Trekkies Beware! Paramount Pictures V. Axanar Productions by Joel M

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Trekkies Beware! Paramount Pictures V. Axanar Productions by Joel M Thursday, March 23, 2017 LAW BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY LAW TECHNOLOGY LAW BUSINESS RECORDERdaily at www.therecorder.com Trekkies Beware! Paramount Pictures v. Axanar Productions By Joel M. Grossman ovie and far and actually produce a very TV stu- professional movie funded by dios often crowdsourcing? That is the allow their question raised by the case of fans to Paramount Pictures Corp. v. Mengage in behavior which tech- Axanar Productions, Inc. The nically might violate copyright case has not been fully liti- or trademark law. For exam- gated, but the district court’s ple, the studio which owns the ruling on cross-motions for copyright to Star Wars might summary judgment is both let fans produce a short video amusing and instructive. in which fans dress up as Darth To begin with the basic facts, Vader or Princess Leia, and act plaintiff Paramount Pictures Trek films before with no law- out a scene from the film. If and CBS own the copyright to suit from Paramount, Axanar the fans post their homemade the Star Trek television shows sought to go “where no man 10 minute video on You Tube, and Paramount owns the copy- has gone before” and produce the studio probably wouldn’t right to the thirteen full-length a professional Star Trek film, mind. They might even encour- movies that followed. While with a fully professional crew, age such amateur tributes, as the copyright owners allowed many of whom worked on one they might keep interest in the fans to make their own ama- or more Star Trek productions. product alive until the next teur films, they sued when, in Axanar raised over a million sequel or prequel hits the mul- their view, Axanar Productions dollars through crowdsourcing tiplex. crossed the line. As the court websites to finance the pro- But what happens if, in a explained, while other Trek- duction. Axanar produced and studio’s view, the fans go too kies have made their own Star publicly released what it called RECORDER “Star Trek: Prelude to Axanar,” the court noted many such the conclusion that Paramount in order to raise money to similarities, it denied Para- will most likely prevail and the make the full-length film. At mount’s motion for summary distribution of Axanar’s film this point Paramount sued, judgment, holding that a jury will be enjoined. As the court and each side moved for sum- must ultimately decide the stated: “Here, there is no dis- mary judgment. Paramount issue. At the same time, the pute that [Paramount and CBS] sought a ruling from the court court denied Axanar’s motion have ownership of copyrights to of copyright infringement, seeking a judicial approval of [Star Trek], and that [Axanar]‘s while Axanar sought summary its fair use defense. The court works are substantially similar judgment on the defense of fair denied the motion, based on to [Star Trek}. Thus, the copy- use. its application of the fair use right infringement claim can In seeking a ruling of copy- factors. While Axanar argued live long and prosper…” right infringement, Para- that its film is actually a par- mount pointed to Axanar’s ody, or “mockumentary,” of Joel M. Grossman, Esq. use of copyright-protected the original Star Trek, the has been exclusively devoted elements, such as Klingons court was not convinced, not- to mediation and arbitration and Vulcans, and the human ing that “Defendants set out since 2004, following his 25-year character Garth of Izar, all of to create films that stay faith- legal career as a litigator, labor whom appeared in the tele- ful to the Star Trek canon and negotiator, and in-house coun- vision series. In addition, appeal to Star Trek fans.” sel overseeing complex enter- Axanar used phasers, the While neither side won its tainment disputes. He may be Federation logo and even summary judgment motion, reached at jgrossman@jam- the Klingon language. While the court’s analysis leads to sadr.com Reprinted with permission from the March 23, 2017 edition of THE RECORDER © 2017 ALM Media Properties, LLC. All rights reserved. Further duplication without permission is prohibited. For information, contact 877-257-3382 or [email protected]. # 501-04-17-02.
