Breeding System of the Iberian Endemic Shrub Colutea Hispanica (Leguminosae)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Anales del Jardín Botánico de Madrid Vol. 66(2): 279-284 julio-diciembre 2009 ISSN: 0211-1322 doi: 10.3989/ajbm.2223 Breeding system of the Iberian endemic shrub Colutea hispanica (Leguminosae) by Sonia G. Rabasa, David Gutiérrez & Adrián Escudero Área de Biodiversidad y Conservación, Escuela Superior de Ciencias Experimentales y Tecnología, Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, Tulipán s/n, Móstoles, Madrid E-28933, Spain. [email protected] Abstract Resumen Rabasa, S.G., Gutiérrez, D. & Escudero, A. 2009. Breeding sys- Rabasa, S.G., Gutiérrez, D. & Escudero, A. 2009. Sistema de cru- tem of the Iberian endemic shrub Colutea hispanica (Legumi- zamiento del arbusto Colutea hispanica. Anales Jard. Bot. Ma- nosae). Anales Jard. Bot. Madrid 66(2): 279-284. drid 66(2): 279-284 (en inglés). Plant breeding systems have been viewed as mechanisms to pro- Los sistemas reproductivos en las plantas se han considerado mote outcrossing in order to increase genetic variability and pre- como mecanismos que promueven los cruzamientos con la fina- vent inbreeding depression. However, reduced fitness after lidad de aumentar la variabilidad genética y evitar la endogamia. crossing, outbreeding depression, has been often observed be- Sin embargo se ha observado con frecuencia un reducido éxito tween individuals from different populations and more rarely, reproductor tras cruzamientos entre individuos de diferentes po- within populations. We studied the breeding system of Colutea blaciones, lo que se ha denominado “depresión exogámica” e hispanica using experimental hand pollinations in field condi- incluso más raramente entre individuos de la misma población. tions in one population in Central Spain in 2004 and 2006. Po- Se estudió el sistema de cruzamiento de Colutea hispanica me- llination experiments showed that C. hispanica set fruits from diante la aplicación de polinizaciones manuales en el campo en both self and cross-pollinations, suggesting that the species is una población situada en Madrid (España) durante los años highly self-compatible. In addition, fruit set was highest follo- 2004 y 2006. Se obtuvieron frutos tanto por autopolinización wing geitonogamy in both years and no flowers set fruits from como por polinización cruzada, sugiriendo que la especie posee xenogamy in 2004. Although such enhanced reproductive suc- un sistema altamente compatible. La alta autocompatibilidad cess following selfing rather than crossing has been largely ig- observada podría deberse a una adaptación a condiciones de es- nored in many studies on plant reproduction, it seems to be not casez de polinizadores y de “parejas reproductoras”. El máximo as rare in plants as previously thought. valor de fruit set se alcanzó en los cruzamientos geitonogámicos en ambos años, y en el año 2004 los cruzamientos xenógamos no produjeron ningún fruto. Este último fenómeno parece ser más común entre plantas de lo que en principio se podría pen- sar, pero ha sido ignorado en la mayor parte de los estudios de biología reproductora. Keywords: fruit set, hand pollination, inbreeding, outbree- Palabras clave: tasa de fructificación, polinización manual, en- ding, self-compatibility. dogamia, exogamia, autocompatibilidad. Introduction channelled by the so called avoidance strategy. How- ever, breeding systems in plants range from complete Knowledge of the breeding system is critical to un- self-compatibility, usually with self and cross pollina- derstand the reproductive success of plants. Plant breeding systems are viewed as mechanisms to pro- tion being equally successful, to complete self-incom- mote outcrossing, increase genetic variability and patibility, with no fruits or viable seeds produced by prevent inbreeding depression (Darwin, 1876; self-pollination, with partial self-incompatibility Charlesworth & Charlesworth, 1987; Barrett, 2003) (Lloyd, 1992) as an intermediate strategy. It has been so the evolution of plant mating systems has been long proposed that self-fertilization can provide re- 280 S.G. Rabasa & al. productive assurance when cross-fertilization is una - petals of around 2 cm. The big size of flowers might be ble to do so (Darwin, 1876). However, although theo- a mechanism to attract pollinators. They are visited by ry predicts that either complete self-fertilization or butterflies and hymenopterans, including honey bees complete cross-fertilization systems should be selec- (Apis mellifera Linnaeus (1758)), and particularly by ted as stable strategies (Lloyd, 1992), several reviews the carpenter bee Xylocopa violacea Linnaeus (1758), have concluded that plants with mixed systems, with which is probably the only effective pollinator (pers. both selfing and crossing, are