Boredom and Interest on Facebook, Reddit, and 4Chan by Liam Mitchell

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Boredom and Interest on Facebook, Reddit, and 4Chan by Liam Mitchell A Phenomenological Study of Social Media: Boredom and Interest on Facebook, Reddit, and 4chan by Liam Mitchell BA, Thompson Rivers University, 2004 MA, York University, 2005 A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in the Department of Political Science Liam Mitchell, 2012 University of Victoria All rights reserved. This thesis may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without the permission of the author. ii Supervisory Committee A Phenomenological Study of Social Media: Boredom and Interest on Facebook, Reddit, and 4chan by Liam Mitchell BA, Thompson Rivers University, 2004 MA, York University, 2005 Supervisory Committee Dr. Arthur Kroker (Department of Political Science) Supervisor Dr. Bradley Bryan (Department of Political Science) Departmental Member Dr. Peyman Vahabzadeh (Department of Sociology) Outside Member iii Abstract Supervisory Committee Dr. Arthur Kroker (Department of Political Science) Supervisor Dr. Bradley Bryan (Department of Political Science) Departmental Member Dr. Peyman Vahabzadeh (Department of Sociology) Outside Member Optimists used to suggest that the anonymity of the internet allows people to interact without prejudices about race, sex, or age. Although some websites still foster anonymous communication, their popularity pales in comparison with sites like Facebook that foreground identifying characteristics. These social network sites claim to enrich their users’ lives by cultivating connections, but they sometimes have the opposite effect. Given the widespread and growing use of social media, my research poses the following questions: Does a particular form of (dis)engagement with the world flow from the reduction of the person to a profile? Does this (dis)engagement extend beyond social media, possibly into the way that we understand the world as such? What can we conclude about the broader theoretical framework in which an analysis of social media might be couched? I answer these questions through Martin Heidegger’s work, which provides the theoretical orientation for the dissertation as a whole. Noting that history informs the way that he understands ontology (Chapter One), I argue that the social changes that are accompanying the spread of the internet suggest modifications to his characterizations of boredom (Chapter Two) and technology (Chapter Three). I then turn to three emblematic social media sites – Facebook, which renders its users connected and identifiable (Chapter Four); Reddit, which gathers its users into a pseudonymous community of common interest (Chapter Five); and 4chan, which demands that its users engage in an anonymous fashion (Chapter Six) – and analyze them using the framework developed above while drawing from them to alter that framework further. I claim that although the patterns of use apparent on these sites differ, they all express different aspects of the mood that holds sway over the internet. Social media is both the cause of, and solution to, boredom, and it is shaping a generalized mood that is coming to seem ontological in its purchase. iv Table of Contents Supervisory Committee ...................................................................................................... ii Abstract..............................................................................................................................iii Table of Contents............................................................................................................... iv List of Figures.................................................................................................................... vi Acknowledgments............................................................................................................. vii Dedication........................................................................................................................viii Epigraph............................................................................................................................. ix Introduction: Causes of and Solutions to............................................................................ 1 Chapter One: A Virtual Boredom ..................................................................................... 10 1.1: Boredom................................................................................................................. 10 Etymology and Literature ......................................................................................... 11 The Rhetoric of Reflection ........................................................................................ 14 1.2: Ambiguities............................................................................................................ 21 The Essential Ambiguity of Philosophy .................................................................... 23 Ontological Historicity and the Clarity of Metaphysics ........................................... 29 The Ontotheological Character of the Lecture on Boredom .................................... 33 The Ambiguity of Attunement .................................................................................... 37 Chapter Two: Forms of Boredom..................................................................................... 44 2.1: The First Side of Passing the Time: Being Bored ................................................. 45 Driving Boredom Away ............................................................................................. 45 Staving Off Boredom (with an iPhone) ..................................................................... 49 Emptiness and Limbo ................................................................................................ 52 2.2: The Second Side of Passing the Time: Being Interested....................................... 57 Becoming Bored with a Dinner Party and with the Internet as a Whole ................. 60 The Possibility of Emptiness ..................................................................................... 66 The Temporality of Limbo ......................................................................................... 70 2.3: The Profound Boredom of Contemporary Dasein................................................. 80 2.4: Conclusion: A Virtual Boredom............................................................................ 