DOCSLIB.ORG

Christian Mortalism

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Christian Mortalism chapter 5 Christian Mortalism De religione, non ratione, sed affectu iudicare . captivandam mentem in obsequium fidei. Sarpi, a letter to Isaac Casaubon, 22 June 1610 (One judges religion not with reason, but with affection . one has to delude the mind to obey belief.) Faith and Religion Due to the enthusiastic work of Renaissance humanists many classical authors enjoyed a revival in the course of the sixteenth century. Whereas Plato was accepted as a philosopher who acknowledged the immortality of the soul, Aristotle was far more problematic with his notion of eternal world and his alleged theory of the soul’s mortality. Pagan philosophers and poets such as Epicurus, Lucretius, Leucippus and Democritus were automatically rejected as impious and dangerous sources of heresy and atheism. During the Counter- Reformation period it became increasingly common to accuse dissidents of atheism, no matter how ill-justified such accusations truly were. In 1639 the Dutch Calvinist theologian Gisbertus Voetius (1589–1676) declared to his stu- dents that there were ‘practical’ and ‘speculative’ atheists, the first consisting of people who—like Epicureans, deists and libertines—considered religion useless; or practiced a wrong religion; or did not observe the rites and the ceremonies; or, like the Machiavellians and the politiques, did so merely on political grounds. ‘Speculative’ atheists in turn denied divine providence, downplayed the significance of the Bible, doubted natural light and the divine attributes, and rejected the idea of the resurrection of the body.1 Later in the seventeenth century writers like Gottleib Spitzel, Anton Rieser and Gabriel Wedderkopf traced the origins of atheism to the infamous writings of figures such as Giromalo Cardano, Jacques Vallée, Pierre Charron, François Rabelais, Lucilio Vanini, Robert Fludd and Tommaso Campanella, in the notorious De Tribus Impostoribus, and in many clandestine manuscripts in circulation. Furthermore, Voetius and other such writers rallied against open-mindedness, 1 Allen 1964, pp. 7–9. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���4 | doi ��.��63/9789004�6674�_�06 christian mortalism 127 the subordination of the church to the state, the diversity of sects, natural philosophers, and, finally, the satanic spreading of atheism. Voetius, the fore- runner of these anti-secular writers, observed that atheism was especially popular in “democracies”, which permitted “liberty of conscience”.2 Many of the aforesaid premises apply to Sarpi (he advocated the subordination of the church to the state, he was a natural philosopher, and he lived in an open-minded republic). Indeed, he was frequently prey to accusations of atheism, but I believe these allegations were based on political interests, not on facts. Historians have offered a variety of interpretations of Sarpi’s religiosity. According to Benedetto Croce, Sarpi’s political writings contributed to the birth of a new religious conscience. Furthermore, Croce claimed that the way in which Sarpi stressed the limits of man was fundamentally religious. I fully agree that Sarpi’s idea of the nature of man was Augustinian and shaped by his religious interpretation of man’s weakness and dependence on divine grace. Gaetano Cozzi and Boris Ulianich have seen Sarpi as a sympathizer of Calvinism in their early studies. However, they have later diverged from this opinion: Cozzi came to view Sarpi as a complicated and tormented reformer, while Ulianich has recently rejected the Calvinian interpretation of Sarpi’s views. In fact, Ulianich eschews ascribing to Sarpi any other religious position but that of a person who based his theology on the Scripture and especially on St. Paul. William Bouwsma’s Sarpi was a philo-protestant whose religious ideas were nevertheless “consistent with Catholic orthodoxy”, while Eric Cochrane described him as a typical representative of the Counter-Reformation period, in the sense that he was a deeply religious person. According to Manlio Busnelli Sarpi was undoubtedly a heterodox and apostate who was convinced of the utter corruption of Rome and who found religious truth in the Protestant doctrine. To Corrado Vivanti in turn Sarpi was a religious reformer who did not