Examining the Relationship Between Computed Tomography and Neuropsychological Measures in Normal and Demented Elderly
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.47.12.1319 on 1 December 1984. Downloaded from Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 1984;47: 1319-1325 Examining the relationship between computed tomography and neuropsychological measures in normal and demented elderly PAUL J ESLINGER, HANNA DAMASIO, NEILL GRAFF-RADFORD, ANTONIO R DAMASIO From the Department of Neurology (Division of Behavioural Neurology) University of Iowa College of Medicine, Iowa City, IA, USA SUMMARY Correlational analysis of CT and neuropsychological measures in patients with demen- tia revealed more predictive relationships in degenerative and vascular subgroups that in a multi-aetiology group. Normal and dementia patients were then matched for age, sex and educa- tional background, and analysed together. The ventricular/brain ratios of the bodies of the lateral ventricles and of the third ventricle correlated most highly with neuropsychologic performance. a Canonical analysis revealed correlation coefficient of 0O725 between the sets of CT and neuro- guest. Protected by copyright. psychological measures, which increased to 0-78 when a degenerative subgroup only was con- sidered. Discriminant function analysis indicated that the combination of CT and neuropsycho- logical measures was more powerful in discriminating normals from dementia patients than CT or neuropsychological measures alone. The relationship between brain and behavioural vascular pathology. The commonly used linear changes in aging and dementia has been the subject measurement of CT features is less likely to reflect of much research and debate. Specifically, the rela- volumetric variation that area measurements. The tionship between changes in brain morphology, as absolute size of brain structures on CT is less likely reflected by computed tomography (CT), and to reflect intersubject differences than a ratio bet- changes in behaviour, as measured by clinical scales ween the area of brain structure and the area of the and neuropsychological tests, has been described as whole brain at the same level. Furthermore, there relatively weak for both normal elderly' 2 and for exists a general consensus that measures of cortical dementia patients.34 Nonetheless, several studies atrophy are unreliable, difficult to incorporate into a have suggested that some correlation exists, albeit ratio and less related to mental decline than ven- moderate between brain atrophy on CT and various tricular measures.4 5 8 10 12 behavioural measures.5-'2 Our contention is that, From a neuropsychological standpoint, the com- owing to a variety of methodological reasons, the mon usage of global clinical judgment, gross rating nature of the relationship has not been fully scales, or simple psychometric tests, may fail to pro- appreciated in previous studies. For instance, the vide important differential features of mental http://jnnp.bmj.com/ lack of correlation in a neuropathologically decline. A notable exception is the report of de heterogeneous dementia group may mask specific Leon et al8 describing patients with Alzheimeres dis- CT-behavioural correlations in more homogeneous ease. The authors employed a variety of standar- subgroups such as those with strictly degenerative or dised tests and found a number of significant corre- lations with CT measures. Address for reprint requests: Paul J Eslinger, PhD Department of In a previous study we have established methods of quantitative CT measurement,'3 utilising ratios of Neurology, University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, Iowa City, IA on September 28, 2021 by 52242. ventricular and whole brain areas which discrimi- nated between scans of older normals and dementia Received 23 March 1984 and in revised form 25 June 1984. patients. Also, we have established that multivariate analysis of objective neuropsychological tests asses- Accepted 25 June 1984 sing verbal and visual memory, word fluency, tem- 319 3* N J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.47.12.1319 on 1 December 1984. Downloaded from 1320 Eslinger, Damasio, Graff-Radford, Damasio Table 1 Characteristics ofdementia sample (Study 1) Two neurologists, blind to the clinical and behavioural profiles of the subjects, independently traced onto translu- sample size 64 cent paper, the following cerebral structures: (1) the third male:female 36:28 age range (yr) 60-88 ventricle at the level of the foramina of Monro; (2) the mean age (yr) 71-73 frontal horns at the level at which they were largest; (3) the (SD) (6 65) bodies of the lateral ventricles at the first level in which age distribution they were fully seen; and (4) the interhemispheric fissure at 60-69 yr 34% 70-79 yr 52% the same