Expert Found Liable for Opinion on Fake Max Ernst Painting Peter Bert Posted on May 28, 2013

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Expert Found Liable for Opinion on Fake Max Ernst Painting Peter Bert Posted on May 28, 2013 AUTHENTICATION IN ART Art News Service Art Law: Expert Found Liable For Opinion On Fake Max Ernst Painting Peter Bert Posted on May 28, 2013 Le Monde reported yesterday that art historian and former Centre George Pompidou director Werner Spies had been ordered to pay damages in the order of EUR 650,000 to the purchaser of a painting. Tremblement de terre purportedly was a work of Max Ernst. Spies, a world-leading expert on Max Ernst and Pablo Picasso, had, according to the Tribunal de grande instance de Nanterre, authenticated the painting and delivered an expert opinion on which the purchaser had relied. Tremblement de terre, however, turned out to be fake. It had been produced by Wolfgang Beltracchi, the man at the centre of Germany’s biggest art scandal for decades. The Economist, in an article at the end of last year, concluded that “fear of litigation is hobbling the art market“. The Economist looked at the reactions of various foundations and authentication boards to the rising litigation risk, with most of the examples being drawn from the United States. There, the Andy Warhol Foundation dissolved its authentication board as a result of enormous legal costs incurred in defending claims by collectors. The Keith Haring Foundation stopped authenticating works, as did the Roy Lichtenstein Foundation. This new French judgment and a similar judgment by the District Court (Landgericht) Cologne of September 2012 which held auction house Lempertz liable over a fake Heinrich Campendonk painting, also by Beltracchi, appear to indicate that in Europe, in the wake of the Beltracchi scandal, the legal risks to experts and auction houses are also increasing. www.authenticationinart.org .
Recommended publications
  • Dark Side of the Boom
    dark side of the boom The Excesses of the Art Market in the Twenty-first Century Georgina Adam dark side of the boom First published in 2017 by Lund Humphries Office 3, 261a City Road London ec1v 1jx UK www.lundhumphries.com Copyright © 2017 Georgina Adam isbn Paperback: 978-1-84822-220-5 isbn eBook (PDF): 978-1-84822-221-2 isbn eBook (ePUB): 978-1-84822-222-9 isbn eBook (ePUB Mobi): 978-1-84822-223-6 A Cataloguing-in-Publication record for this book is available from the British Library. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electrical, mechanical or otherwise, without first seeking the permission of the copyright owners and publishers. Every effort has been made to seek permission to reproduce the images in this book. Any omissions are entirely unintentional, and details should be addressed to the publishers. Georgina Adam has asserted her right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the Author of this Work. Designed by Crow Books Printed and bound in Slovenia Cover: artwork entitled $ made from reflector caps, lamps and an electronic sequencer, by Tim Noble and Sue Webster and One Dollar Bills, 1962 and Two Dollar Bills by Andy Warhol, hang on a wall at Sotheby’s in London on June 8, 2015. Photo: Adrian Dennis/AFP/Getty Images. For Amelia, Audrey, Isabella, Matthew, Aaron and Lucy Contents Introduction 9 Prologue: Le Freeport, Luxembourg 17 PART I: Sustaining the Big Bucks market 25 1 Supply 27 2 Demand: China Wakes 51 Part II: A Fortune on your Wall? 69 3 What’s the Price? 71 4 The Problems with Authentication 89 5 A Tsunami of Forgery 107 Part IiI: Money, Money, Money 127 6 Investment 129 7 Speculation 149 8 The Dark Side 165 Postscript 193 Appendix 197 Notes 199 Bibliography 223 Index 225 introduction When my first book, Big Bucks, the Explosion of the Art Market in the 21st Century, was published in 2014 the art market was riding high.
