DOCSLIB.ORG

Pedagogical Quality in Preschool an Issue of Perspectives

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Pedagogical Quality in Preschool an Issue of Perspectives GÖTEBORG STUDIES IN EDUCATIONAL SCIENCES 160 Sonja Sheridan Pedagogical Quality in Preschool An issue of perspectives ACTA UNIVERSITATIS GOTHOBURGENSIS ISBN etc. To my dearest loved ones: my husband Joseph, my daughter Tina and my son Tony Abstract Title: Pedagogical Quality in Preschool – An issue of perspectives Language: English Keywords: Pedagogical quality, external evaluations of pedagogical quality, self- evaluations of pedagogical quality, a model of competence development, children’s rights ISBN: 91-7346-403-1 The main aims of this thesis on the pedagogical quality in preschool are: to define and describe a pedagogical concept of quality; to explore how quality is experienced and valued from different perspectives; to find out what characterises a pedagogical environment of high quality; and to discuss how those characteristics can be used to improve the quality of pre- school. The thesis comprises four studies, a meta-perspective of the results of these and a theoretical framework. Two studies were part of a project, which aimed to improve the peda- gogical quality in 20 preschools. The use of both external and self-evaluations of quality with ECERS gave an opportunity to compare these evaluations with one another as well as using the results to plan the content of a targeted development programme. In the third study, three preschools evaluated to be of low quality and three of good quality were selected for in-depth studies. Thirty-nine five-year-old children were interviewed about their conceptions of decision-making and how they experienced their possibilities for exercising influence in their own preschool. In a comparative study between Germany and Sweden, researchers made parallel and independent evaluations of the quality with ECERS in 20 preschools, 10 in each country. The underlying perceptual process was documented and reconstructed and presented in the form of five different themes. From a meta-perspective of the results, the concept of pedagogical quality is defined and described on a primary level, which can be seen as one step in the development of a theory of pedagogical quality. The results confirm that high quality in preschool is related to the competence of the teacher and show that activities in the participating preschools are rarely learning-orientated. This indicates that there is a difference between the children’s experience of exercising influence and the level of quality and shows that it is vital for the children to be involved in decision-making. The results clearly show that external and self- evaluations of quality differ, and that there is a tendency for teachers in low-quality preschools to overrate their own quality, while teachers in high-quality preschools seem to evaluate their quality lower than the external evaluator. The results confirm that structural aspects are no guarantee for high quality and show that low-quality preschools are more vulnerable to decreases in resources. Further, the results show that the quality in preschool can be enhanced through competence development even while organisational changes and financial cutbacks are taking place. To allow these conditions to exist and develop, at least four perspectives must be focused on during research on quality and in the development work, that is: the quality of interactions, the perspective of the teacher, the perspective of the child, and the perspective of society. The study suggests that a theory of pedagogical quality needs to be developed, to define the concept further, and that the complexity of pedagogical quality requires broad research approaches and an inclusion of different perspectives. Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS SECTION ONE INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................ 14 THE SOCIAL CONTEXT OF QUALITY ............................................................................................................ 15 A STUDY OF PEDAGOGICAL QUALITY ......................................................................................................... 17 THE OVERALL AIMS ...................................................................................................................................... 20 DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES OF QUALITY ................................................................................................... 22 A RELATIVE APPROACH ................................................................................................................................ 22 AN OBJECTIVE APPROACH ............................................................................................................................ 25 RESEARCH IN PRESCHOOL ............................................................................................................................ 28 FOUR STAGES OF RESEARCH ON QUALITY ................................................................................................. 28 PROGRAMME APPROACHES AND CHILDREN ’S OUTCOMES ...................................................................... 30 RESEARCH OF QUALITY WITH ECERS ........................................................................................................ 35 STUDIES OF CHILDREN ’S CONCEPTIONS AND LEARNING ......................................................................... 38 EVALUATION AND IMPROVEMENT OF QUALITY ....................................................................................... 41 SECTION TWO A PEDAGOGICAL PERSPECTIVE OF QUALITY .......................................................................................... 