Seoul National University
High Entropy Alloy
- Traditional alloy
- High entropy alloy
Minor element 3
Major element …
Major element 3
Minor element 2
Major element 1
Major element
Major element 2
Minor element 1
풏ꢇꢈꢉꢊꢋ 풐ꢌ ꢊ풆ꢊꢈꢊ풏ꢍꢎ ↑ ↔ 풄풐풏ꢌꢏꢐꢇꢋꢑꢍꢏ풐풏ꢑ풆 ꢊ풏ꢍꢋ풐ꢒꢓ ↑
∆푆푐ꢀꢁꢂꢃꢄ. = 푅ꢅꢆ(ꢆ)
Y.Zhang et al., Prog.Mat.Sci. 61, 1 (2014)
- (1) Thermodynamic : high entropy
- (3) Kinetics : sluggish diffusion
(2) Structure : severe lattice distortion (4) Property : cocktail effect
High entropy alloy
: Potential candidate material for extreme environment applications
Seoul National University
Mechanical properties of HEA
. Ashby map
Bernd Gludovatz / SCIENCE VOL 345 ISSUE 6201
There are clearly stronger materials, which is understandable given that CrMnFeCoNi is a single-phase material,
but the toughness of this high-entropy alloy exceeds that of virtually all pure metals and metallic alloys.
Seoul National University
Fracture toughness of HEA
Bernd Gludovatz / SCIENCE VOL 345 ISSUE 6201
Although the toughness of the other materials decreases with decreasing temperature, the toughness of the highentropy alloy remains unchanged.
mechanical properties actually improve at cryogenic temperatures
Seoul National University
Fracture Toughness Testing
Compact tension test & Three point bending test
Pre-cracking
Limitation
Destructive
Fracturing
Complex testing procedure Cannot apply to in-service
Development of testing method to measure the fracture
properties more easily and more economically
Seoul National University
Indentation Fracture Toughness
. Instrumented Indentation Technique (IIT)
In-situ & In-field System, Non-destructive & Local test, Simple & fast
. Indentation Cracking Method (cracking in indentation)
1
2
- E
- P
K = α
IC
3
2
H
c
Only for ceramic materials
(very brittle)
[Vickers indenter, Macroscale]
Seoul National University
Indentation Fracture Toughness
. In case of metallic materials (no cracking in indentation)
- IIT
- Fracture test
Indenter
- No crack and no fracture
- Crack propagation and fracture
. How to correlate flat punch indentation with crack tip behavior
Virtual crack
isotropic
Seoul National University
How to correlate flat punch indentation with crack tip behavior
- Contact mechanics
- Fracture mechanics
- of flat punch indentation
- of cracked round bar specimen
Direct calculation of J from indentation curve
Determination of Fracture toughness
Flat punch: regarded as a very deep cracked round bar specimen
Seoul National University
How to correlate flat punch indentation with crack tip behavior
* Size effect
- * Load-depth curve
- * Normalization
* Crack initiation point
J. H. Giovanola et al., ASTM STP 1244 (1995)
In flat-punch indentation test
Seoul National University
How to correlate flat punch indentation with crack tip behavior
* Load criterion
* Depth criterion
* Evaluation
푷
푲푰 =
ퟐꢑ 흅ꢑ
(ퟏ − 흂ퟐ)푲ퟐ푰
푨ꢒ풆
흅ꢑퟐ
푱 = 푱ꢊ + 푱ꢒ =
+ 휼ꢒ풆
푬
Seoul National University
Fracture toughness of cantor alloy
Reference alloy : Cantor alloy – Cr20Mn20Fe20Co20Ni20
Bernd Gludovatz / SCIENCE VOL 345 ISSUE 6201
Process : Arc melting, copper mold drop casting, cold forging and cross rolling at RT, recrystallization
- KjIc
- Ave. (Mpa·m1/2
~217
- )
- Grain size (μm)
Cantor @293K
Cantor @200K Cantor3 @77K
~ 6
~ 6 ~ 6
~221 ~219
Seoul National University
Fracture toughness of cantor alloy
Reference alloy : CrCoNi
Bernd Gludovatz/ NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 7:10602 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms10602 |
Process : Arc melting, copper mold drop casting, cold forging and cross rolling at RT, recrystallization
- KjIc
- Ave. (Mpa·m1/2
~205
- )
- Grain size (μm)
@293K
@200K
@77K
~ 5
~ 5 ~ 5
~265 ~273
Seoul National University
XRD data of cantor alloy
Cantor1 (As-cast) Cantor2 (24h homogenization) Cantor3 (After recrystallization)
- 20
- 30
- 40
- 50
- 60
- 70
- 80
2 theta (deg.)
