Studies on the Biosynthesis of Porphyrin and Bacteriochlorophyll by Rhodopseudomonas Spheroides 2. the Effects of Ethionine and Threonine
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
550 Biochem. J. (1962) 83, 550 Studies on the Biosynthesis of Porphyrin and Bacteriochlorophyll by Rhodopseudomonas spheroides 2. THE EFFECTS OF ETHIONINE AND THREONINE BY K. D. GIBSON, A. NEUBERGER AND G. H. TAIT* Department of Chemical Pathology and Medical Research Council Research Group in Enzymology, St Mary'8 Hospital Medical School, London, W. 2 (Received 28 December 1961) Gibson, Neuberger & Tait (1962) mentioned RESULTS briefly that, when ethionine was added to suspen- sions of Rhodop8eudomona8 8pheroides illuminated Effect of ethionine on the 8ynthe8i8 of in 'mixture I' of Lascelles (1956), large amounts of porphyrins and bacteriochlorophyll porphyrin accumulated in the medium, although During investigation of the role of biotin in por- growth and bacteriochlorophyll synthesis were in- phyrin synthesis (Gibson et al. 1962), various in- hibited. This was rather surprising since other hibitors of growth were examined to see whether inhibitors of growth prevented the formation of they would prevent the restoration of growth and porphyrin and bacteriochlorophyll. In the present the synthesis of porphyrins and bacteriochloro- paper the effect of ethionine is described in more phyll when deficient organisms are illuminated in detail. Of a large number of other compounds only the presence of biotin. The compounds tested were threonine was found to have a similar effect. In the DL-p-fluorophenylalanine, 8-azaguanine, 5-bromo- presence of ethionine or threonine the synthesis of uracil and DL-ethionine. The first three are partly bacteriochlorophyll can be restored and porphyrin successful in preventing growth and porphyrin and excretion reduced by methionine or homocysteine. bacteriochlorophyll synthesis when added with These results suggested that ethionine exerts its biotin to biotin-deficient organisms illuminated in effect by interfering with the synthesis or utiliza- mixture I. In the presence of DL-ethionine, al- tion of methionine. This was confirmed when it was though no growth or bacteriochlorophyll synthesis found that the methyl ester group of bacterio- occurs, a large amount of porphyrin is excreted chlorophyll is formed from the methyl group of into the medium, even in the absence of added methionine. Some of these results have been biotin. Table 1 shows the results with DL-ethionine briefly presented earlier (Neuberger, 1961; Gibson, and also with DL-p-fluorophenylalanine. Ethionine Matthew, Neuberger & Tait, 1961). has the same effect on anaerobically grown organisms as it has on aerobically grown organisms (Table 2). Table 2 also shows that the effect of MATERIALS AND METHODS ethionine in promoting accumulation of porphyrins Chemicak decreases as the degree of biotin deficiency of the organisms increases. Identical results are obtained DL-Homocysteine thiolactone was obtained from Mann when organisms deficient in nicotinic acid or Research Laboratories Inc., New York; DL-ethionine from Roche Products Ltd., Welwyn Garden City, Herts; D- thiamine are muminated in mixture I with the ethionine, L-ethionine and DL-homoserine from the Cali- addition of DL-ethionine. fornia Corp. for Biochemical Research, Los Angeles; L- The absorption spectrum over the range 355- [Me-14C]methionine from The Radiochemical Centre, 610 m,u of the porphyrins accumulating in the Amersham, Bucks. The sources of other chemicals were as presence of ethionine is identical with that of the given by Gibson et al. (1962). porphyrins accumulating in its absence. The maximum of the Soret band in N-hydrochloric acid Methods is 401 me. Paper chromatography of the por- The organisms used, the conditions of growth and phyrins in the lutidine-water system of Nicholas & illumination, and the methods used for colorimetric esti- Rimington (1949) shows that no new porphyrins mations and for assaying enzymes were as described by are formed in the presence of ethionine, and none Gibson et al. (1962). of the porphyrins normally present is absent. The major porphyrin both in the presence and absence * Some of this work forms part of a Ph.D. Thesis sub- of ethionine is coproporphyrin. mitted to the University of London in July 1961 by G. H. Ethionine also stimulates porphyrin synthesis Tait. and inhibits formation of bacteriochlorophyll when Vol. 83 VMETEIONINE AND BACTERIOCHLOROPHYLL FORMATION 551 added to organisms illuminated in succinate and ('mixture II') they accumulate porphyrins al- glycine ('mixture IS', see Table 3). As pointed out though they do not grow or form bacteriochloro- by Gibson et al. (1962); (see also Lascelles, 1959), phyll. Ethionine also stimulates porphyrin syn- when organisms are illuminated in aminolaevulate thesis in mixture II, which contains aminolaevulate Table 1. Effect