Third Series, Vol.XXXII, No.1 Wedmesday, May 27, 1964 Jyaistha 6, 1886(Saka)
LOK SABHA DEBATES
(THIIlD SBRlBS) \
V.J.... XXXII. r¢4/r886 (sa.)
[May 27 toJune 5, r¢4/Jyaistha 6 ,. IS, r886 (Saka)]
Eighth S.. I_. 1""'1116 (Saka)
(V.I. XXXII CMIIiIu N.,. r ,. 7)
LOK SABRA SECRETAllIAT 'E\"\' T)ELHT -,..•.... CONTENTS ··CoLUMNS [Third Series Vol. XXXII-Eighth Session, 1886 (Sakai]
No. I-Wednesday, May 27, I964!Jyaivtha 6, 1886 (Saka)
State of health of Prime Minister' ,Member sworn- , Shri Vidya Charan Shukla . 1-2 ~cpml Answers to Questions- ( Starred Questions Nos. I to 10 'Written Answers to Questions- Starred Questions Nos. II to 21 , Unstarred Questions Nos. I to 7. 9 to 47 and 49 to 51 /Obituary references ...... ) Re: Motions for Adjournment and Calling Attention Notices- (Query) Calling Attention to Matter of Urgent Public Importance- Firing on refugees from East Pakistan at Tiruvelli RailWay Station 78-87 Papers laid on the Table . 91-93 Presidents assent to Bills . 93-94 Demands for Supplementary Grants (General) 1964-65 . 94 Constitution (Nineteenth Amendment) Bill, 1964-introduced 94-107 Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Amendment Bill . 107-41 Motion to consider as reported by Joint Committee 108-41 Shri Balmiki . 108-16 Shri D. C. Shanns . 116-23 Shri Muthu Gounder 123-2 7 Shri R.S. Pandey 127-32 Shri Onkar Lal Berwla 132-37 Shri Sinhasan Singh 137-39 Shri Sham Lal Saraf. 139-41 Shri D. S. Palil 141 Demise of Shri Jawaharlal Nehru 142
*The sign +marked above the name of a Member indicates that the Question was actually asked on the floor of the House by that Member.
~ 713 (Ai) LSD-I. LOK SABRA Alphabetical List of Memllen
A Barua, Shri Rajendranath (Jorhat). Abdur Rashid, Bakshi (Jammu IIDd Barupal, Sbri Panna Lal (Ganp- Kashmir). nagar). Abdul Wahid, Shri T. (Vellore). Basant Kunwari, Shrimati (Kat- Achal Singh, Shri (Agra). sarganj). Achuthan, Shri R. (Mavelikera). Basappa, Shri C. R. (Tiptur): Akkamma Devi, Shrimati (Nilgiris). Basumatari, Shri D. (Goalpara). Alagesan, Shri O. V. (Chinglepdt). Alva, Shri A. Shankar (Mangalore). Baswant, Shri Sonubhai Dllgad. (Thana). Alva, Shri Joachim (Kanara). Alvares, Shri Peter Augustus Bateshwar Singh, Shri (Giridih). (PlUl.iim). Berwa. Shri Onkar Lal (Kotah). Aney, Dr. 1\(. S. eNagpur). Besra, Shri Satyacharan (Dumka). Anjanappa, Shri B. (Nellore). Bhagat, Shri BaHram (Shahabad). Ankineedu, Shri Maganti (Gudivada). Bhagavati, Shri Bijoy Chaadra Anthony, Shri Frank (Nominated- (Darrang). Anglo-Indians) . Bhakat Darshan, Shri (Garhwal). Arunachalam, Shri N. (Ramanathapu- Bhanja Deo, Shri Laxminarayan ram). (Keonjhar). Azad, Shri Shagwat Jha (Bhagalpur). Bhanu Parkash Singh, 8hri (Raj. garh). B Babunath Singh, Shri (Surguja). Bhargava, Shri M. B. L. (Ajmer). Bade, Shri Ramchandra Vithal (Khnr· Bhatkar. Shri Laxmanrao Shrawan,ji. gon!!). (Khamgaon) . Badrudduja, Shri (Murshidabad). Bhattacharya, Shri Dlnen (Seram- pore). Bagri, 8hri Mani Ram (Hissar). Bajaj, Shri Kamalnayan (Wardha). Bhattacharyya, Shri C. K. (Raiganj). Bakliwal, Shri Mohanlal (Drug). Bhawani, Shri Lakhmu (Bastar). Bal Krishana Singh, Shri (Chandauli). Bheel, Shri P. H. (Dohad). Balakrishnan, smt S. C. (!CoUpaHi) . Biren Dutta, Shri (Tripura West). Balmiki, Shri K. L. (Khurja). Birendra Bahadur Singh, Shri (Raj- Banerjee, Shri S. M. (Kanpur). nandgaon). Banerjl, Dr. R. (Bankura). BiM, Shri Jusa Bahadur SinIh Barkataki, Shrimati Renuka Devi (Almora). (Barpeta). Borooah, Shri Prafulla ChllDdra BarmIlD, Shri P. C. (Coach Bihar). (Sibsagar) . Barrow, Shri A. II:' T. (Nominated- Anglo-Indians) . Brahm Prakuh, Shri (Outer Delhi). Barua, Shri Hem (Gauhatl). Brajt!8hwar Prasad, Shri (Gaya). II11'l (Ai) LSD.-a (ii)
Brij Basi Lal, Shri (Faizabad). Dasappa, Sh1"i H. C. (Bangalore). Brij Raj Singh, Shri Kotah (Jhala- war). Dasaratha Deb, Shri (Tripura East). Brij Raj Singh, Shri (Bareilly). Dass, Shri C. (Tirupathi). Buta Singh, Shri (1\/loga). Deo, Shri P. K. (Kalahandi). Deo, Shri Vijaya Bhushan Singh c (Raigarh).
Chakravartty, Shrimati Renu (Bar. Deo Bhanj, Shri P. C. (Bhubaneswar). rackpore). Desai, Shri Morarji (Surat). Chakraverti, Shri P. R. (Dhanbad). Deshmukh, Dr. Panjabrao S. (Amra- Chanda, Shrimati Jyotsna (Cachar). vati). Chandak, Shri B. L. (Chindwara). Deshmukh, Shri B. D. (Aurangabad). Chandrabhan Singh, Shri (Btlaspur). Chandrasekhar, Shrimati M.- (Mayu- Deshmukh, Shri Shivaji Rao Shankar ram). Rao (Parbhani). 9handriki, Shri Jagannathrao Venka- Dey, Shri S. K. (Nagaur). tarao (Raichur). Dhaon, Shri B. K. (Lucknow). Chattar Singh, Shri (Chamba). Dharmalingam, Shri R. (Tiruvanna- Chatterjee, Shri H. P. (Nabadwip). malai). Chatterjee, Shri N. C. (Burdwan). Dhuleshwar Meena, Shri (Udaipur). Chaturved.i, Shri S. N. (Firozabad). Dighe, Shri Bhaskar Narayan Chaudhary, Shri Yudhvir Singh (Kolaba). (Mahendragarh) . Chaudhry, Shri C. M. (Mahua). Dinesh Singh, Shri (Salon). Chaudhuri, Shri D. S. (Mathura). Dixit, Shri G. N. (Etawah). Chaud:huri, Shrimati Kamala (HBPur). Dorai, Shri Kasinatha (Aruppuk- Chaudhuri, Shri Sachindra Nath kottai). (Ghatal). Dubey, Shri Rajaram Giridharilal Chaucihuri, Shri Tridib Kumar (Bijapur North). (Berhampur) . Chavan, Shri D. R. (Khard). Dwivedi, Shri Mannoo Lal (Hamir- pur). Chavan; Shri Y. B. (NiIBik). Chavda, Shrimati Zohraben (Banas- Dwivedi, Shri Surendranath (Kendra- kantha). para). Chuni LaI, Shri (Ambala). E D Elayaperumal, Shri L. (Tirukoilur). Daile, . Shri (Miraj). Daji, Shri Homi F. (Indore). Elias, Shri Mohammad (Howrah). Daljit Singh,' Shri (Una). Bring, Shri D. (Nominated-North Das, Dr. Mono Mohon (Ausgram). East Frontier Tract). Das, Shri Basanta Kumar (Contai). F Das, S~ Nayantara (Jamui). Das, Shri Sudhansu (Diamond Har- Firodia, Shri Motilal KundanmBl bour). (Ahmednagar). (iii) G Hem Raj, Shri (Kangra). Gaekwad, Silri Fatehsinhrao Pratab- Himatsingka, Shri Prabhu Da~al ainhrao (Baroda). (Godda). Gabmari, Shri Vishwanath Singh Himmatsinhji, Shri (Kutch). (Ghazipur) . Hukam Singh, Shri (Patiala). Gajraj Singh, Shri (Gurgaon). Ganapati Ram, Shri (Machhllshahr). I Gandhi, Shri V. B. (Bombay' Ci~ Central South). Imbichibava, Shri E. K. (Ponnani). Ganga Devi, Shrimati (Mohanlalganj). Iqbal Singh, Shri (Ferozepore). Gayatri Devi, Shrimati (Jaipur). Ghosh, Shri Atulya (AsIlDSOI). I Ghosh, Shri N. R. (Jalpaiguri). Ghosh, Shri P. K. (Ranchi East). Jadhav Shii Madhavrao Laxmanrao (Malegaon). Ghyasuddin Ahmad, Shri (Dhubri). Gokaran Prasad, Shri (Misrikh). Jadhav, Shri Tulshidas (Nanded). GoDi, Shri Abdul Ghani (Jammu and Jagjivan Ram, Shri (Sasaram). Kashmir). Jain, Shri A. P. (Tumkur). Sopalan, Shri A. Ie. (Kasergod). Jaipal Singh, Shri (Ranchi West). Gounder, Shri R. Xuthu (Tiruppat- Jamir, Shri Chubatoshi (Nominated- tur). Naga Hills-Tuensang Area). Govind Das, Dr. (Jabalpur). • Jamunadevi, Shrimati (Jhabua). Guha, Shri Arun Chandra (Barasat). Jayaraman, Shri A. (Wandiwash). Gulshan, Shri Dhanna Singh Jedhe, Shri Gulabrao Keshavrao (Bhatinda). (Baramati). Gupta, Shri Badshah (Mainpuri). Jena, Shri Kanhu Charan (Bhadrak). Gupta, Shri Indrajit (Calcutta South Jha, Shri Yogendra (Madhubani). West). Joshi, Shri Anand Chandra (Sidhi). Gupta, Shri Kashi Ram (Alwar). Joshi, Shrimati Subhadra (Balram- Gupta, Shri Priya (Katihar). pur). Gupta, Shri Ram Ratan (Gonda). Jyotishi, Shri Jwala Prasad (Sagar). Gupta, Shri Shiv Charan (Delhi Sadar).
B Kabir, Shri Humayun (Basirhat). Kachhavaiya, Shri Hukam Chand (Dewas). HajlU'Ravis, Shri R. M. (Bhandara). Kadadi, Shri Madeppa Bandappa Hansda, Shri Subodh (Jhargram). (Sholapur). Hanumanthiah, Shri K. (Bangalore Kajrolkar, Shri Sadoba Narayan City). (Bombay City Central North). Haq, Shri M. M. (Akola). Kakkar, Shri Gauri Shankar (Fateh- Harvani, Shri Ansar (Bisauli). pur). Hazarika, Shri J. N. (Dibrugarh); Kamath, Shri Hari Vishnu (Hostum,a- Beds, Shri Harish Chandra (N'-- bad). bad). Kamble, Shri T. D. (Latur). (ivJ
Kanakasabai, Shri R. (Chidambaram). Lakslimikanthamma, Shrimati T. (Khammam). Kandappan, Shri S. (Tirucheng~de). KaRungo, Shri Nityanand (Cuttack). Lalit Sen, Shri (Mandi). ICappen, Shri Cherian J. (Muvattu- Laskar, Shri Nihar Ranjan (Karim- puma). ganj). Kapur Sinah. Shri (Ludhiana). Laxmi Bai,· Shrimati Sangam (Vice- rabad). Kar, Shri Prabhat (Hooghly). Laxmi. Dass, Shri (Wryalguda). Karni Singhji, Shri (Bikaner). Karuthiruman, Shri P. G. (Gobichetti- Lohia, Dr. Ram Manohar (Farrukha- palayam). bad). ltayal, Shri Pareah Nath (JCJYII&Iar). Lonikar, Shri R. N. (Jalna). Kedaria, Shri Chhaganlal (Mandvi). Keishing, Shri Rishang (Outer Mani- • p1oU'). Mahadeo Prasad, Shri (Bansgaon). Kesar La!, Shri (Sawai Madhopur). Mahadeva Prasad, Dr. (Maharaj- Khadilkar, Shri R. K. (Khed). ganj). Khan, Dr. Purneadu Narayan (Ulube- Mahananda, Shri Hrushilresh (Bolan- ria). girl. Khan, Shri Osman Ali (Anantapur). Mahato, Shri Bhajahari (Purulia). Khan, Shri Shahnawaz (Meerut). Mahida, Shri Harendra Singh Khanna, Shri Mehr ChaDd (New (Anand). Delhi). MBhishi, Dr. Sarojini (Dharwar Khanna, Shri Prem Kiahan (Itaim- North). ganj). Mahtab, Shri Hare ltruslma (Angul). Kindar Lal, Shri (Hardoi). Maimoona Sultan, Shrimati (Bhopal): Kiaan Veer, Shri (Satara). Majithia, Shri Surjit Singh (Tarm Kohar, Dr. (Phulbani). Taran). Kotoki, Shri LUadhar (Nowgon,). Malaichami, Shri M. (Periyakulam). Koujalgi, Shri H. V. (Belgaum). Malaviya, Shri Keshav Dev (Bastl). K~a, Shri C. H. Mohammad (Kozhi- Malhotra, Shri Inder J. (Jammu ad kode). Kashmir). Malliah, Shri U. Srinivala (Udipl). Kripa Shankar, Shri (Domariaganj). Mallick, Shri Rama Chandra (Jajpur). Kripalani, Shri J. B. (Amroha). Manaen, Shri T. (Darjeeling). Krishna, Shri M. R. (Paddapalll). MandaI, Dr. P. (Vishnupur). Krishnamachari, Shri T. T. (Tiru- chendur). Mandal, Shri Bhupendra Narayan (Saharsa). Krishnapal Singh, Shri (Jalesar). Kumaran, Shri M. K. (Chirayinkil). Mandal, Shri Jiyalal (Khagaria). Kunhan, Shri P. (Palghat). MandaI, Shri Y. P. (Jainagar). Manlyangadan, Shri Mathew (Kotta- Kureel, Shri Baij Nath (Rae yam). Bareili). Manoharan, Shri X. (Madras South). L Mantrl, Sbrl Dwarkadas (Bhir). Lahti Singh, Shri (Rohtall:). Muandi, Shri Iawar (Rajmahal). Lakhan 0 .... Shri (Shahjahanpur). Mai'uthiah, ShrI P. (Melur). (v)
