The Merchant of Venice—New Edition Copyright © 2010 by Infobase Publishing Introduction © 2010 by Harold Bloom

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Merchant of Venice—New Edition Copyright © 2010 by Infobase Publishing Introduction © 2010 by Harold Bloom Bloom’s Modern Critical Interpretations Th e Adventures of Great Expectations One Flew over the Huckleberry Finn Th e Great Gatsby Cuckoo’s Nest Th e Age of Innocence Gulliver’s Travels One Hundred Years of Alice’s Adventures in Hamlet Solitude Wonderland Heart of Darkness Othello All Quiet on the Th e House on Mango Persuasion Western Front Street Portnoy’s Complaint Animal Farm I Know Why the Pride and Prejudice Th e Ballad of the Sad Caged Bird Sings Ragtime Café Th e Iliad Th e Red Badge of Beloved Invisible Man Courage Beowulf Jane Eyre Romeo and Juliet Black Boy Th e Joy Luck Club Th e Rubáiyát of Omar Th e Bluest Eye Julius Caesar Khayyám Th e Canterbury Tales Th e Jungle Th e Scarlet Letter Cat on a Hot Tin King Lear A Separate Peace Roof Long Day’s Journey Silas Marner Catch-22 Slaughterhouse-Five into Night Th e Catcher in the Song of Solomon Lord of the Flies Rye Th e Sound and the Th e Lord of the Rings Th e Chronicles of Fury Love in the Time of Narnia Th e Stranger Cholera Th e Color Purple A Streetcar Named Macbeth Crime and Desire Th e Man Without Punishment Sula Th e Crucible Qualities Th e Sun Also Rises Cry, the Beloved Th e Merchant of Th e Tale of Genji Country Venice A Tale of Two Cities Darkness at Noon Th e Metamorphosis “Th e Tell-Tale Heart” Death of a Salesman A Midsummer Night’s and Other Stories Th e Death of Artemio Dream Th eir Eyes Were Cruz Miss Lonelyhearts Watching God Th e Diary of Anne Moby-Dick Th ings Fall Apart Frank My Ántonia Th e Th ings They Don Quixote Native Son Carried Emerson’s Essays Night To Kill a Mockingbird Emma 1984 Ulysses Fahrenheit 451 Th e Odyssey Waiting for Godot A Farewell to Arms Oedipus Rex Th e Waste Land Frankenstein Th e Old Man and the Wuthering Heights Th e Glass Menagerie Sea Young Goodman Th e Grapes of Wrath On the Road Brown Bloom’s Modern Critical Interpretations William Shakespeare’s Th e Merchant of Venice New Edition Edited and with an introduction by Harold Bloom Sterling Professor of the Humanities Yale University Bloom’s Modern Critical Interpretations: The Merchant of Venice—New Edition Copyright © 2010 by Infobase Publishing Introduction © 2010 by Harold Bloom All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage or retrieval systems, without permission in writing from the publisher. For more information contact: Bloom’s Literary Criticism An imprint of Infobase Publishing 132 West 31st Street New York NY 10001 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data William Shakespeare’s The merchant of Venice / edited and with an introduction by Harold Bloom. — New ed. â p. cm. — (Bloom’s modern critical interpretations) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-60413-885-6 (hardcover) ISBN 978-1-4381-3435-2 (e-book) 1. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616. Merchant of Venice. 2. Shylock (Fictitious character) 3. Jews in literature. I. Bloom, Harold. PR2825.W56 2010 822.3'3—dc22 2010006132 Bloom’s Literary Criticism books are available at special discounts when purchased in bulk quantities for businesses, associations, institutions, or sales promotions. Please call our Special Sales Department in New York at (212)967-8800 or (800)322-8755. You can find Bloom’s Literary Criticism on the World Wide Web at http://www.chelseahouse.com Contributing editor: Pamela Loos Cover design by Takeshi Takahashi Composition by IBT Global, Troy NY Cover printed by IBT Global, Troy NY Book printed and bound by IBT Global, Troy NY Date printed: July 2010 Printed in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 This book is printed on acid-free paper. All links and Web addresses were checked and verified to be correct at the time of publication. Because of the dynamic nature of the Web, some addresses and links may have changed since publication and may no longer be valid. Contents Editor’s Note vii Introduction 1 Harold Bloom Marriage and Mercifixion in The Merchant of Venice: The Casket Scene Revisited 9 Harry Berger Jr. The Cuckoo’s Note: Male Friendship and Cuckoldry in The Merchant of Venice 19 Coppélia Kahn Portia’s Belmont 29 Richard A. Levin The Merchant of Venice 65 Robert Ornstein A Garden in Belmont: The Merchant of Venice, 5.1 97 Harry Levin Which Is the Merchant Here? And Which the Jew?: The Venice of Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice 117 Tony Tanner The Merchant of Venice 139 W. H. Auden vi Contents The Merchant of Venice and the Value of Money 151 Peter D. Holland Law and Self-Interest in The Merchant of Venice 173 Grace Tiffany