Ian's Thesis Outline

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Ian's Thesis Outline NOTE: This online version of the thesis uses different fonts than the printed version held in Griffith University Library, and the pagination is slightly different. The content is otherwise exactly the same. ESSENCE AND DECISION. The Case of Coronation Hill. Ian Hamilton Holland B.Sc.(Hons) Syd. U., Grad.Dip.Pub.Pol. UNE. Australian School of Environmental Studies, Faculty of Environmental Sciences, Griffith University. Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, January 1999. ii Abstract The rise of environmental issues has presented a challenge to decision-making in the area of natural resources policy. This challenge has met with diverse responses, ranging from neo-liberal attempts to incorporate environmental values into economic calculus, through ‘ecological rationalist’ arguments for the special nature of environmental issues, to radical theories of the state’s role in controlling the impact of environmental concerns on capitalist profitability. From this plethora of ideas about how to address environmental concern should emerge some directions that are more promising than others. But which? The Coronation Hill mine case, presented in this thesis, exemplified the complexities of natural resources decision-making in an environmental era. By analysis of the Resource Assessment Commission’s Inquiry into the Coronation Hill proposal, this thesis examines the strengths and weaknesses of the claims of different theoretical approaches. Such use of the single case to explore theory is exemplified by Allison’s work Essence of Decision. The RAC, as a neo-liberal institution, attempted to utilise both Pigouvian and Coasian strategies to address environmental issues. Both types of strategy emerge in the application of contingent valuation to preservation values. Private property rights allocation strategies, derived by public choice theorists from Coase’s work, are also in evidence in debate about Aboriginal rights in the Kakadu Conservation Zone (site of the proposed mine). The problems that beset the RAC both in its use of contingent valuation and its attempts to resolve Aboriginal issues exemplify why neo-liberal approaches are of limited use for dealing with the class of policy problem that Coronation Hill represented. Dryzek, Walker and others argue that ecological problems have a distinctive nature, which necessitates a distinctive policy response. However the evidence from the Coronation Hill case demonstrates the falsity of this premise. Ecological problems are in general similar to other policy problems. Radical analysis of environmental issues has treated them as potential sources of disruption to capital accumulation. According to the structural dependence thesis as formulated by Block and Przeworski and Wallerstein, the role of the state is to prevent damage to investor confidence. Data from the Coronation Hill case, however, suggests that the ‘anti-capital’ recommendations of the RAC iii adopted by the government had none of the detrimental effects predicted by radical theories (and by business actors). This is probably because it is not in fact clear that environmental protection is a goal hostile to capitalism. Environmental issues have also acted as an impetus to institutional innovation: innovation which the Resource Assessment Commission to some extent exemplified. The Commission’s apparent failure (it was shut down two years after the Coronation Hill episode) superficially lends credence to criticism of proposals for institutional reform. Comparative analysis of the Resource Assessment Commission and its established twin the Industry Commission, however, highlights the importance of institutional analysis for revealing that the type of institutional reform must match the type of problem being confronted. The Resource Assessment Commission is shown to be in several ways an inappropriate organisation to deal with issues like Coronation Hill. Thus the fate of the Resource Assessment Commission was largely inevitable, and was determined largely by its nature rather than by political events of the early 1990s. Theoretically, the Coronation Hill case highlights the limitations of both neo- liberal and ecological approaches to dealing with environmental concerns in the natural resources policy field. It also, however, leads to the conclusion that there is no coherent policy category of ‘environmental policy’. Rather, environmental policy issues are similar to other policy issues, and are themselves divided into other more important categories. These categories are defined by the divisions between first, issues in which conflict originates in distributive issues versus those in which that conflict originates in value clashes; and second, those issues in which interests are divided along capital / labour lines, versus those in which they divide in other ways. iv Contents Abstract _______________________________________ ii Contents _______________________________________ iv Lists of Tables and Figures___________________________ ix Acknowledgements _______________________________ xi Abbreviations __________________________________ xiii Statement of Originality ____________________________xv Chapter 1. Essence and Decision________________________1 The impact of environmentalism on natural resources policy ____________2 What are environmental issues?