Finding Black Mountain the Spirit of Progressive Education in the 21St Century
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FINDING BLACK MOUNTAIN THE SPIRIT OF PROGRESSIVE EDUCATION IN THE 21ST CENTURY A Dissertation by JOHN HENSON Submitted to the Graduate School at Appalachian State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF EDUCATION December, 2019 Educational Leadership Doctoral Program Reich College of Education FINDING BLACK MOUNTAIN THE SPIRIT OF PROGRESSIVE EDUCATION IN THE 21ST CENTURY A Dissertation by JOHN HENSON December, 2019 APPROVED BY: Dr. Chris Patti, Ph.D Chairperson, Dissertation Committee Dr. Vachel Miller, Ed.D Member, Dissertation Committee Dr. Kim Becnel, Ph.D Member, Dissertation Committee Dr. Vachel Miller, Ed.D Director, Educational Leadership Doctoral Program Dr. Michael McKenzie, Ph.D Dean, Cratis D. Williams School of Graduate Studies Copyright by John Henson 2019 All Rights Reserved Abstract FINDING BLACK MOUNTAIN THE SPIRIT OF PROGRESSIVE EDUCATION IN THE 21ST CENTURY John Henson B.S., Appalachian State University M.Ed., Boston University Ed.D., Appalachian State University Dissertation Committee Chairperson: Dr. Chris Patti This study explores the phenomena of the Black Mountain College Semester (BMCS) as a means to locate the spirit of progressive education in the 21st Century. Through interviews with contemporary faculty who organized and participated in the BMCS, along with document analysis of texts related to the history and legacy of the BMC, this research seeks to identify effective strategies for cultivating innovation, creativity, and community in the classrooms of today and tomorrow. Using a thematic analysis of interviews and historical texts, this study illuminates the values that past and present educators hold as sacred, and the ways in which they put those values into practice in their classrooms. Findings illuminate persistent tensions between descriptions of optimal learning conditions, and the realities of the highly-structured nature of higher education. Specifically, a tension between academic structure and freedom was prominent along with an acknowledgement of the significant impact Information and Communication Technologies are having on our on all aspects of contemporary lived experiences. This study carries implications for the ways in which iv institutions of higher education, and the educators working within, go about establishing innovation, creativity, and community as values. v Acknowledgments Like all students before me, my dissertation research would not be not have been possible without the guidance and encouragement of a group of individuals I feel honored to call friends and mentors. I first want to express my deepest gratitude and appreciation to my wife and partner Theresa, who has given me her unwavering support and care throughout my graduate studies. To my two amazing young boys, who kept me fueled with a constant supply of hugs, but also demonstrated—at every opportunity—the power of curiosity and the wonder of the human imagination. You two will forever be my most important teachers. To my parents, whose love and compassion have shaped who I have am today, and who I strive to become tomorrow. You taught me to never give up on my goals and dreams and to above all bestow upon others respect, compassion, and warmth. To Tracy Smith, for working with me at perhaps the most essential stage of my dissertation journey—conceptualization. Thank you for your thoughtful dialogue and deep listening during long conversations in your office. Your mentorship was essential in helping me converge my overly divergent thinking as I worked to identify a topic and case. To the Faculty Fellows and coordinators of the Black Mountain College Semester who graciously agreed to participate in my research. Your stories, ideas, and perspectives are the foundation of my research. Thank you for sharing your time, your wisdom, and your enthusiasm for education. vi To my doctoral committee, whose great care and masterful touch have been essential in bringing this research to life. To Vachel, for being with me throughout my doctoral journey. Your warmth, scholarly perspective, and progressive teaching practices have been integral from the very beginning of my doctoral adventure. To Kim, whose fellowship during our time together in Cohort 2 of the Scholarly Teaching Academy was inspirational. Your thoughtful and critical perspective helped me refine the scope and focus of this project. To my dissertation chair Chris, with whom I have shared everything from philosophical dialogue, to scholarly-musical jam sessions, to a rope while rock climbing high above the Blue Ridge Parkway. I will forever be grateful to you for the countless hours you dedicated in both the conceptualization and revision phases. I feel fortunate to have experienced your hyper qualitative style of research and interviewing within my own work. Lastly, I wish to acknowledge all teachers who each day aspire to honor the interests, experiences, and skillsets of their students. Within your classrooms, the great ideas of tomorrow are incubated and nourished. vii Dedication I dedicate this research to the power and promise of the imagination—yours and mine. For through our dreams, we can transform the world’s greatest challenges into opportunities. viii Table of Contents Abstract .................................................................................................................................... iv Acknowledgments .................................................................................................................... vi Dedication .............................................................................................................................. viii List of Tables ....................................................................................................................... xviii List of Figures ........................................................................................................................ xix Chapter 1: Introduction and Statement of the Problem ............................................................ 1 Rationale and Context of the Issues Facing Higher Education ............................................. 2 Purpose of Study ................................................................................................................... 7 Research Questions ............................................................................................................... 8 Overview of Methodology .................................................................................................... 9 Role and Assumptions of the Researcher ........................................................................... 10 Significance ......................................................................................................................... 12 Organization of the Dissertation ......................................................................................... 13 Chapter 2: Review of Literature ............................................................................................. 15 Progressive Education: Origins and Theory ....................................................................... 18 Critical Pedagogy: Origins & Theory ................................................................................. 23 ix Subverting oppression through praxis. ........................................................................... 24 Bringing critical pedagogy to the United States. ............................................................ 26 The persistence of the banking model. ........................................................................... 28 Higher Education in the 21st Century .................................................................................. 28 Locating Progressive Pedagogies in the 21st Century ......................................................... 33 Creativity in Education ....................................................................................................... 36 Histories of Black Mountain College ................................................................................. 41 The purpose of the college. ............................................................................................. 46 Student life at Black Mountain College. ......................................................................... 49 Born in the south and the 18th Century. .......................................................................... 53 The Black Mountain College Semester .............................................................................. 56 Summary ............................................................................................................................. 57 Chapter 3: Traversing Qualitative Methods ............................................................................ 59 Rationale for Research Approach ....................................................................................... 59 Research Context ................................................................................................................ 60 Research Sample and Data Sources .................................................................................... 60 Participant Profiles .............................................................................................................. 62 Data Collection Methods .................................................................................................... 66 x Interviews. ......................................................................................................................