes-Viernes 5:00pm Rosary: Mon - Sat after 8:00am Mass Confesiones: Martes & Jueves antes de la Misa a las Mother of Perpetual Help: Tue after 8am Mass 7:15am y 5:15pm. Sábado 4:00pm-5:15pm y con cita pre- Penance: Tues & Thurs 7:15am & 5:15pm Sat 4-5:15pm via a tráves de la oficina parroquial. PAGE 2 ST. MARY CATHOLIC CHURCH January 13, 2019 Ave María sine labe Concepta. Ora pro nobis quia Te confugimus. ST. MARY PRESCHOOL Students working on number sense, fine motor skills, holiday projects/religious themes (Ciborium, wreaths, rosaries, virtue bean bags) and writing letters in shaving cream! These pictures go out to parents every few weeks. January 13, 2019 ST. MARY CATHOLIC CHURCH PAGE 3 Ave María sine labe Concepta. Ora pro nobis quia Te confugimus. OUR LITURGICAL WEEK: MASS INTENTIONS & WEEKLY SCRIPTURE READINGS Fr.
    [Show full text]
  • Culture of Life
    BUILDING A CULTURE OF LIFE ON JANUARY 22, 2015, POPE FRANCIS SENT A TWEET TO THE VAST CROWD GATHERED FOR THE MARCH FOR LIFE IN WASHINGTON, D.C. THE POPE’S TWEET SAID, “LIFE IS A GIFT.” MORE AND MORE, PEOPLE SEEM TO BE GETTING THAT MESSAGE. THOUGH THE NEWS MEDIA DOES NOT TELL YOU, THE PRO- DEATH MOVEMENT IS GROWING WEAKER BY THE DAY, OFTEN BECAUSE OF ITS OWN INTERNAL CONTRADICTIONS. FOLLOWING DISCOVERY OF ABORTION CLINICS WITH UNSANITARY AND HAZARDOUS CONDITIONS, UNSAFE MEDICAL PRACTICES, UNLICENSED PERSONNEL, AND BOTCHED ABORTIONS RESULTING IN INJURIES AND DEATH, MORE AND MORE ABORTION CLINICS ARE BEING SHUT DOWN AND THE NUMBER OF ABORTIONS NATIONALLY CONTINUES TO DECLINE. PARTIAL BIRTH ABORTIONS, MAINLY DONE IN THE THIRD TRIMESTER, ARE NOW ILLEGAL, AND STATES ARE NOW MOVING TO BAN BRUTAL SECOND TRIMESTER DISMEMBERMENT ABORTIONS. MORE AND MORE LEGISLATURES ARE EVEN BANNING ANY ABORTIONS AFTER 20 WEEKS WHEN THE UNBORN CHILD CAN FEEL PAIN. MOREOVER, IN THE LAST FOUR YEARS, STATE LEGISLATURES Building a Culture of Life 4/15 HAVE PASSED MORE PRO-LIFE BILLS THAN IN THE PREVIOUS 10 YEARS COMBINED! WE EXPECT THESE LEGISLATIVE SUCCESSES TO CONTINUE, AS POLLS SHOW THAT THE YOUNGER GENERATION IS THE MOST PRO-LIFE GENERATION IN OUR NATION’S HISTORY! AS THE NUMBERS OF ABORTION CLINICS AND ABORTIONS DECLINE, AN INCREASING NUMBER OF PRO-LIFE PREGNANCY CARE CENTERS OFFER PREGNANT WOMEN THE OPPORTUNITY TO VIEW THEIR UNBORN CHILD ON ULTRASOUND MACHINES FUNDED BY THE KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS. SINCE 2009, THE ORDER’S ULTRASOUND INITIATIVE HAS HELPED STATE AND LOCAL KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS COUNCILS TO PARTNER WITH THE SUPREME COUNCIL TO CONTRIBUTE OVER $36 MILLION TO PREGNANCY CARE CENTERS FOR THE PURCHASE OF MORE THAN 750 ULTRASOUND MACHINES IN CANADA, JAMAICA, GUATEMALA, AND ALL 50 U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Pope Francis on Flight from UAE Talks About Dialogue, War, Abuse
    WWW.THEFLORIDACATHOLIC.ORG | Feb. 8-21, 2019 | Volume 80, Number 7 ORLANDO DIOCESE PALM BEACH DIOCESE VENICE DIOCESE A survivor’s faith story Catholic Schools Week WYD inspires teens Pope Francis on flight from UAE FEAST OF LOURDES talks about dialogue, war, abuse CINDY WOODEN Pope Francis also was asked about Catholic News Service the war in Yemen and about the con- ditions that would be necessary be- ABOARD THE PAPAL FLIGHT fore the Holy See would offer to me- FROM ABU DHABI, United Arab diate in the ongoing political crisis in Emirates | Pope Francis told re- Venezuela. porters he is more afraid of the con- On the question of intervening in sequences of not engaging in inter- Venezuela, Pope Francis said he had religious dialogue than he is of being been informed of the arrival by dip- manipulated by some Muslim lead- lomatic pouch of a letter from Ven- ers. ezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, He told reporters flying back to who is trying to hold on to power in Rome with him Feb. 5 from Abu Dha- Pope Francis aboard his flight from the country. bi that people are always saying he’s the United Arab Emirates, to Rome Asked if he was ready to mediate, letting himself be used by someone, Feb. 5. (PAUL HARING | CNS) Pope Francis said the Vatican would “including journalists, but it’s part of offer assistance only if both sides the job.” a while,” Pope Francis said. “We have requested its help and if both sides “For me, there is only one great suspended some priests, sent them showed a willingness to take steps danger at this moment: destruction, away for this, and -- I’m not sure if the toward resolving the crisis.
