Animals, Acrobats and Amusement: a History of Performance in South Africa’S Circus Industry, C.1882–1963
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Animals, acrobats and amusement: A history of performance in South Africa’s circus industry, c.1882–1963. by Mia Uys Thesis presented in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Faculty of History at Stellenbosch University Supervisor: Professor Sandra S. Swart March 2021 Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Declaration By submitting this thesis electronically, I declare that the entirety of the work contained therein is my own, original work, that I am the sole author thereof (save to the extent explicitly otherwise stated), that reproduction and publication thereof by Stellenbosch University will not infringe any third party rights and that I have not previously in its entirety or in part submitted it for obtaining any qualification. Date ……March 2021………………………. Copyright © 2021 Stellenbosch University All rights reserved Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Abstract In South Africa, the circus industry became an important leisure industry in the 1800s and remained a popular form of entertainment until the turn of the twenty-first century, attracting diverse audiences across the country. Yet this industry is a neglected area of historical research. This thesis uses a rich variety of primary sources to debunk the myth of the ‘timeless circus act’, static and uniform. Instead, it demonstrates that this industry has gone through several transformations throughout the history of its existence. It analyses these changes, with particular focus on animal and gender history, by comparing performances between three circus companies that toured South Africa between 1882 and 1963: Fillis’s Circus, Pagel’s Circus and Boswell’s Circus. In doing so, this thesis explores the international influence on performances. This thesis argues that animals were integral to the circus industry, but their roles were mutable and affected by changes in human society. It traces their shifting role in performances across the companies, while also considering their shifting and subjective experiences in captivity. It contends that we can conceive of animals as ‘political performers’ and even as political agents with the ability to exert their agency and effect change. Throughout this thesis, the notion of ‘performing gender’ is analysed by comparing routines, as well as the various audience reactions to examine the ideals of masculinity and femininity reflected in society at the time. Overall, it argues that the significant changes that occurred within animal and gendered performances were a response to the shifting localised public mindsets and political climates, affected in turn by broader global forces. Keywords: South Africa, history, circus, leisure, entertainment, animals, gender, performance i Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Opsomming In Suid-Afrika was die sirkusbedryf vanaf die 1800s ‘n gesogte vermaaksvorm en dit was nog steeds gewild tot in die begin van die 21ste eeu, met diverse gehore dwarsdeur die land. Ten spyte van die gewildheid van die sirkus is daar egter minimale geskiedkundige navorsing beskikbaar oor dié bedryf. Hierdie tesis maak gebruik van ‘n wye verskeidenheid primêre bronne om die mite van ‘n ‘tydlose sirkusbedryf’ as staties en eenvormig te weerlê. In plaas daarvan word daar in hierdie tesis uitgewys dat die sirkusbedryf verskeie veranderinge deur die jare van hul bestaan ondergaan het. Hierdie veranderinge word ontleed deur die vertonings van drie sirkusgroepe met mekaar te vergelyk, met ‘n spesifieke fokus op die geskiedenis van die gebruik van sirkusdiere en die rol wat die geslag van sirkustoneelspelers gespeel het. Die drie sirkusgroepe wat deur Suid-Afrika getoer het tussen 1882 en 1963 was die Fillis-, Pagel- en Boswellsirkusgroepe. Hierdie tesis verken die invloed vanaf die buiteland op die vertonings van die sirkusgroepe. Dit word in hierdie tesis geargumenteer dat diere ‘n integrale deel van die sirkus industrie gevorm het, maar hul rol was afhanklik van en beïnvloed deur veranderings in die menslike samelewing. Die tesis ondersoek die verandelike rol van diere in sirkusvertonings en oorweeg ook diere se verskuiwinde en subjektiewe ondervinding tydens aanhouding en voer aan dat diere selfs beskou kan word as ‘politieke toneelspelers’ en agente van politieke verandering. Deurgaans in die tesis word die idee van ‘geslag in toneelspel’ ook ge-analiseer deur verskeie sirkustoertjies met mekaar te vergelyk asook die reaksie van gehore as maatstaf te gebruik om die persepsie en ideale van manlikheid en vroulikheid wat gedurende hierdie era geheers het, te openbaar. Oorsigtelik dui die tesis aan dat die aansienlike verandering in die gebruik van diere en die rol van geslag in sirkustonele te wyte was aan die verskuiwing in plaaslike sienings en oortuigings rakende die ideale man en vrou, asook die politieke klimaatsverandering wat op sy beurt weer beïnvloed was deur breër wêreldwye druk. Sleutelwoorde/Terme: Suid Afrika, geskiedenis, sirkus, vermaak, diere, geslag, toneelspel. ii Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Acknowledgements The arduous and enjoyable task of completing a thesis incurs its own debts to those who have aided its development. First and foremost, I owe a great thanks to Professor Sandra Swart, who bent her ‘no masters student’ rule to take me on, and whose insight into the complexity of multispecies history has provided me with a solid foundation to begin my work. My growth over the past three years is largely due to her immense scope of historical knowledge, her sense of humour, and her patient guidance. Thank you for reminding me about the very important human aspect behind any postgraduate journey. Thank you for believing in me. To my fellow colleagues at HFM, it has been a privilege to listen and learn about your research over the past three years. Thank you for the hours spent together in the postgrad room. Thank you for pushing me to ask better questions. I am eternally grateful for the entire history department at Stellenbosch University who have all have aided my journey in numerous small ways. Thank you to Dr Anton Ehlers, for advising me to ‘sit under a tree and think’ before making this decision. Thank you, Dr Chet Fransch, for your equal measures of kindness and critique. Thank you to the staff at the Cape Town archives, the National Library, and the special collections at Stellenbosch University for your assistance. A huge thank you to Athena, for her patience and flawless editing. Thanks to Amy Wilson, for setting aside time for our interview and for our lively chat about all things animal law. To my parents, thank you for your love and support upon embarking on this degree two years ago with little to no knowledge on what it would entail. Thank you for the 107 days I was able to spend at home during lockdown which afforded me precious time to write and think and be. I am grateful for the other MA students who have walked this journey with me, especially thanks to Lyle, who pretended that rescue remedy would really calm my pre-lecturing nerves, and whose support has been invaluable. To all my dear friends, thank you for always being up to listen to my grievances and to celebrate small victories. Thank you for your advice, encouragement and care over the years. Lastly, thanks to Marco, for everything. iii Stellenbosch University https://scholar.sun.ac.za Table of Contents Abstract ..................................................................................................................................... 1 Opsomming .............................................................................................................................. ii Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................ iii Table of Contents .................................................................................................................... iv Abbreviations Used .................................................................................................................. v List of Figures .......................................................................................................................... vi CHAPTER ONE ...................................................................................................................... 1 Literature Review and Methodology CHAPTER TWO ................................................................................................................... 18 A horse and human dyad: The making of the ‘modern-day’ circus and equestrian performances in South Africa, c. 1882–1915 CHAPTER THREE ............................................................................................................... 48 Big cat acts and big men: Performing power and gender in southern Africa, c.1888–1916 CHAPTER FOUR .................................................................................................................. 76 Hagenbeck in Africa? South African circus animal acts in the global context, c.1896–1935 CHAPTER FIVE ................................................................................................................. 104 The agency of attack: ‘Political animals’ and public discontent, c.1940–1959 CHAPTER SIX .................................................................................................................... 135 Conclusion: Committed to a kinder world? SOURCE LIST ....................................................................................................................