Original article
Comparative evaluation of the efficacy and safety of two doses of terbinafine (500 and 1000 mg day)1) in the treatment of cutaneous or lymphocutaneous sporotrichosis
Vergleichende Bewertung der Wirksamkeit und Sicherheit zweier Terbinafin-Dosierungen (500 und 1000 mg/Tag) in der Therapie der kutanen und lymphokutanen Sporotrichose
S. W. Chapman,1 P. Pappas,2 C. Kauffmann,3 E. B. Smith,4 R. Dietze,5 N. Tiraboschi-Foss,6 A. Restrepo,7 A. B. Bustamante,8 C. Opper,2,9 S. Emady-Azar10 and R. Bakshi10 1University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson, MS, USA, 2University of Alabama, Birmingham, AL, USA, 3University of Michigan Medical School and Veteran Affairs Medical Centre, Ann Arbour, MI, USA, 4University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM, USA, 5Nu´cleo de Doenc¸as Infecciosas, Universidade Ferderal do Espirito Santo, Vitoria, Brazil, 6University of Sa˜o Paulo, Ribeira˜o Preto, Sa˜o Paulo, Brazil, 7National University of Columbia, Medellin, Columbia, 8Instituto de Medicina Tropical ‘Alexander von Humboldt’, Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia, Lima, Peru, 9Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation, East Hanover, NJ, USA and 10Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland
Summary The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety and efficacy of oral terbinafine (500 and 1000 mg day)1) in the treatment of cutaneous or lymphocutaneous sporotrichosis. A culture for Sporothrix schenckii was required for inclusion into this multicentre, randomized, double-blind, parallel-group study. Patients received either 250 mg b.i.d. or 500 mg b.i.d. oral terbinafine for up to a maximum of 24 weeks and were assessed up to 24 weeks post-treatment. The main efficacy outcome measure was cure, defined as no lesion and absence of adenopathy at the end of follow-up. Adverse events (AEs), laboratory tests, vital signs and ophthalmological examinations were also assessed. Sixty-three patients (14–85 years of age) were treated with 500 mg day)1 ) (n ¼ 28) or 1000 mg day 1 terbinafine (n ¼ 35). The majority of patients were cured after 12–24 weeks of treatment, and the response was dose-dependent throughout the study and at the end of follow-up. The cure rate was significantly higher in patients treated with 1000 mg day)1 terbinafine compared with those treated with ) 500 mg day 1 terbinafine (87% vs. 52%, respectively; P ¼ 0.004). There were no cases of relapse after 24 weeks of follow-up in the 1000 mg day)1 terbinafine group, compared with six relapses in the terbinafine 500 mg day)1 group. Terbinafine was well tolerated and the frequency of drug-related AEs was slightly higher in the 1000 mg treatment group. Both doses of terbinafine were well-tolerated and effective for the treatment of sporotrichosis. The 1000 mg day)1 terbinafine dose was more efficacious than 500 mg day)1 in the treatment of cutaneous or lymphocutaneous sporotrichosis.
Correspondence: Dr Rajesh Bakshi, Novartis Pharma, CH 4002, Basel, Switzerland. Tel.: +41-61-3243075. Fax: +41-61-3244984. E-mail: [email protected]
Accepted for publication 11 August 2003
62 2004 Blackwell Publishing Ltd • Mycoses, 47, 62–68 Efficacy of terbinafine in sporotrichosis
Zusammenfassung Ziel der Studie war die Sicherheit und Wirksamkeit der oralen Terbinafin-Therapie (500 und 1000 mg ⁄ Tag) in der Behandlung der kutanen und lymphokutanen Sporotrichose zu pru¨fen. In die Studie wurden 63 Patienten im Alter von 13 bis 85 Jahren aufgenommen, die entweder mit 500 mg ⁄ Tag (n = 28) oder 1000 mg Terbinafin ⁄ Tag (n = 35) behandelt wurden. Bei allen Patienten wurde Sporothrix schenkii durch Kultur nachgewiesen. Die Heilungsrate war signifikant ho¨her in der 1000 mg Gruppe, in der wa¨hrend 24 Wochen Nachkontrolle kein Ru¨ckfall beobachtet wurde. Im Gegensatz hierzu traten in der 500 mg Gruppe 6 Rezidive auf. Terbinafin wurde gut toleriert; die Ha¨ufigkeit der Nebenwirkungen war in der 1000 mg-Gruppe leicht erho¨ht. Beide Terbinafin-Dosierungen als gut vertra¨glich und wirksam. In der Behandlung der kutanen und lymphokutanen Sporotrichose war die 1000 mg- Terbinafin-Dosierung jedoch wirksamer als die 500 mg-Dosis.
Key words: Sporotrichosis, lymphocutaneous infection, antimycotic chemotherapy, terbinafine, efficacy.
Schlu¨ sselwo¨ rter: Sporotrichose, lymphokutane Infektion, antimykotische Chemotherapie, Terbinafin, Wirksamkeit.
superficial dermatophyte infections and onychomyco- Introduction sis.8,9 However, the therapeutic potential of terbinafine The dimorphic fungus, Sporothrix schenckii naturally may extend beyond its current uses. In vitro studies have exists saprophytically and has a worldwide distribution. suggested that terbinafine exhibits potent activity Sporotrichosis is caused by the traumatic implantation of against a broad spectrum of pathogenic fungi that are this fungus into the skin from contact with soil, plant involved in subcutaneous and systemic mycoses.10 The debris, thorns, sphagnum moss or timber.1,2 The infec- minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of terbinafine tion may remain confined to the inoculation site (fixed against S. schenckii is 0.11 lgml)1, indicating signifi- cutaneous), presenting as a small, painless, erythema- cant in vitro activity.11 tous papule that may ulcerate or become verrucous.3 Clinical studies and case reports have suggested that In many cases (70–80%) the infection spreads by terbinafine is safe and effective for the treatment of lymphatic drainage to form a series of nodules along the cutaneous and lymphocutaneous sporotrichosis.12–17 In lymphatic vessels (lymphocutaneous).3,4 Thus, secon- these studies, doses up to 500 mg daily for variable dary lesions develop proximally, yet these are often durations have been employed with good results. painless and may eventually drain and ulcerate.3,4 In However, the optimum regimen and treatment duration addition, sporotrichosis can disseminate and present for terbinafine in sporotrichosis has not been precisely with pulmonary or systemic involvement, but this is defined. rare, except in immunocompromized patients. The aim of this randomized, double-blind study was to In otherwise healthy people, the most common forms of compare the efficacy and safety of two doses of oral sporotrichosis are not usually life-threatening, but these terbinafine (500 and 1000 mg day)1) in the treatment conditions do not resolve spontaneously and treatment is of cutaneous or lymphocutaneous sporotrichosis. necessary. A saturated solution of potassium iodide (SSKI) has been used for treating sporotrichosis for approxi- Patients and methods mately 100 years, although its mechanism of action is unclear.5,6 SSKI is still recommended, but new agents A multicentre, randomized, double-blind, parallel- with more convenient dosing regimens and lower fre- group study was performed in patients with S. schenckii quencies of adverse events (AEs) are needed.7 The azole cutaneous or lymphocutaneous infection. Patients antifungals, especially itraconazole, have also proved were enrolled at three centres in the USA, two in effective in the treatment of lymphocutaneous sporotri- Brazil, one in Colombia and one in Peru. The study chosis.7 was conducted in accordance with the Helsinki dec- Terbinafine is a synthetic allylamine derivative laration (including amendments) and patients gave that has long-term effectiveness in the treatment of informed consent.