Occupational Radiation Exposure from U.S. Naval Nuclear Plants and Their Support Facilities
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REPORT NT-19-2 MAY 2019 OCCUPATIONAL RADIATION EXPOSURE FROM U.S. NAVAL NUCLEAR PLANTS AND THEIR SUPPORT FACILITIES NAVAL NUCLEAR PROPULSION PROGRAM DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY WASHINGTON, D.C. 20350 This publication was printed on Recycled Paper Report NT-19-2 May 2019 OCCUPATIONAL RADIATION EXPOSURE FROM U.S. NAVAL NUCLEAR PROPULSION PLANTS AND THEIR SUPPORT FACILITIES 2018 Prepared by T. J. Mueller, T. M. Weishar, J. M. Hallworth, CHP, and T. F. Lillywhite Naval Nuclear Propulsion Program Department of the Navy Approved by __________________________________ J. F. CALDWELL, JR. Admiral, U.S. Navy Director, Naval Nuclear Propulsion TABLE OF CONTENTS SUMMARY .................................................................................................................... 1 EXTERNAL RADIATION EXPOSURE .......................................................................... 4 Policy and Limits ...................................................................................................... 4 Source of Radiation ................................................................................................. 5 Control of Radiation During Reactor Plant Operation .............................................. 5 Control of Radiation in Support Facilities ................................................................. 6 Dosimetry ................................................................................................................. 6 Physical Examinations ........................................................................................... 10 Shipyard, Tender, and Naval Base Training .......................................................... 11 Nuclear Power Training ......................................................................................... 17 Radiation Exposure Reduction .............................................................................. 18 Radiation Exposure Data ....................................................................................... 20 INTERNAL RADIOACTIVITY ...................................................................................... 33 Policy and Limits .................................................................................................... 33 Source of Radioactivity .......................................................................................... 34 Control of Airborne Radioactivity............................................................................ 34 Control of Radioactive Surface Contamination ...................................................... 35 Control of Food and Water ..................................................................................... 36 Wounds .................................................................................................................. 36 Monitoring for Internal Radioactivity ....................................................................... 37 Results of Internal Monitoring in 2018 .................................................................... 38 EFFECTS OF RADIATION ON PERSONNEL ............................................................ 39 Risks Associated with Radiation Exposure ............................................................ 40 Radiation Exposure Comparisons.......................................................................... 40 Annual Exposure.................................................................................................... 40 Collective Dose ...................................................................................................... 42 Conclusions on Radiation Exposure to Personnel ................................................. 43 Studies of the Effects of Radiation on Human Beings............................................ 43 High-Dose Studies ................................................................................................. 44 Low-Dose Studies .................................................................................................. 46 Numerical Estimates of Risk from Radiation .......................................................... 52 Risk Comparisons .................................................................................................. 53 Low-Level Radiation Controversy .......................................................................... 55 Conclusions on the Effects of Radiation on Personnel .......................................... 55 CLAIMS FOR RADIATION INJURY TO PERSONNEL ............................................... 57 AUDITS AND REVIEWS ............................................................................................. 60 ABNORMAL OCCURRENCES ................................................................................... 62 REFERENCES ............................................................................................................ 63 i LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE 1 Total Radiation Exposure Received by Military and Civilian Personnel in the Naval Nuclear Propulsion Program 1958-2018 ............................ 3 FIGURE 2 Total Radiation Exposure Received by Shipyard Personnel from Work on Naval Nuclear Propulsion Plants 1958-2018 ......................... 27 LIST OF TABLES TABLE 1 Shipyard First Reactor Plant Operation and First Radioactive Overhaul Work ..................................................................................... 22 TABLE 2 Occupational Radiation Exposure Received by Personnel Assigned to Tenders, Bases, and Nuclear-Powered Ships from Operation and Maintenance of Naval Nuclear Propulsion Plants ................................ 23 TABLE 3 Occupational Radiation Exposure Received by Shipyard Personnel from Work Associated with Naval Nuclear Propulsion Plants .............. 25 TABLE 4 Shipyard and Fleet Distribution of Personnel Radiation Exposure ...... 28 TABLE 5 Distribution of Total Lifetime Radiation Exposure Associated with Naval Nuclear Propulsion Plants ......................................................... 30 TABLE 6 Personnel Radiation Exposure for Commercial Nuclear-Powered Reactors Licensed by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission ........ 31 TABLE 7 Occurrences of Radioactive Skin Contaminations and Internal Radioactivity Depositions in Shipyard Personnel and Fleet Personnel Assigned to Tenders, Bases, and Nuclear-Powered Ships ................. 39 TABLE 8 Yale Study Results .............................................................................. 51 TABLE 9 New York University (NYU) Study Results .......................................... 52 TABLE 10 Lifetime Occupational Risks ................................................................ 54 TABLE 11 Some Commonplace Lifetime Risks .................................................... 54 TABLE 12 Claims for Radiation Injury to Personnel .............................................. 57 ii SUMMARY This report summarizes the radiation exposures to Navy and civilian personnel monitored for radiation associated with U.S. naval nuclear propulsion plants. As of the end of 2018, the U.S. Navy operated 71 nuclear-powered submarines, 11 nuclear- powered aircraft carriers, and 2 moored training ships. Facilities that build, maintain, overhaul, or refuel these nuclear propulsion plants include six shipyards, two tenders, and six naval bases. The benefits of nuclear propulsion in our most capable combatant ships have long been recognized, and our nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines form the strongest element of the U.S. strategic deterrent. Figure 1 shows that the total radiation exposure in 2018 is about 3 percent of the amount in the peak year of 1966, even though today there are 18 percent more nuclear- powered ships in operation and approximately 3.5 times the number of ships in overhaul. Total radiation exposure in this figure is the sum of the annual exposure of each person monitored for radiation. In 2018, the number of ships in overhaul was approximately the same as in 2017 but the total shipyard radiation exposure decreased from 489 Rem in 2017 to 461 Rem in 2018 (shipyard average annual radiation exposure per person decreased from 0.017 Rem in 2017 to 0.016 Rem in 2018). The total Fleet radiation exposure decreased from 157 Rem in 2017 to 153 Rem in 2018 (Fleet average annual radiation exposure per person remained the same as in 2017 at 0.009 Rem). The current Federal annual occupational radiation exposure limit of 5 Rem established in 1994 came 27 years after the Naval Nuclear Propulsion Program’s (NNPP’s) annual exposure limit of 5 Rem per year was established in 1967. (Until 1994, the Federal radiation exposure lifetime limit allowed an accumulation of exposure of 5 Rem for each year of age beyond 18.) From 1969 to 1994, no civilian or military personnel in the Program exceeded its self-imposed 5 Rem annual limit, and no one has exceeded that Federal limit since then. In fact, no Program personnel have exceeded 40 percent of the Program’s annual limit between 1980 and 2018 (i.e., no personnel have exceeded 2 Rem in any year in the last 39 years). And no civilian or military Program personnel have ever, in over 60 years of operation, exceeded any Federal lifetime limit. Personnel operating the Navy’s nuclear-powered ships receive much less radiation exposure in a year than the average U.S. citizen does from natural background and medical radiation exposure. For example, the occupational exposure received by the average nuclear-trained sailor living onboard one of the Navy’s nuclear-powered ships in 2018 was less than