196 Karl Gunther in a Rich and Important Study, Karl Gunther

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

196 Karl Gunther in a Rich and Important Study, Karl Gunther 196 book reviews Karl Gunther Reformation Unbound. Protestant Visions of Reform in England, 1525–1590. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2014, x + 284 pp. isbn 9781107074484. £65; us$99. In a rich and important study, Karl Gunther reassesses the character of the English church under the Tudors. Combing through both well-known and lesser-studied religious and polemical tracts, Gunther uncovers a “spectrum of voices” (p. 15) who called for radical change in the church. While radical ecclesiological visions have been typically ascribed to radical Puritans and separatists during Elizabeth’s reign, Gunther persuasively argues that these visions had existed in the minds of English reformers since Henry’s day. Gunther’s first and best chapter explores a wealth of radical ecclesiologi- cal expressions in the Henrician church, illuminating the extent of evangelical challenges to traditional institutions. Combing through the works of familiar figures such as William Tyndale, Robert Barnes, and François Lambert he tries to discover their opinions on a range of issues, including the eradication of bishops, the creation of new parishes, congregational discipline, and even the freedom for parishioners to form separatist congregations in case of theologi- cally or morally errant pastors. Perhaps even more important than their radical nature is the way these ecclesiological visions completely contradicted quasi- official publications of the 1530s and 1540s which claimed that the Bible had not set down rules of church governance and that therefore it was for the monarch to determine them. While chapter one antedates what scholars have considered for a long time to be later developments, chapter two ventures somewhere new. It investigates evangelical attitudes concerning peace and unity, widely recognized as vital to a healthy commonwealth, revealing that many radical evangelicals understood the Reformation to bring about ongoing battle between themselves, a godly minority, and the rest of the world. Far from establishing a national church or being aligned with the monarch, some evangelicals saw persecution as an inevitable consequence of faithful adherence to God’s truth, and Gunther shows that this conviction left no room for a unified national church, but instead rendered the king a partisan figure ruling divided subjects. Gunther also demonstrates that this ongoing battle between Christ’s followers and what they took to be Antichrist was not merely metaphorical, with evangelicals urging Henry viii to eradicate Christ’s enemies through violence. Chapter three treads on familiar ground, the topic of Marian anti-Nico- demism. Gunther argues that calls to reject dissimulation played a significant part in fueling the activism of more radical Protestants in the reigns of Henry © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, 2016 | doi: 10.1163/18712428-09601014 book reviews 197 and Mary. While that will not be news to scholars of the English Reformation, Gunther’s contention that the anti-Nicodemism ethos continued throughout the reign of Elizabeth will be. That a cohort of Elizabethan Protestants were anxious not to “deny Christ before men” (p. 100) even under a Protestant regime uncovers a relatively unexplored feature of Elizabethan Puritanism. Like anti-Nicodemism, Protestant ‘resistance theory’ developed in response to the hostile regime of Mary i. Also like anti-Nicodemism, it was supposed to have been spent as an ideological force by the time Mary’s sister Eliza- beth acceded to the throne in 1558. Gunther proves instead that this resistance theory was pivotal in shaping Elizabethan Protestants’ views on the task of reconstructing Protestantism in England. Through a close reading of James Pilkington’s 1560 commentary on the book of Haggai, Gunther demonstrates that God’s commandment to establish true religion even in the face of oppo- sition from rulers, had ongoing purchase for Puritans and separatists who did not believe reform happening fast enough. Chapter five again revisits an episode occurring under the reign of Mary which had later consequences under Elizabeth: the ‘Troubles at Frankfurt,’ a conflict among exiles concerning the use of the Book of Common Prayer. Long seen as part of an ongoing debate over adiaphora that extended from Edward’s reign through Elizabeth’s, Gunther makes the sharp observation that the debate among Frankfurt exiles did not, as other scholars have claimed, foreshadow the split between Elizabethan Puritans and conformists; rather, the arguments made by both sides would later be used by Puritans against the use of vestments. This underscores just how widespread opposition to ‘remnants of popery’ was in early Elizabethan