• GOVERNMENT OF PUDUCHERRY DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT PUDUCHERRY POLLUTION CONTROL COMMITTEE 3rd Floor, PHB Building, Anna Nagar Puducherry — 605 005. *** Phone : (0413) 2201256 Telefax : (0413) 2203494 No. PPCC/MIN/PH/KPPL/TRP/KKL/JE/2016/ /03-6 Puducherry, the Illr4 NOV 7016 To The Joint Director (S), Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, IA.III Section, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan, Jor Bagh Road, New Delhi — 110 003.

Sir, Sub : PPCC — Minutes and proceedings of the Public Hearing conducted on 26.10.2016, at Karaikal, for the proposed Development of Bulk Liquid Handling Berth, for handling LNG — 5 MMTPA, by M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd., Keezhavanjore, Karaikal — Reg. Ref : (1) MoEF&CC, ToR, F.No.11-41/2013-IA.III dated 14.11.2013 (2) MoEF&CC, Extended ToR, F.No.11-41/2013-IA.III dated 10.12.2015 (3) KPPL Letter No. KPPL/ENV/PPCC/178 dated 05.10.2015 (4) PPCC - Minutes of 152nd Meeting held on 08.09.2016. *** With reference to the subject mentioned above, a Public Hearing was conducted on 26.10.2016, as per the procedure laid in the EIA Notification, 2006, at the Multi-purpose Hall, Polagam, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal, for the proposed Development of Bulk Liquid Handling Berth. for handling LNG — 5 MMTPA, by M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd., Keezhavanjore, Karaikal. The entire proceedings of the Public Hearing has been videographed and the Minutes of the same and the proceedings, along with a copy of the videograph are enclosed for kind reference and necessary action. A copy of the representation received for and against the project is also enclosed for kind perusal. An Acknowledgement of the receipt of this communication would be highly appreciated. For & on behalf of PPCC,

(M. ARAKANATH) MEMBER SECRETARY PUDUCHERRY POLLUTION CONTROL COMMITTEE Enclosure : As above.

Copy Submitted to :

The District Collector, Karaikal District, For kind information, please. Karaikal — 609 602. 1 Copy to : 1. M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd., P.B.No. 33, For information, please. Karaikal — 609 602.

2. Standing Guard File. MINUTES OF THE PUBLIC HEARING HELL) ON 26.10.2016, AT THE \It:LTII'URPOSE HALL, POLAGAM, T.R.PATTIN A.N1, KARAIKAL, FOR THE ES I ABLISIINIENc OF IFIED NATI R G,-AS 'FERMIN kL. AT M/S. KA RAINA L PORT PVT. LTD.

Shri. P. Parthiban, IAS, District Collector, Karaikal„ preside over the proceedings.

Shri. Kesavan, IAS, Sub-Collector (Revenue), Karaikal, Dr. N. Ramesh, Environmental

Engineer, Shri. Poo2.ajendy. Junior Engineer, Shri. P.Ashok Kumar, ILA, of Department of

Science ,Technology and Environment / Puducherry Pollution Control Committee. Puducherry and the Project proponent of- M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd. were present.

152 Participants from the various villages, around the Port. includinp, Tamil Nadu, have participated in the Public Hearing (Attendance list is enclosed in Annexure I). 9 participants ha\ e submitted written responses about the project (Copy is enclosed in Annexure

M •s. Indomer Coastal Hydraulics Pvt. Ltd.. Chennai, a Ministry of Environment. Forest and Climate Change. Government of India accredited consultant made a presentation about the proposal. Environmental Impacts and Risk Assessment of the project are explained to the participants.

19 participants have raised various issues pertaining to the establishment of the

Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) Terminal in the Port. A Team of technical Experts of

s. Indomer Coastal Hydraulics Pvt. Ltd., Chennai, have clarified queries raised by the participants (Annexure III). The summary or the Public hearing proceeding, 'accurately rellecting all the views and concerns expressed are recorded by the Officer of the Puducherry

Pollution Control Committee and read over to the audience, at the end of the proceeding. explaining the content in Tamil larillum4e.

The entire Public Hearinp, process have been video graphed (Enclosed).

/4, C\ Place : Karaikal (P. Parthiban. IAS) Date : 26.10.2016. District Collector, Karaikal Government of Puduchert . • GOVERNMENT OF PUDUCHERRY ANIIEM) RPS DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE, TECHNOLOGY & ENVIRONMENT PUDUCHERRY POLLUTION CONTROL COMMITTEE 469, First Floor, Housing Board Office Complex, Bharathiyar Road, Nehru Nagar, Karaikal — 609 605 X * * Phone : (04368) 231540

PUBLIC HEARING FOR SETTING UP LNG TERMINAL IN KARAIKAL PORT PRIVATE LIMITED KARAIKAL DISTRICT, U.T. OF PUDUCIIERRY

Venue/Date/Time of Public Hearing:Multipurpose Hall Polagam, T.R.Pattinam Karaikal /26.10.2016/ 11.00 AM

S.No. Name of the Participant Address Contact No. Signature

)6.,,,,,,_, t„.„ 9 04 3231 gl 7_ t---t---A 'IT

2 - T _ _5 No, ..,:i--\,.;.- A .3-4 1.54.-JA 1,5, 5-s-2-- eb ' q----

ca- 7 ),:1/2.CkAsil_511)=-C 3 ____Ie6,6,(s. clo„7.s,n,„ in-5-iu,ekk, ....___0 i,

4 A . (5--- ..4 /‘-t t_c J_, k ,2 c"--P,‘=,,,,,r, )..,,.. 1 %3 $ / le 1-(0.1

".- (4-6., tR \c

Oc 6 AiNIONPWV\i' cc,Avc-i.. c7\ ekNks--1.--t

It ... . . , it. of 9 .s-, ? 4, t P cs4k: Jp,,_trastkzi '

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing — Handling of LNG1 rv\'C °N2)6v k

-4 -k '1 )s1Q1\/ 4. q 1 it-ets -14 rr.,e 9 b Zc1Z-P--

.3-t\ '3Q7.N‘rptsi 9,1124 L-0,_ . ' S\ tr

)4 'Q-341011ckTIL(r Qt °k, 1-k11-2--6 Cjit NI =a7,79- i ii i\f a gq °`J\11 CP19 N\ G-9--A.T: 7-' kl\ rtmovY l, c,,,.,.__ \1),R im.),_._ 1 ',,e,Avv-p• 12

f kt 0\041 'Art"- t4...ctsul

13 1..3„.0.ytpv.0A-_ et91 , vairto.-- 1012_o5r359- ;-- •

g • p A- v ici-v -, i-s-yq )ti)-,‘...-54.--L---- 14 -V -0-- .69ci--- 2A 18.t-D .f.. yssi.„-c),------Csc-er---.-- 9 4-4 ic,rv•--- )

>e-rs-,,MA, 1.*:, ) A , ‘cc.a\'-vvA 1‘7.1.4,0-6 zr: ./e• ,,,,...., 15 r() Dir)-1.-N OP- 2-2.-1 4W;\;, \ 'c"\\.,-Nii-

t '2-- ‘'N.,.A---N.tqc-vz. 16 i%' (9341\ C)\0-k-t--: 9 1 G 5 2-8'26vii, *. ta -4.L. ,Nr-30.-y . 1,1, v...... \s,Q0.,.4.....A__

600,

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG2 Wir

SoOl \-SV'e-A-6' 18 IK 0 kr‘g)*, Yin; w,e\-k43", *ic9.51c?sg s-3,4, 4,.. , , 14.8e, 3zRi.attisC

, ......

• ` k''' IA ce4e((e 5-..1A--74,

20

f-vo2A4x,c-ire-e,-- ,\-s - - alck st' --y-so)A__rc>c2k gel, (Nou-4

21

22 1 -

23

24 av,t____ so,,v\iN rs ,,,,v2J-tY

9 9-dy a G 79117

iliP Cf (_,le

0,,___IA. - t/(1 , ? ) WI )(?- Cl Ai 26

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG3 ' \--ZrNlYN (yr\tNtrin ZN\ \-p-TIGLP'N k rgI 1 g:9 t7d 28

(- 5- ::). IN i' g4,, f)-,) '1-vd).\ 6•0--#) 29 t

30 O )C8SM-; „ Qin (54Lk6) _51 r&Ck- 2-,- ,z;to

, 31 N , Ho rag,m,,e04 Pi,a1--7-44,tA4 4 - i Zt-73044-20 t, ,

33 P - Q.,zie ) cuur cpcott-Tvlotcluin --1363S-.71 c---e_ I, ;

,_\s-\ J`k\-k tf\ R-----3 J 34 cvk -S\b \A-- (g\-P,5--1 tVNt Rcc.-3-,,, c*-\ , c:\

35 T1 61.4‘4r, S,)

_...... ,,

miscs. 37 iv\ . *.8,1zdt, F'Q ' E-t n to Tles 33 ‘432_,

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing — Handling of LNG4 S

38 i AP 0

39 ebM \AY)ffe ,_ irs g‘cp a,v-. C1/14

40

("5‘_‘____ (,) .. `3 1 tr cke.at v ',\t Q-,,

41 1

42 e t -‘411 Ic-\\? \_SEIV08,11 %-1L--.7P-StriG76N 981r(0/r-0) ' ''‘P?'

43

434 6NA‘' 44 d\0-62 or .1 6 q 9H-7 '229V61 A 10

45 9 i

46 sg g 4( /*)-tocp.c I grIcT ,TL,‘„

47

•--\C) r' 1-1) iitk Ci 61 ? t c Yt -C°.=L

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG5 Vi.

