PLANNING COMMITTEE Agenda Item No. APPLICATIONS DETERMINED UNDER OFFICER DELEGATED POWERS FOR THE MONTH OF SEPTEMBER 2014

App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

12/0461 Full Application Yanwath & Revisions of planning approvals 97/0345 and SOUTHWAITE GREEN MILL, Mr J Heath APPROVED Eamont Bridge 01/0112 for the creation of 16 holiday EAMONT BRIDGE, PENRITH accommodations.

13/0028 Full Application Penrith Retrospective application for the creation of a self- 14 VICTORIA ROAD, PENRITH Mr M Rodda REFUSED contained one bedroomed flat.

14/0283 Notice of Intention Kaber Prior notification for the erection of a roof over STARRAH, KABER, KIRKBY Mr M Morland APPROVED existing slurry lagoon. STEPHEN

14/0284 Full Application Appleby Change of use from workshop to veterinary centre FRANK BRADLEY TRANSPORT, Ms H Gould - Old Hall APPROVED and extension to rear. CROSS CROFT INDUSTRIAL Vet Centre ESTATE, APPLEBY

14/0349 Full Application Sockbridge & Variation of condition no. 2 (plans compliance) BARN ADJACENT TO THWAITE Mr D Brier APPROVED Tirril attached to planning approval 13/0519 comprising COTTAGE, TIRRIL, PENRITH revised fenestration, garden wall and the reconstruction of the outbuilding.

14/0362 Listed Building Sockbridge & Listed building consent for the works required to BARN ADJACENT TO THWAITE Mr D Brier APPROVED Tirril enable the conversion to a dwelling (revised COTTAGE, TIRRIL, PENRITH application).

14/0394 Full Application Alston Erection of a dwelling. ALSTON ROAD, NENTHEAD, Mr D Paisley APPROVED PENRITH

14/0409 Listed Building Ravenstonedale Listed building consent for replacement of 16 THE HAVEN, RAVENSTONEDALE, Mr C Hunter APPROVED windows and rendering works to chimney stack.

14/0484 Full Application Clifton Installation of 124 kw anaerobic digestion plant and CLIFTON HALL FARM, CLIFTON, Mr Holliday APPROVED associated facilities. PENRITH

14/0485 Full Application Culgaith Installation of a 124kW anaerobic digestion plant and SKIRWITH ABBEY FARM, Mr Johnston APPROVED associated facilities. SKIRWITH, PENRITH

14/0503 Full Application Crosby Proposed construction of clay lined slurry lagoon (re- WHITEFOLD, REAGILL, PENRITH Mr A Johnstone APPROVED Ravensworth submission).

14/0513 Full Application Appleby 3 no. dwellings. PLOT 13 WESTMORLAND RISE, Mr Wharton-J.R. REFUSED APPLEBY Wharton & Sons

14/0515 Full Application Orton Change of use, alterations and extensions to form OLD SCHOOL, GREENHOLME, All Saints Church APPROVED dwelling. PENRITH Parochial Church Council - Mr A Moore

03 October 2014 Page 1 of 8 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0521 Listed Building Alston Defibrillator cabinet to be fixed to Listed Building. ALSTON TOWN HALL, FRONT Alston Town Hall APPROVED STREET, ALSTON Trustees - C Johnson

14/0526 Full Application Penrith Upgrade existing floodlighting on 3rd team pitch and PENRITH RUGBY UNION CLUB, Penrith Rugby Club APPROVED installation of new floodlighting on 2nd team pitch. WINTERS PARK, PENRITH Ltd - Mr C Lilley

14/0527 Listed Building Penrith Refurbishment & re-modelling of existing building, 3 KING STREET, PENRITH Mr & Mrs Mimmack APPROVED including the creation of two new two bedroom flats.

14/0543 Full Application Hesket Erection of a new detached silage clamp building, LOW GROUNDS FARM, Mr J Harris APPROVED with roof and concrete sides. PLUMPTON, PENRITH

14/0549 Full Application Kaber Erection of livestock shed. THE BUILDINGS FARM, KABER, Messrs Hastwell APPROVED KIRKBY STEPHEN

14/0551 Full Application Brougham Proposed restoration of dwelling including THE POPLARS, BROUGHAM, Mr R Jenkinson APPROVED conversion of outbuilding to annex, construction of PENRITH stables, indoor arena and horse walker. Widening of entrance and associated landscaping works.