48 THE THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK OF PEDAGOGICAL QUALITY ................................................................ 50 TO VISUALISE QUALITY THROUGH EVALUATION ................................................................................. 56 METHODS FOR EVALUATION OF QUALITY ................................................................................................. 56 THE EARLY CHILDHOOD ENVIRONMENT RATING SCALE (ECERS)........................................................ 57 ECERS AND THE SWEDISH CURRICULUM FOR PRESCHOOL ..................................................................... 58 ANALYSIS USED ON THE FOUR STUDIES ..................................................................................................... 61 FOUR STUDIES OF PEDAGOGICAL QUALITY ............................................................................................ 64 THE FIRST STUDY .......................................................................................................................................... 64 THE SECOND STUDY ...................................................................................................................................... 66 THE THIRD STUDY ......................................................................................................................................... 69 THE FOURTH STUDY ...................................................................................................................................... 72 DECONSTRUCTING AND RECONSTRUCTING QUALITY ......................................................................... 75 THE QUALITY OF STRUCTURAL ASPECTS ................................................................................................... 77 THE QUALITY OF THE ATTITUDE ................................................................................................................. 80 THE QUALITY OF THE PROCESS ................................................................................................................... 82 The quality of interaction................................................................................................ 83 The perspective of the teacher ........................................................................................ 86 The (teacher’s) perspective of the child.......................................................................... 89 The perspective of society .............................................................................................. 90 THE QUALITY OF THE OUTCOME ................................................................................................................. 91 SECTION THREE GENERAL DISCUSSION ................................................................................................................................... 97 ESSENTIAL CHARACTERISTICS OF PEDAGOGICAL QUALITY .................................................................... 98 THE ROLE OF THE TEACHER ....................................................................................................................... 100 COMPETENCE DEVELOPMENT ................................................................................................................... 101 A DIFFERENT APPROACH TO THE USE OF ECERS.................................................................................... 105 IMPLICATIONS FOR RESEARCH AND QUALITY IMPROVEMENT .............................................................. 105 THE FUTURE ................................................................................................................................................. 109 REFERENCES ................................................................................................................................................... 113 STUDIES 1–4 Acknowledgements Pedagogical quality is an issue of meetings
Load more

Recommended publications
  • History Invades the Preschool Classroom
    Journal of Modern Education Review, JSSN 2155-7993, USA June 2013, Volume 3, No. 6, pp. 478-483 ©.Academic Star Publishing Company, 2013 http://www.academicstar.us History Invades the Preschool Classroom Bobbie Gibson Warash, Jessica Day, Melissa Workman, Jessica Troilo, Keri Law, Meghan Devito (West Virgiltia University, 507 Allen Hall, Morgantown WV 26506-6122, USA) Abstract: Young children in a university nursery school engaged in a personal history project. Even with obvious developmental limitations to understanding past events, young children investigated occurrences of the past related to their families. The concepts of centration, reversibility, and transductive thinking impact the cognitive thinking ofthe young child and certainly present a limitation in young children's s~dy of history in the typical manner. However, accounting for these limitations of a young child's thinking, it is important to understand and respond to their capabilities. With this in mind, a simple pictorial family tree was designed and completed by parents. The tree listed only immediate family members as far as the great great grandparents. Interesting tidbits about the family member were included and used to entice the children in their personal study. The results of the project were multifaceted with the engagement of not only children but family members. Key words: early childhood, project, history 1. Introduction Imagine, a young child talking to another child on the preschool playground about how the computer his grandfather used was as large as the school. Using the personal infonnation provided by his parents about his grandfather, the teacher helped Sam visualize the size of the large computer of the early 1970's by using yarn the same length as the circumference of the computer.
