Paul A. Roth

Distinguished Professor Department of Philosophy

University of California-Santa Cruz [email protected]

Mailing Address Cowell Academic Services University of California-Santa Cruz 1156 High Street Santa Cruz, CA 95064

EMPLOYMENT HISTORY

1978 - 1979 Visiting Assistant Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of Missouri, St. Louis 1979 - 1985 Assistant Professor, University of Missouri-St. Louis Jan - May 1986 Visiting Associate Professor, Department of Philosophy (one semester), Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri 1985 - 1990 Associate Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of Missouri, St. Louis 1995 - 1998 Director, Center for the Humanities, University of Missouri, St. Louis 1995 - 2001 Department Chair, Department of Philosophy, University of Missouri, St. Louis 1990 - 2004 Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of Missouri, St. Louis Jul 1 2004 Professor, Department of Philosophy, University of California, Santa Cruz Jul 1 2004 - Chair, Department of Philosophy, University of California, Santa Jun 30 2010 Cruz Jul 1 2015 Distinguished Professor, University of California, Santa Cruz

EDUCATION

1970 B.A., Wesleyan University, With Honors 1972 M.A., Social Science, University of Chicago 1978 Ph.D., Philosophy, University of Chicago

HONORS AND AWARDS

Fall 2017 Visiting International Scholar, University of Hradec Kralove, The Czech Republic %MCEPASTEBIN% 2010 Chosen to participate in the Candoc Colloquium in Villars, Switzerland. For details, see http://www.philosophie.ch/prodoc- romand/pr_single.php?action=edit&eventid=494 2010 October 29 - November 1 Mar - Jun 2009 Visiting Professor: Visiting Scholar at the University of Provence (Aix-Marseille I) 2003 Campus Research Award: Campus Research Award, Released time from teaching (Spring Semester) 1998 UM Research Board: UM Research Board leave for 1998-99 academic year 1997 1998 NEH Summer Institute: PI and Co-Director (with James Bohman, St. Louis University) NEH Institute: "The Idea of a Social Science--40 Years Later." 1991 Research Leave: Research Leave, University of Missouri-St. Louis (Fall Semester) 1989 NEH Seminar: NEH Seminar: 'Naturalistic Epistemology," (University of Hawaii-Manoa; Director: Larry Laudan) 1989 Summer Research Fellowship: Summer Research Fellowship, University of Missouri-St. Louis ($4,000) 1988 Rockefeller Residential Fellowship: Rockefeller Residential Fellowship, Center for the Humanities, Wesleyan University, (Fall Semester) 1988 NEH Interpretation Institute: NEH Institute: "Interpretation and the Human Sciences" (UC-Santa Cruz); Directors: H. Dreyfus and D. Hoy

1988 Chancellor’s Humanities Fund Award: Fellowship, University of Missouri-St. Louis 1987 NEH: NEH Summer Stipend 1987 Research Leave: Research Leave, University of Missouri-St. Louis (Winter Semester) 1986 NEH Institute: NEH Institute On Theory of Knowledge (University of Colorado; Directors: A. Goldman and K. Lehrer) 1985 Fellowship: Fellowship, Center for International Studies, University of Missouri-St. Louis (Course load reduction) 1984 Weldon Spring Humanities Seminar Fellowship: University of Missouri system-wide competitive fellowship, $5,000 1983 NEH Fellowship: NEH Fellowship For College Teachers (academic year) 1982 Research Fellowship: Research Fellowship, University of Missouri-St. Louis (Summer) 1978 NEH Summer Seminar: NEH Seminar: "Concepts of Scientific Explanation," (Johns Hopkins University; Director: Peter Achinstein)

GRANTS

Sep 2007 - Jun 2008 UCSC Institute for Humanities Research, Established RU in "Philosophy of Science in Practice" Grant used to support speaker series for that year. $2,000 2002 Principal Investigator, UMSL Grant from campus research board to fund travel and related costs to present paper at conferences in The Hague and in Paris. $1,000 2000 UMSLGrant from campus research board to fund travel and related costs to present paper at conference on philosophy of social science at Bristol University (UK) $1,000 1997 NEH, Summer Institute: "The Idea of a Social Science--40 Years Later" Co-organized and co-directed NEH Summer Institute. $200,000 1996 Board of the Institute for Instructional Development of the University of MissouriPrincipal Investigator on grant to support development of formal logic course on a CD $31,203 1994 Principal Investigator, UM Research Board Grant providing travel support to conference at Durham, UK and one semester of released time $2,500 1992 Principal Investigator, UMSL Grant to develop and teach computer-assisted course in formal logic $250 1990 Principal Investigator, American Council of Learned Societies Travel Grant (Travel to Madrid, Spain) $1,500 1984 Principal Investigator, Missouri Committee for the Humanities Grant for a symposium on Business Ethics $500 1980 Co-Principal Investigator, (with Stephanie Ross), grant for conference ("Matters of the Mind") at UM-St. Louis (published proceedings) $13,000 1980 UM-St. Louis Curriculum Development Grant $500

