DOCSLIB.ORG

Missing the Apocalypse in Preaching the Crusades

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Missing the Apocalypse in Preaching the Crusades Chapter 7 Missing the Apocalypse in Preaching the Crusades Charles W. Connell Among the reports of the speech of Pope Urban ii at Clermont in 1095 calling for the implementation of an armed pilgrimage to Jerusalem, that of Guibert of Nogent (c. 1055–1124) gave special attention to the need for Christian war- riors to establish Christian kings in the East in order to fulfill the prophecy that foretold their destruction as the Antichrist occupied the Holy Land.1 In Guibert’s account the prophecy indicates that: …it is clear that Antichrist is to do battle not with the Jews, not with the Gentiles, but, according to the etymology of his name, he will attack Christians … And according to the same prophet, he will first kill three kings of Egypt, Africa, and Ethiopia, without doubt for their Christian faith. This could not be done unless Christianity was established where now is paganism.2 As Penny Cole noted in her study of the preaching of the crusades, the various chroniclers of the First Crusade attempted to establish a broader context for 1 Guibert of Nogent, Gesta Dei per Francos, rhc. occ. 4:117–263, here 138H to 139C. For an over- view on the role of the Antichrist in Christian history, see Bernard McGinn, Antichrist: Two Thousand Years of the Human Fascination with Evil (New York, 2000). On the apocalyptic tra- dition in the Middle Ages, idem, Visions of the End: Apocalyptic Traditions in the Middle Ages (New York, 1998); Richard K. Emmerson and Bernard McGinn, eds., The Apocalypse in the Middle Ages (Ithaca, NY, 1992); Brett Edward Whalen, Dominion of God: Christendom and the Apocalypse in the Middle Ages (Cambridge, MA, 2009). For a collection of studies arguing for an intense apocalyptic interest around the year 1000, see Richard Landes, Andrew Gow, and David C. Van Meter, eds., The Apocalyptic Year 1000: Religious Expectations and Social Change, 950–1050 (Oxford, 2003). For an opposing point of view, see Sylvain Gouguenheim, Les fausses terreurs de l’an mil et la paix de Dieu: Attente de la fin des temps ou approfondissement de la foi? (Paris, 1999); Jean Flori, La guerre sainte: La formation de l’idée de croisade dans l’Occident chrétien (Paris, 2001), 62–63; and, Flori, La fin du monde au Moyen Age: terreur ou esperance? (Paris, 2008). 2 Guibert of Nogent, Gesta Dei per Francos, trans. August C. Krey, The First Crusade: The Ac- counts of Eyewitnesses and Participants (Princeton, NJ, 1921), 42–43. Guibert based his ac- count on the only apocalyptic text of the Old Testament in the Book of Daniel. The parallel with Daniel in the New Testament is the Book of Revelations (or Apocalypse) of John. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���9 | doi:�0.��63/9789004386�36_008 <UN> Missing the Apocalypse in Preaching the Crusades 187 Urban’s sermon and “undertook to endow it with the dignity and high-minded qualities appropriate to the movement it inspired.”3 But Guibert was the only one to place Urban’s words in the apocalyptic mode.4 Modern scholars are not in agreement as to the impact of eschatological prophecy on the crusades. Benjamin Kedar, in his study of the historiography of the massacre of the non-Christian inhabitants as the crusaders entered Jerusalem in 1099, pointed out that modern scholars have focused on trying to discern the “totality” of its impact. In so doing they have noted that Raymond of St Gilles, as he entered, is credited with the statement that the crusaders in Solomon’s Temple rode in blood “usque ad frenos equorum” which is based on Apocalypse 14:20, but not so directly quoted at the time by Raymond.5 In 2009 Robert Chazan was among the more recent to note the ongoing debate over various aspects of millenarian expectations of the era and their impact on the crusade.6 In 2004, Al Andrea mentioned the speech of Urban as reported by Guibert, but focused on the attention that Pope Innocent iii gave to the apoca- lypse in his calling of crusades to the Holy Land. After the failure of the Fourth Crusade to reach Jerusalem, Innocent referenced the Apocalypse of John in Quia maior as he called for the Fifth.7 Despite the absence of any actual direct recording of Urban’s speech calling for the First Crusade, Jay Rubenstein has suggested that Guibert believed that Urban would have mentioned the apoca- lypse and so reported his speech in that manner.8 Thus, since 1995, when Chris- toph Maier provided a brief overview of the various ways in which apocalyptic prophecies may have influenced crusade propaganda over time, uncertainty remains.9 3 Penny J. Cole, The Preaching of the Crusades to the Holy Land, 1095–1270 (Cambridge, MA 1991), 32. 