________________________________3 Four and a half ideas about addressing environmental concerns in the natural resources policy area _______________________________________6 Neo-liberal agendas: Pigouvian and Coasian approaches_________________ 7 Ecological analysis _________________________________________________ 10 Radical analysis ___________________________________________________ 13 Institutional analysis _______________________________________________ 14 The RAC as manifestation of, and battleground between, ideas __________ 15 Chapter 2. Mine, Yours or Ours?_______________________19 The Coronation Hill issue up to the establishment of the RAC___________20 Aboriginal People and the Conservation Zone _________________________ 29 From exploration to mining: the Environmental Impact Statement _______ 36 The Environmental Impact Statement and Cabinet _____________________ 41 The RAC is established _____________________________________ 42 The Conservation Zone Inquiry _______________________________ 51 Issues discussed in the Inquiries ______________________________60 Aboriginal interests ________________________________________________ 60 Environmental protection___________________________________________ 65 v Development of the mining industry _________________________________ 68 Conclusion _____________________________________________ 71 Chapter 3. Methods _______________________________72 Analytic induction ________________________________________ 73 Cases _________________________________________________ 75 The use of cases ___________________________________________________ 75 Choice of case _____________________________________________________ 78 Beyond the case ___________________________________________________ 82 Choice of theories__________________________________________________ 83 Limitations of the case-based approach __________________________85 Research methods ________________________________________86 Documentary sources ______________________________________________ 86 Interviews ________________________________________________________ 89 The content analysis of Inquiry hearings ______________________________ 91 Conclusion________________________________________________________ 94 Chapter 4. Neo-liberalism and Environmental Policy Issues ____95 Testing the application of neo-liberal instruments___________________ 97 Analytic criteria ___________________________________________________ 97 Analysing Pigouvian policy instruments ______________________________ 99 Analysing private property rights approaches ________________________ 100 A neo-liberal environment: the RAC in context ____________________ 103 A neo-liberal environment: the work of the RAC ___________________ 107 Contingent valuation______________________________________________ 110 Conclusion ____________________________________________ 118 Chapter 5. Pigouvian Techniques _____________________ 120 The problems of externalities________________________________ 120 The ‘moral free lunch’ and the voters ________________________________ 121 Bimodality and non-use benefits ____________________________________ 128 Devising the benefit cost analysis _____________________________ 130 Paying for goods: willing or able? ___________________________________ 137 When does contingent valuation work? _________________________ 140 vi Why are Pigouvian techniques of limited utility?___________________ 142 Conclusion ____________________________________________ 144 Chapter 6. Property Rights _________________________ 147 Property rights and the RAC ________________________________ 148 Contingent valuation: willingness-to-pay and willingness-to-accept compensation ____________________________________________________ 149 Sacred site, Aboriginal land ________________________________________ 154 Definition and redefinition _________________________________________ 158 Discussion ____________________________________________ 162 Is it worth defining environmental private property rights? ____________ 162 Individuals: aggregated preference curves? __________________________ 165 Politics: truth judgement or preference satisfaction? ___________________ 167 Conclusion ____________________________________________
Recommended publications
  • National Portrait Gallery of Australia Annual Report 13/14
    National Portrait Gallery of Australia Annual Report 13/14 National Portrait Gallery of Australia Annual Report 13/14 © National Portrait Gallery of Australia 2014 issn 2204-0811 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical (including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system), without permission from the publisher. This report is also accessible on the National Portrait Gallery’s website portrait.gov.au National Portrait Gallery King Edward Terrace Canberra, Australia Telephone (02) 6102 7000 portrait.gov.au 24 September 2014 Senator the Hon George Brandis qc Attorney-General Minister for the Arts Parliament House CANBERRA ACT 2600 Dear Minister On behalf of the National Portrait Gallery of Australia Board, I am pleased to submit the Gallery’s first independent annual report for presentation to each House of Parliament. The report covers the period 1 July 2013 to 30 June 2014. This report is submitted in accordance with the National Portrait Gallery of Australia Act, 2012 and the Commonwealth Authorities and Companies Act, 1997. The Performance Report has been prepared according to the Commonwealth Authorities (Annual Reporting) Orders 2011. The financial statements were prepared in line with the Finance Minister’s Orders made under the Commonwealth Authorities and Companies Act, 1997. Yours sincerely Dr Helen Nugent ao Chairman national portrait gallery of australia annual report 2013/14 i Contents Chairman’s letter 3 Director’s report 7 Agency overview 13 Accountability and management 17 Performance summary 23 Report against corporate plan 27 Financial statements 49 Appendices 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Inside This Issue
