M&U Ao. HH9ST -Tnam P/4: M
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
371 M&U Ao. HH9ST HEBREW WISDOM AS THE SITZ1MLEBEN FOR HIGHER EDUCATION IN ANCIENT ISRAEL DISSERTATION Presented to the Graduate Council of the University of North Texas in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY By C. Richard Wells, B.A., M.Min., M.A., Ph.D. Denton, Texas May, 1997 -tnaM P/4: M. 371 M&U Ao. HH9ST HEBREW WISDOM AS THE SITZ1MLEBEN FOR HIGHER EDUCATION IN ANCIENT ISRAEL DISSERTATION Presented to the Graduate Council of the University of North Texas in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY By C. Richard Wells, B.A., M.Min., M.A., Ph.D. Denton, Texas May, 1997 -tnaM P/4: M. Wells, C. Richard, Hebrew Wisdom as the Sitz im Leben of Higher Education in Ancient Israel. Doctor of Philosophy (Higher Education), May, 1997, 232 pp., references, 250 titles. This research grows out of an interest in what scholars commonly call the wisdom tradition of the ancient near east. This tradition or movement involved groups of thinkers and writers, known collectively as scribes, who were concerned in a philosophical way with the problems of living, and with principles of living well. Such communities are known to have flourished in Egypt, the various kingdoms of Mesopotamia, and western Asia, from at least the middle of the third millennium B.C. These scribal communities are also known to have sponsored schools, intended primarily for training in statecraft and the professions, but also for training in the scribal profession per se. The documentary and historical record indicates that such schools provided education from the most rudimentary level of literacy and writing to the most advanced levels of scribal scholarship. These advanced levels of training were functionally equivalent to what is nowadays known as higher education; and the ideals, the philosophy, which guided this enterprise found expression in a corpus of literature bearing the name "wisdom." The problem for this dissertation is whether or not there was in ancient Israel, specifically in the Solomonic era (10th century, B. C.), such an advanced scribal school associated with a Hebrew wisdom tradition. This is a research problem precisely because the evidence for such a school in Israel is both less abundant and less accessible than for the rest of the ancient near east. The beginning point of the research was a definition of "wisdom" (Chap. II), and a thorough analysis of wisdom in the ancient near east (Chap. III). The work then turned to the emergence of Solomonic culture in the context of Egyptian and Mesopotamian antecedents (Chap. IV), and analyzed important differences between Israelite and non- Israelite wisdom relevant to the question of a wisdom school (Chap. V). A summary of evidence for the wisdom school hypothesis concluded the research (Chap. VI). TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter ^a8e I. HEBREW WISDOM AND HIGHER EDUCATION: PROBLEM AND CONTEXT Introduction: Higher Education as a Problem Statement of the Problem Purposes of the Study Background of the Study Significance of the Study Definition of Terms Limitations of the Study Basic Assumptions of the Study Organization of the Study II. TOWARD A DEFINITION OF HEBREW WISDOM 28 On Defining Hebrew Wisdom: Some Problems Introduction Is Wisdom a Literary Genre? Wisdom as Canonical Literature The Social Context of Wisdom Toward a Definition of Hebrew Wisdom The Terminology of Wisdom The "Vocabulary of Wisdom" The "Moment of Truth:" Hebrew Wisdom as "Tradition" III. HEBREW WISDOM AND THE WISDOM OF THE ANCIENT NEAR EAST 54 Introduction: The Tradition of the Wise in the Old Testament Wisdom in the Context of the Ancient Near East: An Overview Historical Survey Ancient Near East Intellectual Culture and Literary Traditionalism in Wisdom Literature and the Schools of the Ancient Near East Literary Traditionalism, Scribes, and Schools Ancient Near East Wisdom Literature as a Literary Type Wisdom Literature and Wisdom Schools in the Ancient Near East Wisdom as the Raison d'etre of the Ancient Near East School Wisdom Literature and Primordial Wisdom The Actualization of Primordial Wisdom in the Wisdom Tradition Conclusion IV. THE RISE OF THE SOLOMONIC STATE IN INTERNATIONAL CONTEXT 101 Introduction: Old Testament Perspectives on the Wise Revisited The Amarna Age: Israelite Statehood and International Relations Introduction: Internationalism and the Rise of the Monarchy in Israel The "Great Fact:" Solomon's New State Solomon's New Culture in International Context The Amarna Age: Israelite Culture and the Influence of the Near East Social Stratification in Solomon's New State Conclusion: Observations on Solomonic Society and the Wisdom Tradition Social Stratification and the Wisdom Movement in Israel Hebrew Wisdom and Solomonic Historiography Solomon and the Emergence of the Wisdom Tradition The Wise King: Wisdom in Israel and in the Ancient Near East V. SOLOMON AS WISE KING AND PATRON OF WISDOM 141 The Solomonic Enlightenment The Social Location of Wisdom The Educational Interests of Wisdom Social Class and the