14/0552 Reserved Matters Morland Reserved matters application for 3 no. dwellings. CROWN INN FIELDS, MORLAND, Mr & Mrs G Young APPROVED PENRITH

14/0558 Full Application Catterlen Erection of timber frame classroom and composting UNIVERSITY OF , Mr W Cleasby - Eden APPROVED toilet. NEWTON RIGG CAMPUS, NEWTON Rivers Trust RIGG, PENRITH

14/0560 Full Application Stainmore Removal of existing building. Replaced with GILLSES FARM, SOUTH Mr G Wearmouth APPROVED agricultural general purpose building. STAINMORE, KIRKBY STEPHEN

14/0571 Listed Building Appleby Listed building consent for a hanging sign and wall 7 BOROUGHGATE, APPLEBY-IN- Arnison Heelis - Mrs C APPROVED mounted sign (retrospective). WESTMORLAND Birtles

14/0574 Non-Material Brough Non material minor amendment to planning approval 11 CASTLE PARK, BROUGH, Mr P Armistead APPROVED Amend 11/0607 comprising revisions to the fenestration. KIRKBY STEPHEN

14/0581 Full Application Penrith Existing doorway currently stone filled to be 34 KING STREET, PENRITH Messrs J Cowper APPROVED reinstated with timber door painted white.

14/0582 Reserved Matters Stainmore Reserved matters application for the conversion and WILKINSON HOUSE, WINDMORE Mr & Mrs M Wilson APPROVED extension of building to form house together with END, NORTH STAINMORE, KIRKBY double garage and farm office. STEPHEN

14/0585 Full Application Kings Meaburn Replace existing lightweight store with new store to SMITHY HOUSE, KINGS MEABURN, Mr R Warburton APPROVED accommodate wood pellet boiler and store. PENRITH

14/0602 Reserved Matters Penrith Reserved Matters application for the erection of three LAND OFF BEACON EDGE, Atkinson Homes APPROVED dwellings. PENRITH

03 October 2014 Page 2 of 8 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0605 Advertisement Penrith Advertisement consent for the display of 2 no. fascia BARCLAYS BANK, MARKET Barclays Bank plc APPROVED signs, 1 no projecting sign and 1 no. branch name SQUARE, PENRITH plate.

14/0606 Full Application Penrith Refurbishment comprising; 1. replacement of BARCLAYS BANK PLC, MARKET Barclays Bank plc APPROVED existing counterline with new studwork partition SQUARE, PENRITH housing ASD self-service machines & open counter position, 2. supporting structure at basement level, and 3. new AC condenser at roof level with ventilations system at ground & first floor.

14/0607 Listed Building Penrith Listed building consent for refurbishment comprising; BARCLAYS BANK PLC, MARKET Barclays Bank plc APPROVED 1. replacement of existing counterline with new SQUARE, PENRITH studwork partition housing ASD self-service machines & open counter position, 2. supporting structure at basement level, and 3. new AC condenser at roof level with ventilations system at ground & first floor.

14/0609 Non-Material Murton Non material minor amendment to planning approval TIMBER HOLIDAY LODGE, C Atkinson APPROVED Amend 13/0567 comprising raising the floor levels and FORMER QUARRIED SITE, height to gain storage underneath. MURTON, APPLEBY

14/0613 Full Application Dacre Two storey side extension to existing house. 4 JOINERS CLOSE, NEWBIGGIN, Mr S Tolmie APPROVED PENRITH

14/0617 Full Application Bolton Variation of condition no 2 (plans compliance) SITE ADJ TO MARMION, BOLTON, Mr & Mrs Lee APPROVED attached to planning approval 12/0141 relating to APPLEBY revised design of approved dwelling.

14/0618 Reserved by Ousby Discharge of condition no.4 (drainage), no.5 and 4 CHURCH ROAD, MELMERBY, Mr & Mrs D Burrows APPROVED Cond no.6 (boundary treatments) attached to planning PENRITH approval 14/0077.

14/0621 Change of Use Great Salkeld Change of use from agricultural building to dwelling BECKBANK BARN, SALKELD Nunwick Hall Estate - APPROVED PD/PN (Class house. DYKES, GREAT SALKELD, PENRITH Mr M Thompson JKLM)

14/0623 Full Application Dacre Change of use of a building from class B8 to class QUARRY GARAGE, STAINTON, Leo Sawrij Limited APPROVED B2 to allow for the servicing and repair of motor PENRITH vehicles.