SCHOLARLY AND CREATIVE WORK

2018 "Reviving Analytical Philosophy of History" in Krzysztof Brzechczyn (ed.), Towards a Revival of Analytical Philosophy of History: Around Paul A. Roth’s Vision of Historical Sciences, Brill-Rodolpi (Series: Poznań Studies in the Philosophy of the Sciences and the Humanities, vol. 110), pp. 9-27. 2018 "Comments and Replies," in Krzysztof Brzechczyn (ed.), Towards a Revival of Analytical Philosophy of History: Around Paul A. Roth’s Vision of Historical Sciences, Brill-Rodolpi (Series: Poznań Studies in the Philosophy of the Sciences and the Humanities, vol. 110), pp. 273-286. 2018 "Undisciplined and Punished," History & Theory, 57:121-126. 2017 "Philosophy of History," in Routledge Companion to the Philosophy of Social Science, A. Rosenberg & L. McIntyre, eds. (New York: Routlege, 2017), Pp. 397-407. 2017 "Essentially Narrative Explanations," Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 62:42-50. 2017 "Translation and Understanding: What the Problems Are Not" Confluence: Journal of World Philosophies (Summer) 141-3. 2017 (With A. Stone) Review of Shearmur & Stokes, ed. Cambridge Companion to Popper, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, ~4000 words, 2016 "What Would It Be To Be A Norm?" in Normativity and Naturalism in the Philosophy of the Social Sciences, ed. Mark Risjord (New York: Routledge, 2016), pp. 43-59. 2016 "Back to the Future: Postnarrativist Historiography and Analytic Philosophy of History," History and Theory (2016) 55:270-81. 2016 "Analytic Philosophy of History: Origins, Eclipse, and Revival," Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal, 37:351-74. Review of Perspectives on Social Ontology and Social Cognition, eds. M. 2015 Gallotti and J. Michael (Springer 2014, 189 pp.), in Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews (February 15, 2015). Published on-line only. (~2500 words) 2015 Review of Retrieving Realism by Hubert Dreyfus and Charles Taylor, online at Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews (11/18/2015) 2014 "Hayden White in Philosophical Perspective: Review Essay of Herman Paul's Hayden White: The Historical Imagination," Philosophy of the Social Sciences (2014) 44:104-113. 2013 "History and the Manifest Image: Hayden White as a Philosophy of History" History and Theory (February 2013) 52:130-43. 2013 "Narrative in Historical Explanation," Encyclopedia of Philosophy and the Social Sciences, B. Kaldis, ed., Sage, pp. 643-644 2013 "Naturalized Epistemology," Encyclopedia of Philosophy and the Social Sciences, B. Kaldis, ed., Sage, 646-649. 2013 "The Silence of the Norms: The Missing Historiography of The Structure of Scientific Revolutions," Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 44 (2013), pp. 545-552. 2013 "Whistling History: Ankersmit's neo-Tractarian Theory of Historical Representation," Rethinking History (2013) 17:548-569. (2014) Discussed in Kuukkanen, "The current state of play in the theory and philosophy of history: the Roth-Ankersmit controversy and beyond," Rethinking History (October 2014), 18:613-19. 2012 "Searleworld: Review/Essay of John R. Searle, Making the Social World," History and Theory 51, 123-142. 2012 "The Pasts" History and Theory 51:313-339. (2012) Reprinted in The New Metaphysics of Time, ed. Ethan Kleinberg. On-line publication. 2011 "The Philosophy of Social Science in the Twentieth Century: Analytic Traditions: Reflections on the Rationalitästreit," Ian C. Jarvie and Jesús Zamora-Bonilla, The Sage Handbook of The Philosophy of Social Sciences, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage, 103-18 2011 "May Philosophy of History Be Useful for Historians? Interview with Prof. Paul A. Roth" (in Slovak), Kultúrne dejiny/Cultural History/Kulturgeschichte 2:1, 115-21 2011 "What Does History Matter to . . ." The Journal of the Philosophy of History 5, 1-7 2010 "Social Psychology and Genocide," D. Bloxham and D. Moses, Oxford Handbook of Genocide Studies, Oxford University Press, 198-216 2010 "Empiricism," Mark Bevir, ed., Encyclopedia of Political Theory, Sage, 424- 28 2010 "Explanation," Mark Bevir, ed., Encyclopedia of Political Theory, Sage, 478- 81 2009 November, Review of William Rehg, Cogent Science in Context: The Science Wars, Argumentation Theory, and Habermas, MIT Press, 2009, 345pp. (~2500 words), Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, (~2500 words) 2009 Review of Robert Piercey, The Uses of the Past From Heidegger to Rorty: Doing Philosophy Historically, Cambridge University Press 2009, 221 pp. (~2500 words), Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews 2009 "Quo Vadis: Quine's Web, Kuhn's Revolutions, and Baert's 'Way Out'" Human Studies 32, 357-63 2008 "Epistemology of Science after Quine," Martin Curd & Stathis Psillos, Routledge Companion to the Philosophy of Science, New York, Routledge, 3- 14 2008 "Varieties and Vagaries of Historical Explanation," Journal of the Philosophy of History 2, 214-226 Replies by Karsten Stueber, Stephen Turner, and John Zammito