    [Show full text]
  • Education: the Three Disciplines of Educational Neuroscience
    MARIAN UNIVERSITY Indianapolis ® School of Education and Exercise Science The Three Disciplines of Educational Neuroscience Educational neuroscience is the discipline that combines neuroscience, pedagogy, and psychology bringing the current research from how the brain learns, behaves, and relates to instructional practices in the classroom. Every class, assignment, and experience shapes the human brain. Understanding how the brain processes information into learning and knowing more about what it takes for students’ brains to be engaged, responsive, and alert are fundamental to the teaching and learning process. Pedagogy is the study of the art and science of the teaching and learning process. Educators need to Neuroscience is the study of the understand how the environment, brain’s development, structure, and NEUROSCIENCE PEDAGOGY poverty, boredom, support systems, function. The goal of educators is to Brain and Individual education substance abuse, and all emotional, have successful students and one of its functioning and learning social, and cognitive facets affect the ways to promote success in our the brain and how it learns, students is to understand how the NEUROEDUCATION relates, and behaves. Educational learning process occurs. The process Mind, brain, and neuroscience is the active of learning involves changing the education science engagement of purposeful strategies brain. The selection of instructional based on the principles derived techniques and the designing from neuroscience and of lesson plans can be aided educational psychology. by understanding how the brain responds and through applying principles from the neuroscience PSYCHOLOGY Educational psychology is the research in the classrooms. Mind and behavior study of developmental mental processes responsible for cognition and behavior.
    [Show full text]
  • Powerful, Joyful, Rigorous Language and Literacy Learning
    A Preschool – 5th Grade Model Preschool Powerful, Joyful, Rigorous Language and Literacy Learning SOBRATO.ORG THE SEAL MODEL POWERFUL LANGUAGE LEARNING INTRODUCTION SEAL is a preschool through third grade program of the Sobrato Family Foundation. SEAL is designed to build the capacity of preschools and elementary schools to powerfully develop the language and literacy skills of young Dual Language/English Learner children, to support development, and to close the academic achievement gap by fourth grade. It is also a model of language-rich, joyful and rigorous education for all children. SEAL develops rich, powerful language and literacy in the context of delivering a full curriculum. SEAL classrooms are alive with language! Language and literacy education is woven into all aspects of the school day. Children use high-level, complex language to talk about what they are learning, express their feelings and thoughts, ask questions, make predictions, and think through solutions to academic and social problems and tasks. Teachers model rich, expressive language and create environments where vocabulary and Teachers model rich, expressive language concepts come to life. Children learn through active hands-on, and create environments where academic play-based, project-based, inquiry focused opportunities to vocabulary and concepts come to life. engage with their world. For young Dual Language Learners, SEAL creates the learning conditions that build language and literacy skills necessary for participation in their multiple language and cultural worlds, the academic world and their communities. Whenever possible, SEAL promotes the development of biliteracy, affirming and supporting home language for Dual Language Learner children and families, and developing high levels of proficiency in both Spanish and English.
    [Show full text]
  • Preschool Educational Practice Guidelines for Preschool Teachers
    STATE OF ISRAEL MINISTRY OF EDUCATION PRESCHOOL EDUCATION DIVISION PRESCHOOL EDUCATIONAL PRACTICE GUIDELINES FOR PRESCHOOL TEACHERS תש”ע - 2010 1 Co-Authors: Aviva Sverdlov Ora Goldhirsch Dr. Ester Barocas Esther Ron Graciela Budnick Hava Biger Tova Shmueli Judith Finkiel Monica Winokur Mia Ronis Martine Worms Dr. AnatSela Fatma Kasem Ronit Amir Shirit Tallis SaritaSpokojny Tamar Eilon Coordinator: Sima Hadad Ma-Yafit, Head of Preschool Education Division Academic and Technical Reviewers: Prof. Eva Teubal Dr. Rina Michaelovitz Published by: Gaaf Advertising, Ministry of Education עשייה חינוכית בגן הילדים קווים מנחים לצוות החינוכי 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface 4 Introduction 7 Preschool Teachers’ Commitment 8 Developmental Processes in Preschool Age Children 11 Optimal Preschool Climate 13 Preschool Staff 16 Class Organization and Administration 18 Educational Goals, Work Plans and Syllabus 22 Preschool Curricular Content 32 Working in Small Groups 35 Adapting Teaching Practice to Children’s Ways of Learning 37 Parents as Partners in the Educational Processes 40 References and Professional Literature Recommended for Further Reading 44 APPENDICES Appendix 1 - Optimal Preschool Climate 47 Appendix 2 - Suggested Daily Schedule for the Extended- Day Preschool in the “New Horizons” Program 53 Appendix 3 - Operational Aims, Goals and Expected Behaviors following the Core Curriculum 60 Appendix 4 - A Strategy for Teaching-Learning in Small Groups 67 3 PREFACE The essence of preschool activity centers on the child and the educational process. The continuous educational process in the school system places particular emphasis on the children’s individual personality from the moment they start preschool, providing for their physical, emotional, social and intellectual needs, allowing them to fulfill their potential, develop their inner creativity and widen their fields of interest.