Masani, 8hri M. R. (Rajkot). Mukerjee, Shri H. N. (Ca1euUa Cea- tral). Masuriya Din, Shri (Chall). Mukerjee, Shrimati Sharda (Ra_- Matcharaju, Shri M. (Sarasipatnam). giri). Mate, Shri Kure (Tikamgarh). Munzni, Shri David (LoharciI!P). Mathur, Shri Harish Chandra (Jalore). Murli Manobar, Shri (Balia). Maurya, Shri B. P. (.w.,arh). Murmu, Shri Sarkar (BalurChat). Mehdi, ShriS. Ahmad (Rampur). Murthy, shri B. S. (Amalapuram). Mehrotra, Shri Braj Behari (Bilhaur). Murti, Shri M. s. (Anakapalle). Mehta, Shri Jaswantraj (Pali). Musafir, Sbri Gurmukh Sinlh (Amrit- Mehta, Shri Jashvantrai N. (Bbav- sar>. nagar). Muthiah, Shri P. (Tinmelveli). Melkote, Dr. G. S. (Hyderabad). Muzatfar Husain, Shri N. (Moracla- Mengi, Shri Gopal Datt (Jammu and bad). Kashmir). N Menon, Shri Panampilli Govinda (Mukundapuram) . Naidu, Shri V. Govindasamy (Tiru- vallur). Menon, Shri V. K. Krishna (Bombay City North). Naik, Shri D. J. (Panchmahals). Minimata, Shrimati Agamdas Guru Naik, ~hri Maheswar (MayurbbaD,D. (Baloda Bazar>. Nair, Shri N. Sreekantan (Quilon). Mirza, Shri Bakar Ali (Warrangal). Nair, Shri p. K.. Vasudevan (Ambala- Mishra, Shri Bibhuti (Motihari). puzha). Mishra, Shri Bibudhendra (Purl). Nallakoya, Shri Koyilat (Nominated- Laccadive, MiDicoy and Mishra, Shri Mathura Prasad Amilldivi (Beeu- Islands). sarai). Nambiar, Shri Ananda Misra, Dr. Udaikar (Jamshedpur). (Tiruchira- palli). Misra. Shri Mahesh Dutta (Khandwa). Nand&, Shri Gulzarilal (Sabarkm- Misra, Shri Shyam Dhar (Mirzapur). tha). Mohammad Yusuf, Shri (Siwm). Naslmr, Sbri P. S. (Mathurapur). Mohan Swaroop, Sbri (Pilibhit). Nath Pai, Shri (Rajapur). Nayak, Shri M~bBn (BhanjllllJlgar). Mohanty, Shri Gokulanand (Bala- sore>. Nayar, Dr. Sushila (Jhansi). Nehru, Shri Jawaharlal (Phulpur). Mohiuddin, Shri Ahmed (Secundera- bad). Nesamony, Shri A. (Nagercoil). Nigam, Shrimati Savitri (Banda). Mohsin, Shri F. H. (Dharwar South). Niranjan Lal, Shri (Nominated- Morarka, Shri Radheyshyam Ram- Andaman and Nicobar Islands). kumar (Jhunjbunu). More, Shri Krishnaji Luman (Hat- o kanangle). Dmkar Singb, Shri (Budaun). More, Shri Shankarao Shantaram Oza, Sbri Gbanshyamlal (Surendra- (Poona). nagar). Muhammad Ismail, Shri (Manjeri). Mukane, Shri Yeshwantrao Martand- Paliwal, Shri Tika• Ram (HiDdaun). rao (Bbiwandi). Pande, Shri Jtashi Nath (Hata). ::'::::.;:~:::.~.~:':::.::;:::::::::.::''':~:'.:':::':::-;>:::;::;~':::::.~':'-::::::::~""J,.~> •• ::, ...... •• ':"'>"f;.• ;dAE5i>'liCji:,{,'\"""~~ (vi) Paneiey, Shri R. S. (Guna). Rai, Shrirnati Sahodra Bai (Damoh) . Pandey, Shri Sarjoo (Rasra). Raj Bahadur, Shri (Bharatpur). P.andey, SOO Vishwa Nath (Salem- Raja, Shri Chittaranjan (Junagadh). pur). Rajaram, Shri K. (Krishnagiri). Panna Lal, Shri (Akbarpur). Rajdeo Singh, Shri (Jaunpur). Pant, Shri K. C. (Naini Tal). Raju, Shri D. Balarama (Narasapur). Paradhi, Shri Bholaram (Balaghat). Raju, Dr. D. S. (Rajahmundry). Paramasivan, Shri S. K. (Erode). Rajyalaxmi, Shrirnati Lalita (Auran- Parashar, Shri V. C. (ShiVpuri). gabad). Patel, Shri Chhotubhai M. (Broach). Ram, Shri T. (Sonbarsa). Patel, Shri Man Sinh P. (Mehsana). Ram Sewak, Shri (Jalaun). Patel, Shri Nanubhai N. (Bulsar). Ram Singh, Shri (Bahraich). Patel, Shri Purushottamdas R. Ram Subhag Sineh, Dr. (Bikrarn- (Patan). g8l'lj). Patel, Shri Rajeshwar (Hajipur). Ram Swarup, Shri (Robertsganj). PatH, Shri Deorao Sheoram (Yoot- Ramabadran, Shri T. D. (Cuddalore). mal). Ramakrishnan, Shri P. R. (Coimba- Patil, Shri J. S. (Jalgaon). tore) . Patil, Shri Madhaorao Bhagwantrao Ramanathan Chettiar, Shri (Karur). (Ramtek). Ramaswamy, Shri S. V. (Salem). Pati!, Shri S. B. (Bijapur South). Ramaswamy, Shri V. K. (Namakkal). Patil, Shri S. K. (Bombay City Ramdhani Das, Shri (Nawada). South). Rameshwaranand, Shri (Kamal). PatH, Shri T. A. (Osmanabad). Rampure, Shri Mahadevappa (Gul- PatH, Shri V. T. (Kolhapur). barga). Patil, Shri Vasantrao Lakhagounda Rarnshekhar Prasad Singh, Shrl (Chikodi). (Chapra). Patnaik, Shri Baishnab Charan Rananjai Singh, Shri (MusalIrkhana). (Dhenkanal) . Rane, Shri Shivram Rango (Bul- Pattabhi Raman, Shri C. R. (Kumba- dana). konam). Ranga, Shri N. G. (Chittoor). Pattnayak, Shri Kishen (Sambalpur). Ranga Rao, Shri R. V. G. K. (Chee- Pillai, Shri Nataraja (Trivandrum). purupalli) . Pottekkatt, Shri S. K. (Tellicherry). Ranjit Singh, Shri (Sangrur). Prabhakar, Shri Naval (Delhi-Karol Rao, Shri P. Hanurnanth (Medak). Bagh). Rao, Shri J. Rarnapathi (Karim- Pratap Sineh, Shri (Sirrnur). nagar). Prithvi Raj, Shri (Dausa). Rao, Shri Jaganatba (Nowrangpur). Puri, Shri D. D. (Kaithal). Rao, Shri S. V. Krishnarnoorthy (Shimoga) . B Rao, Dr. K. L. Vijayawada). Rao, Shri E. Madhusudan (Mahbuba- Raghavan, Shri A. V. (Badagara). bad). Raghunath Singh, Shri (Varanasi). Rao, Shri 1. B. Muthyal (Mahbub- Raghuramaiah, Shri K. (Guntur). nagmo). (vii)
Rac, Shri B. Rajagopala (Srikaku- Sen, Dr. Ranendra Nath (Calcutta- lam). East). Rao, Shri J. RamesRwar (Gadwal). Sen, ShrL Asoke K. (Calcutta-North West). Rao, Shri M. Thirumala (Kakinada). Sen, Shri Phani Gopal (Purnea). Rattan Lal, Shri (Banswara). Seth, Shri Bishanchander (Etah). Raut, Shri Bhola (Bettiah). Sezhiyan, Shri Era (Perambalur). Rawandale, Shri Chudaman Ananda (Dhulia). Shah, Shri Manabendra (Tehri Garh- Ray, Shrimati Renuka (Malda). wal). Heddi, Dr. B. Gopala (Kavali). Shah, Shri Manubhai (Jamnagar). Reddi, Shri Ravi Narayan (Nal- Shah, Shrimati Jayaben (Amreli). gonda) . Shakuntala Devi, Shrimati (Banka). Reddiar, Shri R. V. (Tindivanam). Sham Nath, Shri (Delhi-CbaBdni Reddy, Shri C. L. Narasimha (Rajam- Chowk). pet). Shankaraiya, Shri M. (Mysore). Reddy, Shri G. Narayan (Adilabad). . Sharma, Shri Anant Prasad (Buxar). Reddy, Shri G. Yallamanda (Marka- Sharma, Shri Diwan Chand (Gurdas- pur). pUr). Reddy, Shri K. C. (Chikballapur). Sharma, Shri K. C. (Sardhana). Reddy, Shri K. V. Ramakrishna Shashank Manjari, Shrimati (Pala- (Hindupur) . mau). Reddy, Shri Y. Eswara (Cuddapah). Shashi Ranjan, Shri (Pupri). Reddy, Shrimati Yashoda (Kurnool). Shastri, Shri Lal Bahadur (Allaha- baei). Roy, Dr. Saradish (Katwa). Roy, Shri Biswanath (Deoria). Shastri, Shri Prakash Vir (Bijnor). Shastri, Shri Rama Nand (Ramasane- s highat). Sheo Narain, Shri (Bansi). Sadhu Ram, Shri (Phillaur). Shinde, Shri Annasaheb (Kopargaon). Saha, Dr. Sisir Kumar (Birbhum). Shivananjappa, Shri M. K. (Mandya). Sahu, Shri Rameshwar (Rosera). Shree Narayan Das, Shri (Dar- Saigal, Shri Amar Singh (Janjgir). bhanga). Samanta, Shri S. C. (Tamluk). Shukla, Shri Vidya Charan (Maha- Samnani, Shri Nazir Hussain (Jammu samund). and Kashmir). Shyam Kumari Devi, Shrimati (Rai- Sanji Rupji, Shri (Nominated-Dadra pur). and Nagar Haveli). Siddananjappa, Shri H. (Hassan). Saraf, Shri Sham Lal (Jammu and Siddhanti, Shri Jagdev Singh Kashmir). (Jhajhar). Sarma, Shri A. T. (Chatrapur). Siddiah, Shri S. M. (Chamaraja- Satyabhama Devi, Slarimati (Jahana- nagar). bad). Sidheswar Prasad, Shri (Nalanda). Satyanarayana, Shri Biddika (Par- Singh, Dr. Basant Narain (Hazari- vathipuram). bagh). Scindia, Shrimati Vijaya Raje (Gwa- Singh, Shri Ajit Pratap (Pratap- lior). garh). (viii)
Singh, Shri Digvijaya Narain (Muzaf. Swaran Singh, Shri (Jullundur). farpur). Swell, Shri G. G. (AssliIll-Autol'1o- Singh, Shri Jai Bahadur (Ghosi). mous Districts). Singh, Shri Krishna Kanta (Maha- rajganj). 'I' Tahir, Shri Mohammad (Killilanganj). Singh, Shri S. T. (Inner Manipur). Tan Singh, Shri (Barmer). Singh, Shri Yuvraj Dutta (Shaha- bad). Tantia, Shri Rameshwar (Sikar). Singha, Shri Govinda Kumar (Mid- Thengondar, Shri M. G. (Nagpatti- napore). nam). Singha, Shri Yagnya Narain (Sun- Thevar, Shri V. Vairava (Thanjavur). dergarh). Thirnmaiah, Shri Dodda (Kolar). Sinehvi, Dr. L. M. (Jodhpur). Thomas, Shri A. M. (Ernakulam). Sinha, Shri Banarsi Prasad (Mon- Tiwary, Shri Dwarka Nath (Gopal- ghyr). &anj). Sinha, Shrimati Ramdulari (Patna). Tiwary, Shri Kamal Nath (Bagaha). Sinha, Shri Satya Narayan (Samuti- Tiwary, Shri Ram Sahai (Khajuraho). pur). Sinha, Shrimati Tarkeshwari (Barh). Tripathi, Soo Krishna Deo (Unnao). Sinhasan Singh, Shri (Gorakhpur). Trivedi, Shri Urna Shankar (Mand- saur). Sivappraghassan, Shri K. (Pondi- cherry). Tula Ram, Shri (Ghatampur). Sivasankaran, Shri P. (Sriperumbu- Tyagi, Shri Mahavir (Dehra Dun). dur). Solanki, Shri Parvinsinh Natavarsinh u (Kaira). Uikey, Shri M. G. (Mandla). Sonavane, Shri T. H. (Pandharpur). Soundaram Ramachandran, Shrimati UJaka, Shri Ramachandra (Koraput). T. S. (Dindigul). Urnanath, Shri R. (Pudukkottai). Soy, Shri Hari Charan (Singhbhum). Upadhyaya, Shri Shiva Dutt (Rewa). Srinivasan, Dr. P. (Madras North). Utiya, Shri Buddhu Singh (ShahdoI). Subbaraman, Shri N. M. R. (Madu- rail. v Subramaniam, Shri C. (Pollaw). Subramanyam, Shri Tekur (Bellary). Vaishya, Shri Muldas Bbudardas (Sabarmati). Sumat Prasad, SOO (Muzaffarnapr). Sunder Lal, SOO (SaharanpllI'). yalvi, Shri Laxman Vedu (Nandur- Surendra Pal Singh, Shri (Buland.- bar). shahr). Varma, Shri Manikyalal (Chittor- Surya Prasad, Shri (Bhind). garb). Swamy, Shri M. N. (Dngole). Varma, Shri Ravindra (Thiruvella). Swamy, Shri M. P. (Tenkasi). Veerabasappa, Shri S. (Chltra- durga). Swamy, Shri M. V. (Masulipatnam). Veerappa, Shri Ramachander (Bidar). Swemy, Shri Shivamurthy Siddappa (Koppal). Venkaiah, Shri Kolla (TenaIi). (ix)
Venkatasubbaiah, Shri Pendekanti W (Adoni). Wadiva, Shri N. Y. (Seani). Verma, Shri BalgoYind (Itheri). Wari~r, Shri It. K. (Trichur). Verma, Shri Kunwar Krishna (SuI- Wamik, Shri Balkrishna (Gondia). tanpur). Verma, Shri Suraj Lal (Sitapur). y Vidyalankar, Shri Amar Nath Yadab, Shri Nagendra Prasad (Sita- (Hoshiarpur). marhi). Vijaya Ananda, Shri (Visakhapatnam). Yaday, Shri Ram Harkh (Azamgarh). Vijaya Raje, Shrimati (Cbatra). Yaday, Shri Ram Sewak (Bara "- Banld). Vimla Devi, Shrimati V. (Eluru). YadaYa, Shri Bhishma Prasad (Kesa- Virbhadra Singh, Shri (Mahasu). ria). Yajnik, Shri Indulal Kanaiyalal Vishram Prasad, ·Shri (Lalganj). (Ahmedabad) . Vya., Shri Radhelal (Ujjain). Yaahpal Singh, Shri (Kairana). LOR: SABRA
The Speaker Sardar Hukam Singh
The Depv.tJ'-Speaker Shri S. V. Krishnamoorthy Rao
Panel of Chalrmm Shrimati Renu Chakravartty Shri Surendranath Dwiwdy Shri Thirumala Raa Shri R. K. Khadilkar Dr. Sarojani Mahishi.
Seeretary Shri M. N. Kaul. Barrister-at-Law
(x' GOVERNMENT OF INDIA Members of the Cabinet Prime Minister, Minister of External Aftairs end Minister of Atomic Energy- Shri Jawaharlal Nehru. : Minister of Home Atfairs-Shri Gulzarilal Nanda. Minister of Finance-Shri T. T. Krishnamaclrari. Minister without portfolio-Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri. Minister of Food and Agriculture-Shri Swaran Singh. Minister of Law and Minister of Communications-Shri Asoke K. Sen. Minister of Defence-Shri Y. B. Chavan. Minister of Steel, Mines '" Heavy Engineering-Shri C. SUbramaniam. Minister of Petroleum and Ch-emicals-Shri Humayun Kabir. Minister of Parliamentary Aftairs-Shri Satya Narayan Sinha. Minister of Railways-Shri H. C. Dasappa. Minister of Education-Shri M. C. Chagla. Minister of Labour and Employment-Shri D. Sanjivayya. Minis'ter of RehabilitatiDn--Shri Mahavir Tyagi. Ministers of State Minister of Works and Housing-Shri Mehr Chand Khanna. Minister of International Trade-Shri Manubhai Shah. Minh.""ter Of Induatry-,ShriNityanand Kanungo. Minister of Shipping in the Ministry of Transport-Shri Raj Bahadur. Minister of Community Development and Cooperation-Shri S. K. Dey. Minister of Health-Dr. Sushila Nayar. Minister of State in the Ministrv of Home Aftairs-Shri Jai Sukh Lal Hathi. Minister of State in the Ministry of External Aftairs-Shrimati Lakslmli N. Menon. Minister of Defence Production in the Ministry of Defence-Shri K. Raghuramaiah. Minister of State in the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals-Shri O. V Alagesan. Minister of State iii the Ministry of Food & Agriculture-Dr. Ram Subhag Singh. Minister of State in the Ministry of Food & Agriculture-Shri A. M. Thomas Minister of Supply-Shri R. M. Hajarnavis. Minister of Irrigation and Power-Dr. K. L. Rao. Minister of P1artning-Shri B. R. Bhagat. Depuf)y Ministers Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Education-Dr. M. M. Das. Deputy Minister in ~he Ministry of Railways-Shri Shahnawaz Khan. Deputy Miniater in the Ministry of Railways-Shri S. V. Ramaswamy. Deputy Mindstel" in the Ministry of Transport and Communications-Shrl Ahmed Mohiuddin.