    Inside this Issue Volume 49 • Number16 4 The • July Links 1997 between Economic Freedom and Social Cohesion Enemies of economic freedom argue that it damages the ARTICLES REGULAR FEATURES fabric of society, as the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. But what holds society together? And do the poor 1 Editorial really get poorer? Winton Bates The Governments policy-free zone is not only bad policy, 19 Economic Freedom as a Good in Itself but bad politics too Tony Rutherford Classical political freedom and economic freedom tend 3 From the Executive Director to go hand in hand. Not surprisingly, they have a lot in Globalization is not just a buzzword. Its a real and growing force common—not least their subversive tendencies Padraic that might just help rein in the excesses of government spending McGuinness Mike Nahan 4 Muddying the Waters... Most of us gain our information about the natural environment 21 The `R Files from the media. But what happens when they dont get it right? A close examination of the recent dealings of the WA A Perth-based geological consultant examines a recent case in Government over the proposed sale of its major gas pipeline The West Australian Peter Purcell shows just why governments shouldnt get involved in 6 The Pyrrhonist commerce Alan Moran Much as he appreciatesAunty. Brian Tucker has suffered the 23 Black and White slings and arrows of outrageous ABC misrepresentation at first Not many of us have read the Independent Member for hand. Perhaps fair reporting for fair resourcing might hold the Oxleysutterances on Aboriginal cannibalism.
    [Show full text]
  • French Nuclear Testing in the Pacific, 1995-1996, and Its Fallout For
    FRENCH NUCLEAR TESTING IN THE PACIFIC, 1995–96, AND ITS FALLOUT FOR FRENCH AUSTRALIANS1 MARGARET BARRETT Demoralised by the reverses of World War II, France in post-war years sought renewed self-respect and military independence through the development of a nuclear capability. Its atomic tests conducted in French Polynesia from 1966 aroused strong opposition in Pacific Rim countries, which applauded an indefinite moratorium declared in 1992. With the Cold War over, nuclear proliferation seemed to have been curbed. But on 13 June 1995 a newly elected French president, Jacques Chirac, announced that a further eight tests would take place before his government signed the projected Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty in 1996. Australians protested vociferously, and even Paris heard the furore. This paper highlights two aspects of the controversy whose importance has been underestimated in other accounts. They are the precedent formed by Australian anti-French sentiment in the 1970s and 1980s, and the personally damaging and long-lasting effects of public acrimony on French Australians in 1995–1996. It is argued here that over-reactions in the Australian community to the renewal of French nuclear testing in the 1990s were understandable given increasing provocation by the French government over a period of thirty years or so. It is also claimed that although a supposedly democratic people might have been expected to treat fellow Australians of French descent more generously, such an outcome was unlikely in the circumstances. In the first part of the paper an inexorable deterioration in once-friendly relations between France and Australia is shown to have resulted from events in the latter part of the twentieth century—in particular the atmospheric testing of nuclear devices at Mururoa Atoll in the early 1970s and the bombing of the Rainbow Warrior in 1985.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effect of Compulsory Voting Laws on Government Spending" (2008)
    Clemson University TigerPrints All Theses Theses 7-2008 The ffecE t of Compulsory Voting Laws on Government Spending James Brookie Clemson University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://tigerprints.clemson.edu/all_theses Part of the Economics Commons Recommended Citation Brookie, James, "The Effect of Compulsory Voting Laws on Government Spending" (2008). All Theses. 419. https://tigerprints.clemson.edu/all_theses/419 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses at TigerPrints. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Theses by an authorized administrator of TigerPrints. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE EFFECT OF COMPULSORY VOTING LAWS ON GOVERNMENT SPENDING A Thesis Presented to the Graduate School of Clemson University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts Economics by James Harrison Brookie August 2008 Accepted by: Michael Maloney, Committee Chair Robert Tollison Laura Olson ABSTRACT The United States’ voter turnout is often cited as being disappointingly low. Compulsory voting laws are offered as a possible solution to increase voter turnout and overall political participation. Opponents of the law complain that voters affected will be more politically liberal and in turn seek to enlarge the size and scope of the government. In order to determine whether this is true, a test was run on the effect compulsory voting laws have on the government revenue of 109 nations. The data held that no significant relationship exists between the two variables observed. This paper will discuss compulsory laws and the controversy surrounding them and also offer possible explanations for why the predicted correlation was not found.
