problems, problems, if if obvious, obvious, are are mentioned. mentioned.
sources sources in in the the acoustic acoustic abundance abundance estimate estimate are are enumerated enumerated and and critiqued. critiqued. Outstanding Outstanding
The The results results are are placed placed in in the the context context of_other of_other methods methods of of assessment assessment and and prognoses. prognoses. Error Error
and and estimates estimates of of confidence confidence associated associated with with the the degree degree of of coverage coverage based based on on geostatistics. geostatistics.
survey survey are are expressed expressed through through absolute absolute numbers numbers for for abundance, abundance, composite composite size size distribution, distribution,
averaging, averaging, and and geostatistical geostatistical estimation estimation of of variance, variance, are are described. described. Results Results of of the the acoustic acoustic
integration. integration. Methods Methods of of analysis: analysis: criteria criteria for for echogram echogram interpretation, interpretation, stratification, stratification, global global
distribution, distribution, (7) (7) inter-ship inter-ship calibration calibration of of echo echo integrators, integrators, and and (8) (8) multi-frequency multi-frequency echo echo
associated associated dynamics, dynamics, ( ( 5) 5) herring herring fat fat content, content, ( ( 6) 6) hydrography hydrography with with respect respect to to herring herring
situ, situ, (3) (3) fish fish target target strength strength in in situ, situ, ( ( 4) 4) geographic geographic differences differences in in size size distribution distribution and and
breifly breifly reviewed. reviewed. The The subjects subjects of of these these are are ( ( 1) 1) acoustic acoustic extinction, extinction, (2) (2) fish fish orientation orientation in in
measurements, measurements, and and biological biological sampling. sampling. A A variety variety of of auxiliary auxiliary studies, studies, some some ongoing, ongoing, are are
biology, biology, principal principal elements elements of of the the survey survey are are described, described, namely namely design, design, acoustic acoustic
by by measurements measurements with with RIV RIV "Michael "Michael Sars" Sars" in in December December 1993. 1993. Following Following a a review review of of the the
from from the the December December 1993 1993 and and January January 1994 1994 cruises cruises with with RIV RIV "Johan "Johan Hjort", Hjort", supplemented supplemented
Conditions Conditions for for measuring measuring the the stock stock size size have have been been excellent. excellent. Here, Here, results results are are presented presented
herring herring have have been been wintering wintering in in a a fjord fjord system system in in northern northern Norway Norway in in recent recent years. years.
The The spawning spawning component component and and part part of of the the juvenile juvenile stock stock of of Norwegian Norwegian spring spring spawning spawning
ABSTRACT ABSTRACT
P.O.Box P.O.Box 1870, 1870, N-5024 N-5024 Bergen, Bergen, Norway Norway
Institute Institute of of Marine Marine Research Research
Ingolf Ingolf Kenneth Kenneth R~ttingen, R~ttingen, G. G. Foote, Foote, Ingvar Ingvar Ruse, Ruse, and and Egil Egil Ona Ona
By By
WITH WITH EMPHASIS EMPHASIS ON ON METHODOLOGICAL METHODOLOGICAL ASPECTS ASPECTS
WINTERING WINTERING NORWEGIAN NORWEGIAN SPRING SPRING SPAWNING SPAWNING HERRING, HERRING,
ACOUSTIC ACOUSTIC ABUNDANCE ABUNDANCE ESTIMATION ESTIMATION OF OF
Fishing Fishing Surveys Surveys and and Acoustic Acoustic Measurements Measurements
Exploration Exploration of of the the Sea Sea Joint Joint Session Session on on Estimating Estimating Abundance Abundance from from
International International
Council Council for for the the C.M. C.M. 1994/(B+D+G+H):1 1994/(B+D+G+H):1
~ ~ (• (•
mentionnes. mentionnes. ete ete ont ont majeurs majeurs problemes problemes les les necessaire, necessaire, Si Si
critiquees. critiquees. et et enumerees enumerees soot soot d'abondance d'abondance acoustique acoustique !'estimation !'estimation dans dans d'erreur d'erreur sources sources Les Les
prevision. prevision. de de et et d'evalution d'evalution methodes methodes d'autres d'autres contexte contexte le le dans dans examines examines soot soot resultats resultats Les Les
geostatistique. geostatistique. la la sur sur base base couverture couverture de de degre degre le le avec avec relation relation en en confiance confiance de de l'intervalle l'intervalle
et et
taille taille en en distribution distribution la la l'abondance, l'abondance, pour pour absolu absolu nombre nombre en en exprimes exprimes soot soot acoustique acoustique
campagne campagne la la de de resultats resultats Les Les geostatistique. geostatistique. variance variance la la de de estimation estimation et et global global moyennage moyennage
stratification, stratification, echogrammes, echogrammes, des des d'interpretation d'interpretation criteres criteres decrites: decrites: soot soot d'analyse d'analyse methodes methodes
differentes differentes Les Les multifrequence. multifrequence. echo-integration echo-integration (8) (8) et et navires navires des des echo-integrateurs echo-integrateurs
des des
intercalibration intercalibration (7) (7) distribution, distribution, la la avec avec relation relation en en hydrologie hydrologie (6) (6) hareng, hareng, du du grasse grasse
matiere matiere de de taux taux (5) (5) tailles, tailles, des des distribution distribution la la dans dans geographiques geographiques differences differences (4) (4) situ, situ,
in
reflexion reflexion de de index index (3) (3) poissons, poissons, des des in-situ in-situ orientation orientation (2) (2) acoustique, acoustique, extinction extinction 1) 1) ( (
suivants: suivants: point point les les concernent concernent Elles Elles brievement. brievement. decrites decrites soot soot variees variees complementaires complementaires
etudes etudes Des Des biologique. biologique. echantillonnage echantillonnage et et acoustiques acoustiques mesures mesures campagne, campagne, de de
plan plan
decrits: decrits: soot soot campagne campagne la la de de elements elements principaux principaux les les biologie, biologie, la la de de revue revue un un Apres Apres
93. 93.
decembre decembre en en Sars Sars Michael Michael R.V. R.V. le le par par effectuees effectuees mesures mesures des des par par completees completees Hjort, Hjort, Johan Johan
R.V. R.V.
le le par par 94 94 janvier janvier et et 93 93 decembre decembre en en effectuees effectuees campagnes campagnes de de resultats resultats les les presentes presentes
soot soot
note, note, cette cette Dans Dans excellentes. excellentes. etaient etaient stock stock du du l'abondance l'abondance evaluer evaluer pour pour conditions conditions
Les Les
annees. annees. quelques quelques depuis depuis Norvege Norvege la la de de nord nord du du fjord fjord un un dans dans hivernent hivernent printemps, printemps,
au au frayant frayant hareng, hareng, stock stock du du juveniles juveniles des des partie partie qu'une qu'une ainsi ainsi adulte adulte composante composante La La
Resume Resume
methodologiques methodologiques aspects aspects les les sur sur institant institant en en
printempts, printempts, au au frayant frayant norvegien, norvegien, hareng hareng de de hivernal hivernal stock stock du du
l'abondance l'abondance de de acoustique acoustique Evaluation Evaluation
weather). weather). Further, Further, admixture admixture with with other other species species is is almost almost negligible. negligible.
confined confined
to to a a
limited limited
geographical geographical
region region which which is is protected protected from from the the ocean ocean (and (and bad bad
estimation estimation
using using
echo echo
integrator integrator
techniques. techniques. This This is is because because the the stock stock at at that that time time is is
The The
wintering wintering
period period seems seems to to be be the the most most suitable suitable period period for for acoustic acoustic abundance abundance
December-beginning December-beginning
of of January, January, the the herring herring start start their their spawning spawning migration. migration.
Vestfjorden Vestfjorden
in in
northern northern
Norway, Norway,
i.e., i.e., Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden and and Tysfjorden Tysfjorden (Fig. (Fig. 1). 1). At At the the end end of of
Norwegian Norwegian
spring spring
spawning spawning
herring herring have have been been located located in in the the inner inner tributary tributary fjords fjords of of
where where
they they concentrate concentrate
at at high high densities. densities. Since Since 1987/88 1987/88 the the wintering wintering areas areas of of the the
In In
August, August,
after after
the the end end of of
the the feeding feeding season, season, the the herring herring migrate migrate to to the the wintering wintering areas areas
layer layer of of the the water water masses, masses, where where they they feed feed mainly mainly on on copepods. copepods.
areas areas
in in
the the open open ocean ocean
(RfZjttingen (RfZjttingen
1992). 1992). The The herring herring are are mostly mostly distributed distributed in in the the upper upper
the the
Norwegian Norwegian Sea, Sea,
where where
they they feed feed in in summer summer in in scattered scattered concentrations concentrations over over large large
banks banks of of the the
west west
and and
northwest northwest
coast coast of of Norway. Norway. After After spawning, spawning, the the herring herring migrate migrate to to
The The Norwegian Norwegian
spring spring
spawning spawning herring herring stock stock spawns spawns in in February-March February-March on on the the coastal coastal
MIGRATION MIGRATION BIOLOGY BIOLOGY
too. too.
abundance abundance
and, and,
through through
improvements improvements
in in methodology, methodology, those those of of other other pelagic pelagic fish fish stocks stocks
reviewed. reviewed.
Progress Progress
on on these these is is important important for for improving improving estimates estimates of of herring herring stock stock
is is
called called
particularly particularly
to to the the final final
part part of of the the discussion, discussion, in in which which outstanding outstanding problems problems are are
principal principal
methods, methods,
auxiliary auxiliary
studies, studies, methods methods of of analysis, analysis, results, results, and and discussion. discussion. Attention Attention
This This
paper paper
is is divided divided
into into the the following following sections: sections: migration migration biology, biology, materials materials and and
elaboration, elaboration,
and and some some have have already already been been prepared prepared and and are are duly duly cited cited below. below.
auxiliary auxiliary
studies studies are are
outlined. outlined.
Each Each of of these these studies studies may may require require a a separate separate paper paper for for
cruises cruises
is is summarized summarized
here. here.
In In particular, particular, estimates estimates of of stock stock abundance abundance are are given, given, and and
survey survey
and and
research research
cruises cruises
in in December December 1993 1993 and and January January 1994. 1994. The The major major work work of of these these
The The Institute Institute
of of Marine Marine
Research Research has has accepted accepted these these conclusions conclusions in in authorizing authorizing acoustic acoustic
integral integral part part of of the the apparently apparently more more routine routine work work of of surveying. surveying.
and and
acoustic acoustic scattering scattering
properties. properties.
That That is, is, development development of of methodology methodology is is viewed viewed as as an an
that that
auxiliary auxiliary
studies studies
are are essential essential for for improving improving knowledge knowledge of of fish fish biology, biology, behaviour, behaviour,
the the
conditions conditions
for for
performing performing
an an acoustic acoustic abundance abundance survey survey of of herring herring are are excellent, excellent, and and
Principal Principal
conclusions conclusions
drawn drawn
from from these these and and other other survey survey cruises cruises to to the the same same area area are are that that
and and
from from a a
briefer briefer
cruise cruise
to to the the same same area area in in December December 1991 1991 (Foote (Foote et et al. al. 1992a, 1992a, 1993). 1993).
dependence dependence
of of target target
strength strength
have have also also been been documented, documented, both both from from the the mentioned mentioned cruise cruise
December December
1992 1992
has has
been been documented documented (Foote (Foote 1993). 1993). Adjunct Adjunct studies studies on on the the frequency frequency
Abundance Abundance
estimation estimation
of of the the stock stock according according to to the the acoustic acoustic survey survey performed performed in in
surveyed surveyed
while while
wintering wintering
in in
the the Ofotfjord- Tysfjord Tysfjord system system in in northern northern Norway Norway (Fig. (Fig. 1 1 ). ).
In In recent recent
years, years,
the the stock stock of of Norwegian Norwegian spring spring spawning spawning herring herring has has been been acoustically acoustically
INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION 3 3
migration. migration. spawning spawning the the start start herring herring the the when when
December December of of end end
the the at at
resumed resumed however, however, are, are, migrations migrations These These migrations. migrations. horizontal horizontal
limited limited
only only be be
to to
seem seem
there there
November, November, of of middle middle the the from from month month one one of of period period a a In In
1994. 1994.
