Ottoman Stone Acquisition in the Mid-Sixteenth Century: the Süleyman~Ye Complex in Istanbul

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Ottoman Stone Acquisition in the Mid-Sixteenth Century: the Süleyman~Ye Complex in Istanbul ottoman stone acquisition: the süleymaniye complex 251 ~LKNUR AKTUÅ KOLAY AND SERP~L ÇEL~K OTTOMAN STONE ACQUISITION IN THE MID-SIXTEENTH CENTURY: THE SÜLEYMAN~YE COMPLEX IN ISTANBUL In the light of both the vast archival documentation grade.7 No other mosque is adorned with so many (construction dates, texts on ceremonies, account precious columns that once stood in Roman temples books, construction correspondence, price-setting reg- and Byzantine churches. In this respect, the Süley- isters) and the intact structural evidence, the stone maniye constitutes a symbolically significant collec- used to build the Süleymaniye in Istanbul holds a tion of stone, in which ancient civilizations such as unique place in the history of Ottoman architectonic Roman and Byzantine and their sacred memories sur- science and technology. In this essay, this stone and its vive.8 The chief architect Sinan notes that each stone acquisition in the mid-sixteenth century are considered was famous worldwide and reminiscent of a land,9 and in micro-scale by making use of archival materials, that some came from Solomon’s palace.10 Not only recent research, and extant structural clues. A major did the Süleymaniye represent the common heritage problem has been interpreting the terminology in the of humanity, but it also translated the past into the archival materials, which are mainly building accounts future through Ottoman architectonic knowledge,11 and correspondence written by accountants and scribes synthesizing the legacies of Azerbaijan, Iran, Iraq, Syria, rather than by architects. Analogies between the Sül- Egypt, the Balkans, and Eastern Europe.12 eymaniye and other large imperial complexes with Preceded by the pioneer Fatih complex of Sultan account books shedding light on their structures have Mehmed II (r. 1451–81), the Süleymaniye assumed been used here to solve this problem. a substantial role in enhancing the Ottoman educa- Dominating the skyline of the historic Istanbul pen- tional system. It was commissioned by the imperial insula, with its minarets and hundreds of domes cas- council, and its construction was presided over by Sul- cading down to the Golden Horn like “bubbles on the tan Süleyman. Not counting the unrecorded cost of surface of the sea,”1 the Süleymaniye complex ({im¸ret-i its platform, 26,251,938 akçe (asper, an Ottoman sil- {¸mire, modern külliye), situated on the third hill of ver coin), of which 25,802,000 akçe were provided by the city, is the most ambitious Ottoman building ever the Sultan, were spent on its construction between built. Besides its spiritual and charitable functions, its 1553 and1559 (the period for which expense records basic purpose was education. Comprising a congrega- have been preserved).13 The total cost, according to tional mosque, an elementary school, a Qur}an school, the autobiographical essays that Sinan dictated to a Hadith college, four law colleges, a school of medi- his poet-and-painter friend Mustafa Sa{i Çelebi, was cine, a university hospital, a pharmacy, a hostel, a hos- 53,760,000 akçe.14 On September 18, 1547, the sultan pice, a caravanserai, a soup kitchen, a single hammam, had gained victory over the Austrian empire. With his rows of one-man shops and rooms, and the tombs of new annual budget increasing from four million duc- both Sultan Süleyman I (known in Ottoman histori- ats15 to about seven or eight million,16 he conceived ography as “the Lawgiver”), r. 1520–66,2 and his wife the idea of constructing a new complex, to be built Haseki Hürrem Sultan or Roxelana (Kadæn Efendi in after the completion of the complex (1543–48) of his the endowment deed of the Süleymaniye), the com- late son, Øehzade Mehmed. plex is almost entirely a university city.3 Land acquisition was not an issue for the Süley- As one of the preeminent enterprises of the Otto- maniye, which was to be sited on a plot removed man architecture that sprawls from Budapest to Cairo, from the burned-out Old Palace (the Saray-æ Atik or the Süleymaniye was considered to be as sacred as the Eski Saray) at Bayezid, damaged by a devastating fire Ka{ba4 and the al-Aqsa Mosque,5 as beautiful as the on February 7, 1540.17 One of the most prominent Seven Wonders of the World,6 and as large as Bel- spots on the peninsula’s skyline, this site was also muqarnas23-3_CS2.indd Sec2:251 10/18/2006 11:50:49 AM . 252 ilknur aktuÅ kolay and serpil çelik selected to reduce costs and avoid expropriation else- and wholesale purchases (müb¸ya{¸t) and were evidently where.18 Expropriation was the most crucial issue in presented to the sultan, and imperial correspondence this crowded and expensive commercial area of the such as edicts, decrees, and court orders (_av¸nºn, city, as would be documented in the later cases of the a¥k¸m ve ev¸mir-i hüm¸yün).35 These documents were Nuruosmaniye and Sultan Ahmed mosques. That the published by Ömer Lütfi Barkan36 in 1972 and uti- Süleymaniye, with its relatively larger program, could lized by J. M. Rogers37 in 1982 and more recently by be erected on such narrow, sloped terrain demon- Stephanos Yerasimos.38 Besides recording wages, sala- stated the genius of Sinan, architect-in-chief to the sul- ries, and wholesale purchases, the account books also tans for half a century (1538–88).19 Sinan knew how reflect the assignments of construction team members, to use the site adeptly and how to employ its build- their concentration in one or more different sections ing materials left in situ from the burned-out palace, of the building during the work, and ceremonies such which had itself been built on the ruins of a Francis- as the slaughtering of animals and the giving of alms, can monastery.20 gifts, and tips to teams in celebration of the comple- According to the foundation inscription of the tion of certain structures; this information allows us mosque,21 Sinan’s autobiographical treatises,22 and to deduce unknown dates and construction processes. the chronicle of the contemporary historian Mustafa One can also extract from the account books substan- b. Celâl,23 the cornerstone of the Süleymaniye was tial information on the organizing, managing, moni- consecrated and laid in the foundation of the mihrab toring, obtaining, and transporting of teams, and on by Shaykh al-Islam Ebussuud Efendi on Friday, June sixteenth-century building supplies: stone, iron, steel, 13, 1550. The architectural project24 and its model25 lead, brass, copper, logs, timber, brick, tile, terracotta must have been designed between September 18, pipes, powdered and crushed horasan (mortar of lime 1547 and March 29, 1548, before the sultan went on and powdered bricks), fine sand, lime, flax, and gyp- his second Persian campaign from March 29, 1548 to sum, along with mosque furnishings and ornaments December 21, 1549.26 (pendant globes, tile revetments, oil lamps, flat and Sinan first erected a great platform on vaults to level curved mirrors, pigments, gold leaf, ostrich eggs, car- the mosque, add to its height, and establish its qibla pets, and straw mats).39 orientation.27 In addition, the vaults could accommo- In addition to the the Süleymaniye records, archival date an array of one-man shops. Furthermore, to avoid documents related to other large imperial complexes, loss of space at the construction site and maximize such as the Sultan Ahmed,40 the Nuruosmaniye,41 and the ease of stone use, Sinan had the stone finished to the Ayazma,42 combined with recent