14/0629 Outline Crackenthorpe Outline application for the erection of three dwellings. GARTH HOUSE, Mr A Armstrong REFUSED Application CRACKENTHORPE, APPLEBY-IN- WESTMORLAND

14/0630 Full Application Langwathby The re-instatement of an agricultural access. FIELD ACCESS ON THE A686, Mr Wilson APPROVED SOUTH-WEST OF LANGWATHBY BRIDGE, LANGWATHBY, PENRITH

03 October 2014 Page 3 of 8 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0635 Full Application Lazonby Single storey extension to the rear of the property. HAZEL GARTH, LAZONBY, PENRITH Mr & Mrs Bellas APPROVED

14/0636 Listed Building Skelton Restoration of a grade II listed building. CHAPEL COTTAGE, SKELTON, Mr P Rowlands APPROVED PENRITH

14/0638 Full Application Hutton Extension and alterations consisting of replacement BECKSIDE, PENRUDDOCK, Mr A Atkins APPROVED of a bay window with sun room, creation of storm PENRITH porch to entrance.

14/0639 Listed Building Castle Sowerby Listed building consent for the retention of a light THE ASHES, RAUGHTON HEAD, Mr & Mrs R Arkell APPROVED tube installed on west elevation.

14/0642 Full Application Appleby Proposed rear elevation sun lounge/balcony BRANTFIELD, BONGATE, APPLEBY- Mr & Mrs R Taylor APPROVED extension. IN-WESTMORLAND

14/0643 Full Application Long Marton Proposed general purpose agricultural building at KNOCK CROSS FARM, KNOCK, Mr J.P. & G.J. APPROVED Newlands. APPLEBY SIMPSON

14/0645 Full Application Appleby New agricultural livestock building. COLBY LAITHES, COLBY, APPLEBY- Mr R Warburton APPROVED IN-WESTMORLAND

14/0647 Full Application Penrith Installation of new pole and CCTV camera unit. PAVEMENT ADJ. DENIZ FOODS, 6 Mr Robinson-Cumbria APPROVED MIDDLEGATE, PENRITH Constabulary

14/0653 Full Application Stainmore Change of use from hostel and conference centre MOUTHLOCK CENTRE, BARRAS, Mr K Matchett - APPROVED (sui generis) to residential school (C2). KIRKBY STEPHEN Archbishop Sentamu Academy

14/0657 Full Application Penrith Creation of galvanised flow forge cage plant UNIT 2 CASTLE RETAIL PARK, Iceland Foods Ltd - Mr APPROVED compound and installation of air ULLSWATER ROAD, PENRITH K Jones conditioning/refrigeration plant thereto together with the forming of openings in side and rear elevations associated with same.

14/0658 Full Application Alston Conversion of existing barn into additional domestic LOW FLAT, ALSTON GOLF Mr & Mrs J & L Pease APPROVED accommodation and erection of porch. COURSE, ALSTON

14/0659 Listed Building Appleby Listed building consent for replacement windows and 25 CHAPEL STREET, APPLEBY Mr R Warburton APPROVED front door.

14/0660 Full Application Alston Variation of condition 2 (plans compliance) attached HAYRING FARM, NENTHEAD, Mr J Pennell APPROVED to planning approval 12/0563. ALSTON

14/0662 Full Application Wharton Proposed installation of a ground mounted 50kW WHARTON HALL, WHARTON, Mr M Chippendale REFUSED Solar PV Panel facility. KIRKBY STEPHEN

14/0663 Reserved by Tebay Discharge of conditions 3,4 and 5 attached to LOW BORROWDALE, TEBAY, Holker Estate Trust - APPROVED Cond planning application 13/0159. PENRITH Mr M Carroll

03 October 2014 Page 4 of 8 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0664 Full Application Penrith Installation of iron railings to the top of an existing 1 BEACON STREET, PENRITH Mr D Harris APPROVED wall along the property boundary.

14/0666 Reserved by Tebay Discharge of planning conditions 3,4 and 5 attached LOW BORROWDALE, TEBAY, Mr M Carroll APPROVED Cond to planning application 13/0160. PENRITH

14/0669 Notice of Intention Stainmore Prior notification for the installation of 1 no. 8 EXISTING TELECOMMUNICATIONS Vodafone Ltd & APPROVED element Yagi antenna at 34m above ground level on SITE AT NEW HALL FARM, Airwave Solutions Ltd an existing 42m lattice mast. BARRAS, KIRKBY STEPHEN

14/0670 Full Application Ousby Single storey extensions to existing two storey HILLTOP, MELMERBY, PENRITH Mr A Teasdale APPROVED dwelling.

14/0671 Tree Works (CA) Great Salkeld G1 (Beech): Crown lift branches over fence / playing WELL COTTAGE, GREAT SALKELD, Mr Tim Holliday APPROVED field; G2 (Oak / Beech): Crown lift branches shading PENRITH garden; G4 (Oak / Beech): Reduce branches towards building next door; Crown lift 6-8m to pruning points on outer side of woodland and branch reduction works; All as shown on marked photographs provided; Great Salkeld Conservation Area.

