Perspectives in Quantum Physics: Epistemological, Ontological And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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`3ab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a( ( \\U ME0'>&+,%,G*(#-.(N->,%,G*(0-(I"*'0C'(\-'>$@C>0,-( ( 3a( ( \\\U 8,>0=#>0,-(#-.(N=&$=0&O(,?(H0''&$>#>0,-(I$,^&C>(( ( :;( ( )&?&$&-C&'(2!"#E>&$(36( ( ( ( ( ( ( :4( * @0.%'"#*B2*C")"54%/"+'*4<*D'-9"+'*!"#$%"&'()"$*E*F+('(.5*D'-9("$* GH* ( \U \->$,.@C>0,-( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ca( ( \\U 9>@.0&'( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ca( 1U 9>@.&->(0.&#'(#A,@>(+&#'@$&+&->(C"#-G&(,=&$(>0+&( c`( /U \-'>$@C>0,-#%(C",0C&'(0-?%@&-C&('>@.&->(E&$'E&C>0=&'( _3( !U !,-'0'>&-C*(,?('>@.&->(E&$'E&C>0=&'( ( ( _5( ( \\\U 9@++#$*(#-.(H0'C@''0,-( ( ( ( ( ( _b( ( )&?&$&-C&'(2!"#E>&$(:6( ( ( ( ( ( ( _`( * @0.%'"#*G2*,-.+'-/*F+'"#%#"'.'(4+*.$*I(99"+*@-##(&-5-/*E** J.#(.'(4+$*(+*F+$'#-&'4#*!#.&'(&"$*.+9*:$$4&(.'"9** D'-9"+'*8-'&4/"$* * * * * 53* ( \U \->$,.@C>0,-( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 53( ( \\U \-'>$@C>,$'(#EE$,#C"(F@#->@+(0->&$E$&>#>0,-(.0??&$&->%*( 5c( ( \\\U !,+E#$0-G(\-'>$@C>,$(I$#C>0C&'(21(!%,'&$(Z,,R6( ( ( 5b( 1U /#CRG$,@-.(,-(C,@$'&(+#>&$0#%'(#-.(C@$$0C@%@+(( '0+0%#$0>0&'( ( ( ( ( ( ( 5b( ( /U H0??&$&-C&'(0-(0-'>$@C>0,-#%(#EE$,#C"&'( ( ( 5a( !U J"&(.,@A%&['%0>(&TE&$0+&->(O0>"('0-G%&(F@#->#( ( b:( HU 2\-6C,-'0'>&-C*(,?('>@.&->($&'E,-'&'( ( ( b5( ( \dU 9@++#$*(#-.(H0'C@''0,-( ( ( ( ( ( ba( ( )&?&$&-C&'(2!"#E>&$(c6( ( ( ( ( ( ( b4( ( @0.%'"#*K2*L"<(+"9*@0.#.&'"#(M.'(4+$*4<*D'-9"+'*!"#$%"&'()"$* 4+*,-.+'-/*!01$(&$* * * * * HA* ( \U \->$,.@C>0,-( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( a3( ( \\U \->&$=0&O(E#$>0C0E#->'(#-.(C,@$'&(C"#$#C>&$0'>0C'( ( a:( ( \\\U )&?0-&.(C"#$#C>&$0X#>0,-'(,?('>@.&->(E&$'E&C>0=&'( ( a_( 1U H0'C@''0,-(,?(?,$+#%(0->&$E$&>#>0,-'( ( ( a5( ( /U 9>@.&->'(&TE$&''(A&%0&?'(>"#>(E#$#%%&%(>",'&(,?(&TE&$>( E$,E,-&->'( ( ( ( ( ( ( ab( !U !#>&G,$0X#>0,-(#-.('@++#$*(,?('>@.&->($&'E,-'&'( `;( ( \dU 9@++#$*(#-.(H0'C@''0,-( ( ( ( ( ( `a( ( )&?&$&-C&'(2!"#E>&$(_6( ( ( ( ( ( ( 43( ( @0.%'"#*N2*O".&0(+6*,-.+'-/*F+'"#%#"'.'(4+$*E*@-##(&-5-/* C")"54%/"+'*.+9*F/%5"/"+'.'(4+* * * PG* ( \U \->$,.@C>0,-( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 4c( ( \\U !