January January and and
1993 1993
December December in in Tysfjorden Tysfjorden to to tributaries tributaries fjord fjord different different herring from from herring
of of
distributions distributions
length length
shows shows
which which 2c, 2c, Fig. Fig. in in illustrated illustrated is is This This separately. separately. occur occur older older
the the
and and
young young the the
areas areas
other other in in
older, older, the the with with mix mix herring herring young young the the areas areas some some In In area. area.
wintering wintering the the in in
herring herring older older the the
joined joined have have herring herring younger younger the the November November of of beginning beginning
the the in in
and and
tributraries, tributraries,
inner inner the the reached reached have have herring herring the the October, October, of of end end the the By By
fish. fish. immature immature
younger, younger, by by
replaced replaced
been been have have
fjord fjord the the of of part part outer outer the the in in herring herring older older the the December December
by by that that
indicating indicating 1993, 1993,
December December in in and and October October of of beginning beginning the the at at Tysfjorden Tysfjorden of of outlet outlet
the the
in in
herring herring
the the of of
distribution distribution
age age and and length length the the gives gives 2b 2b Figure Figure first. first. arriving arriving herring herring
older older
the the
Tysfjorden, Tysfjorden,
and and
Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden enter enter herring herring the the October, October, of of beginning beginning the the In In
2a). 2a).
(Fig. (Fig.
migration migration
this this of of
front front the the at at catches catches the the in in dominate dominate herring herring Older Older fishery. fishery.
the the
in in
development development
geographical geographical corresponding corresponding a a by by followed followed is is This This eastwards. eastwards. moves moves
gradually gradually
migration migration the the
of of
front front the the and and Vestfjorden, Vestfjorden, enter enter herring herring the the September September By By
summer. summer.
in in
feeding feeding for for areas areas these these utilize utilize which which herring herring immature immature ecounter ecounter
herring herring
adult adult
the the
Here, Here,
VestedHen. VestedHen. of of west west concentrations concentrations increasing increasing in in appear appear and and Sea Sea
Norwegian Norwegian the the
in in
areas areas
feeding feeding the the from from eastwards eastwards migrate migrate herring herring adult adult the the August August In In
areas areas wintering wintering the the to to Immigration Immigration a) a)
ppt. ppt.
34-35 34-35 of of salinity salinity a a and and 5-7°C 5-7°C of of temperature temperature a a with with masses masses
water water in in winter winter
herring herring the the
speaking, speaking, Generally Generally (1994). (1994). al. al. et et Dommasnes Dommasnes in in discussed discussed is is
situation, situation,
oxygen oxygen the the on on
emphasis emphasis special special with with fjords, fjords, these these of of situation situation hydrographic hydrographic The The
m. m.
450 450 to to
down down
depths depths
have have others others waters, waters, shallow shallow relatively relatively have have these these of of some some
tributaries, tributaries,
many many
has has fjord fjord
The The Ofotfjorden. Ofotfjorden. in in than than complicated complicated more more are are topography topography
general general
and and
bottom bottom both both but but
m, m, 900 900 to to down down depths depths has has basin basin fjord fjord The The Vestfjorden. Vestfjorden.
against against
outlet outlet the the in in
m m 200 200 about about of of sill sill a a has has and and north-south north-south runs runs Tysfjorden Tysfjorden
places. places. in in flat flat remarkably remarkably is is which which m, m, 550 550 about about of of depth depth
a a
with with
basin basin
narrow narrow and and long long
27-km 27-km a a is is there there sill sill the the inside inside Just Just BarS!)y. BarS!)y. at at Vestfjorden Vestfjorden
towards towards m m
320 320
about about of of
sill sill a a
has has
It It km. km. 10 10 is is width width maximum maximum The The axis. axis. east-west east-west an an has has
and and
long long
km km 65 65 is is
It It
1). 1). (Fig. (Fig. area area Vestfjord Vestfjord the the of of part part inner inner the the at at situated situated is is Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden
areas areas Wintering Wintering
estimation. estimation.
abundance abundance
acoustic acoustic in in
significance significance of of are are factors factors These These content. content. fat fat decreasing decreasing
and and
maturation, maturation,
gonad gonad
distributions), distributions), angle angle tilt tilt associated associated in in changes changes likely likely (with (with
horizontal horizontal and and diurnal diurnal both both
migrations, migrations, as as such such occur, occur, changes changes homogenous. Dynamic Dynamic homogenous.
and and static static
as as
regarded regarded be be
not not should should area area wintering wintering the the in in situtation situtation the the However, However, 4 4
migration migration is is observed. observed.
located located in in deeper deeper water water masses masses than than during during the the immigration. immigration. Only Only limited limited diurnal diurnal
herring herring
are are located located in in the the outer outer part part of of the the wintering wintering area area (Fig. (Fig. 3a). 3a). The The older older herring herring are are
Figure Figure
4c 4c shows shows the the emigration emigration situation. situation. The The older older herring herring emigrate emigrate first, first, thus thus the the older older
separately separately (Fig. (Fig. 2c). 2c). Diurnal Diurnal migration migration is is observed. observed.
in in the the
inner inner parts parts of of the the wintering wintering area. area. In In some some areas areas they they mix, mix, in in some areas areas some they they occur occur
Figure Figure
4b 4b shows shows the the situation situation in in December. December. Both Both older older and and immature immature herring herring are are located located
2b 2b ). ). A A diurnal diurnal migration migration is is observed observed during during the the immigration. immigration.
immigrating immigrating
to to the the wintering wintering areas. areas. The The older older herring herring enter enter the the wintering wintering areas areas first first (Fig. (Fig.
schematically schematically
in in Fig. Fig. 4. 4. Figure Figure gives gives 4a the the situation situation in in October October while while the the herring herring is is
The The general general migration migration dynamics dynamics of of the the wintering wintering situations situations is is illustrated illustrated highly highly
zooplankton zooplankton spring spring bloom bloom commences commences in in the the coastal coastal areas. areas.
immature immature are are left. left. These These will will migrate migrate out out of of the the fjord fjord in in a a feeding feeding migration migration as as the the
In In February February most most of of the the maturing maturing herring herring have have left left the the wintering wintering area, area, and and only only the the
wintering wintering areas areas and and are are located located in in the the outer outer part, part, taking taking part part in in the the spawning spawning migration. migration.
figures figures
show show that that by by the the middle middle of of January January the the older older herring herring have have left left the the inner inner part part of of the the
and and
outer outer part part of of the the wintering wintering area area in in the the period period 11 11 - 16 16 January January 1994 1994 (Fig. (Fig. 3b). 3b). The The
and and
16 16 January January (Fig. (Fig. 3a), 3a), and and by by the the length length distrubution distrubution of of herring herring from from the the inner, inner, middle middle
sampled sampled
from from the the inner inner part part of of the the wintering wintering area area (off (off Narvik) Narvik) on on 1 1 December December 1993, 1993, 10 10
The The progress progress of of emigration emigration is is illustrated illustrated by by the the change change in in length length distribution distribution of of herring herring
herring herring remain remain in in the the inner inner part part of of the the wintering wintering area. area.
herring herring undertake undertake diurnal diurnal migrations migrations only only to to a a limited limited degree. degree. In In January January the the immature immature
is is probably probably related related to to the the currents currents of of the the water water masses masses in in the the fjord. fjord. The The outward outward migrating migrating
fish. fish.
This This emigration emigration takes takes place place in in deeper deeper water water masses masses than than does does the the immigration. immigration. This This
The The
general general situation situation in in the the wintering wintering areas areas in in January January is is thus thus an an emigration emigration of of the the older older
individuals individuals of of the the spawning spawning stock stock (Lambert (Lambert 1987, 1987, Ware Ware and and Tanasichuk Tanasichuk 1989). 1989).
individuals individuals have have a a more more rapid rapid maturation maturation rate rate than than first-time first-time spawners spawners and and younger younger
wintering wintering
areas. areas. This This is is in in agreement agreement with with earlier earlier investigations, investigations, showing showing that that the the older older
As As with with immigration, immigration, the the older older individuals individuals dominate dominate the the migration migration front front out out of of the the
The The older older individuals individuals are are the the first first to to commence commence the the emigration. emigration.
December, December, perhaps perhaps earlier, earlier, marking marking the the start start of of the the spawning spawning migration. migration.
The The
first first individuals individuals probably probably start start emigrating emigrating from from the the wintering wintering area area in in the the latter latter part part of of
b) b) Emigration Emigration from from the the wintering wintering areas areas 5 5
both both
ensure ensure to to
Skjomen Skjomen example, example, for for included included These These areas. areas. interesting interesting other other in in employed employed
were were
designs, designs,
parallel parallel and and zigzag zigzag of of variants variants and and design, design, broad-scale broad-scale first, first, the the of of Parts Parts
(NM). (NM). miles miles nautical nautical 0.5 0.5 of of distance distance
intra-transect intra-transect
with with 'E, 'E, 17°16.1 17°16.1 to to .5'E .5'E 16°19 16°19 from from extended extended 1994 1994 January January in in Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden
in in
used used
transects transects parallel parallel of of design design basic basic The The Tysfjorden. Tysfjorden. of of part part central central the the in in also also
but but
Ofotfjorden, Ofotfjorden,
namely namely concentration, concentration, largest largest of of regions regions the the in in transects transects spaced spaced equally equally
parallel, parallel, of of
designs designs in in
consist consist these these 1994, 1994, January January and and 1993 1993 December December in in cruises cruises particular particular
the the
For For
developed. developed. were were designs designs survey survey denser denser further, further, fishery, fishery, local local the the and and trawling trawling
from from
knowledge knowledge with with supplemented supplemented survey, survey, first first the the from from findings findings of of basis basis the the On On
hours. hours. 24 24 about about in in Tysfjorden Tysfjorden and and hours hours 15 15 about about
in in
covered covered
be be can can
Skjomen Skjomen and and Rombaken Rombaken including including Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden knots, knots, eight eight of of speed speed
vessel vessel
a a At At
fjord. fjord.
the the in in herring herring the the of of movements movements large-scale large-scale to to compared compared short short are are that that
periods periods
time time in in
surveyed surveyed be be areas areas fjord fjord or or fjords fjords individual individual that that and and days, days, ten ten about about within within
completed completed be be
measurements measurements auxiliary auxiliary any any and and survey survey the the that that were were this this on on Constraints Constraints
time. time. reasonable reasonable
a a in in distribution distribution herring herring the the of of coverage coverage broad-scale broad-scale comprehensive comprehensive
a a
ensure ensure
to to
attempt attempt fjords fjords both both for for patterns patterns The The (IR). (IR). author author first first the the by by design design earlier earlier
an an on on
based based
is is but but
1993), 1993), (Foote (Foote 1992 1992 December December in in used used first first was was Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden for for pattern pattern
zigzag zigzag The The
5. 5.
Fig. Fig. in in
indicated indicated tracks tracks the the along along conducted conducted was was survey survey first-time first-time basic basic The The
Tysfjorden. Tysfjorden.
and and
Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden of of coverages coverages repeated repeated in in employed employed were were grids grids survey survey Various Various
design design Survey Survey
fishery. fishery. herring herring on-going on-going the the in in participating participating boats boats fishing fishing
commercial commercial from from
samples samples by by supplemented supplemented were were catches catches Own-vessel Own-vessel trawling. trawling. performed performed
also also which which
vessels, vessels, both both by by measured measured were were profiles profiles (STD) (STD) Salinity-temperature-depth Salinity-temperature-depth
measurements. measurements.
photographic photographic and and acoustic acoustic special special to to addition addition in in exercise, exercise, calibration calibration
acoustic acoustic an an
and and concentration, concentration, dense dense of of regions regions of of surveys surveys finer-scale finer-scale additional, additional,
fjords, fjords, both both
of of survey survey large-scale large-scale a a of of consisted consisted These These 1994. 1994. January January 6-17 6-17 cruise, cruise,
second second
the the
during during
system system fjord fjord the the in in measurements measurements performed performed Hjort" Hjort" "Johan "Johan R1V R1V Only Only
calibrations. calibrations. inter-ship inter-ship and and calibration calibration
acoustic acoustic
an an
to to addition addition
in in areas, areas, certain certain in in repeated repeated surveys, surveys, acoustic acoustic of of series series a a performed performed
vessel vessel
second second This This Hjort". Hjort". "Johan "Johan RN RN with with calibrations calibrations inter-ship inter-ship and and calibration calibration
acoustic acoustic
an an to to
addition addition in in measurements measurements environmental environmental and and acoustic acoustic special special of of series series
a a
performed performed
then then
Sars" Sars" "Michael "Michael RN RN cruises. cruises. respective respective their their of of beginning beginning the the at at design, design,
survey survey same same the the
on on based based system, system, fjord fjord the the of of surveys surveys acoustic acoustic large-scale large-scale performed performed
vessels vessels Both Both
December. December. 4-15 4-15 period period the the during during Hjort" Hjort" "Johan "Johan RN RN and and December, December,
November-15 November-15 29 29 period period the the during during operated operated Sars" Sars" "Michael "Michael RN RN Tysfjorden: Tysfjorden: and and
Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden in in
measurements measurements 1993 1993 December December the the in in involved involved were were vessels vessels research research Two Two
operations operations Vessel Vessel
METHODS METHODS AND AND MATERIALS MATERIALS 6 6
at at 38, 38, 120, 120, and and 200 200 kHz, kHz, are, are, respectively, respectively, ±0.2, ±0.2, ±0.5, ±0.5, and and ±0.5 ±0.5 dB. dB.
transducer transducer at at 18 18 kHz kHz was was difficult, difficult, with. with. estimated estimated uncertainty uncertainty of of ±1 ±1 dB. dB. The The uncertainties uncertainties
earlier earlier occasions, occasions, for for example, example, that that described described by by Foote Foote et et al. al. ( ( 1993), 1993), calibration calibration of of the the
previous previous year, year, consistent consistent with with the the basic basic level level of of uncertainty uncertainty in in calibration calibration state. state. As As on on
The The instruments instruments had had performed performed stably, stably, with with insignificant insignificant change change in in performance performance over over the the
38-mm-diameter 38-mm-diameter sphere sphere of of tungsten tungsten carbide carbide with with 6% 6% cobalt cobalt binder binder at at 120 120 and and 200kHz. 200kHz.
