Mid-Nineteenth-Century Female Emigration to Australia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
‘A Mad Proceeding’: Mid-Nineteenth-Century Female Emigration to Australia Brooke Weber Royal Holloway, University of London This thesis is submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) History July 2018 1 Declaration of Authorship I, Brooke Weber, hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented within is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, this is always clearly stated. Signed: Brooke Weber Date: 12 March 2018 2 ‘A Mad Proceeding’: Mid-Nineteenth-Century Female Emigration to Australia This thesis explores the experiences of female emigrants from Britain to Australia in the mid-nineteenth century, a transitionary era in which penal transportation faded, gold rushes boomed, and settler colonialism fostered a new society. This society flourished in six varied, yet wholly British, settler colonies; the presence of Indigenous populations was largely ignored by emigration advocates and emigrants alike. Despite the lack of an explicit discussion about race, a study of these women is rich in themes from gender and sexuality to class and social mobility, presented within a transnational context of migration. This thesis situates female emigration in a new imperial history framework, reading against the archival grain of traditional sources such as emigration society and Colonial Office records to illustrate the emigration process while also acknowledging women’s individuality and agency as they left behind homes and families, navigated the moral concerns of ships and immigration depots, and built new lives and societies in the Australian settler colonies. The thesis also turns to non-archival sources such as women’s fictional writings to address women’s personal experiences and find their voices in an era and situation largely dominated and directed by men. Starting with emigration society and Colonial Office archives, this thesis challenges the generalisation of emigrants as young potential brides; on the contrary, women of varying ages and backgrounds emigrated. This study also exposes the idealism and naivety prevalent among emigration advocates. Officials presented a logical system of emigration and settlement, but immigrants faced financial and physical challenges which threatened success yet were generally attributed to poor personal character. With these disparities between emigration promoters’ ideals and women’s realities in mind, the thesis turns to other sources to explore the immigrant experience. Newspapers expose colonial debates, and an analysis of fictional works by immigrant women writers clarifies the challenges women faced in settler colonies. Although female emigration has been examined in the past, this thesis demonstrates that it is still possible to enrich our understanding of imperial migration and the role of women in the empire. 3 Table of Contents List of Tables ................................................................................................................ 6 List of Figures ............................................................................................................... 7 Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................... 8 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 9 Female Emigration and Women in Australian History ........................................... 14 Questioning and Connecting Female Emigration History ...................................... 26 From Metropole to Colony ..................................................................................... 32 Chapter One – The Ideal Emigrant: An Analysis of the Female Middle Class Emigration Society Records ....................................................................................... 41 The Female Middle Class Emigration Society (FMCES) ....................................... 45 FMCES Report Tables ............................................................................................ 55 Letters from Home, to Home: First Impressions of Life in Australia ..................... 70 Chapter Two – From Metropole to Colony: Bureaucracy and Female Emigration .... 79 Record-Keeping and Recruitment ........................................................................... 82 Emigration Agents .................................................................................................. 95 Protected Passage: The Voyage, Surgeons, and Matrons ..................................... 100 Emigration Collaborations .................................................................................... 107 Women and Chain Migration ................................................................................ 111 Individual Episodes ............................................................................................... 122 Chapter Three – In the Details: A Case Study of South Australia ............................ 130 The History of South Australia and Emigration ................................................... 133 The 1856 Report of the Select Committee of the Legislative Council of South Australia ................................................................................................................ 142 Life at the Depot ................................................................................................... 150 Deception and Depression: Moral and Mental Behaviour of Female Emigrants . 162 Irish Immigration .................................................................................................. 170 Women’s Testimony and the Adelaide Female Immigration Depot .................... 174 Chapter Four – A Warm Welcome? Female Emigration in the Press ...................... 187 Newspapers in Nineteenth-Century Britain and Australia .................................... 189 Press Coverage of Emigration .............................................................................. 196 Sensational Shipwrecks: Capturing the Voyage ................................................... 199 Blessing or Curse? Metropolitan and Colonial Opinions of Female Emigration and Maria Rye’s Emigration Scheme .......................................................................... 203 Rye vs. Queenslander............................................................................................ 218 Chapter Five – Settling in a New Society: Women Authors and the Emigrant Experience ................................................................................................................ 229 Mary Theresa Vidal’s Tales for the Bush ............................................................. 231 Catherine Helen Spence’s Clara Morison: A Tale of South Australia During the Gold Fever ............................................................................................................ 248 Elizabeth Murray’s Ella Norman; or, A Woman’s Perils ..................................... 268 Conclusion ................................................................................................................ 288 4 Appendix 1: Female Middle Class Emigration Society Annual Report Tables ........ 296 1861-1872 ............................................................................................................. 296 1880-1882 ............................................................................................................. 305 1883-1885 ............................................................................................................. 318 Bibliography ............................................................................................................. 324 Archival Sources ................................................................................................... 324 Newspapers and Periodicals ................................................................................. 324 Published Primary Sources ................................................................................... 326 Secondary Sources ................................................................................................ 328 5 List of Tables Table 1.1: 1862 Donations to the FMCES .................................................................. 49 Table 3.1: Occupations of Single Women Arriving in South Australia, 1855.......... 138 Table 3.2: Colonial Land and Emigration Commission, Number of Adult Emigrants from Britain to Australia, 1854 ................................................................................. 139 Table 3.3: Relatives, if any, accompanying assisted female immigrants who were later residents in the Adelaide Female Immigration Depot, 1855 ............................ 144 Table 3.4: Number and percentage of nominated single women using Adelaide Female Immigration Depot services after arrival in 1855 ........................................ 147 Table 3.5: Female emigrants travelling under assumed names on the Velocity, Plymouth to Adelaide, 1855 ..................................................................................... 165 Table 3.6: Age of Female Immigrants in South Australia, 1855 .............................. 174 Table 4.1: Results for searches of ‘female emigration’ and ‘female immigration’ in British and Australian historical newspaper databases, 1845-1885 .......................... 196 Table 4.2: Results for searches of ‘emigration’ and ‘immigration’ in British and Australian historical newspaper databases,