    [Show full text]
  • Of a 'Contested Ground' and an 'Indelible Stain'
    Of a ‘contested ground’ and an ‘indelible stain’: a difficult reconciliation between Australia and its Aboriginal history during the 1990s and 2000s Lorenzo Veracini This article proposes an interpretative narrative of the evolution of Aboriginal history as a scholarly enterprise during the 1990s and in more recent years.1 The 1990s were characterised by attempts to synthesise the interpretative traditions resulting from pre- vious decades of scholarly activity. In more recent years, the debate has shifted dramatically, dealing specifically with the genocidal nature of white Australia’s policy towards Aboriginal peoples. The most important passages in this process are associated with the 1992 Mabo decision by the Australian High Court and the publication of the Bringing them home report of 1997.2 During the 1990s, the relationship between particular political shifts and related historical writings in Australia was comprehensively transformed and became much more direct. The writing and interpretation of history have commonly been a site for direct political contestation, but in the 1990s political agendas became an informing fea- ture of historiographical debates more than in previous decades.3 One outstanding example of this tendency is John Howard’s successful domination of the political scene — an ascendancy based also on an explicit and unambiguous effort to ‘reconquer’ his- tory for the Liberal camp.4 In this context, an array of conservative opinions has challenged academic discourse. Nonetheless, both academic commentators and Aboriginal people successfully linked the ‘unsurrendered’ character of native title and, later, of Aboriginal sovereignty to both the resistential and the collaborative practices of 1. My review is selective.
    [Show full text]
  • Pauline, Politics and Psychoanalysis: Theorising Racism in Australia
    Pauline, Politics and Psychoanalysis THEORISING RACISM IN AUSTRALIA ANDREW WEAR Honours Thesis 1999 Department of Political Science, University of Melbourne Supervisor: Dr Graham Little 1999 Theorising Racism in Australia Andrew Wear Table of Contents Introduction 3 Chapter 1: Psychoanalytic Speculations on Racism 8 Chapter 2: Contemporary Australian Racism 24 Conclusion 41 Bibliography 43 2 1999 Theorising Racism in Australia Andrew Wear Introduction 1996 to 1998 was a dramatic and turbulent time in Australian political life. It was a time in which race - and racism - became the issue. While race has always been an unresolved issue lurking just below the surface of the Australian psyche 1, the rise to prominence of one woman enabled race-based politics to assume momentum not seen for a long time. Pauline Hanson was an unknown political novice when she was expelled from the Liberal Party during the 1996 election campaign. Prime Minister John Howard, seeking to prove his credentials on race, withdrew Liberal Party endorsement for Hanson in the safe Labor seat of Oxley for writing in the Queensland Times that assistance to aborigines had gone ‘too far’ and that: governments shower them with money, facilities and opportunities that only these people can obtain no matter how minute the indigenous blood is that flows through their brains... 2 Appearing as a Liberal on the ballot paper, Hanson secured a swing of 21 percent - the largest anti-Labor swing in the country - and comfortably won the seat. 3 The victory was hailed by many as a case of the hard-working underdog showing up an out of touch establishment.
    [Show full text]
  • 1998 Social Justice Report
    Social Justice Report 1998 © 1999 Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part may be reproduced by any process without prior permission from the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner, Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. Inquiries concerning reproduction and rights should be directed to the Manager, Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, GPO Box 5218, Sydney NSW 1042. ISSN 1321-11 Contents Foreword 1 Introduction: A Handful of Soil 2 Chapter 1: The Aftermarth for Indigenous People 13 Chapter 2: Non-Indigenous Community Response 27 Chapter 3: Church Responses 48 Chapter 4: Government Responses to the Recommendations of Bringing Them Home 53 Appendix 1: Letters to the Editor 83 Appendix 2: Selected Inventory of Apologies and National Sorry Day Events 89 Appendix 3: Text of Sorry Day Statement 92 Appendix 4: Summary of Governments’ Responses to Recommendations 94 Foreword This report presents various responses to Bringing Them Home, the Report of the National Inquiry into the Separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children from their Families. This is not done to re-open the substance of the Inquiry, its findings or the basis of its recommendations. The objective is to record the diverse range of responses and the perspectives they illustrate. The publication of Bringing Them Home had a marked impact on the Australian community. The ensuing public debate was sustained and intense. It stimulated the expression of views reflecting contemporary attitudes and values which directly and indirectly affect the circumstances of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.