125-mm-diameter 125-mm-diameter copper copper sphere sphere at at 18kHz, 18kHz, 60-mm-diameter copper copper 60-mm-diameter sphere sphere at at 38kHz, 38kHz, and and
target target method method recommended recommended by by ICES ICES (Foote (Foote et et al. al. 1987). 1987). The The calibration calibration targets targets were were the the
The The acoustic acoustic instruments instruments were were calibrated calibrated during during each each cruise cruise according according to to the the standard
described described in in the the section section on on analysis analysis methods. methods.
24 24 hours hours of of collection, collection, and and often often within within four four hours. hours. The The process process of of interpretation interpretation is is
All All postprocessing postprocessing was was performed performed on on BEL BEL Survey Survey data data were were generally generally interpreted interpreted within within
resolution. resolution.
region region from from 10 10 m m over over the the detected detected bottom bottom to to 5 5 m m under under the the same, same, with with 0.1-m 0.1-m depth depth
such such time time series series was was supplemented supplemented by by a a near-bottom near-bottom time time series series of of values values covering covering the the
resolution resolution in in depth depth over over the the 500-m 500-m range range and and 2-m 2-m resolution resolution over over the the 1000-m 1000-m range. range. Each Each
data data consisted consisted of of digitized digitized time time series series of of the the volume volume backscattering backscattering strength, strength, with with 1-m 1-m
indentifying indentifying data data as as vessel vessel log log and and Global Global Positioning Positioning System System (GPS) (GPS) coordinates. coordinates. Survey Survey
Data Data from from the the EK500 EK500 system system were were automatically automatically logged logged on on BEl BEl together together with with such such
beam beam devices. devices.
short-range short-range measurements. measurements. Both Both 38-kHz 38-kHz transducers transducers and and the the 120-kHz 120-kHz transducer transducer are are split
were were used used during during surveying. surveying. The The towed towed 38-kHz 38-kHz transducer transducer was was used used during during some some special special
The The cruising cruising speed speed during during surveying surveying was was about about eight eight knots. knots. Hull-mounted Hull-mounted transducers transducers
measurements measurements were were performed performed at at 18, 18, 120, 120, and and 200 200 kHz, kHz, in in addition addition to to 38 38 kHz. kHz.
general, general, two two EK500 EK500 systems systems were were operated operated concurrently, concurrently, each each with with two two transducers. transducers. Thus Thus
the the bottom bottom depth, depth, which which was was often often in in excess excess of of 500 500 m, m, and and use use of of multiple multiple frequencies. frequencies. In In
kHz. kHz. The The pulse pulse repetition repetition frequency frequency was was nominally nominally about about 1/s, 1/s, but but this this was was dependent dependent on on
The The primary primary frequency frequency was was 38 38 kHz, kHz, with with pulse pulse duration duration 1 1 ms ms and and receiver receiver bandwidth bandwidth 3.8 3.8
made made with with both both vessels, vessels, but but only only those those made made with with R/V R/V "Johan "Johan Hjort" Hjort" are are analyzed analyzed here. here.
and and Bergen Bergen Echo Echo Integrator Integrator (BEl) (BEl) (Foote (Foote et et al. al. 1991). 1991). Large-scale Large-scale measurements measurements were were
These These were were made made with with the the SIMRAD SIMRAD EK500 EK500 echo echo sounder sounder system system (Bodholt (Bodholt et et al. al. 1989) 1989)
Principal Principal acoustic acoustic measurements measurements
December December 1992 1992 survey, survey, affected affected the the placement placement of of transects, transects, hence hence design. design.
instance, instance, the the lowering lowering of of a a power power line line from from 35 35 m m to to 26 26 m m over over high high water water since since the the
and and KjS!)psviksundet. KjS!)psviksundet. In In designing designing a a finer-scale finer-scale system system of of transects transects for for Hy11S!)ysund, Hy11S!)ysund, for for
daytime daytime and and night-time night-time coverages, coverages, and and such such navigationally navigationally difficult difficult areas areas as as HullS!)ysundet HullS!)ysundet 7 7
from from measured measured were were Angles Angles release. release. automatic automatic or or manual manual with with either either taken taken were were Pictures Pictures
illumination. illumination. strobe strobe with with equipment equipment underwater underwater using using measured measured were were angles angles tilt tilt Herring Herring
situ situ in in orientation orientation Fish Fish
1987). 1987). (Foote (Foote herring herring spawning spawning
spring spring Norwegian Norwegian for for used used one one standard standard the the is is relation relation The The TS-l TS-l centimeters. centimeters. in in length length fish fish
0 0 rms rms the the denotes denotes and and l l m, m, 1 1 of of distance distance reference reference the the is is strength, strength, target target denotes denotes r r TS TS where where
r r 41t 41t o o
2 2
= = 71.9, 71.9, - log log l l 20 20
log-- 10 10 TS TS
oh oh
for for equation equation ab' ab'
defining defining the the through through size size fish fish to to a a related related is is of of value value absolute absolute The The 2.41. 2.41. be be e e to to assumed assumed
is is I I section, section, cross cross ab' ab' a a backscattering backscattering and and e e extinction extinction of of ratio ratio mean mean the the below, below, reported reported
computation computation the the in in Thus, Thus, section. section. cross cross backscattering backscattering the the with with associated associated that that as as limited limited
as as least least at at is is this this of of knowledge knowledge distribution, distribution, orientation orientation e.g., e.g., behaviour, behaviour, and and maturation, maturation,
of of degree degree size, size, fish fish depth, depth, on on depends depends undoubtedly undoubtedly section section cross cross extinction extinction the the While While
cm. cm. 3.2 3.2 deviation deviation standard standard and and 34.0, 34.0, root-mean-square root-mean-square 33.9, 33.9, mean mean with with
distribution distribution length length herring herring for for cm 22.7 22.7 is is section section cross cross extinction extinction the the terms, terms, absolute absolute In In
2 2
2.41±0.33. 2.41±0.33. is is sections sections cross cross backscattering backscattering and and extinction extinction of of ratio ratio the the that that suggests suggests analysis analysis
Statistical Statistical layer. layer. fish fish intervening intervening the the to to due due echo echo bottom bottom of of diminution diminution the the demonstrated demonstrated
Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden outer outer in in bottom bottom flat flat and and layer layer herring herring the the of of integration integration echo echo pairwise pairwise brief, brief, In In
1994). 1994). (Foote (Foote elsewhere elsewhere
detail detail in in described described are are this this of of Results Results anew. anew. performed performed was was measurement measurement the the 1991, 1991,
and and 1990, 1990, 1988, 1988, in in measured measured was was section section cross cross extinction extinction the the when when state state class-dominated class-dominated
1983-year its its to to relative relative stock stock herring herring the the of of composition composition different different the the Given Given ). ). 1992b 1992b al. al.
et et (Foote (Foote earlier earlier employed employed method method a a to to according according section section cross cross extinction extinction the the measuring measuring
for for suitable suitable also also were were Conditions Conditions necessary. necessary. compensation compensation make make and and extinction extinction acoustic acoustic
significant significant cause cause to to extended extended and and dense dense sufficiently sufficiently often often were were herring herring of of Concentrations Concentrations
extinction extinction Acoustic Acoustic
STUDIES STUDIES AUXILIARY AUXILIARY
fishery. fishery. commercial commercial the the from from 26 26 and and vessel vessel research research by by
taken taken were were samples samples 18 18 these, these, Of Of taken. taken. were were herring, herring, 100 100 of of consisting consisting each each samples, samples, 44 44
Altogether Altogether respectively. respectively. 1994, 1994, January January and and 1993 1993 October-December October-December in in locations locations sampling sampling
the the show show b b and and 6a 6a Figures Figures seine). seine). (purse (purse fishery fishery commercial commercial the the from from catches catches from from
and and (trawl) (trawl) catches catches vessel vessel research research from from originate originate herring herring the the of of samples samples biological biological The The
sampling sampling Biological Biological 8 8
abundance, abundance, because because the the conversion conversion factor factor is is length length (TS) (TS) dependent. dependent.
into into account account when when converting converting the the average average backscattering backscattering cross cross section section to to herring herring
wintering wintering area area vary vary throughout throughout the the wintering wintering period period (Figs. (Figs. 2 2 and and 3). 3). This This must must be be taken taken
these these migrations, migrations, the the length length and and age age distributions distributions of of herring herring in in the the different different parts parts of of the the
previous previous section section (Migration (Migration pattern pattern of of Norwegian Norwegian spring spring spawning spawning herring). herring). As As a a result result of of
The The basic basic dynamics dynamics of of the the migrations migrations to to and and from from the the wintering wintering areas areas is is described described in in a a
Geographic Geographic differences differences in in size size distribution distribution and and associated associated dynamics dynamics
(Kautsky (Kautsky et et al. al. 1990, 1990, Reynisson Reynisson 1993). 1993).
biomass biomass calculations calculations and and in in situ situ target target strength strength data data are are also also discussed discussed in in other other reports reports
The The findings findings of of a a large large difference difference between between the the applied applied target target strength-length strength-length relation relation for for
integration. integration.
the the target target strength strength values values obtained obtained from from combined combined individual individual countings countings and and echo echo
These These high high target target strengths strengths measured measured in in situ situ using using a a split split -beam -beam system system are are comparable comparable to to
strength-length strength-length relation relation as as presently presently applied applied in in biomass biomass calculations calculations 20 20 = = logL- (TS (TS 71.9). 71.9).
target target strength strength of of herring herring is is significantly significantly higher higher than than what what is is deduced deduced from from the the target target
Preliminary Preliminary analysis analysis of of the the data data sampled sampled within within the the herring herring layers layers indicates indicates that that the the in in situ situ
results results from from these these experiments experiments are are reported reported elsewhere. elsewhere.
counting counting methods. methods. The The three three systems systems were were calibrated calibrated several several times times during during the the survey. survey. The The
individual individual fish fish for for target target strength strength measurements measurements and and to to measure measure volume volume density density by by
scanning scanning sonar, sonar, and and Photosea Photosea stereo stereo camera, camera, was was lowered lowered into into the the herring herring layers layers to to resolve resolve
cabled cabled rig rig containing containing a a SIMRAD SIMRAD EKSOO EKSOO split-beam split-beam transducer, transducer, SIMRAD SIMRAD FS3300 FS3300
Herring Herring target target strength strength was was studied studied by by in in situ situ techniques techniques from from RIV RIV "Michael "Michael Sars". Sars". A A
Fish Fish target target strength strength in in situ situ
further further addressed addressed in in Ruse Ruse et et al. al. (1994). (1994).
tilt tilt angle angle measurements measurements made made in in December December and and January. January. The The tilt tilt angle angle measurements measurements are are
studies studies as as when when the the ship ship is is drifting. drifting. There There seems seems to to be be no no systematic systematic difference difference between between
whether whether the the tilt tilt angle angle distribution distribution is is the the same same in in the the survey survey situation situation as as it it is is during during such such
obviously obviously have have a a strong strong impact impact on on Further Further TS. TS. investigation investigation is is therefore therefore needed needed to to find find
to to swim swim at at an an upward upward angle angle in in order order to to maintain maintain depth. depth. The The observed observed tilt tilt angles angles will will
the the low low bouyancy bouyancy resulting resulting from from the the compressed compressed swimbladder, swimbladder, the the herring herring therefore therefore have have
may may be be that that at at night night the the fish fish swim swim more more slowly slowly than than at at daytime daytime and and do do not not school. school. With With
less less than than 1120 1120 of of its its surface surface volume. volume. A A possible possible explanation explanation for for the the difference difference in in tilt angle angle tilt
observations observations are are from from below below 200 200 m m depth. depth. Consequently Consequently the the swimbladder swimbladder is is compressed compressed to to
majority majority of of the the herring herring are are swimming swimming with with a a pronounced pronounced upward upward tilt. tilt. Both Both sets sets of of
Most Most herring herring are are swimming swimming horizontally. horizontally. Fig. Fig. 7b 7b shows shows a a night night situation. situation. Here Here the the
of of the the picture picture vertically vertically were were measured. measured. A A typical typical day day situation situation is is presented presented in in Fig.7a. Fig.7a.
