Cultural Documentation Summary
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Pimachiowin Aki World Heritage Nomination Cultural Landscape Study Cultural Documentation Summary Author: R. Michael O'Flaherty Prepared for: Gord Jones (Project Manager, Pimachiowin Aki Corporation) Date: October 7, 2011 Pimachiowin Aki Cultural Documentation Summary October 7, 2011 Table of Contents Introduction to the Cultural Documentation Summary .................................................. iii PURPOSE........................................................................................................................III APPROACH .....................................................................................................................III SOURCES........................................................................................................................IV ORGANISATION ..............................................................................................................IV A. Anishinaabeg of Pimachiowin Aki in a Wider Context................................................. 1 A1. ETHNOLOGY & LINGUISTICS .......................................................................................1 A2. THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL RECORD .................................................................................1 TABLE 1 - SIMPLIFIED CULTURAL CHRONOLOGY ...............................................................3 A3. CONTINUITY AND CHANGE IN RECENT HISTORY ..........................................................4 A HISTORY OF REMOTENESS ............................................................................................4 ADAPTATION AND SYNCRETISM ........................................................................................6 B. Relationship to Aki – Worldview.................................................................................. 9 B1. INTRODUCTION TO THE ANISHINAABE WORLD OF SPIRIT.............................................9 B2. LANGUAGE AS A WINDOW TO THE ANISHINAABE WORLDVIEW.................................. 11 INDETERMINACY......................................................................................................... 11 ANIMACY & PERSONHOOD............................................................................................ 13 B3. ORAL TRADITIONS AND CULTURAL CONTINUITY ........................................................ 14 MEMORY ................................................................................................................. 14 HISTORY IN THE LAND.................................................................................................. 14 BIRCH SCROLLS .......................................................................................................... 15 ORAL TEACHINGS ....................................................................................................... 16 B4. RELATIONS WITH OTHER BEINGS .............................................................................. 17 SPIRIT BEINGS | OTHER-THAN-HUMAN BEINGS.................................................................. 17 BEMAADIZIWAAD | ‘THOSE WHO HAVE LIFE’ .................................................................... 20 AGENCY AND SPIRIT .................................................................................................... 21 RESPECTFUL BEHAVIOUR .............................................................................................. 22 ONJINEWIN............................................................................................................... 23 B5. CONCLUSIONS | THE GOOD LIFE............................................................................... 24 C. Relationship to Aki – Livelihood................................................................................. 25 C1. CUSTOMARY LIVELIHOOD PURSUITS ......................................................................... 25 FIGURE 1. HYPOTHETICAL SEASONAL ROUND ................................................................ 26 A DESCRPTION OF THE SEASONAL ROUND ......................................................................... 27 NOTE ON THE RELATIVE PERSISTENCE OF CUSTOMARY LIVELIHOOD ACTIVITIES ........................... 32 TABLE 2. ESTIMATED POPULATIONS OF FIRST NATIONS IN PIMACHIOWIN AKI........................ 33 INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE............................................................................................. 33 SHARING & RECIPROCITY.............................................................................................. 35 PARTICIPATION IN THE MARKET...................................................................................... 36 C2. CUSTOMARY GOVERNANCE ...................................................................................... 39 LAND TENURE - FAMILY HUNTING AND TRAPPING AREAS ...................................................... 39 CUSTOMARY AUTHORITY AND DECISION-MAKING ............................................................... 42 GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION ........................................................................................ 44 C3. CONCLUSIONS | SURVIVAL ON THE LAND.................................................................. 47 i Pimachiowin Aki Cultural Documentation Summary October 7, 2011 D. Pimachiowin Aki Anishinaabe Cultural Landscape..................................................... 49 D1. THE CULTURAL LANDSCAPE CONCEPT....................................................................... 49 BOUNDARIES & TERMINOLOGY ...................................................................................... 50 THE UNESCO CONTEXT............................................................................................... 51 D2. PIMACHIOWIN AKI – THE LAND THAT GIVES LIFE....................................................... 51 MATERIAL EVIDENCE OF CHANGE OVER TIME..................................................................... 51 INTANGIBLE ASSOCIATIONS WITH THE LAND....................................................................... 52 LIVING CULTURAL LANDSCAPE........................................................................................ 53 D3. JOURNEYING THE LAND ........................................................................................... 54 E. Authenticity................................................................................................................ 55 E1. SOURCES OF INFORMATION ..................................................................................... 55 ORAL TESTIMONY ....................................................................................................... 55 COMMUNITY DOCUMENTATION...................................................................................... 55 ACADEMIC LITERATURE ................................................................................................ 55 E2. ATTRIBUTES OF AUTHENTICITY ................................................................................. 56 AUTHENTICITY IN USE AND FUNCTION.............................................................................. 56 AUTHENTICITY IN TRADITIONS, TECHNIQUES AND MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS ................................ 56 AUTHENTICITY IN LOCATION AND SETTING......................................................................... 57 AUTHENTICITY IN LANGUAGE, AND OTHER FORMS OF INTANGIBLE HERITAGE .............................. 57 AUTHENTICITY IN SPIRIT AND FEELING.............................................................................. 58 F. Works Cited................................................................................................................. 59 ii Pimachiowin Aki Cultural Documentation Summary October 7, 2011 Introduction to the Cultural Documentation Summary PURPOSE The Pimachiowin Aki Statement of Outstanding Universal Value (OUV) provides a proposed justification for a cultural landscape nomination, using criterion (v): ‘Pimachiowin Aki fully represents the tangible and intangible elements of a living Anishinaabe cultural landscape’. The Cultural Landscape Study is therefore a very significant part of the background research for the Pimachiowin Aki nomination. The purpose of this Cultural Documentation Summary is to provide a more plain- language summary of the cultural landscape features and values in Pimachiowin Aki that provide support for the Statement of Outstanding Universal Value. In this way, the Summary will facilitate the writing of the following sections of the nomination document: Section 2.A Description Section 2.B History and Development Section 3.D Authenticity and Integrity APPROACH This Cultural Documentation Summary was prepared according to the following principles: 1. The Summary has been prepared as a thematic discussion paper so that related materials are consolidated and the specific relevance of documentation details to the various needs of the nomination document is more evident. 2. Summary is provided only for those portions of the Cultural Landscape Study and other documentation directly relevant to the Pimachiowin Aki Statement of OUV and the culture and geography of the Pimachiowin Aki area. Documentation that addresses Anishinaabe (Ojibwe) society beyond the First Nations of Pimachiowin Aki is not addressed here. 3. Discussion of documentation is centered on and takes direction from the Cultural Landscape Study (i.e. Macro-, Meso- and Micro-level Reports); other materials are brought in to provide additional detail or explanation, where needed. At the time of writing, the Micro-level Report is in draft form