    [Show full text]
  • FOE Issue Special May-16.Indd
    FAMILY OFFICE ELITE SPECIAL EDITION BNY Mellon Cory McCruden FAMILY OFFICES - UHNWI - WEALTH - PHILANTHROPY- FINE ART - LUXURY - LIFESTYLE Subscription $100 per year www.familyoffi ceelite.com DOMOS FINE ART FINE ART DOMOS CONSULTANTS DOMOS FINE ART has a portfolio of very Fine Art on sale (Off Market) on behalf of our clients which include works by Caravaggio, Renoir, Monet, Van Gogh, Matisse, Rembrandt, Picasso, Rouault, Bonnard, Raphael and more. DOMOS FINE ART is experienced in dealing We off er the following services with rare off -market Valuation and Sale of Fine Art collections of fi ne art. Locate specifi c pieces of Fine Art Assist in verifying provenance of Art Auction representation UK Offi ce | TEL: + 44 (0) 29 2125 1994 | SKYPE: domosfi neart | [email protected] | www.domos.co.uk FAMILY OFFICEELITE MAGAZINE WHAT IS A FINE ART FAMILY OFFICE US CONGRESS INVESTING ENACT NEW TAX FOR FAMILY OFFICES EXAMINATION 03CAPLIN & DRYSDALE 37 ROLLS ROYCE BERNIE MADOFF BLACK BADGE THE INSIDE STORY ON 25 EXPOSING MADOFF FRANK CASEY 11 43 VIDEO ADVERTS MAYBACH THE FUTURE OF ADVERTISING SESURITY & PROTECTION WITH THE 600 GUARD 17 53 IMPACT INVESTING FAMILY OFFICE IN THE FAMILY OFFICE MULTI-FAMILY OFFICE SELECTION HOLLAND & HOLLAND 21 EXPLORE THE WORLD OF 57 ANTIQUE WEAPONS AFRICA THE SAFRA OPPORTUNITIES FOR FOUNDATION FAMILY OFFICES SAFRA FOUNDATION MAKES ING BANK DONATION TO CLINATEC 25 35 61 1 FAMILY OFFICE ELITE MAGAZINE GULF STREAM 63 100TH G-560 COREY McCRUDEN Cory McCruden BNY Mellon HADHUNTERS 71 Wealth Management, Advisory Services PROPER EXECUTIVE PLACEMENT SUPERYACHT 73 CHARTER - LUXURY VACATION FAMILY OFFICE 7 WHAT TO DO WITH CASH 77 MAN-VS-MACHINE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT 79 PRIVATE BANKS 83 WITH AN INVESTMENT FLOVOUR AUTHENTICITY IN THE ART MARKET 95 IMPACT AND 101 PHILANTHROPY OTHER STORIES..
    [Show full text]
  • A Moral Persuasion: the Nazi-Looted Art Recoveries of the Max Stern Art Restitution Project, 2002-2013
    A MORAL PERSUASION: THE NAZI-LOOTED ART RECOVERIES OF THE MAX STERN ART RESTITUTION PROJECT, 2002-2013 by Sara J. Angel A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of PhD Graduate Department Art University of Toronto © Copyright by Sara J. Angel 2017 PhD Abstract A Moral Persuasion: The Nazi-Looted Art Recoveries of the Max Stern Art Restitution Project, 2002-2013 Sara J. Angel Department of Art University of Toronto Year of convocation: 2017 In 1937, under Gestapo orders, the Nazis forced the Düsseldorf-born Jewish art dealer Max Stern to sell over 200 of his family’s paintings at Lempertz, a Cologne-based auction house. Stern kept this fact a secret for the rest of his life despite escaping from Europe to Montreal, Canada, where he settled and became one of the country’s leading art dealers by the mid-twentieth century. A decade after Stern’s death in 1987, his heirs (McGill University, Concordia University, and The Hebrew University of Jerusalem) discovered the details of what he had lost, and how in the post-war years Stern travelled to Germany in an attempt to reclaim his art. To honour the memory of Max Stern, they founded the Montreal- based Max Stern Art Restitution Project in 2002, dedicated to regaining ownership of his art and to the study of Holocaust-era plunder and recovery. This dissertation presents the histories and circumstances of the first twelve paintings claimed by the organization in the context of the broader history of Nazi-looted art between 1933-2012. Organized into thematic chapters, the dissertation documents how, by following a carefully devised approach of moral persuasion that combines practices like publicity, provenance studies, law enforcement, and legal precedents, the Max Stern Art Restitution Project set international precedents in the return of cultural property.