research, consti- ready-to-use blocks in the mason yards of the quarries. tute a fairly concrete database for further analyses. Almost all the building supplies of the empire were commandeered for this project by order of the imperial council; during construction, even the prefect of the PROVISION OF STONE capital, who was charged with meeting the needs for imperial buildings such as palaces, hammams, kitch- There exist a considerable number of documents ens, bakeries, and military edifices, had to get per- on stone provision for the construction of the Süley- mission from the council to obtain any stone.28 The maniye, giving information on the search for appro- foundation was completed around December 1553,29 priate spolia, work at the quarries, transport of stone, and the last work was finished by January 15, 1560.30 stone ateliers, and costs. For the superstructure of the According to the copy of Tezkiretü’l-büny¸n from the complex, 7,905,910 akçe (30.1% of the total cost) were Revan Library, the mosque had already welcomed the spent on building supplies (müb¸ya{¸t).43 The building first Friday procession31 on Friday, July 30, 1557.32 stone used in the Süleymaniye included spolia from At its inauguration, the sultan honored Sinan with a private properties, which were purchased if owners golden key, paid for, according to an account book, permitted; otherwise, the harm caused by collection between August 28 and September 2, 1557.33 was determined and the owners compensated.44 The available archival documents34 related to the According to the registers, the collection of spo- Süleymaniye are account books (defter) and their sum- lia in the provinces was mainly commissioned by the maries (icm¸l), which record wages and salaries (ic¸r¸t) imperial council through the provincial courts and muqarnas23-3_CS2.indd 252 10/20/2006 11:43:52 AM . ottoman stone acquisition: the süleymaniye complex 253 councils and their high-ranking officials such as gov- by the accountants of the local kadis in order to be ernors-general (beqlerbeqi), sub-governors (sancak beqi), considered legally valid.60 To avoid wasting money magistrates (suba×æ), and fief holders (sip¸hº).
Recommended publications
  • Description of a View of Constantinople, with Its European
    IN THE UPPER CIRCLE, IS NOW OPEN, A VIEW OF R O U E N. AND, mi ©imcJLiB, A VIEW OF ATHENS. DESCRIPTION ' OF A VIEW OF • r\ CONSTANTINOPLE WITH ITS EUROPEAN AND ASIATIC SUBURBS, AND A GREAT EXTENT OF SURROUNDING COUNTRY. 1TOW msmmXTKM® AT THE PANORAMA ROYAL, LEICESTER SQUARE. IPAIOTSID m OTJ FMtfPlOTTGm, ROBERT BURFORD, ASSISTED BY H. C. SELOUS, FROM DRAWINGS TAKEN ON THE SPOT, By WILLIAM .1. SMITH, Esq., of Her Britannic Majesty’s Embassy at Constantinople. ilontron : PRINTED BY T. BRETTELL, RUPERT STREET, HAYMARKET. 3846. CONSTANTINOPLE. Constantinople is universally acknowledged to be the finest city in the whole world. Viewed from the Seraskier’s Tower, from whence the present Panorama is taken, the admirable position it occupies is fully apparent, and the whole of its curious internal economy is at once visible in its fullest extent and magnificence. Mosques, minarets, palaces, and kiosks, in countless variety, being spread out like a map beneath, whilst around, in every direction, stretches an immense extent of scenery of the most varied and picturesque description; on the one side the Bosphorus with the shores of Europe, on the other the sea of Mar¬ mora with the coast of Asia. Earth, sky, and water, combine to inspire wonder and admiration ; the scene is splendid and unique. Enthroned on her seven hills, Stamboul, indeed, deserves the proud title bestowed upon it of “ the Queen of Cities.” The Seraskier’s Tower is a lofty building crowning the third and highest hill of the ridge, and is consequently the most commanding situation in the city, or its immediate environs.