@$$0C@%@+(H&=&%,E+&->(#-.(\+E%&+&->#>0,-( ( ( 4_( 1U 1''&''0-G(0-C,+0-G('>@.&->(E&$'E&C>0=&'(#-.(( C,-C&E>@#%(@-.&$'>#-.0-G( ( ( ( 44( ( /U Z&C>@$&(8#>&$0#%'( ( ( ( ( ( 3;b( !U V,+&O,$R( ( ( ( ( ( ( 3:;( HU MT#+(8#>&$0#%'(( ( ( ( ( ( 3:5( MU 1''&''0-G(,@>G,0-G(E&$'E&C>0=&'( ( ( ( 3:4( BU B0-#%(M''#*( ( ( ( ( ( ( 3cb( ( )&?&$&-C&'(2!"#E>&$(56( ( ( ( ( ( ( 3c`( ( * * @0.%'"#*Q2*O".&0(+6*,-.+'-/*F+'"#%#"'.'(4+$*E*@4/%.#.'()"* *8-'&4/"$*.+9*@-##(&-5-/*L"<(+"/"+'* * AKA* ( \U \->$,.@C>0,-( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 3_3( ( \\U !,+E#$#>0=&(N@>C,+&'( ( ( ( ( ( 3_3( 1U 9>@.&->(\->&$&'>(0-(K@#->@+(8&C"#-0C'( ( ( 3_:( /U \->&$E$&>0=&(1>>0>@.&'(( ( ( ( ( 3__( ( \\\U !@$$0C@%@+()&?0-&+&->(#-.(N>"&$(B@>@$&(H0$&C>0,-'( ( 353( 1U 90-G%&[I",>,-(MTE&$0+&->'( ( ( ( ( 35:( /U M->#-G%&+&->(#-.(!,$$&%#>&.(8&#'@$&+&->'( ( 354( !U 1>,+0C(8,.&%'(#-.(I$,A#A0%0>*( ( ( ( 3b;( ( \dU !,-C%@.0-G()&+#$R'( ( ( ( ( ( ( 3b:( ( )&?&$&-C&'(2!"#E>&$(b6( ( ( ( ( ( ( 3b5( ( R(S5(46#.%01( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( AQH( * :%%"+9(&"$** ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( 1EE&-.0T(1(e(M=,%@>0,-(,?(N-%0-&(9@$=&*(\>&+'( ( ( ( ( 1EE&-.0T(/(e(\->&$=0&O(I$,>,C,%(29E$0-G(:;;46( ( ( ( ( 1EE&-.0T(!(e(9&%&C>&.(8,.&$-(I"*'0C'(!,@$'&(8#>&$0#%'(2B#%%(:;3;6( ( 1EE&-.0T(H(e(9&%&C>&.(V,+&O,$R7(MT#+7(9@$=&*(#-.(B0-#%(M''#*( (9@A+0''0,-'(?$,+(B,@$(9>@.&->'(2B#%%(:;3;6(( ( 1EE&-.0T(M(e(!,%%&C>&.(MTC&$E>'(?$,+(9>@.&->()&?%&C>0,-'(2B#%%(:;3;6( ( 1EE&-.0T(B(e(9&%&C>&.(9>@.&->(H0'C@''0,-(J"$&#.'(2B#%%(:;3;6( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( !"#$%&'()( ( $*+,-*./01*,(02(3452/46($78,0.,( ( “Why do some textbooks not mention complementarity? Because it will not help in quantum mechanical calculations or in setting up experiments. Bohr’s considerations are extremely relevant, however, to the scientist who occasionally likes to reflect on the meaning of what she or he is doing.” – Abraham Pais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x09G!0*.!'/0'!)'+!+3%,)2),!1-1%*'81! 6p9!!#&-&*&#,).&%!)'+!.%2)*)'%!#-,0')-*!6x9!0'!0##!#0'%&!')1%+!6t9D! p 6M;M9! x(t) = x0 + !t ! me N8+'!0+!B)'/!'/%!0++813')-*!-2!".)/&#%'(0*),&!2-&!0##!-$+%&7%&+!)*!O0#)#%0*!&%#0')7)'4G! '/%+%!,#0++),0#! 0++813')-*+! 0&%! $0+%.! -*! )*'8)')7%! *-')-*+! C&-8*.%.!)*!%7%&4.04!