    [Show full text]
  • Why Pedagogy Matters: the Importance of Teaching in a Standards-Based Environment Susan Entz, Instructor, Hawaii Community College
    Forum on Public Policy Why Pedagogy Matters: The Importance of Teaching In A Standards-Based Environment Susan Entz, Instructor, Hawaii Community College Abstract The goal of the standards movement has been to improve student outcomes for all children regardless of their backgrounds or risk factors. The focus has primarily been on the instructional, program or performance standards. Paramount importance has been placed on what children will do to demonstrate that they have learned. While important, there is another ingredient in achieving positive student outcomes. What teachers do and how they do it is critically important and has a profound impact on the quality of the educational experience for children. This paper presents the seminal work of the Center For Research On Education, Diversity and Excellence (CREDE), one of the twelve federally funded research centers on education. Its findings, summarized in five critical elements of effective pedagogy, demonstrate that when consistently implemented the result is greater student outcomes across the curriculum regardless of age, and higher academic test scores regardless of the student population. Application in early childhood education settings is also discussed. Pedagogy: The Science Of Teaching Word Origin--Greek: Paidagogas paidos—a boy a gogos-leader agein-to lead In Ancient Greece a paidagogos was a trusted slave who accompanied a child to his classes, ensured his good behavior in public, cared for his needs and tutored him with his homework. Introduction Teaching and learning are complex processes. Throughout history, society has looked for better ways to educate children. Americans are still struggling with that fundamental issue, particularly in light of our diverse population and the rapid rate of technological change.
    [Show full text]
  • Progressive Education: Why It's Hard to Beat, but Also Hard to Find
    Bank Street College of Education Educate Progressive Education in Context College History and Archives 2015 Progressive Education: Why it's Hard to Beat, But Also Hard to Find Alfie ohnK Follow this and additional works at: https://educate.bankstreet.edu/progressive Part of the Curriculum and Instruction Commons, Curriculum and Social Inquiry Commons, Educational Methods Commons, and the Social and Philosophical Foundations of Education Commons Recommended Citation Kohn, A. (2015). Progressive Education: Why it's Hard to Beat, But Also Hard to Find. Bank Street College of Education. Retrieved from https://educate.bankstreet.edu/progressive/2 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the College History and Archives at Educate. It has been accepted for inclusion in Progressive Education in Context by an authorized administrator of Educate. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Progressive Education Why It’s Hard to Beat, But Also Hard to Find By Alfie Kohn If progressive education doesn’t lend itself to a single fixed definition, that seems fitting in light of its reputation for resisting conformity and standardization. Any two educators who describe themselves as sympathetic to this tradition may well see it differently, or at least disagree about which features are the most important. Talk to enough progressive educators, in fact, and you’ll begin to notice certain paradoxes: Some people focus on the unique needs of individual students, while oth- ers invoke the importance of a community of learners; some describe learning as a process, more journey than destination, while others believe that tasks should result in authentic products that can be shared.[1] What It Is Despite such variations, there are enough elements on which most of us can agree so that a common core of progressive education emerges, however hazily.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Professional Development in Creating
    Draft: Please do not cite or distribute without permission of authors The Brookings Institution 1775 MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE, NW WASHINGTON, DC 20036-2188 TEL: 202-797-6297 FAX: 202-797-6004 WWW.BROOKINGS.EDU Welfare Reform & Beyond Working Paper1 THE ROLE OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT IN CREATING HIGH QUALITY PRESCHOOL EDUCATION BY MARTHA ZASLOW AND KATHERINE TOUT, CHILD TRENDS KELLY MAXWELL AND RICHARD CLIFFORD, FPG CHILD DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE OCTOBER 2004 PAPER PREPARED FOR THE BROOKINGS INSTITUTION – UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA CONFERENCE ON “CREATING A NATIONAL PLAN FOR THE EDUCATION OF 4-YEAR-OLDS.” 1 This working paper