4 Dana C. Munro, “The Speech of Urban ii at Clermont, 1095,” American Historical Review 11 (1906): 240–241, was the first modern crusade historian to point this out. More recently, Whalen, Dominion of God, 53, notes the reference to Daniel in Baudri of Dol’s account of the speech. 5 Benjamin Z. Kedar, “The Jerusalem Massacre of July 1099 in the Western Historiography of the Crusades,” Crusades 3 (2004): 65. 6 Robert Chazan, “‘Let Not a Remnant or a Residue Escape:’ Millenarian Enthusiasm in the First Crusade,” Speculum 84 (2009): 289–313. 7 Alfred J. Andrea, “Innocent iii, the Fourth Crusade, and the Coming Apocalypse,” The Medi- eval Crusade, ed. Susan J. Ridyard (Woodbridge, UK, 2004), 97–106. 8 Jay Rubenstein, “How, or How Much, to Reevaluate Peter the Hermit,” The Medieval Crusade, ed. Susan J. Ridyard (Woodbridge, UK, 2004), 53–71. 9 Christoph T. Maier, “Crusade and Rhetoric against the Muslim Colony of Lucera,” Journal of Medieval History 21 (1995): 343–385. <UN>.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • THE CRUSADES Toward the End of the 11Th Century
    THE MIDDLE AGES: THE CRUSADES Toward the end of the 11th century (1000’s A.D), the Catholic Church began to authorize military expeditions, or Crusades, to expel Muslim “infidels” from the Holy Land!!! Crusaders, who wore red crosses on their coats to advertise their status, believed that their service would guarantee the remission of their sins and ensure that they could ​ ​ spend all eternity in Heaven. (They also received more worldly rewards, such as papal protection of their property and forgiveness of some kinds of loan payments.) ‘Papal’ = Relating to The Catholic Pope (Catholic Pope Pictured Left <<<) The Crusades began in 1095, when Pope Urban summoned a Christian army to fight its way to Jerusalem, and continued on and off until the end of the 15th century (1400’s A.D). No one “won” the Crusades; in fact, many thousands of people from both sides lost their lives. They did make ordinary Catholics across Christendom feel like they had a common purpose, and they inspired waves of religious enthusiasm among people who might otherwise have felt alienated from the official Church. They also exposed Crusaders to Islamic literature, science and technology–exposure that would have a lasting effect on European intellectual life. GET THE INFIDELS (Non-Muslims)!!!! >>>> <<<“GET THE MUSLIMS!!!!” Muslims From The Middle East VS, European Christians WHAT WERE THE CRUSADES? By the end of the 11th century, Western Europe had emerged as a significant power in its own right, though it still lagged behind other Mediterranean civilizations, such as that of the Byzantine Empire (formerly the eastern half of the Roman Empire) and the Islamic Empire of ​ ​ ​ the Middle East and North Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • Charlemagne's Road, God's Threshing Floor
    HStud 32(2018)1, 1–26 DOI: 10.1556/044.2018.32.1.1 CHARLEMAGNE’S ROAD, GOD’S THRESHING FLOOR; COMPREHENDING THE ROLE OF HUNGARY IN THE FIRST CRUSADE JAMES PLUMTREE American University of Central Asia (AUCA)1 [email protected] The violence that occurred in the medieval Kingdom of Hungary at the start of the First Crusade in the medieval Kingdom of Hungary appears in several of the works produced in the outpouring of literature that followed the capture of Jerusalem. Ex- amination of these writings reveals ecclesiastic authors inserting exegesis, exempla, allusion, and aff abulation into their retellings. These inclusions countered criticism of those who fl ed, stressed communal Benedictine values, and crafted an under- standing of the events and the new Crusade movement. Study of these depictions of the chaotic events in the semi-Christianized territory on the periphery of the Latin West reveals the development in presentation and reception of the crusade. Keywords: First Crusade, Kingdom of Hungary, narrative history, Peter the Hermit, Rule of St. Benedict In their accounts of the First Crusade, monastic authors inserted theological ex- egesis into their retellings of the outbreak of violence in the medieval Kingdom of Hungary.2 The bloodshed in Hungary provided them with the opportunity to counter criticism from those who had fl ed and to craft an understanding of the events and the new Crusade movement for their audiences. Since scholarly fi ndings and answers are shaped by questions and aims, the textual constructions of Hungary have gone unnoticed. An aim for a chronol- ogy of the First Crusade meant these sources were mined for details.