(xi) (xii)
Deputy Minister in the KiDi.&try 01 ~ti Tarkeabwari Sinha. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Rehabilitati.on-Shri. P. S. Naskar. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Community Development and Coope- ration-Shri B. S. Murthy. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Education-Shrimati Soundaram Rama- chandran. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Defence-Shri D. R. Chavan. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Labour and Employment and fOl' Plan- ning-Shri C. R. Pattabhi Raman. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Home Mfairs-Shrimati M. Chandruekhar. Deputy Minister in the Department of Supply-Shri Jaganatha Rao. Deputy JIIinister in the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting-Shri Sham Nath. I Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Health-Dr. D. S. Raju. Deputy Minister in 'the Xinistry 01 External Mfairs-Slui Dinesh Singh. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Law--SbTi BlbuclheD4ra Misra. Deputy Minister in the.. Department of. Communkaticms--Shri Bhapvatt. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Community Development and Co-opera- tion-Shri Shyam Dhar Misra. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Steel, Mines and Heavy Engineering-Shri Prakash Chandra Sethi. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Labour and Employment-Shri Ratania) Kishorilal Malaviya. Deputy Minister in the Ministry of Education-Shri Bhakt Darshan. Deputy Mnister in the Ministrv OIl Home AflairB-Sbri L. N. Mlshra. Parliamentary Secretaries ParliazneJttary Secretary to the MinMer- of Food and Agriculture-Shri ShJDde Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of External Mfairs-Shri D. Ering. Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of External Aflairs-Shri S. C. Jamir. Parliamentary ,Secretary to the Minister of Irrigation and Power-Shri S.·A. Mebdi. Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Steel, Mines and Heavy Engineer- Ing-Shri Dodda Thimmaiah. Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Education-Shri M. R. Krishna. LOIC SABRA DEBATES
2 LOK SABRA Mr. Speaker: The Minister of par· liamentary Mairs rn~y introduce the WednesdAy, May 27, 1984/JyaiBtha 6, Member to the House. . 1886 (Sa.ka) The Mbdster of Parliamentary Af- fairs (Shri Satya Narayan SiDha): Sir, I have great pleasure in The Lok Sabha met at Eleven of the introducing to you and through Clock. you' to the House. Shri Vidya Charan Shukla, who has been [MR. SPEAKER in the Chair 1 returned to Lok Saaha from Mahasa- round constituency of Madhya PrA- STATE OF HEALTH OF PiUME desh in the vacancy caused by hiS MINISIEa earlier election to Lok Sabha having been declared void. The M·nister of Home Mairs (Shri NIUIIIa): '~lr. Speaker, Sir, with a SIni Vidya Charan Shukla (Maha- very tro, bled heart, I have to con- . samund). vey to this House the information about the state of health of the Prime Minister which was just passed on to ORAL ANSWERS TO QUE5TIONS me by the doctors in attendance on the Prime Minister. Suddeuly, at Seenrity to the Minorities 6.20 this morning, he was taken seri- ously iII. His condition is causing + Shri Barisb CllaDlra anxiety. Mathur: rShri P. K. Deo: Mr. Speaker: I would ask the Home MiJ1ister to convey our deep concern I Shri MohsIn: so far as the Prime Minister's health -I. ~ Shri Mahesw&r NaIk: is concerned. We wish him speedy I Shri D. C. Sharma: -recovery. I 8hrl Rameshwar Tanlia, Shri DbaoD: 81nt H. N. Makerjee (Calcutta l Shri BisbaD ChaDde~ Seth: Central. rose- Will the Minister of Home AffaIrs be pleased to 'state: Mr. Speaker: I do not think thl!l"e ought to be anything said just now. (a) the steps taken 01' proposed to be taken by Government to !liv" a ftlll sense of security to the minoritks in the context of recent communal d!s- 11.01 hrs. turbances; MEMBER SWORN (b) the main disturbing as also healthy factors brought out as a re- SBRI VIDYA CBARAN 8JroKLA sult of probe in these disturbances; Mr. Speaker: Secretary may call out the name Qf the Mem:hcr who ha< (C) whether Government have con- come to make and subscribe tl-.I) oath sidered the banning of communal .Dr aftInnation unua1' .he Constitution. parties in this context; and Seaetary: Shri Vidya Charan (d) in what manner clistrict admi· Shukla. nistrathn has been strengthened? Drill Answer, 3 MAY 27,1964 Orlll A-.uers 4 Tbe MiDJIIter of State in the MIDIs- Sbri IIariah Chandra Mathur: try of Home AJrairs (Shri RaW) . Though isolated, opiniens have been (a) to (d). A statement is laid eJq)l eased by certain respected per- on the Table of the House. lPIlJCed sons that the minority commumty in LibrllT1/. See No. LT-2891/64]. lives under the fear aDd shadow of death. May I know w.hether the Home Shri BariIIh ChaDdra Mathur: Thl.' Minister has, after thorough investi- hon. Home Minister will rp("ollect gation, made his own assessment? that at CIne stage in the process of What is the number of min(;rity.com- national integration it was the policy munity people who haVe fled from that communal parties could be Lndia to Pakistan as compared to four banned, but it could not 1:.e done lakhs of persons coming from Pakis- bet"ause of the coming ':!l~ctions. tan out of a minority of about one Mlly I know which of the existin.-: crore there? communal parties and organisations have bt:~r identified "is commun.. l, and what are the diftlculties htanding Shri Rathi: With regard to t!lat in the way of the Government in put- view which was extlressed by a cer- tain section of the people here in this ting then away from t.he politi~:ll scene. House the Home Minister has eate- gori.ca.lly denied that ~here was at all Shri HaW: I have mentioned in the any condition in the COU1\trv where reply tJhat while it is true that com- the minorities are living under the munal feelings were, to , velY gn'at shadow of death. That ~ wrong. In extent, responsible for these commu- fact, :they are secure, and because of nal disturbances, whether banning it- the communal disturb!l1lces. I do not self would stop such disturbances is think any of the minority has had also a matter to be considered. Indi- to go away to Pakistan. viduals may combine, groups of people may combine; it is not necessarv that MIr. Speaker: Shri P. K. Oeo. only a political party can take part in communal disturbantles. The ques- Shri BadnuJduja: May I draw your tion, therefore, has to be considered, attention to certain points aaecthlg and is being considered. the mmori SJari p. It. Deo: Part of my quee- 8hri D. C. 811uma: W. ba.... mil- tion bas not been replied to. lions of ClIJDImitteM. What aaI:ion hili! been taken? Mr. Speaker: Sh1'i Badruciduja. Slut Bac1nuIduja: May I know from .~~: ""riflllT~ the Horne Minister what de6.nite secu- ~f'fi~ iIi'~iinrftit~~ rity there is against the repetition of all these terrible happenings in the ~ ;ron ~~'''iIlT~ country, especially when the minori- ~~ rn ';3";r~~ -mm: ties during these last 17 years, re- ~ 'llf~ q;ff ~ alised to their cost that their lives iii' ;r 3fillfi' it and liberties, their honour and pro- JI'~ f'fiIrT f'fi f~ it~ perties, have not been even protected f1:fur ~ ~ om ~ pi' I by the civil authorities in India? Un- a less and until . . . ~~;;rr;r;:rr~~f'fi ~mit~;f iIc ~ ~nft..,. a I Mr. Speaker: Or.ier, order. Not a speech. lIiI" ~.," : ~11 flrf~ ;r,;JI"l ~'J1'I" 8hri HaW: The Government have ~ 1fT ~ ~~ 1fT I W it taken variOUs measures to inspire con- '!fl~ ~ ~ ~~ fidence about the security of the mino- if'Rl"J rity communities. The Home Minis- ~ afT I III $>'1 I f'{el '" ;t'r "IT '1:);;f'rn;r ter !has more than once announced t!he ~ ~ '11'1" f;;m;r1" ~ afT ~ ~, . detennine.d will of the Governmomt to ~ ~ "ll'm '1'@ ~ I safeguard the person and propertv of minorities at all costs. Dr. Bauea Sea: A few days bad: lIOIIle responsible Ministers of the Shri There D. C. Sbuma: are cer- Govemment of IDd.ia had mentioned. tain papers in India-I think their the name of Jan Sangh, BSS aDd number is very large-which speci- Hindu ~he II1II communal par- in inflaming communal pas- alise ties. Has the Government of JDdja aions. May I know if the Government gone back on that Btatement? bas a list of those papers, aDd If so, bas the Government taken any action Shri Bathi: The question was: ill against any of thO!e papers for set- the present commUll8l disturbeDl:ls ting on fire this communal harmony? which are the parties which haYtI taken part. and which are thought at. 8Ilri HaW: One of the measures being banned. 'Which the Govenunent have taken is to put a check on such news as would Shri H. N. Makerjee: In view of the arouse communal troubles or com- wide circulation a!. certain IIlischie-- munal pa§iOM. There is also a spe- vous books !ike Sbri GoIwalllar'a cial press emergency committee under "Why Hindu Rashtra?" to which att- 1Ibe Infarm.ation and Broadcasting ention was drawn in the House by Miinistry, in which the newspapers ~ some Congress Members, may I know represent,ed, and BIlly action which if Government is takillg any steps to has to be taken is being taken agaiRst ban at least this particular kind of thole PeoPle. pernicious publications? 8hrI D. C. Sharma: I wanted to Shri Hathi: That III bem. Conai- if any action bad been taken 1mow dared. ap,inst any paper so fa:r? Mr. Speaker: ]If that ha. been Shri U. II. TriYfldl: 11M it ... talIlen, he must have told m. Nought to the Rotiae of the DGIDI' '113 (Ai) I.SI)-Z. ~. 7 Oral AnstOers M4Y 27, 1~ Minister that all these riQts in Rour- JEela and other industrial centres had taken pIaee entirely on account or the speeclhes made by the communists all Shri Bari Viliba Kamath: It was along and that they had nothing tn do not 80 loDg. with- COIIlmUIIlIliam Shrt 1IatbJ: I have 1uI'gotte:n the first pm .n ~~ ~. : ;;n;r SJariDNI.U Baau Chabavartt)': III it a 'tlIl. tact that th.e!oe was one common pat- ~ ~ fit; "ITroI" ~~ ifllT t if U!rD wbjch was follOWed In the l'iotB ~-~ it ~ wm:..rr ~ in West Beogal as well as in Rour- ~ lI'iT llt'f f.t;lrr ~ fit; ~ Wt ~Ia ~ ~ )IlIrts in Orissa and r.mn -7 I POW whether- the Government ~ ir~prit ~ ~ ~li ~ Qlt acq m II.as tried! to find CNt what was behind 'I'<: ~ srtm: t '3"Wf ~ m'{ fifor it and whether people like Shri Gol- ~ ~ffl ~ F;m ~ iI'f~«4iT .) waIkar had anything to do with it and & a.lao whether the BBS had a direct ~-~t ~~~..n hand in it? ~ taken up by the Kinislry tor imple- ;rt ~"T m1rfoll'T r~T Q«(1 f ?tf mentation. t~~~~;rr~1 Dr. P. S. Dellhmakh: Since there » '" "0 ,"0 ~ : It ;;n0!~1 ~1T joint responsibility in the country and the Minister is a tu1I-fiedged • f'" -s:;r ~ ~ if; qr.{- mftrlft "') member et the Cabinet, has he re- ~ m~ ~ mO!flf6T .'f; 'n.{- commended simrlar treatment ot tlae ~ ;fiffl[1f 'f;1 f"'<:Iit ~ ~ committees in other departmen'taT '!iT ~i1 ir1'fT I ShrI M. C. Cha&1a: There is joint responsibility in the country and I have the honour and privilege to be '" ~. 11\'0 ;nrt\'IT: ~ firm;f ~ a member ot the Cabinet. But I do OflTTlI'T ~ ~f.t;;r ... rvT ~q' T ",T not think it is part of the joint res- ~ Shrl Dem Baraa: In view of the (b) to (e). Do not arise. fact that this Gauhati Refinery has been experiencing diftlcu1ties and Scleu.tJfic Equipment &lid Machiael'J' breakdowns-the kerosene unit broke + down and there was a series of break- (Shrl Yashpal Stach: downs-may I know whether the eco- I Slut S. C. Samanu: nomics of production are being taken ShrI M. L. Dwive4li: into account when the Gov,rnment .S'l Shrlmatt San&rl N .....: are discussing the question of ex- Slut DIIJI: panding the existing capacity of the reftnery? Will the Minister of· UaeatiGll t. pleased to alate: SIut~: All these will be kept in mind and .... e will try to re- (a) ....hether hi. attention has been duce the coo .. much .. possible. drawn to the A1.Idl.t Report on the A~ts Ur the COWlcU d Sc:lentic tft~~:~~~ arid industrial !tesearchfOr 1__ wherein iliftabees of tcletttiBe equip- omrFt .... _m~ bought for 'the ment and ~o ri'atiilnallaborato"ries 'ioemal!iinV litI.,. -.0 __ :IPR qtir .mr used for 13 years have wen tpOinte4 ;jt;rnr~ta1~tt1l't'n'~t 1 GIlt; ~ ~ ~ ~ ",""pr:t I ~ (b) If .0, the reasons fOr this itate ~~~ft m'lft~~w I of af!airI; and ~ ~ ~~, (c) whether strict instructions .. : \r.R-ift ~~I have been 'iIIIIImIl SO that 'SUch mistakes are not repeated? -tt '110" 1f1'M1' : ~ ~ -.. 'De '...... '" ...... (Shd '~ ~ if lfIff ~ 'ITIfr ~ m M. C. Chacla): (a) Yes. Sir. The ~ 4f1'f.1; ... ii Jifta(l" ~ fit Audit teport mentiODll only one ins- mt tance of some eqUipm.ent purchased, aT l{ !!it iaI~(e6"tft' ~:a~ ~ which have remained unused for 13 W~itr~~IfiT....m,"1 Yean. .~ cmr it ~ ~ PI" fir; ~ ~ ~~~:,.,,~~ The Deputy IIiIIw. .. tile ...... try of H_ AJrairJI (Shri L. N. t"~~mm~prt? 1IDabra): (a) to (c). The scheme baa not been finalised yet. ~qo ~o """'" : ~ ~ ~ SJui S. C. s-.tta: May I know qt t I IR1THI'l'f;i1fur ~ ~ ~ qT'f ~ Whether the State Governments haft ~ 'liT :;m1I' ~ I been asked to muster a strong police' force for the protection of th_ Shrt Prl7a Gapta: The hoa Edu- plants? cation stated a prior KIniIter has on SJui L. N. 1UIhra: The State Goy- oceuion that committee. are not 1188- emmenta have been, asked to. give- ful, rather they retard the amooth their comment. on the scheme of a working of the Miniltries, and there- Central Security Force. A number of fore the committees are being dis- State Governments have giYen their .alved. But he has stated just now views. We are awaiting replies from that a high-power committee is going lIome of the State Governments. 10 be set up for gOing into the work- ing of CSIR. May I know whether Sbrl 8. C. SalDaata: Before settina it is just to change the personnel of up these forces, may I know whether the committee that he hal di390lved the State Governments have given and reconstituted the committees? their consent to it! Shri M. C. ChaCIa: No, Sir. Un- Shri L. N. lIIJahra: The whole 1l1lel- der the csm. Rules a reviewing com- tion was discussed in the Chief mittee must -be appointed from time Ministers' conference last Maroh and to time consisting of people in India they have agreed that there was need and outside so that they can make an for such a force on the lines of the objective appraisal of how far CSIR Railway Protection Force. So, they a functioning eftIciently and success- have agreed to the proposal in prin- fully. The reviewing committee has ciple. been appointed in accordance with the rules. It is not an innovation Dr. L. M. Sina"hvi: May I know which I have started. whether it is a fact that the State Governments have resisted this idea? Guru fOr NatloaaJ. Plaat. If so, what is their argument for re- sisting this idea and what t. the xr- + action o! the Government or India to Shri S. C Samaata: such resistance by State Goyern- ·6. { Shri Sub~ Hauda: ments! Shri P. C. Bo~: Shri L. N. Mishra.: The Chid Will the Minister of Home Affain Minister. who met in a conference be pleased to refer to the reply giyen had agreed in principle to have this to Starred Question No. 10511 on the kind of force. There is no question 15th April, 19M and state: of resistance from the State Govern- ments. There are some points of de- (a) whether the proposal to set up tail which are being worked out. Central security forces for protection and guarding of national plants has Shri TricUb K1Imar Chaudh1lri; been finalised; May I know whether it is II. fact that (b) if 10, when tha will be let up; the Hindu.tan Steel Limited has a and security force of its own, as al.'!lo some other national plants. and those (c) what ia the total eatimated cost security forces are employed or en- for setting up thia force and the gaged b;!" the plants concerned or number of people to be recrulted for there is lome kind of liaison with the thia p~' CeutraJ. Gol'ernment? 