from the Brookings Institution has not been through a formal review process and should be considered a draft. Please contact the authors for permission if you are interested in citing this paper or any portion of it. This paper is distributed in the expectation that it may elicit useful comments and is subject to subsequent revision. The views expressed in this piece are those of the authors and should not be attributed to the staff, officers or trustees of the Brookings Institution. Martha Zaslow is a Senior Scholar at Child Trends. Kathryn Tout is a Research Associate at Child Trends Richard Clifford is a Senior Scientist at the Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill Kelly Maxwell is a Scientist at the the Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill 1 Draft: Please do not cite or distribute without permission of authors Brookings Working Paper The Role of Professional Development in Creating High Quality Preschool Education Martha Zaslow and Kathryn Tout, Child Trends Kelly Maxwell and Richard Clifford, FPG Child Development Institute available online at: http://www.brookings.edu/es/research/projects/wrb/200409conference.htm This paper focuses on professional development as a contributor to high quality preschool education.
    [Show full text]
  • Psychological Pedagogy for Quality Teaching and Learning
    Psychological Pedagogy for Quality Teaching and Learning Professor Lucija Rutka, Dr.psych, Mg.math. University of Latvia Aim of presentation To acquaint in general with the personal academic and research experience and to discuss together the most effective ways of achieving the learning outcomes in the Educational Psychology Module About me • Professor, University of Latvia, Faculty of Education, Psychology and Art • Expert in education at the Council of Sciences of the Republic of Latvia • Since 2015 - National research programme „Innovative Solutions in Social Telerehabilitation in the Schools of Latvia in the Context of Inclusive Education” • 2012 – 2013 – ESF project „Creating a Support System for the Youth at Risk of Inclusive Education and Social Exclusion, Preparing and Providing Necessary Personnel and Improving Their Competence” My courses in bachelor, master and doctoral study programs • Developmental Psychology • Theories of Developmental Psychology • Communication Psychology • Personalization of Pedagogical Process • Teaching and Learning in University • Development of the Personality in the Socialization Process • Educator's Personal Effectiveness • Communication in the Study Process • Communication Peculiarities between Doctor and Patient • and others Psychological pedagogy My research area is Psychological pedagogy, wich is new trend in our university. The main research subject of psychological pedagogy is psychological competence of teachers (students) Research area The teacher’s psychological competence is composed of
    [Show full text]
  • Transitions and Alignment from PRESCHOOL to KINDERGARTEN
    SEP 2018 Transitions and Alignment FROM PRESCHOOL TO KINDERGARTEN BRUCE ATCHISON SARAH POMPELIA SPECIAL REPORT www.ecs.org | @EdCommission 2 Too often government officials Six states reference early transitions in statute; and design programs for children as 14 states, plus the District of Columbia, reference if they lived their lives in silos, them in code. as if each stage of a child’s life were independent of the other, unconnected to what came The early childhood years are recognized before or what lies ahead. as the cornerstone of effective P-20 educational James Heckman1 experience, yet there is a persistent gap in the transition from preschool Policymakers and educators continue to grapple with issues of persistent to kindergarten. achievement gaps in student performance at third grade and beyond. As they do, they look for ways to create a more seamless system of education that is “connected from one stage to the next — reducing the chances that students will be lost along the way or require remedial programs to acquire skills or knowledge they could have learned right from the start.”2 Successful transitions from preschool to Successful coordination between preschool and kindergarten helps to lay the groundwork for a child’s positive school experience. If this transition kindergarten and does not go well, children can be turned off to learning and school at an alignment of standards, early age. By aligning standards, curricula, instruction and assessments curricula, instruction and between preschool and kindergarten, children can experience a seamless assessments between the pathway that sets them up for future success. two are key to a child’s Based on research and work with states, Education Commission of the future educational success.