    [Show full text]
  • Peter the Hermit and Ther First Crusade Vler 1990-5
    VICTORIA LODGE OF EDUCATION AND RESEARCH 650 Fisgard Street, Victoria, B.C. V8W 1R6 1990 - 5 Nov. 20/90 PETER THE HERMIT AND THER FIRST CRUSADE. by W.Bro. Frank P. Merritt, Chemainus Lodge No. 114, B.C.R. These were the best of times; these were the worst of times. This was a period in the history of Christendom in which the idealism and imagination of Mankind was exalted to the highest degree; this was the period in which the bestiality and cruelty of Mankind was very evident. This was the period of recorded history which is now referred to as the Crusades. In particular, this was the time of the First Crusade. To say the least, it is very difficult for us to deal with a period of time such as the Crusades. In all there were eight Crusades lasting just over 200 years. It must be observed that the First Crusade created the pace for the Crusades that followed. The stage of history was set by Charlemagne in 800 A.D. in his consolidated empire that encompassed most of what is now modern Europe. The empire of Charlemagne was dynamic only so long as there was a pattern of conquest and addition to the empire. At the end of the period of Charlemagne or as it is referred to as the Carolingian period the empire was threatened by invasions of Magyars, Saracens and Vikings. One of the interesting perspectives is that Charlemagne brought to his conquered lands the religion of Jesus. Christianity and the Muslin religion represented very dynamic forces that were in total opposition.
    [Show full text]
  • Peter the Hermit: Straddling the Boundaries of Lordship, Millennialism, and Heresy Stanley Perdios Iowa State University
    Iowa State University Capstones, Theses and Graduate Theses and Dissertations Dissertations 2012 peter the hermit: straddling the boundaries of lordship, millennialism, and heresy Stanley Perdios Iowa State University Follow this and additional works at: https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/etd Part of the European History Commons, and the Religion Commons Recommended Citation Perdios, Stanley, "peter the hermit: straddling the boundaries of lordship, millennialism, and heresy" (2012). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. 12431. https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/etd/12431 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Iowa State University Capstones, Theses and Dissertations at Iowa State University Digital Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Iowa State University Digital Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Peter the Hermit: Straddling the boundaries of lordship, millennialism, and heresy by Stelios Vasilis Perdios A thesis submitted to the graduate faculty in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS Major: History Program of Study Committee: Michael D. Bailey, Major Professor John W. Monroe Jana Byars Kevin Amidon Iowa State University Ames, Iowa 2012 Copyright © Stelios Vasilis Perdios, 2012. All Rights reserved. ii Table of Contents Chapter Page Chapter One: Introduction 1 Chapter Two: The Crisis of Secular Lordship 7 Chapter Three: The Crisis of Spiritual Lordship 35 Chapter Four: Lordship on the Eve of the Millennium 65 Chapter Five: Conclusion 95 Bibliography 99 1 Chapter One: Introduction When is a hermit not a hermit? When he is Peter the Hermit who led the Popular Crusade in the year 1096.