? lb rs qi.k, (by, f) 48 .19?Ss41A5\ 4" lat% 4-7'Cr &-ki\ 4 '

49 Pr , Norfaig

- 50 R , A ri ey,„2_1,,, ikkisc„, gc,74146517

52

53

i tSutolk-t-I citt-q-2 9:)\51 142 1` i° *10ir,,, 54 \J ' r AO Mkt() .-lk--fk -g4,,

Nal1C7\4—'

55 A • 0 kr') ateDi‘,„ T 17 4 3(c )'*'('-'164‘\C ?Th7.72-0. 4 ✓1--\v----a_____;) ,

56 V1, v,S i,753-, r; e-c ,-Th cli oq_--nok,10.1 ) A. 171A6,4);

i-(•,k oi-- ‘141/f2 1)6

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing — Handling of LNG6 w

58 sp. 12-- f'(-C*1-Cvrn

X - oq iaj - 9fxz,i a ,I1, pv (774-4-P v /9 -,/ P ' ..r

IpdAcAn VOvvv)\ P1.12.-- 60 (V))7 )1 fri ,10110'

A 61`,StWR\ 61 K-4L_- -9-t \\3) '-'?.! /(\ , ---_ii .------"---

62 '-51(1''/1\16,S'49 17-IL 1._ 1 flo-cqh-n9,3-- et ,_

(yetfpf a ThiR._29,(3(9t 63 01 .,2 , c(esg?DigT1 itf • 4, ,

64 >.,- a . ,,, et,_._c q 6 14-6- - ic7-5- s ,..,--

65 Y; g , t‘)qi'0,1,-- P-1-1-r 'T' YZ, V-Z 9 S"--ob,2.0-flo .&< J9 .)___,

66 r Ni)UCIV'llAM ttb AA-•(W)_____ % • : • kA ots 4 oimir

64 `d1 v7:9 6:4 /9N3E, P t_s. 67

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG7 • w 1,730\AAWL1Lito

g P49--r\m/tv,a,5 rr 3eit

iSr— ' M tA—CW,, , V\AckiN

\.-c.,‘i L, Pso,s,tl St 71 ''. ,Soi,vyylocoil cM6c6&2s. mech,90, \klyi 343y- cit 'r •

t /-f , g-41,4:7•74v- '

tDgx\ ---' v 9( 41J QvP 73 (CP-)`,),M g7b0-h\e'5Tpf

74 6/1 • 44,, '

75 C5Liti-73)-AC65.-\ 9 Ic 1-rSC0( 1 °' (t W' P' 6---b

76 t re 1 +tif 6-1 ci) ) V . Sl) Pocl--(\,, ev.Ni% say„ " `qQ\CNN-A e` p----uy \r-g----Q

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG8 78 '&c---7 ,tn ')-) 6v)) 9 L,_5 3 !—(c- L9 ,--r 0) -,\--D g-,,,

Imo. 81 1/. ,g (--(ci-i-e-5/0' (/ LX-Ye'7At 5'J---, \ qq'/S:Scfgh—Zi laic-`'

(I* (';* 6 82 \V*4 1 143C\ ellyv)--):\ _

n i •-G 5 dm e , N. 83 g LY3'- 'S e--`a,,

84 AZ4).444 14,\ 17 &,67„, g;-; ,ig ("))04>,-t 8760 f4Esteme, T71-t-

r I V

) 86 / , ..7..- , ‘..4. .j1 67c4i-vc

87 ,A-7_,p ltY

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing — Handling of LNG9 ..ir

88 C\cel'C''91 - 67' 'O'cg9 err -1(0- *IS7 tlig\l'00/16

89 21 W.CR)Qd5ci-tli Prs6-06\411 gt6.--wovi ol...c_ ci.nG

90 .. Arr.4 , r, e-r1),,g_-,-A , k • r.,00,---- 9 ( e-ri 21

7 .,..,,-, -) '...7 91 7 14--A-re,a s-7,,4„-\\ 72 ?1,6g,L.4 7 (7 sr ,ye

P•1\1._(\__4,, _S a7ft5 92 ‘4=z4 r-ccir- tt-4.4,.\(ilt.)------) w 1' °_5a9Z22.30,j;

‘i, ----' - et LtZ- ',67,76g, 8 c6Ifoilpairsor 93 (1-1/4S/d3Pole-,sOn 25,0097do

P 1 _ ' 8.8 0 085 c—r24j,_, 0),,,,

o. 95 I ()'•' ‘s'"--

ta tC, 6)47tOPI P2 gA VI b, b9:0

e z,_ 97

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG10 III • 07'16(3-(65) 98

, 99 ( r 11\9 40V, PM-HaPvf) iv. q 43 q435 625 0 ao\ tc\490x6— N

100 ' 1\1o\--r (x(zc* D°%- N) SC-7'3. 6'1) n( 1)-56 \ 95 4 321 %---/z0 fir, IN c.----

. 101 - —

r, 102 wch * c9—) cc" te:V3 f----

. • ' '

104 K f2. 5.fteAvoriolo !II ' '-r,Ti'l 6-bli ciqiiis-51724) V, kA,9--

105 Sr- DI GC^' tia99;‘'‘- ,C)-(l222(,),S7 ------Z--;--7

_, 9cc_,/,,m (r. 106 7.,„41:,,,a,.....„6,..ri. 75

ok. ese5-4, CP; dszVx 1°1)- 1 f*P4t lle- 6\att v1. . AI - 107 kt•fecifit I*19541g9 lf ?41146C- l.-

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing — Handling of LNG11 f 108 rj . ri).9_4, jbc,14 0-Jn(, •

109 F,(116,9 p-a-24;- 49,,,,.5 ,,j,3 . ___,_:.. .Ter ciet>0 9

110 hchL.5') CZ- r* cr; 25„,,r di ('„ 4% 5 -ikt, 23 2. 71

4'*Zi 7( q.240(.1 ,,,,- 111 tsz.,,v1 ( es e , A . S ti...... ivrn 1‹__---241v,-, Nr-t-,-; "y-e-- -4P Gtt 102',57. 8A

112 ) ) , Ply 1-N-it 9- 26 ("I' i‘ c kzek,c. 5

113

114 ar, 1 A• 114' kAki 1- BI. - 2-tt-s=)

115 x r ig-t-te-c=. , cz:.\ V Pi -F a)"\r4)-ki-N, i,

)-C) K3--.- On 0--(,%) \/ to evv,, Sc • 6Th vi sb ta 9, 6, 1-7-14- 116 m)-65-2 -,;,7. #1----

s,, e. pr,re,u-cotpiuk,u,(7 cp,--r),,itt-o-N,5„ 5,t2_3311) ,gAz\ j, 117 s p 0.33.4 j am, 9 i' /-r1

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG12 IP

118 Nj--GA CUAi S kek"\ 6\ tvC)31Ltri --T/(1-

1:, ,_ tl'SCI\L-L'i r\. 119 0 9061a4/9

120

0 L C9 r)----

4110'1161";114 C5,-( 4 412-ildS) 121 A, A kvAil),, 0.-

122 (2"Q‘j

V. 6\34 (4- 1\1_-Sl4i(41” \/)31).5 N(Yro q444qedqt,14 a 123 , -.4- i Rf=dckkW 1\158'q 4 ikois‘gl :1-___ van, ghfct‘e NrB -E- DS - iktik 0 ,c1, i9 4 ___ 124 j d i (Q)LAsx-t' Lcc4 • 61

, ,. • • •_ : _ 125 Fl „ ,'':-- , , cf gcV 1--4 kta: (c?. _qvirAt 17-01- 7 5\c, 4,429 e!, ,S 126 /9- 1\ 4 /9 f\I NV' t\if,/ b 61 r,.'f *--'' 4- Atrwi- ty j-t74,,, LS' 0-,------

r 127 9c)1‘°-Seet-4-\ 13

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG13 , gl oti-5)O9di --- -7 R42_,1 tiA) kkAttp-

129 f Pn u 9,111-01-1 E)124qP( •Kf')6'(54Yr

- 130 t( , 4„,= --csal p_.,.5v,- Q-x1'57;1 cl e0S-62MoLt ( 4i#AY .:, laid-t--

131 SC4‘r, ,V40,1\4,1 IN) OVY\;11C Ovvtkivt k C-916\) (3-)&3 1 oi -(

ii5,./p4fit4,,” 132 74 70/7/ , /2: ‘)/?.,„ r /3'.' /r R).- a/c./ 6'

133

(" ' VNI-5' G(/`?( gsg2-3 tligb:0 Tot ko 7 5 - 6.2 ci6 ("\ ' \iLf;"-Li -

134 )316751ASrlY)f G...9 6104-t) 61,,39 _,J),0-st,-.- 2 Le0/w,c4,' 57 SR) t cy-S9_ Lla, ' ‘ACIANPNL_

_ t ‘ 135 \/\1 ( )CX))4 62-)C\0fic p“-k

136 a ..„.__.21,0,,v0.,..0-cs___ 7,c7,-aQQ___c\I .2,V i______.,

137 2011gYr3S', N \i NW RI9Gin P\P,U 7 vos4,0‘vc41,65,t_.

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing - Handling of LNG14

w

138 C H uto.k fo.,iss(lIcAk, v., \ cRi?299 1 Q,----. r-\\ )-34tk tVrk7tri,e, <

..)...3L0, ‘•-_- Q.„/\___„1--- , -r- 7) _--- 139 1 ."---"--# __-- : -'10— '` 6- -, h---- ,", N 75- q.. O 4

140 90ircifca-A utAtiftics,,,-.61, 4 (T `2`c7" Oh ,

I \ ...-- 141 4 9 Y\ (,? .2,e_:,0 ip,t5,-L_er3c9c2).}1 ------c`C)L

(iv i , -

143 Nol2g:TV t\(PKGvia-C-- (5t ^ _-1(31) ckeiri=4C2eti, CT. -12,p r)t''c2'. 144

• A', 1r1 0 Ul- k•-, ' F o 2 , `IF

145

G • Eiluel C-1/4-1C24-fY Co ti- 00-4—v%) itft`A-- q 77 1 So ej,- 5-- 1p-,)'

146 *C0A)-y040,,,Epo t r'"Icv.'"' 14.--4 @R3e13ctol

1 4 7

4010 kf___tt &Illimart: " : , • r0a C3-1\- Cszit---41/1--

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing — Handling of LNG15 0 1114 . 3' 'z ‘g 431eCk /CAI-.3q q 41, 148 A Q'''t AI,. -TR'

=c4.D1A lie,IALIN-sr 149 1)4.0. .5 . A vicAtA- edct-) voc-4-- e,,,,,,,g 0 e-r 1 an NI ci 366466.454 g-j,,.. / ) t v<4.4,1/4,,,,,---i At• We're...... /, ‘414.)-

7 , EL L n qq106/`' 150 k._ „43„, 07 p,yp,-L. 1 ,z,,vt:e _94-,,,4, -2.80?9. , ,‘• .4 7, , 6„, pc,k4likyvli 4-yriz_J

151 2 tvs,L,.. cr C-(0 03\l'IF 54trizazA- )---TEt-r , -

"Ts") q`3i(16)CY,) < 152 ?N, C1&\9 ct 5)i) 1 97 C, A-IciL q3--rc,`;,-)

153

154

155

156

157

Attendance Sheet for Public Hearing — Handling of LNG16 ANNEXURE II

WRITTEN REPRESENTATIONS RECEIVED FROM THE PARTICIPANTS OF THE PUBLIC HEARING CONDUCTED AT THE MULTI-PURPOSE HALL, POLAGAM, T.R.PATTINAM, KARAIKAL, ON 26.10.2016, AT 11.00 AM, FOR THE PROPOSED PROJECT OF HANDLING OF LNG, AT M/S. KARAIKAL PORT PVT. LTD., KARAIKAL:

Few Representations were received from the Participants, for and against the proposed LNG Project, as follows :

I. Representations received in support of the proposal:

1. Thiru. K.R.Rajendiran, Ex-Chairman, T.R.Pattinam Commune Panchayat.

2. Melavanjore Gram Panchayat and local residents, Melavanjore Village, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal.