Recommended publications
  • New Programming Customer Movie
    EVERYTHING YOU NEED FOR successful events, SIMPLY Programming Toolkit | Fall/Winter 2017 © Universal Studios Press © 2017 Disney/Pixar © Universal Studios © Paramount Pictures © Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. New Movie Programming Customer Releases Event Ideas Ideas Spotlight NEW Releases © Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. © Warner © 2017 Disney/Pixar © Universal Studios Despicable Me 3 Wonder Woman Cars 3 Anticipated October 2017 Anticipated September 2017 Anticipated October 2017 PG; 90 minutes; Universal Studios PG-13; 141 minutes; Warner Bros. G; 109 minutes; Walt Disney Pictures Gru battles Balthazar Bratt, a 1980s child star- An Amazon princess leaves her island home Race car Lightning McQueen suffers a severe turned-supervillain, in this animated sequel. and journeys to the outside world, which is crash while trying to compete with a younger being consumed by a massive war. With the rival named Jackson Storm. Afterward, help of an American pilot, she works to put an McQueen embraces new technologies as he end to the conflict. trains for a return to the racetrack. EVENT Idea! EVENT EVENT Promotion Idea Idea The minions are back at it again! Create Allow guests the opportunity to In this movie, legendary Lightning buzz for your movie showing by passing craft their own Tiara or Bracelets of McQueen has to prove that he still has out yellow balloons in your community that Submission. Give them the chance to what it takes to win. Foster a friendly look just like the little stars of the movie. show off their creations at a pop-up sense of competition that mimics the All you need are markers, yellow balloons, photo booth at the event.
    [Show full text]
  • Star Trek: Exploring New Worlds Is a Fully Immersive Exhibition That Showcases Star Trek’S Significant Impact on Culture, Society, Arts, Sports, Tech and Fashion
    STAR TREK: EXPLORING NEW WORLDS IS A FULLY IMMERSIVE EXHIBITION THAT SHOWCASES STAR TREK’S SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON CULTURE, SOCIETY, ARTS, SPORTS, TECH AND FASHION. VENUE: SECURITY: AVAILABILITY: ORGANIZATION 5,000–7,000K SF Medium October April rental period of 2019 2020 & CONTACT 12–14 weeks SPECIAL Shawana Lee REQUIREMENTS Group Sales Manager FEE: ADDITIONAL 206 262 3420 Min. ceiling height of $250,000 plus 14 feet, climate control, shipping & RESOURCES [email protected] gallery supervision, installer’s travel Marketing & promo standard electrical sup- Museum of POP Culture costs templates provided ply, traveling installer (formerly EMP Museum) expenses: (est. $8K) EXHIBIT HIGHLIGHTS Set pieces Transporter simulator EXHIBITION ELEMENTS from Star Trek: The Original Series, where visitors can create a film that including a self destruct panel and shows them being beamed to anoth- Artifacts the navigation console. er location and performing in a Star -Costumes Trek-inspired scene. 100+ props and artifacts -Props from the five Star Trek television series KHAAAAN! video booth and many of the films including: where visitors can recreate the -Scripts, Production -original series tricorder memorable scene from Star Trek II: Documents/Storyboards -communicator phaser The Wrath of Khan -a Borg cube -Sketches -Klingon disruptor pistol Spaceship filming models -Models -Tribbles, and more of the Enterprise, USS Excelsior, a Klingon battle cruiser, and Rare costumes Deep Space Nine space station Films including: Spock’s tunic worn by -Five interpretive
    [Show full text]
  • Paramount Pictures and Dreamworks Pictures' "GHOST in the SHELL" Is in Production in New Zealand