English religious culture. Chapter six then revisits that vestments controversy of 1565–1566, paying special attention to the role that Catholic polemicists, usually sidelined in scholarly consideration of this debate, contributed to the public debates about vestments, adiaphora, and religious authority. Gunther trolls through works by Thomas Harding, Stanislaw Hosius, and others to reveal that these writers had a real impact on Puritan and conformist responses. The chapter also shows that the conformist case for wearing vestments was more robust than previously thought, and the overall result is a much fuller picture of this episode, including Archbishop Matthew Parker’s position. Chapter seven addresses the all-important claim to continuity that drove Puritan and conformist polemic in Elizabethan England. As radical Puritans became more vocal in their dissatisfaction with the slow pace of religious reform, their opponents charged them with abandoning the cause of earlier martyrs of the reformed English Church: Thomas Cranmer, Nicholas Ridley, and John Bradford. Gunther surveys the responses of Puritans and separatists Church History and Religious Culture 96 (2016) 179–234.
Recommended publications
  • Paul Ormerod1 and Andrew P. Roach2* ______Emergent Scale-Free Social Networks in History: Burning and the Rise of English Protestantism
    http://doi.org/10.5334/csci.9 Paul Ormerod1 and Andrew P. Roach2* _________________________________________________ Emergent Scale-free Social Networks in History: Burning and the Rise of English Protestantism 1. Volterra Consulting, London, UK and Institute of Advanced Study, University of Durham; [email protected] 2. Corresponding author. Department of History, University of Glasgow; [email protected] *We are grateful for comments from Dr. Donald Spaeth of the University of Glasgow and participants in the UK Social Network Conference, Queen Mary College, University of London, July 2007, the Global versus Local Dynamics on Networks workshop at the European Conference on Complex Systems, Dresden, October 2007and the European Network on the Economics of Religion workshop, Granada, November 2007. 1 Abstract There is a large and rapidly increasing literature which analyses social networks for which substantial amounts of quantitative data are available. Further, there is a growing and related literature on what is referred to by economists as ‘information cascades’ on such networks. However, there is little discussion of the specific events which lead to either the creation of a network in the first instance, or of how a network which is latent in terms of its awareness evolves into a network on which individual behaviour/beliefs are actually altered. In this paper, we describe the process of emergence and evolution of a historical cultural and social network across which the opinions and behaviour of individuals were influenced. We also illustrate how empirical networks can be reconstructed relying principally on information contained in qualitative, historical sources. The specific example we use is religious belief in England in the 1550s.
    [Show full text]
  • DISSERTATION-Submission Reformatted
    The Dilemma of Obedience: Persecution, Dissimulation, and Memory in Early Modern England, 1553-1603 By Robert Lee Harkins A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Ethan Shagan, Chair Professor Jonathan Sheehan Professor David Bates Fall 2013 © Robert Lee Harkins 2013 All Rights Reserved 1 Abstract The Dilemma of Obedience: Persecution, Dissimulation, and Memory in Early Modern England, 1553-1603 by Robert Lee Harkins Doctor of Philosophy in History University of California, Berkeley Professor Ethan Shagan, Chair This study examines the problem of religious and political obedience in early modern England. Drawing upon extensive manuscript research, it focuses on the reign of Mary I (1553-1558), when the official return to Roman Catholicism was accompanied by the prosecution of Protestants for heresy, and the reign of Elizabeth I (1558-1603), when the state religion again shifted to Protestantism. I argue that the cognitive dissonance created by these seesaw changes of official doctrine necessitated a society in which religious mutability became standard operating procedure. For most early modern men and women it was impossible to navigate between the competing and contradictory dictates of Tudor religion and politics without conforming, dissimulating, or changing important points of conscience and belief. Although early modern theologians and polemicists widely declared religious conformists to be shameless apostates, when we examine specific cases in context it becomes apparent that most individuals found ways to positively rationalize and justify their respective actions. This fraught history continued to have long-term effects on England’s religious, political, and intellectual culture.