of DL-p-fluorophenylalanine and DL-ethionine on growth and the synthesis of porphyrin and bacteriochlorophyll in mixture I Organisms grown aerobically in the dark in medium S containing 0-8 pumM-biotin were harvested and illumin- ated under standard conditions for 26 hr. in mixture I. DL-p-Fluorophenylalanine (10 mM), DL-ethionine (10 mM) and biotin (40 lam ) were added where stated. In this and subsequent Tables the concentration of bacteriochlorophyll and porphyrins is expressed as pm-moles/ml. of illumination mixture. Non-illuminated controls were kept at 0° in the dark; under these conditions the concentration of bacteriochlorophyll does not alter. Dry wt. of Bacterio- organisms Porphyrins chlorophyll Additions (mg./ml.) (,um-moles/ml.) (pm-moles/ml.) None 1-08 2-8 10-8 p-Fluorophenylalanine 0-60 3.9 7-8 Ethionine 1-26 30-5 7-0 Biotin 3-24 4-9 38-6 p-Fluorophenylalanine + biotin 0-54 4-4 10-5 Ethionine + biotin 1-26 29-0 6-6 None (non-illuminated control) 0-96 1-1 4-9 Table 2. Effect of DL-ethionine on the synthesis of porphyrin and bacteriochlorophyll by normal and biotin-deficient organisms Organisms were grown anaerobically in the light in medium S containing the concentration of biotin stated. They were then illuminated under standard conditions for 20 hr. in mixture I. DL-Ethionine (5 mM) was added where stated. Concn. of biotin in Bacterio- growth medium Additions to Porphyrins chlorophyll (JAmM) illumination mixture (um-moles/ml.) (,um-moles/ml.) 40 None 13-2 17-6 40 DL-Ethionine 57-6 6-4 40 None (non-illuminated control) 0-0 12-2 2 None 4-8 8-0 2 DL-Ethionine 53-3 6-7 2 None (non-illuminated control) 0-0 11-7 0-8 None 3-6 4-7 0-8 DL-Ethionine 32-7 4-0 0-8 None (non-illuminated control) 0-0 8-0 0-4 None 1-8 3-6 0-4 DL-Ethionine 6-3 2-1 0-4 None (non-illuminated control) 0-0 3-3 Table 3. Effect of DL-ethionine on the syntheMsi of porphyrin and bacteriochlorophyU by organisM8 illuminated in different media Organisms grown aerobically in the dark in medium S containing 0-8 pmmi-biotin were harvested, and illumin- ated under standard conditions for 26 hr. in the media stated. DL-Ethionine (10 mM) and biotin (40 &mm) were added where stated. Dry wt. of Bacterio- organisms Porphyrins chlorophyll Medium Additions (mg./ml.) (Jum-moles/ml.) (,um-moles/ml.) Mixture IS None 0-87 3-6 3-7 Mixture IS Biotin 1-86 28-2 8-1 Mixture IS DL-Ethionine 1-17 37-2 3-6 Mixture II None 0-87 11-8 2-3 Mixture II Biotin 0-85 10-7 1-2 Mixture II DL-Ethionine 0-93 38-1 2-9 Non-incubated control 0-93 0-0 1-8 552 K. D. GIBSON, A. NEUBERGER AND G. H. TAIT 1962 (Table 3), but this effect appears to differ in nature Ethionine does not stimulate porphyrin excretion from that in mixture I or IS (see below). when added to organisms incubated aerobically in As shown in Fig. 1, DL-ethionine (final concentra- the dark in mixture I. No porphyrin or bacterio- tion 5 m ), when added to non-deficient organisms chlorophyll is normally formed under these condi- illuminated in mixture I, completely inhibits the tions. For the synthesis ofporphyrins and bacterio- synthesis of bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoids chlorophyll by organisms illuminated in mixture I, and only partly inhibits growth. However, the Lascelles (1956, 1959) found that all the components molar amount of porphyrin accumulating in the were necessary. In the presence of ethionine, presence of ethionine is twice as great as the sum of ammonium phosphate can be omitted. Of the the porphyrin and bacteriochlorophyll formed in metal ions in mixture I (Mg2+, Ca2+, Mn2+), only its absence. In a number of experiments this ratio Mg2+ ions are required for ethionine to show a was 3-4 (Table 4). Table 4 shows that even 0 1 mM- large effect on porphyrin excretion. ethionine stimulates porphyrin production, i.e. at a concentration at which it reduces bacterio- Effect of threonine on the synthesis of chlorophyll synthesis only slightly. At equal con- porphyrins and bacteriochlorophyll centrations of each the ratios of porphyrin accumu- In an attempt to elucidate the mechanism of lating were 1-5:1-2:1-0 for the L-, DL-, and D- action of ethionine, a number of compounds were isomers respectively. tested to see whether they had a similar effect when added to organisms illuminated in mixture I. The compounds, which were all tested at concentrations between 1 and 10 mm, were DL-methionine, DL- 6 120 - homocystine, DL-homocysteine thiolactone, L- 100.g cysteine, reduced glutathione and L- and D-penicil- 4 80 lamine, all of which contain sulphur; choline, 60 $:110 betaine, formaldehyde, DL-serine and methanol, all 24 40P40~0, 20 Zs of which are capable of yielding biologically active iIIuI J *- I C1-fragments; DL-norleucine, which like ethionine is ti 120_ 30 an antagonist of methionine for protein synthesis (Vaughan & Steinberg, 1959); acetic acid, acetalde- 20 0 hyde, ethanol, L-aspartic acid, L-asparagine, DL- I--60 0.