Terrorism Democracy.Pdf (1.307Mb)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Terrorism Democracy.Pdf (1.307Mb) TERRORISM, DEMOCRACY, AND THE APOCALYPTIC NARRATIVE Kari Milner Strøm MASTER I POLITIVITENSKAP 2011 1 2 Abstract The ‘war on terror’ that President George W. Bush declared following the attacks on the United States on 11 September 2001 is conducted on many levels, one of which is the debate concerning the need to ‘balance’ security and human rights. His early announcement that ‘you’re either with us or against us’ reinforces dualistic construction and leaves little room for a diversity of opinions and, consequently, for a comprehensive and clear-headed assessment of the means with which the war is being fought. Indicative of the fundamental human rights principles at stake is the question of whether the terrorist threat justifies the use of torture. Despite recent speculation that the war on terror might have been over with the killing of Osama bin Laden the open-ended process of ‘securitizing’ societies in order to minimize threat is likely to continue. The numerous textual and anecdotal glimpses included in this thesis aim to shed some light on how the articulation of threat among politicians and security professionals in particular creates more lay anxiety than necessary, and how everything from the focus on binary opposites to myths surrounding policing, media coverage of terrorist acts, the disciplinary power of the state, the voices of academia, and everyday conversations about surveillance can deeply affect democracy, perceptions of risk, terrorism and ‘the Other’. 3 Acknowledgments The first person I would like to thank is my supervisor, Ivar Fahsing, whose policing input and reading suggestions have been invaluable and whose no-nonsense approach is greatly appreciated. He also provided me with much needed encouragement that will keep me going for a while… The Norwegian Police University College also deserves thanks for giving me the opportunity to delve into an interesting and important area of study by admitting me to the Masters programme in Police Science. Lastly, I am grateful for the support from friends and family who are still wondering why I chose to do this. KMS Oslo, 1 June 2011 4 Table of contents Terrorism, democracy, and the apocalyptic narrative ..........................................................................1 Abstract ..............................................................................................................................................3 Acknowledgments ..............................................................................................................................4 1. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................7 2. The apocalyptic narrative ................................................................................................................9 2.1 Human rights in the age of counter-terrorism ......................................................................... 13 2.2 World leaders and public opinion post-9/11 ............................................................................ 15 3. Theoretical framework and research tools .................................................................................... 16 3.1 Ethical concerns ...................................................................................................................... 21 4. Key concepts in use ....................................................................................................................... 21 4.1 The narrative ........................................................................................................................... 21 4.2 Terrorism ................................................................................................................................ 23 4.3 Liberal democracies................................................................................................................. 27 4.4 Universal human rights............................................................................................................ 30 4.5 The ‘othering’ process ............................................................................................................. 31 4.6 Surveillance ............................................................................................................................. 35 4.7 The police................................................................................................................................ 37 5. The voices in the terrorism debate ................................................................................................ 39 5.1 The language of politicians ...................................................................................................... 39 5.2 The role of the media .............................................................................................................. 42 5.2.1 The relationship between terrorists and the media........................................................... 46 5.3 The everyday vernacular and life under GWOT and hyper-control ........................................... 48 5.4 Academic voices in the surveillance and security discourse ..................................................... 51 5.4.1 The panopticon, surveillance and visibility ........................................................................ 51 5.4.2 The surveillant assemblage ............................................................................................... 52 5.4.3 The role of counter-terrorism and surveillance studies ..................................................... 55 5.5 Summing up the voices and the discourse ............................................................................... 56 6. The politics of terrorism and counter-terrorism............................................................................. 57 6.1 A state of emergency .............................................................................................................. 60 6.2 Exceptionalism ........................................................................................................................ 62 6.2.1 How exceptional was 9/11? .............................................................................................. 63 6.3 Executive prerogative and neo-conservatism .......................................................................... 65 5 6.4 Secrecy and national security .................................................................................................. 70 6.5 The temporal factor: Futur anterieur ....................................................................................... 