Appendix A: Fax: 917-591-3452212-736-1300 Letters to Agencies of the Government of Fax:A SIA DIVISION917-591-3452
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH 350HUMAN Fifth Avenue,RIGHTS 34 WATCHth Floor 350New Fifth York, Avenue, NY 10118-3299 34th Floor NewTel: York, NY212-290-4700 10118-3299 Tel:Fax: 212-736-1300212-290-4700 Appendix A: Fax: 917-591-3452212-736-1300 Letters to Agencies of the Government of AFax:SIA DIVISION917-591-3452 Brad Adams, Executive Director AElaineSIA Pearson DIVISION, Deputy Director Malaysia Requesting Data BradSophie Adams, Richardson, Executive China Director Director ElaineJohn Sifton, Pearson Advocacy, Deputy Director Director SophiePhil Robertson Richardson,, Deputy China Director Director JKanaeohn Sifton, Doi, Japan Advocacy Director Director May 31, 2012 PhilMeenakshi Robertson Ganguly,, Deputy South Director Asia Director KanaeAli Dayan Doi, Hasan, Japan PakistanDirector Director MeenakshiNicholas Bequelin, Ganguly, Senior South Researcher Asia Director Mr. Lim Leong Hock AliDavid Dayan Mathieson, Hasan, Pakistan Senior Researcher Director NicholasSunai Phasuk, Bequelin, Senior Senior Researcher Researcher Office of the Inspector General Police DavidMickey Mathieson, Spiegel, Senior Senior Researcher Researcher SunaiPhelim Phasuk, Kine, Senior Senior Researcher Researcher Ketua Polis Negara MickeyHeather Spiegel, Barr, Researcher Senior Researcher Ibu Pejabat Polis Bukit Aman PhelimTejshree Kine, Thapa Senior, Researcher Researcher HeatherKriti Sharma, Barr, CoordinatorResearcher 50560 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia TejshreeRiyo Yoshioka, Thapa ,Senior Researcher Associate KritiDiana Sharma, Parker, CoordinatorAssociate Via email RiyoJake Scobey-Thal,Yoshioka, Senior Associate Associate DianaShaivalini Parker, Parmar Associate, Associate AJakeDVISORY Scobey-Thal, COMMITTEEAssociate Dear Mr. Lim: Shaivalini Parmar, Associate David Lakhdhir, Chair AOrvilleDVISORY Schell, Vice COMMITTEE Chair David Lakhdhir, Chair Thank you for arranging the meeting with the Deputy IGP Tan Sri Khalid Abu Maureen Aung-Thwin Orville Schell, Vice Chair Edward J. Baker Bakar, Datuk Sri Mohd Bakri Zinin, Dato Hashim, and with ACP Anil Shah on MaureenHarry Barnes Aung-Thwin EdwardRobbie BarnettJ. Baker May 29, 2012. I appreciate the time that officials spent with Human Rights HarryRobert Barnes L. Bernstein Watch. Dato Hashim provided with me disciplinary statistics, which were very RobbieJagdish BarnettBhagwati RobertJerome L.Cohen Bernstein useful. JGeraldagdish Curtis Bhagwati Jeromeohn Despres Cohen GeraldJose Manuel Curtis Diokno JMallikaohn Despres Dutt Human Rights Watch would like the following additional information to JMerleose Manuel Goldman Diokno complete our research: MallikaJonathan Dutt Hecht Paul Hoffman Merle Goldman JSharononathan Hom Hecht PaulRounaq Hoffman Jahan Training SharonJoanne Leedom-AckermanHom RounaqPerry Link Jahan JKimberlyoanne Leedom-Ackerman Marteau-Emerson 1. Training topics for rank and file and length of time spent on each topic. PerryKrishen Link Mehta KimberlyAndrew J. Marteau-EmersonNathan 2. Training topics for officers and length of time spent on each topic. KrishenYuri Orlov Mehta AndrewXiao Qian J. gNathan 3. Has the new Criminal Investigation Department (CID) Training Center YBruceuri Orlov Rabb XBalakrishnaniao Qiang Rajagopal been created yet? If so, on what date? If not, what is the expected date that it BruceVictoria Rabb Riskin BalakrishnanBarnett Rubin Rajagopal will be in operation? VJamesictoria Scott Riskin BarnettSteve Shapiro Rubin 4. Topics covered in the new CID training center. JFrancesames Scott Seymour SteveMark SidelShapiro FrancesEric Stover Seymour Statistics from CID MarkKo-Yung Sidel Tung EricFrancesc Stover Vendrell Tuong Vu Ko-Yung Tung 1. Yearly statistics (2002-2012) on the number and types of complaints HumanFrancesc VendrellRights Watch Tuong Vu Kenneth Roth, Executive Director by the public about police misconduct or abuse received and processed by CID. Michele Alexander, Deputy Executive Director, Development and Global Initiatives 2. Conclusion or results of the investigations done by CID on public Carroll Bogert, Deputy Executive Director, External Relations Jan Egeland, Deputy Executive Director, Europe complaints of police misconduct (2002-2012). IainHuman Levine, DeputyRights Executive Watch Director, Program 3. Since 2002-2012, how many cases and types of cases that have been ChuckKenneth Lustig, Roth, Deputy Executive Executive Director Director, Operations Michele Alexander, Deputy Executive Director, Development and referred to the Attorney General’s office? (The Deputy IGP mentioned the WalidGlobal Ayoub, Initiatives Information Technology Director EmmaCarroll Daly, Bogert, Communications Deputy Executive Director Director, External Relations Aminulrashyid case and noted that other cases that have been