use religion as a political tool, but, instead, aspired towards an ecu- menical church. Here Vivanti seems to have followed Luigi Salvatorelli’s interpretation of Sarpi. Both Cozzi and Federico Chabod rejected any tinge of mysticism in Sarpi and Chabod noted that his religiosity was moral, sin- cere and profound. David Wootton, however, has quite strikingly suggested that Sarpi was an atheist, an argument subsequently accepted for example by A.P. Martinich, Richard Tuck, Paul A. Rahe—who goes as far as to claim that Sarpi was a “militant atheist”—and Gianluca Mori. Vittorio Frajese in turn sees Sarpi as a religious sceptic and a forerunner to Vico, Hegel, Feuerbach, 2 Allen 1964, pp. 11–12. Allen uses the word “democracies” without a reference to the original term..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Travels of a Darwin Groupie Miscellany
    Travels of a Darwin Groupie Miscellany Saddleback tortoise stud Diego at the Charles Darwin Land iguana on North Seymour Island Research Station, Santa Cruz Island Blue-footed booby on North Seymour Island Marine iguana at Punta Espinoza, Fernandina Island Sea lion pup awaiting its mom at Las Bachas, Santa Cruz León Dormido Colorful Place Names in Cambridge Recommended Reading Jesus Lane, Maids Causeway, Midsummer Common, Charles Darwin: Charles Darwin: Voyaging and Charles Darwin: The Power of Mud Lane, Parsonage Street, Drummer Street, Christ's Place by Janet Browne, Darwin and the Barnacle by Rebecca Stott, Darwin Lane, Lion Yard, Trinity Street, King's Parade, and the Science of Evolution by Patrick Tort (suitable for young readers) Trumpington Street, Magdalene Street, Christ's Pieces, Erasmus Darwin: Erasmus Darwin: A Life of Unequalled Achievement and Bridge of Sighs Erasmus Darwin and Evolution by Desmond King-Hele, Erasmus Darwin by Patricia Fara, The Lunar Men by Jenny Uglow A Colorful Reaction Other topics: 40 Years of Evolution by Peter and Rosemary Grant, The In response to Robert Chambers's anonymously authored Prometheans by Max Adams, Scenes from Deep Time by Martin Rudwick, Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, geologist Adam The Man Who Found the Missing Link by Pat Shipman, The Tragic Sense of Sedgwick wrote, "I cannot but think the work is from a Life by Robert Richards, Athanasius Kircher: The Last Man Who Knew woman's pen. [It] leaps to a conclusion, as if the Everything edited by Paula Findlen, Chrysalis by Kim Todd, The Devil's toilsome way up the hill of Truth were to be passed over Doctor by Philip Ball, The Seashell on the Mountaintop by Alan Cutler, with the light skip of an opera-dancer.
    [Show full text]
  • Remarks on Subversive Performance at the Trial of Giulio Cesare Vanini (1618-1619)
    ORE Open Research Exeter TITLE Remarks on subversive performance at the trial of Giulio Cesare Vanini (1618-1619) AUTHORS Horsley, A JOURNAL Modern Language Review DEPOSITED IN ORE 22 March 2018 This version available at http://hdl.handle.net/10871/32196 COPYRIGHT AND REUSE Open Research Exeter makes this work available in accordance with publisher policies. A NOTE ON VERSIONS The version presented here may differ from the published version. If citing, you are advised to consult the published version for pagination, volume/issue and date of publication 1 REMARKS ON SUBVERSIVE PERFORMANCE AT THE TRIAL OF GIULIO CESARE VANINI (1618-1619) AM version of Adam Horsley, ‘Remarks on subversive performance at the trial of Giulio Cesare Vanini (1618-1619)’, Modern Language Review, 110: 1 (2015), 85-103, in accordance with Modern Language Review open access policy on 22nd March 2018.The full published version of this article with correct pagination is accessible via http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5699/modelangrevi.110.1.0085 …on examine les paroles, on devine les pensées, on suppose des desseins. Si on parle, on prend pied sur des mots innocents, on donne un sens préfix à des paroles indifférentes. Si on se tait, on impute le silence à crime, estimant qu’on couvre quelque chose qui ne se dit point. Richelieu, Mémoires (1618)1 For if a Man have that Penetration of Judgment as he can discerne what Things are to be laid open, and what to be secretted, and what to be shewed at Halfe lights, and to whom, and when […] to him A Habit of Dissimulation is a Hinderance and a Poorenesse.