    [Show full text]
  • Aboriginal History Journal: Volume 25
    Aboriginal History Volume 25 2001 Aboriginal History Incorporated The Committee of Management and the Editorial Board Peter Read (Chair), Rob Paton (Secretary), Peter Grimshaw (Treasurer/Public Officer), Richard Baker, Gordon Briscoe, Ann Curthoys, Brian Egloff, Julie Finlayson, Geoff Gray, Niel Gunson, Luise Hercus, David Johnston, Harold Koch, Isabel McBryde, Ingereth Macfarlane, Francis Peters-Little, Deborah Bird Rose, Gary Shipp, Ian Howie-Willis, Elspeth Young. Correspondents Jeremy Beckett, Valerie Chapman, Ian Clark, Eve Fesl, Fay Gale, Ronald Lampert, Campbell Macknight, Ewan Morris, John Mulvaney, Andrew Markus, Bob Reece, Henry Reynolds, Lyndall Ryan, Bruce Shaw, Tom Stannage, Robert Tonkinson, James Urry. Aboriginal History is a refereed journal that aims to present articles and information in the field of Australian ethnohistory, particularly in the post-contact history of the Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders. Historical studies based on anthropological, archaeological, linguistic and sociological research, including comparative studies of other ethnic groups such as Pacific Islanders in Australia, will be welcomed. Issues include recorded oral traditions and biographies, narratives in local languages with translations, previously unpublished manuscript accounts, resumés of current events, archival and bibliographic articles, and book reviews. This volume of the journal is formally dated 2001, but is published in 2002. Aboriginal History is administered by an Editorial Board which is responsible for all unsigned material in the journal. Views and opinions expressed by the authors of signed articles and reviews are not necessarily shared by Board members. The editors invite authors to submit contributions to either the journal or monograph series for consideration; reviews will be commissioned by the reviews editor.
    [Show full text]
  • Why Australia "Had to Have" High Interest Rates
    CRA is a world leader in the productir~nof aluminium, iron ore, lead,zinc, silver, copper, gold, caul, diamonds and salt. For erample, CRA k A'gyIe Diamond Mines operations contribute over 37% of aN tbe diamonds mined in Austrulia. IPA REVIEW mABLISHED IN 1917 BY CHARLES KEMP. FOUNDING DlRECrOR OF THE INSITWE OF PUBLIC AFFAIRS Vol. 44 No. 4 1991 Democracy in Trade Unions 5 Fred Nile, Offensive Books and Literary Stuart Wood Judgment Recent legislation has made SmnMoore union leaders less accountable. A heated dis Ute has broken out over calls for immoral booL to be removed from schools. One Vote, Different Value 9 Ron Brunton Allan Pidgeon Most governments in Australia are elected by minorities, but the worst gerrymander is resewed for Aborigines. Letters from Wiam Wentworth and Peter Hunt. Paying for Protection 13 Editorial John Stone The new censorship. We should level the playing tield internally even if we can't level it internationally. Indicators Australia's tax on children. Should a Consumption Tax Replace Payroll Taxes?.-. .. 22 Debate: Should voting be voluntary? John Freebairn Examined closely, the apparent benefits dissolve. Moore Economics Des Moore Republican Mischief Why Australia "had to have" high interest rates. Bruce A. Knox Press Index Why change what works? The Coalition's consumption tax. Republicanism. Edward VIII's Downfall R.J. Stove Strange Times Is a bad king a good reason to Ken Baker abolish the monarchy? Property rights recede, prostitutes' rights expand. The Flag: symbol of our national identity 32 Defending Australia Santo Sanloro Ham., Gelher - The flag is for all Australians, regardless of origins.