Solomonic Enlightenment Hebrew Wisdom and Solomonic Historiography Test Case: The Date for Ecclesiastes (Qoheleth) Test Case: The Explicit Literary History of Proverbs Solomon and the Emergence of the Wisdom Tradition Philosophy of Kingship in Israel and in the Ancient Near East Outer Forms and Inner Forms The Wise King: Wisdom in Israel and in the Ancient Near East The Lay-Orientation of Hebrew Wisdom The "Wise King" Motif in Hebrew Wisdom Literature The King's Political Consciousness The Ambiguous Present: The Paideia of Hebrew Wisdom Conclusion: Hebrew Wisdom as a Program of Educational Rigor IV VI. AN INSTITUTION OF HIGHER EDUCATION IN ANCIENT ISRAEL: THE CASE FOR A WISDOM SCHOOL 186 The "Broad Hypothesis" of a Wisdom School: Summary and Critique Epigraphic Evidence of Formal Education in Israel The Educational Needs of the Solomonic State Biblical References to Institutionalized Education Biblical Texts Explained by Institutionalized Education A Case Study: The Epilogue of Qoheleth The "Broad Consensus" of Wisdom Scholarship The Epilogue and Ancient Near East Parallels The Epilogue as a Program for Higher Education REFERENCES 215 CHAPTER I HEBREW WISDOM AND HIGHER EDUCATION: PROBLEM AND CONTEXT Introduction: Higher Education as a Problem The emergence in this century of higher education as an academic discipline is problematic on several counts. Dressel and Mayhew (1974) highlight one obvious problem in their important study of this development; namely, that the field is "active" but "confused" (p. 31). It is covered by a vast literature, and marketed through dozens of graduate programs, but it lacks coherence, and often even recognition beyond its own circle. Hence, "[i]ts future," say Dressel and Mayhew, "is obscure" (p. 31). For those interested in philosophy of higher education, however, the emergence of the discipline creates somewhat more serious problems. The first is that formal study of higher education tends to limit its scope. That is, it tends to suppress the evidence that in virtually all cultures of all ages some enterprise serves at least functionally as the equivalent of higher education in this age. Westerners are accustomed to trace the roots of higher education to the founding of the great European universities in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries; or, perhaps to the academies of Greece and Rome. For many Americans, the history of higher education dates no earlier than Harvard College or the Land-Grant institutions. But all civilized people create mechanisms for education that from a philosophical point of view is equivalent to that which is now located in colleges and universities. 1 2 Second, institutionalizing the study of higher education (or education generally, for that matter) tends to distort the historic cultural meaning of education. It tends, in other words, to de-emphasize the philosophy of higher education as such, by focusing on content and processes. In his study of the Greek paideia, Werner Jaeger observed that "education embodied the purpose of all human effort" (Jaeger, 1945, p. xvii). One would no better understand the meaning of education in a culture by studying education, Jaeger believed, than one could assess the cultural significance of Handel's Messiah by completing a dissertation on quarter notes or piano forte. The meaning of education for any culture, he thought, did not lie primarily in either content or process, curriculum or pedagogy, but in the inculcation of cultural ideals. Third, the study of higher education tends to isolate the cognoscenti of the new field from informed and concerned observers in other fields. If higher education embodies cultural ideals, then anyone concerned about those ideals has a stake in the enterprise. Every academic discipline tends toward a closed shop mentality; and there are certainly those (one hopes few in number) who would say of scholars in higher education what John Brubacher says of scholars generally: "Only the scholar's peers, other scholars who have learned the discipline of scholarship, can constitute the court of last resort" (Brubacher, 1982, p. 130). Statement of the Problem A Preliminary Statement All of these problems point in different ways to the (fundamental problem that underlies this study. It arises from efforts to understand more fully an ancient Hebrew 3 cultural milieu which, though remote in time and substance, has gone so far in shaping the West. Western culture is still often called "Judeo-Christian," not least because Western culture falls heir both to the cosmology and the spiritual idealism of Hebrew tradition. This rich Judaic heritage has stimulated research on a number of fronts, but seldom in higher education. This research represents just such an undertaking. Put in its most basic form, the research could be said to focus on the core cultural values or ideals that constitute a philosophy of higher education in ancient Hebrew culture. As a way of clarifying this preliminary statement of the research problem, it will be helpful to recall the three concerns noted above and apply them to the study of Hebrew education.