    [Show full text]
  • Race in Early Modern Philosophy
    Introduction I.1. Nature In 1782, in the journal of an obscure Dutch scientific society, we find a relation of the voyage of a European seafarer to the Gold Coast of Africa some decades earlier. In the town of Axim in present- day Ghana, we learn, at some point in the late 1750s, David Henri Gallandat met a man he describes as a “hermit” and a “soothsayer.” “His father and a sister were still alive,” Gallandat relates, “and lived a four- days’ journey inland. He had a brother who was a slave in the colony of Suriname.”1 So far, there is nothing exceptional in this relation: countless families were broken up by the slave trade in just this way. But we also learn that the hermit’s soothsaying practice was deeply informed by “philosophy.” Gal- landat is not using this term in a loose sense, either. The man he meets, we are told, “spoke various languages— Hebrew, Greek, Latin, French, High and Low German; he was very knowledgeable in astrology and as- tronomy, and a great philosopher.”2 In fact, this man, we learn, “had been sent to study at Halle and in Wittenberg, where in 1727 he was promoted to Doctor of Philosophy and Master of Liberal Arts.”3 On a certain understanding, there have been countless philosophers in Africa, whose status as such required no recognition by European institu- tions, no conferral of rank.4 On a narrower understanding, however, Anton Wilhelm Amo may rightly be held up as the first African philosopher in modern history. Gallandat tells us that after the death of Amo’s “master,” Duke August Wilhelm of Braunschweig- Wolfenbüttel, the philosopher- slave grew “melancholy,” and “decided to return to his home country.” 1 Verhandelingen uitgegeven door het Zeeuwsch Genootschap der Wetenschappen te Vlissingen, Negende Deel, Middelburg: Pieter Gillissen, 1782, 19– 20.
    [Show full text]
  • History of Free Thought in Reference to the Christian Religion by Adam Storey Farrar
    The Project Gutenberg EBook of History of Free Thought in Reference to The Christian Religion by Adam Storey Farrar This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at http://www.gutenberg.org/license Title: History of Free Thought in Reference to The Christian Religion Author: Adam Storey Farrar Release Date: November 19, 2009 [Ebook 30499] Language: English ***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK HISTORY OF FREE THOUGHT IN REFERENCE TO THE CHRISTIAN RELIGION*** History of Free Thought in Reference to The Christian Religion Eight Lectures Preached Before The University of Oxford, in the year M.DCCC.LXII., on the Foundation of the Late Rev. John Bampton, M.A., Canon of Salisbury. By Adam Storey Farrar, M.A. Michel Fellow of Queen's College, Oxford. New York: D. Appleton And Company, 443 & 445 Broadway. 1863 Contents Will of Rev. John Bampton. .2 Preface. .4 Analysis of the lectures. 34 Lecture I. On The Subject, Method, And Purpose Of The Course Of Lectures. 52 Lecture II. The Literary Opposition of Heathens Against Christianity in the Early Ages. 91 Lecture III. Free Thought During The Middle Ages, and At The Renaissance; Together With Its Rise in Modern Times. 129 Lecture IV. Deism in England Previous to A.D. 1760. 172 Lecture V. Infidelity in France in the Eighteenth Century, and Unbelief in England Subsequent to 1760. 221 Lecture VI.