    [Show full text]
  • «Beauty Is the True Scandal in Today's Art»
    6/28/2018 "Beauty is the true scandal in today's art" | NZZ INTERVIEW «Beauty is the true scandal in today's art» Wolfgang Beltracchi has made a career as an art forger and was convicted. Now he leads a second life as an artist with his own handwriting. He keeps little of the genius cult - as well as of the international art scene, which celebrates the ugly above all. In a big interview he disenchanted the myths of the art business. René Scheu 26.6.2018, 05:30 clock Mr. Beltracchi, when you perform or exhibit, people come in droves. Then fall reliably the predicates "master counterfeiters" or "century counterfeiters". What sound do these words have for you? Oh. Hm. "Master" is not bad. (Consider.) Look: I see myself as a master painter, that's how I really understand myself, as a master of my craft. I have, I believe, sufficiently proven that I master the subject. ADVERTISING inRead invented by Teads Alone, art is more than painting – or has the 20th century not taken place in your eyes? https://www.nzz.ch/feuilleton/schoenheit-ist-in-der-heutigen-kunst-das-wahre-skandalon-ld.1397738 1/15 6/28/2018 "Beauty is the true scandal in today's art" | NZZ Yes, yes, something has already happened. And art history is also one of my hobbyhorses. Only, I'm not one of those who think that art has to be ugly and repulsive so that it turns out to be art. That would mean that fine art is not art.
    [Show full text]
  • Open Windows 10
    Leticia de Cos Martín Martín Cos de Leticia Beckmann Beckmann Frau than Quappi, much more more much Quappi, pages 47 — 64 47 — 64 pages Clara Marcellán Marcellán Clara in California in California Kandinsky and Klee Klee and Kandinsky of Feininger, Jawlensky, Jawlensky, of Feininger, and the promotion promotion the and Galka Scheyer Galka Scheyer ‘The Blue Four’: Four’: Blue ‘The pages 34 — 46 34 — 46 pages Manzanares Manzanares Juan Ángel Lpez- Ángel Juan ~' of modern art as a collector as a collector Bornemisza’s beginnings beginnings Bornemisza’s - ~~.·;•\ Thyssen Baron On ~ .. ;,~I il~ ' r• , ~.~ ··v,,,:~ ' . -1'\~J"JJj'-': . ·'-. ·•\.·~-~ . 13 — 33 pages Nadine Engel Engel Nadine Expressionist Collection Collection Expressionist Thyssen-Bornemisza’s German German Thyssen-Bornemisza’s Beginning of Hans Heinrich Heinrich Hans of Beginning 1, 1 ~- .,.... Museum Folkwang and the the and Folkwang Museum ,..~I,.. '' i·, '' ·' ' ' .·1,.~.... Resonance Chamber. Chamber. Resonance . ~I•.,Ji'•~-., ~. pages 2 — 12 2 — 12 pages ~ -~~- . ., ,.d' .. Ali. .~ .. December 2020 2020 December 10 10 Open Windows Windows Open Open Windows 10 Resonance Chamber. Museum Folkwang and the Beginning of Hans Heinrich Thyssen-Bornemisza’s German Expressionist Collection Nadine Engel Emil Nolde Young Couple, c. 1931–35 22 HollandischerDirektor bracht ✓ Thyssen-Schatzenach Essen Elnen kaum zu bezifiernden Wert bat elne Ausslellung des Folkwang-Museums, die btszum 20. Marz gezelgt wird: sie ent­ hiilt hundertzehn Melsterwerke der europaisdlen Malerei des 14. bis 18. Jahrhunderts aus der beriihmten Sammlung Sdtlo8 Roboncz, die heute Im Besitz des nodt Jungen Barons H. H. Thys­ sen-Bornemisza ist und in der Villa Favorlta bei Lugano ihr r Domlzil hat. Insgesamt mnfafll sie 350 Arbeiten.
