Neogene Worlds, Life & Extinctions Norman MacLeod School of Earth Sciences & Engineering, Nanjing University Neogene Worlds, Life & Extinctions Objectives
Understand the structure of the Neogene world in terms of timescales, geo- graphy, environments, and organisms. Understand the structure of Neogene extinction events. Understand the major Neogene extinction drivers. Understand the degree to which these putative drivers correlate with Neogene extinction events. Neogene Worlds, Life & Extinctions Presentation Topics
Stratigraphy - chronostrati- graphy & geochronology Geography - tectonics & distribution Climate - circulation, temp- 0°0° erature, weather Biota - protists, inverte- brates, vertebrates, plants Evolution - evolutionary faunas, adaptive radiations, major innovations Significant Events - sea-level changes, volcanic eruptions, marine anoxia events, bolide impacts, extinctions Phanerozoic Phanerozoic System Durations
80
64
48
32 Duration(myr)
16
0
Sil. Jur. Ord. Dev. Cret. Camb. Perm. Trias. Neog. Quat. Carbon. Paleog. Data from ICS (2020) Cenozoic Epoch Durations
24
19.2
14.4
9.6 Duration(myr)
4.8
0 Paleocene Eocene Oligocene Miocene Pliocene
Data from ICS (2020) Neogene Neogene Timescale
System/ Numerical Period Series/Epoch Stage/Age Age (Ma) 2.580 Piacenzian Pliocene 3.600 Zanclean 5.333 Messinian 7.246 Tortonian 11.63 Serravillian Miocene 13.82
Neogene Langhian 15.97 Burdigalian 20.44 Aquitainian 23.03
ICS International Chronostrat. Chart 2020/03 Neogene
Tectonic Configuration
Establishment of modern tectonic plate configurations and establishment of modern atmospheric and marine circulation patterns.
Continents continue to drift toward their present positions. Land bridge between North America and South America forms during the Pliocene due to sea-level fall. Mountain ranges appear on almost all continents owing to tectonic collisions & subductions. Tectonic collision between Africa and Europe caused Mediterranean Sea to dry up in Messinian.
Map from Scotese PaleoMap Project (2001) Neogene
Tectonic Configuration
Establishment of modern tectonic plate configurations and establishment of modern atmospheric and marine circulation patterns.
Continents continue to drift toward their present positions. Land bridge between North America and South America forms during the Pliocene due to sea-level fall. Mountain ranges appear on almost all continents owing to tectonic collisions & subductions. Tectonic collision between Africa and Europe caused Mediterranean Sea to dry up in Messinian.
Map from Scotese PaleoMap Project (2001) Neogene Marine Circulation
Essentially a modern marine circulation pattern with variations in intensity conditioned on variations in sea level, the latitudinal thermal gradient and global temperature
Five permanent subtropical gyres. Northern gyres rotate clockwise, southern gyres rotate counterclockwise under Coriolis Effect. Boundary currents move water between the major ocean gyres. Vertical circulation controlled by deep-ocean conveyor which was first established in the Neogene.
Map from Scotese PaleoMap Project (2001) Neogene Marine Circulation
Essentially a modern marine circulation pattern with variations in intensity conditioned on variations in sea level, the latitudinal thermal gradient and global temperature
Five permanent subtropical gyres. Northern gyres rotate clockwise, southern gyres rotate counterclockwise under Coriolis Effect. Boundary currents move water between the major ocean gyres. Vertical circulation controlled by deep-ocean conveyor which was first established in the Neogene.
Map from Scotese PaleoMap Project (2001) Neogene Marine Circulation
Tillinger (2011), redrawn from. Broecker (1987) Neogene Marine Circulation
Tillinger (2011), redrawn from. Broecker (1987) Neogene Paleoenvironment
Atmospheric O Atmospheric CO 2 2 35 5000
28 4000
21 3000
14 2000
7 1000 PercentbyVol. Parts PerMillionParts 0 0 Cb. Od. Sl. Dv. Cr. Pm. Tr Jr Ct Pg Ng Cb. Od. Sl. Dv. Cr. Pm. Tr. Jr. Ct Pg Ng
Mean Surface Temperature Sea Level
25 250
20 200
15 150 Present 10 100 Meters Above Meters 5 50
Degrees Celsius Degrees Celsius 0 0 Cb. Od. Sl. Dv. Cb. Pm. Tr. Jr. Ct. Pg Ng Cb. Od. Sl. Dv. Cr. Pm. Tr. Jr. Ct. Pg Ng Neogene
Climate Zones
Comparative Criteria Neogene
O2 Content of 21,5 vo. % Atmosphere (108%)
CO2 Content of 280 ppm Atmosphere (x 1)
Mean Surface 14°C Temperature (0° C)
Sea Level +150 m to - 100 m
Climates remained relatively warm throughout the Early Miocene with a slow cooling trend that ended with two sharp drops in global temperature, one in the Middle Miocene (c. 14 mya) and the other in the Late Miocene (c. 8 mya).