    [Show full text]
  • Women in the First Crusade and the Kingdom of Jerusalem
    Western Washington University Western CEDAR WWU Honors Program Senior Projects WWU Graduate and Undergraduate Scholarship Spring 2019 Women in the First Crusade and the Kingdom of Jerusalem Maria Carriere Western Washington University Follow this and additional works at: https://cedar.wwu.edu/wwu_honors Part of the Higher Education Commons, and the Medieval History Commons Recommended Citation Carriere, Maria, "Women in the First Crusade and the Kingdom of Jerusalem" (2019). WWU Honors Program Senior Projects. 120. https://cedar.wwu.edu/wwu_honors/120 This Project is brought to you for free and open access by the WWU Graduate and Undergraduate Scholarship at Western CEDAR. It has been accepted for inclusion in WWU Honors Program Senior Projects by an authorized administrator of Western CEDAR. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Women in the First Crusade and the Kingdom of Jerusalem Maria Carriere 2 Women’s participation in the crusades has been attributed mainly to ambiguity in Pope Urban II’s preaching and framing of the First Crusade as a kind of pilgrimage rather than a military excursion. A comparison between ranks of women during the People’s Crusade and the First Crusade has been lacking in the historiography of these crusade expeditions. By analyzing attitudes and perceptions toward women, we can connect women’s ability to participate in crusading to their economic status. A comparison between chroniclers and contemporaries’ attitudes toward and descriptions of women in the People’s and the First Crusades can provide insight into women’s economic status, religious affiliation, and actions and how these factors influenced the crusades themselves.
    [Show full text]
  • History of the Crusades. Episode 4. the Peasants' Crusade. Hello
    History of the Crusades. Episode 4. The Peasants' Crusade. Hello again. Last week we saw Pope Urban II call upon the “princes” or nobility of Europe to march to the Holy Lands and take Jerusalem in the name of Christianity. At the same time that Pope Urban was appealing to the aristocrats of Europe, there was another man traveling around France, calling for participants in a Crusade to the Holy Lands. His name was Peter the Hermit, and his target audience was not the nobility of Europe, but the people on the opposite end of the social scale, the peasants. Edward Gibbon, in “The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire”, reports that Peter the Hermit was from a good French family, and had received military training in the French county of Boulogne. After visiting the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem as a pilgrim, Peter had then renounced the sword and the world, dedicating his life to the sole purpose of driving the Muslim occupiers out of the Holy Lands. Except that may not have been the case. Peter certainly preached that he had been to Jerusalem, but in his impassioned speeches that were designed to whip up religious fervor, he made lots of claims which weren't exactly true, as we will see. So, what do we know about Peter the Hermit? He was a short, energetic, persuasive religious man with a knack for preaching to crowds. He was one of those quaint figures of the Middle Ages. He was short, skinny, unwashed and rode a donkey.
    [Show full text]
  • Riding the Horse, Writing the Cultural Myth
    RIDING THE HORSE, WRITING THE CULTURAL MYTH: THE EUROPEAN KNIGHT AND THE AMERICAN COWBOY AS EQUESTRIAN HEROES Metin Boşnak* and Cem Ceyhan* I Any comparative study of cultures will prove that virtually every culture has created its own hero according to its historico-cultural needs, characters, and potentials. In Mexico that hero is called “vaquero;” in Columbia and Venezuela, “illenora;” in Argentina, “gaucha;” in Japan and China, “samurai,” and “karate man” respectively; in Ottoman empire, “akıncı.” Similarly, both the European knight and the American cowboy had an important role in the emergence and development of their national heritage. There are many similarities and historical ties between the two in that they are idealized representatives of the cultures in which they emerged, and that they are equestrian. The popular images of the American cowboy and the European knight have been much misrepresented and distorted to fit the illusions of fiction. The medieval Latin word for “knight,” miles, does not help us sort out definitions much further. Originally signifying “soldier,” in the eleventh century miles became associated with notions of horsemanship and nobility in mysterious and complicated ways (Chickering and Seiler 3). The word eventually became interchangeable with Latin caballarius, its romance cognates, all of which etymologically refer to the idea of horsemanship. Mono-dimensional definition of the European knight, too, has so much been repeated and popularized that the sole perception of him today is the general conclusion that tends to determine him as the paragon of gentility, as was pictured in the Tudor age, when imitating the adventures of the knights of King Arthur was deemed very important by knights.1 Similarly, portrayal of the European knight as a gentle courtier Elizabethan period supplemented the false consciousness of this figure.2 The popular image of the knights is well-known.