Only Only herring herring visually visually evaluated evaluated to to swim swim parallel parallel to to the the picture picture plane plane and and in in the the central central 1/3 1/3
copied copied positives positives using using a a specially specially developed developed Autocad Autocad programme programme and and a a digitizing digitizing tablet. tablet. 9 9
depths, depths, same same the the at at method method Winkler Winkler the the using using measurements measurements and and CTD CTD the the by by
oxygen oxygen measured measured between between regression regression linear linear a a by by made made was was oxygen oxygen recorded recorded continously continously
the the of of correction correction A A 9). 9). (Fig. (Fig. stations stations 35 35 the the of of most most at at method method Winkler Winkler the the using using
depths depths 15 15 to to 10 10 from from at at samples samples water water discrete discrete against against compared compared were were measurements measurements
oxygen oxygen recorded recorded The The sensor. sensor. oxygen oxygen with with probe probe CTD CTD + + 911 911 Seabird Seabird a a using using measured measured
were were oxygen oxygen dissolved dissolved and and salinity, salinity, temperature, temperature, as as such such variables variables Environmental Environmental
distribution distribution herring herring to to respect respect with with Hydrography Hydrography
1993/94. 1993/94. period period wintering wintering the the in in content content fat fat in in variation variation the the shows shows 8 8 Figure Figure survey. survey.
January January the the %in %in 15 15 to to decreasing decreasing 16%, 16%, was was survey survey November/December November/December the the during during
4 4 2 herring herring of of content content fat fat mean mean The The extraction. extraction. ether ether ethyl ethyl with with grinding grinding S0 Na is is content content
fat fat the the determining determining for for used used method method The The in in plant plant production production Bod~. Bod~. meal meal a a at at delivered delivered
catches catches seine seine purse purse from from determined determined was was area area survey survey the the in in herring herring the the of of content content fat fat The The
content content fat fat Herring Herring
1). 1). Table Table 6b, 6b, Fig. Fig. J, J, and and I I (strata (strata
17°E 17°E of of west west and and east east strata, strata, two two into into divided divided was was Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden Consequently, Consequently, b). b). and and 3a 3a
(Figs. (Figs. eastern eastern the the in in younger younger and and fjord fjord the the of of part part western western the the in in distributed distributed were were herring herring
larger larger the the so so Ofotfjorden, Ofotfjorden, of of out out migrating migrating were were herring herring mature mature large, large, the the January, January, In In
adjustments. adjustments.
minor minor with with data data acoustic acoustic 1994 1994 January January the the of of estimation estimation abundance abundance the the for for applied applied
was was 1993 1993 December December from from stratification stratification the the D), D), (stratum (stratum Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden of of exception exception the the With With
survey survey 1994 1994 January January b) b)
b). b). and and 3a 3a (Figs. (Figs. 1990) 1990) and and 1989 1989 1988, 1988, classes classes year year the the (mainly (mainly Ofotfjord Ofotfjord
entire entire the the in in classes classes year year younger younger and and class class year year 1983 1983 the the of of mixture mixture a a December December in in
were were there there herring, herring, immature immature with with E) E) (stratum (stratum Skjomen Skjomen tributary tributary the the of of exception exception the the With With
2c). 2c).
(Fig. (Fig. basin basin main main the the in in as as herring herring large large same same the the were. were. there there (Hellemofjorden) (Hellemofjorden) tributaries tributaries
other other In In 2c). 2c). (Fig. (Fig. herring herring immature immature partly partly and and younger younger of of consentrations consentrations were were there there
however, however, B), B), (stratum (stratum Tysfjorden Tysfjorden Indre Indre and and Stefjorden Stefjorden fjords fjords tributary tributary the the In In 2b. 2b. Fig. Fig. in in
shown shown is is herring herring of of type type this this of of distribution distribution age age and and length length typical typical class. class. A A year year 1983 1983 the the
of of herring herring mainly mainly were were 6a) 6a) Fig. Fig. A, A, (stratum (stratum Tysfjorden Tysfjorden in in basin basin main main the the in in herring herring The The
survey survey 1993 1993 December December a) a)
1. 1. Table Table
in in given given are are strata strata different different the the in in herring herring the the of of length length mean mean on on data data and and b, b, and and 6a 6a
Figs. Figs. shown in in shown are are These These 1994). 1994). January January in in survey survey corresponding corresponding the the for for six six survey, survey, 1993 1993
December December the the for for strata strata (five (five strata strata into into divided divided is is area area distribution distribution herring herring total total the the Thus Thus 10 10
separately separately and and from from the the combined combined transects. transects.
different different from from zero. zero. The The same same results results apply apply to to the the data data from from each each transect transect treated treated
entire entire water water column column is is that that is is not not significantly significantly a a different different from from unity, unity, nor nor is is significantly significantly b b
were were determined determined by by ordinary ordinary linear linear regression regression analysis. analysis. The The result result for for applicable applicable to to the the sA sA
variables variables are are denoted denoted and and x, x, then then the the coefficients coefficients y y a a and and in in b b the the equation equation + + ax ax = = b b y y
namely namely for for R/V R/V "Michael "Michael Sars" Sars" on on that that for for sA sA RIV RIV "Johan "Johan Hjort". Hjort". If If the the respective respective
analysis analysis was was performed performed of of corresponding corresponding values values area area of backscattering backscattering coefficient coefficient sA' sA'
inevitable inevitable differences differences in in corresponding corresponding positions positions of of the the vessels. vessels. A A linear linear regression regression
resolution. resolution. These These values values were were further further averaged averaged over over 0.2-NM 0.2-NM intervals intervals to to help help alleviate alleviate
Data Data collection collection by by the the two two vessels vessels were were analysed analysed in in the the customary customary manner, manner, with with 0.1-NM 0.1-NM
the the two two transects. transects.
other other with with distance distance of of 1 1 NM NM between between vessels. vessels. The The lead lead was was exchanged exchanged after after the the first first of of
its its end, end, covering covering a a depth depth range range from from about about 700 700 to to 160 160 m. m. Again, Again, one one ship ship followed followed the the
transect transect from from the the western western side side of of east east to to Stefjord Stefjord Hauk~yfjord Hauk~yfjord with with continuation continuation towards towards
A A second second inter-ship inter-ship calibration calibration exercise exercise was was performed performed in in Tysfjorden Tysfjorden over over an an 8-NM 8-NM
case case like like the the present present one. one.
does does not not periodically periodically log log all all instrument instrument settings settings in in a a file file for for possible possible reference reference use, use, as as in in a a
one one of of the the vessels, vessels, revealing revealing at at the the same same time time a a weakness weakness in in the the acoustic acoustic system, system, which which
600,000 600,000 m /NM The The exercise exercise miscarried, miscarried, however, however, . . from from loss loss of of instrument instrument
settings settings on on
2 2
when when measured measured over over 0.1-NM 0.1-NM intervals, intervals, spanned spanned four four orders orders of of magnitude, magnitude, from from 40 40 to to
range range of of acoustic acoustic fish fish densities, densities, expressed expressed in in units units of of the the area area backscattering backscattering coefficient coefficient
followed followed each each other other with with 1- NM NM separation, separation, exchanging exchanging the the lead lead after after each each transect. transect. The The
half half of of Ofotfjorden, Ofotfjorden, spanning spanning a a depth depth range range from from about about 200 200 to to 500 500 m. m. The The vessels vessels
first first exercise exercise was was performed performed three three times times along along a a 16-NM 16-NM east-west east-west transect transect in in the the eastern eastern
exercises exercises in in which which the the reference reference target target was was the the mid-water mid-water scattering scattering layer layer of of herring. herring. The The
During During the the first first cruise, cruise, the the two two research research vessels vessels performed performed two two inter-ship inter-ship calibration calibration
Inter-ship Inter-ship calibration calibration of of echo echo integrators integrators
migration migration pattern pattern may may also also indicate indicate that that the the migration migration is is an an oxygen-influenced oxygen-influenced migration. migration.
not not observed observed to to stay stay in in water water with with oxygen oxygen below below 1.0 1.0 ml/1. ml/1. The The observed observed variable variable diurnal diurnal
The The herring herring tended tended to to avoid avoid water water with with dissolved dissolved oxygen oxygen less less than than about about 1.5 1.5 ml/1, ml/1, and and was was
occasionally occasionally the the whole whole layer, layer, ascend ascend from from 200 200 m m to to about about 50 50 m m depth depth during during night-time. night-time.
the the fjord. fjord. The The main main biomass biomass is is found found in in the the deeper deeper layer layer (Fig. (Fig. 11), 11), while while parts, parts, or or
at at about about 200 200 m m depth, depth, is is directly directly related related to to the the vertical vertical distribution distribution of of herring herring biomass biomass in in
10). 10). A A typical typical two-layer two-layer minimum minimum in in dissolved dissolved oxygen, oxygen, one one at at 70 70 - 100 100 m m depth depth and and one one
7.0°C 7.0°C and and a a salinity salinity between between 34.0 34.0 and and 34.9 34.9 ppt ppt at at the the depths depths between between 70 70 and and 230 230 m m (Fig. (Fig.
fjord fjord water water occupied occupied by by the the wintering wintering herring herring maintains maintains an an almost almost constant constant temperature temperature of of
et et al. al. (1994). (1994). Similar Similar conditions conditions were were also also observed observed in in November/December November/December 1993. 1993. The The
The The general general topography topography and and hydrography hydrography of of the the fjord fjord system system are are described described by by Dommasnes Dommasnes
2 2
2
= = (0 0 = = 0.830-0.198, 0.830-0.198, = = 126, 126, n n 0.94). 0.94). (CTD) (CTD) X X r
2 2 11 11
and and Rombaken, Rombaken, Bogen, Bogen, excluding excluding but but Herjangsfjord Herjangsfjord including including Ofotfjord Ofotfjord central central 1) 1) ( ( of of
consist consist these these Ofotfjorden, Ofotfjorden, For For variograms. variograms. experimental experimental and and sections sections cross cross backscattering backscattering
average average computing computing of of purpose purpose the the for for coverage, coverage, acoustic acoustic of of degree degree of of basis basis the the on on
mainly mainly regions, regions, geographical geographical limited limited more more into into divided divided been been has has region region the the Consequently, Consequently,
complicated. complicated. geometrically geometrically is is region region survey survey the the 5, 5, and and 1 1 Figs. Figs. to to according according Clearly, Clearly,
Stratification Stratification
database. database. a a in in stored stored and and interpretation, interpretation,
the the to to according according class class scatterer scatterer by by split split echogram, echogram, the the of of regions regions -selected -selected or or delimited delimited
operator for for computed computed automatically automatically are are of of Values Values species. species. non-target non-target to to sA sA or or herring, herring,
species, species, target target the the to to registrations registrations assigning assigning of of consists consists alia. alia. Classification Classification inter inter profile, profile,
STD STD and and composition composition catch catch as as data data auxiliary auxiliary such such by by aided aided BEl, BEl, running running workstation workstation
the the of of screen screen electronic electronic the the on on displayed displayed generally generally is is which which echogram, echogram, the the on on appearance appearance
their their of of basis basis the the on on classified classified are are registrations registrations acoustic acoustic specific specific process, process, this this In In
interpretation interpretation Echogram Echogram
ANALYSIS ANALYSIS OF OF METHODS METHODS
measurements. measurements. acoustic acoustic principal principal on on section section the the in in above above
described described calibration, calibration, in in uncertainties uncertainties the the of of light light the the in in viewed viewed be be to to are are measurements measurements
The The determined. determined. be be to to yet yet has has dependence dependence frequency frequency the the as as extinction, extinction, for for compensation compensation at at
attempt attempt without without measurements, measurements, the the from from directly directly derived derived are are values values reported reported The The 2. 2. Table Table
in in performed performed is is 1994 1994 January January in in cruise cruise the the of of survey survey first first the the from from data data of of comparison comparison A A
Korneliussen. Korneliussen. R.J. R.J. to to due due operation operation
entirely successful successful entirely an an cruise, cruise, first first the the during during BEl BEl to to extension extension an an of of adoption adoption and and testing, testing,
development, development, involved involved This This data. data. 38-kHz 38-kHz the the with with together together interpreted interpreted were were 200kHz 200kHz and and
120, 120, 18, 18, at at Data Data processing. processing. further further for for logged logged automatically automatically and and BEl BEl by by received received were were
they they where where (LAN), (LAN), network network local-area local-area the the over over broadcast broadcast were were tranceiver tranceiver each each from from Data Data
frequency. frequency.
