Pleistocene Organic Matter Modified by the Hiawatha Impact, Northwest Greenland Adam A
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
https://doi.org/10.1130/G47432.1 Manuscript received 23 January 2020 Revised manuscript received 2 April 2020 Manuscript accepted 8 April 2020 © 2020 The Authors. Gold Open Access: This paper is published under the terms of the CC-BY license. Published online 29 May 2020 Pleistocene organic matter modified by the Hiawatha impact, northwest Greenland Adam A. Garde1, Anne Sofie Søndergaard2, Carsten Guvad1, Jette Dahl-Møller3, Gernot Nehrke4, Hamed Sanei2, Christian Weikusat4, Svend Funder3, Kurt H. Kjær3 and Nicolaj Krog Larsen3 1 Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, Øster Voldgade 10, 1350 Copenhagen K, Denmark 2 Lithospheric Organic Carbon (LOC) Group, Department of Geoscience, Aarhus University, Høegh Guldbergs Gade 2, 8000 Aarhus, Denmark 3 Globe Institute, University of Copenhagen, Øster Voldgade 5–7, 1350 Copenhagen K, Denmark 4 Alfred Wegener Institute, Am Handelshafen, 27570 Bremerhaven, Germany ABSTRACT an iron meteorite (Kjær et al., 2018). The bulk The 31-km-wide Hiawatha impact crater was recently discovered under the ice sheet mineral assemblage and chemical composi- in northwest Greenland, but its age remains uncertain. Here we investigate solid organic tion of the sand indicate sourcing from gran- matter found at the tip of the Hiawatha Glacier to determine its thermal degradation, ulite-grade rocks similar to Paleoproterozoic provenance, and age, and hence a maximum age of the impact. Impactite grains of micro- paragneiss exposed in the ice-free foreland brecchia and shock-melted glass in glaciofluvial sand contain abundant dispersed carbon, to the crater (locally including sulfidic parag- and gravel-sized charcoal particles are common on the outwash plain in front of the crater. neiss with graphite flakes; Dawes, 2004). The The organic matter is depleted in the thermally sensitive, labile bio-macromolecule proto- crater has not been directly dated but is tenta- hydrocarbons. Pebble-sized lumps of lignite collected close to the sand sample consist largely tively referred to the Pleistocene and possibly of fragments of conifers such as Pinus or Picea, with greatly expanded cork cells and desic- as young as the last glacial period, based on cation cracks which suggest rapid, heat-induced expansion and contraction. Pinus and Picea indirect evidence such as preservation of the are today extinct from North Greenland but are known from late Pliocene deposits in the subglacial crater topography, a strongly dis- Canadian Arctic Archipelago and early Pleistocene deposits at Kap København in eastern turbed pre-Holocene ice stratigraphy over the North Greenland. The thermally degraded organic material yields a maximum age for the crater identified by airborne radar imaging, impact, providing the first firm evidence that the Hiawatha crater is the youngest known and an anomalously high modern-day volume large impact structure on Earth. of melt water draining from the impacted area (Kjær et al., 2018). INTRODUCTION raneous vegetation (Howard et al., 2013), and In this study, we investigate organic matter Most terrestrial impact structures contain the small, twin ca. 3.2 ka Kaali craters, Estonia, and its thermal degradation in the impactite only little organic carbon, recycled from target contain locally derived charcoal (Losiak et al., grains, charcoal, lignite, and bulk sediment in rocks. The ca. 35 Ma Popigai crater, Siberia, 2016, 2019). proglacial outwash from the Hiawatha crater contains diamonds transformed from target- With a diameter of 31 km, the newly dis- floor. We identify the wood fragments to gen- rock graphite (Masaitis et al., 1975). Ejecta covered Hiawatha crater under the Greenland era level and discuss the implications of our from the ca. 23 Ma Haughton crater, Canada Ice Sheet in northwest Greenland is one of the findings for the maximum age of the Hiawatha (Parnell et al., 2007), and the ca. 15 Ma Ries 25 largest impact structures on Earth (Fig. 1; impact. crater, Germany (Osinski 2003), contain organic Kjær et al., 2018; Impact Earth, 2020, https:// carbon derived from sedimentary target rocks, impact.uwo.ca/). A large variety of sand-sized METHODS and drill core from the 66 Ma Chicxulub crater, impactite grains originating from the crater Sediment samples described by Kjær et al. Mexico, contains particles of charcoal (Gulick floor were found in a glaciofluvial outwash (2018), and charcoal and lignite collected by us et al., 2019). If the source of the carbon can be sediment sample (HW21-2016 of Kjær et al.; from in front of the Hiawatha Glacier were inves- identified, it may serve to constrain the maxi- see their table S1 with sample information) tigated by standard optical and backscattered elec- mum age of cratering. For instance, dispersed deposited at the front of the Hiawatha Gla- tron scanning electron microscopy (SEM-BSE; graphitic carbon in the ca. 500 Ma Gardnos cier just outside the crater rim (Fig. 1). The Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, crater