21 Oral Answers JYAlSTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) OrA! Amwer. u· 111ft L. N. 1IIIIara: :Every .teel be broll,ht under a Central lepla-- plant and big industrial plant h .. ,ot tion? is. own security force, which is more or Ie.. on the watch and ward lines. Shrl I •. N. MIIIlra: No, we are not Now we want to have a more orp- conCeTDed with that question at this _sed and more disciplined force and atace. So far .. the Central Security ..t i. why we are havinl this farce. Force is concerned, that has to be· kept away from the purview of the Slui P. Vemw-ltbalU: Kay I Trade UnionB Act. The other quea-- IlllOw whetheT there will be aeparate And independent recruitment for tion of bringing all the national plants uI:der a Central legislation does not thele forcel or whether the respec- .r~.e. tin State Governments will lend their leI'Yices of their police ofllcen? '"P"~~:II'IIT~ ilari L. N. 1IIIIuR: It will be an IffiI' qr!fr er,anised independent body. Whe- ~ .1Ifr.r iI' ~ ~ fi!; ,«'{r" theT the recruitment has to be done ~ rom iI' ~ ~AfTIfT ~ (Ti1'« lIy the State Governmen.t or the Cen- .nrort ~ '"I'm q 'l'!ft t ? ~. tral Gol'ernment is a question yet to be decided. ~iI'~IIiT~~~? Slui )[aplIr imp: What step8, if ,""o;no ~ : ~ Wlmr· any, will be taken to immUDise and im safecuard the proposed aecurity force iI(\' t I from the contamination of the trade union cliques such as inflict the cur- Petro-C~l rent arrangement in our national .lDdutriell plants! + Shri L. N. MJ8hrR: There is a pro- Slui D. C. Sharma: posal to keep them away from the f Shrl Onkar Lal llerwa: purview of the Trade Unions Act. .,. ~ Shri Gokaran Pnaad: There is also a proposal to amend tne SIui P. C. BorOOllh: Trade Unions Act. l Shri Maheswar Naik: Shrimatl Sa1'itri Nqam: Kay I Will the Minister of Petroleum. aJUt know whether Government are aware Chemicab be pleased to state: of the fact that in the Bhilai .te~l plant th:! security forces a.me into (a) whether the report of the work- oon1Iict with the State Government ing group on' the development of and, if so, may I know whether Gov- petro-chemical industries has been ernment have. tried to co-ordinate considered; these for.ces with the State police authoriti~s and give them aome right to function dective!y? . (b) if 10, the recommendations that have ·been accepted; and Shri L. N. Mf.Ihra:I am not aware of this particular inCident, but there (c) the steps taken to implement ill, of course, a proposal for such co- the same? ordination. Shri S. M. Buerjee: If I heard The Minister of State In the dIInis- the hon. Minister correctly he hf:Ated try of Petrole1llD and Chemlcals (8hr1 that tbe Trade Unions Act is likely A.Jac-): ShtI D. C. SIwma: May I Imo1r mm. I ...... : kaaiw when this report was submitted and whether this report WBB_1 discu.ed how long the Government will take by the Economic Committee of the to '8l'rlve at a decision? Cabinet and, it BO, what i& -ita reac- tion to it? SJiri AlaIfaD: !he report wu dbmitted OHly recently and we have lftarI ~: Not yet; it will be n6t takeh my unauly long time aver ~ it. We may take some inOte tim'e. .Shr:l A.P. Jain: Are any of the lChemes included in the Four'th Plail 1Jhrl I). C. 3hiUiIDa: May I know at beinI anticipated and Preli:tnina17 what level this report is being consi- action being taken and, it BO, em dered_t a departmental level or what petro-chemical industry? :some extra-depar1mental people are also associated with the consideration Shrl ~: As far as the BOm- of this report? bay group ~f industties is concei'eDii, several industries have been either Sbri AJapan: I do not know what licensed or apptOVed. One in Bom- the hon. Member means by extra- bay, one in Barauni ahd another in departmental level. The matter was Assam have already been: approved. discussed by the production committee of Secretaries fairly well Now it Shrl lIecIa: In view of the new will be discussed by the Economic dliiiensionltiven to the petro-chemical - Committee of the Cabinet and then industry by Mr. Khrushchev in his the decision will be taken. recent statement by saying that they ate 1llMiful and helptul tor agricu1- turall production, may I know whether "" ~ ""'" i"ro : it ;;n;r;rr the conl!ideration of this report would 'ifrrrr fil; ~ ~ ~ it ~ be expedited? ~~ tfrt1r1fT ~ ~ ~ SJui AJiageaq: I have already said· it illl>i't that they are considering it. ~ 'iff 'IT ? Mr. Speakl!l": Are any foreigners ou C_esdOllll .. Iraq and KuwaB inCluded in that? 8hri A...... : No, Sir. -8. Sbrt I. B. S. BIst: Will the Minister a1 Petroleum and Chemleal8 Mr. Speaker: How many members be plelllled to state: were there? (e) wtIlether the efforts made by Shrl Alacesan: Ten members. Gov WIlveraity course. What we empaa- quite certain whether we will be aljle IiEed was that the univenities ahOU'ld to achieve the tarcet or not; but, I DOt be called upon to -do the work think, the majority of the State. will wtUch the schools ahould really do be able to achieve that target. and the emphasis should be placed more on the content of education ra- ""~ q1'iIf : it ~ ~ ther than on iliB duration. "nlere waa a pneral acceptance that gradually !f"'lI'IITfftT~ .~it 1his pre-university course .hou1d be mmt ~ • ~ fiJ!;m: tim Jf1IT done away with and the 12-:pear ~.IIft~m~lI'IIT~~~ oom-ae will be accepted. But tiboat would take aome time. "nle Cmu. fit;;r fiR -u;;qff it ~ ~ ~ ~ t has agreed to help the State. in ~fit;;r fit;;r ~ it lfir ;r@' 'if<'!" W t ? achieving this ultimate objectiYe. Slui M. C. Cha&"1a: Then was DOt !lui lIIatlliah: May I knaw whether very much of a discu8ai.on on the the Education Ministers a,reed to the three-language formul.. at the Edu- eatabliahment of the All-India lDdu- cation Ministers' Conference. cation Service as also to the establiah- Shrimati Suitri Nipm: Just now lIlent of the Secondary Education the hon. Minister hal aaid that Statee Granta Commission? will be given financial help by the Centre for starting the 12-year course. Shri 111. C. Cha.-1a: With regard to What will be the percentage of the the first, there is a general agreement grant which will be given to the in principle on the establiahment of various States for this? the All-India Education Service. What Shrl M. C. Chalrla: The whole qUell- we are working out now is what tion of the financial relations between posts from this service the various the Centre and the States, so far al States will accept. With regard to education is concerned, is being the Secondary Education Commission, worked out. The present pattern hal it is a question of the Constitution. not worked satisfactorily and all the The matter has been referred to the State Education Minister8 agreed that Law Ministry and we are awaiting a new-pattern should be evolved their decision. Also, we are await- which will bring about better remIt&. ing the decision of the Sapru Com- mittee which is expected any moment. 11ft ~smR: 'fIIT~;mr;tT Shrl P. Venkatasultltalah: May I ;r;ri '1ft ~ ~~ it '1fT ~ vfT f.!; '4m know whether any decision has been lIte;tT~~'IQG ~~ ~~;;r) taken to impart compulsory primary education to children of the age group lite ;fi :mIT ~ ~ '!ifIm ~ ~ 8 to 11 in various parts of the coun- mIT ~ ~ lIi! '4m lite i!iT 'JtI1 m try; it that is so, when will the • ~ 'flIT 'R ~ oqr ? target be fulfilled and what will iIW '!iTt mm- be the financial assistance that will be given by the Central Government 11ft '0 1I)io ~: lfir;mr" t to the various State Governments? f.!;'4mm~~r(~~ ~ if;T ~ ~ ~ Shri M. C. Cha,1a: Unfortunately. oqr f.!; lite lIiT there are certain States which are f.rlI1r f.vmr ~ ~ lite ~ t2?;.~ Tery backward; others are forging ;r;T ~ I ahead. The tatget we had placed before us was that by the end of the SIlrimati 4kkam_ Dm: May I Fourth Five-Year Plan every .choo!- know whether the training of tea- aoing child between 6 aOO 11 yean! chers, .cience education, advanced mould be in the .clIool t am not r-.rch and dtlft'lopment of ....omm·. education were some at the IJUbjects ject; it is not a cOtraI III1bjec:t. But recommended by tile State Ministerl we said that the Centre will help tile to the Centre; if so, may I know the States if they will improYetM qua- action taken by the Government on lity of education. those recommendations? wft" ~ fum 1jifi ;;flo 8bri M. C. Claa&'1a: It is too early mo.n: to take action. The Education Minis- ;!r ~ om ~ ~ if iIm'I'11n 'IT f~ ters' Conference was held only last 3f~~~~~QU~iir month and the subjects that the hon. Member has mentioned are subjects ~ lIiT ~ ~ -wbether be bas made a~ complaint Vigilance CommissiOn is starved a •• to that -effect? is not given sta!! ... Shri JIaihi: So far as the bodiee Shri Natia Pal: He eats his meals aU .outside Parliament, namely, the right. 1 did not mean the stat! physi- Sadachar Samities referred to by the cally. 1 was referring to resoU1'Cell. hon. Member are concerned, they -are non-official bodies and their main Mr. Speaker: The bon. M.iniIIter function is to create an atmospbere, also means the same thine: Which the to cultivate public opinion and also to hon. Member means. _hear complaints and grievances of the people and then to approach the Shri Hathi: He has all the staft aad Vigilance Commission itself. It is all the facilities and everything else, not that the Sadachar Committee 18 and he has been receiving complaints, doing anything to deprive the powers and he has been investigating into and jurisdiction of the Central Vigil- them and he has been giving advice ance Commission. What they have and doing all the functions. to do is to take complaints and to cultivate public opinion. If the 11ft' f'i1' ~ qpn'Q' : ill.. m complaints are received, they app- ~ ~ ~l ;;fr W~T:;rr~ im" roach the administrative authorities it and the Central Vigilance Commis- §'-rr ~, "e..n- ~(I' rn ~ f""~ 111' 'flIT sion and then the Central Vigilance (c) if so, the nature thereof? (a) whether it is a fact that there was an enormous increase of Muslim The Minister of Edueatiou (Shri M. population in the ·border State. of C. Chagla): (a) to (c). The University India during the period fJ:om 11151 te Grants Commission has appointed a 1961; Committee to prepare a saheme for the estab1ishment of a Health Service (b) if so, the percentage of the n.e for staff and students in Universities and the reasons therefor; and and Colleges. The Cummittee will commence its work in JULe, 1964. (c) the genera"} rise of Muslim population in lndia during the .aid Increase in Muslim PopaIaUon in period and its percentage? . Border States The Minister 01 state in the Minta- r Shri Ram Barkh Yad&Y: try 01 Rome Affairs (Shri RathO: (a) *12. ~ Shri Baswant: Yes; there has 'been a marked inere_ l Shri S. N. Chaturvedi: in some of the border States. Will the Minister of Rome Mairs (b) A statement is laid on -a.e !be pleased to state: Table of the House. STATBMBNT • Total P.pulation of Muslims in India 1951 1961 P~rcentall" 35>414,284 46,939,357 Increase 25'61 Assam 1,995,936 2,765.509 38'56 Bihar 4,373,360 5,785,631 32'29 Gujarat 1>451,214 '. 1,745,103 20'25. Punjab. 284,993 393,314 38'01 Rajasthan 991,246 1,314,613 32'62 West Bengal 5,II8,269 6,985,287 36'48 Tripura 136,940 230,002 67'96 Manipur 37,[97 48,5 88 30'62 The reasons for increase is partly (a) whether he has had any corree- the inftux from Pakistan and partly pondence with his counter-Part ia the natural growth and migration Pakistan as regards the next series III from other parts of India. meetings to be held between him and (c) The rise is from 35,414,284 to the Pakistan Home Minister at Rawal- 46,939,357, i.e. 25: 61 per cent. pindi; and (b) whether the dates for the mee.. CODference 01 Rome MiniSteft of ing and its agenda have been finally India ud Paldstan fixed? rShri Tridib Kumar The Minister 01 Home Affails ·lS. ~ Chaudhuri: (ShrlNanda): (a) and (b). The~ l Shrl Rem Barna: has been no correspondence between Will the Minister 01 Home Mairs the Home l\finisters of Indili and be pleased to state: Pakistan on the subject of the neG 113 (Ai) LSD--3. 39 Written AfI81DerB MAY 2'1, 1964 W7'ittm Answers 40- meeting of the Home Ministers as en- tiable in ter:Jlls of gazetted and non-· Yisa&'ed in flle " joint communique gazetted o1Iili.als Of the Central GOY- iuued at the conclusion of the IIrst emment. Eries of meetings between the two Home Ministers fr6in April 7 to April (b) 1~7 complaints, which appeared' 11, 1864. to be suitable for examination, are- under investigation throuih the- The matter ia under. consideration authorities concerned. through diplomatic channels and no ute or venue of the meeting haa yet 1teen fixed. CcmmtPaI met. JIaclras anti Bal4la JldDeriflll -16. -8Iui Barish CbaDcIra MaUlar:- Will the :Minister of Bome Alrain be -1~ J Shri P. C. Borooah: pleased to state: .,.. L Sbri P. Veukatasubbalah: (a) the Government's programme- Will the Minister of Petroleum IIDII for rena1lllitation- Of the victims of' Chemicals be pleased to state: communal riots in India; and (a) whether a decision on the olfers for collaboration In the construction (b) what has ,been done BO far in' of the Madras and Haldia rellneries this matter byl-('i) Government, and .-have been put off; if BO, for how long; (ii) private agencies? and ., (b) the reasons therefor? The MiDister of State in the MIDIs- try of Bome Alralrs (Shri BaW): The MiDister of state in the MIDIs- (a) and (br. A Statement is laid on' try of Petroleum and Chemicals (Sbrl the Table of the House. Alage!IaD): (a) No, Sir. The pro- posals received from various parties STATEMENT are still under examination. (b) Does not arise. Broadly, Government's programme for the rehabilitation of victims Df Complaints Received by VigDance communal riots in India places special COIIIDlIIsIoner emphasis on the speooy restoration of their gense of security' and confidence -15. Shri GuIshaD: Will the Minis- so that the displaced persons could' ter of Bome AfraInI be pleased to return to their nouses. Rehabilita- Gte: tion bene1its are extended in the form Of grants and loans for reconstruction (a) the total number of complaints . of dwellings, 1U\d for purchase of' registered with the Vigilance Com- means of cultivation which inight· missioner up to the 31st April, 1964 have been destroyed and for starting against Gazetted and Non-Gazetted trades and occupations which might Government ofll.cials in connection have been disrupted. These measures' with corruption; and are being taken by the State Gov- ernments concerned. We extend (b) how many have been investi- help and assistance, wherever neces- gated so far and action taken against sary. them? The ~r of State in the MInis- We have noted that some private try Of Heme Atrabs (Sbri BaW): agencies have also organised relief (a) 302; 71 against Gazetted officers measures in this regard such as rais- and 103 against Non-Gazetted ofl\cers. ing of funds, and distribution of fOOll' 4!'he remaining 128 being unclassi- and clotheT to rt6t" ·al!ected victims. 4 1 Written Answers JYAlSTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) Written AnStDe1'a 42 LImited CompetiUre IA.S. Ex8iniDation r Shri Bari Vishnu Kamath: "17 J Shrl N~ R. Laskar: Shdi P. C. Borooah: . "l Shri Maheshwar Naik: ·19. Shri Prakash Vir'Shastri: Sbri Bakam ChaDd Will the Minister of Bome A#afrII 1 Kachhavaiya: be pleased to state: Will' the Minister of Bome A1falrs (a) whether it is a fact that the .cheme for holding limited competi- be pleased to state: tive examination for I.A.S. has been (a) the number of Pakistani inftl- revived; and trators evicted from Assam, Tripura ana West Bengal since 1st January, (b) if so, the reaction and response 19M; of the State Governments in this re- gard? (b) whether any action has been taken against those who' harboured The Deputy Mbai!lter in the MlDJs- them; and try of Bome- Mairs. (Shri L. N. (c) if not, the reasons therefor? 