92 Chapter Three: Technology/Ontology.............................................................................. 95 3.1: Questioning Technology........................................................................................ 97 Ancient and Modern Technology .............................................................................. 98 The Four Characterizations of Modern Technology .............................................. 102 Disposal; Boredom; Response ................................................................................ 108 3.2: Browsing Being ................................................................................................... 112 Ge-stell as All-Encompassing Imposition ............................................................... 112 Binary Logic ............................................................................................................ 117 Danger; Boredom; Response .................................................................................. 122 The Occultation and Recuperation of Poi ēsis......................................................... 128 3.3: Conclusion: The Ontological and Technological Aspects of Virtual Boredom .. 136 Chapter Four: A Life Lived on Automatic ..................................................................... 143 4.1: Social Missionaries.............................................................................................. 146 The Securities and Exchange Commission Filing Letter ........................................ 146 v Corporate Culture: Sean Parker ............................................................................ 149 Corporate Culture: Peter Thiel .............................................................................. 153 The Californian Ideology ........................................................................................ 156 4.2: The Instantaneous Archive .................................................................................. 164 News Feed ............................................................................................................... 164 Beacon and Connect ............................................................................................... 166 Timeline ................................................................................................................... 171 Archive Fever .......................................................................................................... 175 4.3: The Virtual Subject and the Digital Reserve ....................................................... 182 4.4: Conclusion: Augmenting Reality......................................................................... 186 Chapter 5: The Voice of the Internet .............................................................................. 192 5.1: Karma, Number, Speed........................................................................................ 193 5.2: Informational Cascades........................................................................................ 202 Marbles ..................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • A Renegade Solution to Extractive Economics
    Center for Humane Technology | Your Undivided Attention Podcast Episode 29: A Renegade Solution to Extractive Economics Kate Raworth: So, the problem begins right on day one. When I give talks about doughnut economics to groups of students or midlife executives, I'll often say, "What's the first diagram you remember learning in economics?" And it's the same the world over, supply and demand. Tristan Harris: That's Kate Raworth. She calls herself a renegade economist. A few years ago, she sat down and drew a new economics chart in the shape of a doughnut. Her chart includes the whole picture, not just of what we buy and sell, but the parts of our lives that mainstream economics often leaves out or oversimplifies. For example, here's how she looks at the story about Vietnamese farming communities. Kate Raworth: There are parts of rural Vietnam where they're famous for their rice paddy fields. And these households aren't particularly well off, and so somebody had an idea like, "Hey, let's have them come, and having home-stay tourists." You get to stay with a family, you get to be there. Great. And it did well, and it expands, and it expands. Tristan Harris: That's good, right? I mean, growth means everyone is better off. Kate Raworth: And now it's expanded to the point that those families are utterly dependent upon the income from the home-stay tourists, and actually they're not really doing the farming, so they're having to just try and maintain it so it still looks good.
    [Show full text]
  • Crisis Spurs Vast Change in Jobs Trump,Speaking in the White Faces a Reckoning
    P2JW090000-4-A00100-17FFFF5178F ADVERTISEMENT Breaking news:your old 401k could be costing you. Getthe scoop on page R14. **** MONDAY,MARCH 30,2020~VOL. CCLXXV NO.74 WSJ.com HHHH $4.00 Last week: DJIA 21636.78 À 2462.80 12.8% NASDAQ 7502.38 À 9.1% STOXX 600 310.90 À 6.1% 10-YR. TREASURY À 1 26/32 , yield 0.744% OIL $21.51 g $1.12 EURO $1.1139 YEN 107.94 In Central Park, a Field Hospital Is Built for Virus Patients Trump What’s News Extends Distance Business&Finance Rules to edical-supplies makers Mand distributors are raising redflagsabout what April 30 they sayisalack of govern- ment guidanceonwhereto send products, as hospitals As U.S. death toll passes competefor scarce gear amid 2,000, experts call for the coronavirus pandemic. A1 GES staying apart amid Washingtonisrelying on IMA the Fed, to an unprecedented need formoretesting degree in peacetime,topre- GETTY servebusinessbalancesheets SE/ President Trump said he was as Congressreloads the cen- extending the administration’s tral bank’sability to lend. A4 ANCE-PRES social-distancing guidelines Manyactivist investorsare FR through the end of April as the walking away from campaigns U.S. death toll from the new GENCE or settling with firms early as /A coronavirus surgedpast 2,000 some demands seem less over the weekend. pertinent in altered times. B1 ANCUR BET Thestock market’s unri- By Rebecca Ballhaus, valed swingsthis month have KENA Andrew Restuccia OPEN ARMS: The Samaritan’s Purse charity set up an emergency field hospital in Central Park on Sunday near Mount Sinai Hospital, ignited even more interest and Jennifer Calfas which it said would be used to care for coronavirus patients.
