Trump, Trump, Trump by Paul H
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Clio’s Psyche Understanding the “Why” of Culture, Current Events, History, and Society The Trump Symposium with Commentaries Trump as a Symptom Trump Studies European and Student Reactions to Trump Why Hillary Lost Ethical Issues Volume 24 Number 1 Summer 2017 Clio’s Psyche Vol. 24 No. 1 Summer 2017 ISSN 1080-2622 Published by the Psychohistory Forum 627 Dakota Trail, Franklin Lakes, NJ 07417 Telephone: (201) 891-7486 E-mail: [email protected] Editor: Paul H. Elovitz Editorial Board C. Fred Alford, PhD University of Maryland • James W. Anderson, PhD Northwestern University • David Beisel, PhD RCC-SUNY • Donald L. Carveth, PhD York University • Lawrence J. Friedman, PhD Harvard University • Ken Fuchsman, EdD University of Connecticut • Bob Lentz • Peter Loewenberg, PhD UCLA • Peter Petschauer, PhD Appalachian State University Subscription Rate: Free to members of the Psychohistory Forum $82 two-year subscription to non-members $75 yearly to institutions (Add $60 per year outside U.S.A. & Canada) Single issue price: $29 We welcome articles of psychohistorical interest of 500-2,000 words and some up to 3,500 words that have deeper scholarship. INSTRUCTIONS FOR CONTRIBUTORS: Clio’s Psyche welcomes original manuscripts that address individual or group issues from a psychological perspective. We are interested in contemporary and historical events. Childhood, family, group trauma, mechanisms of defense, personality, political psychology, psychic trauma, and psychobiography are of special interest. Our readers come from many fields so we avoid technical terminology. All manuscripts must include 6-10 keywords that stress the psychohistorical aspects of the article and an abstract of a maximum of 100 words. Authors should also include a brief biographical statement of no more than 100 words. Manuscripts should be composed on a word processor and sent electronically as a Microsoft Word document to Paul H. Elovitz by e-mail at [email protected]. Copyright © 2017 The Psychohistory Forum Instructions for Contributors: http://cliospsyche.org/guidelines.html The Trump Symposium with Commentaries Trump as a Symptom Trump Studies European and Student Reactions to Trump Why Hillary Lost Ethical Issues Volume 24 Number 1 Summer 2017 Clio’s Psyche Understanding the “Why” of Culture, Current Events, History, and Society Volume 24 Number 1 Summer 2017 _____________________________________________________________________ Psychohistorical and Psychobiographical Studies of Trump Trump Studies . 1 Ken Fuchsman Trump as a Symptom . 8 David James Fisher The Confabulator in Chief? . .15 Daniel Burston Donald Trump’s Tweets . 19 Frederick Stecker The Sycophant . .23 Peter W. Petschauer The Perversion of American Democracy . 24 Danielle Knafo and Rocco Lo Bosco A Tale of Two Presidents: Hoover and Trump . .27 Glen Jeansonne Donald Trump and America’s Death Wish . .33 Tom Ferraro Jews for Hitler: A Cautionary Tale or Unwarranted Hysteria? . .38 Ira Brenner Some German Reactions to Donald Trump’s Early Presidency . 43 Peter W. Petschauer Student Papers and Teaching the Election Voicing the Unpopular Opinion in Academia . .48 Taylor Gilson Against Trump . .51 Christian Polemeni Trump’s Continuing Appeal . 54 David Cifelli Teaching the 2016 Election. 56 Paul H. Elovitz Climate Change . .62 Allan Mohl The Trump Symposium and Commentaries The Implications of Trump’s Need for Conflict on His Presidency . 63 Paul H. Elovitz Why Are Voters Drawn to Trump’s Narcissism? by C. Fred Alford . 71 A Response to Elovitz’ Trump Symposium by Nick Duffell . .74 Trump and the Group by John Jacob Hartman . .77 Make It Super Short: Trump’s Restless Attention by Juhani Ihanus . 81 Paul Elovitz’ Characterization of Donald Trump by William R. Meyers . 84 Trump’s Popularity, Ideology, and Incoherence by Kenneth Rasmussen . .88 Psychoanalytic Free Associations on Trump by Neil Wilson . 92 Trump, Trump, Trump by Paul H. Elovitz . 94 ———————————————————————————————— Why Hillary Lost. 99 Ken Fuchsman and Paul H. Elovitz Transitional Phenomena in an Age of Heightened Anxiety . 108 Joyce M. Rosenberg Narcissism, DSM-III, and the Status of Psychoanalysis . 111 Ken Fuchsman Resisting Denial of the Psychologist’s Role in Post-9/11 Torture . 115 Ian Hansen Book Reviews Poems by Psychohistorians . 120 Allan Mohl The Allure of Trumpism . 124 Paul Salstrom Understanding and Resisting Tyranny . 126 Peter W. Petschauer Letter to the Editor: Feeling More Alive When Confronting Death . 129 Tom Ferraro ———————————————————————————————— Bulletin Board . 131 Call for Papers . 