common between obs.). Flowers and fruits are consumed by several in- plants (Goodwillie & al., 2005). Such a mechanism sect predators, including larvae of hymenopterans, may be advantageous to ensure reproductive success microlepidopterans and two lycaenid lepidopterans in unpredictable environments. (Iolana iolas Ochsenheimer (1816) and Lampides Inbreeder species could suffer depression resulting boeticus Linnaeus (1767)), which may destroy all in reduced fertility. However, some species have seeds in a fruit (Rabasa & al., 2009, report the pro- purged deleterious alleles by selection, minimizing portion of damaged fruits ranged 72-98% in 2003- the risk of inbreeding depression (Husband & 2005). Schemske, 1996; Goodwillie & al., 2005). Moreover, in selfing taxa, adaptation to local environmental con- Study area ditions or coadaptation of different genes may cause The study was conducted in 2004 and 2006 in one reduced fitness of progeny when outcrossing occurs population of C. hispanica located in a gypsum soil between individuals from different populations, gi- area near Chinchón, approximately 45 km southeast ving so-called outbreeding depression (Quilichini & of Madrid, Central Spain (centred on 40º08’ N, 3º28’ al., 2001). W). C. hispanica is patchily distributed in this area, Breeding systems have important ecological and with small populations ranging from tens to a few evolutionary consequences (Richards, 1997). For ins - hundred individuals, which allows the easy delinea - tance, they have been proposed as an important factor tion of populations in the field. We conducted all of affecting vulnerability of plant species to habitat frag- our experiments in one of the larger populations in mentation, in such a way that self-compatible species the area, with several hundreds of individuals, so as to may be less vulnerable to the effects of fragmentation avoid bias due to small population sizes. (Aguilar & al., 2006). The climate is semi-arid Mediterranean with a We studied the mating system of Colutea hispanica mean annual temperature of 14.2ºC and average an- Talavera & Arista (Leguminosae) an endemic and rare nual rainfall of 438 mm (data from Arganda del Rey shrub, which is very patchily distributed in Central thermopluviometric station, N = 29 years). Mean dai- Spain. A previous evaluation of its female reproduc- ly maximum and minimum temperatures are, respec- tive success suggested that habitat fragmentation may tively, 10.6ºC and 0.2ºC in January, and 33.1ºC and have improved the reproductive output of this plant, 15.5ºC in July. There is a pronounced summer since in some years higher fruit set values were ob- drought from May to September. The average rainfall served in smaller and isolated populations (Rabasa & in spring (from April to June) in 2004 and 2006 was al., 2009). We hypothesized that selfing could con- 210.5 mm and 68.8 mm respectively. tribute to explain this surprising result. To determine the breeding system of C. hispanica, we conducted ex- Pollination experiments perimental pollinations in the field during 2004 and We performed crossing experiments with samples 2006 flowering seasons in one population in Central of 20 plants in 2004 and 8 plants in 2006. We could Spain. not obtain more plants with sufficient available flo- wers in 2006 due to low flowering intensity coupled Material and methods to an extreme summer drought (see Study area above). We selected 5 flowers per treatment in each Species plant, totalling 400 flowers in 2004 and 160 in 2006. Colutea hispanica (Leguminosae) is a perennial Flowers were selected before anthesis and assigned leguminous shrub that occurs on limestone or occa- to one of four treatments: (1) Control: open-pollina- sionally gypsum soils in the Iberian Peninsula (Talave - tion; (2) Autonomous selfing (autogamy): flowers ra & Arista, 1998). Plants are mostly summer semide- non-manipulated; (3) hand pollinated with pollen ciduous shrubs, that reach 2-3 m in height and usua lly from other flowers in the same plant (geitonogamy); flower between April and June. The hermaphrodite, and (4) hand pollinated with pollen from other plants papilionoid-type flowers have standard and keel (xenogamy). Anales del Jardín Botánico de Madrid 66(2): 279-284, julio-diciembre 2009. ISSN: 0211-1322. doi: 10.3989/ajbm. 2223 Mating system of Colutea hispanica 281 To avoid contamination of the stigmas with self- World Wide Web at http://www.sas.com.techsup/ pollen, we previously removed all anthers from the download/stat/). flowers in treatments 3 and 4. Previously, we had car- ried out an emasculating test in all plants to examine Results the effectiveness of this treatment. No fruits were pro- Fruit set was relatively low in all cases in both years, duced in emasculated flowers. All flowers in treat- in spite of following the geitonogamy treatment.