Why Pedagogy Matters: the Role of Pedagogy in Education 2030
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Why Pedagogy Matters: The role of pedagogy in Education 2030 A policy advice paper May 2017 Kay Livingston, Michele Schweisfurth, Gary Brace and Moira Nash 1 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 About the authors The two lead authors are Kay Livingston, Professor of Educational Research, Policy and Practice, University of Glasgow, and Professor Michele Schweisfurth, Chair in Comparative and International Education, University of Glasgow. Contributions were also made by Gary Brace, former Chief Executive of the General Teaching Council for Wales, and Moira Nash, formerly a campaigns manager for NGOs. 2 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 1/ Executive Summary This policy advice paper examines the central role that pedagogy should play in achieving the Education 2030 targets.1 By pedagogy, we mean the dynamic relationship between learning, teaching and culture. It also includes teachers’ beliefs about these aspects and a consideration of the context in which learning and teaching takes place. The advice suggests that UNESCO should strengthen its strategy and specific initiatives designed to support the development of quality teaching. As a result, pedagogy would be viewed as a central enabler of the 2030 targets – backed- up by an international framework which can be adapted to local contexts and monitored. A single ‘one size fits all’ vision of quality pedagogy is not appropriate to realise Goal 4 of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) because pedagogy cannot be separated from the social and resource contexts in which it exists – different countries and communities are at different starting points and will approach the Education 2030 targets in different ways. Despite these challenges, it is possible to start with a shared but adaptable vision of good pedagogy. The advice proposes seven possible principles for pedagogy: learner engagement; mutual respect between teachers and learners; building on prior learning; meaningful classroom interactions; relevance of curriculum; developing skills and attitudes as well as knowledge; and the alignment of assessment with curriculum and learner needs. 1 See Appendix for full list of Education 2030 targets. 3 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 To improve pedagogy, teachers need support in the following areas: • High quality pre-service and in-service teacher education. Teacher education and mentoring must be viewed as an on-going process, continuing throughout a teacher’s career and helping teachers to understand and apply different pedagogical principles. • Alignment of curriculum, pedagogy and assessment. Examinations need to be designed to ensure a better fit of the assessment to the different types of knowledge and skills required for the 21st century globalised world. • Alignment of new pedagogical approaches sensitively with existing cultural practices. Educational stakeholders and community leaders should develop equal partnerships and joint visions to meet the educational targets. Pedagogy should be monitored using an International Framework of Indicators which is adaptable to local circumstances and monitored through school-based self-evaluation and external evaluation. The advice suggests some possible indicators. Classroom observation should be used for mentoring as well as to gather information to inform progress. UNESCO could have a key role in helping Member States to deliver and monitor pedagogical approaches through its existing capacity-building work in teacher education; using its network of experts to develop mentoring programmes and support teacher policy development at country level and by publishing data on progress through the Global Education Monitoring Report (GEM). 4 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 We believe that UNESCO should: • Strengthen and use its existing strategies and initiatives to develop and promote a shared understanding of pedagogy which can be adapted to national and local contexts. • Help to develop, disseminate and monitor a global indicator framework for pedagogy, as part of the Education 2030 process, which can be adapted to national and local contexts. • Develop its distance learning programme to support a range of pedagogical approaches and introduce and support mentoring programmes for teachers and school leaders. • Use the Global Education Monitoring Report to monitor the professional development of teachers and teacher educators and the contribution of pedagogical approaches to achieving the Education 2030 goals. 5 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 2/ Background The new Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) or Global Goals seek to reflect the lessons from the previous decade including: • the importance of clear targets and indicators, appropriate to local and national contexts; • the need to measure wider skills – not just those which are easily measurable; • the importance of a clear set of actions to help achieve the goals. The ‘Framework for Action Education 2030: Towards inclusive and equitable quality education and lifelong learning for all’ (Education 2030) was adopted at a High-Level Meeting at UNESCO Headquarters in November 2015. It proposes a thematic indicator framework for Goal 4 of the SDGs.2 Education 2030 focuses on increased and expanded access, equity and inclusion, quality and learning outcomes as well as lifelong learning for all. It acknowledges that provision of and access to good quality education for all requires appropriate pedagogical approaches: “This requires relevant teaching and learning methods and content that meet the needs of all learners, taught by well-qualified, trained, adequately remunerated and motivated teachers, using appropriate pedagogical approaches and supported by appropriate information and communication technology (ICT)…” 3 This policy advice examines the centrality of pedagogy to achieving the SDG on education and offers ways forward for UNESCO. The advice draws on a range of 2 http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0024/002456/245656E.pdf 3 UNESCO (2015) Education 2030: Incheon Declaration and Framework for Action p.30 6 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 sources including the authors’ own research in this field.4 4 Livingston, K, (2012) ‘Quality in teachers’ career-long professional development’, in Harford, J. Hudson, B., Niemi, H. Quality Assurance and Teacher Education Policy: International Challenges and Expectations, Oxford: Peter Lang; Livingston, K. (2015) Pedagogy and Curriculum – Teachers as learners, in D. Wyse, L. Hayward and J. Pandya (Eds.) Curriculum, Pedagogy and Assessment. London: Sage Publications Ltd.; Schweisfurth, M. (2013) Learner-Centred Education in International Perspective: Whose Pedagogy for Whose Development? Series: Education, poverty and international development. Routledge: London; Schweisfurth, M. (2015) Learner-centred pedagogy; towards a post-2015 agenda for teaching and learning 7 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 3/ What is pedagogy? By pedagogy, we mean the dynamic relationship between learning, teaching and culture. Teachers’ actions in the classroom, in relation to learning and teaching, are underpinned by the ideas and values that they have about education. Pedagogy interacts with and draws together beliefs about learners and learning, teacher and teaching, and curriculum. It also includes consideration of the context in which learning and teaching takes place. Pedagogy is often shaped by a teacher’s own experience of learning. For many this was simply knowledge being transmitted by their teacher. Their role as students was to receive this knowledge without question or other interaction. This approach will not give the students of today the experiences and skills that they need to learn, work and live in the 21st century – such as critical thinking, problem solving, communication and collaboration. On-going teacher education can help to address this short-fall but evidence shows it will not be enough to change policy and practice.5 A key factor in pedagogy is developing approaches which work within different national and local contexts. A lack of critical engagement with pedagogy in global policy has allowed the space to be filled with ready-made prescriptions from a range of agencies concerned with classroom practice. Some of these prescriptions are based on models of teaching and learning which carry assumptions about quality and the potential for educational change. For example, there are wide-ranging innovations which are promoted 5 Haser, C. and Star, J. (2009) Change in beliefs after first year of teaching: the case of Turkish national curriculum context. International Journal of Educational Development, 29, pp 293-302; Westbrook, J; Durrani, N.; Brown, R.; Orr, D.; Pryor, J.; Boddy, J.; Salivi, F. (2013) Pedagogy, Curriculum, Teaching Pracitces and Teacher Education in Developing Countries. Education Rigorous Review. DFID/University of Sussex. 8 POLICY ADVICE PAPER / WHY PEDAGOGY MATTERS / MAY 2017 as learner-centred. On the other hand, some approaches are highly prescriptive in framing teacher action and classroom talk, such as so-called ‘teacher-proof’ textbooks, or teacher education with scripted lessons. All countries need to ensure that their curricula are designed to equip children with appropriate skills and knowledge. Teaching and assessment methods also need to complement the aims of education. These are issues for both developed and developing countries. It is argued that the international community