    [Show full text]
  • Delft University of Technology Diachronic Assessment of Cultural
    Delft University of Technology Diachronic assessment of cultural diversity in historic neighbourhoods using space syntax Studies of three neighbourhoods in Istanbul Toprak, Ilgi; Ünlü, A.; van Nes, Akkelies Publication date 2017 Document Version Final published version Published in Proceedings of the 11th International Space Syntax Symposium (SSS 2017) Citation (APA) Toprak, I., Ünlü, A., & Van Nes, A. (2017). Diachronic assessment of cultural diversity in historic neighbourhoods using space syntax: Studies of three neighbourhoods in Istanbul. In Proceedings of the 11th International Space Syntax Symposium (SSS 2017) (pp. 154.1-154.14). Lisbon: Instituto Superior Técnico. Important note To cite this publication, please use the final published version (if applicable). Please check the document version above. Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download, forward or distribute the text or part of it, without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license such as Creative Commons. Takedown policy Please contact us and provide details if you believe this document breaches copyrights. We will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. This work is downloaded from Delft University of Technology. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to a maximum of 10. Proceedings of the 11th Space Syntax Symposium #154 DIACHRONIC ASSESSMENT OF CULTURAL DIVERSITY IN HISTORIC NEIGHBOURHOODS USING SPACE SYNTAX:
    [Show full text]
  • Fatih Tsunami Raporu
    FATİH TSUNAMİ RİSK ANALİZİ ve EYLEM PLANI KİTAPÇIĞI Haziran 2020 İSTANBUL FATİH İLÇESİ TSUNAMİ RİSK ANALİZİ VE EYLEM PLANI RAPORU BU RAPOR; İSTANBUL İLİ MARMARA KIYILARI TSUNAMİ MODELLEME, HASAR GÖREBİLİRLİK VE TEHLİKE ANALİZİ GÜNCELLEME PROJESİ (2018) VE İSTANBUL İÇİN TSUNAMİ EYLEM PLANI HAZIRLANMASI İŞİ (2019) SONUÇ RAPORLARINDAN YARARLANILARAK, İSTANBUL BÜYÜKŞEHİR BELEDİYESİ, DEPREM RİSK YÖNETİMİ VE İYİLEŞTİRME DAİRE BAŞKANLIĞI, DEPREM VE ZEMİN İNCELEME MÜDÜRLÜĞÜ TARAFINDAN ÜRETİLMİŞTİR. 06/2020 PROJE BİLGİLERİ “İstanbul İli Fatih İlçesi Tsunami Risk Analizi ve Eylem Planı Raporu”, İstanbul İli Marmara Kıyıları Tsunami Modelleme, Hasar Görebilirlik ve Tehlike Analizi Güncelleme Projesi (2018) ve İstanbul İçin Tsunami Eylem Planı Hazırlanması İşi (2019) sonuç raporlarından yararlanılarak, İstanbul Büyükşehir Belediyesi, Deprem Risk Yönetimi ve İyileştirme Daire Başkanlığı Deprem ve Zemin İnceleme Müdürlüğü tarafından üretilmiştir. Ortadoğu Teknik Üniversitesi, Mühendislik Fakültesi, İnşaat Mühendisliği ve Jeoloji Mühendisliği Bölümleri: Prof. Dr. Ahmet Cevdet Yalçıner, Proje Yürütücüsü, [email protected] Prof. Dr. Mehmet Lütfi Süzen, Proje Yürütücüsü, [email protected] Araş. Gör. Duygu Tüfekçi Enginar, Bilimsel Proje Uzmanı, [email protected] Gözde Güney Doğan, Bilimsel Proje Uzmanı, [email protected] İstanbul Büyükşehir Belediyesi Deprem Risk Yönetimi ve Kentsel İyileştirme Daire Başkanlığı Deprem ve Zemin İnceleme Müdürlüğü: Jeoloji Müh. Sema KARA Jeofizik Yük. Müh. Yasin Yaşar YILDIRIM (Dai. Bşk. Danışmanı) Jeoloji Müh. Evrens Rıza YAPAR Jeofizik Müh. Özge UZUNKOL Jeoloji Müh. Ahmet TARİH Dr. Emin Yahya MENTEŞE (Md. Yrd.) Jeofizik & Geoteknik Yük. Müh. Kemal DURAN (Müdür) Dr. Tayfun KAHRAMAN (Daire Başkanı) Haziran 2020, İSTANBUL Kıymetli Hemşehrilerim; Dünyada deprem riski en yüksek kentlerin başında, hem nüfus ve yapı yoğunluğu hem de fay hatlarına yakınlığı nedeniyle, maalesef İstanbul geliyor.