    [Show full text]
  • Robert Lehman Papers
    Robert Lehman papers Finding aid prepared by Larry Weimer The Robert Lehman Collection Archival Project was generously funded by the Robert Lehman Foundation, Inc. This finding aid was generated using Archivists' Toolkit on September 24, 2014 Robert Lehman Collection The Metropolitan Museum of Art 1000 Fifth Avenue New York, NY, 10028 [email protected] Robert Lehman papers Table of Contents Summary Information .......................................................................................................3 Biographical/Historical note................................................................................................4 Scope and Contents note...................................................................................................34 Arrangement note.............................................................................................................. 36 Administrative Information ............................................................................................ 37 Related Materials ............................................................................................................ 39 Controlled Access Headings............................................................................................. 41 Bibliography...................................................................................................................... 40 Collection Inventory..........................................................................................................43 Series I. General
    [Show full text]
  • It Requires Enthusiasm to Sell Art – on Either Side Invitation to Consign 2018 Preface 1
    IT REQUIRES ENTHUSIASM TO SELL ART – ON EITHER SIDE INVITATION TO CONSIGN 2018 PREFACE 1 DEAR FRIENDS, It has been more than twenty years since my father Wolfgang Ketterer entrusted me with the business he had formed with all his heart and soul. I am grateful for both his confidence, as well as for yours, because trust is the essence of any relationship. I just want to say thank you for the honor of leading such a wonderful company and for your active support with this task. Thank you for an exceptionally successful year 2017! Even though Ketterer Kunst is a medium-sized business and not one of the biggest auction houses, we once again reached a spot in the top ten ranking of European art auctioneers in 2017 (read more on page 2). In addition to our qualifications and our highly specialized staff, this success is surely owed to the fact that we do our job with a lot of joy and enthusiasm. Art always has and always will be our passion. We pay the same close attention to every single artwork and every single client. Buyers and sellers have been benefiting from our global orientation for many years. We closely cooperate with numerous national and international collectors, curators and museums. However, the master key to our success is, as I have already mentioned, mutual trust. It takes a lot of courage, but it is the basis of every good relationship. In this context it is so wonderful to see how much confidence our clients have in our expertise – especially when it comes to pricing – as our pricing policy is one of the core elements of a successful auction.
    [Show full text]
  • The Art Market in 2020 04 EDITORIAL by THIERRY EHRMANN
    The Art Market in 2020 04 EDITORIAL BY THIERRY EHRMANN 05 EDITORIAL BY WAN JIE 07 GEOGRAPHICAL BREAKDOWN OF THE ART MARKET 15 WHAT’S CHANGING? 19 ART BEST SUITED TO DISTANCE SELLING 29 WHO WAS IN DEMAND IN 2020? AND WHO WASN’T? 34 2020 - THE YEAR IN REVIEW 46 TOP 500 ARTISTS BY FINE ART AUCTION REVENUE IN 2020 Methodology The Art Market analysis presented in this report is based on results of Fine Art auctions that oc- cured between 1st January and 31st December 2020, listed by Artprice and Artron. For the purposes of this report, Fine Art means paintings, sculptures, drawings, photographs, prints, videos, installa- tions, tapestries, but excludes antiques, anonymous cultural goods and furniture. All the prices in this report indicate auction results – including buyer’s premium. Millions are abbreviated to “m”, and billions to “bn”. The $ sign refers to the US dollar and the ¥ sign refers to the Chinese yuan. The exchange rate used to convert AMMA sales results in China is an average annual rate. Any reference to “Western Art” or “the West” refers to the global art market, minus China. Regarding the Western Art market, the following historical segmentation of “creative period” has been used: • “Old Masters” refers to works by artists born before 1760. • “19th century” refers to works by artists born between 1760 and 1860. • “Modern art” refers to works by artists born between 1860 and 1920. • “Post-war art” refers to works by artists born between 1920 and 1945. • “Contemporary art” refers to works by artists born after 1945.
