Expansion, Folding, and Abnormal Lamination of the Chick Optic Tectum After Intraventricular Injections of FGF2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Expansion, folding, and abnormal lamination of the chick optic tectum after intraventricular injections of FGF2 Luke D. McGowan1, Roula A. Alaama, Amanda C. Freise, Johnny C. Huang, Christine J. Charvet, and Georg F. Striedter Department of Neurobiology and Behavior, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697 Edited by John C. Avise, University of California, Irvine, Irvine, CA, and approved May 3, 2012 (received for review February 21, 2012) Comparative research has shown that evolutionary increases in human cortical evolution and expansion in terms of delayed and brain region volumes often involve delays in neurogenesis. How- prolonged precursor proliferation (15, 16). ever, little is known about the influence of such changes on The present study began as an attempt to phenocopy natural subsequent development. To get at this question, we injected variation in telencephalon size among birds. Specifically, we rea- FGF2—which delays cell cycle exit in mammalian neocortex—into soned that FGF2 injections into ventricles of embryonic chicks the cerebral ventricles of chicks at embryonic day (ED) 4. This ma- should, by analogy to the work in mammals (14), increase telen- nipulation alters the development of the optic tectum dramatically. cephalon volume, effectively creating chickens with a telencepha- By ED7, the tectum of FGF2-treated birds is abnormally thin and has lon as large as that of parrots and songbirds (7, 9). However, our a reduced postmitotic layer, consistent with a delay in neurogenesis. FGF2 injections did not significantly alter telencephalon de- FGF2 treatment also increases tectal volume and ventricular surface velopment. Instead, they increased the size of the optic tectum, area, disturbs tectal lamination, and creates small discontinuities disrupted tectal lamination, and created tectal gyri and sulci. in the pia mater overlying the tectum. On ED12, the tectum is still It is tempting to dismiss these induced alterations as mere pa- larger in FGF2-treated embryos than in controls. However, lateral thologies of no evolutionary significance. However, developmental portions of the FGF2-treated tectum now exhibit volcano-like “monsters” have long been used by evolutionary developmental laminar disturbances that coincide with holes in the pia, and the biologists to identify the kind of variation and generative princi- caudomedial tectum exhibits prominent folds. To explain these ples with which natural selection must work (17). Most of this observations, we propose that the tangential expansion of the ven- work has used naturally occurring teratologies, but carefully tricular surface in FGF2-treated tecta outpaces the expansion of the selected developmental manipulations can likewise be useful. pial surface, creating abnormal mechanical stresses. Two alternative Conrad Waddington, for example, argued that experimental per- means of alleviating these stresses are tectal foliation and the for- turbations of development can be used to infer the shape of the mation of pial holes. The latter probably alter signaling gradients epigenetic landscapes that constrain developmental and evolu- required for normal cell migration and may generate abnormal tionary variation (18, 19), even if the results are deleterious. patterns of cerebrospinal fluid flow; both abnormalities would gen- In line with Waddington’s approach, here we describe several erate disturbances in tectal lamination. Overall, our findings suggest changes in tectal development that are induced by FGF2 and that evolutionary expansion of sheet-like, laminated brain regions provide a model to explain them. Our analysis suggests that ex- requires a concomitant expansion of the pia mater. perimental expansion of the optic tectum is disruptive mainly because it is not accompanied by an equivalent expansion of the brain evolution | evolutionary developmental biology | proliferation | pia mater. This mismatch causes tectal foliation and tears holes meninges | cortical folding in pia, which then disrupt laminar development. The presumably maladaptive nature of these alterations probably explains why volutionary increases in brain region volumes are common (1). naturally occurring species differences in optic tectum size are EFor example, the neocortex is disproportionately enlarged in based, as far as we know, on changes in brain patterning, rather primates relative to other mammals, and the telencephalon is than neurogenesis timing (20). Our findings also suggest that disproportionately enlarged in parrots and songbirds relative to the evolutionary expansion of mammalian neocortex must have other birds (1–4). Recent work in evolutionary developmental required a concordant expansion of the neocortical pia. neurobiology has shown that these evolutionary increases in brain region volumes are often caused by delays in cell cycle exit of Results neuronal precursors (5, 6). Among birds, for example, parrots and We first report on changes in tectal volume, ventricular surface songbirds exhibit delayed