Chronology 187 Contributors 189 Bibliography 191 Acknowledgments 195 Index 197 Editor’s Note My introduction dwells on Shylock’s conversion, a critique of Marlowe that costs the play dearly, destroying the plausibility of Shakespeare’s comic vil- lain as a character. Harry Berger Jr. revisits the casket scene in discerning Portia’s divine powers of mercifixion, after which Coppélia Kahn explores male friendship and betrayal in the play. Richard A. Levin traces how the misfortunes of Venice follow the char- acters to idyllic Belmont, the setting of Portia’s villa. Robert Ornstein locates the work’s climactic resolution in the fourth act, which clears the way for the delusions of the play’s ending. Harry Levin returns us to the concord of Belmont and the play’s final act, followed by Tony Tanner’s parsing of Portia’s telling question, upon enter- ing court, “Which is the merchant here? and which the Jew?” W. H. Auden suggests that a society built on speculative trade encour- ages frivolity and impulsiveness in the personal affairs of its citizens, after which Peter D. Holland also meditates on the ducat-mad world of the play. Grace Tiffany concludes the volume exploring the ways self-interest and the law intersect in The Merchant of Venice. vii HAROLD BLOOM Introduction Of Shakespeare’s displaced spirits, those enigmatic figures who some- times seem to have wandered into the wrong play, Shylock clearly remains the most problematical. We need always to keep reminding ourselves that he is a comic villain, partly derived from the grandest of Marlovian scoun- drels, Barabas, Jew of Malta. In some sense, that should place Shylock in the Machiavellian company of two villains of tragedy, Edmund and Iago, yet none of us wishes to see Shylock there. Edmund and Iago are apoca- lyptic humorists; self-purged of pathos, they frighten us because continu- ally they invent themselves while manipulating others. Shylock’s pathos is weirdly heroic; he was meant to frighten us, to be seen as a nightmare made into flesh and blood, while seeking the audience’s flesh and blood. It seems clear to me that if Shakespeare himself were to be resurrected, in order to direct a production of The Merchant of Venice on a contemporary stage in New York City, there would be a riot, quite without the assistance of the Jewish Defense League. The play is both a superb romantic comedy and a marvelously adequate version of a perfectly Christian, altogether murderous anti-Semitism, of a kind fused into Christianity by the Gospel of John in particular. In that latter assertion, or parts of it, I follow after the formidable E. E. Stoll, who observed that Shylock’s penalty was the heaviest to be discovered in all the pound-of-fl esh stories. As Stoll said, in none of them “does the money-lender suff er like Shylock—impoverishment, sentence of death, and an outrage done to his faith from which Jews were guarded even by decrees of German Emperors and Roman pontiff s.” Of all the enigmas presented by 1 2 Harold Bloom Th e Merchant of Venice, to me the most baffl ing is Shylock’s broken acceptance of forced conversion. Is it persuasive? Surely not, since Shakespeare’s Shylock, proud and fi erce Jew, scarcely would have preferred Christianity to death. Consistency of character in Shylock admittedly might have cost Shakespeare the comedy of his comedy; a Shylock put to death might have shadowed the ecstasy of Belmont in act 5. But so does the forced conversion, for us, though clearly not for Shakespeare and his contemporary audience. Th e diffi cult but crucial question becomes: Why did Shakespeare infl ict the cruelty of the false conversion, knowing he could not allow Shylock the tragic dignity of dying for his people’s faith? I fi nd it astonishing that this question has never been asked anywhere in the published criticism of Th e Merchant of Venice. No other Shakespearean character who has anything like Shylock’s representational force is handled so strangely by Shakespeare and ultimately so inadequately. Th at Shylock should agree to become a Christian is more absurd than would be the conversion of Coriolanus to the popular party or Cleopatra’s consent to become a vestal virgin at Rome. We sooner could see Falstaff as a monk than we can contem- plate Shylock as a Christian. Shakespeare notoriously possessed the powers both of preternatural irony and of imbuing a character with more vitality than a play’s context could sustain. I cannot better the judgment on Christian conversion that Launcelot Gobbo makes in his dialogue with the charmingly insuff erable Jessica, that Jewish Venetian princess: Jessica: I shall be sav’d by my husband, he hath made me a Christian! Launcelot: Truly, the more to blame he; we were Christians enow before, e’en as many as could well live one by another.