1Dshra): (a) and (b). The matter has been taken up again with the The Minister of state in the Mlnis- State Governments and their reactions try of Bome Mairs (Sbri Bathl): are awaited. (a) During the period from January to March, 1964, 8,430 Pakistani in- filtrators were evicted from Assam and 46 from Tripura. Information in Shri D. C. Sharma: respect of West Bengal is awaited *18 { Shri Sidheshwar Prasad: from the State Goyernment. . Shri P. R. Chakraverti: Shrimati Savltri Nigam: (b) and (c). The information is being collected and will be laid on Will 'the- Minister of Education be the Tabfe' Of the House as soon as it ·pleased to state: is available. (a~ whether teachers from all Pakistani IdItratiOB in RajasthlLll over' the country have appealed for better conditions of service, uniform Shri Barish Chandra pattern of Secondary education and r Mathur: the esf'abnshment of a Secondary .ZO. J S~ p. C. Borooah: Education Grants Commiss!!ln; and Shri P. L. Barupal: Shri Yashpal SiDg:h: l Shri Pr1iTap Singh: (-b) if so, the action taken or prO- pOsed to be taken in the matter? Will the Minister of- Bome AJraln be pleased to state: The MinIster Of Education (Shri M. C. Chagla): (a) Teachers and (a) whether Government have Teachers' Association.· from many taken a full assessment ot Pakistani parts of the country have sent memo- ilrfiltrators in Rajasthan; Panda covering inter a~ these topics. (b) whether Rajasthan Government (b) The demands have Deen noted have made any proposals in this :on- and are under consideration, as far nection; and as the Education Miind.stry's jurisdic- tion is concerned. Most of them 'll'e (e) if so, the nature of the pro- within "the purview of the State Gov- posals and Goverrurient's' reaction in ernments. the matter? .I'l-.J .6. ____ ~. --- .• 43 Written AnsweTB MAY 27, 1964 Written Allswers 44 The MlnISfer 01 State Is tile MJDiB.. istry of Finance, N eilr try of Home Affairs (Shrl Bathi): Delhi-Member. (a) According to the report from the State Government, there has been (B) Terms of Reference: some infiltration of Pakistani Mus- lims in Rajasthan. An assessment of The Working Group shall examine the actual number is, however, tieing IIl1d report upon- made. (I) the manner of determination (b) and (c). The State Govern- of the ex-refinery prices at ment have made some proposals for refined petroleum products, • modification oL tnt!- procedure for including bitumen Pl'Odw:ecl deportation of Pakistani nationals. 'by the refineries; This matter is under consideration. (ii) the manner of determination Oil Price Enquiry Committee of landed prices in respect of similar products which rShri N. R. Laskar: may be imported; Skimati Savitri Nigam: (iii) determination Qf marketing Shri P. C. Borooah: I and distribution charges of -In. ~ Shrimati JyotsDa ChaD4a: products mentioned in (i) & Shri Rameshwar Tantia: I . (ii) above; I Shri BI!lhaDtlbander Seth: l Shrl Dhaon: . (iv) the determination of ceiling selling prices in respect of Will the Minister of Petroleum aDd lube oils, greases and Chemicals be pleased to state: specialities. (a) whether the proposal to set The Working Group may also up the Second Oil Price Enquiry consider the possibility of linking Committee has been finalised; and prices with the physical supply areas (b) if so, the composition of the for the products of individual re- Committee and its terms of fineries, and consider the possibility reference? of uniform or pooled prices for the whole of the country or in difterent 'l'he Minister of State in the MIn- zones which may be created for the istry of Petroleum &Dd Chemieals purpose. It is possible that physical (Shri Alagesan): (a) Yes, Sir. A supply areas may differ for the Working Group on Oil Prices hal difterent products from the same been set up. refinery. (b) A statement is laid on the . LC.S. OIIlcers Table of the House. STATEMENT 1. Dr. L. M. Singhvi: Will tihe MIn- The ComPQSition and terms of ister of Home Affairs be pleased to reference of the Working Group on state: Oil Prices are as follows:- (a) the total number of .officers (A) Composition: belonging to the I.C.S. in service and on pension; and (1) Shri J. N. Talukdar. 3, Albert Road, Calcutta-l6-- (b) how many departmental in- Chairman. quiries were held during the last ten years ageinst I.C.S. Officers and on (2) Shri S. S. Shiralkar, Joint what charges and with what resulta? Secretary, Ministry of Fin- ance, New Delhi-Member The Deputy Minister in the Mia- (3) Shri N. Krishnan, Chief istry of Home Affairs (Shrl L. 1(. Cost Accounts Officer, Min- Mishra): (a) and (b). The informa- 45 WNten AnsWeTB JYAlSTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) Written AnsweTs 46 tion is being collected and will be 'fl:fr fmn ~) ~ iRIlit "') ry laid on tlte Table of the House. Ii'i;' f'l ~.norlll\ .m:t ('I» 'flfT fu=<;r) ~ 'f1t ~ { flft ~~ ~ : ~ mfcr it w arrcr 'f1t fll"ftTf~ ~. 11ft to ~o ~ : 'f1t t fli" f~) iIi~) iii ~~lf it ~~ ~""~ ~ .qf~ f'f.1:rr ~ f.f; 't~-m J{~r ~;rnriI" 'fl:fr 'f1t 'l'ttT flwrf"iIl'T it 1l~'iiT~, ~f!ifcr m ~ ~f'l>: . iii srfcr f~or iir 'ifT'f 13"<'llJ ~ ; m ~ ~ ('I» iI<'I" i qfcm- (V) lffi: ~, a-~i ~ it ~ iIT\'r '1» '1» ;;rr.r m) m crrnneno 'lfT~it'fl:fr~~tirt ? ~)...=t ~, 13"~ (;r) lffi: aT iIfro 'flfT CoordiDation of Physical EdacaUOD, ~ ? BeereatiOD aDd Yonth Welfare ~~~ ~ ~~ ( flft 4. Shri N. R. Laskar: Will the' Minister of Education be pleased to ~) : ("') ~~ ~-'f'{ ~ if state:" ~ ~- f.r:~ ~ f.Ar~ \. "') (a) whether Government have If>{ ~) t I considered the recommendations made by the Kunzru Committee for bring- (~) m (;r).~~~'f'{ "~ ing about coordination in various schemes of physical education, recrea- ~cr" ~ ~ \);;rr ~ ~'I> '«f ",). tion and youth welfare in the " 1Ii, 'I t ... V...=t filt;rr t I 13"~ '«f it ~ country; and ~ 'f1t ~ f.f; ;;rA ~ iir t rn (b) if so, the steps taken to im- f\;rit ~ ~T "') \iI"I1I" mf.f; ~ plement these recommendations in fif'Ii 'lIro1ft ~ ~ ~, ~ ~Il various States? ~ it l{,~ ~ f~ ~'" Nfl1lTa-m The Deputy Miaister m the Min- f.rlL'Rf Wrr ;;n The Deput,' MbIJster ill the JIIID- The Mmister of State in the IIDI- Istry of Education (SJari Bbaltt istry of Petroleum ud ChemicIi.J. Darsban): (a) to (c). The informa- (Shri A1a..-n): (a) It has been tion is being col~ected and wi!ll be accepted in principle that a fertiliser laid on the table of the House. factory may be set up at Durgapur in West Bengal subject to detailed Science PolicJ C~ examination of the technical feature. 8hri Subodh 1IaDsda: of the scheme. i., 8hri S. C. SaDwlta: f (b) Does not arise. l 8hri B. 1[. Das: Will the Minister of Education be (c) At present land and necessary facilities- will not be available at pl~ to state: Haldia for some time for a fertiliser (a) whether it is a fact that the plant. HaIdia will be considered at a Association of Scientific Workers later stage when the refinery is being of India has urged upon Government set up and ancillary development to form a Science Policy Commis- has taken place. .ron to ensure oo-ordination between different scientifu: agencies and for effective utilisation' of materiai and man-power resources; and 9 f Shri Vishwa Nath Pandey: (b) if so, Government's reaction . 1 Shrimati Savitri NIpm: thereto? Will the Minister of Petroleam. and Chemicals be pleaSed to state: The Deputy Mmlster m the MIn- istry 01 Education (Dr. M. M. DBS) : (a) whether it is a fact that Dr. (a) Yes, Sir. This is one of the sug- Harris B. Stevart, Chief Scientist of gestions contained in the publication the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Surve,. "S=e observations on Scientific Ship "Power" emphasised the 1Wai1- Policy Resolution and its implemen- ability Of minerals and chemical. tation" issued by the ~ation of from the Indian Ocean, i.e., from olr Scientific Workers of India. shore of Andamans; and (b) The auggestk)n is being exa- (b) if so, the reaction ot Govern- ..tned. ment thereto? 'l'he MinUter 01 State ill the Min- The details of the amount oj 'istrJ' 01 Petroleum aDd Chemicals: assistance to be given to each Sta. (Shrl AlagesaD): (a) According to a are under ftnalisaticn. report in the- Indian Express dated "the 28th April, 1964, Dr. Harris B. Arms Factories Dear Kanpu -Stewart, Jr. Chief Scientist of the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey Ship Sbrimati Saritri Nipm: "Pioneer" emphasised the possibility 11 ~ Shri Vishwa Nath Pu.ey: -of economic reco..-.-y of minerals • Shri M. L. Dwi..-e4l: and chemicals from the Indian LShri Bade: <>cean. Will the Minister of Home AJraln (b) Government are aware of the be Pleased to state: -possibility of exploitation of oil (a) the details of the two anna >deposits in the shelf areas of seas in factories found near Kanpur; and -which the water depth is small. At' -present, it is not considered feasible (b) if so, whether there was ~ 10 exploit, economically, oil depOsits foreign help in setting up these illelal 1Iocated in deeper .portions of the factories? .-. The MinIster 01 state In ihe MIa- lstry of Home Mairs (Sbri BaW): «Jeairal Aid for SMODCIary Schoo18 (a) and (b). An illicit arms factory was unearthed in village BilIaon, u J Shrimati Savitri Nipm: district Banda on 30-S-111M. OM .'\. Shri Vishwa Nath Pulley: SBBL. '12 bore gun, four countrY Will the Mnister of EdueaUOII be made .12 bore pistols, six unfinishe4 pistols together with some parts and pleased to state: tools were seized. Three persom, who (a) whether it i. a fact that Gov- were at work there, were, arreste4 oernment have offered to the State under section 25 of Arms Act, 1858. -Governments assilltance on hundred per cent grant basill for certain Another miniature illicit arms -selected schem. for Secondary factory was discovered in village 'Schools during tlte rest of the Third Sikandra, district Kanpl1l' on 8-4-1966 "PJ.an period; and one finished coun-try-made .IJ bore pistol together with a large (b) if so, the total amount of amount of tools and ~essories wu -assistance given or offered for the recovered. Three persons, who were 'States; and found in the house, -were tliken Into (c) the nature of selected achemes custody under section 25 of arms Act, -tor the secondary RchoO'ls for which 1959. Another person surrendered lD grants have been offered? court on 10..... 1964. '1'he MlDJster 01 Ed1leaUon (Sbri . Investigations are oontinuing. So, .. C. ClIa&'la): (a) to (c). Yes, it is far, nothing has come to light to proposed to give 100% grant to the show that the factories were .at lIP States for the implementation of the with any foreign help. 1011owing schemes:- (1) Strengtheninl of Science ~ qiwft' I(ft ;jfi+f m!lIit Laboratories. t~. 11ft ~ snm: : (~r), 1:!R ~1"1ffi \l"i ("".) 'fi"T Three-Year Post-Graduate Courses ~ if'fi"fmlf'f ~i, ir cp~T q~ 14. Shrt p. C. Boreoah: Will the ~!I' 'fi"Tli~ 'fi"R ~ '-~ ~ ? Minister of Education be pleased to. state: fmn ~ (~I!o ~o ~"") (a) whether the University Grants ('Ii) ~1 I fmn t:forl<'iil" it ~~jr ;il"f Commission has recommended three- year post-gradbate courses in subjects tlfllf (if) ~ (f'f;~;:r l1'0fl<'il<;i; ~nc; (b) it so,. Government's decision on tftdt OO~ f;;fu it ~~ ~ ~: f~ this proposjll? . ~ 5Wfnr'li ~flrf Aaistant Commissioners of Schedul- (b) Does not arise. eel Castes and" Scheduleel Tribes Cochin Refinery 13. Shri Bam Sewak Yadav: Will 15. Shri P. C. Borooah: Will the- the Minister of Home AJbirs be Minister of Petroleum and Chemicals pleased to state: be pleased to state: (a) whether it has been deeided to (a) the progress made in the sett- open six new offices of Assistant ing up of the Cochin Refinery; and Commissioners ot Seheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes; and (b) the steps being taken. to pre- pare a scheme tor setting up a com- (b) it so, the estimated annual ex- plex of petro-chemical industries penditure on the new offices an.i why around this refinery? i~ has been considered necessary to open these d~g emergency? The Minister of state in the Min- istry of Petroleum alld Chemicals The Deputy Minister in the MiAistry (Soo Alagesan): (a) Work for ac- ef Home Affairs (Ibri L. N. Mishra): quisition of land is proceeding sati.!- (a) Yell. factorily and the vacant possession of (b) The total estimated expenditure the whole site is likely to be obtain- en these new offices will be' obout ed by end of May, 1964. Work on site ~. 2'10 lakhs per annwn. This will preparation and access roads is in 1te met trom savings from the exist- progress. Contract fOr construction me allocations. ot houses with the architects and town planners is under consideration. Though the 'deeiJ>ion to have these Discussions are also in progress with. _ posts has been taken recently, the Cochin Port authorities in re- &he question ot re-organisation or the gard to pOrt facilities. ~tten Al'IBwers JYAISTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) Written Al'IBWers 54-, (b) At present there are no plans Under the orders there is to be no·· for establishing petro-chemical in- loss of past service for purpose. of dustries at Cochin based on the re- pay, pension, leave, increments, etc. finery other than fertilizer plants. (b) No such resolutions have beeIl-' EdacaUu. Sch~ received in tlhe Ministry of Hom.· Mairs. 16. Sbri Subodh Bausda: Will the Minister of Education be pleased to Central Reserve Pol1ce Foree state: 18. Sbri D. C. Sharma: Will the (a) whether it is a fact that the Minister of Bome Affairs be pleased . Central Government propOsed to give to state: hundred per cent grant to the States (a) whether it has been decided to on certain schemes of education; increase the Central Reserve Police (b) it so, the nature of the specific force; and schemes; and (b) if so, the reasons therefor and (c) whether the State Governments the extent of the expansion proposed. have agreed to this proposal? . to be made? The Mbalster 01 Educa.tiO!ll -':11. Economic Uplift: 21. Shri Kama Cbandra Mallick: 1. Development of Lac cultiva- Will the Minister of Edueat. be tion. pleased to state: 2. Animal Husbandry. (a) whetht!r the NatiopaJ Loan Scholarships Scheme has been intro- S. Minor Irrigation. duced in the State of Orissa; and 4. Reclamation and development (b) if so, the total amount given to . of land. waste the students from Orissa State under 5. Purchase of agricultural lands. the scheme during 19611-64? 6. Traitiing centres for carpentary. The MiDJster of Edueatio. (Shrl M. C. ChaPa): (a) Yes, Sir. 7. Communications. (b) Total amount disbursed to the 8. Subsidy for agricultural aids. scholars under the scheme is -111. Health, Housing and other Rs. 2,55,3621-. Schemes: Grants for Physical Educatioa Ia 1. Houses and house-sites. ora. 2. Water supply. U. Shrl a- Chaadra Mallick: Will the Minister of ~ be 3. Aid to voluntary agencies. pleaSed to state: 4. Establishment of weHare cen- (a) whether any grant or loan has tres. been given to the Government of Central Sector SchaleII Orissa for the development of physi- cal education during I1H12-1S and 1. Pre-matm scholarships. 1963-64; and . 2. Co-operation. including Fores1: (b) if so, the aDlOunta co-operatives and market- .ach year? ~7 Written A7I81Dera JYAISTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) WTittl!1l AlIOWe" Sii 'l'he Deput,.. MinUter ia the MiDls- AlIImoatDm ChlorId8 'try j of EduoaU. (.Shri Bhakt DarsIum): (a) and (b). Yes Sir. u. f Shri Bal KrishDa S.... h: Financial assistance has been given 1... Shri Bishwanatll Bo,..: to the State Government of Orissa during 1962-63 and 11163-Goi by way Will the Minister of Petroleum. .aa .{)f erant, as under:- Chemicals be please!\: to refer to the reply given to Unstarred Question 1962-63 R.I. '191501- No. 2384 on the 22nd April, 1964 and 1965-Goi R.I. 1:730\- date: ' (a) the reasons for all&wing the Sahu Chemicals Soda Ash Factory at Varanasi to produce the Ammo- nium Chloride Fertilizers in powder trom when it had got J,he licence for its production in crystal form; (b) whether there is an,.. proposal for ertension of the plant; and (c) if so, whether it is expected to 'fIfl" ,!