    [Show full text]
  • Department of Early Education and Care
    DEPARTMENT OF EARLY EDUCATION AND CARE Professional Qualification Certification Requirements and Frequently Asked Questions Contact EEC at (617)988-6600 ask for the Professional Qualification Unit or email EEC at [email protected] Department of Early Education and Care October 2017 PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATION CERTIFICATION Requirements and Information Packet Contents EEC Requirements for Certification .............................................................................................................................3 Regulations for Certification ...................................................................................................................................3 Education towards certification: .............................................................................................................................3 Continuing Education Unit (CEU): ............................................................................................................................4 Certificate Program: ................................................................................................................................................4 Work Experience requirements towards certification..............................................................................................4 Acceptable Alternative Early Childhood Training Program: ......................................................................................5 Requirements for Certification breakdown .................................................................................................................6
    [Show full text]
  • The Pedagogy of Poverty Versus Good Teaching
    Kappan Classic KAPPAN digital edition exclusive The Pedagogy of Poverty Versus Good Teaching It will be formidably difficult to institutionalize new forms of pedagogy for the children of poverty, but it is worthwhile to define and describe such alternatives. By Martin Haberman This article Why is a “minor” issue like improving the quality of urban teaching generally overlooked by the popu- was originally lar reform and restructuring strategies? There are several possibilities. First, we assume that we know what published as teaching is, that others know what it is, that we are discussing the same “thing” when we use the word, and “The Pedagogy that we would all know good teaching if we saw it. Second, we believe that, since most teachers cannot be of Poverty Versus Good Teaching” by changed anyway, there must be other, more potent, teacher-proof strategies for change. Third, why bother Martin Haberman. with teaching if research shows that achievement test Phi Delta Kappan scores of poor and minority youngsters are affected 73, no. 4 (December primarily by their socioeconomic class; affected 1991): 290-294. somewhat by Head Start, school integration, and hav- ing a “strong” principal; and affected almost not at all by the quality of their teachers? THE PEDAGOGY OF POVERTY An observer of urban classrooms can find exam- ples of almost every form of pedagogy: direct instruc- tion, cooperative learning, peer tutoring, individual- ized instruction, computer-assisted learning, behav- ior modification, the use of student contracts, media- assisted instruction, scientific inquiry, lecture/discus- sion, tutoring by specialists or volunteers, and even the use of problem-solving units common in progres- Deepen your sive education.
    [Show full text]
  • Pedagogy, Curriculum, Teaching Practices and Teacher Education in Developing Countries
    Education Rigorous Literature Review Pedagogy, Curriculum, Teaching Practices and Teacher Education in Developing Countries Dr Jo Westbrook Dr Naureen Durrani Rhona Brown Dr David Orr Dr John Pryor Dr Janet Boddy Francesca Salvi December 2013 This material has been funded by the Department for International Development. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of the Department for International Development. The authors are part of the Centre for International Education, University of Sussex. This paper can be found on the DFID Research for Development website: http://r4d.dfid.gov.uk/ and the EPPI-Centre website: http://eppi.ioe.ac.uk/ The EPPI-Centre reference number for this report is 2110. Westbrook J, Durrani N, Brown R, Orr D, Pryor J, Boddy J, Salvi F (2013) Pedagogy, Curriculum, Teaching Practices and Teacher Education in Developing Countries. Final Report. Education Rigorous Literature Review. Department for International Development. © Copyright Authors of the review hold the copyright for the text of the review. The authors give permission to display and print the contents of the review for their own non-commercial use, providing that the materials are not modified, copyright and other proprietary notices contained in the materials are retained, and the source of the material is cited clearly following the citation details provided. Otherwise users are not permitted to duplicate, reproduce, re-publish, distribute, or store material from this review without express written permission. Contents Abbreviations ..........................................................................................
    [Show full text]