XRD data shows that all specimen have FCC crystal structure
Seoul National University
Microstructure of Cantor alloy
Cantor 1
(as-cast)
Cantor 2
(24h homogenization)
Cantor 3
( + cold rolling + recrystallization)
Dendritic growth
Annealing twin
100μm
100μm
5μm
Grain size : ~ 97 μm
- ~ 107 μm
- ~ 4 μm
Seoul National University
Indentation test for toughness of cantor alloy
. Test condition
Loading rate : 0.3mm/min, Depth control : 100um, Zero index : 0.1kgf
. Normalized curve
- Cantor 2
- Cantor 3
Cantor 1
2500 2000 1500 1000
500
2500 2000 1500 1000
500
2500 2000 1500 1000
500
Cantor 1
- Cantor 2
- Cantor 3
0
0.0
0
0.0
0
0.0
- 0.1
- 0.2
- 0.3
- 0.4
- 0.1
- 0.2
- 0.3
- 0.4
- 0.1
- 0.2
- 0.3
- 0.4
h/a
- h/a
- h/a
Seoul National University
Result of indentation test
This work Ref
260 240
245 217
220 200
217
Mpa·m1/2
200
180
0
Cantor3
Cantor2
Cantor1
- Ave.
- Grain size
- Kjc
- Test 1
- Test 2
- Test 3
- Test 4
(Mpa·m1/2
217
- )
- (μm)
Ref.
- -
- -
- -
- -
~ 6
~ 97
~ 107
~ 4
Cantor1 Cantor2 Cantor3
229.913 195.559 230.931
225.478 203.835 241.726
204.192 198.548 254.396
208.74
203.291 252.385
217.0808 200.3083 244.8595
Ref. and cantor3 which are similar processing condition show 12% deviation
Seoul National University
Strength of Ni-Fe-Cr systems
H.S.Oh / ph.D graduation paper
1100 1000
900 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100
0
V36.8Ni63.2
Ni Fe Cr (at%)
40 30 30
add V5 add V10
1200 1000
800 600 400 200
0
~8.3 μm
CrCoNi (Acta Mater., 2017)
CrMnFeCoNi (Science, 2014)
~6.5 μm
~6 μm
avg. grain size : 5.75
μm
(111)
V5
(311)
(220)
(200)
FCC phase
10
1.00 1.25 1.50 1.75 2.00 2.25 d-spacing (A)
- 0
- 5
- 15
- 20
- 25
- 30
- 35
- 40
- 45
- 50
- 0
- 10
- 20
- 30
- 40
- 50
- 60
strain (%)
Engineering strain (%)
- at%
- Y.S (MPa)
- U.T.S (MPa)
- Elongation (%)
- Grain size (μm)
Cantor CoCrNi
NiV
331.96
452.9
693.49 927.36
1174.05
736.8
41.3
45.21 44.53
28.3
~ 6
~ 6.5 ~ 8.3
~ 3.65
743.49
470.2
Ni40Fe30Cr30
Ni40Fe30Cr25V5 Ni40Fe30Cr20V10
476.4 682.7
785.7 954.7
28.6 19.4
~ 4.18 ~ 5.75
Seoul National University
Heat treatment of specimen
1
2
3
- Heat treatment
- Phase
- Grain size (μm)
1
234
Ni40Fe30Cr30 _1 Ni40Fe30Cr30 _3
- FCC
- -
As-cast
homogenization + Cold rolling + Recrystallization
FCC FCC FCC
~ 3.7
-
Ni40Fe30Cr20+V10 _1 Ni40Fe30Cr20+V10 _3
As-cast homogenization + Cold rolling + Recrystallization
~ 4
Seoul National University
Fracture toughness and tensile property
- . Yield Strength vs Fracture toughness
- . Ductility vs Fracture toughness
800
50 40 30 20 10
V36.8Ni63.2
700
Ni40Fe30Cr20V10
CoCrNi
V36.8Ni63.2
600
Cantor
500
Ni40Fe30Cr25V5
CoCrNi
Ni40Fe30Cr25V5
Ni40Fe30Cr30
Ni40Fe30Cr30
400
Ni40Fe30Cr20V10
Cantor
300
- 200
- 250
- 300
- 350
- 400
- 250
- 300
- 350
- 400
Fracture toughness
Fracture toughness
Fracture toughness through IIT yield strength에 의한 영향이 더 큰 것으로 보임.
Grain size effect on fracture toughness
260
This work
250 240 230 220 210 200 190
- 0.0
- 0.1
- 0.2
- 0.3
1 / Grain size(um)
Grain size 가 작아질 수록 Fracture toughness 가 증가하는 것으로 보임.