    [Show full text]
  • Imagination Between Physick and Philosophy Koen Vermeir
    Imagination between Physick and Philosophy Koen Vermeir To cite this version: Koen Vermeir. Imagination between Physick and Philosophy: On the Central Role of the Imagination in the Work of Henry More (1614-1687). Intellectual History Review, Taylor & Francis (Routledge), 2008, 18, pp.119-137. 10.1080/17496970701819418. halshs-00641633 HAL Id: halshs-00641633 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00641633 Submitted on 16 Nov 2011 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. Vermeir, Koen. 2008. “Imagination between Physick and Philosophy. On the Central Role of the Imagination in the Work of Henry More (1614-1687).” Intellectual History Review 18: 119-137. IMAGINATION BETWEEN PHYSICK AND PHILOSOPHY On the central role of the imagination in the work of Henry More1 Koen Vermeir ‘Thus far, Madam, I have presum’d to be a physician’ Henry More to Anne Conway, April 4 1653 Abstract I argue that the imagination plays a central role in the thought of the Cambridge Platonist Henry More. First, physiological descriptions of melancholy and imagination were at the heart of his attack against enthusiasm and atheism. Second, in order to defend his metaphysical dualism, he had to respond to traditional accounts of the imagination as a mediating faculty between body and soul.
    [Show full text]
  • Scepticism, Atheism and Libertinism: a Study of the Polemic Between
    Scepticism, atheism and libertinism; a study of the polemic between François Garasse and François Oaier, 1623-25. by Andrew Duncan Erskine Thesis submitted for PhD examination University of London July 1996 Total number of words : 97,392 ProQuest Number: 10017480 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest. ProQuest 10017480 Published by ProQuest LLC(2016). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 11 ABSTRACT The Jesuit Garasse's Doctrine curieuse (1623), an attack on what he saw as the rise of atheism, has been quoted by many modern scholars, most notably Pintard in his Libertinage érudit (1943), as proof that libertinism existed in doctrinal form from the 1620s. This 'intellectual libertinism', as Pintard calls it, was allegedly practised by such influential thinkers as Gassendi, Naudé and La Mothe Le Vayer, and was the direct forerunner of later 17th- and 18th-century free thought. Pintard's case rests on the assumption that Garasse was right to condemn Charron's De la Sagesse (1601) as the work of a secret atheist. Ogier, on the other hand, read De la Sagesse as a secular work by a Christian sceptic and humanist who was unquestionably devout and true to his priestly calling.
    [Show full text]
  • Washington, DC 22–24 March 2012 Leonardo Da Vinci, Ginevra De’ Benci, Ca
    The Renaissance Society of America Annual Meeting Program and Abstract Book Washington, DC 22–24 March 2012 Leonardo da Vinci, Ginevra de’ Benci, ca. 1474/78. Alisa Mellon Bruce Fund. Image courtesy of the National Gallery of Art, Washington. Contents The indexes in this book refer to five-digit panel numbers, not page numbers. Panels on Thursday have panel numbers that begin with the number 1; panels on Friday begin with the number 2; and pan- els on Saturday begin with the number 3. The black tabs on each page of the full program are an additional navigational aid: they pro- vide the date and time of the panels. RSA Executive Board.......................................................................5 Acknowledgments.............................................................................6 Book Exhibition and Registration ...................................................10 Business Meetings...........................................................................11 Plenaries, Awards, and Special Events.............................................12 Program Summary Thursday.................................................................................16 Friday.....................................................................................25 Saturday..................................................................................32 Full program with abstracts Thursday 8:30–10:00.......................................................................41 10:15–11:45.....................................................................74
    [Show full text]
  • Mobility, Creativity, and Technological Development: David Hume, Immanuel Kant and the Economic Development of Europe
    Mobility, Creativity, and Technological Development: David Hume, Immanuel Kant and the Economic Development of Europe Joel Mokyr Departments of Economics and History Northwestern University Prepared for the session on “Creativity and the Economy”, German Association of Philosophy, Berlin, Sept. 18, 2005. Incomplete and Preliminary version, Oct. 2005. Joel Mokyr Creativity, Diversity, and Technological Development 1 Abstract Economic success requires the right environment for creativity to affect the economy. The European Enlightenment was the intellectual movement that helped trigger the technological and institutional changes necessary to bring about the economic growth of the West in the nineteenth century. The Enlightenment itself was made possible by the emergence of a comparatively free market in ideas in the late seventeenth century. One reason for that market to grow is the political fragmentation of Europe, which made it almost impossible for rulers and organized religion to suppress heterodox ideas. Another was that intellectuals catered to a constituency that was international. The main mechanism that made that possible was the capability of creative and original thinkers and scientists to move around on the continent, so that no single ruler could control them. A sample of creative people is assembled to measure this mobility and shows how this kind of mobility differed across countries and over time. Joel Mokyr Creativity, Diversity, and Technological Development 1 Introduction. There are many forms of human creativity. Not all of them produce economic growth, which is the concern of economic history. Art, literature, history, and philosophy may be the target of much creative efforts, yet it is hard to see how they add a large component to a nation’s wealth, nor are they meant to.