~-4'Trt !fiT ~~ifflriTr ~I If1'IT be completed by the end of the cur- ~ f.t; : rent Five Year Plan? (~) m~;;r~ if ;q'~a-"'~ .. tuted by the University Grants Com- (b) The well was projected to R mission to encourage teachers to un- depth of 1200 metres but due to dertake research works; drilling difficulties drillmg had to be discontinued at 839 metres. (b) if so, the State-wise Dllmber of teachers so 'far benefited by the (c) Statigraphic information was. scheme; and obtained. No indication of hydro- carbons has been observed. (c) the nature and the duration of the research work? WeHare of Scheduled Castes ud Scheduled Tri~ In orissa The MiDister Of Education (Sml 27. Shri Mohan Nayak: Will the· M. C. Chagla): (a) Yes, Sir. Minister of Home Mairs be pleas- edto state: (b) A statement is laid on the (a) the amount spent out of the- table of the House. [Placed in Lib- amount allotted for Welfare of Sche- rary, See No. LT-2894/64]. duled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in, (c) The scheme for the grant of Ori~sa during 1963-64; financial assistance envisages promo- (b) the schemes On which the· tion of fundamental research!leamed amount was spent; aDd work in Silence subjects and Huma- nities (including Social Sciences) in (c) how much unspent money was all institutions of higher learning re- refunded to the Central Government. cognised under the University Granta-, from the' above Schemes? Commission Act. The Deputy Minister Ia the Minis- The duration of the research work try of Home Mairs (Shri L; N. depends on each project. But a MIsln'a): (a) The final figures of ex- grant sanctioned under the scheme Is penditure during 1963-64 have not yet nOmially to be utilized within one been received from the State Gov- year of the date of payment. ernment. The estimated expenditure· as reported by the State Government during 1963-64 is of the order of 011 In cauvery Basin Rs. 133.39 .lakhs, as against the allot- ted amount of Rs. 133.10 Jakhs 28. Shri P. Muthlah: Will the (b) A statement showing the· Minister of Petroleum aDd Chemieals sehemes is laid on the table of the be pleased to state: House. [Placed in Library. S~e No. LT-2895!64]. (a) the latest stage in the' explora- tion of oil near Pattukottai and in (c) The estimated eicpenditure is . the Cauvery basin in Madras State; actUally more than the allotted amount. (b) whether drilling has been com- pleted near Pattukottai; and Literacy Survey (c) if so, the result thereof? 28. Shri Mohan Nayak: Will the Minister of Education be pleased to The MinJster or State Ia the MiBis- state: I.' try of Petroleum aaci Chemicals (Shr'i AJq-esan) : (a) Drilling of the struc- (a) by what percentage literacy hall tural well near Pattukkottai has been increased according to .the limited completed on reaching a depth ot survey conducted in 1963 in the ccmn- 839 metres. Drilling of a deep well try; and near Karaikal will commence shortly. (b) the percentage of increa., of" Seilmic Survey is being continued. litelill.CY among women? 4)1 Written Answers JYAISTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) Writteb Answers 6:a The MiDisteo., of Educatioa (SUi Jammu aad KashmiT M. C. Chagla): (a) and (b). This Ministry has not conducted al'Y sur- 31 f SUi Sari Vishnu Kamath: vey on literacy during 1963. The . L SUi A. S. Saipl: :Directorate of National Sample Sur- Will the Minister of Home Main vey, Department of Statistics Cabi- be pleased to' refer to the reply given .net Secretariat, has, however, ~ollect to Starred Questiall. No. 746 On the ·ed some information on educational 25th March,- 1964 aitd state: standards, but the data so ·collected have not yet been tabulated. (a) whether any further step. han been taken towards abrogation of Social Welfare EDeDsioa Projects Article 370 of the Constitution an.d 29. Shrl Mohan Nayak: Will the bringing the State of Jilmmu and ·.Minister of Education De pleased to Kashmir at par with other States of Itilte the Indian Union in all respe::ts; (a) the amount of Central assis- (b) if so, the details thereof; and tance given to Orissa State in 1963- (c) if not, the reasons therefor? '-64 so far for the Social Welfare Ex- tesion Projects and for the Social The MiDJster 01 State in the MiDIs- and Moral Hygiene and Attercare- try of Home Mairs (Shrl Hathi): "- Programmes; and (a) to (c). There has been no (b) how many projects have been change in the position. ·.running till the end of March, 1964? The Deputy ~r In the MmIs- f1I'~ij~ try of Education (Shrlmatl SolUlda- ram Bamachandraa): (a) Rs. 1,61,263 -Welfare Extension Projects. H. "if~mf~: .L.lJi !llr~ --: ~ llilt ~ Q~ ~ II! ~ ~ .l} llib til lSJ1.Hb t~J 1< ~ ,l;1ll1!i. ... ~ ':t.b ~ 'Nlteli!lb l.llli til ~hlb ij&1!J LlJi ~ lJ!ili lflo 4,Ji ~ ij:< .Ua :t.tl.\.,hl :lS:tJ1!b.Iij .yIt !.~ ~J l; ~_hlJJ~ ~ (,Ii!) ,~~~, ~ ~ II! ~ J!.!A .\.,.!I! !.JiIP'kI?$Ii!Ui JU:21 oo)'~);''!. oot'b,,'ob !l.ia .l.Il.Ia ---- ~.Lh ~!> !laD. l!Ia J.t4.ltI.I:t. ,I;~ (!.~) (!.~) ,l;J:!t. h.\:ll~~J 1.\:lj -t .\:)..!Ii )..1.I;.2J ).h ~ .oo~'~a'~ 000'00'-,. ~.~ -t ~ ,I;~ 4".!Ii ~.Lh '2l~J ~~ .ijll!Ia .!IiJ ~ J:.li ~ lJ2I; ( !Ia ) (~) (~) It! ~ ooo');t'b ooo'o);'t ~'t : .!IiJ ~ lL~ !j< ~.e llli ~ ~ lJ2I;: ~ ~~ '~k llhlk ll~ t ~ ~~~~ 1>9 B.tamBUY uan!-'& tOOl 'IZ XVl'i '.Lamsuy uam-'& E9 6S Written Answers JYAlSTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) WrittenA'IIS1Ders 66; ~~: ~ ~ ~~"f ~ '!CIT ,. ;R ~ ;:r;ft" (If) " I WITT I ~1II't~"' ~ (If) ~ ~m~ 'l'~i!iT~ Madhya Pradesh GovemmlOnt have approached the Centre for a centrally ~ ~ iF f<;it ~ fm ~ ""- lponsored university at Bhopal; I'm it ~~. ~ ~ 31. Shri J'ash"'*t Mehta: Will the, '""'"' if Qi' ( Minister ot Petroleum a.d Chemlcab, ~) : (If) ~o I be pleased to refer to the repl" given. to Starred Question No. 1241 on the (V) ~ ~ ~ f.mft 1I£fif- 29th April, 1964 and state: f~, '1t)(~ iiI~~~~ (a) how many .global tenders had ~ ..rot iIf ft;rQ; ~ ~5(it :;rr ~ ~ I been received tor the manufacture of" Written A7I8werB MAY 27, 19114 Written Answers 68 . sulphuric acid plant by the Pyrites (c) The question requires a very and Chemicals Development Com- careful study and it may take some pany Ltd.; time before the Arbitrator is in a posi. (b) the foreign exohange involved tion to decide. in this project; Salt Price ia Anllamaas (c) at what stage the progress 01 ·the Project 9tands now; 40 f Shrlmati Rellu Chakravartty: . L Shri H. P. Chatterjee: (d) when the construction of the .. Project will actually start; and Will the Minister of Home AtlairII ·be pleased to state: (e) the reasons for delay, if any? (a) whether price of salt in Anda- mans is higher than in interior places The Minister of State in the Minis- in India; · try of Petroleum and Chemicals (Shr! AIaI"esan): (a) Eleven. (b) why tlhere is no canning inuus- try for the ·plentiful supplies Of fish, (b) Rupees eighty lakhs approx. pork, ovenison; (c) to (e). Tenders have been (C) 'whether ·bananas and pine-ap- invited on turn-key basis. The ten- ples which are widely grown cannot ·ders are under examination and a be e~rted for want of proper cold · decision is likely to be reached short- storage on board the ships; and ly. Ac<:ording to the terms Of the (d) what steps have been taken tender, the plant should be ready for to !eM frozen fish to the huge mar- · production within the maximum period ket in West Bengal? of 21 years of the date at acceptance · of the tender and placement at a .finn The MiJlister of state in the Minis- order. The delay, i.f any. is due to try of Home Affairs (Shri Bathi): (a) the fact that this will be the first sul- The present retail price of salt in phuric acid plant of this kind in India Andamans is 30 n.p. per Kg. No in- based on pyrites ore. formation is available about tlhe pril'e. of salt in interior places in the coun- ~Iy of Gall to Gujarat Industries try. f Shri .Jashvant Mehta: ('b) The present catch 01 fish 15 just U. "l Shri Sidheshwar Prasad: enou~ for local consumption and the supplies of pork and v~nison are Will the Minister Petroleum and at limited. '. Chemieals be pleased to state: (c) The existing level of product!on (a) whether any interim report has of bananas and pine-apples in the Is- been submitted by the Arbitrator, Dr. lands is not enough even to meet the V K. R. V. Rao in connection with the local demand. fuc:ation of price for the supply of gas to the industries in Gujarat; (d) The present supply being small, the question of exporting frozen fish (b) if so. what are the recommenda- has not arisen. The Andamans Ad- tions; and ministration have, however, taken up (c) if the reply to part (a) above schemes for increasing production of be in the negative, tlhe reaao~ for fish; and cold storage facilities are the delay? also proposed. to be pl'OV'ided. The MiDister of State ia the Millis- Drilling In West Beqal .' try 01 Petroleum and OhemIcalII (Shri U. Sbd IDdrajlt Gupta: Will the Alapsaa): (a) No. Minister of Petroleum and Chemical. (.b) Does not mile. be pleased to state: Written Answers JYAISTHA 6, IBM (SAKA) Written Answers ,. (a) whether the Oil and Natural Gas Commission has finalised its plana ( iF ) 'flfT ~ " ~ f.f; 0fl1Ttt :for oil exploration and drilling in lI'I'I'ftuft ~ Irants last year as the accounts for three months' duration followed by 11163-64 have not yet been finalised. practical training for one month. In 1962-63, however, excepting the ArcbaeolOCioa.l Excavati_ Dear Ka*lo &iates of Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat and "est Bengal (so far as general educa- 46. Shri P. K. Deo: Will th(' Mini.Iter tion sClhemes are concerned) and of Eduoatlon be pleased to state: iUtdhra Pradesh and Madras (so fa, (a) whether excavation conducted< technical education schemes are con- by the Archaeological Department at e:el'ned) no other State was able to Kumauli village has proved that th& .tilise the Central allxation in full original Kashi was situated some nis was because during the emer- miles east of the present Varanm (ency exp~nditure on buildings ('tc., town; load to be drastically curtailed. Non- availability of qualified and trained (b) if so, whether any articles c4 teachefs, difficulties in the procure- great historical and archaeological in- ment of material and equipment etc. terest have been found in that excava-· w~re also contributory causes. tion; and ~hnical Specialists in Audio-Visual (c) whether any period has been a ... EducatiOD certained regarding the antiquity of CS. Shrt Ram Karim Yadav: Wi!! tlhat town? the Minister of Education be ple'lsed to state: The Deputy Minister ill the Mlm.- try of Educatioa (Shrt Bhakt Dar- (a) whether Governmt'nt have shan): (a) to (c). The excavation a 1Indertaken a special short-term pro- being carried out by the Banaras (1'amme of training technical specta- Hindu University. Information in thi. Jists at the National Institute of AudlC- regard is being collected and will ~ Visual Education in Delhi; placed on the Table of the House. (0) if so, a brief outlinE> .,f the ~6gramme; and Promotions or Class I Oftioon (c) the number and quali'l('t.t!on. of 47. Dr. L. M. Slnghvt: Will thlt lIit trainees and the dUration of the Minister of Home Affairs be pleased e:lJIlrse? to refer to the reply given to Urultar- red Question No. 1070 on the 11th 'l'he MinIster of Education IShrf M. March, 1964 and state: C_. Chagla): (a) The National lnstitute at Audio-Visual Education has in~l 0- ctUced a short term Technical Tra'ning (a) whether the Officers of Grade! COurse for Teaclhers, Projectiom~ts and Selection Grade of C.S.S. wh~ znd Technicians incharge {l~ Audio- are drawing max>mum in their gradeiJ Visual equipment in Educational Insti- were duly considered for promotion tl) tUtions. the posts of Deputy Secretary and Joint Secretary Or equivalent befOrlt (b) The Course covers the principles Government decided to bring officers 0{ working, maintenance and repair cf of other services to the Central Secre- important items of Audio-Visual tariat; equipment and also Elementary theo- retical instruction in Electricity, (b) the number of Officers of Grade o,ptics and Electronics. I and Selection Grade of C.S.S. anet (ci The prescribed minimum quali- Officers of other services e.g.. I.A.S- ftCations are Matriculation/Higher and I.A. and A.S. who have been pro- Secondary with Science. In case of moted on. a regular basis to the post. cmdidates otherwise well experienced Of Deputy Secretary and Joint Secre- relaxation can be made. l11e number tary or equivalent separately durin, cit. trainees is 12 and the COUl'3I! is of the last 4 years, year-wlge; and 73 Written 8, 1886 (SAKA) Written Amwer. AmwenJYAISTHA 74 (C) the number of 'POSts that wpre (e) State Civil Service officeI'\! required to be filled in durmg th~ last whose names are included in the 4 years, year-wise and separately! Select List referred to in Regula. The Deputy Minister m the Ministry tion 7(3) of the lAS (Appo;nt-- of Home AJralni (Shri L. N. Ml5hra): ments ,by Promotion) Regulation,; and (a) to (c). The sources from which officers are ordinarily drawn for man- ning seninr administrative posts at (f) State Civil Service officei'll the Centre of and above the rank ,)f other than those mentioned in (c) Deputy Secretary are laid down in may also be appointed '0 seniCT para 2(i) of the Scheme published po,t, in consultation with the with the Government of India, Minis- UPSC in each case." try of Horne Affairs Resolution No. F. 34(3)EO/57 dated the 17th Octol-er, Each State IAS cadre carries. 1957, which reads as follows:- 9p:!ci!led quota for deputation to th_ CE'n ~r l! Government, and 45 posts rif "(i) Such posts will ordinarily be and aw,e 1Jhe rank of Dt-puty Secre- manned by officers of one or other of tary have to be provided to membel'll the following categories:- of the Central Secretariat Service.. (a) Officers borrowed from the But apart from these provisIons ther. State Cadres of the lAS and from is no reservation, direct Or in<:iirect other Class I Services of the States for any service. The posts of Deputy (other than the State Civil Ser- SeerE'tary and above are not l'es!'r\'ed.. vice) on tenure deputation; Selections for these posts depend mainly on three considerations-(i) (b) Officers borrow~ on tenure requirements of the posts; (ti) exper~ deputation from Central Servic~, ence. background, merit and suitalii- Class I including officers serving Jity of the available eligible offieets in Public Industrial Undertakings of various services; and (iii) seniority (hereinafter referred to as Central of the said offtcerw within their ~ Services); pective Services. (c) Officers of the Selection Grade of the Central Secretariat A statement showing the number Service; of officers appointed on a regular basls to the posts of Deputy Secretary and (d) Officers of the Central Ad- .Toint Secretary or equivalE'nt durin« ministrative Pool; the last 4 years is as under: Name of Deputy Secretary & Equivalent Joint Secretary & Equivalent Serrice 1960 1961 196a 1963 1960 1961 196a 1963 IeS/IAS 19 as 34 37 8 [2 21 30 IA&AS 6 , 6 ID.A.S. I 2 :a I.R.S. 5 6 8 3 2 Indian Postal Service a 2 1 C.S.S. 8 9 14 :a '6 Othen- a 1 .. a Total 34 S2 73 ,a I2 14 29 32 -This does not include appointments made in the Ministries of Eztemal AffaiR and Law of oflicen belonging to the Indian Foreign Service and Central Legal Sernc:e. 75 WrittE!!l AfIIWUII KAY ZT, 1864 Be. Motions for Ad;ouna- 76 IMIIt lind C"mng Atten- tion N otic. Andaman Special Pay into the firing at Port Blair in 111ft has completed its enquiry; and U. SIIri MoIuuamad Elias: Will the Minister of IIome Affairs be pleased (b> if 80, the finding thereof! to state: Tbe Mbd8Ier of State III the MlIdI- (a) whether Government have con- try of Rome Main (Sbri BaW); (a) 8ld!ereci the question of increuln, the and (b). The requisite informatiOll Andaman speciBil pay for the emplo- was laid on the Table of 1II1e BOUIe _ Tees working in the Andamans in view ~e 16~ March, 1963. of the rise in cost of living; and (b) if 80, the decision taken there- on? 12.00 hrII. 