New Zealand Fish Passage Guidelines for Structures up to 4 Metres Acknowledgements
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
New Zealand Fish Passage Guidelines For structures up to 4 metres Acknowledgements The development of these guidelines was funded by contributions from the Ministry for Business, Innovation and Employment (contracts C01X1002, C01X1524 and C01X1615), the Department of Conservation, Environment Canterbury, Fish and Game New Zealand, Greater Wellington Regional Council, Horizons Regional Council, Otago Regional Council, Northland Regional Council, Tasman District Council and Waikato Regional Council. We would like to thank the members of the New Zealand Fish Passage Advisory Group: David Boothway (Christchurch City Council), Alice Bradley (Ministry for the Environment), Matt Dale (Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu, Bruno David (Waikato Regional Council), Kati Doehring (Cawthron Institute), Christopher Fern (Trustpower), Michael Greer (Greater Wellington Regional Council), Kelly Hughes (ATS Environmental), Trevor James (Tasman District Council), Megan Kennedy (NZ Transport Agency), Patrick Lees (Pattle Delamore Partners Ltd), Bryn Quilter (Tonkin & Taylor), Melissa Shearer (Environment Canterbury), Tom Stephens (DairyNZ) and Mark Webb (Fish & Game NZ) for their contributions to these guidelines. We would also like to thank Don Jellyman, Bryn Quilter, Laddie Kuta, and the members of the New Zealand Fish Passage Advisory Group for their contributions to reviewing this document. Our Funders: Prepared by: Paul Franklin Eleanor Gee Cindy Baker Sjaan Bowie (Department of Conservation) For any information regarding this report please contact: Dr Paul Franklin Scientist Freshwater Ecology +64-7-859 1882 [email protected] National Institute of Water & Atmospheric Research Ltd PO Box 11115 Hamilton 3251 Phone +64 7 856 7026 NIWA CLIENT REPORT No: 2018019HN Report Date: April 2018 NIWA Project: END17201 Report Version No: 1.0 Quality Assurance Statement Reviewed by: Don Jellyman Formatting checked by: Alison Bartley Approved for release by: David Roper Contents Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................. 2 Executive summary ........................................................................................................... 10 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 16 1.1 Purpose of the guidelines and intended audience ................................................. 16 1.2 Scope of the guidelines ........................................................................................... 17 2 Why should fish passage be considered? .................................................................. 19 2.1 Freshwater fish and fisheries values ....................................................................... 19 2.2 Potential adverse effects of instream structures ................................................... 19 2.3 Characteristics of instream structures that impede fish movements .................... 20 2.4 Legislative requirements......................................................................................... 23 3 Planning and design considerations for fish passage at instream structures ............... 25 3.1 Background ............................................................................................................. 25 3.2 Design process ........................................................................................................ 25 3.3 Defining objectives and performance standards .................................................... 27 3.4 Principles of good fish passage design.................................................................... 29 3.5 Planning for instream works ................................................................................... 31 3.6 Monitoring and maintenance ................................................................................. 31 4 Design requirements for new instream structures .................................................... 34 4.1 What type of structure is best for fish passage? .................................................... 35 4.2 Culverts ................................................................................................................... 38 4.3 Weirs ....................................................................................................................... 60 4.4 Fords ....................................................................................................................... 66 4.5 Tide and flood gates ............................................................................................... 70 4.6 Stormwater management ponds ............................................................................ 72 5 Design requirements for remediation of existing instream structures for fish passage ................................................................................................................... 73 5.1 Assessing & prioritising structures for remediation ............................................... 73 5.2 Setting fish passage objectives for existing structures ........................................... 74 5.3 Good practice remediation design ......................................................................... 75 6 Built barriers: A special case for protecting native biodiversity .................................. 98 6.1 When must selective fish passage be considered? ................................................ 98 6.2 Which native fish may benefit from built barriers? .............................................. 100 6.3 Biological factors to consider in creating and maintaining a built barrier ........... 101 6.4 Setting objectives for built barriers ...................................................................... 102 6.5 Best practice design criteria and installation of built barriers .............................. 103 6.6 Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 120 7 Monitoring fish passage success ............................................................................. 122 7.1 BACI survey ........................................................................................................... 124 7.2 Mark and recapture study .................................................................................... 126 7.3 Defining success .................................................................................................... 134 8 Knowledge gaps & research needs ......................................................................... 136 8.1 State-of-the-art in fish passage research methods .............................................. 136 8.2 Challenges for fish passage research and management in New Zealand............. 137 8.3 Critical knowledge gaps ........................................................................................ 138 8.4 The need for novel solutions and innovative approaches .................................... 140 9 Glossary of abbreviations and terms ...................................................................... 142 10 References ............................................................................................................. 145 Appendix A Legislative context – who manages fish passage? ............................ 161 Appendix B Legislation ..................................................................................... 165 Appendix C Legal definitions ............................................................................. 173 Appendix D Ecological considerations for instream structure design .................. 175 Appendix E What creates a barrier to fish movements? ..................................... 186 Appendix F Fish swimming speed look-up tables ............................................... 207 Appendix G Minimum design standards for fish passage at instream structures ...................................................................................... 208 Appendix H Remediation case studies ............................................................... 210 Appendix I Monitoring case studies ................................................................. 211 Tables Table 4.1: Types of road crossings over streams and relevant features of these crossings for fish passage. 37 Table 5.1: Examples of some possible ecological prioritisation criteria for fixing instream barriers. 74 Table 5-2: Common causes of fish passage problems and some possible mitigation solutions. 76 Table 5.3: Summary of design specifications for 'nature-like' rock ramp fishways for small-bodied fish. 78 Table 5.4: Guide to the number of baffles required for different culvert diameters. 89 Table 5.5: Changes in culvert capacity at different flows, for bare pipes and for pipes fitted with spoiler baffles. 91 Table 5.6: Coefficients for the generalizable relationship between Q* and y0/D for culvert baffles. 91 Table 6-1: List of key non-migratory galaxias that could have increased protection from a natural or built barrier to exclude invasive fish. 101 Table 6-2: Factors influencing fishes’ ability and likelihood of successfully negotiating barrier(s). 102 Table 6-3: Barrier types that have been found to protect native values. 108 Table 6-4: Design considerations for built (weir) barriers. 113 Table 7.1: The main benefits and drawbacks of various monitoring approaches. 123 Table D-1: Summary of fish swimming data for NZ species. 182 -1 Table F-1: Maximum