transmit transmit respective respective the the of of 10% 10% were were bandwidths bandwidths receiver receiver nominal nominal The The ms. ms. 0.2 0.2 and and 0.3, 0.3, 1, 1,
2, 2, were were durations durations pulse pulse corresponding corresponding The The 200kHz. 200kHz. and and 120, 120, 38, 38, 18, 18, frequencies, frequencies, four four of of
each each at at simultaneously simultaneously made made were were Hjort" Hjort" "Johan "Johan RIV RIV with with measurements measurements mentioned, mentioned, As As
integration integration echo echo Multi-frequency Multi-frequency
92. 92. is is intervals intervals 0.2-NM 0.2-NM of of number number
The The of of y y units units x x with with each each 71, 71, 304 304 = = and and sA' sA' 29459 29459 = = are are values values mean mean The The 1906. 1906. ± ± 1084 1084
= = = = b b and and 0.049 0.049 ± ± a a 0.931 0.931 following: following: the the are are deviations deviations standard standard first first with with coefficients coefficients
the the of of values values the the transects, transects, combined combined the the for for and and kHz kHz 38 38 at at made made measurements measurements For For 12 12
computed computed
for for the the various various strata, strata, and and models models have have been been fitted fitted to to these. these. In In some some cases, cases, the the
et et al. al. 1990, 1990, Petitgas Petitgas 1993). 1993). For For the the present present data, data, experimental experimental variograms variograms have have been been
known known
(Laurec (Laurec and and Perodou Perodou 1987, 1987, Conan Conan et et al. al. 1988, 1988, Petitgas Petitgas and and Poulard Poulard 1989, 1989, Guillard Guillard
Application Application
of of geostatistics geostatistics in in the the analysis analysis of of fish fish abundance abundance survey survey data data is is becoming becoming well well
Geostatistics Geostatistics
function function by by N. N.
characteristics characteristics of of the the region region is is derived derived by by multiplying multiplying the the length length probability probability density density
the the region. region. The The result result is is the the estimated estimated total total number number of of scatterers. scatterers. N N The The length length distribution distribution
The The
cumulative cumulative
abundance abundance figure figure is is derived derived by by multiplying multiplying p p by by the the total total A A surface surface area area of of
where where p p is is the the sought sought A A area area density density of of target target scatterers. scatterers.
= = SA SA pAO pAO , ,
echo echo integration, integration, namely namely
converted converted
to to a a measure measure of of biological biological density density according according to to the the fundamental fundamental equation equation of of
The The
arithmetic arithmetic mean mean of of blocks blocks containing containing measured measured sA-values sA-values is is computed. computed. This This is is
part part of of a a grid grid of of blocks blocks covering covering the the entire entire survey survey region. region.
averaged averaged
over over individual individual blocks, blocks, or or statistical statistical squares, squares, of of side side length length 0.2 0.2 NM. NM. These These are are
GPS, GPS,
and and because because of of
integration integration
over over 0.1-NM 0.1-NM intervals intervals of of sailed sailed distance, distance, values values of of are are sA sA
Because Because
of of uncertainty uncertainty in in the the precise precise positions positions of of data data collection, collection, notwithstanding notwithstanding use use of of
Global Global averaging averaging
system. system. Data Data from from Tjeldsund Tjeldsund are are not not analyzed analyzed here. here.
quantity quantity
of of younger younger herring herring in in the the context context of of the the biomass biomass present present in in the the Ofotfjord- Tysfjord Tysfjord
Tjeldsund Tjeldsund
was was acoustically acoustically surveyed surveyed in in December December 1993, 1993, but but with with finding finding of of a a rather rather small small
west west or or east east
of of the the meridian meridian
at at 17°E. 17°E. The The respective respective areas areas are are 51.2 51.2 and and 40.6 40.6 NM . .
2
cruise, cruise,
the the data data of of central central Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden must must be be separated separated into into two two parts, parts, as as the the data data lie lie
The The
geographical geographical subdivisions subdivisions are are affected affected only only in in one one way: way: for for the the January January 1994 1994 survey survey
differences differences in in size size distribution distribution and and associated associated dynamics. dynamics.
-values, -values, the the fjords fjords sA sA are are divided divided into into the the regions regions described described in in the the section section on on geographic geographic
Biologically, Biologically,
and and for for purposes purposes of of assignment assignment of of the the average average backscattering backscattering cross cross section section to to
apparently apparently justified justified by by the the encountered encountered distributions distributions of of herring. herring.
( 1 1 ( 0) 0)
northern northern Tysfjord. Tysfjord. The The boundaries boundaries of of these these regions regions are are somewhat somewhat arbitrary, arbitrary, but but are are
KjS!)psviksund, KjS!)psviksund,
(8) (8) eastern eastern HaukS!)yfjord HaukS!)yfjord including including Stefjord, Stefjord, (9) (9) western western HaukS!)yfjord, HaukS!)yfjord, and and
(4) (4) Hellemofjord, Hellemofjord, (5) (5) eastern eastern HullS!)ysund HullS!)ysund and and Mannfjord, Mannfjord, (6) (6) inner inner Tysfjord, Tysfjord, (7) (7)
justifying justifying its its neglect. neglect. Tysfjorden Tysfjorden is is divided divided into into the the following following seven seven regions: regions:
Skjomen, Skjomen,
(2) (2) Rombaken, Rombaken, and and (3) (3) Skjomen. Skjomen. The The occurrence occurrence of of fish fish in in Bogen Bogen was was minimal, minimal, 13 13
conditions. conditions. prevailing prevailing under under least least at at abundance, abundance, of of measures measures reasonable reasonable yielding yielding
of of capable capable seem seem hours hours 12-24 12-24 of of period period a a in in conducted conducted be be can can that that Surveys Surveys days. days. of of period period
a a over over movement movement horizontal horizontal little little be be to to appears appears there there however, however, Often, Often, unpredictable. unpredictable. be be
to to appear appear movements movements horizontal horizontal large large Rather Rather behaviour. behaviour. schooling schooling daytime daytime and and migration migration
vertical vertical diurnal, diurnal, with with associated associated changes changes regular regular ignoring ignoring hours, hours, 12-24 12-24 say say time, time, of of period period
rather short short rather a a over over dramatically dramatically changes changes occasionally occasionally distribution distribution spatial spatial the the that that namely namely
system, system, fjord fjord same same the the in in herring herring of of observations observations earlier earlier confirms confirms cruises cruises reported reported the the
of of observation observation One One vessel. vessel. research research the the of of passage passage the the to to due due effects effects behavioural behavioural other other or or
reactions reactions avoidance avoidance of of presence presence possible possible and and sections, sections, cross cross extinction extinction and and backscattering backscattering
of of values values of of appropriateness appropriateness coverage, coverage, acoustic acoustic of of degree degree stock, stock, the the of of distribution distribution
spatial spatial the the concern concern here here reported reported survey survey of of kind kind the the about about asked asked be be to to questions questions Major Major
assessment. assessment. abundance abundance their their for for prerequisite prerequisite a a 1993), 1993),
(Gunderson (Gunderson surveying surveying acoustic acoustic to to fish fish the the of of availability availability the the for for importantly importantly argues argues but but
validity, validity, their their prove prove not not does does This This consistency. consistency. internal internal strong strong a a show show results results the the Clearly, Clearly,
sources sources Error Error
DISCUSSION DISCUSSION
5. 5. Table Table in in presented presented also also are are mean mean the the of of error error
standard standard and and variance variance estimation estimation The The excluded. excluded. and and included included both both are are transects transects parallel parallel the the
connecting connecting end-links end-links designs, designs, several several the the from from data data the the analyzing analyzing In In 5. 5. Table Table in in compared compared
are are transects, transects, spaced spaced equally equally parallel, parallel, of of system system fine-scale fine-scale subsequent subsequent and and pattern pattern
zigzag zigzag large-scale large-scale initial initial the the with with surveyed surveyed as as Ofotfjord, Ofotfjord, central central for for estimates estimates Abundance Abundance
4. 4. Table Table in in presented presented are are estimate, estimate, abundance abundance
stock stock respective respective the the by by weighted weighted distributions distributions length length individual individual the the combining combining by by formed formed
distributions, distributions, length length composite composite Corresponding Corresponding shown. shown. are are extinction extinction for for compensation compensation
with with and and without without Estimates Estimates cruises. cruises. both both during during followed followed designs designs survey survey zigzag zigzag large-scale large-scale
initial initial the the on on based based are are Estimates Estimates form. form. summary summary in in given given is is system system Tysfjord Tysfjord Ofotfjord-
the the for for abundance abundance total total 3, 3, Table Table In In tables. tables. of of series series short short a a through through presented presented are are These These
RESULTS RESULTS
1993). 1993). (Foote (Foote analyzed analyzed
were were 1992 1992 December December from from data data survey survey acoustic acoustic the the that that manner manner very very the the in in effected effected
been been has has This This computed. computed. be be to to variance variance estimation estimation the the allows allows models models these these of of Use Use
terms. terms. spherical-function spherical-function and and nugget nugget summing summing
by by fitted fitted be be can can which which variograms, variograms, bounded bounded of of cases cases important important are are there there between, between,
In In variogram. variogram. increasing increasing linearly linearly with with scales, scales, all all at at seen seen is is structure structure cases, cases, other other In In NM. NM.
0.2 0.2 namely namely analysis, analysis, of of size size scale scale basic basic the the at at least least at at structure, structure, of of absence absence an an show show data data 14 14
understanding understanding
it, it,
is is necessary necessary for for proper proper stratification stratification in in analyzing analyzing large-scale large-scale survey survey data, data,
replete replete
with with biological biological implications. implications. Describing Describing this this structure, structure, not not to to mention mention
Geographical Geographical
separation separation
or or structuring structuring of of the the stock stock even even within within a a limited limited fjord fjord system system is is
herring, herring, and and North North Sea Sea herring) herring) must must be be solved. solved.
important important
herring herring
stocks stocks (Norwegian (Norwegian spring spring spawning spawning herring, herring, Icelandic Icelandic summer summer spawning spawning
split-beam split-beam
techniques techniques
and and TS-length TS-length relations relations used used in in the the acoustic acoustic biomass biomass estimation estimation of of
The The problem problem
of of the the reported reported discrepancy discrepancy between between in in situ situ TS TS measurements measurements using using
orientation orientation
remains remains a a subject subject of of the the greatest greatest importance importance to to stock stock abundance abundance estimation. estimation.
those those
of of
depth, depth,
depth depth history, history, physiological physiological state state including including fat fat content content (Ona (Ona 1990), 1990), and and
acoustic acoustic
properties properties of of
herring herring in in situ, situ, especially especially to to delineate delineate such such possible possible dependences dependences as as
studies studies
performed performed
concurrently concurrently with with the the surveying surveying measurements. measurements. Thus, Thus, measuring measuring the the
That That
there there
are are outstanding outstanding problems problems is is evident evident from from the the number number and and extent extent of of auxiliary auxiliary
Outstanding Outstanding problems problems
significant significant avoidance avoidance reactions. reactions.
R/V R/V
"Johan "Johan Hjort" Hjort"
in in Table Table 3. 3. Such Such an an agreement agreement argues argues strongly strongly for for the absence absence the of of
extinction extinction
indicates indicates
agreement agreement to to within within about about 10% 10% of of the the corresponding corresponding result result shown shown for for
been been
presented presented here, here,
for for want want of of time, time, a a preliminary preliminary analysis analysis of of data data not not compensated compensated for for
conditions. conditions.
While While
results results from from the the large-scale large-scale survey survey with with RIV RIV "Michael "Michael Sars" Sars" have have not not
remarkable remarkable
by by
the the
apparent apparent specificity specificity of of reactions reactions to to time, time, place, place, and and intangible intangible in in situ situ
not not prevented prevented
results results
obtained obtained at at different different times times from from showing showing a a consistency consistency made made more more
Avoidance Avoidance
reactions reactions
have have not not been been proven proven to to be be absent. absent. If If present, present, however, however, these these have have
with with the the same same variables variables that that influence influence the the backscattering backscattering cross cross section. section.