73 6.6 Terrorism and its causes .......................................................................................................... 75 7. Delegating the task of governing and policing unease ................................................................... 78 7.1 Policing myths and dilemmas .................................................................................................. 79 7.2 Racial/religious profiling .......................................................................................................... 84 7.3 Transparency, accountability and the rule of law ..................................................................... 89 7.4 The thick green line ................................................................................................................. 91 8. Surveillance, counter-terrorism and human rights ......................................................................... 92 8.1 The lack of resistance to counter-terrorism and surveillance ................................................... 93 8.2 Rights skepticism ..................................................................................................................... 94 8.3 ‘Balancing’ security and rights ................................................................................................. 97 9. Threats to our sense of security .................................................................................................... 99 9.1 Challenges to democracy ....................................................................................................... 101 10. Can SWOT shed some light on GWOT? ...................................................................................... 105 10.1 The rule of law .................................................................................................................... 106 10.2 An open society ................................................................................................................... 107 10.3 Resistance and public engagement ...................................................................................... 107 10.4 Democratic policing ............................................................................................................. 109 10.5 Community relations and diversity ...................................................................................... 109 10.6 Resources and resilience ..................................................................................................... 110 11. Summary and conclusion .......................................................................................................... 111 Bibliography.................................................................................................................................... 115
Recommended publications
  • Swedish Literature on the British Market 1998-2013: a Systemic
    Swedish Literature on the British Market 1998-2013: A Systemic Approach Agnes Broomé A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy UCL Department of Scandinavian Studies School of European Languages, Culture and Society September 2014 2 I, Agnes Broomé, confirm that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Where information has been derived from other sources, I confirm that this has been indicated in the thesis. …............................................................................... 3 4 ABSTRACT This thesis examines the role and function of contemporary Swedish fiction in English translation on the British book market in the period 1998-2013. Drawing on Bourdieu’s Field Theory, Even Zohar’s Polysystem Theory and DeLanda’s Assemblage Theory, it constructs a model capable of dynamically describing the life cycle of border-crossing books, from selection and production to marketing, sales and reception. This life cycle is driven and shaped by individual position-takings of book market actants, and by their complex interaction and continual evolution. The thesis thus develops an understanding of the book market and its actants that deliberately resists static or linear perspectives, acknowledging the centrality of complex interaction and dynamic development to the analysis of publishing histories of translated books. The theoretical component is complemented by case studies offering empirical insight into the model’s application. Each case study illuminates the theory from a different angle, creating thereby a composite picture of the complex, essentially unmappable processes that underlie the logic of the book market. The first takes as its subject the British publishing history of crime writer Liza Marklund, as well as its wider context, the Scandinavian crime boom.
    [Show full text]
  • The Historian-Filmmaker's Dilemma: Historical Documentaries in Sweden in the Era of Häger and Villius
    ACTA UNIVERSITATIS UPSALIENSIS Studia Historica Upsaliensia 210 Utgivna av Historiska institutionen vid Uppsala universitet genom Torkel Jansson, Jan Lindegren och Maria Ågren 1 2 David Ludvigsson The Historian-Filmmaker’s Dilemma Historical Documentaries in Sweden in the Era of Häger and Villius 3 Dissertation in History for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy presented at Uppsala University in 2003 ABSTRACT Ludvigsson, David, 2003: The Historian-Filmmaker’s Dilemma. Historical Documentaries in Sweden in the Era of Häger and Villius. Written in English. Acta Universitatis Upsalien- sis. Studia Historica Upsaliensia 210. (411 pages). Uppsala 2003. ISSN 0081-6531. ISBN 91-554-5782-7. This dissertation investigates how history is used in historical documentary films, and ar- gues that the maker of such films constantly negotiates between cognitive, moral, and aes- thetic demands. In support of this contention a number of historical documentaries by Swedish historian-filmmakers Olle Häger and Hans Villius are discussed. Other historical documentaries supply additional examples. The analyses take into account both the produc- tion process and the representations themselves. The history culture and the social field of history production together form the conceptual framework for the study, and one of the aims is to analyse the role of professional historians in public life. The analyses show that different considerations compete and work together in the case of all documentaries, and figure at all stages of pre-production, production, and post-produc- tion. But different considerations have particular inuence at different stages in the produc- tion process and thus they are more or less important depending on where in the process the producer puts his emphasis on them.
