DOCSLIB.ORG

German Idealism: the Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801 Pdf, Epub, Ebook

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
German Idealism: the Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801 Pdf, Epub, Ebook GERMAN IDEALISM: THE STRUGGLE AGAINST SUBJECTIVISM, 1781-1801 PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Frederick C. Beiser | 752 pages | 04 May 2011 | HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS | 9780674027176 | English | Cambridge, Mass, United States German Idealism: The Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801 PDF Book The Meaning of Absolute Idealism 3. Friend Reviews. The Blinding Light of 2. Thanks for telling us about the problem. More filters. View all 3 comments. Professor Philosophy Hall of Languages The Problematic Status of the Categories 2. Regulative or Constitutive? The Transcendental versus the Subjective 4. Beiser, Harvard University Press June 10, , pp. The Elements of Magical Idealism 5. Self-Knowledge and Freedom 7. Objective Idealism 3. In this book, Beiser sought to reconstruct the background of German Idealism through the narration of the story of the Spinoza or Pantheism controversy. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. A very interesting and thorough examination of thinkers who get very little attention, especially in the English speaking world. In the current volume Zammito carries over and amplifies this sentiment. The Aenesidemus Review 3. The Origins of Intellectual Intuition 4. It is impossible to not only read Kant and the Jean school but the whole of the post-Husserlian phenomenologists except in the light the history of post-Kantian thought and its development as well as misinterpretation. Namely the problematic relationship of subjectivity to objectivity in the works of Kant, Fichte, Jena romantics and Schelling. Models of Knowledge 4. If the boundary between apes and humans was subject to equivocations it would not be surprising that there would also be debate about the unity of humans as a species, resulting in discourses about race and the origins of what has been referred to as "scientific racism. Beiser, Cambridge University Press April 26, pp. Beginning with Ken Caneva's scathing review, a minor cottage industry "The Conversation" to which I referred above arose oriented toward denying the influence of Kant and, with no less partisan fervor, championing the scientific merits and accomplishments of Naturphilosophie instead. The Theory of Ideas 2. Showing Stahl, while a leading chemist of the times, held the "rational" capacity of living tissue to sustain functional order and resist decay to constitute a prima facie basis for rejecting any purely physicalist medicine. Jason Bowden rated it it was amazing Mar 29, Problems, Methods, and Concepts of Naturphilosophie 1. Critical Idealism 1. As I get into Schelling, I find myself agreeing with the direction of Absolute idealism so much more. Lists with This Book. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Beiser, Harvard University Press May 29, , pp. German Idealism: The Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801 Writer Andrew rated it liked it Oct 09, I actually quite enjoyed reading this, with the only part becoming burdensome being the explanation of Schelling's philosophy of nature, which is fairly obscure and outdated nowadays, even if it did play a leading part in the development of absolute idealism. Zammito defines the conversation that shapes the aims and point of departure of his recent book and in relation to which he offers some criteria for assessing its merits. The experiences and things St. The First Quarrel 2. The Problematic of Naturphilosophie 3. Enlarge cover. Problems, Methods, and Concepts of Naturphilosophie 1. The Battle against Skepticism 1. The Discovery of Desire 4. Mar 18, Aryandokht Massahi rated it it was amazing. The Transformation of the Kantian Problematic 2. The First Decisive Step 4. International Napoleonic Society Literary Award Organic processes entailed a force that was supplemental to those of physics and chemistry but not such as to exclude them. He's also intimately familiar with the context he's dealing with, and with all of the subsequent debates about interpretation. Black voices matter. The Meaning of Freedom 2. The chemical physics of excitable soft condensed matter now offers the opportunity for renewed thinking about the productivity of matter. Hardcover , pages. Cyberdionysos rated it it was amazing