    [Show full text]
  • Storari Grid Layouts
    URBAN TRANSFORMATION: CONTROVERSIES, CONTRASTS and CHALLENGES TRANSFORMATION OF THE NINETEENTH CENTURY URBAN FABRIC IN ISTANBUL’S HISTORICAL PENINSULA: STORARI GRID LAYOUTS. TAN KAMİL GÜRER Adres: Yıldız Teknik Üniversitesi, Mimarlık Fakültesi, Yıldız, Beşiktaş, İstanbul E-mail: [email protected] PINAR GÖZEK Adres: Yıldız Teknik Üniversitesi, Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü, Yıldız, Beşiktaş, İstanbul E-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT Urban transformation in the nineteenth century Istanbul is under the effects of westernization. Westernization was the modernization project of the Ottoman government. It begins with the declaration of Tanzimat (Ottoman Reform) in 1839 and spreads to lots of fields of the society. Urban planning decisions and the architecture of the period were also affected from the Tanzimat project by referring to western urban planning models – grid and radial plan – and architecture. Many foreign engineers and architects were invited to the Capital for applying the new planning models commonly after the great fires occurred in the Historical Peninsula. Luigi Storari was one of them who became known with application of first grid layouts and subdivision systems in the urban fabric of Istanbul. His grid layouts had different characteristics than others, which applied after him. Regions such as Aksaray, Imrahor, Salma Tomruk, Küçük Mustafa Paşa and Boyacıköy have certain typo-morphological features in its own: grid layout, the square with the beveled corners and the widened main arteries. This study will focus on the morphological characteristics of the Storari grid layouts in the Historical Peninsula. INTRODUCTION Eighteenth and nineteenth centuries are known as westernization periods in Ottoman Empire. Steps taken in this regard loomed large in many areas.
    [Show full text]
  • National Inventory of Intangible Cultural Heritage of Greece
    NATIONAL INVENTORY OF INTANGIBLE CULTURAL HERITAGE OF GREECE FORM OF THE ELEMENT Tinian Marble Craftsmanship Ι. Brief presentation of the element of Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH) 1. Other names: Marble sculpture, the art of marble, marble-carving, stone-carving 2. Identification and definition The construction of an object, self-contained or part of a larger construction, made of marble (extraction of raw material, squaring, design, decoration, assembly, installation) and its relevant social and economic aspects (workshops, tools and techniques, machinery, apprenticeship, clientele, products, mentalities). 3. Domain of ICH • Oral traditions and expressions: Both technical terminology about tools, techniques and customary craftsmanship on the one hand, and sayings, traditions and anecdotes on the other, are classified as oral tradition. The former impart technical knowledge and skills and the latter impart social attitudes and behaviors. The particular motifs and patterns (cypresses, ships, etc.)conceived by marble craftsmen are inspired by oral traditions and are accordingly put to use. • Social practices, rituals and festive events: There are certain rituals and festive practices that are implemented on certain occasions, such as the opening of a quarry, the transition from the stage of apprenticeship to that of master craftsman, the festivity of Saint Charalampos, the patron saint of marble craftsmen et al. • Knowledge and practice about nature and the universe: Quarrymen and marble craftsmen possess empirical, albeit accurate, geological knowledge of the composition and structure of marble-bearing rock layers, the properties of each kind of marble, the manipulation of its swirls and veins, its schistosity, etc. They also have knowledge of certain elements of the material’s mechanical behavior and pathology.