Map from Scotese PaleoMap Project (2000) Neogene
Global Temperature Variation Neogene
Global Temperature Variation
Diagram from Hansen et al. (2012) Neogene
Global Temperature Variation
Diagram from Hansen et al. (2012) Neogene
Middle Miocene Vegetation Model
Diagram from Henrot et al. (2017) Neogene
Miocene Sea-Surface Temperature Model
Diagram from Tim Herbert Lab, Brown University (2021) Neogene
Pliocene Land-Surface Temperature Model
Diagram from Salzmann et al. (2008) Neogene
Pliocene Sea-Surface Temperature Model
Diagram from Fedorov et al. (2013) Neogene
Cambrian Evolutionary Fauna
Trilobite Graptolite
Monoplacophora Inarticulata Polychaete Neogene
Paleozoic Evolutionary Fauna
Articulata Crinoid
Tabulate Coral Bryozoan Ammonite Ruose Coral Neogene
Modern Evolutionary Fauna
Bivalve Gastropod Echinoid Bony Fish Neogene Reefs
Pliocene Reef
Widespread reef formation around throughout the Tethys, the proto-Gulf of Mexico, across southeast Asia and around Pacific islands. Quite a hemispherically asymmetrical latitudinal distribution with reefs extending to above 60° latitude, bit more reefs in northern hemisphere reflecting a latitudinally asymmetrical distribution of shallow marine habitats and sea-surface temperatures.
Map from Scotese PaleoMap Project (2000) Neogene
Fish
Ophiodon
Emola
Acanthurus
Hippocampus
Oncorhynchus Cretaceous Fish Neogene
Elasmobranchs
Carcharhinus Megalolamna
Carcharoides
Hemipristis Manta Cretaceous Elasmobranchs Neogene
Terrestrial Environment
Miocene Grassland Biome Neogene
Terrestrial Environment Global climates become more seasonal with a larger latitudinal thermal gradient with a continuation of the cooling and drying trend that began in the Eocene. Ice caps at both poles grow and thicken along with the Greenland ice cap and mountain glaciers worldwide. Alternating massive glacial-interglacial phases begin at the end of the interval.
Plants Arthropods (incl. insects) Amphibians Reptiles Birds Mammals
Plioene Terrestrial Scene Neogene
Trees
Quercus Northofagus Pinus (Oak) (Beech) (Pine)
Magnolia Metasequoia Ginko (Magnolia) (Metasequoia) (Ginko) Neogene
Terrestrial Arthropods
Tumidocarcinus Tityus Maevia (Crab) (Scorpion) (Spider)
Archaeogeryon Luthobiidid Chilopod (Crab) (Centipede) Cretaceous Terrestrial Arthropods Neogene Terrestrial Insects
Acanthognathus Luzomyia Anochetus (Ant) (Sand Fly) (Ant)
Undescribed Platypodid Coleopteran Hydrophiloid Coleopteran (True Bug) (Beetle) (Beetle) Cretaceous Terrestrial Insects Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Amphibians)
Rana (Frog)
Chelotriton (Salamander)
Bufonid Anuran (Toad) Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Amphibians)
Chart from Roelants et al. (2005) Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Reptiles)
Armandisaurus (Lizard)
Crocodylus (Crocodile)
Meiolania Colubrid Serpentes Rhamphosuchus (Tortoise) (Snake) (Crocodile) Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Reptiles) Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Birds)
Ostedornis (Seagull Relative) Pelagornis Titanis (Pelican/Stock Relative) (Terror Bird)
Struthio (Ostrich Relative)
Bathornis (Seriemas Relative) Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Birds) Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Mammals) Rhynchotherium
Pliohippus
Aepycamellus
Samotherium
Chalicotherium Neogene
Marine Quadrupeds (Mammals)
Balaenoptera
Livyatan Odobenocetops
Pontolis
Brygmophyster Neogene
Terrestrial Quadrupeds (Mammals)
Diagram from Novacek (2001) Neogene
Biodiversity
800
600
400
Modern Fauna
200 Paleozoic Fauna NumberFamiliesof
Cambrian Fauna 0 Cambrian Ordovician Sil. Devonian Carbon. Permian Tri. Jurassic Cretaceous Tertiary 500 400 300 200 100 0 Geological Time Data from Sepkoski (1981) Neogene
Extinctions End-Ordovician End-Devonian End-Permian End-Triassic End-Cretaceous 80 Palaeozoic Mesozoic Cenozoic Neogene 60
40 PercentExtinction 20
0 Cambrian Ord. Sil. Dev. Carb. Perm. Trias. Jurassic Cretaceous Paleoc. Neo. Paleozoic Mesozoic Cenozoic
Data from Sepkoski (1998) Neogene
Extinctions System/ Numerical Period Series/Epoch Stage/Age Age (Ma) 2.580 Great American Biotic Inter- Piacenzian Change (GABI) Pliocene 3.600 Zanclean 5.333 Messinian 7.246 Tortonian 11.63 Serravillian 13.82 Miocene Local mammal & benthic in- Neogene Langhian vertebrate extinctions 15.97 Mostly local terrestrial Burdigalian extinctions in Europe 20.44 (lizards, alligators, turtles) Aquitainian 23.03