    [Show full text]
  • A Personal Perspective on Individual and Group: Comparative Cultural Observations with a Focus on Ibn Khaldun
    A personal perspective on individual and group: Comparative cultural observations with a focus on Ibn Khaldun GEORGE KATSIAFICAS Wentworth Institute of Technology, 550 Huntington Avenue, Boston, MA 02115, USA (Email, [email protected]) As the Islamic world declined in the 14th century, Ibn Khaldun wrote the Muqaddimah, a massive philosophical work in which he sought scientific grounds for a universal analysis of human beings. By seeking a global history of humanity, one that was not derived from the particular history of any one group, he was able to offer insight into the importance of group solidarity, assabiyeh. In this essay, I discuss the dynamics between autonomous individuality and group identity and offer some cultural comparisons to illustrate more general insights. [Katsiaficas G 2014 A personal perspective on individual and group: Comparative cultural observations with a focus on Ibn Khaldun. J. Biosci. 39 327–332] DOI 10.1007/s12038-013-9393-9 1. Introduction declaring freedom of the individual. In the 18th century, European and American revolutions won new freedoms In the contemporary world, groups have achieved prepon- and rights. Today, past accomplishments are systematically derant power over the lives of all of us, enmeshing us in eroded as governments claim for themselves new powers, webs of nation, race, and gender and stimulating an expand- including even the right to decide without due process mat- 2 ing range of investigations into collective behaviour. In our ters of life and death. Such vast historical changes compel historical epoch, scientists examine afresh individual ontog- us to consider the categories of individual and group viewed eny amid the role of groups.
    [Show full text]
  • From Influence to Inhabitation: the Transformation of Astrobiology in the Early Modern Period
    1 From Influence to Inhabitation: The Transformation of Astrobiology in the Early Modern Period James Edward Christie Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of PhD. The Warburg Institute, School of Advanced Study University of London January 2018 2 I declare that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Signed: James Edward Christie 3 Abstract: This dissertation presents a conjoined and comparative history of astrology and the debate about the existence of extraterrestrial (ET) life in the early modern period. These two histories are usually kept separate, largely because the same period represents a certain terminus ad quem for the former and the terminus a quo for latter. The sixteenth and seventeenth centuries saw the decline or marginalisation of astrology—the dismantling of the celestial causal chain of Aristotelian cosmology and the dismissal of any planetary or astral influence outside of light, heat and gravitation. They also saw the adoption, or re-adoption, of the cosmological view concerning the existence of a plurality of worlds in the universe (pluralism) and the possibility of ET life. Both these trends are considered as consequences of a Copernican cosmology and hallmarks of a modern worldview. The modern and in some sense artificial delineation between these two strands of historical enquiry (i.e. the history of astrology and the history of pluralism) may be detrimental, both to our understanding of celestial philosophy at any given time, as well as to our appreciation of cosmological change over longer periods. The most general and obvious similarity is that both these concepts meld astronomy and the life sciences.