    [Show full text]
  • Balicka-Witakowska Constantinople.Pdf
    The Urban Mind Cultural and Environmental Dynamics Edited by Paul J.J. Sinclair, Gullög Nordquist, Frands Herschend and Christian Isendahl African and Comparative Archaeology Department of Archaeology and Ancient History Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden 2010 Cover: NMH THC 9113 Artist: Cornelius Loos Panorama over the southern side of Istanbul facing north east. Produced in 1710. Pen and brush drawing with black ink, grey wash, water colour on paper. The illustration is composed of nine separate sheets joined together and glued on woven material. Original retouching glued along the whole length of the illustration. Dimensions (h x b) 28,7 x 316 cm Photograph © Erik Cornelius / Nationalmuseum English revised by Laura Wrang. References and technical coordination by Elisabet Green. Layout: Göran Wallby, Publishing and Graphic Services, Uppsala university. ISSN 1651-1255 ISBN 978-91-506-2175-4 Studies in Global Archaeology 15 Series editor: Paul J.J. Sinclair. Editors: Paul J.J. Sinclair, Gullög Nordquist, Frands Herschend and Christian Isendahl. Published and distributed by African and Comparative Archaeology, Department of Archaeology and Ancient History, Uppsala University, Box 626, S-751 26 Uppsala. Printed in Sweden by Edita Västra Aros AB, Västerås 2010 – a climate neutral company. 341 009 Trycksak 13. Constantinople in the Transition from Late Antiquity to the Middle Ages Ewa Balicka-Witakowska Contact details Dr Ewa Balicka-Witakowska Department of Linguistics and Philology Byzantine Studies Uppsala University Box 635 751 26 Uppsala, Sweden <\\\¬<< ABSTRACT This chapter gives an overview of the transformations which took place in Constantinople from the time of its foundation in the early 4th century as a Late Antique metropolis and $#$#Áth century when it was changed to a medieval town, perhaps less splendid in some respects but well adapted to new geopolitical and economic circumstances and still the centre of imperial power.
    [Show full text]
  • Cathedral Free Download
    CATHEDRAL FREE DOWNLOAD Raymond Carver | 227 pages | 20 Oct 1993 | Random House USA Inc | 9780679723691 | English | New York, United States Mass Livestream The three halls create an open courtyard, in which was originally located a separate baptistery. In the Catholic or Roman Catholic tradition, the term Cathedral correctly applies only to a church that houses the Cathedral of the bishop of Cathedral diocese. In one hour that Cathedral and enormous church Cathedral filled with men and women. Numerous buttresses have been added throughout the centuries. Restorers have attempted to maintain Cathedral balance between Cathedral Christian and Islamic cultures. Main articles: Architecture of cathedrals and great churches and List of regional characteristics of European cathedral architecture. GermanDutchetc. This often takes the form of an eagle of brass or carved Cathedral which supports the book on its outstretched wings and is the symbol of John the Evangelist. Bythe Cathedral project was Cathedral, though many other areas of Hagia Sophia continue to Cathedral significant stability improvement, restoration and conservation. Normandy, Complete Gordon Home. Need even Cathedral definitions? Date of experience: October It depicts the emperor Alexander in full regalia, holding a scroll in his right hand and Cathedral globus cruciger in his left. This part of the building is called the Choir or Quire, and is generally located between the sanctuary and the nave. Cathedral diagram Duomo Gothic cathedrals and churches French Gothic architecture English Gothic architecture List of basilicas List of cathedrals List of highest church naves List of largest church buildings in the world List of regional Cathedral of European cathedral architecture List of tallest churches in the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Two Cases of Primary Stabbing Headache Primer Saplanıcı Başağrısı: İki Olgu Sunumu
    Agri 2016;28(2):106–108 doi: 10.5505/agri.2015.26680 A RI PAIN C A S E R E P O R T / O L G U SUNUMU Two cases of primary stabbing headache Primer saplanıcı başağrısı: İki olgu sunumu Murat GUNTEL,1 Ozge HURDOGAN,2 Derya ULUDUZ,2 Taskin DUMAN1 Summary Primary stabbing headache is an excruciating and relatively rare type of headache that typically lasts for only a few seconds. Pain is predominantly felt in the distribution of the first division of the trigeminal nerve and can be experienced as single stabs or as a series of stabs, either per day or every few days. Primary stabbing headache has been well-defined for decades and must be kept in mind during diagnosis. Exclusion of other possible causes is necessary