Recommended publications
  • Production History Organized by Season
    Great Lakes Theater: Production History Organized By Season Year Author Title Director Run Dates 1962-1965 *Lakewood Civic Auditorium *Great Lakes Shakespeare Festival Born *Artistic Director: Arthur Lithgow Rotating Repertory 1962 Shakespeare, William As You Like It Lithgow, Arthur July 11 - Sept 6 1962 Shakespeare, William Richard II Gruenewald, Tom July 28 - Sept 8 1962 Shakespeare, William Othello Lith + Grue, co-dir July 18 - Sept 7 1962 Shakespeare, William Henry IV, Part I Lithgow, Arthur Aug 11 - Sept 9 1962 Shakespeare, William Henry IV, Part II Lithgow, Arthur Aug 11 - Sept 9 1962 Shakespeare, William The Merchant of Venice Lithgow, Arthur Aug 22 - Sept 9 Rotating Repertory 1963 Shakespeare, William Comedy of Errors Lithgow, Arthur June 25 - Sept 13 1963 Shakespeare, William Romeo and Juliet Lithgow, Arthur July 2 - Sept 13 1963 Shakespeare, William The Merry Wives of Windsor Moffatt, Donald July 9 - Sept 13 1963 Shakespeare, William Henry V Lithgow, Arthur July 23 - Sept 13 1963 Shakespeare, William Julius Caesar Moffatt, Donald July 30 - Sept 13 1963 Shakespeare, William Measure for Measure (designer also directed) Lithgow, Arthur Aug 13 - Sept 13 Rotating Repertory 1964 Shakespeare, William The Taming of the Shrew Lithgow, Arthur June 30 - Sept 19 1964 Shakespeare, William Hamlet Lithgow, Arthur July 7 - Sept 19 1964 Shakespeare, William Much Ado About Nothing George, Hal July 14 - Sept 19 1964 Shakespeare, William Henry VI Siletti, Mario July 28 - Sept 19 1964 Shakespeare, William Richard III Earle, Edward August 4 - Sept 19 1964 Shakespeare, William Antony and Cleopatra George, Hal August 18 - Sept 19 Rotating Repertory 1965 Shakespeare, William Macbeth Lithgow, Arthur June 25 - Sept 25 1965 Sheridan, Richard Brinsley The Rivals Siletti, Mario June 29 - Sept 25 1965 Shakespeare, William A Midsummer Night's Dream Hooks, David July 13 - Sept 25 1965 Moliere + Chekhov, Anton The School for Wives + Marriage Proposal Linville, Larry/Lithg.
    [Show full text]
  • An Examination of the Travels and Texts of the Shakespearean Company
    AN EXAMINATION OF THE TRAVELS AND TEXTS OF THE SHAKESPEAREAN COMPANY i A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF ENGLISH AND THE GRADUATE COUNCIL OF THE KANSAS STATE TEACHERS COLLEGE OF EMPORIA IN PARTIAL FULFILlMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS BY DARYL E. TROYER July, 1965 Approved for the Major Department .~.~ Approved' for the Graduate Counoil ...­ ~;~~:~.J'} i·~/.~ S PREFACE Throughout the centuries since Shakespeare lived, soholars have delved into almost every conceivable aspect of his life and work, and the age which produced them. But, in spite of the vast amount of research that has been done, many important areas remain underdeveloped or subject to further investigation. One such field is the provincial travels of the company of actors with which Shakespeare was associated and the problems that these tours involved. Several works, including J. T. Murray's English Dramatic Companies, Sir E. K. Chambers's The Elizabethan Stage, A. Thaler's series of artioles on travelling players, and Glynne Wickham's Early English Stages, oontain valuable examinations of aspeots of provinoial dramatic activity and are basic to any examination of this SUbject. The need that exists is to collect the various view­ points on the travels and texts of the Shakespearean oompany. To achieve the goal of a oomprehensive look at the many con­ siderations of the travelling company is the aim of this study. For aid in making this project a reality, this writer wishes to express particular gratitude to two individuals: Dr. Charles E. Walton, through whose inspiration and advice the study took shape; and Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Happiness: Early Modernity and Shakespearean Comedy
    Happiness: Early Modernity and Shakespearean Comedy Kathleen French Faculty of Arts The University of Sydney A thesis submitted in fulfilment of requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Abstract This thesis investigates attitudes to happiness in the early modern period and literary representations of positive emotion. It is situated methodologically at the nexus of a number of interconnected approaches. Against a background of body studies and Freudian psychology, it engages with current research in the history of the emotions and work being done in the field of positive psychology. The insights provided by positive psychology into the power of positive emotions, such as optimism, resilience and emotional intelligence, open up a way to access the originality of Shakespeare’s understanding of the emotions and their power in people’s lives. An interdisciplinary approach provides a methodology that can incorporate analysis of imaginative and non-fiction texts with research into the historical, cultural, religious and political influences that shaped how people might have thought and felt about happiness. It considers the extent to which people could be happy in the context of religious beliefs that emphasised the fallen nature of man. As a result of increasing political absolutism and the failure of political theory to provide for societal or personal happiness, people engaged in a process of myth making. They imagined utopian societies, and they imposed their beliefs in the possibility of discovering a lost paradise on the new worlds they discovered in the Americas. More realistically, they accommodated themselves to the conditions of their lives by searching for happiness through forming meaningful personal relationships.