    [Show full text]
  • About-Asana.Pdf
    About Asana Asana is a leading work management platform that helps teams orchestrate their work, from daily tasks to strategic initiatives. Asana ​adds structure to unstructured work, creating clarity, transparency and accountability to everyone within an organization—individuals, team leads and executives—so they understand exactly who is doing what, by when. Our co-founders started Asana because they experienced firsthand the growing problem of work about work, or internal coordination. Instead of spending time on work that generated results, they were spending time in status meetings and long email threads trying to figure out who was doing what. They recognized this pain was universal to teams that need to coordinate their work effectively to achieve their objectives. As a result of that frustration, they were inspired to create Asana to solve this problem for the world’s teams. Leadership Team ​https://asana.com/leadership ● Dustin Moskovitz, Co-Founder and CEO ● Anna Binder, Head of People Operations ● Chris Farinacci, Head of Business ● Alex Hood, Head of Product ● Oliver Jay, Head of Sales & Customer Success ● Dave King, Head of Marketing ● Eleanor Lacey, General Counsel ● Prashant Pandey, Head of Engineering ● Tim Wan, Head of Finance Board of Directors ● Sydney Carey, CFO, Sumologic ● Matt Cohler, General Partner, Benchmark Capital ● Adam D’Angelo, CEO, Quora ● Dustin Moskovitz, CEO, Asana ● Lorrie Norrington, Operating Partner, Lead Edge Capital ● Anne Raimondi, Chief Customer Officer, Guru ● Justin Rosenstein, Board Member
    [Show full text]
  • The Technological Singularity and the Transhumanist Dream
    ETHICAL CHALLENGES The technological singularity and the transhumanist dream Miquel Casas Araya Peralta In 1997, an AI beat a human world chess champion for the first time in history (it was IBM’s Deep Blue playing Garry Kasparov). Fourteen years later, in 2011, IBM’s Watson beat two winners of Jeopardy! (Jeopardy is a general knowledge quiz that is very popular in the United States; it demands a good command of the language). In late 2017, DeepMind’s AlphaZero reached superhuman levels of play in three board games (chess, go and shogi) in just 24 hours of self-learning without any human intervention, i.e. it just played itself. Some of the people who have played against it say that the creativity of its moves make it seem more like an alien that a computer program. But despite all that, in 2019 nobody has yet designed anything that can go into a strange kitchen and fry an egg. Are our machines truly intelligent? Successes and failures of weak AI The fact is that today AI can solve ever more complex specific problems with a level of reliability and speed beyond our reach at an unbeatable cost, but it fails spectacularly in the face of any challenge for which it has not been programmed. On the other hand, human beings have become used to trivialising everything that can be solved by an algorithm and have learnt to value some basic human skills that we used to take for granted, like common sense, because they make us unique. Nevertheless, over the last decade, some influential voices have been warning that our skills PÀGINA 1 / 9 may not always be irreplaceable.