in order to establish diagnosis. Indomethacin has classically been considered the first treatment option, but therapeutic failure occurs in up to 35% of cases. Recent studies have suggested that cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitors, gabapentin, nifedipine, paracetamol, and melatonin are also effective treatments. Keywords: Primary stabbing headache; primary headache; treatment; indomethacin. Özet Primer saplanıcı baş ağrısı; saniyeler süren nadir ve şiddetli bir başağrısıdır. Ağrı özellikle trigeminal sinirin birinci dalı boyunca hissedilir ve günde bir veya birkaç günde bir gelen bir veya birkaç kez tekrarlayan saplanma atakları şeklinde ortaya çıkar. Primer saplanıcı başağrısı yıllardır bilinmekle birlikte tanı için klinisyenin sorgulaması gereklidir. Primer saplanıcı başağrısının tanısını koymada diğer olası nedenlerin dışlanması önemlidir. İndometazin klasik olarak ilk tedavi seçeneğidir ancak olguların %35’e yakını tedaviye direnç gösterir. Son yıllarda cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitörleri, gabapentin, nifedipine, parasetamol, ve melatonin tedavisinin etkinliğini destekleyen çalışmalar bildirilmektedir.
    [Show full text]
  • The Byzantine Heritage of Istanbul: Resource Or
    THE BYZANTINE HERITAGE OF ISTANBUL : RESOURCE OR BURDEN ? A STUDY ON THE SURVIVING ECCLESIASTICAL ARCHITECTURE OF THE HISTORICAL PENINSULA WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF PERCEPTION , PRESERVATION AND RESEARCH IN THE TURKISH REPUBLICAN PERIOD by Ayİe Dilsiz A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate School of Social Sciences in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Anatolian Civilizations and Cultural Heritage Management Koç University November 2006 Koç University Graduate School of Social Sciences This is to certify that I have examined this copy of a master‘s thesis by Ayİe Dilsiz and have found that it is complete and satisfactory in all respects, and that any and all revisions required by the final examining committee have been made. Committee Members: Alicia Simpson, Ph. D. (Advisor) Gül Pulhan, Ph. D (Advisor) AslÛ Niyazio₣lu, Ph. D. Lucienne Thys-ğenocak, Ph. D. Engin Akyürek, Ph. D. Date: ii Abstract This thesis aims to examine the current state of the Byzantine architectural heritage of Istanbul and, more specifically, the factors responsible for the ideological and physical approach to Byzantine ecclesiastical monuments during the Turkish Republican Period. A comprehensive examination of the current situation has shown that politics and nationalism, religion and urban development in the Historical Peninsula are the principal factors and conditions that have affected the Byzantine monuments throughout the twentieth century. These issues are first treated individually in order to determine their impact on the perception of Byzantine heritage in general and the state of preservation of its monuments in particular. The above discussion is complemented with an enquiry into the fate and condition of individual structures during the twentieth century.
    [Show full text]
  • 282 NOTICES of BOOKS Mission Archeologique De Constantinople
    282 NOTICES OF BOOKS were built. All the others have disappeared, unless indeed the mosque known as Kilissi Mesjedi is the church of Agia Anastasia Pharmacolytria, a point on which the author would have done well to consult Van Millingen's Byzantine Churches in Constantinople. The second part finds its material in the actual relics and reliquaries of Byzantine work scattered about in Europe, many of which can be directly traced to the depredations of the Crusaders. And even amongst these much has been lost; many examples, formerly preserved in France, disappeared at the Revolution, and are now known only from earlier descriptions. The study of these sanctuaries is carefully documented throughout, and affords striking evidence of the part played by relics in the popular and official worship of the church at Constantinople. This is all the more valuable, as a change has come about in this matter owing to the wholesale dispersal of relics by the crusaders and Turks. Conspicuous relics are now comparatively few in the Christian east, and the popular devo- tion which was formerly spent upon them is now mainly directed to wonder-working eicons. The present book reminds us that this was not always the case; the city was full of relics, and these were regarded as its protection against enemies, and received on fixed days the ceremonial visits of the emperor and the Court. Finally, mention must be made of the very interesting illustrations of the cult of relics drawn from the Menologion of Basil II. R. M. D. Mission archeologique de Constantinople. By JEAN EBERSOLT.