3. Local Residents, Pillayar Koil Street, Keezhavanjore Village, Karaikal.

4. Gram Panchayat and local residents, Nagore Village, Nagapattinam District.

5. Tamilnadu Dhargas Co-ordinate Peravai, Darga Market Lane, Nagore.

Representations received against the proposal:

I. Keezhavanjore Grama Nirvaga Panchayat, Keezhavanjore Village, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal.

2. Thirumalairayanpattinam Consumer Forum, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal.

***

tA/ 1.)) 2_L n 4 t.J(‘

t:o

'L'tfj'AX,j

0%. Ariz.

6' 40 €11114,

rift„ RUT& C4,747—M(Starril K. S'APALITi fg), • f;-"P7 tUSTAT, ofiu.37-.3K 61-1.11-97)11t7dt irfctrif ,4 A 4315081' 6529 97839 98290 9snoo S942'1

. : . • r e (-1

ot, salary 300 650.5 195150 food 64 650.5 41632 Tea 14 650.5 9107 245889 Rk Baskaran Labour Contract payment 245889

411( ojefhatixt ffirr6-rilLutbwak zgamaaT Gwa) urrgtrt *Trip ugffrrit4wrri-E66-ir wk3lib &prumuilffisit

&AV 6)1Ffg60 ECT-rnb, $3. utipo-th.

EbrF66)9A6676t wrruLLth

Guoi6i) :

2_u_Jr.r$3 uprruLL ,91L6flu_it a61111-6561-r,

ffirr6mAEbri-6t. MUST,

ffirr6-m-Ebffirr6t wrr621LLth CLe6v@in-gtri. E61yru46nM Gun-wiA666fr1rEgui

LivEfGarfl .0JEF,Ew6i) td6nm u*aLb LorrEfiffiii@iliurrL (TuD,Lb, 27.09.16

faerol $661.11)6Vi. G411.1$ rr6616) ffirr6/50,66a6i) ti6uu6E.Lb aLueDEE. oflurral

6DE6Lurr LI$LIJ G1511J6i)&66)W $L1L$675)661 a6/161-1-1 ,606)JacrF

6TrrrEE.$061r 4rrLr1:6 2_00-1$51Jub U3fO1 41-fl$zi Gffirr6s6-TCL1rth.

601ftli 61166611.51 '86@f4)1 1. _06nE6 6rrfl6vrrui6)16z T1r6i) Guriltn ,a6r6)S16t 6),I1L4] Outil ,,9160-1T6i) U61)

&U)rr LEL L 1r EF0m6TT6)16f1611 661D-rruAlE6Lb uAFEsii) urr$0u6/5)LtE urria_iyozilLrr?

2. 4rfiLrrup6i) 616/16116RE6LLIFF6lt urrtiffirral Ourr@EbEiT

GiERLILLICJ CurrdAi-666fr,

3. a$LL4$6-arr6i) 6)-401Lb aurranb, 61S1u CUrT6Z06Z1)61 6Jf uLLrr6i)

,91061F661 (5Fa46i) 6)J5$E66iT G1511_11

4. 6-11E6611V 6gpu4$6-isr(y)66TC65-0m$M

68r6unnE66.fr GEFuliti Gurr36-Trrrruth CLabuL 6-T6tDEbin

$LLA1EE67r GECLLI6tUOiLl@li)? 5. -1C_L4$66r(r6i) uutt516uNivn_1666t. 6rrflGurr36m-rffi

[email protected] fia),E)E66115166-r uuithrurr@ 6u)m$5i ,916zirrr6i)

611511E611-61Alffi6616t r 16\IFE.E6IfiliT6bErT60. 6)- uth Lama' ffilla:_IL.030.Jul.i.„(6 a0obece&w6i) &Dibu@tb 6166TU6)) CE66t6/11E1U&ilWrilb.

$1C__1416urrr6i) E6D-rrnb LDDL'o ,9166)6o-r EFO rT I p__6fr6Yr u$E€,6-616t fi6-opti G1 416-i) 8LrEB6fr @A EC ,D.16o-rrr6i) u6A) Cu3E6

to°6)J6b)6) 6)J1llJOLIE6611 LDEt.6666166T GLIfT361-Trffipb CLOWLALb 6T66T01 thi_1(561Grrt.b.

7. 9) -1L11_416zsrrr6i) Lizonu aj.thE*6 6)JgLon-6-cab Lb, C4D61)Lb

LDEEE5e5 U60 6?if6t1)LIJEE.6iT &ID-Eh umb 6J (Y 6)JITU:JULI6t16T1t1 6T6-6-Tg i.b1_4661GmErLi).

,91606)J, u_.06n66 erfl6)Jrru.4 L_01 ,901$bGE6rr&R4L416t ,916arrr6i)

6r62161ilwrr6/11 urrAiLith 6J fl" @Jul 1_4 6t6-6)61) 6T66-rm1 LO ab 0E66)1th

urrvEurC_Iurr6-o-rtd 6rftiti) ,:9-01$v GE6rr6GLrnb. 616zirC6y all_J6D66 6rflurru_066)65r

65),Ebuirr6BM Eur 6WEEE51F60 516/DMUFBCO

cwilauGnorthitb 6U 6a)6\) 6r6trg rf164t1 Gffirr6frECCrrth.

ct9-t aniv)

- 511 witfklia `uvCst.

V. • C-04O—S cts

(1°

v)

8.

G-14) 46) ki_b

) 1 • A • f),(AA; ) 1‹ • goer-) r?-/2 1-1

1 3 Plash-6P

4. R

c 1/4 .0\ND •

Tra0 a-33 6 cur, . Av --itxx.

S • _1 14,1.c4c9--c-c?, -

23, ,t,,-.1-fctost, c:( Vrinceo,u14-

,c-p , qsAtrrr6„1-02, sio

•• ce7a,t,

c>-Thi N (PIN I r\16-aff LA F"OcID-rOcN P2

2-; 67. 6s. 69.

9..

Rp-trg' T17°

6/1 6/3) 61) 611111111014E6611 Go& rr .661 Lut,E66-tfleir Gurrooirrrrr9-th CEDCDU&b 616zirg

7. 9:,$11_11._$6srrrot Lamm auff,665 ugwrrgab an$1b, coab uNtEE.E.65 1161) m6res)u)E66fr ,919-(sh op6lAb OuL @irrifiCi146tiffitJ 6T6dfa

L.1314E6lerrtb. ,91E6C6)1, u_06-nE6 grflurrui L001 6ilffrufly ,90$tiGffirr6iscirt416i) aftsurrr6i)

6r6i164Lorr6rsr urr$C.iyib OuL 6urrtinli 6i) g ) 61) 6r66rotb u51666*

urrtdffirrOurr6ary 6-r66unb ,901$t1 Gffirr GstiTCL oitzau LIJORD65 arflairruidoxiar

6DE61111T6)1 E5rD6wi.ffirrot v6ts)mg,E5d) oirEsE.E.65

graitb 6t6um 6166-r Grf16)1151 Gffirr6trE6Imnb.

bc uu[96E.5

\re Lesit2.37.0119

)4144—

CD4-Af.,,J La:d\o‘cr • a:4

1-ULttAl,

\,€.1w_,))-,,)?n4)41 140

6r)017fUot, 0 (3cZ

A

v s,%1C_L416-6T1T6t 61fiE561 E61fJ rriffib L.ftilb ,9165)6-01 6hg P___6i1611 LI vff PE)666i)

1675)WL/J Go errao,i_r666tr a6)J(rE61 ,91661FT6i) U61) CI136.6 C6)J6D61) 6211T11JCJLIffi6rT 6TiTLTE61 LD8E56ii16&E Gurrao-arrruth CLotbu@Lb 6-H61-g Li)LIE61Cmri-th. sa,11:_L416-urrr6i) Lizonal aD-ffre 6113wri6 ub a4d), 66Tcy)61)(13, LDEE.E6 S E.6C U61) 6616tDLDE€46fT ,90-ffi covth 6J ,f 62JFILI:JEL16t6115 6r6-(kg LiDLIE61Cmrrtb. 9,) arflurral a_u&iirr661Eiurr6t u6Tb,61)n-rfl, aga,E€.7 urrE661SIF1Eb6(i Curr6rm

L2.Ef6t L*Dth GuLer61516urrr6i) auJE.5650u@th 6117,E66Z5116661TCy3, 6ab Ga16-610u&i) Li6DEbu516arr6i) EhftVctw6i) WrfthLA6?J5 L.110E6r-r6vrE66•616) Ehftlecffiw6t 2LabLaLiD.

86 °0621, au.06nE6 61116/HUI LOg 61115711t1 ,9(11 ref iGlffirr6-6616i) ,c9i6o-rrr6i) 6r65.16211Lorror urrOjyth arriii__i 6t6D61) 6-fe6rath uslE56)0 urroffirrOurraTtd 6ifromb Gffirr63AL-Filb. 6r6-a-au alLOGRE6 6r116)1rni46)516n6u 65)Ebuirr6)] E61T6Wk,E61r6i) 56--nuEE.Lip 6irisE5Q6 ,Et. 616ii6)51 ,w10EFu6n6aultb 9.)6t6n6v 6r6&rg Grf16)115 Gffirr6frECCmrab.

• 2,

Fi 7 t°3

a " C3— )6viZ6‘L

q , teemt;c44/

cV)-

,

c,A) 347') vg,rwAfFair\ o_ir)

,4 Pcuf-ruic f? 51,) ectA,; Ufa M, W-vat,t-jfv‘ .