    [Show full text]
  • Conducted by the Fathers of the Institute of the Incarnate Word Website
    January 19, 2014 2800 Mission College Blvd., Santa Clara, CA 95054 Conducted by the Fathers of the Institute of the Incarnate Word Website: www.olop-shrine.org RECTORY Rev. Gustavo Nieto, IVE, Pastor (408) 988-4585 Rev. Samuel Leonard, IVE, Associate Pastor Rev. Juan Nuñez, IVE, Associate Pastor Rev. Joseph LoJacono, IVE, Associate Pastor CONVENT Servants of the Lord and the Virgin of Matara (408) 988-4160 Mother Maria Regina Pacis, SSVM, Superior OFFICE HOURS Rectory: Mon. 9am-4:30pm (closed 12-1); Tue. - Fri. 9am-7pm (closed 12-1pm); (408) 988-4585 Sat. 9am-1pm; Closed Sunday Catechism: Tues. & Thu. 9-11:30am & 5:30-8pm; Wed. 9-11:30am & 3-6pm; (408) 988-7543 Sat. 9am-1pm Adult Religious Ed: Tue. - Fri. 2 to 7pm; Sat. 9am-1pm (408) 988-7543 Library: Sun.-Tue. 9am-5pm, Wed. 1pm-3pm, Fri 9am-5pm (Ext. 1214) (Located in the Family Learning Center Room 1214) Music Ministry: Contact Bernadette Arnold (Ext. 2217) MASSES Sunday Vigil: Sat. 5pm & 7:30pm Sunday: 7:30am, 9:00am,10:30am, 12noon, & 5pm, 6:30pm (Spanish) & 8pm Holy Days: Please see our website or call the Rectory Office Weekdays: 8am, 12noon, 5:15pm; also 7:30pm Wed. & 8am Sat. First Friday: 8am, 12noon, 5:15pm, 7:30pm CONFESSIONS Saturdays: 3:30pm - 5pm Other times: During all Sat & Sun Masses Mon. during the 12noon & 5:15pm Masses Tue - Fri. during the 8am, 12noon; 5:15pm Masses GIFT SHOP (408) 980-9825 St. Vincent de Paul (800) 557-1961 BAPTISMS, MARRIAGES & FUNERALS: Please contact the Rectory Office for arrangements (For Marriages please contact the office before setting the date.) Our Lady of Peace Church & Shrine Mission Statement Our Lady of Peace is a church and shrine dedicated to the greater glory of God and the salvation of souls.
    [Show full text]
  • Florida Catholic
    WWW.THEFLORIDACATHOLIC.ORG | Dec. 21, 2012-Jan. 10, 2013 | Volume 74, Number 4 ORLANDO DIOCESE PALM BEACH DIOCESE VENICE DIOCESE A statue represents Mary in prayer at the new Sacred Heart Church. (STEVE ANTON | FC) St. James Cathedral School student Robert Duckworth shows his artwork of a Nativity scene to Bishop Lake Okeechobee John Noonan while his parents, Patricia and Brian Duckworth, look on. (MICHAEL HARKER | FC) parish dedicated A statue of Our Lady of Guadalupe is crowned during a Mass celebrated at Pioneer Park in Zolfo Springs Dec. Student’s artwork to the faith 9. (BOB REDDY | FC) recognized After eight years of remodeling and enlarging, Community and after a recession, setbacks and challenges, nationally Sacred Heart’s new, more modern and enlarged honors Our Lady church building was unveiled. Robert Duckworth thought he was going to “This church was a small church and it kept of Guadalupe the orthodontist Oct. 23. But instead his parents growing and growing,” said Tom Peer, a parish- brought him to Bishop John Noonan’s office ioner since 1975. “I walked in and was shocked to to be congratulated for winning a national art see how much bigger it is now.” Parishes throughout the Diocese of Venice cel- contest sponsored by the Pontifical Missionary “I want to congratulate all of you on this new ebrated the Feast of Our Lady of Guadalupe Dec. Society’s Holy Childhood Association. Robert’s church here in Okeechobee. This church of Sa- 12. The feast commemorates the story of when the depiction of the Nativity scene garnered him a cred Heart is such a wonderful faith-filled group Virgin Mary appeared to Indian peasant St.
