East Devon District Council List of Planning Appeals Lodged
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
East Devon District Council List of Planning Appeals Lodged Ref: 19/1267/FUL Date Received 17.12.2019 Appellant: Mr C Olisa Appeal Site: Flat 1 6 Alston Terrace Exmouth EX8 1BH Proposal: Subdivision of flat 1 into two flats (retrospective application) Planning Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/1360/FUL Date Received 17.12.2019 Appellant: Dr Paul Barber Appeal Site: Gardeners Barn Honiton Bottom Higher Brand Lane Honiton Proposal: Change of use and alteration of agricultural building to form dwelling Planning APP/U1105/W/19/3243366 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/2011/PDQ Date Received 17.12.2019 Appellant: Mrs S Herrod Appeal Site: Building At Pinneywood Farm Lodge Lane Axminster EX13 5RT Proposal: Prior approval for proposed change of use of agricultural building to a dwelling (use class C3) and associated operational development Planning APP/U1105/W/19/3243386 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/0821/FUL Date Received 18.12.2019 Appellant: Mark Thomas Appeal Site: 1 Hardys Court Hawkerland Road Colaton Raleigh Sidmouth EX10 0HL Proposal: Demolition of the old stables and construction of a new bungalow including new vehicular access from Hardys Court. Planning Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/1962/LBC Date Received 18.12.2019 Appellant: Mrs Carol Gay Appeal Site: Fiddles Reach Preston Farm Upottery Honiton EX14 9PF Proposal: Infill of covered patio area to provide ground floor bedroom including insertion of doorway; construction of porch and 2no. dormers; construction of external wall Planning APP/U1105/Y/19/3243521 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/1826/FUL Date Received 24.12.2019 Appellant: Mr & Mrs Boote Appeal Site: Oaklands Farm Monkton Honiton EX14 9QH Proposal: Change of use and conversion of existing farm shop/cafe and redundant agricultural buildings to create 5 no. dwellings together with extensive landscaping, vehicle parking and access. Planning APP/U1105/W/19/3243903 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/1787/CPE Date Received 07.01.2020 Appellant: Mr Derek Branker Appeal Site: Site Of Spillers Cottage Shute Proposal: The excavation, laying out and back filling of an inspection chamber and associated pipework ready to connect to a new septic tank for the foul sewage system of the new house granted permission reference 7/87/91/P0654/00119 on 24 June 1991 and validly implementing that the permission so that it remains extant Planning APP/U1105/X/20/3244399 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/0488/FUL Date Received 09.01.2020 Appellant: Mr Stuart Phillips Appeal Site: 8 Mill Street Ottery St Mary EX11 1AD Proposal: Conversion of 1st floor and part of ground floor to 4no. apartments; retention of part of ground floor as storage Planning APP/U1105/W/20/3244536 Inspectorate Ref: East Devon District Council List of Planning Appeals Decided Ref: 18/2608/OUT Appeal 19/00039/NONDET Ref: Appellant: Mr Rix Appeal Site: Land South Of King Alfred Way Newton Poppleford EX10 0DG Proposal: Construction of up to two dwellings (with all matters other than access reserved) Decision: Appeal Allowed (with Date: 20.12.2019 conditions) Procedure: Written representations Remarks: Appeal against the failure of the Council to determine the application within the statutory time period. Officer recommendation to approve, Committee decision to defer the application for three months to provide an opportunity for the Parish Council, applicant and Coleridge Medical Centre to get together to resolve the situation and to make their positions clear to the local planning authority. Following the lodging of the appeal, the Committee resolved that had the Council been able to determine the application, it would have been approved. The Inspector agreed that whilst a doctor’s surgery was approved as part of the original residential development of the site, it was not required to be provided in planning terms as the development itself did not justify the need for additional health space/doctors surgery. As such, its loss to two dwellings could not be resisted in planning terms. Application for a full award of costs against the Council allowed. BVPI 204: No Planning APP/U1105/W/19/3231349 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/0898/LBC Appeal 19/00055/LBCREF Ref: Appellant: Mr Steve Thompson Appeal Site: The Captains Cottage Fore Street Beer Seaton EX12 3EE Proposal: Alterations to, and replacement of windows. Decision: Appeal Dismissed Date: 20.12.2019 Procedure: Written representations Remarks: Delegated refusal, conservation reasons upheld (EDLP Policy EN9). BVPI 204: No Planning APP/U1105/Y/19/3235532 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/0281/FUL Appeal 19/00064/REF Ref: Appellant: Mr A Vinall Appeal Site: 16 Parkey Cottages Clyst St George Exeter EX3 0NZ Proposal: Change of use from