    [Show full text]
  • Signatures of the Possible: Writing and Political Rupture in the Archives of Industrial Unionism
    SIGNATURES OF THE POSSIBLE: WRITING AND POLITICAL RUPTURE IN THE ARCHIVES OF INDUSTRIAL UNIONISM By MICHAEL VASTOLA A DISSERTATION PRESENTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA 2010 1 © 2010 Michael Vastola 2 To my parents, Janis and Anthony Vastola, and to my wife, Jessica Livingston This would not be possible without their love and almost pathological generosity 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This dissertation has benefited from the advice and guidance I have received throughout my time at the University of Florida. My dissertation director Sidney Dobrin consistently encouraged experimentation and even audacity in my writing. My committee members supplemented that license to experiment with some brutal lessons during my exams. John Leavey coached me into a deeper understanding of what was at stake in the differences between the theories I was then ham-handedly trying to compare. Raul Sanchez compelled me to clarify my ideas and to more rigorously articulate their relationship to existing scholarship in my field. Those difficult lessons, as well as the valuable encouragement of my outside reader, Robert Hatch, were instrumental in shaping the document I would ultimately defend. The drafts of several of my chapters benefited significantly from the advice of my fellow traveler, Jeffry Ginger Rice, who was even more valuable in his capacity as a sounding board for my incessant complaining about academic conventions. But my wife, Jessica Livingston, was just as important an outlet for my frustrations. Without her encouragement and vocal insistence that I finish in a timely manner, this project would have surely stalled numerous times, and might have even been abandoned.
    [Show full text]
  • Larin Paraske, Finnish Folk Poet
    NO. 76 | F AL L 2018 a quarterly publication of the ata’s literary SOURCE division FEATURING NORTHERN LIGHTS LD PROGRAM, ATA 59 CONTEMPORARY SCANDINAVIAN LITERATURE LARIN PARASKE, FINNISH FOLK POET REVIEW: Misha Hoekstra’s translation of the Danish novel Mirror, Shoulder, Signal WORDS, WORDS, WORDS: Our isoisä from Vaasa SOURCE | Fall 2018 1 IN THIS ISSUE FROM THE EDITORS.................................................................3 SUBMISSION GUIDELINES .....................................................4 LETTER FROM THE LD ADMINISTRATOR ..........................5 LD PROGRAM AND SPEAKER BIOS FOR ATA 59................7 READERS’ CORNER.................................................................11 LARIN PARASKE, FINNISH FOLK POET/SINGER by Frances Karttunen..................................................................13 CONTEMPORARY SCANDINAVIAN LITERATURE by Michael Meigs.........................................................................25 REVIEW OF MISHA HOEKSTRA’S TRANSLATION OF MIRROR, SHOULDER, SIGNAL by Dorthe Nors by Michele Aynesworth...............................................................37 WORDS WORDS WORDS COLUMN: Our isoisä from Vaasa..................................................................44 by Patrick Saari BY THE WAY: TOONS by Tony Beckwith........................................................24, 36, 43 CREDITS....................................................................................49 © Copyright 2018 ATA except as noted. SOURCE | Fall 2018 2 From the Editors he Nordic countries
    [Show full text]
  • Wavelength Midlo Center for New Orleans Studies
    University of New Orleans ScholarWorks@UNO Wavelength Midlo Center for New Orleans Studies 2-1986 Wavelength (February 1986) Connie Atkinson University of New Orleans Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.uno.edu/wavelength Recommended Citation Wavelength (February 1986) 64 https://scholarworks.uno.edu/wavelength/56 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the Midlo Center for New Orleans Studies at ScholarWorks@UNO. It has been accepted for inclusion in Wavelength by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UNO. For more information, please contact scholarworks@uno.edu. UNIVERSI COS50 12/31199 BULK RATE EARL KLON6 LIBRARY tnL U. S. POSTAGE UNIV OF N.O. PAID ACQUISITIONS DEPT I N.O., LA 70148 ·VV39 Lt} COL. VIITDANS AT DAVID MON. -THUR. 1o-1 0 FRI. & SAT. 10-11 SUN. NOON-9 885-4200 Movies, Music & More! METAIRIE NEWORLEANS ¢1NEW LOCATIONJ VETmiANS ..,.~ sT. AT ocTAVIA formerly Leisure Landing 1 BL EAST OF CAUSEMY MON.-SAT. 1o-10 • MON.-SAT. 1o-10 SUN. NOON-8 SUN. NOON-9 88t-4028 834-8550 f) I ISSUE NO. 64 • FEBRUARY 1986 w/m not sure. but I'm almost positive. thai all music came from New Orleans.·· Ernie K-Doe. 1979 Features Flambeaux! ...................... 18 Slidell Blues . ......... ............ 20 James Booker . .................... 23 Departments February News . 4 Caribbean . 6 New Bands ....................... 8 U.S. Indies . ...................... 10 Rock ............................ 12 16-track Master Recorder: Movies .......................... 15 Reviews ........ ................ 17 Fostex B-16 February Listings ................. 25 Classifieds ....................... 29 Last Page . ....................... 30 COVER ART BY SKIP BOLEN Two #l hits in October. Member of NetWOfk Next? Puhlhhu. 'aun1an S S.ullt f..ditc•r .