'l'he MIDIstel' of State i4 tbe MIab- OBITUARY REI'l!!RZNCIS U7 of Home Affairs (Shrl BaW): (a) There is no such proposal under Mr. Speaker; I haw to inform the consideratiOill. House· of the sad d.emiIe of two of (b) Doe!! not arist'!. our friends, namely Shri Bansni Prasad Sinha and· Dr. Hari MohIIn. Bducation System ia ADdamaa ud NtODbar lidaDds Shri Banarsi. Prasad Sinha _ • sitting Member of the House from _ lit. Sbri MIIbamma4 Eliu: Will the Monghyr constituency of Bihar. He Minister of Educatton be nleased to was also a Member of the First aDd .tate: . Second Lok Sabba during ~e year!! (a) wlhether the study team which 1952 to 1962. He passed .rw-ay at was appointed by the Education De- Monghyr on the 15ta1 May, 19M, at the partment of the Central Government age of M. has completed its enquiry regarding the education system in Andaman and Dr. Hari Mohan was a Member of Nicobar Islands; the First Lok Sabba during the year. 1952 to 1957. He passed away on the ('b) whether the study team hilS 18th May, 19M, at the age of 62. made any recommendation l·egarding the medium of education for the non- We deeply mourn the 10lil of theM Hindi speaking students in Andoamsn friends and I am au:re the House will and Nicobar ISlands; and join me in c:onveying our condol~ (C) if so, what is the recommenda- to the bereaved families. tion! The House may stand In ailence fOr The MDdSer Of BilacatlDa (Drt 111. a short while to ~ t~ mrro.... C. Cbacla): (a) The Ministry of Edu- cation has not appointed in the recent (The Members then "DOd in silence past any such study team. for a short while.) (b) and (c). '11he question doea not arISe. 11•• Iln. I'IrIq at Port 1IIa~ RE: MOTIONS FOR ADJOURNMENT 51. Sbri Mobam_d ElIas: Will the AND CALL1N~AT1'ENTlON Minister of H_ MI,Irs be pleased NO'l'JCJ:S to state: (QuaY, (a> whether the one man commls- "011 of enquiry which was a~DtecI Mr. Speabr. I bave recelved notice. b7 the C:mtraI Govemmea.t to IIIqUIr8 of adjOlll1'D1lleDt motiOM u well. 77 Re: Motions for JYAISTHA II, 1888 (SAKA) Ad;ournment aM Calling-Attention Notices 1%.0& lin. ealling-attention notices on the mat- ter Of rehabilitation of the migranta, CALLING A'I"l'ENTION TO A MAT- and they relate to: TER OF URGEN'r PUBLIC lM- PORTANCE. "The reported tiring by po!ice on FmINc ON REFUGEES FROM EAST PAXllI- refugees from East Pakistan on the 'l'AN A'l' TmUVELLI RAILWAY S'l'A'l'ION 19th May, 1964, at Tiruvelli rail- way station, retrulting in the death Sbrl Krislmapal SInch (Jalesar): I of five refugees and irQuries to call the attention of the Minister of 8I!Veral." Rehabilitation to the following matter of urgent public importance and I re- I have not thought it proper to admit quest thal: he may make a ltatement the adjournment mofion. I could not thereon: do so. But I have admitted the cal- '"!'he reported firing by police ling-attention notices, and the namt!I on the refugees trom. East PakiB- or all those Members have been club- tan on the 19th lIa.Y, 111M, at bed together. I shall call upon Sllri Tiruvelli railway station, resulting Xrishnapal Singh whose name appear. in the death of five refugees and first, to call the attention of the hoD. irQuries to several." :Minister. 'l'!Ie MbIfster 01 Bebabllltatioa (Slut ."..,.): The of Sbrl S. M. JIaaaojee (Kanpur): MII7 Government Oriaa I know the realODS why 1Ihe adjourn- bave opened five camps, which in- clude and Tiruvelli, under a ment motion has not been admitted? Sunabeda programme to migrant Through the adjournment motion, we resettle 5,000 familiea in small-ecale lnd.~ wanted to censure the Govemment for the brutal firing on the refugees for Agricultural land available in the country being llmited, it is inevitable whom 80 much Is said on the floor of that a large proportion of the migrant the Hou8e and outaide. After all, we ·wanted to censure the Government, families should be reaettled in OCCUPI!- tionI other than agriculture. Pend- thoueh the bon. Minister hu exprea- ed his regret. We should have been Ing establishment of small indUltriea liven an opportunity. Even after the In these areas for permanent employ- ment displaced peI'8Ollll, 0pportu- atatement Is made In reply to the cal- ot nity of temporary employment in un- ling-attention notice, If the facti are skilled jobs (e.g., earth work for road revealing, I would request you to Bee building, railway track and contour that the adjournment motion mI!7 be bunding, bamboo cutting, brick load- aclmlt1le4. ing and unloading, stone quarry work, work as helpers for masons etc.) have Mr. Speabr. The hon. Member been IllTIIJIged ·for the entire adult ~ that the re&SODIeannot be given population ot these CIIJDP8 and also tor ID their verr nature. BODle skilled worbn II!JlQJIg them (e.g., call)enters, teachers, clerks. ma- tIIut S... BaerIee: It Is a pure17 sons, blacksmiths, brick moulders etc.). Central matter. The Centre II con- The employment opportunities are eemecl. IIeIng displayed prominentJ,y on notiee boardI and also throuCb cyclostylecS Mr. SptM.: It Is not. purel7 CeIl- dbarta and are being announcecl to tI'lIl matter. the displaced persons practleally eve!7 day In each camp by the rehabilitatloa Now, Sbrl Kri81mapIIl SIDIh. staft at the camps. No compulsion or foft!e of any kind l8, however, aIIiI to make the mlgrantl to work. CaUitIQ Attention MAY 2'1, 1964 to a Matter of Urgent 80 public Importance rShri Tyagi] The total number of families stay- ed on the railway track. Seeing their ing at Tiruvelli camp on 18th May, threat~ning attitude and tendency • 1964 was 597. AJs the families arrived take law in their own hands, the at Tiruvelli, they started demanding District Magistrate promulgated Rttlement on agricultural land only. orders under Section 144 of ,he Cri- 'fhey were, however, advised to avail minal Procedure Code against 14 per- of employment opportunities in non- sons who were the main agitatorl. agricultural work. which had been Warnings were issued on microphone ~anged near the camp, for aU adult in Oriya. Bengali and Hindi that their males. They were also told that the assembly had been declared unlawfuL Orissa Gavernment did not have any AJs this proved ineffective the District agricultural land on which they could Magistrate ordered imm~iate arreBt be rehabilitated. . of the leading agitators. The police party which included the Additional On the 16th May, the migrants Superintendent 'of Police made two pve an ultimatum to the Rehabflita- arrests but the mob surrounded the tion Officer of the camp that unless police officers and snatched away one the Government decided to provide of the arrested perse>ns. The situation, them land within 24 hours, they would therefore, demanded immediate use of eet tihe demand fulfilled by resorting force to disperse the mab and to rescue to other means. Out of the 597 1ami- the officers who had been surrounded. lies in Tiruvelli camp, about 375 de- Owing te> unfavourable condjtions, _ Rtted the camp on the 17th and l~th Yay and reached the Tiruvelli rail- tear-gas could not be used and. there- way station. On 18th May. the mi- fore. a lathi charge was ordered. As grants threatened the Assistant Sta- soon as the charge started. big-sized tion Master, Tiruvelli. with serious stones were hurled by the mob. consequences it he failed to arrange Several agitated migrants took out Clecial train for them within one hour tangias (a sort Of axe), lathis and for their return to the transit centre knives and started brandish!n!; them at Mana The Mioister in char;e 01 A Sub-Inspector e>f Police was hit on t'ribal and Rural Welfare in Orissa. the head by a big stone lind another the Deputy Rehabilitation Commis· stone hit a constable on the chest. An Idoner and the Additional Superinten. officer of the pe>lice party W30 went c1ent of Police. Koraput, advised them to rescue the Additional Superinten- th~o return to the camp and not to dis- dent of Police was ... n on the to ground by the mQb and belaboured. rurb the peace and tranquJllity ~t .that (Shri S. M. Banerjee: Nobody died.) place but this had no effect at all. Fifteen police personnel including the About 200 persons squatted on the railway track and thus delayed the Additional Superintendent of Police and two Assistant Commandants re- departure of a train. ceived injuries and were later odnIit- On the 19th May, the migrants ted to hospital. Seven members of a.ssumed a violent mood and threaten- the police party received serious in- ed to kill the Railway p.nd other Go· juries incluciing fractures. ""emment officers. The DistrIct M3.gis- (rate. Koraput. and tibe Rehabilitation Having regard to the situation Minister entreated them in Oriya and that had developed. the District :\bgla- Bengali not te> violate the law. and trate was ,atisfied that no time could to clear the track and the pJatform. be wasted on a further lathi ·,harge 'I'he District Magistrate 31 so a~k" brutal sttaek .,Ued te> by violent gestur0s an':! by the mob. The District Magistrate, Ilagans and some more migrants jump- therefore. ordered the displ'!rsal Of the Calling Attention JYAISTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) to a Matter of Urgent I Public Importance .mob Shri Tyap: May I inform the Mr. Speaker: Has he not received -House that I have been having hour any intimation? to hour information through tele- 'phone as well as on telegrams; when Shrl Mohammad EUas: No. these refugees deserted the camp, I - got information; when they reached Speaker: will have the inti- the station I got information; I got a Mr. I mation sent to those Members who message when they squatted on the have not received it. I have allowed rails. It is not the version of the no adjournment motion. The caIlint . police alone; the Deputy Commis- attention notice which I allowed- sioner was there and one of the 'Min- that waR what I just allowed. isters was also present. It is their ver- sion that I have given... (Interrup- Shrl R. N. Mnkerjee (Calcutta tions.) Central): If yOU can say whether the other adjournment motions for Mr. Speaker: Whether he proposes which alternative calling attention to form a committee of Members of motion. also have been given would Parliament-that is what he wants to be considered by you sO that the call- .1mow. ing attention might come up later ... Shri Tya": There is no such inten- Mr. Speaker: I have kept some of tion. them pending and they will be in- formed when 1 decide what to do with thein. I might have received more than fifty notices tOday and I cannot lU5 hrIL recollect which one of them I had dealt with. "RE: MOTIONS FOR ADJOURl\TMENT AND CALLING ATTENTION NOTICES Shri S. M. Banerjee (Kanpur): Sir, one word. While rejecting the calling (QUERY) attention notice on abnormal rise in prices, it has been stated here that Mr. Spea.ker: Papers to be laid .... the motion had been rejected because (Interruptions.) an un starred question had heen ad- mitted for the 2nd June, 1964. Shri Nambla.r (Tiruchirapa1!i): "The question about Heavy Eleetricall. Mr. Speaker: I have not seen this. Be: Motions JYAJSTHA 8, 1888 (SAKA) frw Ad;ourntneld 90 cmd Calliftg Atten- tion Notice, Shri S. M. Banerjee: It is from this Mr. Speaker: The hon. lady Mem- .Secretariat; signed by M. C. Joshi, ber must realise that I cannot remem- ..upposed to be one of the Under ber each alld ever:y. calling atteDtioIl .Secret aries ..... (Interruptions.) notice that may have come to JD7 notice and the orders that 1 have Mr. Speaker: That did not form the passed on each of fhem. I have always .subject-matter of any adjournment requested hon. Members who dis- ·motion... (Interruptions.) agree with me either to come to me 8'0 that·1 can explain the reasons. But ~wr (~TmtitT): II:i\' Wi iw if some hon. Members are not prepar- 1f'~ f' j ~r~ If;f '4T ~ Shrl S. M. Banerjee: The Centre'. Shrl U. M. Trivedi (MandsawJ. On 'responsibility is there. the question of refugees from B~ a calling attention notice has been Mr. Speaker: Who is to decide? given. I would like to knITN whether Somebody ha·, to decide... (Interrup- that matter will be taken up in the com.) If the hon. Member continues course of the day. in this manner. I cannot tolerate that. I have asked them to keep Mr. Speaker: I will' have the infor- ,-order three or four times. If he has mation sent to tm;' hon. Member. The .anv grievance he can write to me. 1 Secretariat should send intimation to -cannot argue about the notices here. all the hon. Members who gave n0- tice and who have not received an), Shrimati Renu Chakravartty (Bar- information so far. rackpore): Sir, it was a very impor- tant question to disappearance of rice Shri Bade (Khargone): from West Bengal shops. That was an adjournment motion which you Mr. Speaker: Order, order .... (In- have disallowed. We want to' kn'lw ten-uptions.) This will riot be re- whether the same motions tabled as corded. calli:1it attention motions have been disalJwed. . ON ot recorded. 91 MAY 27, 1964 Papers ~aid on the Table U.sl..,., (iii) a COpy of the Defence 01 India (Eighth Amendment) PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE Rules, 19M published in Noti- INDIAN TELEGRAPH (2ND AMENDMENT fication No. G.S.R. 710 dated RULES) the 1st May\ 19M, under sec- tion 41 Of the Defence of In- 'l'he MblIstry of Law and MlDIsier India Act, 1962. [Placed in Of CommunicatiODs (Shri A. K. Sen): Library, See No. LT-2887/64].· I beg to lay on the Table a copy of the Indian Telegraph (2nd Amend- RICZ-MILLING INDUSTRY (REGULATIOX meM) Rules, 1964 published in Nlrti- AND LICENSING) AMENDMENT RULQI fication No. S.O. 1050 dated the 28th The MiDJster of State ID the MiD- March, 1964, under sub-section (5) istry of FOOd and Apiculture (ShI'l Of section 7 of the Indian Telegraph A. M. Thomas): I beg to lay on the Act, 1885. [Placed in Ubrary, See No. Table a copy of the Rice-Milling in- LT-2884/64]. . dustry (Regulation and Licensing) Amendment Rules, 1964 published in NOTIFICATIONS UNDER Au. INDIA SI!lI!VI- Notification No. G.S.R. 747 dated th. CES ACT AND Dl:FENCE OF INDIA (EIGHTH 16th May\ 1964, under sub-section (4) AMENDMENT) RULES of section 22 of the Rice-MilliDC in- dustry (Regulation) Act, 1958. Tbe MinIster of State In the MlIIIa- [Placed in Library, See No. LT-28881 tI7 of Bome A1railw (Shrl Balbi): I 64]. ~ to lay. on the Table- ORDERS OF DELxMrrATION COMMISSION (i) a copy each of the following Notifications under sub-sec- The Deputy MIDJstIer In tile MJaIs... tion (2) of section S of the All try Of Law (Shrl BlbudheDdra Misra): India Services Act, 19111, I beg to lay on the Table a copy eacb makmg certain further of the following Orders Of the Deli- amendments to Schedule m mitation Commission under sub-sec- to the Indian Administrative tion (3) .of section 10 of the Delimita- Service (Pay) Rules. 1954:- tion Commission Act, 1962:- (a) G.S.R. 182, dat~ the 30th (i) Order No. 21 determining de- November, 1963. limitation of assembly co~ tuencies in the Union Terri- (b) G.8.R. 484, dated the 28th tory Pondicherry published March, 1964. or in Nati.ftcation No. S.O. 1510 (c) G.S.R. 485 dated the 28th dated the 2nd May, 19M. March. 19M. [Placed in Library, See No. LT-2889IM]. (d) G.S.R. 486 dated the 28th March. 19M. (ii) Order No.7 determlning deli- [Placed in Library, See No. mitation of parliamentary and LT-2885/64]. usl'mbly constituencies In the State of Kerala published (11) a copy of Notification No. in Notification No. S.O. 1610 G.S.R. 525 dated the 4th dated the 7th May, 1964- April, 19M making certain [Placed in Library, See No. further amendments to Sche- LT-2890IM]. dule m to the Indian Police Service (Pay) Rules, 19M. Shrl Ban Vishnu Eamath (lIoshan- under sub-section (2) of sec- ,abad) : On a point of ~1ar1- tion 3 of the All India Ser- fication, Sir, with regard to item "rices Act, 19!11. [Placed iD (ii) here. in view of the ambiguous Library, See No. LT-2886/M]. mwwer. liven by the Government .. -9J Pusident's Assent JYMSTHA 6, 1886 (SAKA) Constitution (Nine- 94 to BiZZ. temth Amendment) Bill 1he last session. Does this indicate a l (ot) 'llhe East Punjab Aryurve4ic ftrm and final decision taken by the and Unani Practitionera 'Government to hold the general elec- (Delhi Amendment) Bill, !l0n in Kerala next year? 1964. Shri A. J[. Sea: This has nothing to (5) The Goa, Daman and Diu ~o with the holding Of general elec- Judicial Commissioner's Court 'tions. This is only with reference to (Declaration as High Court) 'the question of delimiting the parlia- Bill, 1964. mentary and assembly constituencies by a statutory commission, namely, (6) The Indian COinage (Amend- 1he Delimitation Commission. ment) Bill, 1964. ('1) The Industrial Development u.n_ Bank of India Bill, 1964. (8) The Oil and Natural Gas Com- PRESIDEN!l"S ASSENT TO BILLS mission (Amendment) Bill, 1964. Seeretan': Sir, I lay on the Table following four Bills passed by the (9) The Durgah Khawaja Saheb Houses of Parliament during the last (Amendment) Bill, 1964. 