May 26, Buy Elsewhere Bookshop. More Details It is impossible to not only read Kant and the Jean school but the whole of the post-Husserlian phenomenologists except in the light the history of post-Kantian thought and its development as well as misinterpretation. Beiser, Harvard University Press January 22, , pp. The Clash of Interpretations 2. The Doctrine of Inner Sense 6. The Dark Night of the Absolute 1. What are we capable of knowing about the world and what are the pieces that make up the world? In the background, but not deep in the background, is the continuation of an on-going demolition of Timothy Lenoir's [2] Kantian interpretation of some of the same history, but more on this later. In exploring the applicability of the same family of mechanisms in an infinity of different ways, nature appears to adhere to a unity of method, a universal principle, or "world soul". The Elements of Magical Idealism 5. He received a NEH Faculty Fellowship at Indiana University , and he has won awards for his outstanding undergraduate teaching. Transcendental versus Empirical Idealism 4. Bekijk en vergelijk alle verkopers. From a "presentist" and scientific point of view however the exact interpretation of Kant's distinction may be of less moment than the extent to which Kant's "methodology of teleology" has been pragmatically put to use in practice. Reviews Schrijf een review. This is a great book for undestanding the epistemological questions driving Kant's critical philosophy, including the question and challenges posed by the empiricism of Berkeley and Hume. An Antifoundationalist Epistemology 4. It totally explodes the tired old stereotypes about the school blowing ever larger solipsistic bubbles that grow to cosmic size with Hegel. Theory of Life and Matter 1. Kenneth Westphal Oxford: Blackwell , pp. View 1 comment. The time for invidious historicist squabbling is past. As I get into Schelling, I find myself agreeing with the direction of Absolute idealism so much more. German Idealism: The Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801 Reviews Betrokkenen Auteur Frederick C. The Development of Naturphilosophie 1. The Critique of Fichte 4. Het is echter in een enkel geval mogelijk dat door omstandigheden de bezorging vertraagd is. The Meaning of Freedom 2. International Napoleonic Society Literary Award The Critique of Idealism in the Inaugural Dissertation 5. The preponderance of irritability, for example, would be inversely proportional to the place of species in the hierarchy of life forms. Background 2. The Aenesidemus Review 3. The German Historicist Tradition. Beiser then goes into the challenges Kant's answers faced and Kant's responses as well as the responses of later German Idealists, particularly Schelling. The issues discussed in this most highly readable book get at the current foundational dilemmas floating around the hardest of the hard sciences, physics. The Argument of the Refutation 7. The Cambridge Companion to German Idealism 0. The Theory of Life 4. Schelling pursues a synthesis of Buffon, Kant, Blumenbach and Kielmeyer. In his book The Strategy of Life , [4] Lenoir laid claim to the idea that out of the Kant-Blumenbach correspondence there arose a "teleomechanist" research program embodying a Kantian regulative vs constitutive distinction, that could be clearly demarcated from all forms of Romantic Naturphilosophie , and whose uptake can be seen at root in the great advances of 19 th century German biology including the identification of germ layers in embryonic development, the identification of the human ova, the primacy of the cell and the advancement of cell theory and cellular based studies of pathology. Beginning with a critical evaluation of Zammito's treatment of Kant, I will offer some suggestions for how subsequent investigators, with a vision of contemporary problems in the philosophy of biology, could draw upon the legacy of teleomechanism and Naturphilosophie as complementary resources. Sometimes the question get posed as is their freewill, or is the world an illusion or are appearances different from reality, or other such variations. Harveycmd rated it it was amazing Jun 05, German Idealism: The Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801 Read Online Lectures on Transcendental Idealism IV. Beiser frames the discussion by examining each thinkers relation to idealism and subjectivism, often arguing against mainstream narratives as overly simplistic or niave. Beiser's first book, The Fate of Reason: German Philosophy from Kant to Fichte Harvard, was widely influential in revising the commonly held, but notorious accounts of German Idealism. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. The Two Systems 3. Appearance of Appearance: Its Novelty 8. In winkelwagen. Beiser has a talent for making incredibly complex philosophical arguments accessible. Showing Related Articles. Contemporary Kant Scholarship 1. Jason Bowden rated it it was amazing Mar 29, Theory of Life and Matter 1. Models of Knowledge 4. Reintroducing and Reinterpreting the Thing-in-Itself 7. Diderot made the case for extending the interpretative ambit of experimentalism beyond strict empirical observation. Cyberdionysos rated it it was amazing May 26, Transcendental versus Empirical Idealism 4. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. This is a great book for undestanding the epistemological questions driving Kant's critical
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Truth in Economic Subjectivism
    Munich Personal RePEc Archive Truth in Economic Subjectivism Zuniga, Gloria L. October 1998 Online at https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/5568/ MPRA Paper No. 5568, posted 04 Nov 2007 UTC Journal of Markets & Morality 1, no. 2(October 1998), 158-168 Markets & Morality 159 Copyright © 1998 Center for Economic Personalism The first is an epistemic sense of ‘subjective’ that provides an acco unt of choice given the constraint of limited resources despite unlimited wants. The second is an ontological sense of subjective that describes the eco- nomic character of things as dependent on human acts of valuing. Truth in Economic Subjectivism Carl Menger advanced this account of the subjective theory of value in his Principles of Economics, first published in 1871. The significance of his co ntributio n lies in the transcatego rical description of social phenomena. Gloria L. Zúñiga While most accounts reduce value either to the mind or to some intrinsic Doctoral Candidate in Philosophy pro perty o f things, Menger demo nstrated that all so cial phenomena was State University of New York at Buffalo composed of varying combinations of beliefs and entities, judgments and facts, mind and matter. In order to achieve such a transcatego rial acco unt of value, Menger first provided an epistemic account of economic valua- tion by grounding his analysis on the experience of the valuing individual. Second, he provided a description of exact laws of economic phenomena, The Problem of Subjectivism thus advancing an ontology of economic objects. The achievement
    [Show full text]
  • A Sociological Study of Nihilism: a Case Study
    International Journal of Liberal Arts and Social Science ISSN: 2307-924X www.ijlass.org A Sociological Study of Nihilism: A Case Study Jahangir Jahangiri, PhD Assistant Professor of Sociology, Department of Sociology and Social Planning, Faculty of Social Sciences, Shiraz University, Eram Place, Shiraz, Fars, Iran Code Postal: 7194685115 Email: [email protected] Rayehe Ghareh M.A in Sociology, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran Email: [email protected] Abstract The present research aims at studying nihilistic thoughts among students of Shiraz University. The framework of the research is Crosby’s theory about nihilism. The study is based on a quantitative approach and employs a survey method so as to collect the required data. Statistical population of the study is the whole Students of Shiraz University that according to the formal statistics consists of 20000 students. 400 students are selected by multistage sampling method. The results show that there is a significant relationship between the independent variables of gender, adherences to religious practices, fatalism, fear of failure, need for achievement and the dependent variable nihilism. Stepwise regression method used to predict the dependent variable. Ordinarily, five variables of fatalism, fear of failure, Adherences to religious practices, gender and need for achievement could predict 33% of dependent variable (R2=0.338) Key Words: Nihilism, Sociology, University Students, Shiraz University, Iran Introduction Undoubtedly, the most fundamental question that every human being faces with, is about the purpose of life. Not only modern human, but also pre-modern human beings have been encountered with this question. The intolerable journey from birth to death, and relentless onslaughts of hopelessness and despair, persuade every human to answer the question, as possible.