2008 Review of J. Gorman, Historical Judgement (Acumen Publishing Ltd., 2007), Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, (~2500 words) 2008 February, "Three Dogmas (More or Less) of Explanation," History & Theory 47, 57-68 2007 "The Disappearance of the Empirical," Journal of the Philosophy of History 1, 271-292 2006 "Naturalism Without Fears," Stephen Turner & Mark Risjord, Handbook of the Philosophy of Science, Volume 15: Philosophy of Anthropology and Sociology, Elsevier, 683-708 2006 February, Review of C. Mantzavinos, Naturalistic Hermeneutics, Cambridge University Press, 2005, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, (~2500 words) 2005 September, "Three Grades of Normative Involvement: Risjord, Stueber, and Henderson on Norms and Explanation," Philosophy of the Social Science 35, 339-52 2004 August, (coauthored with Mark Peacock), "Holocaust Studies: What is to be Learned?," Paul A. Roth & Mark Peacock (guest editors), History of the Human Sciences 35, 1-13 2004 August, "Hearts of Darkness: 'Perpetrator History' and Why there is no Why," History of the Human Sciences 35, 211-51 2004 Summer, Review of F.G. Bailey: The Saving Lie: Truth and Method in the Social Sciences, Review of Politics 66, 46-48 2003 The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of the Social Sciences, Stephen P. Turner & Paul A. Roth, ed. (Electronic edition 2007; Chinese translation published 2009), Blackwell Publishing Ltd., 2003 (2003) Reviewed by Berel Dov Lerner, Philosophy in Review (December 2003) 23:412-414. 2003 "Mistakes," Synthese 136, 389-408 2003 "Fuller's '18th Brumaire of Thomas K'" Social Epistemology 17, 281-89 2003 (coauthored with Stephen Turner), "Ghosts and the Machine: Philosophy of Social Science in Contemporary Perspective," S. Turner & P. Roth, The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of the Social Sciences (Blackwell Publishing Ltd.) 1-17 2003 "Why There is Nothing Rather than Something: Quine on Behaviorism, Meaning, and Indeterminacy," D. Jacquette, Philosophy, Psychology, and Psychologism: Critical and Historical Readings on the Psychological Turn in Philosophy, Kluwer Academic, 263-287 2003 "Beyond Understanding," S. Turner & P. Roth, The Blackwell Guide to the Philosophy of the Social Sciences, Blackwell Publishing Ltd., 311-33 2003 "Feminism and Naturalism: If Asked for Theories, Just Say 'No'" L. Hankinson Nelson and J. Nelson, Feminist Interpretations of W.V. Quine, The Pennsylvania State University Press, 269-305 2003 Review of Hilary Kornblith, Knowledge and Its Place in Nature Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, (~3200 words) 2003 September, "Kitcher's Two Cultures: Review essay of Philip Kitcher's Science, Truth, and Democracy," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 33, 386- 405 2002 November, "Ways of Pastmaking," History of the Human Sciences 15, 125-43 2002 Fall, Review of Berel Lang, Holocaust Representation: Art Within the Limits of History and Ethics, Journal of Aesthetics & Art Criticism 60, 367-9 2002 Spring, Review of Steve Fuller, Thomas Kuhn: A Philosophical History for Our Time, Common Knowledge 8, 18-9 2000 "The Object of Understanding," K. Stueber & B. Kögler, Empathy and Agency, Westview, 243-269 1999 "The Epistemology of 'Epistemology Naturalized'" Dialectica 53, 87-109 1999 May, "The Full Hempel: Review essay of Clayton Roberts, The Logic of Historical Explanation," History & Theory 38, 249-63 1999 "Naturalizing Goldman," The Southern Journal of Philosophy 37, 89-109 1998 "The Cure of Stories: Self-Deception, Danger Situations, and the Clinical Role of Narratives in Roy Schafer's Psychoanalytic Theory," P. Marcus and A. Rosenberg, Psychoanalytic Versions of the Human Condition, NYU Press, 306-331 1996 "Dubious Liaison: Review essay of Alvin Goldman's Liaisons: Philosophy Meets the Cognitive and Social Sciences," Philosophical Psychology 9, 261- 79 1996 "Will the Real Scientists Please Stand Up? Dead Ends and Live Issues in the Explanation of Scientific Knowledge," Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 27, 43-68 1995 "Microfoundations Without Foundations: Comments on D. Little's, 'Causation in the Social Sciences'" The Southern Journal of Philosophy 34, 57-64 1995 (coauthored with Thomas Ryckman), "Chaos, Clio, and Scientific Illusions of Understanding," History & Theory 34, 30-44 1995 "Can Post-Newtonian Psychologists Find Happiness in a Pre-Paradigm Science?," Journal of Mind and Behavior 16, 87-97 1995 Review essay of Murray G. Murphey, The Foundations of Historical Knowledge, History & Theory 34, 231-44 1995 October, Review of James Bohman, New Philosophy of Social Science, Metaphilosophy 26, 440-48 1994 "What Does the Sociology of Scientific Knowledge Explain? or, When Epistemological Chickens Come Home to Roost," History of the Human Sciences 7, 95-108 (1998) Reprinted in I. Velody & R. Williams, ed. The Politics of Constructivism, Sage 1998. 1994 (coauthored with Ronald Munson), "Testing Normative Naturalism: The Problem of Scientific Medicine," British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 45, 571-84 1992 "Hayden White and the Aesthetics of Historiography," History of the Human Sciences 5, 17-35 1992 Review essay of Raymond Martin, The Past Within Us: An Empirical Approach to the Philosophy of History, History & Theory 31, 200-208 1991 "Words of Authority: The Anti-Social Epistemology of Narrative Experiments," Social Epistemology 5, 301-10 1991 September, "The Bureaucratic Turn: Weber contra Hempel in Fuller's Social Epistemology," Inquiry 34, 365-76 1991 June, "Truth in Interpretation: The Case of Psychoanalysis," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 21, 175-95 1991 "Interpretation as Explanation," J. Bohman, D. Hiley, and R. Shusterman, The Interpretive Turn: Philosophy, Science, & Culture, Cornell University Press, 179-196 1991 Review of Reed Way Dasenbrock, ed. Redrawing the Lines: Analytic Philosophy, Deconstruction, & Literary Theory, Journal of Aesthetics & Art Criticism 49, 180-82 1991 March, Review of Stewart Richards, Philosophy and Sociology of Science: An Introduction, Philosophy of the Social Sciences 21, 130-2 1990 November, (coauthored with Robert Barrett), "Deconstructing Quarks: Rethinking Sociological Constructions of Science," Social Studies of Science 20, 579-632 Replies by S. Fuller, T. Nickles, D. Oldroyd, A. Pickering, and T. Pinch. Responses by Roth and Barrett, pp. 729-45 1990 Winter, "The Virtue of Violence: Dimensions of Development in Walter Hill's The Warriors," The Journal of Popular Culture 24, 131-45 1990 June, "Reply to Carrithers," Current Anthropology 31, 275-6 1990 February, Current Anthropology 31, 53-58 Additional "Comments" and "Replies" to "Ethnography Without Tears" 1990 February, Review of Relativism: Interpretation and Confrontation, ed. M. Krausz, Canadian Philosophical Reviews 10, 66-70 1989 December, "Ethnography Without Tears," Current Anthropology 30, 555-69 Includes "Comments" on article and my "Replies" 1989 Summer, "How Narratives Explain," Social Research 56, 449-78

