ED427369.Pdf
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
DOCUMENT RESUME ED 427 369 CS 510 003 AUTHOR Whitney, Shawnlee A., Ed. TITLE National Developmental Conference on Individual Events Addressing Individual Events, NFA Lincoln-Douglas Debate, and NPDA Parliamentary Debate Conference Proceedings (3rd, Houston, Texas, August 13-16, 1997). PUB DATE 1997-00-00 NOTE 224p. PUB TYPE Collected Works - Proceedings (021) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC09 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS *Debate; *Debate Format; Higher Education; Oral Interpretation; Persuasive Discourse IDENTIFIERS *Debate Coaches; *Debate Tournaments; Individual Events (Forensics); National Parliamentary Debate Association ABSTRACT This proceedings presents 19 papers delivered a National Developmental Conference on Individual Events, addressing individual events, Lincoln-Douglas debate, and parliamentary debate. After presenting the conference schedule, the list of attendees, and resolutions, papers in the proceedings are: "The Ghostwriter, The Laissez-Faire Coach, and the Forensic Professional: Negotiating the Overcoaching vs. Undercoaching Dilemma in Original Contest Speeches" (James J. Kimble); "Professionalism and Forensics: A Matter of Choice" (Larry Schnoor and Bryant K. Alexander); "Creating Space for the Physically Challenged Competitor in Individual Events" (David L. Kosloski); "Creating an Individual Events Judging Philosophy" (Jeff Przybylo); "Challenging the Conventions of Oral Interpretation" (Chris S. Aspdal); "Returning to Our Roots: A New Direction for Oral Interpretation" (Trischa Knapp); "Developing Functional Standards as a means to Greater Accessibility in NFA-LD" (John M. Devine); "Maintaining the Status Quo: Recommendations for Preserving Public Argument in Parliamentary Debate" (Steven L. Johnson); "Forensics Fellows: Integrating Faculty Participation into Intercollegiate Parliamentary Debate Programs" (Lewis E. Rutledge); "Presumption in Parliamentary Debate: Examining Whately's Ideas and Their Application to an Emerging and Evolving Debate Style" (Tammy Duvanel Unruh); "Forensics Education and Tournament Management" (Joel Hefling); "Equal Opportunity?: The Impact of Specialized Tournaments on Forensics Pedagogy, Forensics Professionals, and the Forensic Laboratory" (Scott Jensen); "Judge Agreement and Student Rotation: A Real-Life Study of the 1990 DSR-TKA National Forensics Tournament" (Vicki L. Karns); "AFA-NIET: The Culture of Qualifying and Its Effects on Forensics" (Daniel A. West); "Teaching and Coaching Individuals: The Use of Learning Styles in Forensics Coaching" (Thomas Bartl); "Solving for a Healthy Future: Creating National Standards for Training Future Directors of Forensics" (Thomas A. Workman); "New Directions for Public Speaking: The Perfect Pendulum Swings" (M'Liss S. Hindman); "Fisher's Narrative Paradigm Theory: A Model for Differentiating After Dinner Speaking from Informative and Persuasive Speaking"(C. Thomas Preston, Jr.); and "If It's Problem-Cause-Solution This Must Be Persuasive Speaking: Are We Short-changing the Art of Persuasion?" (Shawnalee A. Whitney) . (RS) ' I % I I) r""i%.10 CONFERENCEPROCEEDINGS THIRD NATIONALON INDIVIDUALDEVELOPMENTALEVENTSCONFERENCE c-) INDIVIDUAL EVENTS,Rice NFAUniversity,LINCOLN-DOUGLASAugustADDRESSING 13-16, Houston, 1997& NPDA Texas PARLIAMENTARYDEBATE Coordinated & Co-Hostedby EDUCATIONALOfficeU.S. of DEPARTMENT Educational RESOURCES Research OF EDUCATIONand INFORMATION Improvement M 'LissDaniel Hindman, A. West, Tyler Rice JuniorUniversityCollege DISSEMINATEPERMISSIONBEEN TOGRANTED Ti lISREPRODUCE MATERIAL BY HASAND CI9I( Minororiginating receivedThis documentchanges from it.CENTER the havehas person been been(ERIC) reproducedor made organization to as ShawnaleeConference A. Whitney, ProceedingsUniversity:of Compiled Alaska and Edited Anchorageby officialdocumentPointsImprove ofOERI reproduction view do position not or opinionsnecessarily orquality. policy. stated represent in this 1 TOINFORMATION THE EDUCATIONAL CENTER RESOURCES (ERIC) Editor's Notes theserveimportantNational influence as adevelopmental touchstonetime of to ideas regroup, for addressed conferences the to forensics reflect, at developmental like and community the plan one for in forour Houstonconferences many future. years.have We when been canThey seewean conference.forWest,I want their M'Lissto effortsecho Like Hindman, the inmany sentiments coordinating ofand us the in of the Ricethe and forensics conference University hosting community, the attendeesSpeech 1997 and developmentalDanin Debatethanking and M'Liss Team Dan Professionalismlastingcareerscolleaguesattend tournamentsways. shaped remarkIt theirandseemed that throughoutForensics forensics attending appropriate with thepedagogy a developmental country.the then, 1997 