in Norway stems from Cambrian Alum sand contains shocked quartz, microbreccias, Copenhagen, Denmark), pyrolysis, and Raman Shale (Gilmour et al., 2003; Parnell and Lind- shock-melted mineral glasses, and micromag- spectra. The Raman spectra were obtained with gren 2006). Carbon inclusions in impact glasses matic aggregates; elevated Pt contents and a WITec alpha300 R system and a 488 nm laser linked to the purported ca. 0.8 Ma Darwin crater, anomalous platinum-group element ratios in at the Alfred Wegener institute (Bremerhaven, Tasmania, preserve biomarkers from contempo- this sediment suggest that the impactor was Germany); see the Supplemental Material1 for CITATION: Garde, A.A., et al., 2020, Pleistocene organic matter modified by the Hiawatha impact, northwest Greenland: Geology, v. 48, p. 867–871, https://doi.org/10.1130/G47432.1 Geological Society of America | GEOLOGY | Volume 48 | Number 9 | www.gsapubs.org 867 Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geology/article-pdf/48/9/867/5135263/867.pdf by guest on 26 September 2021 A Charcoal and Lignite Sand- and gravel-sized pieces of charcoal from sample HW21-2016 have a largely amor- phous structure (“glassy coal”) but also preserve relict cell structures (Fig. 3A). Their reflectance in incident white light is high (Ro ≤ 3.5%), within the range of modern charcoal (Braad- baart and Poole, 2008; McParland et al., 2009). Pebble-sized lumps of lignite collected at Figure 1. (A) Location of the Hiawatha crater the eastern Hiawatha Glacier front (Fig. 3B) and Kap København in have cellular structures and a low random Greenland. (B) Elevation reflectance (Ro ∼0.2%–0.5%). The ash con- map showing circular tent is only ∼0.5 wt%. One of these lumps depression of the crater, yielded a non-finite 14C age of >43,500 yr B.P. covered by the Greenland Ice Sheet (semitranspar- (our sample Beta-471661). Most of the lignite ent), and positions of consists of woody material with rows of well- glaciofluvial sand sample preserved, even-sized cells with central voids, HW21-2016 (78.83305°N, spiraled fibrous cell walls, and bordered pit pairs 67.13653 W) and two ° (Fig. 3C); layers of cork cells have filled inte- B older reference samples from the outwash plain riors. Alternating growth zones of spring and (HW12-2016, 78.84183°N, summer wood are up to a dozen cells thick. 67.29250°W; and HW13- These cell structures are diagnostic of conifer 2016, 78.88696°N , wood, most likely Pinus or Picea, whereas few 65.99227°W) from Kjær et al. (2018). Modified from fragments contain wood cells of uneven size Kjær et al. (2018). and distinct perforation plates, which is the characteristic of the angiosperm genus Betula (Hoadley, 1990). Some conifer cork layers have greatly inflated cells with numerous spherical voids (Fig. 3D), which we interpret as results of expansion by heating with sudden release of volatile components from the lipid-rich cork cells. Common branching and tapering systems of shrinkage cracks are likewise interpreted as evidence of rapid loss of volatile components by heating (Fig. 3E). Other lumps display flattened details. Organic carbon geochemistry in bulk front of the Hiawatha Glacier. The macroscale cells with homogeneous (gelatinous) interiors sediment sample HW21-2016 and two refer- organic matter comprises angular, sand- to and low reflectance (Ro = 0.1%–0.2%; Fig. 3C), ence samples was obtained by Hawk pyrolysis gravel-sized particles of charcoal in sample interpreted as remnants of decaying and mildly at Aarhus University (Aarhus, Denmark) follow- HW21-2016, as well as pebble-sized lumps compacted wood. Conglomerate-like masses ing Carrie et al. (2012), measuring the quantity of of lignite rounded by water transport on the of variably decomposed and disrupted wood total organic carbon (TOC, in weight percent) and eastern side of the glacier front; small twigs particles mixed with small vitrinous particles proto-hydrocarbons (S2, in milligrams thermally from dwarf bushes unrelated to the impact (Fig. 3F) are interpreted as results of normal sensitive, labile bio-macromolecule hydrocarbons occur locally on the glacial outwash plain. degradation of lignite and/or impact-related per gram sediment) released between 300 and The microscale, finely dispersed organic car- mixing and redeposition. Only very sporadic 650 °C from the preserved humic matter. Three bon was identified in the impactite grains of remnants of plant spores and/or algae have been grain-size fractions of each sample were mea- sample HW21-2016. found, and no leaf cuticula. sured to check potential variability with grain size. The lignite was dated by the Beta Analytic Organic Matter in the Impactite Grains Carbon Ordering and Organic Carbon Dating Service (https://www.radiocar- Microbreccia grains contain splinters of sili- Geochemistry bon.com/) with calendar-year calibration using cate minerals including shocked quartz as well The organic matter was characterized using OxCal v. 4.3 with the IntCal13 calibration curve as partially melted mineral fragments, set in an laser Raman spectrography (Figs.