    April 14, 2016 Paramount Pictures and DreamWorks Pictures' "GHOST IN THE SHELL" is in Production in New Zealand HOLLYWOOD, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- Paramount Pictures and DreamWorks Pictures have announced that production is underway on "GHOST IN THE SHELL," starring Scarlett Johansson ("AVENGERS: AGE OF ULTRON," "LUCY") and directed by Rupert Sanders ("SNOW WHITE AND THE HUNTSMAN"). The film is shooting in Wellington, New Zealand. This Smart News Release features multimedia. View the full release here: http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20160414005815/en/ Paramount Pictures will release the film in the U.S. on March 31, 2017. The film, which is based on the famous Kodansha Comics manga series of the same name, written and illustrated by Masamune Shirow, is produced by Avi Arad ("THE AMAZING SPIDER-MAN 1 & 2," "IRON MAN"), Ari Arad ("GHOST RIDER: SPIRIT OF VENGEANCE"), and Steven Paul ("GHOST RIDER: SPIRIT OF VENGEANCE"). Michael Costigan ("PROMETHEUS"), Tetsu Fujimura ("TEKKEN"), Mitsuhisa Ishikawa, whose animation studio Production I.G produced the Japanese "GHOST IN THE SHELL" film and television series, and Jeffrey Silver ("EDGE OF TOMORROW," "300") will executive produce. Scarlett Johansson plays the Major in Ghost in the Shell from Paramount Pictures Based on the internationally-acclaimed sci-fi and DreamWorks Pictures in Theaters March 31, 2017. (Photo: Business Wire) property, "GHOST IN THE SHELL" follows the Major, a special ops, one-of-a-kind human-cyborg hybrid, who leads the elite task force Section 9. Devoted to stopping the most dangerous criminals and extremists, Section 9 is faced with an enemy whose singular goal is to wipe out Hanka Robotic's advancements in cyber technology.
    [Show full text]
  • Is Klingon an Ohlonean Language? — a Comparison of Mutsun and Klingon
    Is Klingon an Ohlonean Language? | A Comparison of Mutsun and Klingon Dick Grune [email protected] April 19, 1996 1 Introduction Klingon is an artificial language designed by Marc Okrand [1] in 1985 for Paramount Pictures Cor- poration, to serve as the language of the Klingons in the second Star Trek movie and all subsequent Star Trek and spin-off productions. Its best known expression is Qapla'! = Success! Mutsun (pronounced moot-soon, with the short oo of book, and the t and the s well separated) was an American Indian language of the Ohlonean [3] (= Costanoan) family, which, together with Tsimshian in British Columbia, the Mayan languages in Mexico, and many others, is part of the Penutian stock. It was spoken until the beginning of the 20th century around Mission San Juan Bautista, just south of San Francisco, Ca. Its last speaker, Mrs. Ascensi´onSolorsano de Cervantes, died Jan. 29, 1930, at the age of 74. The most accessible work on Mutsun is a grammar produced as a PhD thesis by this same Marc Okrand [2]. So, naturally, the question arises to what degree Klingon was inspired by Mutsun. Already being in the possession of [1] and having recently been able to put my hands on a copy of [2], I set out reading and comparing, in order to find the answer to this question. Those of you who are just after a juicy bit of gossip will be disappointed: No, Klingon is not more similar to Mutsun than it is to any other American Indian language, neither in vocabulary nor in structure.
    [Show full text]
  • The Original Series, Star Trek: the Next Generation, and Star Trek: Discovery
    Gender and Racial Identity in Star Trek: The Original Series, Star Trek: The Next Generation, and Star Trek: Discovery Hannah van Geffen S1530801 MA thesis - Literary Studies: English Literature and Culture Dr. E.J. van Leeuwen Dr. M.S. Newton 6 July, 2018 van Geffen, ii Table of Contents Introduction............................................................................................................................. 1 1. Notions of Gender and Racial Identity in Post-War American Society............................. 5 1.1. Gender and Racial Identity in the Era of Star Trek: The Original Series........... 6 1.2. Gender and Racial Identity in the Era of Star Trek: The Next Generation......... 10 1.3. Gender and Racial Identity in the Era of Star Trek: Discovery........................... 17 2. Star Trek: The Original Series........................................................................................... 22 2.1. The Inferior and Objectified Position of Women in Star Trek............................ 23 2.1.1. Subordinate Portrayal of Voluptuous Vina........................................... 23 2.1.2. Less Dependent, Still Sexualized Portrayal of Yeoman Janice Rand.. 25 2.1.3. Interracial Star Trek: Captain Kirk and Nyota Uhura.......................... 26 2.2. The Racial Struggle for Equality in Star Trek..................................................... 28 2.2.1. Collaborating With Mr. Spock: Accepting the Other........................... 28 3. Star Trek: The Next Generation........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Epix Launches on Atlantic Broadband in Johnstown and Surrounding Areas