    [Show full text]
  • Xerox University Microfilms 300 North Zeeb Road Ann Arbor, Michigan 48106 I I
    INFORMATION TO USERS This material was produced from a microfilm copy of the original document. While the most advanced technological means to photograph and reproduce this document have been used, the quality is heavily dependent upon the quality of the original submitted. The following explanation of techniques is provided to help you understand markings or patterns which may appear on this reproduction. 1.The sign or "target" for pages apparently lacking from the document photographed is "Missing Page(s)". If it was possible to obtain the missing page(s) or section, they are spliced into the film along with adjacent pages. This may have necessitated cutting thru an image and duplicating adjacent pages to insure you complete continuity. 2. When an image on the film is obliterated with a large round black mark, it is an indication that the photographer suspected that the copy may have moved during exposure and thus cause a blurred image. You will find a good image of the page in the adjacent frame. 3. When a map, drawing or chart, etc., was part of the material being photographed the photographer followed a definite method in "sectioning" the material. It is customary to begin photoing at the upper left hand corner of a large sheet and to continue photoing from left to right in equal sections with a small overlap. If necessary, sectioning is continued again - beginning below the first row and continuing on until complete. 4. The majority of users indicate that the textual content is of greatest value, however, a somewhat higher quality reproduction could be made from "photographs" if essential to the understanding of the dissertation.
    [Show full text]
  • '[A] Litle Treatyse in Prynte and Euen in the English Tongue': Appeals to The
    University of Tennessee, Knoxville TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 5-2010 ‘[A] litle treatyse in prynte and euen in the english tongue’: Appeals to the Public during the Early Years of the English Reformation Bradley C. Pardue University of Tennessee - Knoxville, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_graddiss Part of the Intellectual History Commons Recommended Citation Pardue, Bradley C., "‘[A] litle treatyse in prynte and euen in the english tongue’: Appeals to the Public during the Early Years of the English Reformation. " PhD diss., University of Tennessee, 2010. https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_graddiss/733 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. It has been accepted for inclusion in Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of TRACE: Tennessee Research and Creative Exchange. For more information, please contact [email protected]. To the Graduate Council: I am submitting herewith a dissertation written by Bradley C. Pardue entitled "‘[A] litle treatyse in prynte and euen in the english tongue’: Appeals to the Public during the Early Years of the English Reformation." I have examined the final electronic copy of this dissertation for form and content and recommend that it be accepted in partial fulfillment of the equirr ements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, with a major in History. Robert J Bast, Major Professor We have read this dissertation and recommend its acceptance: Thomas Burman, Palmira Brummett, Heather Hirschfeld Accepted for the Council: Carolyn R.