    [Show full text]
  • ARIT Newsletter American Research Institute in Turkey
    ARIT Newsletter American Research Institute in Turkey Number 54, Fall 2012 ETTER FROM THE RESIDENT President L P A. Kevin Reinhart Immediate Past President A trip to Turkey – with visits in Ankara and Istanbul – was both reassuring and disap- G. Kenneth Sams pointing. The centers are both strong and doing all they are meant to do. With superb Vice President Nicholas Cahill leadership and first-rate staffs, both Ankara and Istanbul ARIT proffer advice, obtain Secretary permits, host visiting scholars, facilitate scholarly interchange, and provide libraries filled Linda Darling with scholarly rarities and the latest works in our field. The hostels are spartan but clean, Treasurer Maria deJ. Ellis and are quite suitable for work and rest. Use of the Ankara hostel continues to be lighter Directors than desirable, but Istanbul is very often full. Seeing ARIT in action was tremendously Bülent Gültekin Gottfried Hagen heartening, and assured me that we are an essential institution both for the US and for Nina J. Köprülü Kathleen Lynch Turkey. Beatrice Manz Catherine Millard However, we have spent the fall digesting the news from the Department of Education Sylvia Önder (DOE) Title VI program that funds our administrative and infrastructural costs. Congress Christopher Roosevelt Honorary Director zero-budgeted the program last year, but this year we were assured there would be 50- Lee Striker 75% funding for this program. In the end, however, the DOE funded only ten Overseas Institutional Members Full Members Research Centers (ORCs), none of them from the Middle East. Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, University of Chicago Egypt, Yemen, Palestine, Iraq, and Turkey all received zero funding.
    [Show full text]
  • 1278 Daniștay, Onuncu Daire
    PROPERTY LAW — MEDIEVAL CHARITABLE TRUSTS — TURKEY’S HIGHEST ADMINISTRATIVE COURT ANNULS ATATURK’S 1934 DECISION CONVERTING THE HAGIA SOPHIA INTO A MUSEUM. — Daniștay, Onuncu Daire [Council of State, Tenth Chamber] Matter No. 2016/16015, Decision No. 2020/2595, July 2, 2020. Last July, Turkey’s President Erdogan sparked global controversy by ordering that Istanbul’s Hagia1 Sophia reopen as a mosque.2 A UNESCO World Heritage site, the Hagia Sophia was a cathedral and then a mosque before it became a museum, thus standing as a symbol of interfaith harmony for many.3 Many saw President Erdogan’s move as an attempt to energize his base in the face of declining poll numbers,4 but the decision technically came from a court. On July 10, 2020, the Council of State, Turkey’s highest administrative court,5 held that the 1934 conversion of the Hagia Sophia into a museum constituted misap- propriation of an Islamic charitable trust (waqf) and ordered that it re- vert to being a mosque.6 Despite claims that President Erdogan influ- enced the outcome,7 the decision was in fact legally correct. Where the court erred, however, was in its reasoning, as its cursory application of Ottoman law made an already controversial decision more vulnerable to criticism. Built in 537 A.D., the Hagia Sophia stood as the premier cathedral of the Byzantine Empire until 1453, when Ottoman forces under Sultan Mehmed II conquered Constantinople and turned the cathedral into a mosque.8 A few years later, Mehmed endowed it as an Islamic charitable trust.9 It remained a mosque until 1934 when President Ataturk, founder ––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– 1 Pronounced “Aya.” 2 See Carlotta Gall, Erdogan Signs Decree Allowing Hagia Sophia to Be Used as a Mosque Again, N.Y.
    [Show full text]