    EPIX LAUNCHES ON ATLANTIC BROADBAND IN JOHNSTOWN AND SURROUNDING AREAS New Service Includes Eight Premium Movie and Original Programming Channels JOHNSTOWN, Pa., – December 21, 2015 –Atlantic Broadband, the nation's 12th largest cable operator, today announced it is now offering EPIX, the premium entertainment network, in Johnstown and the surrounding service areas including Conemaugh, Davidsville, Geistown, Hollsopple, Richland, Westmont and Windber. The launch delivers thousands of movies and original programs including original documentaries, concerts and comedy specials to Atlantic Broadband customers across eight new channels: EPIX East, EPIX West, EPIX2, EPIX Drive In, EPIX East HD, EPIX West HD, EPIX 2 HD and EPIX Hits HD. “As the evolution of entertainment continues, and consumers demand more commercial-free programming, we are thrilled to partner with EPIX to deliver its premium content,” said Atlantic Broadband’s CEO and Chief Revenue Officer, David Isenberg. “This is yet another way of showcasing Atlantic Broadband’s innovation through key industry partnerships, and the commitment to the communities we serve.” “EPIX is thrilled to be partnering with Atlantic Broadband, as it continues to be a leading provider of entertainment products and services,” said Mark Greenberg, President and CEO, EPIX. “This launch expands our footprint into new markets and provides an exciting opportunity for EPIX to bring Hollywood’s biggest films and blockbuster content to Atlantic Broadband’s large base of subscribers.” A leader in multi-platform availability of the largest lineup of big movies, EPIX will provide Atlantic Broadband customers with access to thousands of titles including top blockbuster hits such as The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1, Interstellar, Sponge Bob and Selma.
    [Show full text]
  • Download the Borg Assimilation
    RESISTANCE IS FUTILE… BORG CUBES Monolithic, geometric monstrosities capable of YOU WILL BE ASSIMILATED. defeating fleets of ships, they are a force to be Adding the Borg to your games of Star Trek: Ascendancy feared. introduces a new threat to the Galaxy. Where other civilizations may be open to negotiation, the Borg are single-mindedly BORG SPIRES dedicated to assimilating every civilization they encounter into Borg Spires mark Systems under Borg control. the Collective. The Borg are not colonists or explorers. They are Over the course of the game, Borg Spires will build solely focused on absorbing other civilizations’ technologies. new Borg Cubes. The Borg are not controlled by a player, but are a threat to all the forces in the Galaxy. Adding the Borg also allows you to play BORG ASSIMILATION NODES games with one or two players. The rules for playing with fewer Borg Assimilation Nodes are built around Spires. Built than three players are on page 11. Nodes indicate how close the Spire is to completing a new Borg Cube and track that Borg System’s current BORG COMPONENTS Shield Modifier. • Borg Command Console Card & Cube Card BORG TECH CARDS • 5 Borg Cubes & 5 Borg Spires Players claim Borg Tech Cards when they defeat • 15 Borg Assimilation Nodes & 6 Resource Nodes the Borg in combat. The more Borg technology you • 20 Borg Exploration Cards acquire, the better you will fare against the Borg. • 7 Borg System Discs • 20 Borg Technology Cards BORG COMMAND CARDS • 30 Borg Command Cards Borg Command Cards direct the Cubes’ movement • 9 Borg Dice during the Borg’s turn and designate the type of System each Cube targets.