'Session and assented to by the Presi- (10) The Advocates (Amendmellt) dent since a report was last made to Bill, 1964. 'the House on the 6th May, 1964. (1) The Appropriation (No.3) BID, 1964. DEMANDS FOR ,SUPPLEMENTARY (2) The Taxation Laws (Continua- GRANTS (GENERAL), 1964-111 "tion and Validation Of Recovery Pr0- ceedings) Bill, 1964. The Minister, of PIaIlniD&' (Shri .. B, Bhapt): I beg to present a State- (3) The Indian Railways (Amend- ment showing SUPPlementlll'y' De- ment) Bill, 1964. mands for Grants in respect of the (4;) The Drugs and Cosmetics Budget (General) for 1964-65. (Amendment) Bill, 1964. 2. Sir, I also lay on the Table copies, duly authenticated by the Secretary DoH hI'II. Of Rajya Saobha, of the following ten Bills passed by the Houses of Parlia- CONSTITUTION (NINE"l'DNTB ment during the last Session and .... AMENDMENT) BILL- • ented to by the President since a re1)()rt was last made to the House on The MIIIIRer of Law aud IDaIIdIer 1h~ 6th May, 1964:- of c-mumcatloas (8hrl A. It. !JeD): (1) The Armed Forces (Special I beg to move for leave to introduce Powers) Continuance BilL a Bill further to amend the eon.titu- 1964. tion of India. (2) The Public Employment (Re- Mr. 8peaer: Motion moved: quirement as to 'Residence) Amendment Bill, 1964. "That leave be cranted to IDa. '(3) The Dakshina Bharat HIndi duce a Bill further to amend the Prachar Sabba Bill, 111M. Constitution of IndiL" -Published in Gazette of Jndia-Extraordinary, Part n, SectiOIi 2, , oIated 27-5-64. 95 MAY 27, 1964 (Nineteenth Amendmem) 96 Bill Shrl P. It. Deo (Kalahandi): On a are the custodian of all the democra- point of order, Sir. I beg to 8Ubmit tic rights. that besides infringing the varioas democratic conventions and prece- Mr. Speaker: Is it his point of order' dents, this Bill contravenes the very that this chakra should be removed fundamentals of democracy. This Con- or I should be removed? stitution (Nineteenth Amendment) Shri :N. Sreekantau Nair (Quilon)~ Bill is a carbon copy of the Seven- He is shedding crocodile teal'll ova teenth Amendment Bill, which hu the peasants. been negatived by the collective wis- dom of this House. TIllS' Bill has got Shri Ra.np (Chittoor): Question. far-reaching effects and tries to rob the citizen of his right over property Shri P. It. Deo: MY' point of order and the poor peasant of his proprie- is that when there is a national emer- torship. In the debate on the 17th gency and when the Prime Minister Amendment. Bill, various speakers is not keeping good health. it is an fr9m the treasury benchea also op- the more imoerative that we should p6sed it. not bring a legislation of this type. A Government with 43 per cent • Mr. Speaker: He should come to of m. backing of the people is trying to point of order. thrust an unconstitutional Bill of thi8 Shri P. It. Deo: I am coming, Sir. nature, (Interroptions). Mr. Speaker: He should come to Mr. Speaker: Rather there ought -his point of order first aDd then ('x- to be some limit tOmy patience alSo. plain it. So far he has been arguing his c.... but no point of order has been made. Shri P. It. !)eo: My point of order is that it is the inherent prerogative That is not fair. It should com. of the Chair either to disallow it or straight. They want to oppose it. allow it to be introduced. because That is all that they want to say. your function is not just to interpret They should say it stnight. Why the comma, semi-colon, etc. should they resort to these things!' Shri Yashpal Singh. Mr. Speaker: It may be the prero- gative of the Chair, but what IS his 11ft ~ ~ (~'UifT): ~ POint of order? ~~. ~' Shri P. It. Deo: The fundamental 1Ift~~:1Jfo~~~. right over property. Above the Chair. it is written: " Iflf".flli - 'f ~'fl1f .. (iron) It is for you to see that proper de- mocratic principles are nbsen'ed. You ""'" ~: qrh-, ~ t 97 JY.A.JSTHA 8, 1886 (SAKA) (Nineteenth Amend- 91' ment) Bm "" ~ fiI1: : 'IIT>iI' tr'F ~ 111 ~~ :f;r.ron~1il'ooor ",~~~~~~~) ~~ ~ ~l<: It>{ ~:a- t ~fr;r fif; ~ ~ ~ ft.;i1tZ ~ '!lIT ~ ~ • nr ;;ft ~ ~~~:~~~~ Shri RaDca: I am oppoaing him. I am oppos;ng the very introduction of 11ft 'ioro:f'fifwitm- ~ ~ f;r.r 1fI"ij' ~ ~ this Bill. It is very destructive of ~ ~ m ~ ~ 1fI"~ 1fi1J;f ~ f"l'l:t the fundamental rights and it is dero- gatory to the dignity and status and ~'T i!pRl" lm"1f ~ 'fi<: ffi' m t positi'on of the Supreme Court which ~ om ~ ~;ro;fi:I;f~ if;'T QT the founders of our Constitution had ~ ~ lII'r.fr;;r;:r<:rr ilfrl{'T ;;n fq~(~}: Sbrl Valv1 (Nandurbar): The "' ...... machine ill Dot working; I am far '5I'omr~prt I ff.t~~'fT I "A,yet/'. itu Ii'tz ;f\';w itnnwr t I Mr. Speaker: All these statementa VIIIW ~: i!p1l"i'llT I have been recorded. Dlvuioa No. I.) AYES _Rabld._ Bbattar. Sbri D .... SbriC. AdlaI SlaP. Sbrl --,SbriD_ DoD Bbanj. Sbri P. C. Ad>ath .... Shri Brabaa I'IUub, Sbri Deaai, Sbri Morarji ~ Devl, SbriIut1 Bni-Pnaacl, Shri Deabmukh. Dr. P. S. AI_.Sbri Brij RaI SiD8b Kotob, Sbri Deobmukh, Sbri B. D. AIoa, 8bri A. S. Cbatra_. _iRma Dey. Sbri S. K. Aln. Sbri 100cbim Cbatraverti. Shri P. R. DbaJeabwu "'- Sbri A1nza. Sbri CbaDcI .. Shrimati 1_ Diebe. Sbri Mod. Sbri Bhqwat Jba CwIdat. Sbri DIDt. Sbri G. N. BabWl&th Siach. Shri CbaDdriki, Sbri Dubey. SbriR. G. BUJ~Sbri Chatterjee. Sbri H. P. D.rivecII, Sbri M. L. Ba1 KriIIma SiDab, Shri Chatterjee. Sbri N. C. . Elias, Shri Mob"""'" JIaIatrUImaD, Shri Cba...... di, Sbri s. N. Gahmari. Sbri IIalmiki, Sbri CbaadhrJ. Sbri C. L. Gajraj Smgb RaG, Sbri -oriee. Sbri S. M. CbaDclburi. Sbri D. S. Gouapati a- Sbri Barbtaki, Shrimati_ Cballdhuri. Sbri S1ICbiDdra Gandhi. 8hri V. B. Barm.... Sbri p. C. Cbaudburi. Sbri Tridlb ~ Gaoga Devi, Shrimati BanIa. SbriH.... Cba1lClhuD. Sbrimatl KmIal& Ghosh. Sbri N. R. Barua. Sbri R. Cbavm. Sbri D. R. Gooi, Shri Abdul Ghoni ~SbriP.L. Cbavda. Shrimati 10_ Gopolao, Sbri A. K. Buappo, Sbri Quai Lal. Shri GoviDd Du, Dr. JIoaumatari. Sbri Dan, Sbri Guha, Sbri A. C. Baawaat.Sbri DoIjit SlaP. Shri Gupta, Shrl Rubia- Be.... Sbri Da.. Dr.M.M. Gupta, Sbri Shiv a.- ...... SbriB.R. DtIa. Shri B. K. IfuuaaaothaI,.. Sbri m.a-atl._ o.nbaD. Sbri _ D ... SbriN.T. Hoq. Sbri M. M. D __ Du, SIai SadIIaaa Hanoai. Sbri_ ...... ShriM.B. H-na. Shri J. N. JYAlSTBA 6, 1880 (SAKA) (Nineteenth Amend- Io6 ment) Bin HI4I.Shfi Muuri,.. DiD, Shri Raj.. Shri C. R. Raj_Sbri _RaI.SbrI j40tdwsju, Sbri H_iqU,Shri Mate, Sbri Rojcleo SiDab. Sbri Imbldu••••• Silri Math.... Sbri Haritb 0l0Dd00 Raju. Sbri D. II. Jc,boI SiDId>. Shri Mebmtn. Shri Bnl BibarI RamSewok,SbrI Jadbav Sbri M.L Mehta. Sbri J. R. Ram Sub,,"- SIaab. Dr. J_v; Shri Tultbidos Mehta, Sbri Jatb_ RomS_.Sbri JOIIif'nD Ram, Sbri Meikote. 0.. JIamobodnD. Sbri JaiD. Sbr .A. P. MeaIP. Sbri GopoI Datt RomobioImaD, Shri P. R. J...... ,mm. $briIIIoti MODO'" Sbri P.·G. Rammothm Cbettiar. Sbri JOdbe. Sbri MiDlmata. _d -..",.. Shri V.re. J ..... Sbri Mirza, Sbri BabI' All Il.a>clhlDi Du. Sbri Jbo. 8br; Yopadn MiIbn, Sbri BibbDti Ilompu... Sbrj M. Jotbl. Sbri A. C. Mitbn, Sbri B~ Raaajai SIaab. Sbrl Jotbi. Sbrimoti SDbIwIn Mitbn. Sbri M.P. RODe, Sbri JJodtbI. Sbri J. P. Misra, 0.. U. RoDiIt SiDah. Sbri XojIOibr. Sbri MimI. Sbri SbJ.... DJ>u Roo. Dr. K. 1.. Jtatbr. 8bri GoDri Sb_r MoiwIt)'. Sbri ~do Roo. Sbri HaamutIl Roo. Sbri J__ KaDotb. Sbri Hori VltbDII MobiuddiD. Sbri ltomble. Sbri Mob..... Sbri Roo. Sbri 1trisbDamowthy JtoDdoppm. Sbri S. MonIb, Sbri Roo. Sbri Mutbyol _1IO. Sbri Mo... Sbri It. 1.. Roo.Sbri~ JtappeD, Sbri Mol'e. Sbri S. S. Roo.Sbrl~ Ito",. Sbri P. N. MulwmDad I..DoiJ, Shri Roo.Sbri~ Jt&doria, Sbr' C. M. Mutme.Sbri RorIaDLoI,Sbri IteltbiDa. 8bri RiIb.... Muterjee. Sbri H. N. RouI,Sbri_ DodiIbr. Sboi Mmtby. Sbri II. S. RunmdaIe. Sbri ltboD. Sbri 0_ All M...d. Sbri M. S. Ray. Sbrimod Reauta KboD. 8bri s-.a Mutbitb. Sbri ReddIor. Sbri KboDDo. Sbri M .... OloDd NoIt, Sbri D. J. Reddy. Sbri RImatrIobo ltiDdoOLoI.8bri Nair. Sbri N. SnobIaD Reddy. Sbrimoti Yatbodo lOla v:er t Shri Nair. SbrI V_aD Ray. Dr. SaradiIb ~. Sbri Lilodbu NaIIoIroJo. SbrI Ray. Sbri BItb_ Kouiolll, Sbri H. V. NamblE. Sbri SodbuRam,Sbri ltripa SIwIkU. Sbri Nath Poi. SbrI Saba, 0.. S. It. JtriobDo. Sbri M. R. NoyU. Shri Mobm ...... Shri Rameob.... It_. Sbri M.It. Ni8IID. SbrImod Soltri SoIIoI, Sbri A. S. KUDbm.SbriP. Ozo, Sbri _ta,SbriS.C. Kunel. Sbri B. N. PoDde, Sbri It. N. S."ji Rupji, Sbri LUbm Du. Sbri PODCIey. Sbri R. S. S...r. Sbri _ LoI LB'hmiJr,nthermp., SbrilDati Pmcle1. Sbri Sujoo Sootyabbamo Dm. Sbrimati LoIit SeD. Sbri PmcIe1. Shri Vltb... NIIIa SeD, 0.._ Lnkao. Sbrl N. R. PaD. LoI. Sbri Sen. Sbri A. K Lami Boi. Sbrimoti PonobH. Shri SeD, Shri P. G. LamiD.... Shri Patel, 8hri CbboIubIW SabI-. Sbri J..oDita'. Sbri Potd. Sbri N. N. Shab. 8bri Mo_ MaIwIeo Pnud. Sbri Potd. Sbri P. R. Shab. Sbrimod Ja7ll_ Mobtob. Sbri Poti1. Sbri D. S. S_ Nath. Sbri MobOlD. Sbri_~ PodI, Sbri J. S. ShaDtaraiya,8br1 Mobitbi.__ Dr. SuItoD. SaaiiDi SbrIaWI PodI, Sbri S. B. Sbarmo, Sbri A. P. PatU. Sbri T. A. Sbanua, Sbrl D. C. Ma;itblo. Sbri PotDoik, Sbri B. C. Sh...... Sbri K. C. -.Sbri IDdeo J. Pottobbi _. Shri C. R. Sbubi Rauj.... Shri MaUiob. 8brl U. S. PiIIoi. Sbri Notanja Sha,tri, Shri Ramanuld. MDIIicI:. Sbri Ramo Cbadn _-,Sbri Sbee NaralD. Sbrl _.Sb.1 _.SbriN.... SbiDdo. 8br1 MmdaI,o..P...... p SiDab. Shri Sbukla, Sbri Vid,-. a.- M.-I, Sbri J. Pm!, Sbri D. D. SiddauaDi_ SbrI MuuIoI, 8bri Y-"- llqbUDath SiDab. Shri Sidditb. Sbri ~ RaPanmaitb. Shri Sidhetbwar Pruad, Shri IbDui.Sbri .. RoI, Sbrimod Sobo&oboI 'iDab. Shri D. N. ~_.SbrI RaI_.SbrI SiDab. SbrIIt. It • ... - .. ~ .... - .. ~-.. ---.... ~--.~'-"-.-.~ ..... ------.:.:~.::...~--..:.:" Slu", Areas MAY 2'1, 1964 (Improvement and Clev- 108 Anee) Ammdment mit AYB8-Contd. Sinha, Shri Satya Nara,.,. Swarm SinBb. Shri V.... PP •• Sbrl SIDha. Shrimati Ramdulari Tanti>. Shri Ramesbwar Vonkaiab, Shri KoB. SiDha, Shrim.ati Tarkelhwari Tbomu. Shri A.. M. Venkatuubbaiob, Sbri P. SiDhasan SiDsb. Shri Tiwary. Shri D. N. Venna,ShriK.K. Sivapprsha...... Sbri K.U.. Tiwary. Shri K. N. Vidya1anbr. Shri A. N. SODaVlPle, 8hri Tiwary. ShriR. S. Vijaya Anand&, Mabaralkum•• 80undaram Ramachandzan. Tomb~ Shri Vimia Deri, Sbrimatl Sbrimati Tripaobi. Shri KriIIma 000 Vishram Ptuad, Shri SOY. Sbri H. C. Tula Ram, Sbri Vyu. Sbri Radbelal ariDlyuan. Dr. P. Tyagi. Shri Wadi.a, Shri SubbUOllllD. Sbri Uitey. Shri Warior, 8hrj SubnmaDJO!D. Shri T. UIaka, Shri_ Wunit. Sbri Ba1kri.hn. Samat Pruad. Shri Vaishya, Sbri M. B. yada.... Sbri Ram Huth llurendra Pal Sinsh. Shri Varma, Shri M. 1.. Yedaft, 8hri B. P. Surya Pruad. Shri Varma. Shri aariDdra Yainit. Shri S ...... y. Sbri M. N. V.... boNppa, Shri YIII1If', Sbri Mohammad '''"'''Y. Shri M. P. NOES B.drudduja, Shrl Xam.i Sill8bli. Sbri RecId7. Shri NuuImha Buant Kunwari. Shrimati 1 Kobot Sbri seth, Shri BishaDchander Bbanu Ptllkash SiDlh. Shri Lahri Sinab, Shri SIwbanit Manj~ Shrima:i bftaaWliDl. Shri Lathmu MaIwwuIa, Sbri Sbutri. Shri PtIIkash V it Bbeel. Sbri P. H. Maaani. Shri M. R. Sinsh. Dr. B. N. Ch.udhary. Shri Y. S. PrItbri Raj. Shri SiDsba, Shri Y. N. Rajyaluml. Deo, Shri P. X. SiDsbri. Dr. 1.. M. Gayatri Deri. Shrimatl S_ SoIankI, Shri Ram Sinsh. Sbri G ....b. SbriP. K. Ram-,Sbri VjJaya Raj.. Sbrim.ti Himmataiobji. Shri Ranp, Shri Yashpal SiDsb. Sbri Kapur SiDsb. Shri Mr. Speaker: The result of the Chand Khanna on the 6th May, 1984. division is: namely:- Alles: 318; Noes: 81. ''That the Bill to amend the Slum Areas (Improvement and The motion Will adopted. Clearance) Act, 1956, as reported by the Joint Committee, be taken Shri Baap: We wa'lk out as a pro- into consideration." test the failure of the Chief Whip to give the assurance not to issue a whip Shri Balmiki was on his legs. He and the challenge hurled at the pea- may continue his speech sant masses by the Law Minister. Shrl BaDp aDd some other 1\on. ,"IIT"~ (~) : ft f'lnr.t q Members then left the House. it IJ'~ ~r Iffi;r (~CI1fT~) Shri A. K. Sea: Sir, I introduce the ~ fir.!' ~ ~ it ~ ~ tI>II Bill. ~'fl'flI;~it~~ii>'~m1I' lJ';;ft iIfufIi'f it '1''' i{fir i!T ~ ~ .m: lf~ ~ ~tr.f\' ~,. ~ ~T ~ ~ flI; "t ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 12.56 hrL Uii>' u.t't ;;rr I .m: SllT'I' ~-l 11ft 'I'J1i~ ~. I omit SLU'M AREAS (IMPROVEMI!lNT ~i ~ ~ ~ ~ fR, AND CLEARANCE) AMENDMENT f<;ro; BILL--eontd. !l~r;qi'{ ~~ IpJ' ~ ~ t I f1r~ ~ m ii>' f<;ro; ;;it ITII'')vr Mr. Speaker: The House will take IJ'~ 1111~ up further OOIl&ideration of the fdl- m i .mt t q'\'{ .rom it 1fT lowma motion moved by Sbri Mehl' ;m.mt~~tR~ it~~ Jog Sltim A'I'8G". JYAJSTRA 6, 188& (SAKA) (Improvement lind J 10 CIeCITllnCe) Amend- ment Bill 13 hrs. (f\';r ~ it>' ~ '1ft VTIfrar W N<'f IIiT m.ft ~ ~ ~lffl ;r ~)lR if ~Ifi fifoI;m ~ ~ ~ t ~ ~ ~ m;r~~:JIiI'::q~~~) W iii< m: it>' fuif ll;'F ~ 1fiT f.r\;r OINT ;;rrif ~ ~ W!iT~ I WTI!')vr m if~, mit>', 'SI"JI11I' ~ ~ I mGI' ~ ~ ;;f\1rr ll'l'R it>', ~-smr lI>'I' "();;it it>' Glfl'l'1fi m: ~~~it~~~ l!i1f R ~ ~ .ro .f.t;if ~ t I IliTfm ~ ~ 1fiT ~ I if ~\'iIl ~ ~ ij' ~ if \roI'i1iI' t ~~T'llTamrtf'l>'WN<'fit>' i;r iIlf \roI'i1iI' ~ I ~ ~ t f.!; i mT~~if qR ~ tfr;r ~ it>' ~ ~-smr 'lIT wm: 1fiT 1fir1f ~~iI;trr ~ ~ it>' ~ iI'r.I'f U-ir \'iIl1fi~ ~ 1fi1f ~'~~) ~ it>' ~ it>' fuif SI'lIt"f f.!;ln ~ wft,~'Ift~~t I ~~~ ~~~tflt;:JiI"~it>'fuif flfilfT \iI'lm ~ VTIfrar m if ~ \i[\'IR-lfI'tiI' it>' ~ ~ '" ~ \Vft ~ If"( ~ m~;f Ifir m ~ ~ ~ f.!;ln ;;mIT flfi ~ 'II'1i SP«ft f.!;ln \iI'lm ;it !qfGI' ~ ~ ~ t .;;it ;;it ~ ~, ~ ~ it>'~~)~iIft;Ifi~ it>'~~ W'$ &, V11IT ij- '1ft ~ ~ it>' ~, ~ Ifirif it>' ;:rqoU it>' ~ '1ft # ~, ~, ~,~~it>'~~~I~ ~,~~if\i[)~~'IIT SRmIT 'lIT amr f.!; m'f ~ S'Il'J'iI' ~ ~if'!firl!:)~t,q",~ I t ~~flfi~~~~lfiTli'titwm: ~~-~;r~,~~ Ifit ~ ~ 'Ii': lI>'I'~~it>'~~f.t;if~(, it>', qt 'lIT it wm: it>', qt~~1f~~it>'~~~ ~VTlfrarmif;f'lft'" it>' iI'~~\' ~, 1fif1f IIiT flfilfT ;;rrif, ~ ~il ~~~i!ft;mr~ w ~~it'lft~~tl ~m-u~iff == ~""&~1if~ti~ i i' j ~ '~.;;,,'"" ~ r;;'! dD~,~ 11+-~ ~ ~~'! '1Ir ~~ I'" i ~ I - ~!~-'Ii :Ifi I!o/~ .. .::: ~ Jr/~ <;is ~-"" II:; -rr tt.::" iij t ~ ~~ ~'WI ~ ~ 11.~ ::~ ~ f~ 'I:: ,~ U I II' ilt:·i!i;ii'i:~i!~~!lli~I~!:I!ii~i:;~~!i:l ~ IW~ ~ ~ ~ Ch ! ,~:~ ~~ ~: i~' ~ ~~.ifD" ~~ ~ ~ I~.E 3 !i: 1 i"i r::J! ! J! g;"it t ~ti.tr i [; 'Ii t .~~-li i ~ cit~ i ~$ ~! 4: rt-I ~t IV ~It-. i -~ ~~r,. ,,," ~ ~! ~ If: ~ i.. .. ~!~;~~iII"l~il!i;lti!~;;~~~~i~tt!I~lt~~~~~ ~~ ~~ ! ~f 1 _~: I "~~ ~1:: : ~ ! tT I ~,I! ~~ ~! ~1i i ~t ai ~ l;;~ ~ 1 ~ ~ f • . . 'If- If ~ ~ Ii - lr '!itt If 11+ I~:! ltd ~ _ Jg ~UgiiHi~U!H!!i!tHiiUHdid.~H!H ~ 1~1i ~i.~~W~~'Ii·g~~iiji,,~~j~';.rod~"""fI';'::~!;!;~""" ~ ~~ltiiit~ti~i;1Ji~J:~~i'i~I~'i~lfil!·! u ~!~~ljiJ!ii~!'itf-i.!1iI!I-~~~~I!'ii~!il!' il'i!'liI~~f'1dri'~t'iiJ'litRr~~ ;f!~i~iit!i!i~~i i ii!!!!!!~!iill!ili.;III~ fIl ~i ~Ii 'Ii i ~i't i i 1&~ i i 1d I~~ ~ ~ ~ i.; ; rr Ii t;: f.1ij j t ~ ill'II'~tj!li~~:r:'j;!~~~ 135 Slum Areas MAY 27. 1964 (ImprOvement IJ1Id C1ear- 136 alICe) Amendment Bill [sfI:~omr ~], ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ qo{t fif;' Iff f;;p:i\'mf urf~~ Ipt Zil 1f.Il:!' ~'iIT "1[,nl'nlej,foil·r, ., "'I <41'~ ~I'" --.1"'.'<. ,CfIRt· .... .m~ \;\"t fill ~i ~q;rr If.1l:!' ~ ~ {refn ~ if mrnr if ~~ ItiTl£ iii Ill'( I ~~ ~~ fif,ljf ;;j1{( \':'if tf'1 ~ 1f.1~ f~ if~~~IWRqlfi ~t ~ ~, "'1- , ~£ ~:~w:t ~ i ~"i ~ ~'~I'''r ~-~ar 'if: l t ~~ :e· t ~t t ~ !/~~!tliOJ - ~.~. ~If ~'''":I~'~: Ii --( ~~ 'I!: ~~ t ibd~ ~ ~ t ~,t i *.- -:Ji t ~1glIlY· f I~'~- i ~-: .~'~~:i tf: ~ ,It l ~ 'i ~'Ii; t ~*"''; ibd tIU' 1 til>":: ~'Ii; ~Ii ~~ ~W ~. ~ E; ,Ii , ~ ~1~~~i'i~1~rr;*"" **"',~~~-~'If~1f:~ i!i~t~~'1~ ~ .~~ibdl!~"~ !i~~~~.~~ii~ ~!!'if'~ i::f~- i.'~·rl!~ti il~ ~ li$'1?t'j:g1t;i1i;~W~~~,jf-II>"~aribd/~'~~'~~~~~~i~i~i.~:~'~~ ~ 1~:~~:rritiii!!~~I~II~::·I~1if~II!I!'1 ~ "i:i;~~i'~!i~~!:i ~!~~~~~'f~l~trit!~it ~i .. !! Slum Areas 139 MAY 27, 1964 (Improvement and Clear- 140 ance) Amendment Bill [l'.lT fi;r~HFr f~~] GT~ q-~aT ~ aT ~if; ~T~ ~T ~ 'll'~1' I would again submit that slum clearance is a very important problem q-ffCflif ~1~~nrT~lqf&<:r) em ~) «~)Uif f.r.r ;;r) f'" ~ t Mr. Speaker: It is the ereatest tragedy that could befall this country m~ ~ f~ 'fl ~ ~ ·Subsequently the sitting of the House for 28th May, IBM wu ceIl- celled. GMGIPND-LS 1-713(Aj) J..9D-9-.6-64-86'1.