    [Show full text]
  • Department of Scandinavian Studies
    DEPARTMENT OF Scandinavian Studies Message from the Chair TERJE LEIREN Celebrating the centennial of its founding is a significant milestone for any institution, no less an academic department at a major research university. Since its establishment by an act of the Washington State Legislature in 1909, the Department of Scandinavian Studies has grown and prospered, largely due to the dedication of its faculty and staff and the excellent character and quality of its students. To com- memorate the milestone, several celebratory events, including lectures, dinners, special programs, and conferences are being scheduled between now and the summer of 2010. Please stay in touch with us, check our departmental website, and plan to attend as many events as you can over the next two years. Of course, at the heart of what we do in the Department is teaching and scholarship. Cutting-edge research and innovative teaching enhance and broaden our knowledge about, and appreciation of, the Nordic region. Our comprehensive language programs and wide range of course offerings focusing on the five Nordic countries and the three Baltic countries make the Department unique in the world. The UW is the only North American university that regularly teaches Estonian, Latvian and Lithuanian. In 2009–2010, we will celebrate the 15th anniversary of the Baltic Studies program. By its very nature, the teaching at a research university is informed by the research of its teachers. All of the faculty in the Department of Scandinavian Studies are active scholars who bring their SPRING 2008 research back into the classroom, whether it be for a graduate seminar on literary theory, a discus- sion of Strindberg’s Paris, a broad introductory course on Scandinavian culture, or an advanced undergraduate course on the cinematic expressions of Scandinavian attitudes about sexuality or crime fiction.
    [Show full text]
  • Guilloutinen
    Paul Frigyes Guilloutinen Biografi om Jan Guillou Lindelöws Bokförlag 3 Innehåll Förord november 2014 • 7 Akt 1 Ikonen • 9 Akt 2 Vägen till scenen • 25 Akt 3 I Botolfsens trädgård • 97 Akt 4 TV-stjärnan och folkhjälten • 151 Akt 5 Berättare med ett kall • 211 Akt 6 Krönikor, agitation och bataljer • 239 Akt 7 KGB och kalla krigets återkomst • 263 Akt 8 Enmansprocessionen • 283 Akt 9 Åter till Saltis • 291 Epilog Därför stoppades boken • 293 Jan Guillous bokutgivning • 303 Källor • 305 Personregister • 309 5 Förord – Men varför vill du egentligen skriva en bok om Jan? Jan Guillous fru Ann-Marie Skarp ställer frågan i ett skeptiskt tonfall när hon tar emot mig i sitt rum på Piratförlaget, på Öster- malm. Jag finner frågan besynnerlig. Självfallet är väl en av de mest kontroversiella och centrala gestalterna i senaste halvseklets me- dievärld intressant för många. En rimligare fråga vore varför ingen tidigare skrivit en bok om honom. Ann-Marie Skarp ser inte nöjd ut efter mitt svar. – Är det en skandalbok? – Inte alls. Mitt svar är uppriktigt menat. Jag vill förstå personen, yrkes- mannen och fenomenet Jan Guillou. Dessa tre aspekter hänger givetvis ihop. Men de är också nästan besynnerligt skilda åt. Många avskyr personen Guillou, respekterar yrkesmannen men älskar fenomenet Guillou. Så hur hänger de tre delarna ihop? Först har vi personen, hans drivkrafter och bakgrund som berät- telserna har sitt upphov i. Våra egna liv är ofta målade i gråskalor, i Guillous berättelser härskar de bjärta färgerna. Vad i hans egna livserfarenheter ger upphov till detta? Sedan har vi historien om yrkesmannen Jan Guillou.
    [Show full text]
  • Mass Effect! Action! Drama! War! Romance!