1111406zirri-6i) u6Nrililsurr6zirE,55 6-161Gurr36nrub v_____LaurrEthu(i`Oiu(i`tb fi6vtEbrfluS168r um66run-$ (613)m$ti ,916o-trr6i) 6110rEbrrwri666T116i) 161)66.E661016arr6i) Ou$th Lyra, Ebt.I$Ciu$Oui...1 ffiftiiftw6b Utbual 616dru6iD effi6frdluu$6414rrtb.

ff~$1LL.406bffT6U artE66i-r Eglynoth ,9160)6zir ffi0 2_61TM U5$E661116t 16-cs)mu_i 4416i) (Ern.LrE66fr E456-o-661 aieggrr6i) U61) Guo&,5 Ubs15)61) 6vriin:114656fr o_fiairLrrE61 Gurroffrucruth triLbu$Lb o-E66r9 tim_idGmrrtb. lE_L_Ml6arr6i) Lawou a9-6h(st. 6)Jown-6ani) aft$6), sp6lAb Lo,E6E6 61 d u6-1) 6iIT615)u)666i-i uamb 6J 3U 6)11111JCJLI61T6115) advrab i'Di4E61Tma-Lb. u_065)(s6 grflairral P____uGuirrEgliJurr6i) u61i),6vrril, ()ff,st( r ij 6)111-E560Tf65611 Turr66-rm L2ff6) we Lb GuLICf9-5-61516armi) (1St 65 u ib 621n-Eb6cgra,6-fr go-oLb G6m6iiliju$Li) Li6a)6515165-rir6i) EfiWFetw6t LorrEhu62J5i arg(*sFffiw6t Li).Lbu&b. 4E6 , Lu6,5)(1. grflurral ug ,901$tiGE6r1-66611416i) ,DiEzrrr6i) t.crr6ur urr011* 6-juL 61)66)61) 6166-r(l b u51E6620 un-51ffirrCiurrizr& 6-rfRirmab ,901$v Gffirr6FirCLrrth. 6-16Au 91, UJ65)65 6T 616)J rruldlo-D5a 6-6)6buirr6)JM5 66rr666ri-6i) vaDx.y)E5th COIM15i_JUM5 6TIFE.5 6r6ii6211 4LIC6fu60)67sru_ltb 9)6i)65)6A) o-r6tWg G0164v Gffirr6i-rd1Cpub.

.1.111fr

J.M. 5,6)rr.66-r Wrrfia) GUITV#GEFLU61)11-6111t

61ufbtbrrucaurffiedrru51 &man, ES LAD' marfluithuNirr comma, vilarraflaninixar ORD6001

;ftweinragribrir • 11 Jaw Oieurreb uagszaw/01

Avairr6erber- 611 002. ;Bo-uLy6arti), ffirreogeteursb.

R.K.inraluitcrak K. ItzAownrit R. (wolBergfeir tbn6enu-DO6offtrr tfi* otscoso6uir Wrimoirsirir 61urraysormi 95787 31074 975081 6529 97889 98290 - - -

128

ingth LD6601611611th urti_16tpum_irr60r Tft 6116un-LiGurri.b! .ffirri_Ourrthl! (9160)w1IGurnb!!!

P___LuftA5. wrraiLL f:%Lgluir, a611ri.E561-r,

Giurreth : arFiiffisir uUs & ei(561irrE6 2._.6-46Tr Liquefid Natural Gas (L.N.G.) 6-r6iyw Grrflarru_lomei 615ILIUJ 6.11)L 621105E6 G62J66010th. GiDgth611.)L6-151.E.64:6 061.16601 0th 6-1-6aTuth, 0160) 0661T6b 6ruLnpuuLL_ 66T60T6bE564 6-r6iTru dirfleirreb 9-1_11uL06.46-n-0.

zurepo-zizrrd) wrran_a_th, et.:JuL4260rth GiffirrLin46&r,446-lirr6ffbri- z@g-ITUD6i) LIJIT;RE 6/1(Lb ffirreDgsizrr6i) 06-0)0.E66i) LNG 61-6-8-w Grrflarru_i 6-1Orr6i) 6r1FilE664 Glurfltu sz%uod gebuOth. (420r, E61tu wrrffrurr®, 9t.E660TG6IJ f 6utiffirflu_06i) zuribD (),60§DCD ur*IlueDLitti Gipsth ‘5 LNG arflarru_iap_b Guit 51-61JITEf a1gifff615)60TE664, 616/1421:R1 A6-tig.62Jrr urrogurCiy G1uu_irfl61) ffirr61i6)0160), ,5L61J42.E66IME5, Eb6U6i) urrogunii glimp 61-661-D GwyllifiE5 LD60)mgmbwn-Eb U60 dif 60T 6i) E6 E6 2_646rmg61irrth. .4.01 agefr c91ffirrrfltEszi. 2_600111-611 41-61ILDITE6 GlrflNElab 611f161JITU_160)611 61160) fl GIEFLLJLIJ G611600TLITLb. 6Trr21E664 GE6FTrfli660)Eb613)11J saw LEflU_ILIIL.16111.1) G61.160bILITLb. L.N.G. 6T1f161HTILI GIEFLiJ61irr60 g.,6u0L.i) ailuirrunvOci) (616,- Gyfl ag :JeDu 6)51L) Glurroupistis 6UFTtE*6 uliJEtpu 6T66rD 61u1TglanibE664 airrrurr Glrf16-1110.11.6 Glffirr6i-r&GrrLb. 016116Urth Glefrr6bwiD G61160)60 611FTLEIL1 6T6i.)61.)1T1b 6666bi 0160)LIILI 6166TD GIEFIT6b611 ,th GlE61T6Obil.pe4i(tLi) 0160),D(.9E6GLD ffrittfl. 06/3),D0666b 9(D 61,VTg51,b5ii-E,Lb 6-0)611 9GO. Ebn-9-600160176i) 616D 61r-rg516u1T6Tilt56iT uLL_ z66142L1Filimir G1urr6b6D omillurr L.Drra) eiger (9101LDOELE. AbGL111-0 fL urTo86rn:mAD oi6o)tu&sEst.b. 86-0) ,DETr&E66iT G5g142LIJITE6 un-ri- 06i-rgarrn.b. c9 9-6r(9-10Ebrrrflzb.i, .4.01 6r6b6Drab Ori-GurrsE6Lip

biiipmgmbnrbi) 1-,huaLi) urrWmjaidrir

et; r-F;JGEb 6)J,Glurrgo 61urr01Lptit564 tbe& f5146).116bez6o. ge 616DrilL_Lb GuelailLO 01eppG34:56) e16cDuDiEziJuLL01. 616Ourlo Glurrgdwe'5E6 6UFT i6 rei0z6 061)&01 is(6).11Tft4b6iT 6166TU rflU rT . 6161w66o1 .I., kat, u4rthurr 61-613TDI 8,D/ELD 6T681.DJET68T 61ffIT6oT60TO1 619-ErLb, 016CD,D&E6ri-6-ain15()Lb. 61UFTOILDEk661T1TiELLJ ,51TrF;m66iT 6116kb6i-r 6/116CDGIT6INFambeDGT1060),UGDE5Ab 61ffirrOGrrib.

/6/

0615)D&8b OrairrEbQp.b. g6-iyi-DCSLD .4.6060DeD. 060),D&ffin-6i) 6TET:iJ 836ir Li16{r6076Trzb61T u51(

561, cyp&Er u)306-ii6-mg urrft66E6 G61.]66tyripuJ. 6/761) 2_646-rrtd.

6151621ffrriL06o) 6-ig51:5rr6i) ErrF;JE56h- EVgriuxb(13urroi ffruirrft 120 GLIE'ftbE.5 ur.ra.EbeDg.

6tbL61ffirr6Zur(jr 61T6TTO. J60)r~T rr W 16-461-fl 6)5161Q-Lip. 6re 6131.Drr6D-r&Lb 6b676D. C1361.161D6DLL1W ..4,606)60. sECgrrup673-) 6frbOlgLiD G-Irr451beyrreD6DE56-4. (%6OTIT6i) anrEkgr_r G61615)60 .4.6be3)60. ri-rr;JEb6i- -r 6-r6i3Terr(5C_14gn- 61560 60 04211W. 45 61R461510 55

6/111J6i) o_646rr6ii11E66* 65161)5rru_n_ip LDLOGLD 046-116-ffiGh. (Di:J4rfl6i) et1.11J9- 6i) G61161)60 616Flini.1 LJOILDIT? irri-errekbe_Wiurr allyrilLuTIALI)q).

GL_DE56o-b-1L Ab61E56b6DITLiD 61unaLlu1reyr W1r E5LOtliurrLCFj 61.1rrrfliuLb 61urr6b621eD GE5LLr-r6)

4EFENTfiE.5E5IT60)11J CurrA016i) ummfuuuti CurrEiirru ugDGILDrrgil LWTLJEE, 6/13EV,D01. LiD6CDg3, Gurr6b

(6151016iT6IT ,t6-1)iEbrfl E5IT,b616i) l_19-611EeW;d 6T6i)TU GI EffT681-601.1T6i) 611CrE564 Use:MU 61160)60615)W 15 LEL' Lft

~WfJJJ USgideD,D&EBLi) EU:4211061W 6T6iTTD LO6i)(EeDrrii-tbar. aCJuyusi.6-o-Trr6i) urthy LDET611LL

Q%Ltfluin- GE5u6-)thr 61-r-Fi1 E564 Lgg-n-LD6o-)Of ffr,b0 GE&E660)61T LJIT(T&LiD, 6rr-F;18561r 6-16460)6TFE560)6TT 611TL:( urrrroiLi), 2_6=611E660761T urrr'roLiD u-runii) airu

6T60TD GIEFIT6i3T6UTO GI uriLLilit? c9i rr EE,11-613T sz9f1V1F;JEE.6.4 LD,bDli) LiaDEUJULT;1th6TT 61TFilffi6ifiLth P_EiT6TTO. ffirtD LorreyrurrO .46b60)61). ,D6b6D EbrtD 6-16-(Dgiuu06-i-rar a6rr6).51G6o 2_61I611.01 6166-rD 61urrEsime,Dn-ri-Ebdr.

60DT6ILIJ Glurr3LEssrfl6b 60EbEbr-fl 6fi60)6crr 6obriLi) ,Drrt-Fiumir 6T6/16/167611 36rrr-rEE .43e66eGurrLip 6r6o-rD 61TF:i1(beD6rr 6)J INT oi Grfl6i) 0thifT6iT611611Lb. aeLby

&066Li) 61r6TT(y)31-FiJECDE5EbEE&DU60)11J un-LialL(ppLurro. &31-F;i675-Azt6-(Drjmu_i 60-rfr) c%0, LINTOEblb

113,1,Q01 61511_1L J. 09,61161161T611 u1r0Juffi6fi- (1 5 L.13, p)- 60)60T Grfl6i) U T1t 60ffirrrflE56i7 GlunbeJo

610711_111_11r?.