(2000) Reprinted in J. McErlean, Philosophies of Science: from foundations to contemporary issues, Westview Press 2000. 1989 June, "Politics and Epistemology: Rorty, MacIntyre and the Ends of Philosophy," History of the Human Sciences 2, 171-91 1989 Review of B. Glassner and D. Sylvan, A Rationalist Methodology for the Social Sciences, Philosophy of the Social Sciences 19, 104-108 1989 June, Review of R.H. Newell, Objectivity, Empiricism and Truth, Philosophy of the Social Sciences 19, 244-47

1989 Spring, Review of Images in Our Souls: Cavell, Psychoanalysis, and Cinema, Journal of Aesthetics & Art Criticism 47, 184-86 1988 "Narrative Explanation: The Case of History," History & Theory 27, 1-13 (1993) Reprinted in M. Martin & L. McIntyre, ed. Readings in the Philosophy of Social Science, MIT Press 1993. 1988 "On Margolis' Way Out," Social Epistemology 2, 249-52 1988 Winter, "Virtue and Violence: The Meaning of Mayhem in Peckinpah's The Wild Bunch," Post Script: Essays in Film and the Humanities 7, 29-42 1987 Meaning and Method in the Social Sciences: A Case for Methodological Pluralism, Cornell University Press (Paperback edition, Fall 1989) (1993) Reviewed by Randall Curren, Noȗs (December 1993), 27:530- 32. (1992) Reviewed by Alan Nelson, The Philosophical Review (July 1992), 101:679-81. (1990) Reviewed by Stephen Turner, Theory and Society (April 1990), 19:252-55. (1989) Reviewed by James L. Curtis, The American Political Science Review (March 1989) 83:275-76. (1989) Reviewed by Graham Macdonald, The Journal of Philosophy (August 1989) 86:442-46. (1989) Reviewed by Arthur L. Stinchombe, Ethics (January 1989), 99:434-35 (1988) Reviewed by Roger Paden, Review of Metaphysics (Dec. 1988), 42:409-10. 1986 June, "Reply to Feleppa," Current Anthropology 27, 251-2 1986 March, "Pseudo-Problems in Social Science," Philosophy of the Social Sciences 16, 59-82 1986 "Semantics Without Foundations," L. Hahn & P.A. Schilpp, The Philosophy of W.V. Quine, Open Court, 433-58 1985 "Resolving the Rationalitätstreit," Archives Européennes De Sociologie/European Journal of Sociology 26, 138-53 1984 July/October, "Who Needs Paradigms?," Metaphilosophy 15, 225-38 1984 "On Missing Neurath's Boat: Some Reflections on Recent Quine Literature," Synthese 61:205-231 1983 September, "Discussion: Siegel on Naturalized Epistemology and Natural Science," Philosophy of Science 50, 482-93 1983 August, "Personhood, Property Rights, and the Permissibility of Abortion," Law and Philosophy 2, 163-91 1983 July/October, "Reconstructing Quine: The Troubles With a Tradition," Metaphilosophy 14, 249-66