referred). BarbaraJan Egeland, Guglielmo, Deputy FinanceExecutive and Director, Administration Europe Director PeggyIain Levine, Hicks, Deputy Global Executive Advocacy Director, Director Program BabatundeChuck Lustig, Olugboji, Deputy DeputyExecutive Program Director, Director Operations Dinah PoKempner, General Counsel TomWalid Porteous, Ayoub, Information Deputy Program Technology Director Director JEmmaames Ross,Daly, CommunicationsLegal & Policy Director Director 103 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH|APRIL 2014 JBarbaraoe Saunders, Guglielmo, Deputy Finance Program and Director Administration Director Peggy Hicks,h Global Advocacy Director BabatundeAMSTERDAM Olugboji Deputy ·BEIRUT Program Director · BERLIN · BRUSSELS · CHICAGO · GENEVA · JOHANNESBURG · LONDON · LOS ANGELES · MOSCOW · NAIROBI ·NEW YORK · PARIS · SAN FRANCISCO - TOKYO · TORONTO · WASHINGTON a. What is the outcome of cases referred to the Attorney General’s office (2002-2012)? 4. Since 2002, has any police officer or rank and file police been successfully sued in a civil suit by a member of the public? a. If yes, the date of judgment, case name, type of case, and damages awarded to complainant against the police? b. In the event of damages, has the IGP’s office paid for damages or does the individual police have to pay out of pocket? 5. What is the CID process for investigating and responding to a complaint by the public of police misconduct or abuse? a. If a complainant files a complaint with the local police station in a village or a major city is it automatically transmitted to CID in Bukit Aman from all over the country? Thank you for your cooperation. I look forward to receiving the requested information. Sincerely yours, Sahr Muhammedally Human Rights Watch First Floor Audrey House 16-20 Place London, England EC1N 6SN TEL: +442077131995 [email protected] “NO ANSWERS, NO APOLOGY” 104 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH 350 Fifth Avenue, 34th Floor New York, NY 10118-3299 June 27, 2012 Tel: 212-290-4700 Fax: 212-736-1300 Fax: 917-591-3452 Datuk Idrus Harun A SIA DIVISION Solicitor General Brad Adams, Executive Director Attorney General’s Chambers Elaine Pearson, Deputy Director Sophie Richardson, China Director No. 45, Persiaran Perdana, John Sifton, Advocacy Director Phil Robertson, Deputy Director Precint 4, 62100, Putrajaya, Malaysia Kanae Doi, Japan Director Via email [email protected] Meenakshi Ganguly, South Asia Director Ali Dayan Hasan, Pakistan Director Nicholas Bequelin, Senior Researcher David Mathieson, Senior Researcher Dear Datuk Idrus Harun: Sunai Phasuk, Senior Researcher Mickey Spiegel, Senior Researcher Phelim Kine, Senior Researcher Human Rights Watch is researching police reform issues in Malaysia. I met Heather Barr, Researcher Tejshree Thapa, Researcher with the Deputy IGP Tan Sri Khalid Abu Bakar and Datuk Sri Mohd Bakri Kriti Sharma, Coordinator Riyo Yoshioka, Senior Associate Zinin on May 29, 2012 in Kuala Lumpur. Diana Parker, Associate Jake Scobey-Thal, Associate Shaivalini Parmar, Associate Human Rights Watch requested and has been provided data from Bukit A DVISORY COMMITTEE Aman on police disciplinary actions as well as complaints by the public David Lakhdhir, Chair Orville Schell, Vice Chair investigated and referred for prosecution by the RMP. Maureen Aung-Thwin Edward J. Baker Harry Barnes Human Rights Watch would like some additional information from the Robbie Barnett Robert L. Bernstein Attorney General’s office to complete the research. Jagdish Bhagwati 1. Yearly statistics (2002-2012) on the number and types of cases Jerome Cohen Gerald Curtis referred by the Royal Malaysia Police (RMP) to the Attorney General’s John Despres Jose Manuel Diokno office. Mallika Dutt Merle Goldman 2. Since 2002-2012, how many cases, including types of cases, were Jonathan Hecht prosecuted by the AG’s office? What was the outcome of those cases? Paul Hoffman Sharon Hom 3. Since 2002-2012, after investigation by the deputy public prosecutor, Rounaq Jahan Joanne Leedom-Ackerman how many cases were classified as NFA (no further action) and reasons for Perry Link Kimberly Marteau-Emerson NFA? Krishen Mehta 4. Since 2002, has any police officer or rank and file police been Andrew J. Nathan Yuri Orlov successfully sued in a civil suit by a member of the public? Xiao Qiang Bruce Rabb a. If yes, the date of judgment, case name, type of case, and Balakrishnan Rajagopal Victoria Riskin damages awarded to complainant against the police? Barnett Rubin James Scott Steve Shapiro Thank you for your cooperation. I look forward to receiving the requested Frances Seymour Mark Sidel information. Eric Stover Ko-Yung Tung Francesc Vendrell Sincerely yours, Tuong Vu Human Rights Watch Kenneth Roth, Executive Director Michele Alexander, Deputy Executive Director, Development and Global Initiatives Carroll Bogert, Deputy Executive Director,