A Toxic Legacy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A TOXIC LEGACY THE CASE FOR A MEDICAL STUDY OF THE LONG-TERM HEALTH IMPACTS OF THE TRAFIGURA TOXIC WASTE DUMPING Amnesty International is a global movement of more than 7 million people who campaign for a world where human rights are enjoyed by all. Our vision is for every person to enjoy all the rights enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other international human rights standards. We are independent of any government, political ideology, economic interest or religion and are funded mainly by our membership and public donations. © Amnesty International 2018 Except where otherwise noted, content in this document is licensed under a Creative Commons (attribution, non-commercial, no derivatives, international 4.0) license. Cover photo: Maize growing next to one of the sites where toxic waste was dumped in August 2006, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/legalcode at the domestic waste dump at Akouédo, Abidjan (UNDAC site reference 1.1). July 2016 © Amnesty For more information please visit the permissions page on our website: www.amnesty.org International Where material is attributed to a copyright owner other than Amnesty International this material is not subject to the Creative Commons lisence. First published in 2018 by Amnesty International Ltd Peter Benson House, 1 Easton Street London WC1X ODW, UK Index: AFR 45/7594/2018 Original language: English amnesty.org CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4 METHODOLOGY 6 1. THE DUMPING OF THE TOXIC WASTE AND ITS IMPACT 7 1.1 THE DUMPING OF THE TOXIC WASTE 7 1.2 HEALTH IMPACT 8 1.3 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT 11 2. THE CASE FOR A LONG-TERM HEALTH STUDY 19 2.1 LEGACY OF FEAR 19 2.2 OBLIGATIONS UNDER INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS LAW 22 3. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 25 3.1 CONCLUSION 25 3.2 RECOMMENDATIONS 25 A TOXIC LEGACY THE CASE FOR A MEDICAL STUDY OF THE LONG-TERM HEALTH IMPACTS OF THE TRAFIGURA TOXIC WASTE DUMPING Amnesty International 3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY “We would like to know the contents of the waste and what degree of danger we are exposed to. … If someone is the victim of something, they have the right to know what the damage is and to know the health consequences in the short and long-term.” s)KUGNG-QPG6GCEJGT&LKDK8KNNCIG#DKFLCP,WN[ On 20 August 2006, the people of Abidjan in Côte in helping to address people’s fears about ongoing Fo+XQKTGYQMGVQƂPFVJCVHQWNUOGNNKPIVQZKEYCUVG EQPVCOKPCVKQPCVVJGFWORUKVGU JCFDGGPFWORGFCVOWNVKRNGNQECVKQPUCETQUUVJGKT EKV[6JGUOGNNGPIWNHGF#DKFLCP+PVJGFC[UCPF #PGSWCNN[KORQTVCPVsCPFNQPIQXGTFWGsUGEQPF YGGMUVJCVHQNNQYGFVJGFWORKPIVJQWUCPFUQH UVGRKUKFGPVKH[KPICPFCFFTGUUKPICP[NQPIVGTO RGQRNGUVTGCOGFKPVQVJGEKV[oUOGFKECNHCEKNKVKGU JGCNVJKORCEVU#HHGEVGFEQOOWPKVKGU#OPGUV[ EQORNCKPKPIQHPCWUGCJGCFCEJGUDTGCVJKPI +PVGTPCVKQPCNCPF7PKVGF0CVKQPUGZRGTVUJCXG FKHƂEWNVKGUUVKPIKPIG[GUCPFDWTPKPIUMKP$[VJG EQPUKUVGPVN[ECNNGFQPVJG%ÐVGFo+XQKTGIQXGTPOGPV GPFQH1EVQDGTOQTGVJCPRGQRNG VQVCMGVJKUUVGR#VVJG%ÐVGFo+XQKTGIQXGTPOGPVoU JCFDGGPVTGCVGFCEEQTFKPIVQQHƂEKCNTGEQTFU6JG TGSWGUV70'2CPFVJG9QTNF*GCNVJ1TICPK\CVKQP CWVJQTKVKGUTGRQTVGFVJCVDGVYGGPCPFRGQRNG 9*1 JCXGPQYQTICPKUGFCOGGVKPIQHRWDNKE FKGF6JGFWORUKVGUTGSWKTGFGZVGPUKXGENGCPWRCPF JGCNVJGZRGTVUVQCPCN[UGKPHQTOCVKQPQPVJGJGCNVJ FGEQPVCOKPCVKQP KORCEVUQHVJGFWORKPICPFVQEQPUKFGTVJGPGGFHQT CNQPIVGTOJGCNVJUVWF[ 6QVJKUFC[RGQRNGKP#DKFLCPNKXGKPHGCTQHVJGNQPI VGTOKORCEVUQHVJGFWORKPIQPVJGKTJGCNVJCPF 6JKUDTKGƂPIOCMGUVJGJGCNVJCPFJWOCPTKIJVU VJGJGCNVJQHVJGKTEJKNFTGPHQTVYQUKORNGTGCUQPU ECUGHQTVJCVUVWF[+VUWOOCTK\GUVJGUVQT[QH sCNCEMQHCEVKQPCPFCNCEMQHKPHQTOCVKQP0QQPG VJKUFKUCUVGTJQYKVCHHGEVGFRGQRNGoUJGCNVJCPF JCUGXGTEJGEMGFWRQPQTOQPKVQTGFVJGJGCNVJQH VJGKTGPXKTQPOGPVCPFVJGKORCEVKVJCUQPVJG CHHGEVGFEQOOWPKVKGUQTHWNN[CUUGUUGFCP[NQPI RGQRNGQH#DKFLCPVQVJKUFC[+VQWVNKPGUJQYVJG VGTOJGCNVJTKUMUQHGZRQUWTGVQVJGEJGOKECNUKP VJGVQZKEYCUVG(GCTJCUƂNNGFVJKUICRsURCTMGFD[ FWORKPIXKQNCVGFVJGTKIJVVQJGCNVJQHVJGRGQRNG CNCEMQHKPHQTOCVKQPCDQWVYJCVGZCEVN[YCUKPVJG QH#DKFLCPCPFYJ[TGNGXCPVIQXGTPOGPVUUVKNNJCXG YCUVGCUYGNNCURGQRNGoUDGNKGHVJCVVJGFWORUKVGU CPQDNKICVKQPVQTGOGF[VJCVXKQNCVKQP+VCNUQOCMGU CTGUVKNNEQPVCOKPCVGFCPFVJCVVJG[CTGUVKNNKNN TGEQOOGPFCVKQPUQPYJCVVJGUVWF[EQWNFKPXQNXG DGECWUGQHVJGFWORKPI JQYKVEQWNFDGKORNGOGPVGFCPFJQYCP[NQPIVGTO JGCNVJKORCEVUEQWNFDGOQPKVQTGFCPFCFFTGUUGF 'NGXGP[GCTUQPYGƂPCNN[JCXGCPQRRQTVWPKV[VQ CFFTGUUVJGVQZKENGICE[QHVJKUFKUCUVGT THE DUMPING OF THE TOXIC WASTE AND ITS 6JG7PKVGF0CVKQPU'PXKTQPOGPV2TQITCOOG IMPACT 70'2 YKNNUJQTVN[TGNGCUGVJGTGUWNVUQHVJGKT ,WN[GPXKTQPOGPVCNCWFKVQHVJGXCTKQWU 6TCƂIWTCCOWNVKPCVKQPCNEQOOQFKVKGUVTCFGT FWORUKVGUWPFGTVCMGPCVVJGTGSWGUVQHVJG%ÐVG RTQFWEGFVJGVQZKEYCUVGVJCVYCUFWORGFCTQWPF Fo+XQKTGIQXGTPOGPV6JKUKUCPKORQTVCPVƂTUVUVGR #DKFLCPKP#WIWUV6JGYCUVGKPENWFGFCOKZ A TOXIC LEGACY THE CASE FOR A