I_Jr1- 1:1GLJ 6060)61) 6T6oTIDI 61u1f6boiLb LINTUr Eb1_101:11Jf1-0 6INTIflUiLiD 6J661- 6I1T-1E6611 EgMTLID56D g(D 03,61D,D EkiL L1J 611 G15L1Jui61516060)6D? 6) Jrnihun-E5 EbrtOthr 6i6TreD61 (DLi) wrrth tbLOC_JurrLO 6111[4111JW Eer11TLn6) 6J66-1- sEbITAil6oT ca611EEE5 6)516060)60. Guw.b wrreRE6E5LVJurrLO

6I1rtrfliuLb Glurr6bsLb 61616rflCuJ E0-f1u_JrrE6 L.DrrffrEbE5L u un- L@ -gD6-)J6-0T6CD 61E6rt60o-r c%Lii 611 6-r6olu G1arr606151 (9i0E.56/3),E6 tD67J6o-rAb g(DQ.y)61D (%L1.J611

618L1iu_IWGun-0 go E6uL5t.b QTurriL 6-4LiD cpthru 6DL5Lb cp6i)Tu rtD6-11601. 06CDDgiE6 ii-arrEab uegmb 6IE5FrOuurrE5 upriffrE.E.86L@C_IurrLC6 airrrfliud) ffoluEeruo. uerarth 3L.b go

6-11JIT*Eb Q91fr 6560)45L_Drr?. 6J661- go 61116-do-r0 tD6116CY1- 60).EE..

61E61-160bTO 61-1FilEb64 EegITLD,th673),g) c% L611 @if li_11.1_161516b60)61). ALIGUITOJ 61160)9" 6J60T 6TIT;16564 EgEJITLD613)

(%(11611 615lL1U-162516060760. wrriffi-E5E5La.:JurrLO arrrfliuLiD. 6T6C-)6UT(yD6CD,D LDOIE.6E560)61-1 ap-efrti. asiut_ii6-0-Frrwb LD.EbEE,ITLID6i) LDIT5T-E5EbLOLliun. -Le 61Jrrrflu4Ab LDSI6M6/1 GlEbrrOC_Ourab Grels-rueD e0.• r-F;ial) un.01E.baffirre-46Pgp-rL.b.

17/

LD6SPD611 61LtDgb. 61Lbn-6dol-L 06cD,D MLurrE6 615116triluirrE5 6TivilEbar ECMTLJ*60)

c%LiJ 6/1 @&L& 617F;JE661T gEbiTif1611),E5E560)67 GEbLI 9(..T rT6O)619TUF LDrTrT i GEE.L&E 61 Eur6i-r&Grnia. 6TrF;LE56IT gGg Cffir-rrflE66w6 0161D03,,E6613) 6@grrLID6C1) 6/911:GL ad.DaDa)GILudycurr 13oaffirfl, arflairru_i (LNG) ..9,.EE.(u4 61Eninti 6151 LL1 rFi1 Ebb T. 6-i116).0 G)42LL16/916b6M61) 6r6Dr fT 1r606TrFiJE56CD6IT writu L46i) 61-1- 56iT Gffin-rflei,6-cDE6. Lb11.1-Fikb61T U6D LD016.6Eb613)6TT aLb11.00J 6)f L' bGur-ro

LerT,E5 6)J061r61r (9i6rrrfltb61-r 6)Sft LD06111TE, g,bD go , 6i)61) Ar'r MEI LID rr GE6LV6 61Ebn-6a&G,Dn-LD.

urrp- 6519- Lprfl6iir E66m-611 tnii_J60)Lnuirr6-o-r urrp- Lip 61-6-iyrru (tfriiiaDup

03 L L Lb) 6(3) rr Li* 6i) Er0loiLiD, 6467 D611671-F;kb6i-i Gmfbaffirr6clurt___rr? 001 6060)61.).

EflOtu Eep-raD6-o) uriLigaDu_Jrrffi 61D6-103,EbE66orran? 06-o-)yosEbLb. Gleni_wrCrE66-rm?

OA 6b613)61). ,DITFFiRE,G6IT 6FrO.)111L100- .36.6 GlEbrrGobi-CLab. 6i6o)6fr61kr._,Lb EbL 1L1151L 6/JU 6T6i1cD 46U)ffj

el6D LorrelfluirFEbe-(r @ffirrC60)g)gd.- 6EFri_DAb EV6TD4f);brr?, 6b6-CD6D. Ebrrg6-czni)

,c95i6a)01E5LiD. ,DrriT;m661-1- ,E6g51ua1LW 6lEsrrOE6E@GrrLb 6r6i3TD Glurr6b6151 100 6151(50 150 65u511:JaILLb

LDLISQuDi E6L426-7n-CrE6dr. 6U 66-1-06) 60 6-E(jt Eb 6V~EEC thg51ualL 61IsEF 606CD61). E6g51L51L0LiD gLIJLO aticaliu6O)Lu_516b ez5Lipiurr6b 6r6b60rrth 6191LL0. E6g5ltiaL 61J E&.4.6b6orrrr6b

60 6ELL,Q6i3T 61U6krEb6H @LOLL LD601-2_613)6116i6f06.5 (961-11TEe 6.113EC,DITftEb6iT. ,Dr-rfri1E564 61ILL115

61J6Triree1 610'6161)a. (B DO) 6b (Eba_1r60 06-cr)(y)E6Lip LE•Ly.E6 6lz6n-066Lb 6r6Zyr(T J ffig5le'stErr(rE66i-r. 6TTF;1 Eb61r 61516tio-r6utirCiu6w 6)510&un-ftE66i-r. 0J6/3) fT~06E.LiD EbLip 61516b6cD6D. 6r66-ror (9-iffirrrfl.E56rfiLLi) gliaD,D0E6Li) Eb L SI U L 1 L 6) JU P 6461T0 61-thrD 4:9-1061D.E6 P 660T66)LD , 613)61) 61-66T6OT &6 3T fT sz9,bLiJ6/1 GIULLI ILI 6151606CD6D.

16)6016-0)65 Gurrri- Gurro 668-r6o-r6b6561T 2UIT6) 06u)DooffiLi) 6-miliE56(T2f_Trezi. L51,UQS 6FraL5FT Gurr6b Lni-r06)51LL0. of;•673)6-ur- Ety-OGrrDLi) urrruiLb Guff&

Lel r~F C611p56m6D-ru_5160 6,; (56th (ptbo-o- 93611(r urr(rod 671T-ii.E56iT L_IrFiLE56-1-r gr-FA

p.)6aSIMGrub.- 6-1-r&564 P GUOTCF611Eb60)6FT yrf1NN 61Ebr16thr 6-rr-FE,Q ,D6i)61) 641 E5ITLOFFEE.G(T. 6-rrFiR564 6106F6-m63r w&rDLi) Ebrr6)51141 61056cD65r Gurr6b 6061D61). LDLLJ, LDIT. 61) agffrw,

016(Du&cb(y)L:o , 60)6-cyr_brr6b 6r6b6brab &Al clutimJC_IuL6Drilb. @urfliu g6-o-rDLip 61ffiLliii

u_16-Drroi 6T6iYFD Glurr6b6Dan6b 6-n-rEb6-ED6-rr 61TF;kbdr a161-r6cp6rrEb6cD6rr, 6r1F;m5,64 61Ebrr6Ef Ebr-r6bLi) L 60 ,D6b0L6-6-r 61.m4) 641 61efiLaLirritb6-T. E2601-:11 ,111LJE5 ,DITL1426i) 3ffiEGG,Dr-rLD 6T6CgrD

r&op6u1-611Lthr 619 fTg) 641 61(fibu_1iTiiffi6h- (%Leluiri-ffiG6Tr. /8/

6113 ,E@ 2020 Lb (9,b6dur Gf (%6db-r 6-r66-r , 916CD 60T 6113 Lb a675-)60-ro

2_113 (T.E5Lb 6/J11 r5 6-1145-i 61EfLLJU__IFF;m561T. 6Or01.

LIJOYEE56/3)6TT 6Irr6(3)61) t__W (FAX)cp6Dux5E56-11Lb, OD-Li2LUITE56/1Lb 16 aL 1 6iTG6rr1ab.

umpz:b,

wG3nrr4i- E63-aup Giurrbitnakb4rt

u4cfnriujr,rrrira,AT

fT

,5666i) : (:-\\ 1. LINT 613:C3T 1_6 601 11. u c916thE661T, PIT61,4L9 - U 61166T , Lit161L6i)661 ,aC16615°. 2. wrrob-a__61(q). urr t_Sup(r. &16116-656iT, yo@usbasi A.6 1.B • 3. GLD ED 60TIT60") 61) ,z9kr.r, (91eirrE564, 9-1rE2u6) J6r, Liti&Gurfl

4. Lnrrekryu51. (y:, 61)6opup&ffr'r a 611 li-E6 6.4 , yoiGurfl.

5. 2_Lui13. (rp6i6MLID 61ffui6urrarn- a61Jdr.E56iT, 613)61)6(DUDif GIEFLL160E5Lb, yo&GEf

6. (yD66-reDLD 61ffui61)17 CF a61irffi61r, grrE*2 U 611 66T Lizi&Gurfl

7. mr-rekialu51. LIDOLJ 616a)LithEni. 6161irE56-4, eYrui_k_iuiftr-buD6i) L_Dut.13, Efi-Ebrrg31- 061D, yo61L6i)6151

8. wrr6uiiryL151. Lnrc&D aLlu6i) uprbDLip 06-zpruopE5 c96-muD&EFEi-, (916-thffi6i-r, yoifGEf rfl

9. 2_u_iro. 511rrL LINTOJLL c%Leflu_J6-, (96)JTTE56-4, airraWAE51F6i)

10. 0._iur-1- 3. LINT Er E*5 Eb u1T aurflu] (91ffirrrfl, a611 (TEb dif , (615 UJ 61) ft) yogiGurfl

11. 2.u_1(ro. L_DrrffrE5ffiL. LJUITL: (9iEurrfl, aariffidr, (@ffiumi) 8jrr6wc.6,ffirr6b

12. LD fT6OOT Li U51 6191 ,d1) U L 142611T 6.1, 1Ff L LD 66T ,D r1j L11 al T Cr 611 (1-Eb 6'1T,' - U Lipool Lb.

to2) z-A/1

1 ao S1615 IlphDILD bieD,DvE6 11110111166 threkb uNiEb i0)6661 Lurthuth

611-i4fifEi @mut 6m61uirruuth

k • 6)(91c )r)1"" 14 61j)-44 61 a c • g. ;")

-2 • I-1 .L.; tprys---rUi cs---rs P - b,6'- c,,T,

-k i7 z 4 Th i0JJ7f(L e_ __ __,,, _ _

P ---„-,n is 6) 3-1(1 Li-) n.:--, :2,,,fdivii.-1 \I ,-.).e-,--) 2 ,--A;, • k/ i ( h 9 k.- <;,:,a,-,41,-,7- 1 .____ (c1,;d,t-31 T aA 4 W rt-, t-_. r? rr-r>„,;1 v,_ Nc,..„e_.____A „, 1.z • Pi-n-; f' e e--gsn on I ,L - ,9,, ' 6).6\,,---___'_____- LA , V k ,4•1 (Y1 A L.k , — _X- 'N S ' At\kt)(x 1;ftA AL-0621140 -3.<_L,-11,Accifr- 1\A , ,,, ._15.1__EiE(5g- rn.5c5rrr - k.-- Ga‘Na\A.).6tNYI - .trt-v. 4 t k...____,

P9'1-1-1 ti F.:' Aft trC) 0Y,CL_C:IK /(1,.-- 1\1 i HAJ1/:$),:00,0A N ' 14 t.,! , 0. 00 c7. S. Ciiilt I,Aq,#-----

0 (7

.ihol(l (,) 0 u 6-1,,,,t. q=tr,„564,)0q6.51,1..,- - ri - M-- Ia. ccojci3O Fr°

• - ". ' 4) LI , ' `"":,';,.