14/0672 Tree Works Crackenthorpe 1) Fell Sycamores T1 and T2; 2) Reduce branch ROSE COTTAGE, Mr D Hall APPROVED (TPO) spread of T3 towards house; TPO48, 1992, Rose CRACKENTHORPE, APPLEBY-IN- Cottage, Crackenthorpe. WESTMORLAND

14/0673 Tree Works Dufton Group 1: 1) Fell Lime tree due to extensive decay; 2) ORCHARD HOUSE, DUFTON, Mr D Main APPROVED (TPO) Crown raise Sycamores T2 and T3 to 3m; TPO 92, APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND 1998, Field OS No 2400, Duton.

14/0674 Tree Works (CA) Dufton 1) Prune Hollies; 2) T4 Ash: Remove basal shoots; ORCHARD HOUSE, DUFTON, Mr D Main APPROVED 3) T5 Elm: Reduce crown spread; 4) G1: Thin out APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND and prune Ash / Elm / Elder coppice; 5) T6 and T8 Sycamores: Remove coppice stools; 6) T7 Elder: Prune; Dufton Conservation Area.

14/0676 Full Application Penrith Erection of agricultural building. CARLETON HILL FARM, PENRITH Mr T Barr APPROVED

14/0677 Full Application Culgaith Division of existing building to create an additional PEA TOP FARM, CULGAITH, Mr & Mrs D Donaldson APPROVED dwelling. PENRITH

14/0678 Full Application Bandleyside Construction of clay lined slurry store. LOW RUTTER FARM, HOFF, Mr R Forrest APPROVED APPLEBY

14/0679 Advertisement Penrith Advertisement consent for high level sign to front UNIT 2 CASTLE RETAIL PARK, Mr K Jones-Iceland APPROVED elevation and totem pole sign. ULLSWATER ROAD, PENRITH Foods Ltd

14/0680 Full Application Skelton Change of use from ancillary annex to holiday let CHURCH HOUSE, SKELTON, Mr & Mrs Fisher APPROVED accomodation. PENRITH

03 October 2014 Page 5 of 8 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0681 Reserved by Kirkby Stephen Discharge of condition nos. 12 & 14 (remediation BIRBECK GARDENS, NATEBY Mr Paul Fenton - Story APPROVED Cond scheme works) attached to planning application ROAD, KIRKBY STEPHEN Homes 12/0017.

14/0682 Non-Material Bandleyside Non material amendment to planning approval GHYLL HOUSE, ORMSIDE, Mr S Taylor APPROVED Amend 13/0913 comprising of amendments and additions to APPLEBY-IN-WESTMORLAND windows and doors.

14/0684 Full Application Skelton Re-roof existing barn. BARN AT LAITHES, LAITHES, M Beaty APPROVED PENRITH

14/0687 Full Application Kirkby Stephen Change of use from office space into a residential CERBERUS PRINTING LTD, Mr P Hunter APPROVED dwelling. FAIRVIEW, NATEBY ROAD, KIRKBY STEPHEN

14/0695 Full Application Penrith Variation of condition 2 on planning application CRANSTONS LTD., ULLSWATER Cranstons Limited APPROVED 14/0248 to allow an increase in eaves and building ROAD, PENRITH height.

14/0696 Non-Material Long Marton Change of roofing material from approved zinc roof WHITE GATE CARAVAN PARK, P & T Carruthers Ltd. APPROVED Amend to natural slate. LONG MARTON, APPLEBY-IN- WESTMORLAND

14/0697 Full Application Bolton Variation of condition 1 of planning application LAND BETWEEN EDENHOLME AND Mr & Mrs Hayton APPROVED 12/0937 to allow a revised design requirement. LINDISFARNE, BOLTON, APPLEBY- IN-WESTMORLAND

14/0698 Tree Works (CA) Kirkby Stephen 1) Fell T1Conifer, T3 Apple, T5 Conifer, T6 Birch, T8 KIRKBY STEPHEN BRANCH OF Mrs Johnston - Kirkby APPROVED Conifer, T9 Conifer; 2) T2 Maple - 15% Crown thin; FREE MASONS, SILVER STREET Stephen Town Council 3) Crown raise to 2.5m - T4 Sorbus, T7 Birch, T10 GARDENS ADJACENT MASONIC Sorbus; Kirkby Stephen Conservation Area. HALL, NORTH ROAD, KIRKBY STEPHEN

14/0699 Tree Works Kirkby Stephen 1) Crown reduction of 2.5m; 2) 15% crown thin MEETING HOUSE / YORK Mr David Solway - APPROVED (TPO) (Beech tree) - TPO127, 2006, Quaker Meeting COTTAGE HIGH STREET, KIRKBY Friends Meeting House House / York Cottage, High Street, Kirkby Stephen. STEPHEN

14/0700 Tree Works (CA) Langwathby T1 (Yew) - Fell due to damage in tree crown, close HOME FARM, EDENHALL, PENRITH Mr Richard Metcalfe APPROVED proximity to house and root damage to footpath; T2 (Prunus) - Fell tree as it is growing into wall; Replant with smaller trees/shrubs; Edenhall Conservation Area.