    [Show full text]
  • How English Baptists Changed the Early Modern Toleration Debate
    RADICALLY [IN]TOLERANT: HOW ENGLISH BAPTISTS CHANGED THE EARLY MODERN TOLERATION DEBATE Caleb Morell Dr. Amy Leonard Dr. Jo Ann Moran Cruz This research was undertaken under the auspices of Georgetown University and was submitted in partial fulfillment for Honors in History at Georgetown University. MAY 2016 I give permission to Lauinger Library to make this thesis available to the public. ABSTRACT The argument of this thesis is that the contrasting visions of church, state, and religious toleration among the Presbyterians, Independents, and Baptists in seventeenth-century England, can best be explained only in terms of their differences over Covenant Theology. That is, their disagreements on the ecclesiological and political levels were rooted in more fundamental disagreements over the nature of and relationship between the biblical covenants. The Baptists developed a Covenant Theology that diverged from the dominant Reformed model of the time in order to justify their practice of believer’s baptism. This precluded the possibility of a national church by making baptism, upon profession of faith, the chief pre- requisite for inclusion in the covenant community of the church. Church membership would be conferred not upon birth but re-birth, thereby severing the links between infant baptism, church membership, and the nation. Furthermore, Baptist Covenant Theology undermined the dominating arguments for state-sponsored religious persecution, which relied upon Old Testament precedents and the laws given to kings of Israel. These practices, the Baptists argued, solely applied to Israel in the Old Testament in a unique way that was not applicable to any other nation. Rather in the New Testament age, Christ has willed for his kingdom to go forth not by the power of the sword but through the preaching of the Word.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography
    BIBLIOGRAPHY Primary Sources Anonymous. The glasse of the truthe. London, Thomas Berthelet, 1532{?}. Barnes, Robert. A supplication made by Robert Barnes doctoure in diuinite, vnto the most excellent and redoubted prince kinge henrye the eyght. Antwerp, Simon Cock, 1531. ——. A supplicacion vnto the most gracious prynce H. the .viii. London, John Byddell, 1534. Bormelius, Henricus. The summe of the holy scripture, and ordinarye of the Christen teaching, the true Christen faith. Trans. Simon Fish{?}. Antwerp, Merten de Keyser{?}, 1529. Coverdale, Miles. Biblia The Bible, that is, the holy Scripture of the Olde and New Testament. Antwerp, Merten de Keyser, 1535. ——. The Christen rule or state of all the worlde. 1547{?}. Cranmer, Thomas (preface). The Byble in Englyshe, that is to saye the contēt of al the holy scrypture, both of ye olde, and newe testamēt. London, Edward Whitchurch, 1540. Dillenberger, John, ed. Martin Luther: Selections From His Writings. New York: Anchor Books, 1962. Elyot, Thomas. The boke named the Gouernour. London, Thomas Berthelet, 1531. ——. Of the Knowledg which maketh a wise man. London, Thomas Berthelet, 1533. ——. The Dictionary of syr Thomas Eliot knyght. London, Thomas Berthelet, 1538. ——. The Castel of Helth. London, Thomas Berthelet, 1541. ——. A Preservative agaynste Deth. London, Thomas Berthelet, 1545. ——. The Boke Named the Governour. London: J.M. Dent & Co., 1907. Erasmus. The Epistles of Erasmus from his Earliest Letters to his Fifty-First Year Arranged in Order of Time, Vol. II. Ed. F.M. Nichols. New York: Russell & Russell, Inc., 1962. ——. Collected Works of Erasmus: Spiritualia, Enchiridion, De Contemptu Mundi, de Vidua Christiana. Ed. John O’Malley.
    [Show full text]
  • Hugh Latimer (1485-1555) John Bradford (1520-1556) Martyrs of the English Reformation by Art Lindsley C.S.Lewis Institute Senior Fellow
    KNOWING & DOING A Teaching Quarterly for Discipleship of Heart and Mind This article originally appeared in the Spring 2008 issue of Knowing & Doing. C.S. LEWIS INSTITUTE PROFILES IN FAITH Hugh Latimer (1485-1555) John Bradford (1520-1556) Martyrs of the English Reformation by Art Lindsley C.S.Lewis Institute Senior Fellow UGH LATIMER i s Latimer began an intense study of the Scriptures. known as the greatest He often took long walks with Bilney, and they visited preacher of the English prisoners and those who were sick. Reformation. He was Latimer began preaching in the university pul- HHoften asked to speak before King pits, having a great impact on many who heard him. Henry VIII and King Edward VI. Becon, later Cranmer’s chaplain, said of Latimer’s He was a man who showed great preaching: courage and faith. Prior to his conversion, None except the stiff-necked and uncircumcised in Latimer was a leader of the op- Art Lindsley heart went away from it without being affected with position to Reformation doc- high detestation of sin, and moved unto all godliness trines at Cambridge University. He later wrote of that and virtue. period of his life: Preaching was important to Latimer because it I was an obstinate a papist as any was in England, in- was the means of salvation. Latimer said, “Take away somuch that when I should be made bachelor of divin- preaching and take away salvation.” He was also ity, my whole oration went against Philip Melanchthon strongly opposed to those ministers of his time who and his opinions.