telencephalic neurogenesis relative to area, and proliferative-zone fraction at embryonic day (ED) chicken-like birds (7–9). Among mammals, cell cycle exit in the 7, 3 d after the FGF2 injections (on ED4). We then describe how neocortex is similarly delayed in primates, which have a dispro- these alterations manifest on ED12. Finally, we describe portionately enlarged neocortex (5, 10–12). Unfortunately, the downstream effects of delayed cell cycle exit on subsequent developmental processes and adult morphology This paper results from the Arthur M. Sackler Colloquium of the National Academy of remain poorly understood. One way to fill this gap in our knowl- Sciences, “In the Light of Evolution VI: Brain and Behavior,” held January 19–21, 2012, at the Arnold and Mabel Beckman Center of the National Academies of Sciences and Engi- edge is to experimentally recreate the key species differences in neering in Irvine, CA. The complete program and audio files of most presentations are the laboratory by means of carefully selected developmental available on the NAS Web site at www.nasonline.org/evolution_vi. manipulations. A good example of this phenocopy approach was Author contributions: L.D.M. and G.F.S. designed research; L.D.M., R.A.A., A.C.F., J.C.H., the creation of transgenic mice with a constitutively active form and C.J.C. performed research; L.D.M., R.A.A., A.C.F., J.C.H., and C.J.C. analyzed data; and of β-catenin that prolongs proliferation, increases neocortical L.D.M. and G.F.S. wrote the paper. volume, and generates cortical folds (13). In another example, it The authors declare no conflict of interest. has been shown that intraventricular injections of FGF2 in rats This article is a PNAS Direct Submission. delay neocortical cell cycle exit, leading to dramatic increases 1To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: [email protected]. in neocortex volume and neuron number (14). Based in part on This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10. these experiments, it is becoming increasingly common to explain 1073/pnas.1201875109/-/DCSupplemental. 10640–10646 | PNAS | June 26, 2012 | vol. 109 | suppl. 1 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1201875109 Downloaded by guest on September 26, 2021 qualitative changes in tectal shape and cytoarchitecture that re- Postproliferative cells in the developing brain’s mantle zone sult from FGF2 injection. are less densely packed than their proliferating precursors in the ventricular zone (Fig. 1C). Therefore, the FGF2-induced tectal FGF2 Expands the Tectal Progenitor Pool. On ED7, FGF2-treated thinning is consistent with FGF2 delaying tectal cell cycle exit. embryos exhibit an expanded tectum compared with controls To test this hypothesis, we computed the fraction of all tectal (Fig. 1). Because of substantial variability in absolute volumes at cells that is proliferative, rather than postproliferative. We have this age, we express tectum volume relative to the rest of the previously used this proliferative zone fraction (PZF) measure to brain (minus telencephalon and medulla), as estimated stereo- demonstrate species differences in neurogenesis timing (7, 9). logically (Materials and Methods). By using these methods, we Here we extend the approach by staining ED7 brains with pro- observed a 32% increase in normalized tectum volume [t(11) = liferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), a relatively specific 3.9; P < 0.01; n = 13] for the FGF2-treated chicks relative to marker for proliferating cells (21) (Fig. 1 C and D). As very few controls. In contrast, telencephalon volume does not differ PCNA-negative cells were observed within the PCNA-positive significantly between FGF2-treated and control embryos, relative zone (and vice versa), we calculated the tectum’s PZF as the to diencephalon-tegmentum volume [t(11) = 1.3; P = 0.23; n = volume of the PCNA-positive zone divided by total tectum 13]. FGF2 injections also expand the tectum’s ventricular surface volume. Our analysis revealed that the tectum’s PZF is 67% area by 79% [t(11) = 4.9; P < 0.01; n = 13] and reduce tectal larger in FGF2-treated embryos than in controls [t(9) = 7.2; P < thickness by 35% [t(11) = −4.5; P < 0.01; n = 13]. 0.01; n = 11; Fig. 1E). Fig. 1. On ED7, the optic tectum is expanded in FGF2-treated embryos relative to controls, as illustrated here with Giemsa-stained horizontal sections (A and B; anterior is to the left). Staining with antibodies against PCNA (C and D) reveals that FGF2 treatment increases the proportion of proliferating cells in the tectum (i.e., PZF; E). Normalized tectum volume and tectal ventricular surface area are also larger in FGF2-treated birds than in controls, but tectal radial thickness is reduced. SE bars are shown. (Scale bars: A and B, 1 mm; C and D,100μm.) McGowan et al. PNAS | June 26, 2012 | vol. 109 | suppl. 1 | 10641 Downloaded by guest on September 26, 2021 Fig. 2. FGF2-treated embryos on ED12 have a significantly enlarged and abnormal tectum (A and B). Absolute and normalized tectum volumes, as well as the tectum’s ventricular surface, are increased significantly in FGF2-treated chickens relative to controls (C).