Disaster Risk Management Master Plan (DRMMP) Implementation in Metropolitan Manila
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
E M I Earthquakes and Megacities Initiative Disaster Risk Management Master Plan (DRMMP) implementation in Metropolitan Manila In partnership with MMDA – PHIVOLCS and Quezon, Makati and Marikina Cities Field Trip Report - Summary April 17-22, 2005 Purpose of the Fieldtrip • To initiate discussions with the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA) and other city stakeholders on a consensus draft work plan and the components of a DRMMP for Metro Manila, based on a 10-point framework proposed by the 3cd Team. • To report back to the cities, particularly Makati and Quezon Cities, about the findings from previous work carried out by the 3cd Team, especially on the Disaster Risk Management City Profile and compilation of Sound Practices. • To invite the City of Marikina to become the third case study city as part of the 3cd Program in Metro Manila. • To request and obtain commitments from the 3 cities in Metro Manila and other institutions such as PHIVOLCS and MMDA to review and comment on the DRM city profile and sound practices compiled so far, as well as submit new ones. • To promote the use of e-learning and on-line tools, such as the knowledge base and the map viewer, as useful and efficient risk communication tools. Background Metro Manila, a complex urban area that encompasses a population close to ten million distributed in 13 cities and 4 municipalities, is one of the three pilot cities in Asia where the 3cd Program is currently being implemented. Starting in July 2004, the Earthquake and Megacities Initiative (EMI) in cooperation with the Earthquake Disaster Mitigation Center (EdM) in Kobe, Japan, introduced its Cross-Cutting Capacity Development -3cd- Program, in the cities of Quezon and Makati. In January 2005, EMI and the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority signed a cooperative agreement for the implementation of the 3cd Program in the capital region. In August 2004, initial fieldwork and a bi-city workshop were carried out with the participation of delegates from Makati City, Quezon City and MMDA that permitted understanding the current structures and framework for disaster risk management (DRM) in Metro Manila1 and identifyied several relevant DRM sound practices mainly aimed at reducing the impact of flooding and earthquakes. In November 2004, the Pacific Disaster Center, PDC, joined EMI in a collaborative effort to promote shifting the vision from response management to risk management and accelerating the process of implementating a Disaster Risk Management Master Plan (DRMMP) in Metropolitan Manila, by building on the significant work already accomplished by different national and international initiatives in this city. 1EMI-EdM, Metro Manila Philippines, Disaster Risk Management Profile, December 2004 Page 2 Given the previous work done by the Pacific Disaster Center through the multi-hazard urban risk assessment project for Marikina City and its guidelines for implementing a risk reduction strategy2, and the excellent relationship developed by those two organizations, it was suggested to invite Marikina to become part of the case-study cities under the 3cd Program. In this next phase, the 3cd Implementation Team, along with city officials and other interested stakeholders will look in detail at the main issues that have prevented the realization of the recommendations of different projects and will assist the cities and the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA) in structuring a comprehensive implementation plan that turns existing risk analysis studies into risk management instruments. Resource Group The unique composition of the 3cd Team facilitates the progress of the different activities planned for the city. There is a mixture of skilled local and international professionals with different backgrounds who provide strong leadership and an enhanced vision by combining the local and global perspectives. The active and dedicated participation of the EMI secretariat based in Metro Manila, the local investigator PHIVOLCS represented by its director and his team, members of the Local Working Group who bring in their individual knowledge but also that from their organizations such as MMDA, the Universities and Professional Associations all have assisted during the fieldtrip organization or providing logistics, but most importantly, by guiding the team to better accomplish the objectives. EMI and its partners, the Pacific Disaster Center -PDC- based in Maui, and the Earthquake and Disaster Mitigation Center –EdM- of Kobe, provide partial financial support for the investigative and consultative work, as well as provide guidance for the research and implementation process. Methodology Meetings, structured discussions, power point presentations, interviews and an evaluation questionnaire designed to get feedback from the participants were among the tools used during this field trip; details can be seen on the attached final agenda for the whole week activities. Individual meetings with the cities Each one of the three case-study cities engaged in the 3cd Program, Quezon, Makati and Marikina, has a different geographical setting, varies in size and population and has different characteristics in terms of its Disaster Risk Management Organization and Development. 