    [Show full text]
  • Lambeth Palace Library Research Guide Sources for Clerical Dress
    Lambeth Palace Library Research Guide Sources for Clerical Dress 1 Introduction .................................................................................................................... 1 2 Reference Sources on Clerical Dress ............................................................................ 2 3 Liturgical and Other Ecclesiastical Reference Sources .................................................. 3 4 Historical Sources .......................................................................................................... 3 5 Biographical Sources ..................................................................................................... 4 6 Pictorial Sources............................................................................................................ 5 7 Portraits ......................................................................................................................... 5 8 Appendix One: Ecclesiastical Heraldry .......................................................................... 7 9 Appendix Two: The Legal Basis – A Short Bibliography ................................................ 7 1 Introduction This brief survey covers Lambeth sources for the costume of both pre-Reformation English clergy and post-Reformation Anglican clergy. Lambeth also holds some material relating to the dress of clergy of other denominations and countries. Clerical dress varied according to the occasion. The nature and use of outdoor, lay, convocation, court, choir, and liturgical dress were
    [Show full text]
  • The Marian Exile and Religious Self-Identity: Rethinking the Origins of Elizabethan Puritanism
    Perichoresis Volume 13. Issue 1 (2015): 17-36 DOI 10.1515/perc-2015-0002 THE MARIAN EXILE AND RELIGIOUS SELF-IDENTITY: RETHINKING THE ORIGINS OF ELIZABETHAN PURITANISM ANGELA RANSON * University of York ABSTRACT. This paper challenges historians’ portrayal of Elizabethan puritanism as rooted in the Marian exile of 1553-1558, through a fresh examination of three exiles who have been de- scribed as early puritans: James Pilkington, John Jewel, and Laurence Humphrey. By studying the value they placed on church unity, this paper brings out the fundamental differences be- tween the early reformers and the later puritans. It also demonstrates that the religious self- identity of these men pre-dated the accession of Mary. Thus, their exile was a means of strength- ening their faith, not finding it, and their return meant that there was more continuity between the Edwardian and Elizabethan churches than is often allowed in current scholarship. KEY WORDS: Religious self-identity, Protestant, exile, puritan, unity Introduction The reign of the Catholic Mary between 1553 and 1558 often provides a con- venient dividing line for the historiography of the English Reformation. The Reformation of Edward VI, which came before it, is portrayed much as is Edward himself: well-meaning and generally sound, but tragically lost far too soon. In contrast, the Elizabethan Reformation which followed Mary’s at- tempt to return to the Church of Rome is described as comparatively slow and awkward, plagued with the problems caused by three major parties. These were: the papists who still adhered to Rome, the conservatives who had managed to remain in England during the Marian years, and the exiles who returned ready to establish a new church that followed the Genevan ex- ample.
    [Show full text]
  • John Foxe's 'Acts and Monuments' and the Lollard Legacy in the Long English Reformation
    Durham E-Theses John Foxe's 'Acts and Monuments' and the Lollard Legacy in the Long English Reformation ROYAL, SUSAN,ANN How to cite: ROYAL, SUSAN,ANN (2014) John Foxe's 'Acts and Monuments' and the Lollard Legacy in the Long English Reformation, Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/10624/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk 2 John Foxe's Acts and Monuments and the Lollard Legacy in the Long English Reformation Susan Royal A Thesis Presented for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Durham University Department of Theology and Religion 2013 Abstract This thesis addresses a perennial historiographical question of the English Ref- ormation: to what extent, if any, the late medieval dissenters known as lollards influenced the Protestant Reformation in England. To answer this question, this thesis looks at the appropriation of the lollards by evangelicals such as William Tyndale, John Bale, and especially John Foxe, and through them by their seven- teenth century successors.