    [Show full text]
  • 1369 the Business Model That Ate the World (Facebook)
    #1369 The Business Model That Ate the World (Facebook) JAY TOMLINSON - HOST, BEST OF THE LEFT: Welcome to this episode of the award-winning Best of the Le7 podcast, in which we shall learn about the rising concern over Facebook as more and more nega>ve impacts of the site become evident to an ever-expanding group of concerned people. And more specifically, we show how it is the fundamental business model of Facebook that is at the heart of its problems. Also today: two major changes to the show are taking place, very coincidentally, both on today's episode. So stay tuned to learn all about that. Clips today are from Democracy Now!, On the Media, Your Undivided APen>on, The Social Dilemma, the Michael Brooks Show, and TedTalks. Early Facebook Investor We Need to Hold Big Tech Accountable For CreaNng “Toxic Digital Spills” - Democracy Now! - Air Date 10-27-19 AMY GOODMAN - HOST DEMOCRACY NOW: AOC tweeted, “Hypothe>cally, if you were, say, a member of Congress sing on the Financial Services CommiPee given 5 minutes to ques>on Mark Zuckerberg, what would you ask?” What would you advise these congressmembers ask Mark Zuckerberg, the man you knew very well, you invested in early on? ROGER MCNAMEE: So, I think the issue for all members of Congress, irrespec>ve of what commiPee they’re on, essen>ally dis>lls to the same thing, which is, “Mr. Zuckerberg, you’ve built one of the most successful businesses in American history, but at enormous cost.” To me, Facebook is like the oil companies of the '50s.
    [Show full text]
  • Seen from 2020'S Tumult
    ARAB TIMES, TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 2, 2021 NEWS/FEATURES 13 People & Places Media Hiaasen quits Miami Herald Search is on for new leaders in journalism NEW YORK, Feb 1, (AP): The “help wanted” list for top management jobs in journalism is suddenly get- ting very long. Searches for new leaders at brand names like The Washington Post, ABC News and the Los Angeles Times are coming at a time of rapid change in the news industry and increased attention paid to diversity in decision-making roles. The two latest openings came this week when Marty Baron, the executive editor who transformed the Post over the past eight years, and ABC News President James Goldston both said they will step down over the next two months. The Los Angeles Times is further along in its search for a successor to Executive Editor Norman Pearlstine. The Reuters news agency is looking to replace its editor-in-chief, Stephen Adler, who is retiring on April 1. HuffPost and Vox Media need leaders, too. Dean Baquet, executive edi- tor of The New York Times, is the subject of speculation, both because his job is the golden ring of journalism and he’s 64 years old. By tradition, the Jones Times’ top editor steps down before reaching 66. CNN chief Jeff Zucker, whose name was frequently invoked by former President Donald Trump during his administration’s battles with the media, is expected to announce soon whether or not he will move on. Both Baron and Goldston cited the end of an in- tense election cycle and its exhaustive pace of news as a natural time to turn the page.
    [Show full text]
  • Big Data and the Nature of Business Decisions
    Big Data and the Nature of Business Decisions April, 2013 Mark Madsen www.ThirdNature.net @markmadsen Our ideas about information and how it’s used are outdated. How We Think of Users The conventional design point is the passive consumer of information. Proof: methodology ▪ IT role is requirements, design, build, deploy, administer ▪ User role is receive data Self‐service is not like picking the right doughnut from a box. How We Think of Users How We Want Users to Think of Us Our design point is the passive consumer of information. Proof: methodology ▪ IT role is requirements, design, build, deploy, administer ▪ User role is run reports Self‐serve BI is not like picking the right doughnut from a box. How We Think of Users What Users Really Think Food supply chain: an analogy for data Multiple contexts of use, differing quality levels What do you I never said the mean, “only “E” in EDW meant doughnuts?” “everything”… It’s going to get a lot bigger E Not E! Everything is digital. It’s no longer just rows and columns, it’s bits. The sensor data revolution Sensor data doesn’t fit well with current methods of collection and storage, or with the technology to process and analyze it. Copyright Third Nature, Inc. Unstructured is really unmodeled. We turn text into data, but we don’t model it by hand. Sentiment, tone, opinion Words & counts, keywords, tags Topics, genres, relationships, Categories, Entities abstracts taxonomies people, places, things, events, IDs Copyright Third Nature, Inc. Three kinds of measurement data we collect The convenient data is transactional data.