/ / k-f,,, -.9 .`,:•:. -\\

• NG Ufairratapai .tbS166 u),buti) braRpg366 u1riitiEb61r , • Eftipups,thu)rrffi ElDbGlitirriluti) . .., . '',7-d ,; •,,,,,i,. (4, ,.-.,... ,t, • •.,.. •, -,,-,... ,.•.. -,,,,--;`;,''' al . 6T657. — 61Laufr GIDE5611IJITI:JULb

— P1 IN1 M' A ,E) _.134p,f4yhhi4) 1..A)PN:40 i

iv, .s4, • I\47 (attidi il e iLj_._ 4 i'0)

, l3Vi LU 1L, ---2-•__ _ , 5t ilp --, , Pi 65?tt mit T 'DAM WIN A MooR FR y , I' • aticliLiftt yyzelAkti u- v.N A Nfiz..1.-061 A,/ V - N • ....------, iia 1 n - - - e 1 Ail :)- '0 ,

-HS tk i 0- 1 L-U-nq R-R --, A, 5.FT , 0 to- /2--pA__ ...... ,.

R 4 Plil NIA y ( _asa./....,...... /...,---; .

ono giq Li f) 1 i 0 gici IV

,,, - - f : ' - • -, --, ei; ,r.r."., . 4 li : •,.., ." , :-*:!..: .t . N , -- - -...... k:,*. ;AV. ' 7 ,'-'`!"

' . ' - ' *.• r (°! r, //V ifr:A11.0 IF-,e tV/

- —

PERUNTHAIAIVAR KAMARAJAR STATE AWARDEE - 2008 THIRU.MALAIRAYANPATTINAM CONSUMER FORUM CD OAINED6u36ogrriuGiirutipainlo wasirGenrir ingiesib Regd.S1.No. 215/1989 No. 40, Market Street, Thirum2lairayanpattinam - 609 606. Karaikal (Dist). Puducherry (State). Cell : 94420 18534, 94435 25782, 80125 57777, 94436 54185. * Ex-Member- Central Consumer Protection Council * Ex-Member- Pondicherry State Consumer Protection Council * Member- Karaikal District Consumer Protection Council

Date : 26.10.2016 Honorary President : 61u0A56b M. Rajadurai, B.A.,(SR C.O.M.P. 1. The Member Secretary, 2. The Collector, 3. The Managing Director, Puducherry Polluction Karaikal District, Karaikal MARC Port Pvt. Ltd., Control Committee Karaikal-609 602. Keezhavanjore, President : 3rd Floor, PHB Building, UT of Puducherry. Thirumalairayanpattinam. S. Ravichandran, M.A., Anna Nagar, Karaikal District, UT of Puducherry. Puducherry-605 005. Nagore PIN -611 002.

MUJET, Vice President : urrfrou : 1) PPCC 6)516MbUgLi) : 27.9.2016 05nD6Dfr, A5641ffi6i) &ma:1y No. 707/PPCC/KPPUKKUJE/2016 A. Kadirvel, Retd. Teacher ) PPCC 61ffiu6w)6cDp /heififfiii) sfh6i). A.S. Ramesh, B.B.A., 3) 61,56isrwl6D5jaffirrarr uWai wrrefai6 &la:Jun:0 @irrrfluitb, 61562yrwlo-orniseaffirr6ur 00111.1 Uth6D11) OrUurruab &06i250§61ffistraport616 " W6 aL6D ffftieew6i) 2016 " 6-roirp,66men516bE6(55.rtii@, uMrflezffi 61,74 Secretary : 23.10.2016 ,66tsr,6,,6, ffi6i) &60)6turiig R. Gunasekaran, M.A., 61urresir : ffirr6Duiffirr6i) waft& oimposti) (%Luatiffi 6rrfl6)1rru4 amturre,56 6r6Zfrp ystu 61atu6g6top$LIL_M5 26.10.20166 61urrop8thr iLeObjg &mai (70.1.4$6 - ffrimb ffi(5,65i 61,5616)51A,56 - E64/0) L.60L61142i60)5 C6)16Ezi@561) Joint Secretary : R Varatharajan, Retd. VAO. etDaDournimisru46arti) ffithr6141.pfr urruth 25 eieLrLehi66 eimorreh S. Veeramani, M.Com.,B.Ed., 61urroja6 ffi6ir 66tr)m5f6iS)6Tr GLYTihffi 0560)61161ffli.10 eigeDm§. licrai4W6b L5lUeff60)6151-6B60)61T Efi660LE51T6i5Z1flA0 fg01.11 L6111cak7D656661T 6T051 oleaGmrrth. 6rgrarr6) 61)60Te6e,6 godr 6r@o6i-r6rr ffirremu&arr6b wrrfr& 06tDAypehth 61ffirruiry AoiLth chlaturLehoir ffirburf1681- CLE6INT6UT E66)J6t5TA60 Treasurer : 6.18 rreiar@ 6-115&Gprrth. N. Ravi, M.Com.,B.Ed., ffirraDu&ffirr6 wrr6IILLth, $eumt:o6Durrtu6irruc_qarrth 61ffirribtL.66isr uffrrt4,66i) eyro16,55 .6i) urr$Uy c9-i$E6th. a ffi uoL.96i) a_shoir arretr'r egurriD,66i) 6)516ts) o-rr6o ,5615, r 6orhiffxrrrribaUuLLO - Ehrrarfl f rT umrriffi6ts)m - Excutive Committe Members : u6v61f6rTLOl ffrTaD6va t~F6T 8h(Sj 2_rflipth swrLehUuL.@6i-r6-Tro. S. Rajaram Glurflui uarrivarr 61riu51.ffrreD6D GehrT, f5rrrfl arEardo & 61ffiuS18mmb6iu (ffiGurreD,DLI S. Shakundhala 61,D4leyrrep6ou.516isr Glutufr 61ffithal6Trrr6toc_ 56isr1Drrer) 066m61m/516isr- 146-4E66i-r c9 fl au:Jut:0 6hrr6b6CDL6b61T, L6otreismb urr$ULI guLuo. 61,64B6co6Tr L601 c966M6D J. Raju e6TTrrek ,660 r 6UA,5L 6rOli,e6UuLk5rr6i) f 61), r6L9. r rT urrdai. ,wieFrai6tDffiturr6i) V. Sivarajan rr 61urrprifie56ir urr6Uy. 00,5 WO6b 6rrLffi6i-r ffrLe5th &Oral 61ffirflo51,Wdr Curf16 ,966-0)6D.E.6.E46)1 ~jr n 61eisrflau_weJo @,FhE61.1.ic_0,. /4611 u_brflu.m &J6OJ5 P._.umrriAin,566-r 6E161D6Tr62J a6isro 61ffiru51ff11.613)60 wurfAasir au10,5 Cffirra_rEithr 2_66)11TalL1§. (Lq.Or urfoCurr@eiti ftjA,5L:JuL@ 616A011461661(501 GLJLE6fr eip6oth ffieityroarer 2_LaitirrffiLltuffiLlJuLLLo. ffiOurro 6•E'esr 06tDp616 ffrOffirilAo utu6ifru@AD:JuL:2 6-)Jeapo.i. EJEFM1.101" 6155-OlarrEco6Offierr OLDgth agiu4i6E6UuL_ wrrLt_rro 6-r6 rp dquar 2_0461L.Dru51 u5pUuca ffruprrer 15 aeibLi 2_eathrT6M60,56iT 61ffIli6ULL® 6/16.5268Tp615T. a,56/511T6i) 616111jUlb c91.6ffilDITA LD6CV (60')M0.16"i1.61TO. ,E,O0iLRB61516i) &iamb ffinto dar(Qmti. Gi rr6i) c9irfal 6tuagmoi. wrrar ffiLOUurrO Curr6u.i 61T611 a6i) 6D6)Lu auok_th 6aare8iffirriapJA6isr 6116tD6rreirra 1_06Carfl wrraraffiL@LliurrO r 0J61161ffs $6t'sr &mar ag61161?alb 6,rT6iDg&6irT61516i) c9i6COLD6iffiinna_g. LiffirliTE661T 61,51TLfTLITE6 E666018fT6Cpf116 b GifffirflOy u*Dith 96ti_16-)1ffi6iT 61atii646iff,656T6bffi6tp6Yr Clurrojwihaih".'6 0.146-A6Curroi @ffirflotlifieb G61J6doi®Lb. 06tur6i) 61un-pD6ffielotr aGffiffiralfh(s6(5 61ffi6rfl62igept_66th. a6t06Du516i) fht...,5 2009,96th ez,66-6trr@(y)ffi6 yoleaffrii. c9-04fiksoiD MARC t0616-urcpth 90 agem Glati_10615rwitsr@ OL140), c905r1:1Aii eieth 9-00m,6, aMif1L13,6 C6zDelfh6-mar 6:offiturrLi) GrriLe464. aearcirsr0 1.516L-66UuGuE.-Lqurr6o-r6Twouft (BOT)036tDmu516 2_g6)Jrr856,UuLt_a 6sflt.urrer tiappuffith .4611n- etit Aux1.466 G1auJ6buCa 610.f2p0. Affi tjappoffith66 u6bGelo fg rraffisrfl6i) N00161)imfirfl, &A,66hrfl8 8 imun-,5 ef&EheDg, Egibq oi.fL61T8b6iT, 61urra_rr6iq, 1.461turr Curmisrp apih(5u3,6 @au:ALA:Jul® eraegpo. 2- °""1"."1441N, PERUNTHAIAIVAR KAMARAJAR STATE AWARDEE - 2008 /01....1"1"":"I THIRUMALAIRAYANPATTINAM CONSUMER FORUM $1(oulan6ogniumifiruitifikorib 5psirGoinir wifinsii) Regd.SI.No. 215/1989 No. 40, Market Street, Thirumalairayanpaftinam - 609 606. Karaikal (Dist). Puducherry (State). Cell : 94420 18534, 94435 25782, 80125 57777, 94436 54185. *Ex-Member- Central Consumer Protection Council * Ex-Member- Pondicherry State Consumer Protection Council *Member- Karaikal District Consumer Protection Council