    [Show full text]
  • Terror in the Old French Crusade Cycle: from Splendid Cavalry to Cannibalism
    Terror in the Old French Crusade Cycle: from Splendid Cavalry to Cannibalism Sarah-Grace Heller Synopsis Westerners, including former president George W. Bush, use the term “crusade” casually. However, the term evokes dark memories in Arabic traditions. This paper explores “terror” techniques such as cannibalism and catapulting of Muslim remains into besieged cities as recounted in the now-neglected cycle of Old French texts narrating the First Crusade, studying the narrator’s representation of the manipulation of fear in the context of extreme battle situations. Biography Sarah-Grace Heller is an associate professor of medieval French and associate director of the Center for Medieval and Renaissance Studies at the Ohio State University. She is the author of Fashion in Medieval France (2007) and articles on the Crusade Cycle, the Roman de la Rose , semiotics, and consumption. Essay It is worth examining memories of the crusading experience in discussions of terrorism in history as well as the current political situation. The main piece of propaganda that linked Osama Bin-Laden to the 9/11 attacks, the “World Islamic Front Statement urging Jihad Against Jews and Crusaders ,” evoked a Muslim memory of the crusades largely forgotten in the West. It conflates the modern Westerners present in Arab lands with the crusaders: The Arabian Peninsula has never -- since Allah made it flat, created its desert, and encircled it with seas -- been stormed by any forces like the crusader armies spreading in it like locusts, eating its riches and wiping out its plantations. All this is happening at a time in which nations are attacking Muslims like people fighting over a plate of food.
    [Show full text]
  • Twenty-First Century Antisemitism and Its Origins
    TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY ANTISEMITISM AND ITS ORIGINS SLLL-Senior Scholars February 4 – March 3, 2019 TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY ANTISEMITISM AND ITS ORIGINS Feb 4 – Greco-Roman Roots Feb 11 – The Theological Angle Feb 18 – Folk Superstition and Economics Feb 25 – From Religion to Race Mar 3 – White Nationalism and White Supremacy Synagoga and Ecclesia The Crusades Peter the Hermit and the “Peasant’s Crusade” Cluniac Reforms (c. 950–c.1130) Benedictine Abbey of Cluny in Burgundy spearheaded a series of revivalist reforms within Western monasticism focusing on reenergizing traditional monastic life through art and music. It also urged pilgrimages to the Holy Lands. One impetus was corruption within the Church, especially the control of monastic property by lay landowners. In contrast, Cluniac monasteries were to report directly to the pope rather than to a local lord. By the twelfth century the Congregation of Cluny included more than a thousand monasteries and was the largest religious movement in Europe. The First Crusade Preached In November 1095, Pope Urban II convened the Council of Clermont where ambassadors from the Byzantine emperor Alexius I Comnenus, were welcomed as they asked for help against the Muslims. First Crusade First Crusades and Local Jewish Communities First, unofficial, Crusade led by Peter the Hermit. Was a mob of religious zealots. Transversed Europe, piilaging and plundering as they went. Rhineland especially hard hit Jewish communities bedame targets. Some Jewish communities protected by local authorities Crusaders States ← County of Edessa Second Crusade (1145-1149) • Started in response to the fall of the County of Edessa the previous year.