    [Show full text]
  • Selected Works Selected Works Works Selected
    Celebrating Twenty-five Years in the Snite Museum of Art: 1980–2005 SELECTED WORKS SELECTED WORKS S Snite Museum of Art nite University of Notre Dame M useum of Art SELECTED WORKS SELECTED WORKS Celebrating Twenty-five Years in the Snite Museum of Art: 1980–2005 S nite M useum of Art Snite Museum of Art University of Notre Dame SELECTED WORKS Snite Museum of Art University of Notre Dame Published in commemoration of the 25th anniversary of the opening of the Snite Museum of Art building. Dedicated to Rev. Anthony J. Lauck, C.S.C., and Dean A. Porter Second Edition Copyright © 2005 University of Notre Dame ISBN 978-0-9753984-1-8 CONTENTS 5 Foreword 8 Benefactors 11 Authors 12 Pre-Columbian and Spanish Colonial Art 68 Native North American Art 86 African Art 100 Western Arts 264 Photography FOREWORD From its earliest years, the University of Notre Dame has understood the importance of the visual arts to the academy. In 1874 Notre Dame’s founder, Rev. Edward Sorin, C.S.C., brought Vatican artist Luigi Gregori to campus. For the next seventeen years, Gregori beautified the school’s interiors––painting scenes on the interior of the Golden Dome and the Columbus murals within the Main Building, as well as creating murals and the Stations of the Cross for the Basilica of the Sacred Heart. In 1875 the Bishops Gallery and the Museum of Indian Antiquities opened in the Main Building. The Bishops Gallery featured sixty portraits of bishops painted by Gregori. In 1899 Rev. Edward W. J.
    [Show full text]
  • Rallies Marking Abortion Anniversary Set for Days After Inauguration
    Rallies marking abortion anniversary set for days after inauguration WASHINGTON – Thousands of pro-life marchers are expected to rally in Washington Jan. 22 to commemorate the 36th anniversary of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade decision legalizing abortion, just days after President-elect Barack Obama is inaugurated. Abortion opponents also will hold multiple events in the nation’s capital and throughout the U.S. the day before and the day of the official 2009 March for Life, as well as the following days. The main event will begin with a noon rally on the National Mall, followed by a march along Constitution Avenue that will end at the U.S. Supreme Court. From there, participants are encouraged to meet with members of Congress to lobby on abortion-related issues. “The first session of the 111th Congress will convene in January, with all newly elected members of the House and many newly elected members of the Senate,” organizers of the march wrote on the official Web site, www.marchforlife.org. “We shall be a large group of Americans to bring our prayers and our important simple pro-life message to this new administration and new Congress.” With millions expected in Washington for inauguration events the week of Jan. 19 and the thousands of participants anticipated for the march and related activities, organizers said it will be a “crazy week” in the nation’s capital. The theme of this year’s march is “Remember – The Life Principles Mean ‘Equal Care’ With No Exceptions,” meaning the intentional killing of even one unborn human is never justified or necessary, the Web site said.
    [Show full text]
  • “Life of Washington” Mural the Importance Of
    GEORGE WASHINGTON HIGH SCHOOL “LIFE OF WASHINGTON” MURAL TECHNICAL SOLUTIONS, BUILDING CONSENSUS, RESOURCES (Submitted to SFUSD on 4.17.19, updated 7.16.19) Over the past year, San Francisco Heritage (Heritage) has been researching examples of comparable mural and public art controversies across the country and solutions prescribed for addressing objectionable and offensive imagery. Heritage commissioned the City Landmark nomination for George Washington High School, co-authored by Donna Graves and Christopher VerPlanck, which comprehensively documents the school’s public art and architecture, including Victor Arnautoff’s “Life of Washington” (1936) mural. Heritage is closely following the public process concerning the “Life of Washington” mural, having attended three of the four Reflection and Action Group meetings convened by the school district in early 2019. Regardless of Arnautoff’s original intent, we recognize the offensive nature of the mural’s depictions and their impact on students, especially students of color. Our goal in compiling this memo is to provide a range of technical options for consideration by district officials in order to facilitate a constructive and unifying solution. George Washington High School is the latest in a series of controversies surrounding depictions of Native Americans, African Americans, and other historical events locally and nationally – frequently involving New Deal-era artworks. Although each case must be considered in its own context, taking into account the intent of the artist and how the imagery is experienced by contemporary viewers, there have been a range of creative approaches to remedying inaccurate, offensive, and/or stereotypical content in public art. All of the cases profiled below combine multiple responses to address the controversial historical depictions, including screening, interpretation, education, and/or new artwork to provide a contemporary perspective.