    [Show full text]
  • Michael Krasny Has Interviewed a Wide Range of Major Political and Cultural Figures Including Edward Albee, Madeleine Albright
    Michael Krasny has interviewed a wide range of major political and cultural figures including Edward Albee, Madeleine Albright, Sherman Alexei, Robert Altman, Maya Angelou, Margaret Atwood, Ken Auletta, Paul Auster, Richard Avedon, Joan Baez, Alec Baldwin, Dave Barry, Harry Belafonte, Annette Bening, Wendell Berry, Claire Bloom, Andy Borowitz, T.S. Boyle, Ray Bradbury, Ben Bradlee, Bill Bradley, Stephen Breyer, Tom Brokaw, David Brooks, Patrick Buchanan, William F. Buckley Jr, Jimmy Carter, James Carville, Michael Chabon, Noam Chomsky, Hillary Rodham Clinton, Cesar Chavez, Bill Cosby, Sandra Cisneros, Billy Collins, Pat Conroy, Francis Ford Coppola, Jacques Cousteau, Michael Crichton, Francis Crick, Mario Cuomo, Tony Curtis, Marc Danner, Ted Danson, Don DeLillo, Gerard Depardieu, Junot Diaz, Leonardo DiCaprio, Joan Didion, Maureen Dowd. Jennifer Egan, Daniel Ellsberg, Rahm Emanuel, Nora Ephron, Susan Faludi, Diane Feinstein, Jane Fonda, Barney Frank, Jonathan Franzen, Lady Antonia Fraser, Thomas Friedman, Carlos Fuentes, John Kenneth Galbraith, Andy Garcia, Jerry Garcia, Robert Gates, Newt Gingrich, Allen Ginsberg, Malcolm Gladwell, Danny Glover, Jane Goodall, Stephen Greenblatt, Matt Groening, Sammy Hagar, Woody Harrelson, Robert Hass, Werner Herzog, Christopher Hitchens, Nick Hornby, Khaled Hosseini, Patricia Ireland, Kazuo Ishiguro, Molly Ivins, Jesse Jackson, PD James, Bill T. Jones, James Earl Jones, Ashley Judd, Pauline Kael, John Kerry, Tracy Kidder, Barbara Kingsolver, Alonzo King, Galway Kinnell, Ertha Kitt, Paul Krugman, Ray
    [Show full text]
  • One | What Is Ai?
    ONE | WHAT IS AI? Artificial intelligence (AI) is a difficult concept to grasp. As an illustra- tion, only 17 percent of 1,500 U.S. business leaders in 2017 said they were familiar with how AI would affect their companies.1 These executives understood there was considerable potential for revolutionizing business processes but were not clear how AI would be deployed within their own organizations or how it would alter their industries. Hollywood offers little help in improving people’s understanding of advanced technologies. Many movies conflate AI with malevolent robots or hyperintelligent beings such as the Terminator or the evil HAL in Arthur C. Clarke’s 2001: A Space Odyssey. In film depictions, superpow- ered entities inevitably gain humanlike intelligence, go rogue, and inflict tremendous harm on the human population. The ominous message in these cinematic renditions is that AI is dangerous because it will eventu- ally enslave humans.2 One of the difficulties in understanding AI is the lack of a uniform definition. People often intertwine many things in their conceptions and then imagine the worst possible outcomes. They assume advanced technol- ogies will have omniscient capabilities, destructive motivations, and lim- 1 West-Allen_Turning Point_ab_i-xx_1-277.indd 1 6/2/20 10:30 AM 2 TURNING POINT ited human oversight and will be impossible to control. For those reasons, it is important to clarify what we mean by artificial intelligence, provide understandable examples of how it is being used, and outline its major risks. AI ORIGINS Alan Turing generally is credited with conceptualizing the idea of AI in 1950, when he speculated about “thinking machines” that could reason at the level of a human being.