    [Show full text]
  • Agency: Moral Identity and Free Will
    D Agency AVID Moral Identity and Free Will W DAVID WEISSMAN EISSMAN There is agency in all we do: thinking, doing, or making. We invent a tune, play, or use it to celebrate an occasion. Or we make a conceptual leap and ask more ab- stract ques� ons about the condi� ons for agency. They include autonomy and self- appraisal, each contested by arguments immersing us in circumstances we don’t control. But can it be true we that have no personal responsibility for all we think Agency and do? Agency: Moral Ident ty and Free Will proposes that delibera� on, choice, and free will emerged within the evolu� onary history of animals with a physical advantage: Moral Identity organisms having cell walls or exoskeletons had an internal space within which to protect themselves from external threats or encounters. This defense was both and Free Will structural and ac� ve: such organisms could ignore intrusions or inhibit risky behav- ior. Their capaci� es evolved with � me: inhibi� on became the power to deliberate and choose the manner of one’s responses. Hence the ability of humans and some other animals to determine their reac� ons to problema� c situa� ons or to informa- � on that alters values and choices. This is free will as a material power, not as the DAVID WEISSMAN conclusion to a conceptual argument. Having it makes us morally responsible for much we do. It prefi gures moral iden� ty. A GENCY Closely argued but plainly wri� en, Agency: Moral Ident ty and Free Will speaks for autonomy and responsibility when both are eclipsed by ideas that embed us in his- tory or tradi� on.
    [Show full text]
  • Objectivism/Subjectivism in Scientific Articles of Different Areas: the Heterogeneity of Academic Writing
    OBJETIVISMO/SUBJETIVISMO EM ARTIGOS CIENTÍFICOS DAS DIFERENTES ÁREAS: A HETEROGENEIDADE DA ESCRITA ACADÊMICA Ângela Francine FUZA* ▪ RESUMO: A existência do discurso que postula a homogeneização da escrita acadêmico- científica no processo de constituição do texto é a problemática que desencadeou esta pesquisa. Nesse sentido, o objetivo deste estudo é analisar artigos científicos brasileiros de periódicos A1 das diferentes áreas do conhecimento a partir dos elementos que constituem os gêneros, forma composicional, estilo e temática, delimitando aspectos que tendem ao objetivismo e ao subjetivismo nos textos. O trabalho se pauta nos pressupostos dialógicos do Círculo de Bakhtin, no tocante aos gêneros, ao objetivismo e subjetivismo, e nas pesquisas desenvolvidas segundo os princípios dos Novos Estudos do Letramento. Os resultados apontam que: a) todo enunciado é constituído de elementos subjetivos e objetivos; b) os aspectos que evidenciam objetividade e subjetividade marcam-se predominantemente na forma composicional (e arquitetônica) e no estilo dos textos, em diálogo com a temática; c) os artigos das diferentes áreas se assemelham, ao tratar de elementos que tendem à objetividade, como forma composicional e recursos linguísticos; d) os artigos diferem quando apresentam aspectos que, embora estejam na materialidade verbal, encontram significação no contexto extraverbal, perpassando a subjetividade, como escolha temática; variação no número de autores no texto etc.; e) a existência de nuances de objetividade e de subjetividade permite caracterizar a escrita nas áreas de forma heterogênea. ▪ PALAVRAS-CHAVE: Objetivismo. Subjetivismo. Escrita acadêmica. Artigo científico. Introdução A escrita acadêmico-científica tem sido um tema amplamente discutido no meio acadêmico por pesquisadores do campo dos estudos da linguagem em seus vários âmbitos e perspectivas metodológicas.
    [Show full text]
  • Frederick Beiser: German Idealism. the Struggle Against Subjectivism
    Elizabeth Millän-Zaibert (Chicago) Frederick Beiser. German Idealism. The Struggle against Sub­ jectivism, 1781-1801. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA, 2002. XVI + 726 S. ISBN 0-674-00769-7. A recent surge of Anglophone inte­ cerning Lessing's alleged Spinozism rest in German Idealism and early (1780-85); the profound effects German Romanticism has resulted in which the publication of Kant's Cri­ nothing less than a publishing boom tique of Pure Reason (1781, 1787) of studies in this area. Frederick Bei­ had upon the philosophical climate ser's work was crucial in preparing of the period; K.L. Reinhold's at­ the ground for this development of tempts to establish a foundation for English language studies of German Kant's Critique, which found their Idealism and early German Romanti­ fullest expression in his Über das cism. In The Fate of Reason: Ger­ Fundament des philosophischen Wis­ man Philosophy Between Kant and sens (1791); and the effects of Fich- Fichte (1987) and Enlightenment, te's Wissenschaftslehre (1794) on the Revolution, and Romanticism: The German philosophical mood of the Genesis of Modern German Political period. Thought (1992), Beiser made a com­ Beiser's work imbued the philoso­ pelling case that many German phi­ phical drama that unfolded on the losophers of the immediate post- German philosophical scene of the Kantian period and the issues that late 1700s and early 1800s with new they raised were worthy of much life. This reawakening of the key more attention than they had hitherto controversies and the figures who received in the English-speaking were crucial players in this drama world.