    [Show full text]
  • Pro-Life Events Show Ongoing Opposition to Abortion
    Pro-life events show ongoing opposition to abortion WASHINGTON – Pro-life activities in California, Washington, Pennsylvania, Illinois and the District of Columbia, among other places, highlighted the continuing opposition in the United States to legalized abortion. San Francisco’s fourth annual Walk for Life West Coast Jan. 19 drew thousands of people. Among the participants were Bishop Tod D. Brown of Orange, Calif., who concelebrated a Mass with several other West Coast bishops at St. Mary of the Assumption Cathedral in San Francisco; Father Frank Pavone of Priests for Life; actor Eduardo Verastegui, star of the movie “Bella”; and Alveda King, niece of the late Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. On Jan. 20, more than 700 gathered in St. Joseph Cathedral in San Diego for a prayer and procession against abortion, led by San Diego Auxiliary Bishop Salvatore Cordileone. The procession stretched out for three city blocks. Thomas McKenna, president of Catholic Action for Faith and Family, which organized the event, called it a “procession of reparation” to decry the Jan. 22, 1973, Supreme Court decisions in Roe v. Wade and Doe v. Bolton that legalized abortion. The court’s Roe decision threw out most state restrictions on abortion, while the Doe decision permitted abortions through all nine months of pregnancy. In Washington state, the 30th annual March for Life drew thousands to Olympia, the state capital, Jan. 22. The march crowd was estimated to be larger than in past years, possibly because of the Jan. 12 death of Kathy McEntee, the march’s organizer. She suffered a stroke. McEntee’s daughter, Noreen, who succeeded her as president of Washington State March for Life, told the crowd, “She died far too soon, but we are here to carry on her cause.” Close to 200 gathered Jan.
    [Show full text]
  • Local and National Life-Affirming Activities
    ProLife News Briefs February 2017 Local and National Life-Affirming Activities Congress Likely to Re-Direct Funds At Your Parish: Variety of Ways to Congress will consider a budget bill that re-directs Support and Respect Life taxpayer money away from the abortion industry and instead # The Holy Heroes Spiritual Adoption Prayer to community health centers. These centers provide Adventure, a Catholic education program, helps kids better comprehensive health care for women but do not perform understand how babies grow and develop, and fosters a abortions or harvest fetal body parts for profit. culture of life in children without directly addressing Planned Parenthood (PP) requires its affiliates to abortion. [holyheroes.com] perform abortions and reported performing 324,000 Mary Mack helped to research and develop the content. abortions in 2014. The organization has been referred to The online program “focuses on the positive, that this is a the Department of Justice and FBI for potential criminal child, this is how you started, this is how a baby develops prosecution for trafficking fetal body parts from abortions. and grows,” she said. It includes puzzles, games and Community health centers (www.getyourcare.org) music and stories to listen to. Individuals can sign up, or it outnumber PP facilities 20-to-1 nationwide. They offer the can be used in parish children’s groups. The program lasts same preventative services as PP, but also offer services for nine months, and after the baby is “born”, participants PP doesn’t such as mammograms, prenatal care, and have a final quiz and are asked to continue praying for the treatment for diabetes, hypertension and arthritis.
    [Show full text]
  • Memorializing Knute Rockne at the University of Notre Dame: Collegiate Gothic Architecture and Institutional Identity Author(S): Sherry C
    Memorializing Knute Rockne at the University of Notre Dame: Collegiate Gothic Architecture and Institutional Identity Author(s): Sherry C. M. Lindquist Source: Winterthur Portfolio, Vol. 46, No. 1 (Spring 2012), pp. 1-24 Published by: The University of Chicago Press on behalf of the Henry Francis du Pont Winterthur Museum, Inc. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/665045 . Accessed: 05/11/2013 20:06 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. The University of Chicago Press and Henry Francis du Pont Winterthur Museum, Inc. are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Winterthur Portfolio. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 35.8.11.3 on Tue, 5 Nov 2013 20:06:57 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Memorializing Knute Rockne at the University of Notre Dame Collegiate Gothic Architecture and Institutional Identity Sherry C. M. Lindquist This article explores how the neo-Gothic building that was eventually built to commemorate Knute Rockne expresses a key moment in which the University of Notre Dame shaped its identity; it considers how the Knute Rockne Memorial Fieldhouse accordingly embodied and negotiated contradictory strains of manliness and civilization, populism and elitism, democracy and church authority.
    [Show full text]