    [Show full text]
  • EPIX Big on Any Screen
    Adobe Flash Platform Success Story EPIX Big on any screen EPIX drives innovation with the Adobe® Flash® Platform—giving subscribers unprecedented access to premium HD content while connecting with friends, family, and fans on devices everywhere EPIX Audiences across the United States are going to movies, concerts, and all kinds of New York, New York entertainment when and where they want to—online, on tablets, and on mobile www.epixhd.com devices. EPIX—a joint venture of Paramount Pictures, Lionsgate, and MGM Studios— is using the Adobe Flash Platform to redefine the way movie buffs consume video across devices. The partnership brings current releases, classics, and original entertainment to all video platforms: linear TV, on demand, online, and mobile. However, EPIX subscribers are not just tuning in; they are sharing premium HD video experiences with friends, family, and fans. At the crest of the ‘TV everywhere’ wave, EPIX is leveraging the Adobe Flash Platform to design, build, and execute broadband authentication systems, available to over 30 million U.S. homes through its distribution partners—including Charter Communications, Cox Communications, DISH Network, Mediacom Communications, NCTC, Suddenlink Communications, and Verizon FiOS. Additionally, Netflix members can instantly watch EPIX offerings streamed over the Internet. “The Adobe Flash Platform drives our differentiation, giving us the easiest, most flexible, cost-effective way to gain unprecedented access to the widest possible audience on emerging platforms.” Nora Ryan Chief of staff, EPIX Challenge Adobe technology provides EPIX with the tools to distinguish itself on the multiscreen video landscape. • Provide premium HD video “The Adobe Flash Platform drives our differentiation, giving us the easiest, most flexible, cost-effective entertainment to widest possible way to gain unprecedented access to the widest possible audience on emerging platforms,” says Nora audience Ryan, chief of staff at EPIX.
    [Show full text]
  • Parties in Star Trek Fan Litigation Don't Boldly Go Into the Unknown
    INCONTESTABLE® BLOG Parties in Star Trek Fan Litigation Don’t Boldly Go Into the Unknown; Sele Claims February 27, 2017 By Jonathan Uffelman Edited by Naresh Kilaru; Julia Anne Matheson The Central District of California recently denied both parties’ motions for summary judgment in a copyright infringement case involving a fan Star Trek film, setting the dispute up for a jury trial. However, the Court’s findings that defendant Axanar Productions, Inc.’s film was objectively similar to Plaintiffs’ copyrighted Star Trek works, and that Defendants had no valid fair use defense, was sufficient to lead the parties to settlement. Since 1966, Plaintiffs have produced six Star Trek television series totaling more than 700 episodes, and thirteen Star Trek motion pictures. Additionally, Plaintiffs have licensed numerous derivative works, including books, games, merchandise, and audio-visual works. These works incorporate stories taking place in time periods both before and after the original television series. Collectively, these works constitute the Star Trek canon, used by many Trekkers to create fan fiction. As avid Star Trek fans, Defendants intended to make a fan film about a character called Garth of Izar, who appeared in one episode of the original television series. In that episode, Garth is a former starship captain, famous among Starfleet officers for his exploits in the Battle of Axanar with the Klingons twenty-one years earlier. The Defendants’ film was to depict Garth’s exploits. Defendants sought to make “a professional production” with a professional crew, “many of whom have worked on Star Trek itself.” Defendants raised money and produced a twenty-one minute film called “Star Trek: Prelude to Axanar” (“Prelude”) and released it on YouTube to raise funds for a full-length feature film.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Releases