1982 March, "Logic and Translation: A Reply to Alan Berger," Journal of Philosophy 77, 154-63 1980 July, "Theories of Nature and the Nature of Theories," Mind 89, 431-38 1978 July, "Paradox and Indeterminacy," Journal of Philosophy 75, 347-67

PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES

Public Lecture or Forum Participation

Mar 29 2018 "Does Language Exist?", The Lendület Morals and Science Research Group, Hungarian Academy of Science, Budapest, Hungary Dec 13 2017 "Reviving Philosophy of History," University of Ostrava, Ostrava, The Czech Republic Nov 30 2017 "The Structure of Structure: Revealing the Missing Historiography of Kuhn's Structure and What It Teaches Us," presented at the Seminar of Historical Epistemology, University of Milan Nov 16 2017 "The Structure of Structure: How Kuhn Establishes that Science Requires Historical Explanation," Twentieth Century Think Tank talk, University of Cambridge Nov 15 2017 "Reviving Analytical Philosophy of History," Cambridge Philosophy of Science Seminar Colloquium (HPS), University of Cambridge Nov 10 2017 "The Structure of Structure: Kuhn's Narrative Reconstruction of Science and Its Significance," University of Vienna Oct 11 2017 "Does Language Exist?", LMS Lecture series, University of Hradec Králové, Hradec Králové, The Czech Republic Apr 2016 "Evaluating Narrative Explanations," University of Amsterdam Apr 2016 "Reviving Philosophy of History," Humanities Institute, University College Dublin Mar 2016 "Narrative as Explanation," University of Leiden Mar 2016 "Narrative as Explanation," Institute for Historical Research, University of London Mar 2016 "Narrative as Explanation," University of Ghent

Oct 16 2015 "Does Language Exist?", talk presented at the Catholic University of Lublin (Poland). Oct 15 2015 "Re-establishing the Philosophy of History," presented at The Catholic University of Lublin (Poland). Oct 9 2015 "Reviving Philosophy of History," presented at Institut für Philosophie, University of Vienna Oct 1 2015 "Intolerance: Revisiting Debates about Logic and Pragmatics," presented at Catholic University in Ružomberok.

Sep 29 2015 "Bringing it All Back Home: Refounding Analytic Philosophy of History," presented at Catholic University in Ružomberok Dec 4 2014 Presented discussion of my work on philosophy of history to a graduate seminar on "Narrative Knowing" (co-listed as Hist 344 and Phil. 344), Stanford University. Seminar organizer: Professor Norton Wise. 2012 "The Kuhnian Revolution that Wasn't, But Should Have Been: The Structure of Scientific Revolutions as Philosophy of History," talk given to the Philosophy Department at the University of Bergen (Bergen, Norway). Fall 2010 Lecture: Presented workshop for graduate students at the University of Lausanne on the philosophy of Ian Hacking. Fall 2010 (November 2) Fall 2010 Lecture: Presented a seminar on Donald Davidson and conceptual schemes at Eötvös Loránd University (Budapest), Fall 2010 (November 4) 2010 "Constructing the Pasts," Catholic University (Ružomberok, Slovakia). November 15 2010 "Constructing the Pasts," Institute of Philosophy and Social Sciences of Faculty of Arts University of Hradec Králové (Czech Republic). November 10 2010 "Constructing the Pasts," Eötvös Loránd University (Budapest), November 5. 2010 "The Pasts," University of Lausanne (Lausanne, Switzerland). November 2. 2009 "The Pasts: Reflections on the Epistemology of History" Institut Jean Nicod (École normale supérieure, Paris) March 6 2009 "'Hier ist kein Warum': Philosophical Reflections on the Social Psychology of Genocide." Paper presented to the Departamento de Logica, Historia y Filosofia de la Ciencia UNED (Madrid) March 13 2009 "Whatever Happened to Analytic Philosophy of History?" Paper presented at the Erasmus Institute for Philosophy and Economics, Rotterdam March 16 2009 "The Disappearance of the Empirical," presented at Universite Paris- Sorbonne, March 20 2005 "The Openness of the Past": Paper presented to the Department of Philosophy, California State University-Chico 1995 "Will the Real Scientists Please Stand Up: Pseudo-Issues in the Sociology of Science." Paper presented to the Philosophy Department, Washington University 1988 "How Narratives Explain," (Wesleyan University, October 1988; Smith College, December 1988; University of South Florida-Tampa, February 1989; University of Iowa, April 1989) 1983 "On Missing Neurath's Boat," (Western Illinois University, Fall) 1982 "Pseudo-Problems in Social Science," (Washington University, Fall) 1981 "Reconstructing Quine: The Troubles With a Tradition," (UM- Columbia, Winter 1981; SIU Carbondale, Winter 1981)