agricultural land to domestic garden and parking with new vehicular access Decision: Appeal Allowed (with Date: 30.12.2019 conditions) Procedure: Written representations Remarks: Delegated refusal, countryside protection and amenity reasons overruled (EDLP Strategies 7 & 46 and Policies D1 & D2 and Clyst St George NP Policies CSG5 & 7). The Inspector considered that the change of use would result in having a minimal impact on the character and appearance of the area and would therefore comply with Local Plan Strategies 7 & 46 and Policies D1 & D2. He concluded that the proposal would also comply with Policy CSG5 of the Clyst St. George Parish Neighbourhood Plan, which seeks to protect the essential character of the area. There would be a degree of conflict with NP Policy CSG7 insofar as relates to the partial loss of hedgerow. However, the construction of a new hedgerow on the boundary of the garden with the field would result in a net gain in hedgerow overall, and thus, would comply with the broader objective of the Policy. BVPI 204: Yes Planning APP/U1105/W/19/3237679 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 18/2890/TRE Appeal 19/00017/TRE Ref: Appellant: Mr P Trumper Appeal Site: Westgate Kilmington Axminster EX13 7RJ Proposal: T1 Indian Bean tree - Fell. Decision: Appeal Dismissed Date: 02.01.2020 Procedure: Written representations Remarks: Delegated refusal, amenity reasons upheld. BVPI 204: No Planning APP/TPO/U1105/7240 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/0298/MFUL Appeal 19/00059/REF Ref: Appellant: DJ & JG Hooper Appeal Site: Higher Wick Wick Honiton EX14 4TY Proposal: Construction of manure slurry store lagoon and associated earthworks and landscaping for existing dairy unit complex. Decision: Appeal Dismissed Date: 14.01.2020 Procedure: Written representations Remarks: Delegated refusal, Landscape reasons upheld (EDLP Strategies 7 & 46 and Policies D1 & D7). BVPI 204: Yes Planning APP/U1105/W/19/3236683 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 16/F0227 Appeal Ref: 19/00029/ENFAPP Appellants: Mr J & Mr P McCarthy Appeal Site: Rath Na Ri Clyst Honiton Exeter EX5 2HR Proposal: Appeal against the serving of an enforcement notice in respect of the carrying out of a material change of use of the land from a mixed agricultural use and car repair business to a mixed use of the land for agricultural use, car repair business and residential use by the siting on the land of a mobile home for residential purposes. Decision: Appeal Dismissed Date: 20.01.2020 Enforcement notice varied and upheld Procedure: Written representations Remarks: Countryside protection and sustainability reasons upheld (EDLP Strategy 7 and Policies H4 & TC2). BVPI 204: No Planning APP/U1105/C/19/3227987 Inspectorate Ref: Ref: 19/0439/FUL Appeal Ref: 19/00061/REF Appellant: Mrs Hatice Oflaz Appeal Site: 20 New Street Honiton EX14 1EY Proposal: Change of use from A2 (professional Services) to (A3)restaurant use, including new rear access to serve residential unit and fenestration changes Decision: Appeal Invalid Date: 20.01.2020 Procedure: Remarks: All of the necessary documents were not submitted by the appellant within the six month deadline. BVPI 204: No Planning APP/U1105/W/19/3237187 Inspectorate Ref: East Devon District Council List of Appeals In Progress App.No: 18/2151/FUL Appeal Ref: APP/U1105/W/19/3233336 Appellant: Mr Roger Rudkin Address: South Lodge St Johns Road Exmouth EX8 5EG Proposal; Erection of two bedroom bungalow Start Date: 29 July 2019 Procedure: Written reps. Questionnaire Due Date: 5 August 2019 Statement Due Date: 2 September 2019 App.No: 18/2173/VAR Appeal Ref: APP/U1105/W/19/3234261 Appellant: Mr David Manley Address: Enfield Farm Biodigester Oil Mill Lane Clyst St Mary EX5 1AF Proposal; Variation of conditions 2,5,7 and 10 of planning permission 17/0650/VAR to allow increase annual tonnage of crop input from 26,537 to 66,000 tonnes and increase annual tonnage of digestate exported from the site from 21,354 to 56,000 tonnes and vary wording of Odour Management Plan Start Date: 20 August 2019 Procedure: Written reps. Questionnaire Due Date: 27 August 2019 Statement Due Date: 24 September 2019 App.No: 18/2376/MFUL Appeal Ref: APP/U1105/W/19/3233226 Appellant: Colyford Eden Ltd Address: Land North Of Kingsholme And West Of Coly Road Colyford Colyton Proposal; Proposed residential development of 15no. dwellings (10no. affordable) with site access and associated works. Start Date: 28 August 2019 Procedure: Hearing Questionnaire Due Date: 4 September 2019 Statement Due Date: 2 October 2019 Hearing Date: 15 January 2020 Venue: Memorial Hall, Swan Hill, Colyford App.No: 18/F0077 Appeal Ref: APP/U1105/C/19/3225216 Appellant: Luke John Kent Address: Flat 1, 31 Cranford Avenue, Exmouth Proposal; Appeal against the serving of an enforcement notice in respect of the unauthorised construction of a building. Start Date: 30 August 2019 Procedure: Written reps. Questionnaire Due Date: 13 September 2019 Statement