thatin conference very Inwe conferenceaddition, embracedsignificant as we I the earlyhave tookand theme in aheardlong- theirlook of Ithatconferencefelt am theythat grateful fartook on too theforindividual many proverbialthe personal years events bull had and inby passedDenver professionalthe horns sincein and1990. the supportinvited lastI appreciate usdevelopmentalI have to Houston. received the fact attendedNFA-LDWhileat where the wethe debatepurpose have1997 been andconference of this andNPDA-style conferencewhere represented we parliamentaryare was going. a to broad focus range on debate, individual of intercollegiatethose events, who colleaguesverykindthisfrom document. helpful.wordsmany colleaguesatin Finally, tournamentstheEditing Department I inam thisthe appreciativeand forensics compilation thoughtfulof Communication community of thewasnotes support not through while an at Ieasy receivedthe I emailhave taskUniversity workedhave andfrom yourbeen my onof resolutionsveteranCEDA/NDT.Rhoforensic Pi, forensic organizations.PKD, and DSR-TKA,papers Undergraduates,educators includedPresenters attended the in AFA-NIET, graduatethisand the packetattendeesconference. students, of NFA, conferencewere Not NPDA,newaffiliated surprisingly, coaches, proceedings and with even and Phithe helpfulUAA'sthealwaysAlaska efforts Anchorage.informationgood-naturedSeawolf of my Speecheditorial throughout Theabout andDepartment assistant, letting Debate the meprocess. Laure Team. Secretary,use her C.In I Macamcomputeraddition, Christine indebted Connell, I and want Simonka, to ashe memberherto providedmention for was the of presentersTheofaddress people table a whobroad whoof contentswere wererange present accepted of includes issues in Houston. for and athe completeinterests conference. reflective listing Papers of of thethenot papersbroadincluded range and in proceedings.significant time and effort she put forth in helpingShawnalee me withA. Whitney these attendpriorconferencepacketthis packet to and/or are the are asprogrampublication tocomplete indicated check but on ofwithasdid the thesepossible. not statusan attendasterisk.proceedings of their orPeople presentThe papers. to materials whoverify papers In were short, that includedwere listed theyI have contacted did in done thisthenot UniversityConferenceCo-Director of Proceedings AlaskaMarch of Anchorage. Forensics 9, Editor 1998 conference.wereeverything left out possible at the toauthor's ensure requestthat those or papers because not they included did not in thisattend packet the 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.. NEW DIRECTIONS FOR NPDA & NFA LD 2 ... ConferenceList of AttendeesSchedule 35 . JolminDeveloping NFA-LD M. Devine, Functional University Standards asof a Rhode means to Island Greater Accessibility PAPERS3 FROM... Resolutions THE KEYNOTE SESSION 4339 . LewisStevenArgumentMaintaining E. L. in Rutledge,Johnson, the Parliamentary Status Quo: UniversityPt. DebateLomaRecommendations Nazarene of Alaska for College Anchorage Preserving Public 7...JamesDilemmaProfessional:The Ghostwriter, J. Kimble,in Original Negotiating The George Contest Laissez-Faire the SpeechesOvercoachingMason Coach, University andvs. Undercoachingthe Forensic 56 . TammyIntercollegiateForensicsPresumption Duvanel Fellows: in Parliamentary Parliamentary Integrating Unruh, BethelDebate FacultyDebate: Programs College ParticipationExamining (KS) Whately's into Ideas and 14 ... BryantLarryProfessionalismSchnoor, K. Alexander, and St. Forensics: Olaf Southern College A Matter Illinois & of Choice University TOURNAMENTtheir MANAGEMENT Application to an Emerging and Evolving Debate Style NEW DIRECTIONS FOR EVALUATION & JUDGING 61 ... JoelForensics Hefling, Education South and Dakota Tournament State Management University 18 ...DavidEventsCreating L. Space Kosloski, for the PhysicallyHastings Challenged College Competitor in Individual 66 . .ScottForensicsEqual Jensen,Opportunity?: Pedagogy, Webster The Forensics Impact University Professionals, of Specialized and Tournaments the Forensic on 20 ...JeffCreating Przybylo, an Individual Harper Events College Judging Philosophy 73 . .VickiJudgeLaboratory AgreementL. Karns, and Suffolk Student University Rotation: A Real-Life Study of the 1990 NEW DIRECTIONS FOR ORAL INTERPRETATION 79. .DanielDSR-TKA A. NationalWest, RiceForensics University Tournament 24 ...ChrisChallenging S. Aspdal the Conventions or Oral Interpretation AFA-NIET: The Culture of Qualifying and Its Effects on Forensics 29...TrischaReturning Knapp to our Roots: A New Direction for Oral Interpretation TRAINING OF COACHES AND JUDGES 81 ... ThomasForensicsTeaching Bartl, andCoaching CoachingSouthwest Individuals: State The University Use of Learning Styles in 83 ...ThomasFutureSolving Directors for A. a Workman,Healthy of Forensics Future: University Creating