    Story: In the year 2148, explorers on Mars discovered the remains of an ancient spacefaring civilization. In the decades that followed, these mysterious artifacts revealed startling new technologies, enabling travel to the furthest stars. The basis for this incredible technology was a force that controlled the very fabric of space and time. They called it the greatest discovery in human history. The civilizations of the galaxy call it... --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Intro: Element Zero! You're going to be hearing that term (or eezo) a lot from now on. It'll be used to justify faster-than-light travel, energy shields, even glowy space psychic people. Why? Because you get to spend the next 10 years in the sci-fi adventure setting of Mass Effect! Action! Drama! War! Romance! You will begin your adventure in the year 2181. For the record, the first Mass Effect takes place in 2183, Mass Effect 2 takes place in 2185, and Mass Effect 3 kicks off in 2186. You get a few years to get yourself ready for the impending Reaper (sentient starship) invasion. You might even be able to stop it yourself. Remember, you probably know information (or can learn it by just reading the Jump) that could save a lot of lives if you can get people to believe you. Cerberus' (human supremacist organization headed by the Illusive Man) antics, the Collectors, all of that information could be resolved with less fuss if you can get the word out to the right people. You'll have to survive though. Good luck with that! Go join up with Shepard, take things into your own hands, or use your information to change the galaxy.
    [Show full text]
  • THE INSURRECTIONIST HERESYP.38 PENSACOLA CHRISTIAN COLLEGER COLLEGE VISIT OPTIONS DESIGNED for YOU Virtual
    EARNING YOUR TRUST, EVERY DAY. 02.13.21 VOLUME 36 NUMBER 3 “HONG KONG HAS ENTERED A COLD WINTER. THE WIND IS STRONG AND COLD.” —P. 56 —P. COLD.” AND STRONG IS WIND THE WINTER. COLD A ENTERED HAS KONG “HONG THE INSURRECTIONIST HERESYP.38 PENSACOLA CHRISTIAN COLLEGER COLLEGE VISIT OPTIONS DESIGNED FOR YOU Virtual. In-person. Your choice. College Days* A multi-day event to experience life as a college student. Explore PCC* A one-day guided visit to give you a personalized look into college life. College at a Glance A live webinar designed to answer your questions from the comfort of your home. Campus Tours* Can’t make it to an event? Pick a date that works for you and schedule your tour of campus. Find out more and reserve your spot at go.pcci.edu/WorldVisit *Events are subject to change based on current conditions. FEATURES 02.13.21 VOLUME 36 NUMBER 3 50 A DAY IN THE LIFE OF BUSINESS SURVIVORS Street-level views of how small businesses in America and beyond are faring by Marvin Olasky and the 2021 WJI mid-career class 38 44 56 CRISIS OF FAITH SOUTHERN BAPTIST DIVISION FREEDOM FIGHTER How can Christians prevent Amid debates on race within the Christian Benny Tai helps political passion from turning Southern Baptist Convention, some lead Hong Kong’s fight for democracy to unholy furor? black pastors wonder if it’s the right even as Beijing continues its clampdown denomination for their churches by Jamie Dean by June Cheng and Erica Kwong by Sophia Lee PHOTO BY DANIELLE RICHARDS/GENESIS 02.13.21 WORLD DEPARTMENTS 02.13.21 VOLUME 36 NUMBER
    [Show full text]
  • Van KGB-Sp'ion Tot Meesterschrljver De Zweedse Auteur Jan Guillou Werkt Aan Zljn• • Magnum Opus, Een Romancyclus Over De Twintigste Eeuw
    IJan Guillou Van KGB-sp'ion tot meestersChrljver De Zweedse auteur Jan Guillou werkt aan zlJn• • magnum opus, een romancyclus over de twintigste eeuw. Daarvoor was hij vooral ~... bekend om zijn thrillers en als de onthuller ..- -'~ van het Zweedse 'Watergate'. 'Woodward en Bernstein kregen de Pulitzer-prijs, Ik tien maanden cel.' tekst & beeld Rutger Vahl JANGUILLOU et is het veiligste land van Europa, maar ner­ 'Journalisten in de bak om gens tiert het spiona­ ge- en thrillergenre zo wat ze schrijven? In Zweden? welig als in Zweden. Zijn de Zweden geob­ Op dat moment had ik nog sedeerd door alles wat hun Ikea-woning bedreigt? Dat ook. Maar er is meer aan de zeven uur in vrijheid te gaan.' hand. Nergens is het misdaadgenre zo politiek geladen als in Zweden. Niet alleen het bloed druipt van de pagina's, maar ook de maatschappijkritiek. In hun misdaad­ romans tonen Zweedse schrijvers de ware De ruimte waar hij zijn bestsellers schrijft, delen er nog volgen, weet hij niet. aard van de samenleving. Die lijkt zo ge­ doet nog het meest denken aan een zaal in Heeft hij tijd van leven, dan eindigt zijn moedelijk en welvarend, maar onderhuids het Londense National History Museum. magnum opus op 11 september 2001. "Ik broeit en stinkt het. Laten we niet vergeten Dezelfde afmetingen. Dezelfde hoeveel­ wilde mezelf uitdagen om een traditionele dat Zweden het enige Europese land is heid opgezette dieren. Guillou heeft zich familiekroniek te schrijven die de hele waar de afgelopen 25 jaar twee keer een omringd met antilopen- en impalakop­ twintigste eeuw zou omvatten.