Papers Presented at Professional Meetings

Mar 31 2018 "Resolving Winch’s Dilemma: Narrative Explanations and The Idea of a Social Science," presented at a conference, Sixty Years of an Idea: Peter Winch’s „The Idea of a Social Science" after More than Half a Century, University of Pecs, Pecs, Hungary Oct 19 2017 Keynote talk, "Science, History, and Truth: Understanding Strategies for Learning About the World," Slovakian Philosophical Association, Smolenice, Slovakia. Oct 16 2017 "What Does Translation Translate?," conference on The Nature of the Normative, Czech Academy, Villa Lanna, Prague Sep 11 2017 Keynote Address, "Undisciplined and Punished," Factual Narratives: Types, Possibilities and Limits. Held at Catholic University, Faculty of Arts and Letters in Ruzomberok, Slovakia Aug 2016 "Essentially Narrative Explanations," at the 2nd International Network for the Theory of History Conference (Ouro Preto, Brazil). PEER REVIEWED Mar 30 2016 "Reviving Philosophy of History," European Social Science History Conference (Valencia, Spain). PEER REVIEWED Oct 23 2015 "Bringing It All Back Home: Refounding Analytic Philosophy of History," presented at conference on "Historical Investigations in Science," University of Calgary. Oct 13 2015 "Reviving the Philosophy of History," Keynote talk at conference, "Naturalizing the Humanities: A View from the Analytical Philosophy of History," Departments of Philosophy and History, Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland. Sep 23 2015 "Refounding Philosophy of History," talk presented at the European Philosophy of Science Association (Dusseldorf, Germany) Jun 4 2015 "Reviving Philosophy of History," Keynote Address, Conference on Assessing Narrativism, The Oulu Centre for Theoretical and Philosophical Studies of History (http:www.oulu.fi/centreforphilosophyofhistory) May 8 2015 "Reviving Philosophy of History." Presented at the 2015 Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (University of Washington, Seattle). Dec 28 2014 Commentator on papers by A. Tucker and J. Kuukkanen at invited session on Philosophy of History, American Philosophical Association Eastern Division (Philadelphia), December 28, 2014. Nov 9 2014 "Reviving Philosophy of History," paper presented at invited session on Recent Trends in Philosophy of Social Science, Philosophy of Science Association meeting (Chicago). Sep 10 2014 "What Would It Be to Be a Norm?", keynote address, European Network for the Philosophy of Social Science meeting, Madrid. Aug 31 2014 "Intolerance." Paper presented at the 8th European Conference for Analytic Philosophy, Bucharest. Oct 2013 conference: "What Would It Be to Be a Norm," paper presented at conference on Normativity and Naturalism in the Social Sciences held at Amicalola Falls Lodge, Dawsonville, GA. Jul 2013 "Whistling History: Ankersmit's neo-Tractarian Theory of Historical Representation," presented at the conference "The Future of the Theory and Philosophy of History," the inaugural conference of the International Network for Theory of History. (Ghent, Belgium July 2013) Jul 2013 Commentator for session on "Narrativist Tradition Reassessed" (four papers) at the conference "The Future of the Theory and Philosophy of History," the inaugural conference of the International Network for Theory of History. (Ghent, Belgium July 2013) May 2012 Keynote speaker, International Conference on "Naturalism and Normativity in the Social Sciences." University of Hradec Králové, The Czech Republic. May 10-12, 2012. Paper title: "What Would It Be To Be A Norm?" 2011 "The Pasts (Part II)," Pacific Division meeting of the American Philosophical Association, Society for the Philosophy of History (April 21) 2011 "Explaining Multiple Histories," Conference on Exploring the Cosmopolitan: Ideas, Theories, Methods. University College, Cork. (March 30) 2011 "Searleworld," Conference on Exploring the Cosmopolitan: Ideas, Theories, Methods. University College, Cork. (March 29) 2011 "Searleworld," Conference on Individual and Collective Rationality, Nice, France. Sponsored by the Institut des Sciences Humaines et Sociales of Nice-Sophia Antipolis (March 21-22) 2011 Invited participant in the Summer Institute in American Philosophy, University of Oregon. Presented talks; chaired session (July 11-15). 