A Sanpan Shan Chariot Ornament and the Xiangrui Design in Western Han Art Author(S): Wu Hung Reviewed Work(S): Source: Archives of Asian Art, Vol
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A Sanpan Shan Chariot Ornament and the Xiangrui Design in Western Han Art Author(s): Wu Hung Reviewed work(s): Source: Archives of Asian Art, Vol. 37 (1984), pp. 38-59 Published by: University of Hawai'i Press for the Asia Society Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/20111143 . Accessed: 19/12/2011 18:10 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. University of Hawai'i Press and Asia Society are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Archives of Asian Art. http://www.jstor.org A Sanpan Shan Chariot Ornament and the Xiangrui Design inWestern Han Art Wu Hung Harvard University THE DATE AND THE OWNER In 1965 the cultural relics team of Hebei province a in the People's Republic of China excavated three This chariot ornament belonged to set of chariot at was a large tombs Sanpan Shan,a Dingxianb county. fittings and used to join the handle of canopy in a With the advance of the Cultural Revolution to carriage.6 From pertinent archaeological evi the following year, however, the unearthed mate dence and relevant historical documents, we can were un a rials along with the relevant records left derive fairly clear idea of the date and place of its a attended in provincial storeroom to gather dust. manufacture, as well as of the status of its owner. They remained virtually unknown to all but the The three tombs (Mi20, M121, and M122, ac small number of persons directly concerned with cording to the designation of the Hebei^ Museum) ten one are their handling until years later, when of located side by side from east to west, facing a were on the artifacts from these tombs, chariot ornament, south.7 High earthen tumuli built top of was selected for exhibition in the United States.1 each grave, giving the place its name, Sanpan This was the first time an item from these excava Shan, which means "three circular mounds." Each was to a a tions shown the public; in the words of tomb has wooden chamber in vertical pit that Professor Li Xueqin,c "this particular work of art is further divided into parts, the front containing won the admiration of many during exhibitions funerary objects, and the back, the body of the both in China and abroad"2 (Fig. ia). deceased.8 Since this kind of wooden chamber ornament Inmy opinion, this chariot is signifi tomb, typical of the Western Han in Hebei prov art was cant for the study of Chinese history in two ince, later replaced by the brick tomb during as respects. First, Shi Shuqing^ has pointed out, it the Eastern Han period,9 this feature of the San a demonstrates outstanding skill in gold and silver pan Shan tombs provides valuable clue to the inlay of bronze.3 It could be said that in the chariot probable date of their construction. ornament this special technique reached its apex Lunu,B the capital of the ancient Zhongshan*1 a was following long development that began in the feudatory state during the Han dynasty, lo to Spring and Autumn period.4 Second, this piece cated in Dingxian county.10 According Li a epitomizes popular Han dynasty art motif that DaoyuanV Shuijing Zhuj four of the princes of were may be called the xiangruie (good omen) design. this kingdom buried in the vicinity of the This art motif has been discussed by various schol capital.n Archaeological finds confirm his report. ars, such as Laufer and Hay asi, who have each Three tombs, all located in suburbs of Dingxian, focused on Eastern Han variations of the Western have been identified as the tombs of Prince Huaik A.D. Han xiangrui design.5 To my knowledge, how (d. 55 b.c.), Prince Jian1 (d. 90), and Prince no one ever, has studied the Western Han design Mum (d. A.D. 174) of the Zhongshan.12 In tomb were itself. This article will discuss the date and subject M120 of the Sanpan Shan tombs, two seals matter of the Sanpan Shan chariot ornament, what found bearing the names of Liu Jiaojun11 and Liu the xiangrui design signified to the people ofthat Zhanshi.0 In tomb M121 was found a piece of to customs time, how this design related their and stamped clay that bears the royal title Zhongshan. ideas, and this motif's artistic realization. Another tomb, M122, yielded two bronze vessels 38 inscribed with the characters Zhongshan NeifuP figures in four scenes. This kind of inlaid pictorial was (the royal house of Zhongshan). Liu the fam work requires costly materials, highly skillful cut name an ily of the Han^ royal family, of which ting and inlay techniques, and extraordinary one Zhongshan was lineage. These finds indicate amount of meticulous work. To date we know of that these three tombs belonged to the royal fam only one similar chariot ornament, in the collec ily of Zhongshan state. For identifying the per tion of Tokyo Art Institute (Fig. 2).20 Since the sons buried in these tombs, a passage in the Shui decor of these two works has almost identical mo a jing Zhu provides valuable record: "The Kor tifs and shares certain artistic characteristics, and runs no River continues to flow eastward and north since comparable artifacts have been found in tu.s or of Bai The tomb of Prince Kang? (of Zhong the earlier later graves of Zhongshan princes son shan), of Prince Qing,u lies to the south. It can (though these graves contain some of the finest be identified as a group of three tombs built side inlaid work of the times), I would venture the by side."13 The ancient Ko River, now known as opinion that this kind of inlaid pictorial decora runs was 100 the Tangv River, north of the Sanpan Shan tion mainly used in the period around tombs.14 This correlation has led the author of b.c., as indicated by the date of the tomb at San to Dingxian Zhi to believe that the Sanpan Shan pan Shan belonging Prince Kang of Zhongshan east state. tombs that lie of the present Baitu village belonged to Prince Kang's family.15 From tomb THE XIANGRUI DESIGN M122, which is the largest of the three, came the most elaborate chariot the fittings, including The motif of the decor on the Sanpan Shan orna discussed in this article. These facts piece may ment has been called the hunting design.21 Similar that this was the of Prince suggest tomb Kang decorations have also been called animal designs. who was buried in b.c.16 The com himself, 90 other It ismy belief that these appellations are not tombs be those of his wife and son.17 even may pletely accurate because though the designs So far of the eight graves of five generations of consist of animals and hunters, their meaning rulers Zhongshan have been found in Hebei differs from that of the hunting designs of the As shown contents a ex province.18 by the of the Warring States period. Because new idea is when a a as graves, Zhongshan prince died, large pressed, Iwill refer to this motif xiangrui. number of chariots was often buried together Xiangrui refer to certain phenomena that the with a one. as him, including highly elaborate From people of the Han dynasty interpreted expres historical records and from the study of the tombs sions of the will of Heaven. For example, if beau of the Zhangshan princes, we know that this type tiful birds of multicolored feathers came to rest on of elaborate chariot was a status a symbol of the the palace roof, if the emperor found qilinx (uni This means a a or royal prince.19 that when former corn) during hunt, if one stalk of wheat had was prince's royal chariot buried with its owner, many ears of grain, it was understood to mean another one had to be made for successor. em his The that Heaven had bestowed its blessing on the ornament particular under consideration here be peror's rule. Good omens indicated that the ruling to a set of coun longs extremely elaborate chariot fit emperor was enlightened and governed his from tings the tomb of Prince Kang. Its date can try well. In contrast to the auspicious xiangrui the be estimated to no fall between and 90 b.c., the Han people considered other natural phenomena, of Prince as or years Kang's rule. such eclipses big gusts of wind, to represent Differing from all other chariot ornaments Heaven's dissatisfaction.22 This view of natural in found the tombs of Zhongshan princes, the phenomena already existed before the QinY dy a decor of the Sanpan Shan piece is complete pic nasty, especially during the Eastern Zhou.2 But torial at omens were more composition, skillfully inlaid with gold, sil that time evil frequently ver, turquoise, and gems, that successfully creates mentioned. The Spring and Autumn Annals (Chun mountains, plants, and 125 human and animal Q/waa) records solar eclipses and earthquakes 39 i Chariot bronze inlaidwith same.