    [Show full text]
  • Doctor Who: the Doctor, Tegan, Nyssa and Adric
    WWW.BIGFINISH.COM • NEW AUDIO ADVENTURES DOCTOR WHO: THE CLASS OF 82 THE DOCTOR, TEGAN, NYSSA AND ADRIC REUNITE FOR BIG FINISH! PLUS! DOCTOR WHO: PHILIP OLIVIER ON HEX AND HECTOR! THE FIFTH DOCTOR BOX SET: WRITING FOR ADRIC! AND IT’S ALL CHANGE FOR BLAKE’S 7… ISSUE 66 • AUGUST 2014 WELCOME TO BIG FINISH! We love stories and we make great full-cast audio drama and audiobooks you can buy on CD and/or download Big Finish… Subscribers get more We love stories. at bigfinish.com! Our audio productions are based on much- If you subscribe, depending on the range you loved TV series like Doctor Who, Dark subscribe to, you get free audiobooks, PDFs Shadows, Blake’s 7, Stargate and Highlander of scripts, extra behind-the-scenes material, a as well as classic characters such as Sherlock bonus release and discounts. Holmes, The Phantom of the Opera and Dorian Gray, plus original creations such as Graceless and The Adventures of Bernice Summerfield. www.bigfinish.com We publish a growing number of books (non- You can access a video guide to the site by fiction, novels and short stories) from new and clicking here. established authors. WWW.BIGFINISH.COM @BIGFINISH /THEBIGFINISH VORTEX MAGAZINE PAGE 3 Sneak Previews & Whispers Editorial OMETIMES, the little things that you do go a lot further than you would ever expect. At Big Finish, S Paul Spragg was testament to that. Since Paul’s tragic passing earlier this year, Big Finish has been inundated with messages from people whose lives Paul touched, to many different extents, from friends who knew him well, to those he helped with day-to-day customer service enquiries.
    [Show full text]
  • National Security and Secret Evidence in Legislation and Before the Courts
    National Security and Secret Evidence in Legislation and before the Courts: Exploring the Challenges Didier Bigo, Sergio Carrera, Nicholas Hernanz and Amandine Scherrer No. 78/ January 2015 Abstract This study provides a comparative analysis of the national legal regimes and practices governing the use of intelligence information as evidence in the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Spain, Italy, the Netherlands and Sweden. It explores notably how national security can be invoked to determine the classification of information and evidence as 'state secrets' in court proceedings and whether such laws and practices are fundamental rights- and rule of law-compliant. The study finds that, in the majority of Member States under investigation, the judiciary is significantly hindered in effectively adjudicating justice and guaranteeing the rights of the defence in ‘national security’ cases. The research also illustrates that the very term ‘national security’ is nebulously defined across the Member States analysed, with no national definition meeting legal certainty and “in accordance with the law” standards and a clear risk that the executive and secret services may act arbitrarily. The study argues that national and transnational intelligence community practices and cooperation need to be subject to more independent and effective judicial accountability and be brought into line with EU 'rule of law' standards. This document was originally commissioned by the European Parliament's Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs (LIBE) and published in December 2014. It is available for free downloading on the European Parliament’s website (www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2014/509991/IPOL_STU(2014)509 991_EN.pdf) and is republished by CEPS with the kind permission of the Parliament.
    [Show full text]