    [Show full text]
  • Renaissance Drama
    Renaissance Drama To Nell and Back: Revisiting Mistress Quickly --Manuscript Draft-- Manuscript Number: 2018010R2 Full Title: To Nell and Back: Revisiting Mistress Quickly Corresponding Author: Helen Ostovich, Ph.D. McMaster University Forensic Psychiatry Program Toronto, Ontario CANADA Order of Authors Secondary Information: Other Authors: Rosemary Gaby, PhD James Mardock, PhD Alice Leonard, PhD Abstract: Although the popularity of Shakespeare's Falstaff from 1597 to now receives frequent acknowledgement, his straight-woman, Mistress Quickly, has attracted relatively scant attention. She was popular enough, however, for Shakespeare to include her in four plays, within varied social contexts but with a consistently inconsistent voice. This collaboration reviews the role of Mistress Quickly across all four plays — 1&2 Henry IV,, Henry V and The Merry Wives of Windsor — drawing on our experience of editing the character electronically for Internet Shakespeare Editions. These papers report on the problems, choices, and insights that e-editing Mistress Quickly has exposed. Powered by Editorial Manager® and ProduXion Manager® from Aries Systems Corporation 1 To Nell and Back: Revisiting Mistress Quickly Although Sir John Falstaff has historically inspired an abundance of critical considerations commensurate with his girth, his straightwoman, Mistress Quickly, has received relatively scant attention. She was popular enough, however, for Shakespeare to include her in no fewer than four plays and, in fact, of all the characters invented for 1 Henry IV only Bardolph can equal this feat. Given Mistress Quickly’s ubiquity when her plays are considered together, an extended interrogation of the role seems well overdue. This project arose from conversations about editing the Mistress Quickly plays—1 and 2 Henry IV, Henry V and The Merry Wives of Windsor—for the Internet Shakespeare Editions (ISE).1 The facility of the hyperlink encourages editors of electronic texts to draw attention to echoes and connections across related plays.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fifty-Year History of Great Lakes Theater by Margaret Lynch
    The Fifty- Year History of GLT | Page | 1 The Fifty-Year History of Great Lakes Theater By Margaret Lynch Prologue Fifty years is a long time. Especially the fifty years that measure the distance from 1962 to 2012--from the Beatles to Lady Gaga, from the first transatlantic TV transmission to the iPad, from the Civil Rights Movement to Occupy Wall Street, from the Cold War to the War on Terror. So it’s not just fifty years that Great Lakes Theater marks this year, it’s fifty years against the backdrop of some of the most tumultuous, eventful and quickly changing decades on record. It’s noteworthy that Great Lakes Theater survived these fifty years, but the fact that it has also flourished is a cause for incredible pride and joyous celebration. There are few adults whose close involvement with the theater spanned the entire fifty years and in 2012 could still remember gathering at the Lakewood Civic Auditorium on the evening of July 11, 1962, to launch Great Lakes Shakespeare Festival. Audrey Watts, the theater’s longest serving trustee, was one who could recall fifty years later how the Lakewood High School cafeteria was festooned with banners that evening for a festive dinner catered by a popular Lakewood family restaurant. She could relive the anxiety when the air-conditioning broke down during the dinner but also the mounting excitement when congratulatory messages were read from First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy and former First Lady Mamie Eisenhower and the lights dimmed for Shakespeare’s As You Like It. Much has changed since that long-ago July evening.