14/0701 Full Application Greystoke Demolish existing garage and erect new single SHEIGRA, ORCHARD DRIVE, Mr Nigel Weatherill APPROVED storey garage and utility room. GREYSTOKE, PENRITH

14/0702 Householder Hesket Single storey rear extension. 4 MILL BANK, LOW HESKET, Mrs P Wilson APPROVED PD/PN CARLISLE

03 October 2014 Page 6 of 8 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0704 Non-Material Hesket Non material amendment to application 11/0223 27 ELM CLOSE, HIGH HESKET, Mr R McManus APPROVED Amend comprising of change in plan and roof to rear sun CARLISLE room.

14/0707 Non-Material Culgaith Non material amendment to application 14/0278 ROSE COTTAGE, BLENCARN, Mr & Mrs J Turnbull APPROVED Amend comprising of extension to first floor porch area, PENRITH amend to stone to render and add velux lights.

14/0720 Tree Works (CA) Temple Sowerby 1) Remove overgrown Blue Atlantic Cedar; 2) GREENFIELD HOUSE, TEMPLE Mr Chris Rush APPROVED Remove Fir tree; 3) Prune Purple Leaf Plum to avoid SOWERBY, PENRITH overhead power lines; 4) Remove overgrown Conifer; 5) Remove Himalayan Cherry (to avoid power lines & due to speed of growth); 6) Remove Spanish Beech as it has outgrown space; Temple Sowerby Conservation Area.

14/0721 Notice of Intention Ravenstonedale Change of use of agricultural building to dwelling with RIGG END, NEWBIGGIN-ON-LUNE, Mr D & Mrs C APPROVED associated building operations. KIRKBY STEPHEN Penhallurick

14/0723 Tree Works Clifton W1:Crown raise trees and bushes overhanging field STATION YARD, CLIFTON, PENRITH Messrs K, IH and M APPROVED (TPO) to 2.5m on the field side to facilitate erection of new Little fence along north side of site; Work specification agreed on site with Council Arboriculturist; TPO 116, 2003, Former Coal Yard, Clifton Moor, Clifton.

14/0726 Full Application Penrith Variation of condition no.2 (design and layout) HUTTON HALL, BENSON ROW / Atkinson Homes Ltd APPROVED attached to planning approval 13/0928 (variation to FRIARGATE, PENRITH 13/0406).

14/0727 Full Application Penrith Variation of condition no.2 (design and layout) HUTTON HALL, BENSON ROW / Atkinson Homes Ltd APPROVED attached to listed building approval 13/0930 FRIARGATE, PENRITH (variation to 13/0407).

14/0728 Notice of Intention Clifton Notice of intention of an agricultural building. BROWN HOWE, MELKINTHORPE, Messrs T APPROVED PENRITH Cowperthwaite

14/0730 Tree Works (CA) Penrith T1 - Fell Poplar tree; T2 - Overall crown reduction of PINFOLD, NICHOLSON LANE, Mr Tomas Niedt APPROVED 2-3m for Beech tree; Penrith New Streets PENRITH Conservation Area.

14/0752 Non-Material Penrith Non-material amendment to 14/0121 for the GREENBANK ROAD, EDEN Ast Signs APPROVED Amend reduction in total gross internal floor space from BUSINESS PARK, PENRITH 2600 sq m to 2050 sq m, the simplification of building form and reduction in site area from 1 ha to 0.696 ha.

14/0753 Notice of Intention Newby Agricultural building. LAND TO THE SOUTH WEST OF C J & H Jackson - Mr C APPROVED SLEAGILL, SLEAGILL GILL, Jackson SLEAGILL, PENRITH

03 October 2014 Page 7 of 8 App No App Type Parish Description Location Applicant Decision

14/0789 Non-Material Warcop Non material minor amendment to planning approval VILLAGE HALL, WARCOP, APPLEBY Mr J Willan APPROVED Amend 13/0462 comprising the use of PVC windows instead of timber.

03 October 2014 Page 8 of 8