Bibliometric Analysis of Ongoing Projects 11Th Report September 2020
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Bibliometric analysis of ongoing projects 11th Report September 2020 Copyright ©2020 Innovative Medicines Initiative Prepared by Clarivate on behalf of IMI Programme Office under a public procurement procedure document reference: IMI.2018.OP.01. Bibliometric analysis of IMI ongoing projects 1 Disclaimer/Legal Notice This document has been prepared solely for the Innovative Medicines Initiative (IMI). All contents may not be re-used (in whatever form and by whatever medium) by any third party without prior permission of the IMI. Bibliom etric analysis of IMI ongoing projects 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................. 5 2 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 8 2.1 OVERVIEW ............................................................................................................................. 8 2.2 INNOVATIVE MEDICINES INITIATIVE (IMI) JOINT UNDERTAKING ................................... 8 2.3 CLARIVATE ............................................................................................................................ 8 2.4 SCOPE OF THIS REPORT .................................................................................................... 9 3 DATA SOURCES, INDICATORS AND INTERPRETATION ......................................................... 10 3.1 BIBLIOMETRICS AND CITATION ANALYSIS ..................................................................... 10 3.2 DATA SOURCE .................................................................................................................... 10 3.3 METHODOLOGY .................................................................................................................. 11 3.4 DATA COLLATION ............................................................................................................... 13 4 CITATION ANALYSIS – IMI SUPPORTED PUBLICATIONS OVERALL ...................................... 14 4.1 PUBLICATIONS FROM IMI-SUPPORTED PROJECTS ...................................................... 14 4.2 PUBLICATIONS FROM IMI PROJECTS BY DOCUMENT TYPE ........................................ 16 4.3 TRENDS IN PUBLICATION OUTPUT .................................................................................. 17 4.4 PUBLICATION OUTPUT BY COUNTRY .............................................................................. 19 4.5 PUBLICATION OUTPUT BY IMI PROJECT ......................................................................... 22 4.6 IS IMI PROJECT RESEARCH WELL-CITED? ..................................................................... 24 4.7 IN WHICH JOURNALS DO IMI PROJECT PUBLICATIONS APPEAR MOST FREQUENTLY? .............................................................................................................................................. 26 4.8 WHICH RESEARCH FIELDS ACCOUNT FOR THE HIGHEST VOLUME OF IMI PROJECT PUBLICATIONS? .............................................................................................................................. 30 4.9 IMI RESEARCH FIELDS WITH THE HIGHEST VOLUME OF PUBLICATIONS BENCHMARKED AGAINST EU-28 PUBLICATIONS OF THE SAME FIELD .................................. 35 5 CITATION ANALYSIS – AT IMI PROJECT LEVEL ....................................................................... 37 5.1 TRENDS IN PUBLICATION OUTPUT BY IMI FUNDING CALL .......................................... 37 5.2 SUMMARY BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSES FOR IMI 1 PROJECTS – CALL 1 ....................... 41 5.3 SUMMARY BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSES FOR IMI 1 PROJECTS – CALL 2 ....................... 43 5.4 SUMMARY BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSES FOR IMI 1 PROJECTS – CALL 3 ....................... 45 5.5 SUMMARY BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSES FOR IMI 1 PROJECTS – CALL 4 ....................... 47 5.6 SUMMARY BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSES FOR IMI 1 PROJECTS – CALL 5-10 .................. 49 5.7 SUMMARY BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSES FOR IMI 1 PROJECTS – CALL 11 ..................... 51 5.8 SUMMARY BIBLIOMETRIC ANALYSES FOR IMI 2 PROJECTS ....................................... 53 6 GEOGRAPHIC CLUSTERING ANALYSIS.................................................................................... 56 6.1 LOCATIONS WHERE IMI-FUNDED RESEARCH TAKES PLACE ...................................... 56 7 COLLABORATION ANALYSIS FOR IMI RESEARCH .................................................................. 68 Bibliom etric analysis of IMI ongoing projects 3 7.1 COLLABORATION ANALYSIS FOR IMI RESEARCH ......................................................... 