2010 "Intolerance," Candoc Colloquium, Villars, Switzerland. (October 30) 2009 "Where Are They Now? Analytic and Narrativist Philosophies" Panel on "Narrative, History, and Identity," Pacific APA (April) 2009 "The Pasts" Presented at the 1st Workshop in Philosophy of the Social Sciences at the Universite de Provence (Aix-en-Provence), March 9 2009 "The Ontological Turn in the Sociology of Science" Paper Presented at the 2nd Workshop in Philosophy of the Social Sciences, Universite de Provence (Aix-en-Provence), March 19 2009 "Philosophical Reflections on the Social Psychology of Genocide," Paper presented at the 3rd Workshop on the Philosophy of the Social Sciences, Universite de Provence (Aix-en-Provence) June 25 2008 Commentator on Michael Lynch's paper, "A Turn to Ontology," conference sponsored by the Oxford Science, Technology, & Society group, Said School of Business, Oxford U. (June) 2007 Author meets Critics, Patrick Baert, Philosophy of Social Science: Towards Pragmatism, Pacific APA (April) 2007 Author meets Critics, Ann E. Cudd, Analyzing Oppression, Pacific APA (April) 2007 "The Disappearance of the Empirical: Reflections on Current Trends in Historiography and Culture Studies": Panel at the Social Science History Association, Minneapolis (November 2006); Philosophy Department, Emory University (February 2007); Panel at group meeting for Society of Philosophy of History, Pacific APA (April) 2006 Invited Commentator, (i) Meet the Author session with Avi Tucker: Our knowledge of the past: a philosophy of historiography and Martin L. Davies: Historics. Why History Dominates Contemporary Society, and (ii) The Nature of Historical Explanations and Historical Narratives. European Social Science History Conference, Amsterdam, The Netherlands (March) 2004 "Changing the Past": Paper presented at a panel for the European Social Science History Conference I organized on "Realism, Anti- Realism, and Irrealism in History," Berlin, Germany (March 2003 "Historical Irrealism": Panel on Philosophy of History; APA, Western Division 2002 "Historical Irrealism": Panel on Philosophy of History; APA, Eastern Division 2000 "Mistakes": Conference on the Philosophy of Peter Winch, Bristol University (UK), September 2000. Versions of this paper were also presented at the European Social Science History Conference (February 2002), The Hague, The Netherlands and the Institut des Sciences Humaines Appliquées, Université de Paris-Sorbonne, (March 2002). 2000 "Fuller's '18th Brumaire of Thomas K'" Panel on S. Fuller's Thomas Kuhn, joint meeting of the American, Canadian, and British branches of HSS, St. Louis, (August) 1999 "Feminism and Naturalism: If Asked for Theories, Just Say 'No'" Invited paper for conference on Feminism and Naturalism, UM-St. Louis and Washington University, (September) 1996 "Naturalizing Goldman," Special session on work of Alvin Goldman, Central States Philosophical Association (October, in Kansas City, MO), with Alvin Goldman commenting 1996 Commentator (on papers by Harry Collins, Hubert Dreyfus, and Joseph Rouse), Conference on "Practices and Social Order," Zentrum für interdisziplinäre Forschung, Bielefeld University (Germany), January 1995 "Dubious Liaisons: Goldman, Quine, and the Naturalizing of Epistemology," (Given to the Philosophy Dept., St. Louis University, March) 1994 "What Does the Sociology of Knowledge Explain?" Presented at "The Social Construction of Knowledge," University of Durham, Durham, UK, April 1994 "Chaos, Clio, and Scientistic Illusions of Understanding," (Presented at the symposium "The Chaos of History: The Science of Chaos and the Nature of History," American Historical Association, San Francisco, January) 1994 "Will the Real Scientists Please Stand Up: Pseudo-Issues in the Sociology of Science," Symposium paper for "Norms in Science," HSS/PSA/4S Meeting, New Orleans, October 1994 1990 Commentator, M. Levine's "The Boethian Historian Tells His Story," (American Philosophical Association, December, Boston, MA. Levine's paper is a response to "Narrative Explanation: The Case of History," cited above.) 1990 Commentator, papers by E. Bruner and T. O'Meara, session on "Scientific and Humanistic Ways of Understanding in Anthropology," (Invited Session at the American Anthropological Association, November, New Orleans, LA) 1990 "Language, Truth, and Bureaucracy," (Symposium on Fuller's Social Epistemology at PSA/4S, October, Minneapolis, MN) 1990 "Does Historism Matter?" (17th International Congress of the Historical Sciences, Madrid, Spain, August)