    [Show full text]
  • German Idealism: the Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801
    Marquette University e-Publications@Marquette Theology Faculty Research and Publications Theology, Department of 1-1-2004 Review of "German Idealism: The trS uggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801" by Frederick C. Beiser Philip J. Rossi Marquette University, [email protected] Published version. Theological Studies, Vol. 65, No. 1 (2004): 217-218. Permalinkf. © 2004 Theological Studies, Inc. Used with permission. BOOK REVIEWS 217 Catholic leaders to give us the married as well as the celibate diocesan priests we need. Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles JOHN A. COLEMAN, S.J. GERMAN IDEALISM:THE STRUGGLE AGAINST SUBJECTIVISM, 1781–1801. By Frederick C. Beiser. Cambridge: Harvard University, 2002. Pp. xvi + 726. $61.50. Beiser’s important earlier studies—The Fate of Reason (1987) and En- lightenment, Revolution, and Romanticism (1992)—placed the trajectory of ideas, issues, and arguments of late 18th- and early 19th-century German philosophy and political thought within an illuminating account of their cultural and political contexts. In this work, B. shifts attention from that larger background and presents, in contrast, a closely focused analysis of the texts of six thinkers—Kant, Fichte, Ho¨ lderlin, Novalis, Schlegel, and Schelling—that bear upon “one specific theme: the meaning of idealism itself, and more specifically the reaction against subjectivism” (viii). The analysis is in service of a larger thesis that goes counter to a commonly accepted interpretation of German idealism as “essentially the culmination of the Cartesian tradition,” which is usually accompanied by “a seductively simple narrative” that makes it “the gradual and inevitable completion of Kant’s ‘Copernican Revolution’”(1–2). B.
    [Show full text]
  • G. E. MOORE on CONCEPTS and JUDGMENT* G. E. Moore Sobre Conceptos Y Juicio
    DOI: 10.36446/af.2021.357 G. E. MOORE ON CONCEPTS AND JUDGMENT* G. E. Moore sobre conceptos y juicio SEBASTIÁN BRICEÑO a https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3040-4869 [email protected] a Universidad de Santiago de Chile, Santiago, Chile Abstract In “The Nature of Judgment” (1899), G. E. Moore defends the strange thesis according to which “[i]t seems necessary… to regard the world as formed of concepts”. Philosophers have offered distinct understandings of this proposal, in particular of what Moorean concepts really are. In this article I discuss and reject three of them: one, according to which Moorean concepts are universals within the framework of a bundle theory of concrete particulars (Nelson, 1962; Baldwin, 1990); a second one, according to which Moorean concepts are particulars within a mereological framework of analysis (Bell, 1999); and a third one, according to which Moorean concepts are a sui generis category, resulting from his alleged rejection of the substance (particular)/attribute (universal) distinction (MacBride, 2018). I end by defending my own understanding, which highlights the openly Platonic stance of the young G. E. Moore. Key words: Concepts; Judgment; Proposition; Abstract; Particular; Universal; Substance. Resumen En “The Nature of Judgment” (1899), G. E. Moore defiende la extraña tesis según la cual “[p]arece necesario… entender al mundo como formado de conceptos”. Los filósofos han ofrecido distintas comprensiones de esta propuesta, en particular de lo que los conceptos mooreanos realmente son. En este artículo discuto y rechazo tres de ellas: una, según la cual los conceptos mooreanos son universales dentro del marco de una teoría del cúmulo sobre particulares concretos (Nelson, 1962; Baldwin, 1990); una segunda, según la cual los conceptos mooreanos son particulares dentro de un marco de análisis mereológico (Bell, 1999); y una tercera, según la cual los conceptos mooreanos son una categoría sui generis, resultante del supuesto rechazo de la distinción substancia (particular)/atributo (universal) (MacBride 2018).