    [Show full text]
  • Faking, Forging, Counterfeiting
    Daniel Becker, Annalisa Fischer, Yola Schmitz (eds.) Faking, Forging, Counterfeiting Daniel Becker, Annalisa Fischer, Yola Schmitz (eds.) in collaboration with Simone Niehoff and Florencia Sannders Faking, Forging, Counterfeiting Discredited Practices at the Margins of Mimesis Funded by the Elite Network of Bavaria as part of the International Doctoral Program MIMESIS. An electronic version of this book is freely available, thanks to the support of libraries working with Knowledge Unlatched. KU is a collaborative initiative designed to make high quality books Open Access for the public good. The Open Access ISBN for this book is 978-3-8394-3762-9. More information about the initiative and links to the Open Access version can be found at www.knowledgeunlatched.org. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommer- cial-NoDerivs 4.0 (BY-NC-ND) which means that the text may be used for non- commercial purposes, provided credit is given to the author. For details go to http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/. To create an adaptation, translation, or derivative of the original work and for commercial use, further permission is required and can be obtained by contac- ting [email protected] © 2018 transcript Verlag, Bielefeld Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Na- tionalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available in the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de Cover concept: Maria Arndt, Bielefeld
    [Show full text]
  • Beltracchi - Die Kunst
    Präsentiert BELTRACCHI - DIE KUNST DER FÄLSCHUNG Ein Film von Arne Birkenstock Kinostart: 06. März 2014 PRESSEHEFT Beltracchi - Die Kunst der Fälschung 1 PRESSEBETREUUNG: Panorama Entertainment Senator Film Verleih GmbH Amélie Linder Antje Pankow (Leitung Publicity) Elena Schäfer Thalkirchner Straße 45 Schönhauser Allee 53 80469 München 10437 Berlin Tel: 089 / 30 90 679 – 33 /34 Tel: 030 / 880 91 - 799 Fax: 089 / 30 90 679 -11 Fax: 030 / 880 91 - 703 E-Mail: [email protected], E-Mail: [email protected] [email protected] VERTRIEB: Central Film Verleih GmbH Keithstr. 2-4 10787 Berlin Tel: 030 / 214922-00 MATERIAL / INFORMATIONEN: Über unsere Homepage www.senator.de haben Sie die Möglichkeit, sich für die Presse-Lounge zu akkreditieren. Dort stehen Ihnen alle Pressematerialien, Fotos und viele weitere Informationen als Download zur Verfügung. EPK und APK werden nach vorheriger Anmeldung unter www.digital-epk.de zum Download bereitgestellt. Beltracchi - Die Kunst der Fälschung 2 INHALT STAB & MITWIRKENDE TECHNISCHE DATEN KURZINHALT & PRESSENOTIZ INHALT INTERVIEW MIT ARNE BIRKENSTOCK BIOGRAFIEN / STAB Arne Birkenstock Markus Winterbauer Katja Dringenberg Der Protagonist Wolfgang Beltracchi KLEINES LEXIKON EUROPÄISCHER KUNSTFÄLSCHER Beltracchi - Die Kunst der Fälschung 3 STAB Regie ARNE BIRKENSTOCK Produzenten ARNE BIRKENSTOCK THOMAS SPRINGER HELMUT G. WEBER Koproduzenten THOMAS WEYMAR HELGE SASSE Kamera MARCUS WINTERBAUER Montage KATJA DRINGENBERG Ton PATRICK VEIGEL LUDWIG BESTEHORN Mischung MALTE
    [Show full text]
  • Daxer & M Arschall 20 19 XXVI
