United Arab Emirates a 1988 Law Requires That All Publications Be Licensed with the Ministry of Education and Delineates Accep
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Intercultural Communication Studies XV: 2 2006 Walters, Quinn, & Jendli A New Roadmap to Life: Media, Culture, and Modernity in the United Arab Emirates Tim Walters, Zayed University, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates Stephen Quinn, Deakin University, Melbourne, Australia Adel Jendli, Zayed University, Dubai, United Arab Emirates Abstract Critical to the vision of a new United Arab Emirates is an educated, skilled workforce that fuels the intelligent growth needed in a knowledge-based economy. As the country begins developing its version of that economy, the mediated, transparent environment fundamental to this process will carry with it new visions of (and possibilities for) living life. If peaceful change is to be achieved, a transitional generation faces the conundrum of adapting the best that modernity can offer while retaining the best of tradition. As have others, this study suggests two things: that (1) media literacy, growing in part from education, is correlated with urbanization and a changing infrastructure, and that (2) media in all its forms is inseparable from the outcome of this drive to modernization. Introduction A simple way to look at culture is as a roadmap to life that facilitates the capacity to survive and adapt to an environment. Passing along shared traditions, myths, legends, ceremonies, and rituals, among other things, culture helps create shared realities. This reality is created, shaped, modified, and preserved through communication. At some moment in time, ancient forms of associations, politics, and entertainment conducted by storytelling through speech were overlaid with reading and writing, the habits of print literacy. Today that storytelling has become intertwined with electronic habits that require a newer literacy. Today’s technology and what it implies have been called the 8th day of creation, and demands for “growth” and a modern economy impose the need for using that technology. A knowledge-driven economy with its use of (and dependence upon) modern media both interacts with and changes culture. The United Arab Emirates is an example of this interaction. The United Arab Emirates has been transformed from an impoverished collection of sand-blown principalities to a modern economic powerhouse with a top-twenty standard of living in three mere decades. Today’s Emiratis live life large. At all levels, their paternalistic governments support them with no-cost public education, low-cost medicine, high-paying jobs, short working hours, marriage grants, enormous pension contributions, and inexpensive housing. Inspired by the benevolent leadership of the late Sheikh Zayed, the country has blossomed in the desert. In doing so, it has moved from petrodollar dependence to a diversified economy with destination tourism a major force, more than a dozen free trade zones, and a state-of-the-art telecommunications infrastructure. Dubai’s speculative building boom with freehold 150 Intercultural Communication Studies XV: 2 2006 Walters, Quinn, & Jendli ownership for foreigners has created a get-rich quick mentality. The country also has become a transportation hub with modern airports and efficient container ports and increasingly serves as communications gathering place for Arabic-language media who wish to return from their self-imposed diaspora. To attract media enterprises, the country has adopted public policy to minimize restrictions and has a Constitution offering protection for free expression in most of its forms (Reuters, 7 November 2000; see also, Trabelsi, 2001). The singular goal of these several initiatives is to eliminate the drag on progress that the lack of raw materials has made for other area countries (Selber & Ghanem, 2004). The UAE’s economic vision is that of an Arab/Islamic incarnation of Alvin Toffler’s third wave. In riding the developmental swell, leadership has recognized the need to make more of its Emirati human assets, a resource of which there is now abundance. Though a knowledge-based economy is the dreamed of “third star on the right” guiding Emirati development, that star is twined. It raises hopes. It also illuminates societal fault lines. As mediated knowledge fans the flames of enlightenment, this knowledge also provides scripts of possible, alternative lives. They promote the scripts of those possible lives in entertainment programming and even in news stories. Thus, the electronic media in all forms help create a modern moment. That is because the mediated world which brings knowledge is also characterized by a new role for imagination powered by media. (See Appadurai, 1991). Such potential lives are beamed into the United Arab Emirates from a vast external world through satellite and cable television, the Internet, and print media including magazines and newspapers and books. Society and Culture The people’s will articulated in civic society greatly impacts what happens in all facets of life (O’Donnell and Schmitter, 1986; Geremek, 1992; Diamond, 1994; Bryant, 1995). That is because complex networks of economic, social, and cultural practices based on friendship, family, the market, and voluntary association help shape daily life (Wapner, 1995). Such civic forces are in flux in the United Arab Emirates, which remains in many ways a “to be” society in which kith and kinship and extended family networks wield enormous power over “possible” lives to be led. In this context, the many marketplaces of ideas transmitted by the modern media system inhabiting a 3rd wave economy now butt heads with other more familiar and comfortable visions of family and living. (See for example, Essoulami, 2001; Za’Za’, 8 January 2002.) That is because a closed society and a transparent modern economy are mutually exclusive. Forecasters believe that there will soon be two worlds, defined simply by closed or open access to information. Geography, history, culture, language, and the seven Emirate-based monarchies remain keystones of a millennium-old routine of life. The building blocks of this life require that individuals serve families, families serve society, and the individual serves both (Patai, 1983; Nawar, 2000). For most, the family and tribal structure are the fundamental metaphors. Traditionally, the freedoms that matter have been those that the ruler offered his tribal “family” or those that the head of the household offered his wife(s) and children. One critical element in those things that matter is Islam, which permeates all of society as it serves as the normative force (Patai, 1983; Lewis, 1990). Until most recent economic developments, Muslims have felt little particular need for secularism. Even today, the mere recognition that secular transparency is valuable in mundane economic corners remains grudging. That is because conservative Muslims envision the West imposing an 151 Intercultural Communication Studies XV: 2 2006 Walters, Quinn, & Jendli entire system of political and social values from such small beginnings (Ringle, 2001). They use this forecast of small, step-by-step change as a way to inject fear into even the most moderate of their numbers. Media and Culture New ways of communication, education, and media literacy have grown in lockstep (Lerner, 1958). Partly because the UAE had not been a reading society and partly because the consumer base for advertising in a market economy took time to develop, newspapers took root slowly in the UAE. From modest beginnings in the late 1960s, the print industry has grown to include six Arabic language and four English language daily newspapers and more than 160 magazines and journals. Most have on-line versions. The broadcast media, much like their print counterparts, have shallow roots also dating from the late 1960s (Babbili and Hussain, 1994 p. 304). From few options television choices have now exploded, arriving over the air, via satellite or cable, and offering a menu of viewing alternatives from across the Gulf and around the world. The United Arab Emirates also has worked hard to develop suitable physical and psychic space for new media. Emirates Internet and Multimedia (EIM), the country’s sole Internet service provider, put the current number of Internet subscribers at more than 210,000 and the number of users at more than a million in 2004, making the United Arab Emirates one of the most wired nations in the entire on-line world (International Business Newsletter, October, 2003). The United Arab Emirates, particularly the Emirate of Dubai, has attempted to draw technologically based business to its dunes, creating enterprise zones built on the duty-free model. Media City and Internet City have had some notable success in drawing media businesses and Internet related business to their gleaming glass buildings. Drawing these businesses to the sands is one part of the economic puzzle. Creating business models that work within regulatory frameworks and the context of Islamic society for far-flung enterprises such as e-business, traditional media, and tax-free distribution centers remains the other, more vital puzzle piece (Arabiata, 2002; Quinn, Walters, & Whiteoak, 2003). Media and Culture Because of the country’s recent development, Emiratis can live in a media rich environment if they so desire. They can interact on the Internet, see the entertainment and news programming of their choice, or view magazines and newspapers filled with worldly consumer delights. But this bringing the world at large into Emirati homes has been the subject of debate, particularly in the context of preserving the local culture. The