2 PDC, Multi-hazard Urban Risk Assessment for Marikina City and guidelines for implementing multi-hazard risk reduction strategies, December 2004 Page 3 The following chart shows some of the most relevant characteristics of each one of these cities. Quezon Makati Marikina Size 166.2 Km2 27.36 Km2 21.5 Km2 Population 2,390,688 est. 2005 471,379 c. 2000 437,000 in 2004 # Barangays 142 in four districts 33 in two districts 14 in two districts Pop. Growth 1.92% -0.5% City Small to medium Financial and Large Revenues scale business Banking Sector Manufacturing Services provision Business & Firms Finished product Commerce distribution Land Use 45.5% residential 38% residential Relevant Construction of DRM criteria is Tax incentive Policy major transport and introduced in the system to promote infrastructure to city planning industrial sector reactivate the procedures investment economy Related • Reducing Informal • Medical • The Safety Programs Settlers Programs Emergency Program, 2004. • Saving the Streams Services • A Comprehensive in QC (Sagip Batis) • Public-Private Land Use Plan, • Barangay disaster Safety Program 2003; brigades (South • Urban Renewal • Long-Term Master Triangle) Program Plan, 2003; • Health Networking • Home Along the • Invest in Marikina Program Estero Program, 2004 • Review DM and • The Flood Development Mitigation Plans Strategy, 2004. Holding individual city meetings or workshops is an approach that helps the 3cd team keep track of particular activities in the cities, promote documentation and exchange of sound practices and other inter-city cooperation instruments, achieve a closer contact with city officials, facilitate one-on-one discussions and address specific needs of the city. At the same time, the team looks for effective means to integrate those lessons in the megacity context of Metropolitan Manila. Therefore, a 1/2 session with the senior staff of both Quezon and Makati was hosted by each one of these cities on Tuesday, April 19 and Friday, April 22, respectively. One key objective was to report on the major findings from the August 2004 bi-city workshop held in Quezon and the current state of sound practice collection in Metro Manila and the other EMI cities engaged in the 3cd Program. On Monday, April 18, Marikina City was visited and invited to join the program, and at the same time city officials made a general presentation related to specific actions implemented in relationship to disaster risk management. Finally, the usefulness of the knowledge base and a map viewer for Metro Manila was also introduced in the discussion. Page 4 The approach for the implementation of a comprehensive DRMMP and its expected process was also described in these meetings in order to get the participants’ reactions to this initiative. In each one of the cities, city officials received the 3cd Team and the mayors of the cities briefly joined the workshops as to show of their support to the project. Joint Workshop with MMDA and other Stakeholders On Wednesday, April 20 and Thursday, April 21, the authorities and staff of MMDA received the 3cd team, while representatives of the three above-mentioned cities, the Office of Civil Defense (OCD), PHIVOLCS and Professional Associations also participated in this meeting, which included 42 attendees. Concepts such as the mainstreaming model and the Disaster Risk Management Master Plan (DRMMP) tool were explained and discussed with the participants, along with a suggested 10-point framework prepared by the program director, Ms. Shirley Mattingly, for the purpose of this field trip. See attachments for details. Mainstreaming Model: Disaster reduction actions can actually take place with the involvement of all stakeholders if mitigation and preparedness are regularly included on the operations and functions carried out by the cities and municipalities. DRMMP: a tool to enable local governments to establish a process and to systematically and systemically implement a comprehensive Disaster Risk Management Agenda. 10-Point Framework: 3cd Team proposed a collective review of some of the key actions suggested by previous studies, particularly MMEIRS and its experience from other cities. Participants at this meeting were welcome to endorse, dismiss or change them, incorporating what,