    XXVI Daxer & Marschall 2019 Recent Acquisitions, Catalogue XXVI, 2019 Barer Strasse 44 | 80799 Munich | Germany Tel. +49 89 28 06 40 | Fax +49 89 28 17 57 | Mob. +49 172 890 86 40 [email protected] | www.daxermarschall.com 2 Oil Sketches, Paintings, Drawings and Sculpture, 1668-1917 4 My special thanks go to Simone Brenner and Diek Groenewald for their research and their work on the texts. I am also grateful to them for so expertly supervising the production of the catalogue. We are much indebted to all those whose scholarship and expertise have helped in the preparation of this catalogue. In particular, our thanks go to: Peter Axer, Iris Berndt, Robert Bryce, Christine Buley-Uribe, Sue Cubitt, Kilian Heck, Wouter Kloek, Philipp Mansmann, Verena Marschall, Werner Murrer, Otto Naumann, Peter Prange, Dorothea Preys, Eddy Schavemaker, Annegret Schmidt- Philipps, Ines Schwarzer, Gerd Spitzer, Andreas Stolzenburg, Jörg Trempler, Jana Vedra, Vanessa Voigt, Wolf Zech. 6 Our latest catalogue Oil Sketches, Paintings, Drawings and Sculpture, 2019 Unser diesjähriger Katalog Paintings, Oil Sketches, comes to you in good time for this year’s TEFAF, The European Fine Art Fair in Paintings, Drawings and Sculpture, 2019 erreicht Sie Maastricht. TEFAF is the international art market high point of the year. It runs rechtzeitig vor dem wichtigsten Kunstmarktereignis from March 16-24, 2019. des Jahres, TEFAF, The European Fine Art Fair, Maastricht, 16. - 24. März 2019, auf der wir mit Stand The Golden Age of seventeenth-century Dutch painting is well represented in 332 vertreten sind. our 2019 catalogue, with particularly fine works by Jan van Mieris and Jan Steen.
    [Show full text]
  • Greatest Fakers in the World | Counterfeit
    Worlds most famous fakes, Famous art forgers, famous fakes, famous fakers, Fake paintings, fake signatures, fake drawings, fake picasso, Worlds Greatest Forgers, Copyists & Fakers - Art Fraud, Art forgery- forgers, faking art - fake paintings, art crime, The world's most famous and greatest art forgers and fakers HOME PROFILE CONTACT The Fine Art of Faking The faces of the world's greatest art fakers forgers and fraudsters ART FRAUD AND FORGERY INFORMATION ARCHIVE FROM INTERNATIONAL ART AUTHENTICATION EXPERTS THE FREEMANART CONSULTANCY ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Arty-Fact: Art fraud and forgery dates back more than 2000 years. Arty-Fact: The Freemanart Consultancy who specialise soley in art authentication and art fraud investigations, see more FAKE Pablo Picasso drawings, prints watercolors and oil paintings than any other artists work. On average, about a dozen a week! All about the Worlds Greatest Forgers, Copyists & Fakers (Arranged here by time frame) The Romans. CONTENTS: The Romans. Assiduously copied Greek sculptures, many of which were sold believed to be originals by their purchasers. The Chinese. 14C Italian stone carvers. Jacopo di The Chinese generally! Poggibonsi'. Faking in China dates from at least the Sung Dynasty (960-1280) when the wealthy began to collect art. Forged paintings were Piero del Pollaiuolo. mostly made by students seeking to imitate the masters. It still seems a common practice! Michelangelo. Giovanni Cavino. Pirro Ligorio. 14th century, Italian stone carvers: Hendrik Goltzius. The stone carvers lead the way in commercially forgery, faking works of art by imitating Greek and Roman master craftsmen and Pieter Brueghel the creating sculptures which could and were to be sold to the rich as authentic antiques! Much the same tale as that of their Roman Younger.
    [Show full text]