Determination Determination
of of this this quantity quantity is is intrinsically intrinsically statistical, statistical, but but it it probably probably shares shares dependence dependence
remains remains
to to be be
done. done. The The situation situation is is similar similar with with respect respect to to the the extinction extinction cross cross section. section.
distribution distribution
in in relation relation to to depth, depth, impact impact of of changing changing fat fat content content on on the the target target strength), strength),
are are
outlined outlined
in in the the present present paper paper (in (in situ situ target target strength strength measurements, measurements, tilt tilt angle angle
However, However,
fundamental fundamental
work work on on the the target target strength-length strength-length relation, relation, of of which which some some topics topics
prognosis prognosis
has has been been the the basis basis for for management management of of this this commercially commercially important important stock. stock.
tuning tuning
process process
to to estimate estimate the the stock stock size size as as a a starting starting point point for for a a stock stock prognosis. prognosis. This This
the the ICES ICES
Working Working
Group Group on on Atlanto-Scandic Atlanto-Scandic Herring Herring and and Capelin Capelin (Anon. (Anon. 1994) 1994) in in a a
have, have,
together together
with with
other other estimates estimates of of the the spawning spawning stock stock (from (from tagging), tagging), been been utilized utilized by by
applied. applied.
The The
results results from from previous previous acoustic acoustic surveys surveys in in the the wintering wintering area area (Foote (Foote 1993) 1993)
target target
strength-fish strength-fish
length length relationship relationship for for Norwegian Norwegian spring spring spawning spawning herring herring has has been been
depends depends
entirely entirely
on on the the backscattering backscattering cross cross section section or or target target strength. strength. Here, Here, the the standard standard
Whether Whether
the the stock stock abundance abundance estimates estimates are are to to be be interpreted interpreted as as absolute absolute or or relative relative
measure measure (Anon. (Anon. 1993). 1993).
disregards disregards
this. this.
It It has has been been earlier earlier argued argued that that the the estimation estimation variance variance is is the the more more useful useful
quantity quantity
includes includes
information information on on spatial spatial structure, structure, through through the the variogram, variogram, while while the the second second
corresponding corresponding
values values
for for the the standard standard error error of of the the mean mean shows shows no no regular regular pattern. pattern. The The first first
Ofotfjord Ofotfjord
in in January January 1994, 1994, comparison comparison of of values values of of the the estimation estimation variance variance with with
is is assessed assessed
by by the the estimation estimation variance. variance. In In the the case case of of herring herring as as measured measured in in central central
The The
degree degree
of of acoustic acoustic
coverage coverage relative relative to to the the stock stock distribution distribution and and area area to to be be surveyed surveyed 15 15
pp. pp. 69 69 144. 144. Res., Res., Res. Res. Coop. Coop. ICES ICES
guide. guide. practical practical a a estimation: estimation: density density fish fish for for instruments instruments acoustic acoustic of of Calibration Calibration
1987. 1987. E.J. E.J. Simmonds, Simmonds, and and D.N. D.N. MacLennan, MacLennan, G., G., Vestnes, Vestnes, H.P., H.P., Knudsen, Knudsen, K.G., K.G., Foote, Foote,
[Mimeo] [Mimeo] pp. pp. 10 10 1994/(B+D+G+H):2. 1994/(B+D+G+H):2. CM CM ICES ICES
speculations. speculations. and and measurements measurements new new herring: herring: of of section section cross cross Extinction Extinction 1994. 1994. K.G. K.G. Foote, Foote,
[Mimeo] [Mimeo] pp. pp. 12 12 1993/D:45. 1993/D:45.
CM CM ICES ICES fjord. fjord. a a in in hibernating hibernating herring herring of of estimation estimation Abundance Abundance 1993. 1993. K.G. K.G. Foote, Foote,
981-987. 981-987. 82: 82: Am., Am.,
Soc. Soc. acoust. acoust. surveys. surveys. J. J. integrator integrator echo echo in in use use for for strengths strengths target target Fish Fish 1987. 1987. K.G. K.G. Foote, Foote,
63-69. 63-69. 51: 51: Sci., Sci., mar. mar. ICES ICES J. J. areas. areas. wintering wintering
herring herring in in concentrations concentrations oxygen oxygen Reduced Reduced 1994. 1994. I. I. RS?Sttingen, RS?Sttingen, and and F. F. Rey, Rey, A., A., Dommasnes, Dommasnes,
[Mimeo] [Mimeo]
pp. pp. 8 8 1988/D:21. 1988/D:21. CM CM ICES ICES herring. herring. of of school school a a in in distribution distribution spatial spatial of of analyses analyses
Geostatistical Geostatistical 1988. 1988. M. M. Cumeau, Cumeau, and and M. M. Chadwick, Chadwick, E., E., Wade, Wade, U., U., Buerkle, Buerkle, G.Y., G.Y., Conan, Conan,
123-130. 123-130.
11(3): 11(3): lOA, lOA, Proc. Proc. system. system. echo-sounder echo-sounder new new A A 1989. 1989. H. H. Solli, Solli, and and H. H. Nes, Nes, H., H., Bodhold, Bodhold,
1994/Assess:8. 1994/Assess:8. CM CM
ICES ICES Group. Group. Working Working Capelin Capelin and and Herring Herring Atlanto-Scandian Atlanto-Scandian the the of of Report Report 1994. 1994. Anon. Anon.
pp. pp. 87 87 195. 195.
Rep., Rep., Res. Res. Coop. Coop. ICES ICES 1991. 1991. September September 5-9 5-9 Reykjavik, Reykjavik, Data, Data, Survey Survey Acoustic Acoustic to to
Techniques Techniques Statistical Statistical Spatial Spatial of of Applicability Applicability the the on on Workshop Workshop the the of of Report Report 1993. 1993. Anon. Anon.
REFERENCES REFERENCES
surveys. surveys. the the of of parts parts wearying wearying and and intensive intensive navigationally navigationally during during especially especially patience, patience,
and and cooperation cooperation their their for for saluted saluted are are vessels vessels the the of of crews crews and and officers officers The The morphometry. morphometry.
swimbladder swimbladder including including especially especially work, work, laboratory laboratory in in participation participation for for thanked thanked are are Tiarsin, Tiarsin,
M. M. Kinacigil and and Kinacigil T. T. scientists, scientists, guest guest Two Two cruise. cruise. 1993 1993 December December the the during during plotter plotter
new new a a testing testing and and maps maps distribution distribution preparing preparing for for 0stensen 0stensen 0. 0. and and cruise, cruise, 1994 1994 January January
the the during during samples samples biological biological analyzing analyzing for for NS?Sdtvedt NS?Sdtvedt A. A. BEl, BEl, on on work work for for Korneliussen Korneliussen
R.J. R.J. data, data, of of gigabytes gigabytes interpreting interpreting for for Romslo Romslo A. A. and and Hansen Hansen K.A. K.A. thanked: thanked: particularly particularly
are are following following The The help. help. steadfast steadfast their their for for thanked thanked are are cruises cruises the the on on participants participants Fellow Fellow
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
frequencies. frequencies. same same the the at at operate operate that that models models transducer transducer new new with with Hjort" Hjort" "Johan "Johan
RIV RIV board board on on mounted mounted transducers transducers 120-kHz 120-kHz and and 18- current current the the of of replacement replacement clear: clear: is is
solution solution The The eliminated. eliminated. be be must must performance performance transducer transducer inferior inferior to to due due uncertainties uncertainties gross gross
potential, potential, this this realize realize to to Certainly Certainly however. however. developed, developed, be be to to remains remains tool tool The The 1993). 1993). ( ( al. al.
et et Foote Foote in in example, example, for for found, found, is is this this on on Speculation Speculation properties. properties. scattering scattering and and behaviour behaviour
fish fish about about learning learning for for tool tool valuable valuable potentially potentially a a is is integration integration echo echo frequency frequency Multiple-
important. important. similarly similarly is is content, content, oxygen oxygen dissolved dissolved especially especially hydrography, hydrography, with with
herring herring of of distribution distribution spatial spatial of of connection connection the the Understanding Understanding work. work. this this in in attempted attempted as as 16 16
1776-1784. 1776-1784.
in in Pacific Pacific herring herring (Clupea (Clupea harengus harengus pallasi). pallasi). Can. Can. Fish. Fish. J. J. Aquat. Aquat. Sci., Sci., 46( 46( 10): 10):
Ware, Ware,
D.M. D.M. and and Tanasichuk, Tanasichuk, R. R. 1989. 1989. Biological Biological basis basis of of maturation maturation and and spawning spawning waves waves
CM CM 1992/H:18. 1992/H:18. 10 10 pp. pp.
R~ttingen, R~ttingen, 1992. 1992. I. I. Recent Recent migration migration routes routes of of Norwegian Norwegian spring spring spawning spawning herring. herring. ICES ICES
herring herring in in the the period period 1985-1992. 1985-1992. ICES ICES CM CM 1993/B:40. 1993/B:40.
Reynisson, Reynisson, P. P. 1993. 1993. In In situ situ target target strength strength measurements measurements of of Icelandic Icelandic summer-spawning summer-spawning
on on hake hake in in the the Bay Bay of of Biscay. Biscay. ICES ICES CM CM 1989/G:62. 1989/G:62. 21 21 pp. pp. [Mimeo] [Mimeo]
Petitgas, Petitgas,
P. P. and and Poulard, Poulard, J.C. J.C. 1989. 1989. Applying Applying stationary stationary geostatistics geostatistics to to fisheries: fisheries: a a study study
application. application. ICES ICES mar. mar. J. J. Sci., Sci., 285-298. 285-298. 50: 50:
Petitgas, Petitgas, P. P. 1993. 1993. Geostatistics Geostatistics for for fish fish stock stock assessments: assessments: a a review review and and an an acoustic acoustic
fish. fish. mar. mar. J. J. biol. biol. Ass. Ass. U.K., U.K., 70: 70: 107-127. 107-127.
Ona, Ona, E. E. 1990. 1990.
Physiological Physiological factors factors causing causing natural natural variations variations in in acoustic acoustic target target strength strength of of
1987/D:9. 1987/D:9. 27 27 pp. pp. [Mimeo] [Mimeo]
!'analyse !'analyse des des pussances pussances de de peche peche et et des des abondances abondances apparentes. apparentes. ICES ICES CM CM
Laurec, Laurec, A. A. and and Perodou, Perodou, J.B. J.B. 1987. 1987. Considerations Considerations statistiques statistiques et et informatiques informatiques sur sur
209-220. 209-220.
related related to to the the age age structure structure of of the the mature mature population. population. Mar. Mar. Ecol. Ecol. Prog. Prog. Ser., Ser., 39: 39:
Lambert, Lambert,
T.C. T.C. 1987. 1987. Duration Duration and and intensity intensity of of spawning spawning in in herring herring (Clupea (Clupea harengus) harengus) as as
Alaska: Alaska: 163-182. 163-182.
dual-beam dual-beam and and split split beam beam sonar. sonar. Proc. Proc. Int. Int. Herring Herring Symp., Symp., Oct Oct 1990, 1990, Anchorage, Anchorage,
of of Pacific Pacific herring herring ( ( Clupea Clupea harengus harengus pallasi) pallasi) in in the the eastern eastern Strait Strait of of Georgia Georgia using using
Kautsky, Kautsky, G.A., G.A., Lemberg, Lemberg, N.A. N.A. and and Ona, Ona, E. E. 1990. 1990. In In situ situ target target strength strength measurements measurements
overwintering overwintering Norwegian Norwegian spring spring spawning spawning herring. herring. ICES ICES CM CM 1994/B: 1994/B: 19. 19.
Huse, Huse, 1., 1., Foote, Foote, K.G., K.G., Ona, Ona, E. E. and and R~ttingen, R~ttingen, 1994. 1994. I. I. Angular Angular distribution distribution of of
Gunderson, Gunderson,
D.R. D.R. 1993. 1993. Surveys Surveys of of fisheries fisheries resources. resources. Wiley, Wiley, New New York. York. 248 248 pp. pp.
Reun. Reun. Cons. Cons. int. int. Explor. Explor. Mer, Mer, 189: 189: 410-414. 410-414.
estimation estimation by by echo echo integration integration in in lakes: lakes: the the example example of of Lake Lake Annecy. Annecy. Rapp. Rapp. P.-v. P.-v.