level as the bodies of the ventricles. At each level, 80-88 yr 14% the entire perimeter of the brain was also traced. The sur- educational range (yr) 5-20 faces circumscribed by those tracings were then retraced mean years of education 11-02 connected to a (SD) (3-14) with a magnetic digitiser pen, directly Aetiology degenerative disease 45% Hewlett-Packard graphics computer. By means of a vascular disease 24% specifically designed program, the area subtended by each other/mixed aetiologies* 31% tracing was determined, and a percent ratio between the *that is, head injuries, alcoholism, drug effects, metabolic and ventricular or interhemispheric fissure area and the corres- endocrine disease, alone and in combination. ponding brain area was calculated. The mean of the two neurologists' tracings served as the dependent measure. Neuropsychological tests poral orientation and visual perception, discrimi- The neuropsychological battery, administered by a nated between older normals and dementia neuropsychologist blinded to both CT and neurological patients.'4 Based on these methods of analysis, we evaluation, included the following tests: the nature of the relationship between 1 Temporal Orientation This test assesses the accuracy considered of identification of the year, month, day of month, day of CT measures and neuropsychological performance week and time of day according to the standardised a group of in two studies. The first examined large method of Benton." A perfect score is zero and increasing guest. Protected by copyright. patients with dementia. The second focused on scores represent increasing disorientation. matched groups of normal and demented elderly. 2 Digit span Administration and scoring of this immediate memory test was similar to the WAIS Digit STUDY 1 Span subtest except that the raw score represents the number of digit sequences correctly repeated (forwards Method and backwards) rather than the number of digits per se. This methods results in a more reliable estimate of perfor- Subjects mance.'9 The dementia sample consisted of 64 patients referred to 3 Digit sequence learning (" Digit supraspan") This test University Hospitals for neurological evaluation because of short-term auditory-verbal memory requires the subject of progressive mental decline. The principal complaints to learn an eight or nine digit sequence, depending upon included failing memory, poor judgment and inability to education level, over repeated trials. Testing is terminated live independently (see table 1 for sample characteristics). after 12 trials or two consecutive correct repetitions. We purposefully included various aetiologies of dementia, Administration and scoring followed the method of but simultaneously identified the major subgroups of Hamsher et al.20 degenerative disease and vascular disease. Patients who 4 Logical memory (Wechsler Memory Scale) Scores on could not satisfactorily complete comprehensive neurolog- this test of verbal recall represent the average number of ical and neuropsychological examinations because of items correctly recalled from two stories. Administration severe mental decline were excluded. The conditions of all and scoring followed the method of Wechsler.2' patients conformed to Roth's'5 definition of dementia, that 5 Associate learning (Wechsler Memory Scale). Scores is, a condition of progressive deterioration of intellectual on this test of learning 10 word pairs over three trials were and affective faculties in a state of intact consciousness, as obtained through the standard method of Wechsler.2' http://jnnp.bmj.com/ well as to DSM III criteria. Each patient had an extensive 6 Visual retention test Number correct and error scores evaluation, which included neurological examination, on this test of short-term visual memory for designs were comprehensive blood chemistry analyses (complete blood obtained through administration A (immediate reproduc- cell count, 6- and 12-factor automated chemical analysis, tion after 10 second exposure of each design) of Form C.22 ESR, VDRL, and determinations of serum vitamin B129 Though highly correlated, number correct and error scores folate, thyroxine, and thyroid-stimulating hormone levels), were treated separately in analysis. study of cerebrospinal fluid, computed tomography (CT), 7 Controlled oral word association (" Word and EEG in a standard 20-20 montage. Diagnoses were Fluency") This test requires the oral production of words based on the application of current clinical diagnostic beginning with a given letter of the alphabet over a one on September 28, 2021 by criteria'6 and of Hachinski's'' ischaemia scale. Aetiology of minute period. Three letters are successively presented, dementia is summarised in table 1. and scores represent the cumulative number of correct responses.23 CT analysis 8 Facial