    [Show full text]
  • The Market for Ideas and the Origins of Economic Growth in Eighteenth Century Europe
    The Market for Ideas and the Origins of Economic Growth in Eighteenth Century Europe Joel Mokyr Depts. of Economics and History Northwestern University Berglas School of Economics Tel Aviv University revised: Sept. 2006 I am grateful to Marianne Hinds and Michael Silver for loyal and competent research assistance. The comments of Avner Greif on an earlier version are much appreciated. 1 Two statements summarize much of the conventional wisdom about the historical experience of growth in the West: (1) Modern economic growth was ignited by the Industrial Revolution in the eighteenth century, and (2) the Industrial Revolution was, as everybody had always suspected, primarily about technology. Both statements must be qualified and nuanced: growth proper did not start until the second third of nineteenth century, and technology (to say nothing of “industry”) was not all there was to it. Yet when all is said and done, the place of technology in the economic miracle that occurred in Europe in the nineteenth century remains central. Technology, in its widest sense, is about new ideas and the growth of useful knowledge.1 Yet the economic impact of new technology, no matter how ingenious, can be realized only if the institutional environment is conducive and allows for the exploitation of inventions in an effective manner. In a simple economic model, it is hard to know whether conducive institutions “cause” technological change or the other way around. It is arguable that neither are truly exogenous, and instead both depend on the formation process of ideologies and beliefs that follows its own rules. Do ideas affect the outcomes of economic history? In a famous paragraph, John Maynard Keynes wrote that "the power of vested interests is vastly exaggerated compared with the gradual encroachment of ideas ...
    [Show full text]
  • Philosophical Aphorisms: Critical Encounters with Heidegger and Nietzsche
    Philosophical Aphorisms: Critical Encounters with Heidegger and Nietzsche By Daniel Fidel Ferrer ©2004 Daniel Fidel Ferrer. All rights reserved. No part of this hook may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission. No part of this book may be stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means including electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the prior permission in writing of the publisher or author. Some brief cataloging. Ferrer, Daniel Fidel (1952- ) Philosophical Aphorisms: Critical Encounters with Heidegger and Nietzsche / Daniel Fidel Ferrer. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Ontology. 2. Metaphysics. 3. Philosophy, German. I. Ferrer, Daniel Fidel, 1952-. II. Nietzsche, Friedrich Wilhelm, 1844-1900. III. Heidegger, Martin, 1889-1976. 2 Dedication and Acknowledgements To my larger family: José Ferrer, Juana Espinosa Fradera Ferrer, Efrain Ferrer, Ernesto Bartoleme Ferrer, Gustie Ruth Lindstrom Ferrer, Ernesto Bartoleme Ferrer, Jr., Joseph and Helen Longrich Ferrer, Alice Amanda Ferrer, Dolores Juanita Ferrer, Louise (Reavis) Ferrer, Shobha Ferrer, Vandana Dayal, Ashmita Rita Ferrer, Marguerita Ruth Ferrer, Ernesto Jo Ferrer, Laurie and Daniel Large, and Scott Young. To Dr. Gupta and family. To Timothy Bagley. To Richard Pulaski and Harvey Williams. To Dr. Alfred Denker. To Dr. Holger Zaborowski. To Samara Anarbaeva, working with the German and English text. To Central Michigan University Libraries and staff. This text was started in the summer of 1974. 3 Table of Contents Acknowledgements …………………………………………………………… 3 Prelude Preface Introduction ….………………………………………………. 5 An Experiment with the Philosophical Aphorism ……………………………. 13 Aphorisms Martin Heidegger and the new other beginning (Anfang)……....... 93 Aphorisms: recent and new developments …………………………………… 126 Aphorisms: Heidegger on Zarathustra.
    [Show full text]