    [Show full text]
  • 5G Utility Pole Planner Using Google Street View and Mask R-CNN Yanyu Zhang, Osama Alshaykh
    5G Utility Pole Planner Using Google Street View and Mask R-CNN Yanyu Zhang, Osama Alshaykh Abstract—With the advances of fifth-generation (5G)[1] Static Street View and labeled by VGG Image cellular networks technology, many studies and work have been Annotator(VIA)[8]. Then training the dataset base carried out on how to build 5G networks for smart cities. In the previous research, street lighting poles and smart light poles are on Mask R-CNN structure with an efficient capable of being a 5G access point[2]. In order to determine the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2080 Super GPU. After position of the points, this paper discusses a new way to identify training, we got a train test error rate of 7.86% and poles based on Mask R-CNN[3], which extends Fast R-CNNs[4] by making it employ recursive Bayesian filtering and perform a test error rate of 32.03%. Then we downloaded all proposal propagation and reuse. The dataset contains 3,000 of the street view pictures in Boston from Google high-resolution images from google map. To make training Map and detect whether there are poles in these faster, we used a very efficient GPU implementation of the convolution operation. We achieved a train error rate of 7.86% pictures or not. After that, we marked poles as and a test error rate of 32.03%. At last, we used the immune points on the map, and use immune algorithm to algorithm[5][6] to set 5G poles in the smart cities. decide the best and least number of poles that will Keywords – 5G, Mask R-CNN, immune algorithm, google be built in Boston.
    [Show full text]
  • Kurzweil's Argument for the Success of AI
    Artificial Intelligence 170 (2006) 1227–1233 www.elsevier.com/locate/artint Book review Ray Kurzweil, The Singularity Is Near: When Humans Transcend Biology, Viking Adult, ISBN 0670033847, September 2005, 672 pages. Kurzweil’s argument for the success of AI Drew McDermott Yale University, Department of Computer Science, PO Box 208285, New Haven, CT, USA Available online 7 November 2006 “Positive feedback” is one of those phrases that sounds like it ought to mean something good, when it actually means something that is almost always bad: a runaway process whose output forces its inputs further in the direction they are already headed. A chain reaction in an atomic bomb is a classic example, where the production of neutrons is proportional to the number of atoms split, which is in turn proportional to the number of neutrons. Of course, a bomb is one of the few cases where the goal is to produce a runaway process. Even in this case, positive feedback has the property that it quickly destroys the conditions that made the positive feedback possible. This is a hallmark of the breed. Take any other example, such as the multiplication of rabbits, whose output—rabbits—is proportional to the number of rabbits. This simple model assumes that food is abundant; the exponentially increasing rabbit population soon violates that assumption. In Ray Kurzweil’s book, The Singularity is Near, it is argued that the evolution of humanity and technology is driven by a positive feedback, and that the resulting destruction of many of the truths we hold dear will result in a post-human world of wonders.
    [Show full text]
  • Ray Kurzweil Reader Pdf 6-20-03
    Acknowledgements The essays in this collection were published on KurzweilAI.net during 2001-2003, and have benefited from the devoted efforts of the KurzweilAI.net editorial team. Our team includes Amara D. Angelica, editor; Nanda Barker-Hook, editorial projects manager; Sarah Black, associate editor; Emily Brown, editorial assistant; and Celia Black-Brooks, graphics design manager and vice president of business development. Also providing technical and administrative support to KurzweilAI.net are Ken Linde, systems manager; Matt Bridges, lead software developer; Aaron Kleiner, chief operating and financial officer; Zoux, sound engineer and music consultant; Toshi Hoo, video engineering and videography consultant; Denise Scutellaro, accounting manager; Joan Walsh, accounting supervisor; Maria Ellis, accounting assistant; and Don Gonson, strategic advisor. —Ray Kurzweil, Editor-in-Chief TABLE OF CONTENTS LIVING FOREVER 1 Is immortality coming in your lifetime? Medical Advances, genetic engineering, cell and tissue engineering, rational drug design and other advances offer tantalizing promises. This section will look at the possibilities. Human Body Version 2.0 3 In the coming decades, a radical upgrading of our body's physical and mental systems, already underway, will use nanobots to augment and ultimately replace our organs. We already know how to prevent most degenerative disease through nutrition and supplementation; this will be a bridge to the emerging biotechnology revolution, which in turn will be a bridge to the nanotechnology revolution. By 2030, reverse-engineering of the human brain will have been completed and nonbiological intelligence will merge with our biological brains. Human Cloning is the Least Interesting Application of Cloning Technology 14 Cloning is an extremely important technology—not for cloning humans but for life extension: therapeutic cloning of one's own organs, creating new tissues to replace defective tissues or organs, or replacing one's organs and tissues with their "young" telomere-extended replacements without surgery.
    [Show full text]