    [Show full text]
  • 12-Ethical Subjectivism.Pdf
    Metaethics Ethics and Metaethics Normative ethics: the study of goodness, virtue, and right action. • What is intrinsically good? • What is the best distribution of benefits and burdens in the world? • What traits of character do we value in people? • What rules or principles should we follow? Metaethics: the study of these moral concepts and their grounding. • What is the scope and status of moral values? • What does it mean to say that “X is good”? • Do moral claims like “X is good” have a truth-value? • Do moral values exist in the world independently of human beings? Subjectivism and Objectivism Ethical Subjectivism: the truth of moral judgments is grounded in an arbitrary will. • Simple Ethical Subjectivism (SES): the individual’s feelings. • Divine Command Theory (DCT): the will of God. • Ethical Relativism (ER): the beliefs of the group. EthicalArbitrary Objectivism =df. based: theon truthrandom of moral choice judgments or is groundedpersonal in some whim, non-arbitrary rather than reality any .reason or • Aristotle’ssystem: virtue his theory: mealtimes human flourishing were. entirely • John Stuart Mill’s utilitarianism: pleasure. • Immanuelarbitrary. Kant’s deontologism: reason. Subjectivism and Objectivism Ethical Subjectivism: the truth of moral judgments is grounded in an arbitrary will. • Simple Ethical Subjectivism (SES): the individual’s feelings. • Divine Command Theory (DCT): the will of God. • Ethical Relativism (ER): the beliefs of the group. Ethical Objectivism: the truth of moral judgments is grounded in some non-arbitrary reality. • Aristotle’s virtue theory: human flourishing. • John Stuart Mill’s utilitarianism: pleasure. • Immanuel Kant’s deontologism: reason. Simple Ethical Subjectivism (1/4) “Take any action allow'd to be vicious: Wilful murder, for instance.
    [Show full text]
  • Mackie's Argument from Queerness for Nihilism I. Introduction to Moral
    Phil. 173: Metaethics Jan. 24, 2018 Lecture 2: Mackie’s Argument from Queerness for Nihilism I. Introduction to Moral Nihilism moral nihilism: Just as there is no such thing as phlogiston, there is no such thing as moral goodness, rightness, wrongness, duty, obligation, or any other moral notion. It is commonly claimed that according to nihilism, all moral sentences are false. This is a mistake. • first problem: Even if nihilism is correct, some moral sentences should come out as true. “Failing one’s students for fun is wrong.” “It is not the case that failing one’s students for fun is wrong.” “Your professor believes that failing one’s students for fun is wrong.” • second problem: On some semantic theories, if there is no such thing as wrongness, then “Failing one’s students for fun is wrong” is neither true nor false. (For example, according to P. F. Strawson’s theory of definite descriptions, “The present king of France is bald” is neither true nor false. For similar reasons, we might think that “Phlogiston is lighter than air” and “Failing one’s students for fun is wrong” are neither true nor false, if nihilism is correct.) Nihilists can avoid these problems by taking whatever semantic theory is used to determine the truth-value of phlogiston sentences and also use it to determine the truth-value of moral sentences. It is also commonly claimed that according to nihilism, everything is permitted. This is also a mistake. According to nihilism, there is no such thing as permissibility. II. The Standard Interpretation of Mackie Mackie’s main thesis: there are no objective values (values are not “part of the fabric of the world”).