    Press Releases O’Melveny Guides ViacomCBS Through MIRAMAX Investment April 3, 2020 RELATED PROFESSIONALS FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Bruce Tobey CENTURY CITY—April 3, 2020—O’Melveny represented leading media and entertainment company Century City ViacomCBS (Nasdaq: VIACA; VIAC) in its acquisition of a 49­percent stake in film and television studio D: +1­310­246­6764 MIRAMAX from beIN Media Group. The transaction, previously announced in December 2019, closed today. Amy Siegel ViacomCBS acquired 49 percent of MIRAMAX from beIN for a total committed investment of US$375 million. Century City Approximately US$150 million was paid at closing, while ViacomCBS has committed to invest US$225 million D: +1­310­246­6805 —comprised of US$45 million annually over the next five years—to be used for new film and television Silvia Vannini productions and working capital. Century City D: +1­310­246­6895 In addition, ViacomCBS’s historic film and television studio, Paramount Pictures, entered an exclusive, long­ term distribution agreement for MIRAMAX’s film library and an exclusive, long­term, first­look agreement Eric Zabinski allowing Paramount Pictures to develop, produce, finance, and distribute new film and television projects Century City based on MIRAMAX’s IP. D: +1­310­246­8449 Rob Catmull ViacomCBS creates premium content and experiences for audiences worldwide, driven by a portfolio of Century City iconic consumer brands including CBS, Showtime Networks, Paramount Pictures, Nickelodeon, MTV, D: +1­310­246­8563 Comedy Central, BET, CBS All Access, Pluto TV, and Simon & Schuster. Eric H. Geffner beIN MEDIA GROUP is a leading independent global media group and one of the foremost sports and Century City entertainment networks in the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Warrior Culture and Science Fiction TV
    Copyright rests with Florilegium. The contents of the journal may not be copied, reprinted, or posted electronically without the editor's express written permission, although users are welcome to download and print articles for individual use. High-Tech Feudalism: Warrior Culture and Science Fiction TV Graham Knight and Jennifer Smith "Richard ΠΙ with aliens" is how Cornell (102) describes "Sins of the Father," an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation (hereafter TNG) in which the Klingon warrior Worf, son of Mogh, seeks to restore his family's honour by exposing and challenging those responsible for falsely accusing his dead father of treason to the Klingon Empire. Worf is only partly successful in his quest, and he remains a perpetually marginal figure whose identity is divided by his Klingon heritage, his childhood as a Klingon orphan raised by humans., and his current status as the only Klingon in Starflect, the military arm of the Federation of Planets, an alliance of Earth and other worlds whose relationship with the Klingon Empire is marked by tension, suspicion and, at times, open hostility. As a result of these divisions and struggles, Worf s family is e'ventually stripped of its wealth and rank on the Klingon home-world, and Worfs brother Kurn seeks a ritual death as the only way to absolve his own and his family's disgrace. Historical and cross-cultural motifs are common in TNG, and resonate throughout the secondary texts that have sprung up around the television series— comics, reference books, novelisations of the TV episodes, fan conventions, and numerous Internet sites where devotees debate the minutiae of an imaginary future.
    [Show full text]
  • Klingon Empire
    Original texts and manuscript concept copyright © 2007 by Richard E. Mandel STAR TREK, its on-screen derivatives, and all associated materials are the property of Paramount Pictures Corporation. Multiple references in this document are given under the terms of fair use with regard to international copyright and trademark law. This is a scholarly reference work intended to explain the background and historical aspects of STAR TREK and its spacecraft technology and is not sponsored, approved, or authorized by Paramount Pictures and its affiliated licensees. All visual materials included herein is protected by either implied or statutory copyright and are reproduced either with the permission of the copyright holder or under the terms of fair use as defined under current international copyright law. All visual materials used in this work without clearance were obtained from public sources through public means and were believed to be in the public domain or available for inclusion via the fair use doctrine at the time of printing. Cover illustration by Harry Doddema This work is dedicated to Geoffery Mandel, who started it for all of us. Memory Alpha and SFHQ/Mastercom cataloging data: UFP/SFD DTA HR:217622-A SUPPLEMENT A: THE KLINGON EMPIRE TABLE OF CONTENTS THE KLINGON EMPIRE: A BRIEF HISTORY KLINGON HULL NOMENCLATURE TIMELINE (2150s TO PRESENT) STARSHIPS B-1 JUL’KAR CLASS BATTLESHIP B-10 KAR’HARMER CLASS BATTLESHIP C-8/C-9 K’HERR CLASS DREADNOUGHT D-4 DAMA CLASS BATTLECRUISER K-5 DUPAT CLASS CRUISER D-5 HAK’HYL CLASS “WAR” CRUISER The ambush of the U.S.S.
    [Show full text]