    [Show full text]
  • Material on John Anderson in the Sydney University Archives Compiled by Jim Packer, 2005-6 a Micro-Description of All John Ander
    Material on John Anderson in the Sydney University Archives Compiled by Jim Packer, 2005-6 A micro-description of all John Anderson material held in records in the University of Sydney Archives, drawn from an examination of the records themselves and using as a template the Guide to the Anderson Family Archives and other personal archives guides. Records examined include: SUA P42 John Anderson and Family Papers, as well as SUA P88 (A.K. Stout); P158 (Ruth Walker); P169 (Alexander Mackie and Family); P196 (W.H.C. Eddy); P198 (Tom Rose); P212 (David Stove); and SUA M (Miscellaneous) 237, 240, 242-3, 287, 307, 468. The numbering is based on the Guides produced by the University of Sydney Archives. The format follows the Series/Box/Item registration in the Guides (all in bold type). Where there are multiple components to an item and where these seem to require expansion, I have used / annotation to indicate this further expansion. These / annotations are not in the Guides and only itemize JA material. Abbreviations AET A.E. Taylor HE W.H.C.Eddy PL Peter Loveday AJA Sandy Anderson JA John Anderson rev. reverse AJB A.J. Baker JABH John Holland SA Samuel Alexander AJP Australasian Journal JAP John Passmore SEP Studies in Empirical of Philosophy; AJPP JBT J.B. Thornton Philosophy Australasian Journal of JCA Janet Anderson SH Sidney Hook (in JA) Philosophy and Psychology JCB Janet Anderson Soc Socrates (in JA) AKS A.K. Stout (unmarried) SP Subject [+] Predicate ARW Ruth Walker JLM John Mackie SSO Sidney Sparks Orr B Bosanquet (in JA) JMcA James McAuley S/T Space-Time BR Bertrand Russell (in JA) JMcI John MacIntyre ST&D Space, Time and D Descartes (in JA) K Kant (in JA) Deity DCS David Stove L Leibniz (in JA) TAR Tom Rose DJI D.J.
    [Show full text]
  • Copyright by Jason Louis Pierce 2002
    Copyright by Jason Louis Pierce 2002 The Dissertation Committee for Jason Louis Pierce Certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: Judicial Entrepreneurism and the Politics of Institutional Change: An Analysis of the Recent Judicial Role Transformation in the High Court of Australia Committee: John C. Higley, Co-Supervisor Hersel Watson Perry, Jr., Co-Supervisor Gary P. Freeman David A. Anderson Sanford V. Levinson Judicial Entrepreneurism and the Politics of Institutional Change: An Analysis of the Recent Judicial Role Transformation in the High Court of Australia by Jason Louis Pierce, B.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctorate of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin August 2002 Dedication To Emily Acknowledgements Preliminary fieldwork for this dissertation began in 1997, when I spent a few months as a research intern at the Australian Parliament and the Australian National University in Canberra. Over the five ensuing years, an ever-growing group of individuals assisted me along the way. Let me state from the outset that this dissertation would have been impossible without the help and encouragement of numerous people. The dissertation draws heavily upon eighty-plus in-depth interviews that I conducted with Australia’s most senior appellate judges from 1997 to 2000. These interviews were conducted under conditions of anonymity, meaning that I draw quotations from the interviews, but I nowhere disclose who made particular comments. My informants agreed, however, to have their names listed as participants, which I have done as Appendix A.
    [Show full text]
  • 'It's Mabo, It's the Constitution, It's the Vibe'
    ‘It’s Mabo, It’s the Constitution, It’s the Vibe’ Debates over the ‘active citizen’ and Aboriginal history in the NSW History Syllabus in the 1980s and 1990s Michael David Condie University of Sydney 2012 A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of B. A. (Hons) in History Contents Synopsis ii Acknowledgements ii Introduction: Something Profound 1 Chapter One: Creating the ‘Active’ Citizen 22 Chapter Two: The Aboriginal Perspective as a means of fostering inclusive citizenship 45 Chapter Three: ‘Was this an invasion?’ 65 Bibliography 89 ii Synopsis In the 1980s and 1990s, the NSW History Syllabus was subject to debate as varying groups’ competed for control over content. This thesis focuses on one aspect of the debate: the steps that led to the inclusion of mandatory Aboriginal history in the 1992 History Syllabus and the responses this generated among the teaching profession and the community in the wider context of the history wars. This thesis argues that these debates about Aboriginal history need to be considered in the context of a renewed push for citizenship education, and the ways in which the NSW History Syllabus engaged with the idea of the ‘active citizen’. iii Acknowledgements I would like to express my sincere thanks to my supervisor, Dr Julia Horne, for her invaluable suggestions, guidance and patience over the past year. I was so fortunate to have such a wonderful supervisor and could not have completed this thesis without her support. I would like to thank all my friends for their prayers, love and care and reminding me of my true identity in Christ.
    [Show full text]