    [Show full text]
  • Anarchism and Existentialism
    CHAPTER 19 Anarchism and Existentialism Shane Wahl Introduction One way to approach the relationship between anarchist philosophy and exis- tentialist philosophy would be to trace the historical connections between the two and provide an account of how certain thinkers in both “schools” share philosophical and pragmatic concerns, questions, and maybe even answers. Such an approach has the merits of comprehensiveness and perhaps exhaus- tiveness on its side. This method would give ample breadth to the relationship and its philosophical underpinning, providing a full account of historical and theoretical connections. While this chapter is meant to give a solid overview along these lines, I am also mostly concerned with developing a “philosophy of the future” for anarchist-existentialists (or existentialist-anarchists). A key part of this, in my view, is to grapple with a major problem that confronts both the existentialist and the anarchist at the theoretical and practical level. This is the problem of the supposed (or maybe assumed) distinction—sometimes held to be hard and fast—between the “individual” and the “social.” Focusing on this particular issue will provide some depth to the discussion. Anarchism has varying degrees of “individualism” built-in theoretically, that is, there are different kinds of anarchists seeking different understandings of how anarchism is to operate in terms of individual liberty versus social cohe- sion, often with some strong skepticism for the possibility of the latter in an- archist theory and practice.1 The practical issue regarding the individual and social cannot be overlooked. A “common sense” understanding of anarchism as somewhat synonymous with “chaos” breeds an outlook of dismissal of any claims of it “working” in any kind of truly social setting.
    [Show full text]
  • The Welfare-Nihilist Arguments Against Judgment Subjectivism
    Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy https://doi.org/10.26556/jesp.v19i3.886 Vol. 19, No. 3 · March 2021 © 2021 Author THE WELFARE-NIHILIST ARGUMENTS AGAINST JUDGMENT SUBJECTIVISM Anthony Kelley ne way to construe subjectivism about well-being is as the view that x is basically good for S if and only if, because, and to the extent that x is Ovalued, under the proper conditions, by S.1 Dale Dorsey argues for an idealized, judgment-based theory of valuing, one according to which a person values a thing if and only if, because, and to the extent that she would believe, under the proper conditions, that it is basically good for herself.2 Call subjectiv- ism about well-being coupled with a judgment-based theory of valuing judgment subjectivism.3 Judgment subjectivism is a remarkable theory, and Dorsey’s case for it is compelling. If the theory is true, then what is good for you is wholly determined by what you believe is good for you. It is somewhat surprising that it has not been the subject of much scrutiny.4 In this paper, I offer three related arguments against the theory. The arguments are about what judgment subjectivism im- plies about the well-being of welfare nihilists, people who believe that there are no welfare properties or at least that none are instantiated. I maintain that wel- 1 This construal is Dale Dorsey’s; see Dorsey, “Subjectivism without Desire,” 407. One con- troversial feature of Dorsey’s statement of subjectivism is that it requires that a theory link a person’s good to her values in order for it to count as subjectivist.
    [Show full text]
  • Reason and Intuitive Knowledge in Spinoza's Ethics
    Reason and Intuitive Knowledge in Spinoza’s Ethics : Two Ways of Knowing, Two Ways of Living by Sanem Soyarslan Department of Philosophy Duke University Date: _____________________ Approved: ___________________________ Tad Schmaltz, Co-Supervisor __________________________ David Wong, Co-Supervisor __________________________ Michael Ferejohn __________________________ Andrew Janiak __________________________ Alan Nelson Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Duke University 2011 ABSTRACT Reason and Intuitive Knowledge in Spinoza’s Ethics : Two Ways of Knowing, Two Ways of Living by Sanem Soyarslan Department of Philosophy Duke University Date: _____________________ Approved: ___________________________ Tad Schmaltz, Co-Supervisor __________________________ David Wong, Co-Supervisor __________________________ Michael Ferejohn __________________________ Andrew Janiak __________________________ Alan Nelson An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of Philosophy in the Graduate School of Duke University 2011 ii Copyright by Sanem Soyarslan 2011 iii ABSTRACT While both intuitive knowledge ( scientia intuitiva ) and reason ( ratio) are adequate ways of knowing for Spinoza, they are not equal. “The greatest virtue of the mind” and “the greatest human perfection” consist in understanding things by intuitive knowledge, which
    [Show full text]