    [Show full text]
  • The Crusades
    The Crusades There were a number of different Crusades from 1090s through the 1200s. The People's Crusade, led by ______________ the Hermit in 1096. The people who set out from France included _______________________________________. When they arrived in ______________________ the Emperor shipped across to Asia Minor. They found an empty castle and settled in. Turkish soldiers crept up and surrounded them. The leader of the peasant Crusaders offered to surrender, but asked to be spared. When the gates were opened the soldiers attacked. Very few crusaders survived. The First Crusade, 1096-1099, led by ___ nobles who led their armies by different routes to Constantinople. _________________ people set out, but only ____________ were knights. (The others were wives, children, cooks, blacksmiths, etc.) Once again, the emperor sent them across to Asia Minor (so they wouldn't __________________________) They had a terrible trip across to the Holy Land because ___________________________________________________________. Eventually they reached Jerusalem. They constructed siege towers and eventually attacked and entered the city. Many inhabitants were massacred. After that many crusaders went home. Those who stayed organized four feudal territories which were known as ______________________, the Kingdom beyond the Sea. Crusaders occupied this territory for nearly __________ years. The Second Crusade, 1147-49, led by the French King _________________, his wife _________________ of Aquitaine, and Conrad III of the Holy Roman Empire. ©Made by Liesl at homeschoolden.com They traveled in style with troubadours and wagons with clothes, furs, jewels, cookware, carpets, etc. The French and German armies attacked Damascus, but a storm of arrows from the city walls killed hundreds of French soldiers.
    [Show full text]
  • June 2019 Question Paper 52
    Cambridge Assessment International Education Cambridge Pre-U Certificate HISTORY (PRINCIPAL) 9769/52 Paper 5b Special Subject: The Crusades, 1095–1192 May/June 2019 2 hours *1574684771* Additional Materials: Answer Booklet/Paper READ THESE INSTRUCTIONS FIRST If you have been given an Answer Booklet, follow the instructions on the front cover of the Booklet. Write your centre number, candidate number and name on all the work you hand in. Write in dark blue or black pen. Do not use staples, paper clips, glue or correction fluid. DO NOT WRITE IN ANY BARCODES. Answer Question 1 in Section A. Answer one question from Section B. You are reminded of the need for analysis and critical evaluation in your answers to questions. You should also show, where appropriate, an awareness of links and comparisons between different countries and different periods. At the end of the examination, fasten all your work securely together. The number of marks is given in brackets [ ] at the end of each question or part question. This syllabus is regulated for use in England, Wales and Northern Ireland as a Cambridge International Level 3 Pre-U Certificate. This document consists of 4 printed pages. DC (LT) 162425/3 © UCLES 2019 [Turn over 2 Section A Nominated topic: The preaching of, and responses to the call for, the First Crusade 1 Study all the documents and answer the questions below. In evaluating and commenting upon the documents, it is essential to set them alongside, and to make use of, your own contextual knowledge. A An account of Urban II’s speech at Clermont in 1095, and the response of the crowd, written by a French monk who was present at the council and who participated in the First Crusade.
    [Show full text]
  • The Crusades
    The Religious Landscape The Crusades Islam Crusades were armed pilgrimages to Jerusalem, to free the holy Islam had spread through the once Christian Sepulchre of Jesus Christ and allow the pilgrims to go, without being strongholds of North Africa and into Spain. In killed or ransomed. 1053, the vast areas of North Africa had only 5 The First Crusade (1096-1099) remaining bishops. Pope Urban II held a great Council in France. At the end of the Europe session, the Pope called for help to assist the Christians in the East The Church was hampered by political interference and to recover the Holy Land from the infidel. The Pope offered the in the appointment of Popes and Bishops. This chance of a plenary indulgence to those who took up his call to rescue changed in 1057 when the Roman Emperor died Jerusalem. leaving his young son as heir, too young to assume The first to respond, galvanized by Peter the Hermit were the lower the responsibility of the role. In this power vacuum, classes. They crossed Europe but were massacred near Nicea. Six the church elected a new pope independently and months later, in 1097, knights from Germany and France, lead by a then set in motion laws to safeguard such cardinal and Godefroy de Bouillon, set off on what was to be the only independence in future. This was the first step in crusade that would free Jerusalem. This peace lasted 150 years, the Gregorian reform. Christianity could then Pilgrims were protected by the Christian Knights. flourish. A monastery was established at Cluny, Second Crusade (1147 - 1149) which had permission to elect their Abbots and run The second military expedition to the Holy Land was called for by the their affairs free from political interference.
    [Show full text]