-2- Honorary President : (501Uurrffi Ap,561616-rflu.S16i) 61ffirrc_LUuabi 61),e6ffirflu.516arr6b olaDmoffiA6tD,g M. Rajadurai, B.A.,(SW) C.O.M.P. iffrOlu.16-frar aurru)rEiffisrfl6 iburkbEh6i-r, 61ffigffici6 cfroj6iff3p6tD6Du.46), L.D6Ool61J6fT6CDffiLLILb LIIT,61:JUOL68T, 61.)1:6661f1 §ffiGirffith rit016 UfJ6116)1,51T6 c9iCiu(5,6016 orrulb GlurrowaffisiT Lboitip Gemrnim-Nrrtii6uE.Lafrffisir 06-8T.Gu President : (01LISILIL0 Curr6b C,5rr6i) arru:J, ebarerf16.56, tp,s4hOesrp6b Guniffp6tDaffisarr6 6/1,6inalb et 060)61) 2_6trar6tDffiu.4b, 2_6titrrith 2....6tRyre516 6o.fichrflAois6-tr56i-r S. Ravichandran, MA, ffirr016-b upol 6)51g61,5rr6b Ourr6ifrm arrulbE66-ir otut._ goarrapo 6r66-ru,56toanaitb, Gemomeirrtin:R516 a6m6-Treerffii5(5 (p6isrorileow Gei6Ooacagib Glurroja) c9i6tOLDULIffith Or116i) GaLab, 066ar® blusgrurfiasir rzbp6IXDITE6611lb Vice President : ClurrMeoch amA0.1 611,5 6rriumfr efrhath Grfl6i) shlarrrflog.b, un-fraDeRt51Lab aoi 61,5nterurreb ,E6t4,5 A. Kadi rye!, Retd. Teacher 16.9.2010 G,5$11511.:1_ oiodiameh u$6-11A,5urr6bopamb wrrfra §6tDm(y)66,Wir A.S. Ramesh, B.B.A., auJih(eihob, 61urroaumorrarer Oialfrffiii(51b c9i0UalwoL68T, ot566-r yoeCarfl 0613)65U060)61).:966., 0.,560)61.)6o.rmi @atm-wrath., $0. 2.__DCA516arft 61ffumfr PPCC, EfilTaDuli,ffirr6b $e. L.DrraLL c96LefluJft c9W2Guirre/16 Secretary : .01061.51 urrolffirrai L611421:661:5)5 670&ffi GEBLOa6-1ffirr6i-rarEmilLo. wrrfr ofimp(ymb OreirrehM6Isr eyrrfrun.ffi e2urru) uw165i6(5 EfrffirrffirTutb, (Dlider, R. Gunasekaran, M.A., Lithe LINT600f611, LDIT600ldlffi.f1(5 /266befil UU.516D Gv56tD61JUJIT615T 61J6,65617, LDffieln. 2....ffi6)511:660aELi66 C6)160)606111TU:JUL1 L.DOLb UlireDLD $C.Lribmir g0u0A$ 61ffirT@A016461TOIL68T, 61.)/16ffirfli66-filtu6i) 600i U.51im5CJULL c:916TT6fil0(5 aea6Lb utp_gb, Joint Secretary : 0564564 ffirt016-b ucreirrup6 ffi@ifieL urrauDir SC._0666i-r 06DLID urroisrally otuff@asiT P. Varatharajan, Retd. VAO. 61eftimEnAL06i-rar,5rrffi 20.10.2010 0015ILL. ffitcwb urrit.ilorrffi 8T6topu.irror ffirrrflturhmhi66 arbffiti) Eziojapesarturrffi aeibob S. Veeramani, M.Com.,B.Ed., aciu0 eisrreriEkAii)(5 6. 6r66-rm 6)&14614_6* 8.11.2010 COu5ILL u$6 ffitcl,Lb c9imaninati. aela5lopb 61),E.fiehril uSoi 06tDpGui utc1,51 ffirr016i) uueirrmoi) 61ffirrui- urrolffirrini L6-1a9..E.6613).E6 G6a6olab. Treasurer : a6616-Trei ffrojiiff5 6i) urr011yffisir aLrfAtu ELA5,6016b r5Gurrol N. Ravi, M.Com.,B.Ed., ffirraDuaffirr6 OurrerL (KPPL) $U6NUDIIJ aUJ613).Eh 6111TILI (Liquified Natural Gas) au_106ED5 arflarrq 6-cochturr,56i) 6r6-isrm 1.4,6u Glaiti6cy3,6tDp 6116117ffi 6r66tD61)(56i-r 24G,56fli ojoirsrri5, ,56tInALS166orr efrr6isro@up a,611.1 agarrrimbAA6-6-r arftgi wftitb elesr csfiaDicaffe6A,66&01016fibli 0.S.1533 Excutive Committe Members : 14.9.2006 L.D0CD ,60A,51b ,966tDcar 0.S.3067(E) effi,6 1.12.2009-66r UK/ S. Rajaram G)urrollpiLeheilL.Ab 50A0 CffiLuoi u5leh ,516-Nolumrr6aro. utialub S. Shakundhala 26.10.2016 a6aro ,60tDaD6DurruJ6isruLaq6arib Curre)ffilb uffrru..00 u6-bGrr,i0 J. Raju waltrrLuA,66-b (wLub 601A0 PPCC adsr 617U.JdocpeDp Efreilaa u5prrasrfl up0mpb ur6tsTrru51, V. Sivarajan 60C.1616 gOILSIC_Odrerrogurro 4ffiLbutip, uturbffiErairr,5 gra6comq, Glffirr01606tDm dluAgffisir, 616isresfIC_® otuab Or, artg 961 L.Drrur wOoth cfrftjeff3s.6b urr,6LiffisiT 6T,6frunfrihai*Juab 60)61)u.S6i) Aeh$La_LbG,56wallirr? 61,56tru)16D:5§iharror LDOw wrreal ffiLVAirn.10 61,568nDlaximeasrrar Gffiefiui UffratiD SfrUurruni) a6C067Z0§ 61adr6toom.516i) " W66011_60 ffrOolif6i) 2016 " 6rsisrp ,56tooL516 soAeggrizi6 sOALL516i) wrraimp516 wetrp tpA5 Mu$ &lamed), wrraiarqu51@ 2...u.dra6 umivrpti) Mu,6 &aimed% LiveiCarfi u)16D OLD,6(5 §65)6c;5061:00 660fr aethebed), Offiditu Liar's= %frinirnu6iir ffi6tD6D611fT frsetb, 6156trwrrit6W0arrer WILLI wham) PliurrttiOdr umitrap516 Mu$ aairtheibffiu5iphib, c96grr, &wag, afr,mrrLsrr, LipiGarfl 66/211.1 wlo-othis6to6mi Giffr i5 wrrEcrsraUurn'a c91,6srrrflffisir is6D§G1Efirr6Riur@ ffrft,lifff5 6i) (501A01 mi656-ir 1.b, i6u516) 6)511..Lpsurfrei. QtUL Gei6OciaLb. uroliflw6cD6-1) LDITffiCi La0JU611(T.Ehih EhOGDLININTOT eiZITL6t06/5T 6210-A561,568T Op 6D allJ61D135 61161Trbehapar urroffirrachoqu4d) &arm 61,56,6 4,66165w:6016i) (501CialLUuL:Bsiraro. 23.10.2016 ,66u0ffiM, ev...grfr u$CA516i) Gleofiturror Gifffirilii6suLL 61ffii4 plb6i) ffirkaalleiT Gumrrair urnieDa.i6,6 imUuCaoiraroi. $L4615),5 yoeGeFrfl csoigur urflg6DaDar @ffti.Joi ffirraw&ffirr6i) u0 11)0.10E. yol6Cffrfl uprOo affrfriFEfik5 oguhi.J4frenbrror L6-)n.q.a6-tubs'a GuD61ffirro-i-raloL6isr, 6r0,iffiC.iu@tb t_6)119.&6zDebehsi-r ffiK2,5CD eirrt616Drreh G1ffirflehleiffi $6w6co6ourrumirruc..yoni) Mall* urrulb 61urrolumiffisrfl6ar rrfturra Ut:.@ri@arrar4p§.

6jYr0). adruCb 5ffinleIrrfr Gff61:06/1016 1.Cm igc5 0160)6006M sz9 imfr, Li&J6Garfl 61E5611ff6116 ffi6.1)61dr 2. LDIT600iLIL61(5 (g)g 606tDLINTiffT, •14016FG'ifrfl • 3. 0. ,56e0606COLDEF Glatue?rraur, HowGurfl ev,14`,V____61/ (95)61)6111'T 4. 6. anumrr6rrfr, ffrOgaitaoso LoOgu) 611615T aiGOLDeffffilb, L.106661 autuorerfr 5. 0. 61ffuorrarrr, CS&CA, LiticiGffrfl '1(4'q 6. e. &tua(50, CS&CA., L.41ffGarfl Ourrearrret 7. 0. &MON awih(5,mfr, Cg&CA, ffirraogimmr6. L5 I o • al 0:61 1.4a .6,(.,-,'&1ii-605 005

7' I@ "Clean India and Clean Puducher " aFACTOR:14,-, • 4j-- ff • ,

•

ANNEXURE III

QUERIES AND COMMENTS RAISED BY THE PARTICIPANTS AND THE CLARIFICATIONS PROVIDED AT THE OF THE PUBLIC HEARING CONDUCTED AT THE MULTI-PURPOSE HALL, POLAGAM, T.R.PATTINAM, KARAIKAL, ON 26.10.2016, AT 11.00 AM, FOR THE PROPOSED PROJECT OF HANDLING OF LNG, AT M/S. KARAIKAL PORT PVT. LTI)., KARAIKA L.

I. Queries and Comments of the Participants:

Post the presentation of the Consultant of the Project, the participants were given opportunity for expression of their Queries and Comments, regarding the project. The queries and comments raised during the Public Hearing are as follows:

Name & Address of the participants and Queries / Comments raised in the S. Public Hearing. No.

Dr. Anand Kumar, President, Indian Anti-Corruption Group, Puducherry:

(a) At the outset, the above said representative welcomed the project to Karaikal District.

1 (b) But alleged that, the consultant of the project have masked the truth stating that, Methane Gas is non-toxic, but actually it is toxic.