68 7.2 COLLABORATION ANALYSIS BY IMI PROJECT ............................................................... 71 7.3 COLLABORATION METRICS FOR IMI RESEARCH........................................................... 84 7.4 COLLABORATION INDEX .................................................................................................... 94 8 BENCHMARKING ANALYSIS – IMI PROJECT RESEARCH AGAINST RESEARCH FROM SELECTED COMPARATORS .............................................................................................................. 96 8.1 IDENTIFYING COMPARATORS .......................................................................................... 96 8.2 TRENDS IN OUTPUT: IMI PROJECT RESEARCH COMPARED WITH SELECTED COMPARATORS .............................................................................................................................. 97 8.3 SUMMARY OF BIBLIOMETRIC INDICATORS: IMI PROJECT RESEARCH COMPARED WITH SELECTED COMPARATORS .............................................................................................. 112 ANNEX 1: BIBLIOMETRICS AND CITATION ANALYSIS .................................................................. 113 ANNEX 2: BIOMEDICALLY RELATED JOURNAL CATEGORIES .................................................... 122 ANNEX 3: TOTAL NUMBER OF WEB OF SCIENCE PUBLICATIONS FROM IMI PROJECTS BETWEEN 2010 AND 2019 BY COUNTRY ....................................................................................... 123 ANNEX 4: TOTAL NUMBER OF WEB OF SCIENCE PUBLICATIONS, PAPERS AND OPEN- ACCESS PUBLICATIONS BETWEEN 2010 AND 2019 BY PROJECT ............................................ 126 ANNEX 5: COLLABORATION INDEX FOR ALL IMI SUPPORTED RESEARCH PROJECTS ......... 129 ANNEX 6: BIBLIOGRAPHY OF HOT PAPERS AND HIGHLY-CITED PAPERS ............................... 132 Bibliom etric analysis of IMI ongoing projects 4 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report presents a bibliometric analysis of the Innovative Medicine Initiative Joint Undertaking’s (IMI JU) research published between 2010 and 2019, using citations as an index of academic impact and co-authorship as an index of collaboration. This is the eleventh report commissioned by IMI from Clarivate. The data show that IMI continues to perform well. To date, IMI projects have produced 5,943 publications which have been matched to the Clarivate Web of Science™. This represents a 20% increase from the 4,938 publications matched to the Web of Science in the tenth report, which covered IMI project research published between 2010 and 2018. Between 2010 and 2018, the number of IMI research publications increased year on year. However, in 2019, the most recent year, publication output had fallen slightly. Growth had previously been sustained by an increasing number of active IMI projects and the fact that by some of IMI 1’s longest running and most productive projects (e.g., BTCure) have now come to an end is almost certainly a factor in the observed change in trend. However, this is a single observation and should not necessarily be taken as indicative of a long-term change in trajectory which will depend on the output of new and future IMI 2 projects. The majority of IMI research (55.7%) continues to be published in high impact journals, i.e. those journals in the highest quartile (Q1) ranked by Journal Impact Factor, and the average Journal Impact Factor of all IMI project publications was 6.38. IMI research was wide-ranging from basic biological research to clinical practice. IMI project research has been published most frequently in the fields of Pharmacology & Pharmacy, Neurosciences and Biochemistry & Molecular Biology. The impact of IMI project research (as indicated by citation impact) has remained high, with an increase in citation impact since last year. The field-normalised citation impact of IMI project research (2.05) is over twice the world average (1.00), which indicates the research was internationally influential. Between 2010 and 2019, the field-normalised citation impact of IMI papers was considerably higher (80%) than the European Union’s (EU) average citation impact (1.14) in similar biomedical fields (journal subject categories). Over a quarter of papers from IMI projects were highly cited - that is, the papers were in the world’s top 10% of papers in the same journal category and year of publication, when ranked by number of citations. The output of individual IMI projects has also increased between 2010 and 2019. BTCure (Call 2) has remained the most prolific IMI project, with 680 publications as of this report. This is a 5.4% increase on the 645 publications attributed to BTCure in the previous report. However, this growth is slower than the growth for all IMI projects in aggregate; most likely because the BTCure project ended in early 2017. Projects funded by IMI are highly collaborative. Since the last report, an