Guillard, Guillard, J., J., Gerdeaux, Gerdeaux, D. D. and and Chautru, Chautru, J.-M. J.-M. 1990. 1990. The The use use of of geostatistics geostatistics for for abundance abundance
strength strength of of mature mature herring. herring. ICES ICES CM CM 1993/B:30. 1993/B:30. 8 8 pp. pp. [Mimeo] [Mimeo]
Foote, Foote,
K.G., K.G., Hansen, Hansen, K.A. K.A. and and Ona, Ona, E. E. 1993. 1993. More More on on the the frequency frequency dependence dependence of of target target
aggregating aggregating fish. fish. acoust. acoust. J. J. Soc. Soc. Am., Am., 91: 91: 1983-1989. 1983-1989.
Foote, Foote,
K.G., K.G., Ona, Ona, E. E. and and Toresen, Toresen, R. R. 1992b. 1992b. Determining Determining the the extinction extinction cross cross section section of of
strength strength of of mature mature herring. herring. ICES ICES CM CM 1992/B:10. 1992/B:10. 8 8 pp. pp. [Mimeo] [Mimeo]
Foote, Foote, K.G., K.G., Hansen, Hansen, K.A. K.A. and and Ona, Ona, E. E. 1992a. 1992a. On On the the frequency frequency dependence dependence of of target target
Postprocessing Postprocessing system system for for echo echo sounder sounder data. data. acoust. acoust. J. J. Soc. Soc. Am., Am., 90: 90: 37-47. 37-47.
Foote, Foote, K.G., K.G., Knudsen, Knudsen,
H.P., H.P., Korneliussen, Korneliussen, R.J., R.J., P.E. P.E. Nordb~, Nordb~, and and K. K. R~ang, R~ang, 1991. 1991. 17 17
5.2 5.2 -43.9 -43.9 25.20 25.20 K K Skjomen Skjomen 1994 1994 January January
7.7 7.7 -42.1 -42.1 30.89 30.89 J J 17°E 17°E of of E E Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden 1994 1994 January January
9.4 9.4
-41.3 -41.3 34.03 34.03 I I 17°E 17°E of of W W Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden 1994 1994 January January
6.7 6.7 -42.7 -42.7 28.80 28.80 H H Stefjord Stefjord 1994 1994 January January
6.6 6.6 -42.8 -42.8 28.50 28.50 G G Tysfjord Tysfjord Inner Inner 1994 1994 January January
10.0 10.0 -41.0 -41.0 35.15 35.15 F F Tysfjord Tysfjord 1994 1994 January January
5.2 5.2 -43.9 -43.9 25.20 25.20 E E Skjomen Skjomen 1993 1993 December December
9.5 9.5 -41.2 -41.2 34.16 34.16 0 0 Ofoten Ofoten 1993 1993 December December
6.3 6.3
-43.0 -43.0 27.80 27.80 c c Tjeldsund Tjeldsund 1993 1993 December December
8.1 8.1 -41.9 -41.9 31.63 31.63 B B Tysfjord Tysfjord Inner Inner Stefjord, Stefjord, 1993 1993 December December
10.1 10.1 -41.0 -41.0 35.23 35.23 A A Tysfjord Tysfjord 1993 1993 December December
TS(dB) TS(dB) !(cm) !(cm) region region Fjord Fjord Stratum Stratum Eeriod Eeriod ) ) (cm (cm Cruise Cruise ab ab
2 2
centimeters. centimeters. in in expressed expressed is is where where ! !
71.9, 71.9,
-
2 2 log log
TS=20 TS=20 equation equation the the from from derived derived are are strength strength target target and and 2 2 length length
root-mean-square root-mean-square The The differentiated. differentiated. is is ab ab section section cross cross backscattering backscattering
mean mean the the which which in in Tysfjorden Tysfjorden and and Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden of of state state 1. 1. Biological Biological Table Table
(5.9) (5.9) (6. (6. 2) 2) ( ( 4. 4. 1) 1) (3.7) (3.7)
Skjomen Skjomen 9.5 9.5 25.2 25.2 110 110 14.3 14.3 13.3 13.3 10.1 10.1 9.0 9.0
(4.3) (4.3) (3.3) (3.3) (2.6) (2.6) (2.0) (2.0)
Rombaken Rombaken 5.2 5.2 30.9 30.9 58* 58* 0.19 0.19 0.19 0.19 0.15 0.15 0.18 0.18
E E of of 17°E 17°E (2.0) (2.0) (2.1) (2.1) (2.3) (2.3) (2.1) (2.1)
Central Central Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden 40.6 40.6 30.9 30.9 237* 237* 73.1 73.1 63.2 63.2 51.6 51.6 56.7 56.7
W W of of 17°E 17°E (1.4) (1.4) (1.4) (1.4) (1.5) (1.4) (1.4) (1.5)
Central Central Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden 51.2 51.2 34.0 34.0 310 310 89.6 89.6 76.1 76.1 49.4 49.4 89.5 89.5
Stratum Stratum
~(cm) ~(cm)
s s
(NM2) (NM2)
18 18 n n 38 38 120 120 200 200
~,, ~,, Area
sA(1000m sA(1000m /NM) /NM) & & (cv) (cv) vs. vs. f(kHz) f(kHz)
2 2 2 2
i~ i~ expressed expressed in in parentheses parentheses below below the the mean mean value value of of sA. sA.
n n to to 235 235 and and 34 34 at at the the respective respective locations. locations. The The coefficient coefficient of of variation variation cv cv
absence absence of of data data at at 120 120 kHz kHz from from a a 5-NM 5-NM interval interval of of integration, integration, which which reduced reduced
which which there there me~sured me~sured are are values values of of sA. sA. The The asterisks asterisks call call attention attention to to the the
fish fish length, length, and and n n the the number number of of statistical statistical squares squares of of side side length length 0.2 0.2 NM NM in in
geographical geographical
and and biological biological strata. strata. The The quantity quantity denotes denotes the the ~ ~ root-mean-square root-mean-square
at at each each of of four four frequencies frequencies during during the the January January 1994 1994 cruise, cruise, selected selected from from four four
2. 2. Table Table Mean Mean values values of of sA sA uncompensated uncompensated for for extinction extinction as as measured measured simultaneously simultaneously
10 14.6 14.6 10 10.2 10.2 1994 1994 January January
9 9 9 9
10 13.2 13.2 10 9.5 9.5 1993 1993 December December
9 9 9 9
comE.ensation comE.ensation compensation compensation period period Cruise Cruise
With With Without Without
extinction. extinction. acoustic acoustic
for for compensation compensation with with and and without without both both performed performed are are Computations Computations fish. fish.
of of numbers numbers total total as as expressed expressed surveys, surveys, zigzag zigzag large-scale large-scale the the from from derived derived
system, system, Ofotfjord-Tysfjord Ofotfjord-Tysfjord the the in in herring herring for for figures figures Abundance Abundance 3. 3. Table Table
-
39.75 39.75
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03
39.25 39.25
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.09 0.09 0.10 0.10
38.75 38.75
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.65 0.65 0.72 0.72
38.25 38.25 0.29 0.29
0.29 0.29
0.83 0.83 0.93 0.93
37.75 37.75
1.05 1.05
1.09 1.09
2.30 2.30 2.48 2.48
37.25 37.25
4.40 4.40
4.55 4.55
4.17 4.17 4.47 4.47
36.75 36.75
6.81 6.81
7.13 7.13
5.85 5.85 6.31 6.31
36.25 36.25
9.83 9.83
10.39 10.39
6.28 6.28 6.67 6.67
35.75 35.75
8.23 8.23
8.81 8.81
4.97 4.97 5.24 5.24
35.25 35.25
9.88 9.88
10.44 10.44
2.73 2.73 2.87 2.87
34.75 34.75
4.57 4.57
4.80 4.80
2.37 2.37 2.55 2.55
34.25 34.25
3.41 3.41
3.55 3.55
2.53 2.53 2.65 2.65
33.75 33.75
2.43 2.43 2.50 2.50
3.09 3.09 2.95 2.95
33.25 33.25 5.64 5.64
5.80 5.80
3.99 3.99 3.88 3.88
32.75 32.75 4.56 4.56
4.74 4.74
4.88 4.88 4.82 4.82
32.25 32.25 4.81 4.81
4.86 4.86
6.10 6.10 6.07 6.07
31.75 31.75 2.47 2.47
2.50 2.50
4.32 4.32 4.43 4.43
31.25 31.25 4.30 4.30
4.41 4.41
4.73 4.73 4.83 4.83
30.75 30.75 1.51 1.51
1.53 1.53
4.03 4.03 3.81 3.81
30.25 30.25 1.08 1.08
1.07 1.07
3.69 3.69 3.85 3.85
29.75 29.75 1.34 1.34
1.30 1.30
3.01 3.01 2.84 2.84
29.25 29.25 0.69 0.69
0.69 0.69
2.92 2.92 2.76 2.76
28.75 28.75 0.80 0.80
0.71 0.71
2.36 2.36 2.23 2.23
28.25 28.25 1:77 1:77
1.70 1.70
4.02 4.02 3.84 3.84
27.75 27.75 1.09 1.09
1.02 1.02
3.30 3.30 3.19 3.19
27.25 27.25 2.71 2.71
2.41 2.41
4.25 4.25 4.12 4.12
26.75 26.75 2.57 2.57
2.16 2.16
3.24 3.24 3.08 3.08
26.25 26.25 2.71 2.71
2.31 2.31
2.11 2.11 2.02 2.02
25.75 25.75 1.61 1.61
1.33 1.33
1.26 1.26 1.14 1.14
25.25 25.25 0.66 0.66
0.57 0.57
0.45 0.45 0.43 0.43
24.75 24.75 0.20 0.20
0.17 0.17
0.29 0.29 0.27 0.27
24.25 24.25 0.66 0.66
0.54 0.54
0.40 0.40 0.37 0.37
23.75 23.75
1.47 1.47 1.19 1.19
1.02 1.02 0.90 0.90
23.25 23.25 1.01 1.01
0.86 0.86
1.09 1.09 0.99 0.99
22.75 22.75 2.38 2.38
2.00 2.00
1.17 1.17 0.96 0.96
22.25 22.25 1.01 1.01
0.87 0.87
0.58 0.58 0.50 0.50
21.75 21.75 1.01 1.01
0.86 0.86
0.24 0.24 0.19 0.19
21.25 21.25 0.20 0.20 0.17 0.17
0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06
20.75 20.75 0.50 0.50 0.41 0.41
0.31 0.31 0.36 0.36
20.25 20.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
0.05 0.05 0.06 0.06
19.75 19.75 0.05 0.05 0.04 0.04
0.05 0.05 0.06 0.06
19.25 19.25 0.31 0.31 0.25 0.25
0.05 0.05 0.07 0.07
(cm) (cm) Without Without With With Without Without With With
Length Length December December 1993 1993 January January 1994 1994
with with compensation compensation for for extinction. extinction.
expressed expressed
as as percentage. percentage.
The The weighting weighting functions functions are are computed computed both both without without and and
individual individual
biologicaL biologicaL strata strata by by the the estimated estimated abundance abundance in in each each stratum, stratum,
Ofotfjord-Tysfjord Ofotfjord-Tysfjord
system, system, obtained obtained by by weighting weighting length length distributions distributions for for
Table Table
4. 4. Probability Probability density density functions functions of of length length for for herring herring over over the the entire entire
16.0 16.0 15.2 15.2 10 10 1.83 1.83 13.3 13.3 13.3 13.3 10 10 1.42 1.42 ends ends w/o w/o Parallel Parallel 17°E 17°E of of E E
109 109 1.71 1.71
14.7 14.7
10.8 10.8 109 109 1.35 1.35 12.1 12.1 10.1 10.1 w/ends w/ends Parallel Parallel 17°E 17°E of of E E
109 109
5.62 5.62
20.0 20.0
29.4 29.4 109 109 3.32 3.32 13.8 13.8 22.7 22.7
Zigzag Zigzag
17°E 17°E of of E E 9 9 9 9
8.9 8.9
11.8 11.8 10 10 7.59 7.59 6.2 6.2 7.4 7.4 10 10 5.50 5.50 ends ends w/o w/o Parallel Parallel 17°E 17°E of of W W
109 109 7.31 7.31 7.9 7.9
9.6 9.6 109 109 5.8 5.8 5.30 5.30 6.8 6.8 w/end w/end Parallel Parallel 17°E 17°E of of W W
109 109 5.54 5.54
12.9 12.9
14.4 14.4 109 109 4.14 4.14 8.1 8.1 10.2 10.2
Zigzag Zigzag
17°E 17°E of of W W 9 9 9 9
se se
N N se se N N design design Surve~ Surve~ crE crE Stratum Stratum crE crE
comEensation comEensation With With compensation compensation Without Without
mean. mean. the the of of percentages percentages as as expressed expressed are are
se, se, mean, mean, the the of of error error standard standard and and crE crE variance variance estimation estimation The The extinction. extinction.
for for compensation compensation with with and and without without both both given given are are N N Numbers Numbers 1994. 1994. January January
9-10 9-10 on on separation separation 0.5-NM 0.5-NM with with transects transects spaced spaced equally equally parallel, parallel, of of system system
a a by by and and 1994 1994 January January 7 7 on on design design zigzag zigzag large-scale large-scale the the by by Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden
central central in in surveyed surveyed herring herring of of estimates estimates abundance abundance of of Comparison Comparison 5. 5. Table Table
Ofotfjorden, Ofotfjorden, Fig. Fig.