(c) He informed that, Methane Gas will take oxygen from the atmosphere and it will cause health and fire hazard. The EIA report is silent about the compensation to be awarded to the victims, if any.

Thiru. R. Murugesan, Treasurer, Keezhavanjore Grama Nirvaga Panchayat, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal:

(a) Since inception of M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd., in 2006, the people of the Keezhavanjore Village have been suffering from the Coal Dust, due to Handling of Coal at the Port and stated that, No CSR activities has been carried out by the Port, but claiming that they have spent nearly 7 Crores for the same. 2 (b) No plantation has been done around the port area.

(c) LNG is dangerous for Human life, at minus 162°C has a chance of explosion, as LNG is highly inflammable and that, the subject village is located onl) at a distance of 50 m from the Port.

(d) Employment for the local people was not provided in the Port.

(e) Air Quality Monitoring was not conducted in the village since 2012, by PPCC

Page 1 of 7 • Queries / Comments of the Public — Handling of LNG — M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd.

and that, third party monitoring is not advisable. (f) Groundwater has been polluted due to the present port activities. (g) Fishing is already been prohibited in the Port Area and will be prohibited in the proposed area of the Port also, since Handling of Bulk LNG, poses security threat and can manifest itself to a national security threat. (h) Due to coal dust deposition in sea, the fish catch in the nearby area has reduced and thereby a dire impact in the livelihood of the local people.

Thiru. Subramaniyan, Consumer Forum, Karaikal: (a) He was really happy for the project of Karaikal Port, before implementing, because of the expectation of developments like local employment offers and livelihood of the local public. (b) But, later on, due to unexpected handling of Coal and its consequent dust pollution in the village, he was frustrated. 3 (c) Automatic Coal Handling system was not installed and practiced right now, which in turn is causing for the Air Pollution in the surrounding villages. (d) The port was alleged to offer only timely temporary compensations to the local public, as and when agitations were raised. (e) No single tree is planted in the surrounding villages by the Port and the local public has lost confidence on the management of the Port. (0 Land and Air are already polluted due to the poor handling of coal.

Thiru. S. Jayakrishnan, Wood Merchant, Karaikal: (a) The main activity in Karaikal was Agriculture which is majorly affected due to 4 port activities. (b) No job opportunity was given to the local people. (c) No development in the local areas due to the Port activity.

Thiru. Ramadurai, Pattinacherry, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) Fishing activity has been prohibited in the port area and hence, Livelihood of Fishermen is affected due to the advent of Port. 5 (b) Local people have been denied their rights on fishing in the very port area. (c) Fish stock has decreased due to dredging and port activity. (d) Local people may revolt against the Port, if the LNG project is permitted. (e) It will be another Bhopal Gas Tragedy.

Page 2 of 7 • Queries / Comments of the Public — Handling of LNG — M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd.

Thiru. James Baly, President, Press Club and Reporter, Dinakaran, Karaikal:

(a) Due to handling of Coal at the Port, the local villages surrounding the same, 6 such as, Keezhavanjore Village and Nagore, has been affected and also questioned PPCC & the District Collector, Karaikal that, how many inspections / monitoring has been carried out at the Port and the surrounding villages and what actions has been taken so far, regarding the same.

Thiru. M. Rajendiran, President, Consumer Forum, T.R.Pattinam:

(a) Facts about the possible hazards of the LNG to the lives and Environment have been hidden in the Draft EIA Report. (b) Deficiency in the pollution control measures by the port for coal handling has made local public to suffer.

Thiru. Sliaktliivel, Nagore Pattinacherry:

(a) Due to the construction of the breakwaters of the Port, the shore on either side of the port got eroded and around 60 houses got inundated in the sea.

(b) The breakwaters have forced the local fishermen to sail long way for fishing.

8 (c) The Oil pipelines of the CPCL, near the Vettar River, has been a major hindrance for the landing of Fishing Boats.

(d) Most of the fishermen's boats were damaged due to the same.

(e) The dredged sand has been poured into the River Vettar and hence the river mouth has been closed.

(f) If LNG also has been permitted the effects would be so devastating.

Thiru. Sowrirajan, Meenavar Panchayat, Nagore:

(a) No public hearing was conducted before establishing port.

(b) The River Vettar has been damaged by the advent of Port and has been major hindrance for the fishing activities.

(c) Coal transportation through wagons spill coal in the river Vettar and the same has been polluted.

(d) The north easterly wind carried coal dust and has deposited the same on the residences and Nagore Dargha, a sacred tourist place and also on the fishing net, which on using leads to lesser fish catch.

(e) This affects the livelihood of around 5000 fishermen

(f) Since the population density around the Port area is high, any accident due to LNG handling may cause serious damage, hence opposed the proposal.

Page 3 of 7 Queries / Comments of the Public — Handling of LNG — M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd.

Thiru. Shakthivel, Pattinacherry, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) When the port has been proposed in 2006, the public were not aware of the proposed handling of Coal, since no public hearing was conducted. (b) Coal is being carried out by the rainwater and the sea water is being polluted. (c) Port has placed bouys in the sea water, which is hindering the pathway of boats for fishing and the same is being damaged.

10 (d) Fishermen are denied of their right for fishing due to the advent of Port and hence, most of the fishermen have migrated to nearby coastal areas, like Poombuhar, Kodiyakarai, etc., for livelihood. (e) Awareness about the mobility for the fishermen, around the port was not provided by the port. (t) Around 1 km stretch of casuarina plantation has been uprooted for the construction of the port in the coastal area. (g) Hence, the local public need no port and don't support for the expansion.

Thiru. A. Abdul Rahman, Keezhavanjore, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) Due to the advent of port, the local livelihood have been affected like, palm trees were dead, groundnut cultivation could not be carried out and there had been flood in the village due to heavy rains. (b) Port did not provide job offers to the local public, as propagated before 11 establishment of port, instead destroyed the oneness of the people of the village, for their benefit. (c) Due to loss of groundnut cultivation, no compensation was provided also. (d) Pisciculture in ponds also could not be carried out by the local public. (e) The above said representative of the public expressed that, he may file a case against port in the NGT and hence did not support Port or LNG Project.

Thiru. Rajaraman, Melavanjore, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: 12 (a) There is hazard in LPG also and hence, requested the Government to assess the project and then decide on granting permission for the project, if no risk is envisaged.

Thiru. Rajendiran, Pattinacherry, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: 13 (a) Already CPCL has laid their pipeline beneath the Vettar River. Due to these the fishing crafts gets damage. The revolt for relief for the same is being carried out for the past three years, which was not addressed till now.

Page 4 of 7 • Queries / Comments of the Public — Handling of LNG — M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd.

(b) Now Port's LNG pipeline will also have same effect on fishing crafts.

Thiru. Ramesh, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) Advent of Port has affected the livelihood of all the adjacent villages and there were no development for them. 14 (b) Why to support to such organization which has offered no development to the surrounding public. (c) Hence, he neither supported the Port nor the proposed LNG project.

Thiru. Senthil Kumaran, Pattinacherry, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) The existing port operation is not done properly. is (b) Though Port claims huge amount of money spent on CSR activities, no CSR benefit has reached the village. (c) Port should first conduct a hearing for the present port operations and then go for the LNG expansion.

Thiru. K.R.Rajendiran, Ex-Chairman, T.R.Pattinam Commune Panchayat, Keezhavanjore, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) Being a farmer and Agriculture being a major activity in the region said that 16 port activities should not affect farming or prawn culture. (b) Pollution issues to be tackled by the port. (c) Requested for compensation by the port in case of those lands those are not usable by the villagers.

Thiru. Kadar Mohideen, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: 17 (a) Environment has been polluted due to the poor handling of coal. (b) Prove that there is no pollution from the port activities and then go for expansion.

Thiru. R.K.Baskaran, President, Keezhavanjore Grama Nirvaga Panchayat, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) Mentioned that complaints were submitted by the Grama Nirvaga Panchayat 18 with regards to the pollution due to coal handling. (b) Groundwater already polluted due to the port activities. (c) Solid waste/ garbage from the port is being disposed into the village. (d) Waste from LNG handling might pollute the sea water.

Page 5 of 7 • Queries / Comments of the Public — Handling of LNG — M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd.

(e) Awareness about the LNG was not well created and the project has not been clearly explained.

Thiru. Anbukadhiravan, Keezhavanjore, T.R.Pattinam, Karaikal: (a) What is the impact on neighbouring areas if LNG explodes and how much distance will it spread? (b) What are the impacts on fisheries due to drawing of seawater for cooling and outfal I discharge? (c) Will LNG proposal be a hindrance for fishing? (d) Safe LNG handling by the port is an uncertainty. 19 (e) Safe zones such as the 500 mtrs from the LNG terminal to be ensured. (0 Dust deposition on the houses due to Poor coal handling by the port. This dust washed by the rain water pollutes the land. (g) Dredging will affect the ground water. (h) The oneness of the people of the surrounding villages, has been effected due to the Port's Public relations. (i) LNG may be permitted only if it is 100% safe.

11. Clarifications provided to the participants of the Public Hearing : In pursuance of the Queries and Comments raised by the participants of the Public Hearing, the following clarifications were provided:

S. Clarifications provided to the Participants No.

Dr. P. Chandramohan, Project Co-ordinator of the Proposed LNG Project, Indomer Coastal Hydraulics Ltd., Chennai: (a) LNG is non-toxic and not a dangerous gas to the Environment and does not explode at minus 162°C. (b) LNG is compressed to Liquid and maintained at minus 162°C, to be safe. 1 (c) Methane Gas is lighter than air and hence, if leaks occur, will not disperse transversely, but move up in the atmosphere. (d) This project does not cause any pollution to the Environment, Land or water. (e) All safety measures and mitigations measures required and raised by the participants will be incorporated in the Final EIA Report.

Page 6 of 7 • Queries / Comments of the Public — Handling of LNG — M/s. Karaikal Port Pvt. Ltd.

Dr. N. Ramesh, Environmental Engineer, Department of Science, Technology and Environment, Puducherry Pollution Control Committee, Puducherry : (a) No-Objection Certificate for the establishment of the Port was issued prior to 2 the EIA Notification, 2006, wherein, Public Hearing for a Minor Port was not mandated. (b) Now that, the proposed LNG Project falls under the EIA Notification, 2006 and hence, Public Hearing was conducted for the same.

Thiru. K. Dharmalingam, Indomer Coastal Hydraulics Ltd., Chennai : (a) LNG is not hazardous and dangerous to the Environment and does not explode at minus 162°C. 3 (b) LNG is proposed to be handled at liquid phase at minus 162°C, which is very safe. (c) Many successful similar projects have been handled previously and no accidents have been reported till date.

Page 7 of 7