MEDICAL STUDY OF THE LONG-TERM HEALTH IMPACTS OF THE TRAFIGURA TOXIC WASTE DUMPING Amnesty International 4 QHURGPVECWUVKE CUQFKWOJ[FTQZKFGUQNWVKQP CPF QHCECWUCNTGNCVKQPUJKRDGVYGGPRTQNQPIGFGZRQUWTG EQMGTPCRJVJC CJKIJUWNRJWTFKTV[D[RTQFWEVQH CPFCPKPETGCUGKPVJGHTGSWGPE[QHDTQPEJKCNJ[RGT ETWFGQKNTGƂPKPI 6TCƂ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o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ƂIWTCJCUPGXGTFKUENQUGFCNNVJGKPHQTOCVKQP VJG[CTGEQPEGTPGFCDQWVVJGEQORNGVGPGUUQHVJG KVJQNFUCDQWVVJGEQORQUKVKQPQHVJGYCUVG6GUVU ENGCPWRQRGTCVKQP YJKEJKPVWTPETGCVGUCHGCT EQPFWEVGFD[&WVEJCWVJQTKVKGUKP#OUVGTFCOFKF VJCVVJG[CTGUVKNNDGKPIGZRQUGFVQVJGEJGOKECNUKP JQYGXGTTGXGCNVJCVVJGYCUVGKPENWFGFXCTKQWU VJGYCUVG CPFOCP[DGNKGXGVJCVVJG[CTGUVKNNKNN EJGOKECNUMPQYPVQDGJC\CTFQWUVQJGCNVJKPENWFKPI DGECWUGQHVJGFWORKPI UQFKWOJ[FTQZKFGOGTECRVKFGUUWNRJKFGUCPF DGP\GPG#FFKVKQPCNN[CVQZKEQNQIKUVJCUCFXKUGF 6JKUNCEMQHCEVKQPCPFKPHQTOCVKQPCNUQOGCPU #OPGUV[+PVGTPCVKQPCNVJCVVJGOGTECRVKFGUCPF VJCVVQVJKUFC[VJGXKQNCVKQPQHRGQRNGo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Ƃ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mnesty International 5 VGTOKORCEVUCTGEQORTGJGPUKXGN[CUUGUUGFCPF METHODOLOGY CFFTGUUGFRGQRNGKP#DKFLCPYKNNEQPVKPWGVQNKXGKP HGCTQHVJGVQZKENGICE[QHVJGFWORKPI 6JGKPHQTOCVKQPKPVJKUDTKGƂPIKUDCUGFQPThe Toxic Truth,CTGRQTVGFRWDNKUJGFD[#OPGUV[+PVGTPCVKQPCN #UUWEJVJKUDTKGƂPIOCMGUXCTKQWU CPF)TGGPRGCEGKP5GRVGODGTHQNNQYKPIC TGEQOOGPFCVKQPUVQGPUWTGVJCVCP[NQPIVGTO VJTGG[GCTKPXGUVKICVKQPKPVQVJGFWORKPICPFKVU JGCNVJKORCEVUCTGƂPCNN[CUUGUUGFCPFCFFTGUUGF CHVGTOCVJFGUMDCUGFTGUGCTEJCPFKPVGTXKGYU 6JKUKPENWFGU EQPFWEVGFD[#OPGUV[+PVGTPCVKQPCNKP#DKFLCPHTQO VQ&GEGODGTCPFHTQOVQ,WN[ • %CNNKPIQPRWDNKEJGCNVJGZRGTVUCVVJGOGGVKPI QTICPKUGFD[70'2CPFVJG9*1VQTGEQOOGPF +P&GEGODGT#OPGUV[+PVGTPCVKQPCNVTCXGNNGF VJCVVJG%ÐVGFo+XQKTGIQXGTPOGPVKOOGFKCVGN[ VQ#DKFLCPVQHQNNQYWRYKVJVJG%ÐVGFo+XQKTG RWVKPRNCEGCUVWF[VQEQORTGJGPUKXGN[CUUGUU IQXGTPOGPVQPVJGTGEQOOGPFCVKQPUKPThe CP[NQPIVGTOKORCEVUQHVJGFWORKPIQPJGCNVJ Toxic Truth4GUGCTEJGTUOGVYKVJQHƂEKCNUHTQO 6JKUUVWF[UJQWNFCKOVQKFGPVKH[CP[NQPIVGTO VJG/KPKUVT[QH*GCNVJ/KPKUVT[QH6TCPURQTVCPF KORCEVUCPFQPIQKPITKUMUQHGZRQUWTGVQVJG /KPKUVT[QH*[IKGPG'PXKTQPOGPVCPF5WUVCKPCDNG EJGOKECNUKPVJGYCUVG+VUJQWNFCNUQKPENWFGCP &GXGNQROGPV4GUGCTEJGTUXKUKVGFFWORUKVGUKP GRKFGOKQNQIKECNUVWF[ #MQWÅFQCPF8TKFKCPFKPVGTXKGYGFPKPGTGUKFGPVU CHHGEVGFD[VJGFWORKPI4GUGCTEJGTUCNUQ • %CNNKPIQPVJG%ÐVGFo+XQKTGIQXGTPOGPVVQ KPVGTXKGYGFVYQOGFKECNRGTUQPPGNQPGNCY[GTCPF