1 1
Tysfjorden Tysfjorden
and and adjoining adjoining areas. areas.
1 1 4° 4°
15° 15°
1 6 6 1 ° °
17° 17° 18° 18°
/. /.
)' )'
t t
68° 68°
( ( ......
( (
/ / ;
i i
30' 30' 68° 68°
1993. 1993. - 11.12 11.12 and and 1.10 1.10 Tysfjorden, Tysfjorden,
of of
outlet outlet the the at at
herring herring of of 2b 2b Fig. Fig. distributions distributions Length Length
Lcngdc(cm) Lcngdc(cm)
Alder(i1r) Alder(i1r)
Lcngdc(cm) Lcngdc(cm)
34 34
32 32 :w :w 30 30
26 26 21 21
22 22
20 20
u u 10 10 0 0 4 4 ao ao :JU :JU :JG :JG :J4 :J4 :J2 :J2
0 0 0 0
V V
10 10
20 20 -
10 10
L L
t t ~ ~
ao ao
n n
n n
c c
c c
c c
40 40
s s
5 5
5 5
20 20
0 0
0 0
50 50
0 0
I" I"
r r
r r
p p P P GO GO
p p
ao ao 70 70
uo uo
20 20
!JO !JO ~0 ~0
11.12.93 11.12.93
11.10.93 11.10.93
1993. 1993. -
9.9 9.9 E), E), 14° 14° (approximately (approximately Vestfjorden Vestfjorden
areas. areas. wintering wintering the the to to immigration immigration the the of of
front front
the the at at
herring herring of of
distribution distribution
age age and and Length Length
2a 2a Fig. Fig.
Aldc1'(i11·) Aldc1'(i11·) l.cngrlc(cm) l.cngrlc(cm)
11 11 10 10
4 4
' ' ;: ;:
0 0 :10 :10 :.:n :.:n .(0 .(0 Jr. Jr. :12 :12 :14 :14 :tO :tO L_,_.~- 20 ...... ~~ ~~
11- l 10 10
·20 ·20
1\ 1\
10 10
l l
l l
n n
n n
c c
c c
s s
:so :so
s s
.. .. :!0 :!0
0 0
0 0
r r
r r
40 40
p p p p
ao ao
::.o ::.o • •
(j(l (j(l ~0 ~0 fJ.9.fJ3 fJ.9.fJ3
January January 1994. 1994.
tributaries tributaries of of Tysfjorden Tysfjorden
in in
December December 1993 1993 and and
Fig. Fig. 2c 2c
Length Length distributions distributions of of herring herring in in different different
Lcngdc(cm) Lcngdc(cm) Lcngdc(cm) Lcngdc(cm)
lU lU
20 20
A!~ A!~
24 24
211 211
211 211
:JO :JO
a-! a-! :12 :12
ao ao an an 111 111 20 20 22 22 20 20 21 21 20 20 an an 34 34 32 32 :10 :10 :Ill :Ill 40 40
0-
0-
l l
L L
10 10
n n n n 10 10
c c
c c
s s
s s
0 0
0 0
r r
r r
p p 20 20
p p 20 20
30 30 :10 :10
9.1.91. 9.1.91. 8.1.94 8.1.94
Stcfj Stcfj Tysfj/Hcllcmofj Tysfj/Hcllcmofj
-----· -----·
Lcngde{cm) Lcngde{cm) Alder{ar) Alder{ar)
20 20 22 22 24 24 20 20 20 20 30 30 ::12 ::12 34 34 :JO :JO 4 4 3D 3D 2 2 n n lO lO 0 0
10 10
t t t t
n n n n
c c c c
s s
10 10 s s 20 20
0 0 0 0
r r r r
p p p p
30 30
20~------~ 20~------~ 40 40
6.12.93 6.12.93 Tysfj/Indrc Tysfj/Indrc
1994. 1994.
January January
16 16
-
11 11
period period
the the
in in
Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden
of of
part part
inner inner
and and
right) right)
(upper (upper
middle middle
left), left),
(upper (upper
outer outer
the the
from from
herring herring of of 3a 3a Fig. Fig.
distributions distributions Length Length
Alcler(;ir) Alcler(;ir)
10 10 0 0
0 0 4 4 :Z :Z
JO JO 30 30
0 0 rrr-r-rr-
JO JO
l l
l l
n n
10 10 n n c c 20 20
c c s s
s s
0 0
0 0 r r -30 -30
r r
p p
p p 20 20
40 40
DO DO
30 30
16.1.94-
Ofotfjordcn/Narvik Ofotfjordcn/Narvik
Alclcr(ar) Alclcr(ar)
Lcngclc(cm) Lcngclc(cm)
Alclc•·(ar) Alclc•·(ar)
12 12 Lcngclc(cm) Lcngclc(cm)
. . 10 10
0 0
0 0
:z :z
4 4
:JO :JO
:JO :JO
34 34
:J:Z :J:Z
:10 :10
20 20
20 20
24 24
:ZZ :ZZ
:tO :tO
0 0
I I
12+ 12+
10 10
0 0
0 0
.. ..
2 2
-10 -10 I·""."' I·""."'
an an I I I I ao ao
1\ 1\ a-1 a-1 I I I I a:z a:z
30 30
:zn :zn :za :za 2-1 2-1 22 22 :zo :zo .,-J-rr-filllliilli .,-J-rr-filllliilli
0 0 ,-,-,-,-,,..r-;-
10 10
10 10 l l
l l
n n
. l l .
l l
n n
n n c c
n n
c c
c c s s
c c 20 20
s s
s s 20 20
0 0
JO JO
S S 0 0
0 0 r r
0 0
r r
r r
p p r r
p p
p p
30 30 p p
30 30
40 40
40 40
20~------r 20~------r
20 20
11.1.9'1-
11.1.f:H 11.1.f:H
Ofotfjordcn/Liland Ofotfjordcn/Liland
nJy nJy a a D D n/ n/ d c c d or or j j o o tf tf f f 0 0
December December 1993, 1993, 10 10 and and 16 16 January January 1994. 1994.
inner inner part part of of the the wintering wintering area area (at (at Narvik) Narvik) from from 1 1
Fig. Fig. 3b 3b Changes Changes
in in length length distribution distribution of of herring herring ·from ·from the the
Lengdc(cm} Lengdc(cm} Aldcr(ar} Aldcr(ar}
o o
z• z• 1 1 :Jo :Jo 20 20 :J:.: :J:.: 22 22
ao ao
20 20 an an
20 20 :H :H
z z 4 4 0 0 0 0 10 10
I I
,_ ,_ 10 10
t t
t. t.
n n 10 10
n n
. . 20 20 c c c c
s s
s s
0 0
0 0
r r
r r :10 :10
p p
20 20
p p
40 40
30 30 50 50
16.1.94· 16.1.94·
Lcngde(cm) Lcngde(cm) Alder(ar} Alder(ar}
Lcngdc(cm} Lcngdc(cm}
ao ao 20 20 az az 22 22
ao ao 20 20 ao ao 20 20 z~ z~ a~ a~ o o 2 2 G G ~ ~ 10 10
10 10 20 20 22 22 24 24 I I 26 26 20 20 JO JO 32 32 34 34 JG JG :JO :JO
10 10
l l
t t
n n L L 10 10 • •
n n
n n
20 20
c c c c
c c
s s s s
s s
0 0
0 0
0 0
r r :JO :JO r r
r r
p p
20 20
p p
p p
40 40
20~------30~------r 30~------r 50 50
1.12.93 1.12.93 1 1 0.1.94· 0.1.94· Narvik;Sk. Vestfjorden Bar121y JOmen
100 j I ) Night I ==J , E 2oo ~ t t l 1' ) Day ..c I ~~-=j I 6. 300 Q) ··o 400
f...., ~...... 500 I ~ A
Vestfjorden Bar121y Narv i k; s kj omen
1 00 Night ...... E 200 ..c. 4-l Day
Q)0. 300 0 400 -
· :SOD B
Vestfjorden Bare;y Na rv i k1 s kj omen
Night 100 __ ..._ ____.t t _ ...... Day E I_---- __ j 200 ..c. 4-l 0. 300 < -.v If' Q) 0 c 400
500 c
c-=-=-=-J Young and immature herring Adult herr~ng
Fig. 4 Schematic presentation of immigration and emigration in relation to the wintering area. See text for explanation.
/, /,
Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden and and Tysfjorden Tysfjorden in in tracks tracks Fig. Fig. 5 5 Survey Survey
~§::.·---"~~~= ~§::.·---"~~~=
I-- I--
1 1 ...... -
------
=:.=.:::::-- ~ ~ -----
--
__ __ ......
TYSfJC)ftD[H TYSfJC)ftD[H Of'OTr Of'OTr ..oiiiXH ..oiiiXH 01 01
no:cu no:cu :D:l.I"Y :D:l.I"Y lU':7 lU':7
...... _ _
denote denote different different strata strata (Table (Table 1) 1)
Commercial Commercial catch catch (purse (purse seine) seine) . . Encircled Encircled letters letters
December December 1993. 1993. F= F= Reseach Reseach vessel vessel (trawl), (trawl), K= K=
spawning spawning herring herring in in the the wintering wintering areas, areas, October
Location Location
of of biological biological samples samples of of Norwegian Norwegian Fig. Fig. spring spring 6a 6a
16°00' 16°00' 17°00' 17°00'
6lo' 6lo'
TYSFJORD TYSFJORD 68~0' 68~0' _68°30'
\D
TYSFJORD
68°0 I .,,
16°00' 17"o0'
Fig. 6b Location of biological samples of Norwegian spring spawning herring in the wintering areas, January 1994. F=Research vessel (trawl), K=Commercial catch (purse seine) . Encirled letters denote different strata (Table 1).
situation. situation.
Night-time Night-time
area. area.
wintering wintering
the the in in
herring herring of of
distribution distribution
angle angle Tilt Tilt
7b 7b Fig. Fig.
-90° -90°
5 5
oo oo N=1484 N=1484
90° 90°
situation. situation.
Daytime Daytime
area. area.
wintering wintering
the the in in
herring herring of of
distribution distribution
angle angle
Tilt Tilt 7a 7a Fig. Fig.
-90° -90°
~30 ~30
oo oo N=800 N=800 90° 90°
1.2-1994. 1.2-1994. to to 1.9-1993 1.9-1993 period period the the in in area area wintering wintering
the the in in herring herring of of content content fat fat in in 8 8 Fig. Fig. Variation Variation
1.2.94 1.2.94 94 94 1.1. 1.1. 93 93 1.12. 1.12. 93 93 1.11. 1.11. 93 93 1.10. 1.10. 93 93 1.9. 1.9.
~----~--~--~~h ~----~--~--~~h
5 5
10 10 Q Q
t_ t_
a a
V) V)
Cl.J Cl.J
c:: c:: ~ ~
~ ~
15 15
~ ~
20 20 25 25 68°30'N
68°
16° 17° 18°
Fig. 9 Hydrographical stations worked from R/V "Michael Sars" during the November/December 1993 survey.
conditions. conditions. oxygen oxygen and and salinity salinity temperature, temperature,
10 10 Fig. Fig. showing showing Ofotfjorden Ofotfjorden entire entire the the along along Section Section
500 500
,1:00 ,1:00
300 300 ~ ~
~ ~
p.. p..
E-< E-< ::r: ::r:
5 5
200 200 -. -.
100 100
0 0
~ ~
~ ~
p.. p..
E-< E-<
::r: ::r:
~ ~
~ ~
p.. p..
E-< E-<
::r: ::r:
.•. .•. 1160 1160 0
100
z ·200
I I Q_w 0 300
·400
·500 0 2 4 6 8 10 OXYGEN
Fig. 11 Echo recordings of two herring layers, with corresponding oxygen profile.