    [Show full text]
  • Revisiting Mistress Quickly
    To Nell and Back: Revisiting Mistress Quickly Gaby, R., Leonard, A., Mardock, J. & Ostovich, H. Author post-print (accepted) deposited by Coventry University’s Repository Original citation & hyperlink: Gaby, R, Leonard, A, Mardock, J & Ostovich, H 2019, 'To Nell and Back: Revisiting Mistress Quickly', Renaissance Drama, vol. 42, no. 2. https://dx.doi.org/10.1086/705891 DOI 10.1086/705891 ISSN 0486-3739 ESSN 0486-3739 Publisher: University of Chicago Press © 2019 by Northwestern University Copyright © and Moral Rights are retained by the author(s) and/ or other copyright owners. A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge. This item cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the copyright holder(s). The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. This document is the author’s post-print version, incorporating any revisions agreed during the peer-review process. Some differences between the published version and this version may remain and you are advised to consult the published version if you wish to cite from it. 1 To Nell and Back: Revisiting Mistress Quickly Although Sir John Falstaff has historically inspired an abundance of critical considerations commensurate with his girth, his straightwoman, Mistress Quickly, has received relatively scant attention. She was popular enough, however, for Shakespeare to include her in no fewer than four plays and, in fact, of all the characters invented for 1 Henry IV only Bardolph can equal this feat.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 the Wild West Meets the Wives of Windsor Shakespeare and Music in the Mythological American West
    1 The Wild West meets the wives of Windsor Shakespeare and music in the mythological American West Kendra Preston Leonard Theatre historians have long recounted the ways in which Shakespeare’s works were carried to and performed in American frontier towns: they were put on in saloons and in beautiful little opera houses, in crowded mining camps and mili- tary outposts, in hotels and brothels striving for elegance. As Jennifer Lee Carrell has written, ‘In the frontier West, the fact that Shakespeare tells good stories, and that those stories should be told well in the West, was no surprise at all – at least not to Westerners’ ( Carrell 1998 , 107). But what Carrell states can be read in multiple ways: in addition to being told well in the West, Shakespeare is also told well in the West . Shakespeare’s legacy in the West is strong, demonstrated by the numerous Shakespeare festivals and companies spread throughout the region. Many recent productions that have adopted approaches to their adaptations that draw on this legacy and history, locating the action of the plays in a fi ctional Wild or Old West. Indeed, the stories of the American West and those of Shakespeare are often concerned with the same matters: self-determination, independence, the role of women in a male-dominated society, the pursuit of wealth and power, class issues, gender roles, and violence. The Taming of the Shrew , The Comedy of Errors , The Merry Wives of Windsor , Measure for Measure , Hamlet , King Lear , Othello , Much Ado About Nothing , Two Gentlemen of Verona , Romeo and Juliet , The Merchant of Venice , As You Like It , Cymbeline , and the Henriad have all been staged with settings in the nineteenth-century American West.
    [Show full text]
  • Lone Star Love Or the Merry Wives of Windsor, Texas
    Redux Working Draft February 12, 2013 STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION WITHOUT PERMISSION OF JOHN L. HABER AND JACK HERRICK LONE STAR LOVE or, The Merry Wives of Windsor, Texas An American Musical SHAKESPEARE ON THE RANGE In the wake of The War Between the States, cattle became king in Texas — with a population ratio of 9 cows to every human. Within three years, the annual total grew from 35,000 to 350,000 head of cattle that were driven on foot to Colorado, Wyoming, and Kansas, beside the thousands that were shipped by steamer to New Orleans and other points south and east. This boom time attracted a lot of carpetbaggers, scoundrels and social misfits to the Lone Star State. Among them were “Big John” Falstaff and his Musical Band of Rebels. FURTHER HISTORICAL BACKGROUND Texas became the twenty-eighth state in 1845. By 1860, it was ninth in the nation in per capita wealth, due largely to livestock and farming interests. There emerged an affluent and aspiring middle class from peasant roots, not unlike the bourgeoisie of Shakespeare's Windsor, England. In 1861, Texas seceded from the Union and joined the Confederacy. Though the state was never the scene of significant military operations during the Civil War, it did contribute 50,000 men and extensive supplies to the Confederate cause. The Reconstruction era presented significant problems of law enforcement in Texas, with the influx of carpetbaggers, ex-Confederates and other opportunistic outsiders. From its earliest days, Texas had attracted more than its share of outcasts and criminals. In the rebuilding of a war-damaged economy, land and cattle were the state's greatest assets.
    [Show full text]