0 10 20 % Extinction (Genera) Neogene
Miocene Extinctions
Victims Marine Plankton Foraminifera Marine Benthos Foraminifera Marine Nekton Elasmobranchs Terrestrial Ungulates Perissodactyls
Overall, quite low proportions of extinction. Neogene
Pliocene Extinctions
Victims Marine Benthos Bivalves (regional extinctions) Gastropods (regional extinctions
Overall, quite low proportions of extinction. Neogene
Messinian Salinity Crisis Neogene
Great American Biotic Interchange Neogene
Great American Biotic Interchange (GABI) 40 mya (Bartonian) - 2.7 mya (Piacenzian)
Caused by continent-continent tectonic collision. Resulted in extinctions in both North and South America owing to competitive exclusion. Resulted in physical and biological divergence of Atlantic and Pacific Ocean basins. Neogene
Sea-Level Changes System/ Numerical Period Series/Epoch Stage/Age Age (Ma) 2.580 Piacenzian Pliocene 3.600 Zanclean 5.333 Messinian 7.246 Tortonian 11.63 Serravillian Miocene 13.82 Neogene Langhian 15.97 Burdigalian 20.44 Aquitainian 23.03
0 10 20 % Extinction (Genera) Neogene
Ocean Anoxia Events System/ Numerical Period Series/Epoch Stage/Age Age (Ma) 2.580 Piacenzian Pliocene 3.600 Zanclean 5.333 Messinian 7.246 Tortonian 11.63 Serravillian Miocene 13.82 Neogene Langhian 15.97 Burdigalian 20.44 Aquitainian 23.03
0 10 20 % Extinction (Genera) Neogene
LIP Eruption Events System/ Numerical Period Series/Epoch Stage/Age Age (Ma) 2.580 Piacenzian Pliocene 3.600 Zanclean 5.333 Messinian 7.246 Tortonian 11.63 Serravillian Miocene 13.82 Neogene Langhian 15.97 Columbia River (2.1 Kkm2) Burdigalian 20.44 Aquitainian 23.03
0 10 20 % Extinction (Genera) Neogene
LIP Eruption Events
Columbia River Igneous Province Age: 17 - 14 mya (most intense interval) Extent: 2.1 Kkm2 Duration: 3 m.y. Location: Northwestern US
Though volcanism has characterized this region for the past 20 m.y., most geologists accept that this LIP was emplaced when the North American Plate moved over what is now called the Yellowstone Hotspot ( = mantle plume). However, this model does not explain the prominent bow or deflection in the plume’s track or the apparent necking that occurred when it migrated to the south. Landsat Photo from NASA, map from Stöffler et al. (2013) Neogene
Bolide Impact Events System/ Numerical Period Series/Epoch Stage/Age Age (Ma) Talemzane (1.8 km), 2.580 Aouellout (0.4 km) Piacenzian Pliocene 3.600 Roten Kamm (2.5 km), El’gygytgyn (18 km) Zanclean Kara-Kul (52 Kkm2), Colonia 5.333 (4 km), Bigach (8 km) Messinian 7.246 Tortonian 11.63 Serravillian Miocene 13.82 Neogene Langhian Ries (24 km), Steinham (3.8 15.97 km) Burdigalian 20.44 Aquitainian 23.03
0 10 20 % Extinction (Genera) Neogene
Bolide Impacts
Ries Impact Crater Age: 14.81 ± 0.0038 mya Diameter: 24 km Location: Bavaria Germany
Ries was one of the first impact craters to be recognized as such by the criteria developed by Eugene Shoemaker and Edward Chao (e.g., coesite, shocked minerals. It’s also one of the few rampant craters (= characterized by a fluid post- impact ejecta flow) known on Earth. The impactor is thought to have had a diameter of c. 1.5 km. Landsat Photo from NASA, map from Stöffler et al. (2013) Neogene
Bolide Impacts
Kara-Kul Impact Crater Age: 5 mya Diameter: 52 km Location: Tadjikistan
This crater is unusual in that its roughly circular aspect was first identified through the study of Landsat images taken from space. Some suspect that this impact may have played a role in Pliocene cooling of the planet and so might have been a factor that contributed to the initiation of the Pleistocene ice ages. Landsat Photo from NASA, map from Stöffler et al. (2013) Neogene
Extinctions: Synthesis (No Large Extinction Events)
Eustatic Sea-Level Regression
Reduced Increased CO2 Shelf Area Albedo Release
Increased Marine Increased Global Global Competition Climate Extremes Cooling Temp. Rise
Altered Terres- Altered Marine trial Habitats Habitats
Extinctions
Continental LIP Eruptions Bolide Impact
CO2 SO2 Shock Wave Thermal Flash Ballistic Ejecta Stratospheric Dust Release Release
Proximate Wildfires Global Increased Global Acid Rain Extinctions Darkness Albedo Temp. Rise
Global Cooling
Altered Terres- Productivity Altered Marine trial Habitats Collapse Habitats
Extinctions Neogene Worlds, Life & Extinctions Norman MacLeod School of Earth Sciences & Engineering, Nanjing University