    [Show full text]
  • The Elizabethan Protestant Press: a Study of the Printing and Publishing of Protestant Literature in English
    THE ELIZABETHAN PROTESTANT PRESS: A STUDY OF THE PRINTING AND PUBLISHING OF PROTESTANT RELIGIOUS LITERATURE IN ENGLISH, EXCLUDING BIBLES AND LITURGIES, 1558-1603. By WILLIAN CALDERWOOD, M.A., B.D. Submitted for the Ph.D. degree, University College. (c\ (LONBI 2 ABSTRACT Uninterrupted for forty-five years, from 1558 to 1603, Protestants in England were able to use the printing press to disseminate Protestant ideology. It was a period long enough for Protestantism to root itself deeply in the life of the nation and to accumulate its own distinctive literature. English Protestantism, like an inf ant vulnerable to the whim of a parent under King Henry VIII, like a headstrong and erratic child in Edward's reign, and like a sulking, chastised youth in the Marian years, had come of age by the end of the Elizabethan period. At the outset of Elizabeth's reign the most pressing religious need was a clear, well-reasoned defence of the Church of England. The publication of Bishop Jewel's Apologia Ecclesiae Anglicanae in 1562 was a response to that need and set the tone of literary polemics for the rest of the period. It was a time of muscle- flexing for the Elizabethan Church, and especially in the opening decades, a time when anti-Catholicism was particularly vehement. Consistently throughout the period, when Queen and country were threatened by Catholic intrigues and conspiracies, literature of exceptional virulence was published against Catholicism. But just as the press became an effective tool for defenders and apologists of the Church of England, it soon was being used as an instrument to advance the cause of further reform by more radical Protestants.
    [Show full text]
  • The Elizabethan Age 1558-1603 (Unit 1)
    KNOWLEDGE ORGANISER: The Elizabethan Age 1558-1603 (Unit 1) Key Question 7: Why did the Puritans become an increasing threat during Elizabeth’s reign? KEY EVENTS/ TIMELINE KEY VOCABULARY KEY PEOPLE 1566 Puritans- An extreme Protestant who wanted very plain churches and simple services. A Professor at Cambridge University, he gave a series of lectures The Vestments Controversy Thomas calling for a Presbyterian church system. His system would have Cartwright weakened the power of Elizabeth as Supreme Governor, which is why 1570 Calvinists- Supporters of the French Catholic, John Calvin. He believed she bitterly rejected his ideas and he was forced to flee to Geneva. Proposals by Thomas Cartwright in abolishing bishops. A Puritan, Stubbs wrote a pamphlet criticising Elizabeth’s marriage talks with the Duke of Anjou, a Catholic. Elizabeth was so unhappy 1579 Moderate Puritans- A Puritan who reluctantly accepted Elizabeth’s John Stubbs Religious Settlement. that she had him arrested and charged with ‘seditious writing’. He French marriage pamphlet of John Stubbs was sentenced to have his right hand cut off and later imprisoned. 1583 Some MPs attempted to use Parliament to further their Puritan Presbyterians- Wanted even simpler services, established in Scotland. Three Articles idea. Elizabeth closed down Parliament before the ideas of Walter Puritan MPs Strickland could be discussed. Peter Wentworth demanded MPs be allowed to discuss religion in Parliament and was imprisoned as a 1588-89 Separatists- The most radical Puritan who wanted to break away from result. The Marprelate Tracts the national church and run churches parish by parish. Archbishop of Canterbury from 1559 to 1575, he issued a book 1593 Prophesyings- Meetings of ministers and other interested people in laying down the rules for wearing vestments.
    [Show full text]