1990 "Doin' What Comes Naturalistically" (Presented at a symposium on "Cognitive Science as Epistemology," Southern Society for Philosophy & Psychology, April, Louisville, KY) 1989 "How Narratives Explain," Conference on Disciplinarity, University of Minnesota, April 1989 1988 "Ethnography Without Tears," (Western Social Science Association, Denver, CO, April 1988; AAAS, Wichita, KS March 1988) 1987 "What Counts?" (Symposium on Stanley Lieberson's Making It Count, Midwest Sociological Society, Chicago, April)

1987 "The Metaphorical Structure of the World," (Symposium on M. Johnson's The Body in the Mind, Illinois Philosophical Association, November 1985 "Should Any Corporation Be Made Moral?" (Society for Business Ethics, San Francisco, March)

Conferences and Meetings

Nov 7 2014 Chaired session on Scientific Method Revisited, Philosophy of Science Association conference, Chicago. Apr 2014 Chaired Invited Symposium, History and Philosophy of Skill, APA Pacific Division Meeting (San Diego) Apr 2014 Chaired Session, Society for the Philosophy of History (Session I), held in conjunction with the APA Pacific Division meeting (San Diego) Sep 3 - Sep 4 2013 Co-organized and chaired a session at the first joint meeting of the European Network for the Philosophy of Social Science (ENPOSS) and the Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable held at the University of Venice. Mar 28 2013 Chaired session for the Society for the Philosophy of History, Pacific APA (San Francisco) Mar 22 - Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Mar 24 2013 Roundtable (UCSC). Sep 21 - Chaired two sessions at the first annual ENPOSS Conference Sep 23 2012 (European Network for the Philosophy of the Social Sciences). ENPOSS was created to be a European counterpart to the Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable. I also attended as the American representative for the Roundtable Executive Committee. Mar 9 - Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Mar 12 2012 Roundtable (University of Nebraska, Lincoln). Mar 2012 Organized and Chaired two separate sessions of meetings for the Society for the Philosophy of History, held at the Pacific APA, Seattle, WA. 2011 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (École normale supérieure, Paris). 2010 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (Saint Louis University). 2009 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (Emory University). March 20 - March 22 2008 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (University of Washington-Seattle). March 7 - 9 2007 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (University of South Florida, Tampa). March 23 -25 2006 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (UCSC). March 17 - March 19 2005 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (Barnard College). March 11 - March 13 2004 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (Saint Louis University). March 19 - March 21 2003 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (UM-St. Louis). March 21 - March 23 2002 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (Saint Louis University). March 15 - March 17 2001 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (Washington University, St. Louis). April 20 - 22 2000 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (UM-St. Louis). March 31 - April 2 1999 Co-organized and co-directed Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable (Saint Louis University). 9 April 9-- - April 11

Memberships or Activities in Professional Associations

2006 - Present Member, Social Science History Association 1995 - Present Society for the Social Studies of Science 1990 - Present Philosophy of Science Association 1978 - Present American Philosophical Association (Pacific Division) Fall 2013 - Member, Program Committee for Pacific APA Mar 2017 Jan 2014 - Sep 2015 Member, Program committee for the 2014 Biennial meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association. Jul 2007 - Jun 2010 APA Committee on the Status & Future of the Profession 1978 - 2004 Central States Philosophical Association: Secretary/Treasurer 1984; V. P. 1985; President 1986 1995 - 1998 Central Division APA representative Romanell Lectures selection committee Editorial Services

Mar 1 2018 Special Issue: Papers from the Roundtable on Philosophy of the Social Sciences University of British Columbia, Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 38:139-261

Mar 1 2017 Special Issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences, Papers from the Philosophy of Social Sciences Roundtable University of South Florida, Tampa, March 11-13, 2016, 47:95–180

2016 Special Issue: Co-edited Special Issue of Philosophy of the Social Sciences (2016) 46:103-209 from Joint Session the the Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable and the European Network for the Philosophy of Social Science (ENPOSS), Seattle, May 8-10, 2015 Mar 2014 15th Philosophy of Social Roundtable Issue, Philosophy of the Social Sciences 44:131-222. Mar 2013 14th Roundtable Issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2013) 43:3-72. 2013 Invited to join Editorial Board: Invited to be a member of the Editorial Board of a new book series for Springer, "Philosophical and Historical Perspectives on the Social Sciences (PHPSS)." 2006 - 2013 Journal of the Philosophy of History (Member, Editorial Board); resigned July 2013 due to editorial differences Mar 2012 13th Roundtable Issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2012) 42:3-120. Sep 2011 "What Does History Matter to . . .," special issue of The Journal of the Philosophy of History 5, 301-583. I conceived the project, recruited all 13 of the participants, and edited all the papers for this issue. Mar 2011 12th Roundtable Issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2011) 41:3-136. 2010 11th Roundtable Issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2010) 40:3-106 2009 10th Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2009), 39:3-92 2008 9th Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2008), 38:3-120 2007 8th Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2007), 37:3-73 2006 7th Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2006), 36:3-85 1978 - 2006 Reviewed book proposals for: Cambridge U.P.; Cornell U.P.; Harcourt Brace Jovanovich; Holt, Rinehart, & Winston; Houghton- Mifflin; McGraw-Hill; Prentice-Hall; Springer; SUNY Press; Wadsworth; Westview 2005 6th Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2005); 35:3-97 2004 "Theorizing the Holocaust," Paul A. Roth & Mark S. Peacock, ed. History of the Human Sciences (August 2004) 17:1-251. (Includes eight essays commissioned and edited by Roth and Peacock plus introductory essay by co-editors.) 2004 5th Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2004) 34:3-78 2003 4th Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2003) 33:3-99 2002 3rd Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2002) 32:3-91 2001 2nd Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2001) 31:3-82; (June 2001) 31:139-86 2000 James Bohman, Alison Wylie, and I co-edit one issue annually of Philosophy of the Social Sciences. The journal devotes its March number to papers which the three of us select and edit from those presented at the preceding year's Philosophy of Social Science Roundtable. *1st Roundtable issue: Philosophy of the Social Sciences (March 2000) 30:5-112 1998 Philosophy of the Social Sciences (Member, Editorial Board) 1995 History of the Human Sciences (Member, Editorial Board) 1995 Theory and Society (Member, Editorial Board) (no longer active as of 2004) 1982 "Matters of the Mind," Stephanie Ross & Paul A. Roth, ed., Synthese Vol. 53 (November 1982), 203 pp. (Proceedings of conference organized and run by Ross and myself. Papers by: A. Baier, D. Dennett, D. Hofstadter, G. Dworkin, H. Frankfurt, A. MacIntyre, D. Parfit, R. Rorty)