131, 133 Page 1 Clio’s Psyche Examining Trump Page 1 Psychohistorical and Psychobiographical Studies of Trump Trump Studies Ken Fuchsman—University of Connecticut Keywords: Trump, Trumpmania, psychobiography, American-history, cultural-history, political-history Abstract: In this Age of Trump, a special field called Trump Studies needs to be established. This essay lists essential topics that should be part of this still-emerging enterprise. This includes a critical examination of his childhood and business career, how his ideology and policies fit within the Republican Party, and what in our culture, politics, and history ex- plains how an individual with so little regard for the truth, so ill- informed, and who so extremely slanders others could be elected presi- dent in 2016. In the 1960s, there was Beatlemania; since June 2015, we have had “Trumpmania.” Few if any American political figures have so dominated media attention as has this New York real estate tycoon. In the Age of Trump, there should be Trump Studies. This would be an interdisciplinary endeavor that would need to include contributions from at least history, political science, sociology, eco- nomics, media studies, psychoanalysis, and psychology. The aim is to understand the Trump phenomenon in all its manifestations. As with any subject matter, we need to ascertain all the topics needed to have a comprehensive overview of the task at hand. These es- sential topics include: explaining what in American culture and his- tory can help us understand how Trump was elected; discussing the how, why, and consequences of Trump making untrue statements; how his domestic and foreign priorities and ideology can be placed in historical perspective; what in his childhood and business career have shaped how he acts as president; and showing how his actions as Commander in Chief reflect these past patterns. Much of what follows is familiar. There may be additional subject areas that oth- ers think are necessary as well. Trumpmania is based on the popular appeal of Donald John Trump. At his rallies this New Yorker elicited enormous enthusias- tic support from millions of his fellow Americans. The political pundits and pollsters consistently underestimated the extent of this Page 2 Clio’s Psyche support. The varied motivations of Trump voters must be carefully examined. The foundation of Trump’s support was in whites with- out a college degree, which he won by bigger margins in exit polls than any candidate since 1980. The same exit polls also showed him getting four percent more of white college graduates’ votes than did Hillary Clinton. In addition, in exit polls Trump did better with women than did McCain or Romney. As with any successful candidate, he had significant support from diverse groups. One of the reasons for examining Trump relates to his abil- ity to get so much media attention. He has shown a remarkable tal- ent to draw the attention of the mass media. As Trump remarked during the campaign, the cable news networks broadcast his rallies live and far more often than those of his rivals. The reasons for that, he said, is because he increases their ratings. What is it in what Trump does that has so captivated so many people, and has so dominated news coverage? I cannot think of a more major concern in Trump Studies than explaining his ability to rivet so many in the nation and media so often and for so long. Comprehensive biographical examinations of Donald Trump’s family background, childhood, and business career are essential. The historian of the family finds a three-generation pat- tern of energetic male ambition, practical skills, and using any and all means to achieve success (Gwenda Blair, The Trumps: Three Generations Who Built an Empire, 2000, 456-7). Donald Trump said of his personality: “When I look at myself in the first grade and I look at myself now, I’m basically the same. The temperament is not that different” (Michael D’Antonio, The Truth About Trump, 2016, 53). Examining the nature of his character as a child of six and its continuity to the present is a central component of Trump Studies. Also, needed here is an analysis of how his parents and schoolteachers responded to his rambunctious childhood behavior, which eventually led to Donald being sent to military high school. He grew up in a wealthy family as one of five children; family dynamics are important to Trump Studies. Donald is the second son, and his older brother would ultimately become a nega- tive example. The President attributes his refusal to smoke and drink to his older brother’s role as a cautionary tale. Their father both encouraged and disciplined his children, but eventually chose Donald as his successor and told him regularly that he is a king. His father strongly encouraged Donald’s tendency to exhibit narcis- sistic traits. Page 3 Clio’s Psyche Examining Trump Page 3 Donald Trump has spent over 40 years as a businessman and over 30 as a celebrity. He followed in his father’s footsteps, and whereas Fred Trump was a self-made real estate magnate in Brooklyn and Queens, Donald desired to make his mark in Manhat- tan. A self-described small loan of a million dollars from his father helped him get started and other loans rescued him when his casi- nos were about to go under. As an ambitious, wealthy young man in Manhattan real es- tate, Donald had some remarkable accomplishments at an early age.